The latest episode of MuggleCast dives deep into Chapter 13 of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, “The Muggle-Born Registration Commission.” Andrew, Eric, Micah, and Laura follow Harry, Ron, and Hermione deeper into Voldemort’s Ministry of Magic, where the trio’s plan starts falling apart almost immediately and Dolores Umbridge presides over some of the cruelest scenes in the entire series.
Get MuggleCast in your podcast app
Listen to the episode above, and check out some of our key takeaways from the chapter and our episode discussion below.
A Ministry Plan That Falls Apart Right Away
The chapter picks up with the trio already split up. Ron has gone off to deal with the rain in Yaxley’s office, Hermione (still disguised as Mafalda Hopkirk) has been pulled away by Umbridge to help with the day’s blood status hearings, and Harry, as Albert Runcorn, is left to bluff his way through an elevator ride with Pius Thicknesse. When Harry blurts out that he needs to see Arthur Weasley, Thicknesse makes it clear that Arthur is being watched, and that blood traitors are just as bad as Muggle-borns in his eyes.
Eric recognized a familiar strategy in that line. “As soon as you dehumanize and it becomes widely acceptable for you to dehumanize one portion of the population, it becomes infinitely easier to get the machinery of the government to go after another group,” he said.
Micah pointed out how frightening this must be for teenage Harry, who is suddenly being asked by the Minister for Magic whether the man who has been a surrogate father to him is up to no good. Laura added that Harry “has to walk a very thin line of not saying anything to get Arthur in trouble, but he also can’t blow his cover.”
Harry himself admits the plan now feels childish, and the hosts agreed. Eric wondered what the trio expected to do as a group of “three random people” with nothing to do with each other, walking the halls together. Micah asked whether this could have been a one person operation all along, and Andrew suggested it might have been safest as just Harry under the Invisibility Cloak, though “Hermione in particular would never have let him go by himself.”
Eric also floated a fun thought experiment. Since Thicknesse is under the Imperius Curse, what would happen if Harry randomly muttered the word “Horcruxes” in that elevator? Would it set off some kind of alarm back to Voldemort? Laura had wondered the same thing, guessing that so many people are Imperiused at this point that nobody could keep track of all of them in real time.
Propaganda Outside Umbridge’s Office
Right outside Umbridge’s door, about a dozen Ministry workers are assembling pamphlets titled “Mudbloods and the Dangers They Pose to a Peaceful Pure-Blood Society.” Laura connected this directly to Nazi propaganda from World War II, noting that the image on the pamphlets, a rose being strangled by a fanged weed, echoes the garden and agricultural metaphors the Nazis used to describe the people they persecuted. Micah added that propaganda cartoons of that era often depicted Jewish people as parasites and even vampires.
The most interesting part of this conversation was about the workers themselves. They call Umbridge an “old hag” behind her back, yet they keep folding the pamphlets. Eric noted that nobody in that room seems to believe in the cause, but “people are scared, and they’re going to work, and they’re doing what they’re told to do.”
Micah put it most clearly: “You don’t have to believe the propaganda to help spread it, and fear will turn ordinary people into participants.” Laura suggested that many of these workers are probably thinking, “I’m not Muggle-born, so I’m not at risk,” and that keeping their heads down will keep their families safe, which she tied back to the famous “First they came” poem. Eric’s takeaway was that people have enormous power when they resist together, which is exactly why division tactics are so effective.
Mad-Eye’s Eye, a Kitten Note, and a Fake Family Heirloom
Once Harry slips into Umbridge’s office with the help of a Decoy Detonator, things get even worse. He finds Arthur’s file, a copy of The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore, and his own Undesirable Number One poster, complete with a pink kitten note reading “To be punished.” Eric joked that Undesirable Number One sounds like the name of a debut album, then questioned Umbridge’s maturity. Laura called her “extremely emotionally immature,” adding that she clearly still has an ax to grind with Harry for embarrassing her at Hogwarts.
Then there is Mad-Eye Moody’s magical eye, now mounted in Umbridge’s door as a peephole. Micah said he had “a really bad taste” the first time he read this. “You’re taking the signature feature of one of the most accomplished Aurors in the wizarding world at this time, and you’re mounting it above your door as a trophy,” he said. Eric agreed: “It’s a conquered adversary’s body part. It is a trophy.” Laura noted that this answers a question from earlier in the book, when the Order was unable to recover Mad-Eye’s body.
The hosts also gave Harry a hard time for nearly getting caught yet again. Thicknesse walks in to leave a note and almost spots Harry’s elbow poking out from under the cloak, and Micah reminded everyone that the kitten plates on Umbridge’s walls were spying for her back in Order of the Phoenix. Andrew had a simpler fix: the trio should have spent those months figuring out how to make the cloak bigger instead of staking out the Ministry.
Arthur Weasley Stands Up to Runcorn
After a brief reunion with Ron in the lift, Harry is left alone with Arthur, and Arthur lets him have it. Believing he is talking to Runcorn, Arthur confronts him over turning in Dirk Cresswell, telling him Cresswell is ten times the wizard he is and warning that he will have to answer for it. Laura gave Arthur his flowers, pointing out how dangerous this kind of defiance is inside Voldemort’s Ministry.
Eric said the scene shows “the man that punched out Lucius Malfoy” back in Chamber of Secrets, adding that Arthur “would punch out Runcorn if he could get away with it.” Micah called it “definitely his Gryffindor side shining through, which we don’t see very often,” since Arthur is usually played as the lovable goofball. Andrew compared the “ten times the wizard” line to the way immigrants are so often treated as less than, when many of them are talented people their communities need.
Laura was struck by how performative every lift conversation in these chapters feels. “It just feels like this is another way of communicating the Ministry’s atmosphere of paranoia,” she said. “You can’t trust anybody.” The elevator talk also led to a fun detour, with Micah revealing his pet peeve: people who pull out their phones in elevators instead of simply saying good morning.
Why Is It Raining Inside the Ministry?
Arthur mentions that Yaxley is not the only one dealing with rain in his office, which opened up one of the best theories of the episode. Andrew wondered whether the building itself might be reacting to what is happening inside it, and Laura pointed out that Hogwarts does something similar.
Eric ran with the idea. The Ministry was built to serve all of wizardkind, and now Muggle-borns are being marched in, having their wands broken, and sent to Azkaban with “a sham of due process.” If a building had weather, he argued, it would work like emotions, and “the building is weeping because government is weeping.” Laura loved it so much that she declared it canon. Micah had wondered whether the Ministry had its own version of Peeves, and Eric noted that with so many confiscated magical artifacts in the building, any one of them could go off and cause chaos.
Dementors in the Courtroom and Umbridge’s Happy Place
Down in the dungeons, Harry finds Muggle-borns lined up along the corridor while Dementors drift up and down in front of them. Laura said the setup “totally screams Umbridge because it is both orderly and terrifying.” Micah noted that the Dementors are not just security here, since “their very presence strips people of hope and happiness.” Eric pointed out that a real court carries a presumption of fairness, while this one starts from an assumption of guilt. Even Harry’s disciplinary hearing in Order of the Phoenix did not have Dementors in the room. “If you’re here, you’ve already lost,” he said of these hearings.
Inside the courtroom, Umbridge keeps her cat Patronus going so the prosecutors stay warm while the accused freeze. Andrew called out the hypocrisy, especially since Umbridge is not even a pure-blood herself. When Hermione asks about the locket, Umbridge claims the “S” stands for Selwyn, a pure-blood family she says she is related to. Laura put it plainly: she is “literally using a stolen Horcrux as a pure-blood prop.”
The group then debated whether the locket is making Umbridge worse. Eric wondered whether “this level of depravity” was truly in her before she started wearing it. Laura was not convinced, noting that “she literally sent Dementors to Little Whinging” two books earlier. Micah thought the thrill of all this power is what feeds her Patronus, and Andrew agreed: “She’s the boss. She’s in power.”
Harry’s Big Rescue and Why the Movie Should Have Shown It
Umbridge’s lie about the locket is the last straw for Harry, who has “I must not tell lies” carved into the back of his hand because of her. He stuns both Umbridge and Yaxley, her Patronus vanishes, and the Dementors close in on Mary Cattermole. Harry conjures his stag with ease, while Hermione struggles to produce hers. Andrew asked why the Patronus has always been Hermione’s weak spot. Eric argued it is about circumstances more than skill, joking that “the further Hermione gets from the classroom, the further all of her magic falls apart.” Laura agreed that Hermione tends to crack under pressure, going all the way back to the Devil’s Snare in the first book, while Micah suggested Harry’s anger actually helps him in the moment.
Harry then leads the Muggle-borns up to the Atrium and, pulling rank as Runcorn, gets them out before the exits are sealed. Micah loved Harry threatening to do to the guard what he did to Dirk Cresswell, and he connected Harry’s advice to the Muggle-borns, to go home, get their families, and leave the country if they need to, with the people who were forced to flee Nazi Germany.
The hosts all wished this scene had made it into the film. “It’s Harry being a hero and actually saving people,” Eric said. Andrew called it “a good rebellion moment,” and Laura argued that the movie’s focus on Mary Cattermole alone loses the power of showing just how many people Harry saves.
So was Harry right to charge ahead before the plan was ready? Andrew noted that the job gets done, and that these are kids putting together a plan with no adults involved. Eric summed it up best: “He’s not right because he had a great plan that succeeded,” but he was right because he could do some good, since the people he rescued would probably have been thrown in Azkaban.