Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #585, Does the Sorting Hat Divide Students Equally Across Hogwarts Houses? And More MuggleMail
Show Intro
[Show music plays]
Andrew Sims: Welcome to MuggleCast, your weekly ride into the Wizarding World fandom. I’m Andrew.
Eric Scull: I’m Eric.
Micah Tannenbaum: I’m Micah.
Laura Tee: And I’m Laura.
Andrew: It’s a MuggleMail episode today. We’ve got some emails. We’ve got some voicemails. We’ve got a lot of great feedback on our recent discussions coming up in today’s episode.
News
Andrew: But first, we wanted to talk about a couple of books. Last week, we mentioned that Order the Phoenix Illustrated Edition, illustrated by Jim Kay, is out now. Eric is modeling it off. Eric, it’s heavy, right?
Eric: This is a murder weapon.
[Andrew and Micah laugh]
Micah: It really is.
Eric: And I’m actually looking for a disclaimer on the back that says, “Do not use this to blunt force somebody,” but it’s not there.
Andrew: Honestly, I am starting to wonder how do you read these things? You have to put it on your lap. You can’t travel with it. It’s a kind of effort to hold these things. I love them, they’re beautiful, but they’re big and heavy.
Eric: The only solace is this is clearly going to be the biggest and the heaviest because Order of the Phoenix had the most pages.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Laura: It was the longest.
Eric: It was the longest Harry Potter book, so nowhere to go but down in weight and lethality.
Andrew: But just a little bit. Not too much, though.
Eric: A little bit, yeah.
Micah: Well, you raise a good point, though, Andrew, because like you, I’ve been using this illustrated edition as we read through Chapter by Chapter of Sorcerer’s Stone. By the time we get to Order of the Phoenix, I don’t know how I’m going to be able to use this.
Eric: But you’re going to be stronger from having lifted all the other books so many times.
[Laura and Micah laugh]
Laura: Yep, you’re going to build up your tolerance. [laughs]
Eric: Get your reps in.
Andrew: Well, this is a MuggleMail episode, and it felt appropriate to start this review with an email. Micah, do you want to read this?
Micah: Sure. This email comes from Jennifer, and she says,
“Hey y’all! I was a bit worried about how many illustrations we were going to get for Book 5, since it is the biggest of the series, plus there’s not as many action-packed scenes as Goblet of Fire. However, I was pleasantly surprised and was blown away once again by how much hard work Jim Kay (and Neil Packer) put into this book. From Karkus’s head (page 277), to Snape and Sirius (pages 340-341), to Voldemort and Dumbledore’s duel (528-529), I was absolutely amazed by all of the stunning artwork in Book 5. Jim Kay captured Tonks (38) and Kingsley (42) perfectly, along with Neville and Luna (134). But my favorite pages have to be with Harry and the Thestral (142-143), and the truly heartbreaking scene of Harry and Dumbledore in his office (538).”
Yeah, this is an amazing drawing we should talk more about.
“On the Thestral’s harness, you see part of the Latin phrase ‘Finis vitae sed non amoris.'”
Hopefully I did that justice.
Eric: Nice job, Micah. As a two-year Latin student, you did great.
Micah: Okay. I should have gone to you, Eric. I’m sorry.
Eric: [laughs] I couldn’t have done it that well.
Micah: Jennifer looked it up, and in English, it reads,
“‘The end of life but not of love.’ You can see this phrase on a piece of parchment in Dumbledore’s office as well. The reason Harry can see Thestrals is because of Cedric’s death, and at the end of the book we see him mourning the loss of Sirius. This hits on such a deeper level, which makes both illustrations so much more poignant. I wasn’t expecting to have such an emotional reaction while looking through this book, but I think that is a testament to the heart and talent that Jim Kay has given us fans over the years. I’d love to hear your thoughts. Thank you all for all you do to keep this a fun and engaging podcast.”
Andrew: Thank you, and thank you for that detailed review. Yeah, there’s so much to love in this book. I’ve had a blast paging through it. You know what I found interesting? Right at the start, actually, in the dedication page, Jim Kay, he wrote in his dedication, “To Josephine, Dave, and all those who work so hard for the NHS,” the NHS being the National Health Service of the UK, which I thought was a really nice nod to the fact that we just went through COVID. I assume that’s why he gave a shout-out to the NHS.
Laura: Yeah, I think that’s a safe assumption.
Micah: Well, when you said that, I was thinking, too, noting that he did call out that he’s been going through some mental health challenges of his own, maybe that had something to do with his dedication too.
Andrew: That thought did cross my mind as well. But oh my gosh, I mean, we’ve said it before; these books are one of the best parts of fandom right now. Just to run through a couple things that really stood out to me: the Dementor attack on page 16, and they kind of have fun with some of these pages when Harry is going through a moment. On this page, there’s less text on the page than you would expect, but a lot of darkness on the page to highlight the Dementor attack. And a page or two later, we get Figg coming to help! It was really great seeing Figg illustrated.
Eric: And I think Figg is drawn as a woman of color.
Micah: She is.
Andrew: Yes!
Eric: Yeah, it’s very… so adding to diversity, adding to… I just love the way that they’re playing with some of these illustrations in a really cool way to bring these books more color.
Andrew: Just to run through some of the illustrations that really stood out to me. Jennifer mentioned the younger Tonks; that was nice to see. Also, Sirius, who looks younger than he does in the movies, so that was a pleasant surprise. Harry is looking fondly at him too, which just breaks your heart if you know what’s going to be happening later. There’s more nods to Newt in the creature illustrations. There’s a Black family tree. There’s a map of the Ministry of Magic, which I don’t think we’ve ever gotten before. Snape’s worst memory; we see Lily protecting Snape as an invisible Harry watches. That’s on page 417. Sirius heading into the veil. Augh! Oh my gosh.
Laura: Yeah, that one hurt. [laughs]
Andrew: So those were some of my favorites.
Eric: Yeah, Dumbledore and Voldemort battling; you get to see that next level magic we talked about. Going to London on the Thestrals; it’s this wonderful overhead shot. There’s this huge two-page for Grawp versus the centaurs on page 488, which is great. Actually, Grawp is, I think, really well done. He’s just an unwieldy guy. There’s another one of him on 446. I think as always, there are ones I want to see that aren’t in here. I mentioned Ginny in Book 2, that kind of a thing. The only one I could really think of is I was hoping to see Professor Lockhart when they go back to St. Mungo’s.
Micah: Oh.
Eric: Maybe an illustration of seeing what… just as a result of having done Book 2 illustrated…
Micah: His madness.
Eric: Yeah, seeing how far he has fallen, and that did not occur. But the amount of artwork and even just the decorations for the page alongside the text in this book is a tremendous feat. It’s really no wonder they had to bring on a second artist, and I’m really happy with their different complementary styles. Meg and I paged through this last night, and it’s really clever and interesting how they work together. And I think it’s really a gargantuan feat that has now been completed.
Laura: Yeah, I was going to say, I’m a big fan. Always been a big fan of the portraits that we see in these books, so portrait of Luna… although it was unsettling, the portrait of Umbridge…
[Andrew laughs]
Laura: I saw that and I was like, “Oh my God, this is exactly as she is described in the book.”
[Micah laughs]
Laura: And Imelda Staunton is amazing, and she portrayed Umbridge beautifully, but she is just quite a deal more pleasant than the actual description of the character.
Eric: [laughs] To look at.
Micah: Right.
Laura: So that was cool. And to Eric’s point, I think they do such a good job of immersing you in the mood of the moment, thinking about the “Snape’s Worst Memory” chapter and how the first part of that is all black pages. I need to look a little closer at the surrounding area, but it’s all very brightly colored. Did y’all notice that?
Eric: I noticed the bright red blood on the chapters where Harry is in detention.
Laura and Micah: Yeah.
Eric: Just splattered across several pages. As the only art on that page, it’s amazing. And terrifying at the same time.
Micah: I like how you brought up Luna, because she’s one of the characters that we see multiple times. We get that portrait of her that you mentioned at the very end of the book, but then she’s also in that shot with Neville. So it’s interesting that they chose to spend so much time with her, but this is kind of her big book when she comes on scene. I really loved more than anything – and I will say, I loved the scene in Dumbledore’s office at the very end of the book – but Peeves saluting the Weasley twins as they were exiting Hogwarts…
[Laura laughs]
Andrew: Oh, yeah.
Micah: … was just so cool, because unfortunately, Peeves is a character we never got to see in the movies, was never brought to life. We know he was cast in Sorcerer’s Stone, but they ended up cutting him from the film. So I just love being able to see those moments that don’t necessarily end up making it on screen. And again, Laura, I agree; Jim Kay’s ability to draw characters in those portraits are just so cool. I’m thinking back to Mundungus when he’s first introduced. He’s kind of sitting at the table, and there’s this pipe that he’s smoking, and there’s this green mist wafting into the air, and he just looks like he’s a guy who’s been out on the streets hustling. And then Jennifer mentioned Tonks, Kingsley… they are just so well done, so this is really just a great book to go through.
Laura: There’s lots of little Easter eggs. I mean, I think, Andrew, you called out the mention of Newt. We see a measurement of the pixies, I think they were, in Grimmauld Place, and the little thing just says “Newt Scamander” on it. There’s also an informational page on giants.
Eric: Yeah, they wear houses as hats, and yeah, different things as hats.
[Laura laughs]
Eric: A giant church bell as hats. It’s not in the book, but it colors the world.
Laura: It really does, and it makes you wonder, I mean, is this something that was consulted on to find out? Is this canon, or was this just a creative liberty that Jim Kay was able to take?
Eric: Yeah, it’s kind of like the things that are written in the margins of the old Comic Relief books. It’s like, can we take that as canon?
[Laura laughs]
Eric: But I’m just looking at this one – it’s page 279 – of Hagrid with the steak, nursing the eye.
Laura: Oh, yeah, that was a good one.
Eric: An amazing… and again, the background detail. You really just feel like you’re looking up at this giant.
Micah: There’s a lot of good Hagrid depictions in this. I’m also thinking about the one of him… I think it’s page 465. He’s busting out of his hut; he’s fighting off, I guess, the Ministry officials that show up to try and attack him. And then also, he’s carrying meat on his back as he leads students into the forest to teach them about Thestrals. So there’s just a lot of really fun depictions of Hagrid.
Andrew: Micah, you mentioned we should talk about that one of Harry and Dumbledore towards the end looking defeated. It was a really stunning illustration, like Jennifer said in her email. Dumbledore looks almost frail, and Harry looks kind of frail, and also they’re just both very sad, sitting in Dumbledore’s office. That was definitely a very striking illustration. I would love to see some of these printed out as art someday. I have to think they’ll release these as art prints one day, because it’s almost a shame that these are, dare I say, hidden in these books. I would love to have some of this art hanging up. And another thing I’ve really loved about this illustrated series is watching the characters grow up, particularly the children, watching them age over time. And I also thought one nice touch… like we’ve mentioned, the assistant illustrator Neil Packer, he joined Jim Kay for the first time. On all of his illustrations, you’ll find his initials in the corner of the illustration, and I really appreciate that because otherwise, you look at some of these illustrations, and most of Neil’s are smaller. You’re like, “Well, is this Jim’s or Neil’s?” So it’s nice, kind of like a peace of mind thing that you know who did what. So if you see an “NP” next to an illustration, it was Neil’s, and if you don’t see anything next to it, it was Jim Kay’s. I thought that was really great, so you’re not left wondering who did what.
Eric: Neil is also great at these really intricate… I’m thinking… there’s one that’s the entire Ministry of Magic underground, and it’s a shot by shot, floor by floor, what’s on each ground. They’re very almost like blueprints. It’s a really unique sort of very detailed, minuscule detail art style that’s very different than sort of the lush portraiture, watercolor-esque of Jim Kay, so it really works well together.
Andrew: And to that point, I think I speculated a week or two ago: I wonder if Neil is going to be the one taking over. His style is noticeably different than Jim Kay’s, so I wonder if they want to go with Neil or if they want to use somebody who’s closer to Jim Kay. I would hope it’s somebody who’s going to be closer to Jim Kay, just for the consistency’s sake.
Eric: Yeah, there’s no reason they can’t do both again as they did in this book. Maybe they’ll have an artistic duo to do… because there’s only two books left at this point. You’ve got to keep going.
Andrew: MinaLima is taking over for the final two books. [laughs]
Eric: I need to complete… no, they have their own illustrated books that they’re doing with the graphics and the…
Andrew: I know, I know.
Eric: But yeah, I need to complete my set. [laughs]
Andrew: Oh, yeah, absolutely. No, they’re going to finish this, but it’ll be interesting to see who they select for the final two books. But I do agree, Eric. That’s a good point. Even if they don’t use Neil to lead the illustrations in the next two books, they should still have him just to help bridge the gap between 5 and 6.
Eric: Plus, he’s got good experience going through fire on this one.
Andrew: So that’s the Order of the Phoenix Illustrated Edition. Check it out. Great holiday gift if you want to put something on your wish list. Also, we didn’t mention this book last week, but we should have. We mentioned last week that there’s a lot of books for Harry Potter fans coming out around the holiday season, and another one that came out is this book called The Magic of MinaLima. MinaLima are the graphic designers behind virtually everything you see in the Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts movies, and this book gives you a complete look at all of their Wizarding World work to date, showing how they worked together to design art for the Potter movies, the Fantastic Beasts movies, the theme parks, the conferences, the various Potter spinoff projects… and I have this book; every page is packed with artwork, and each page is dedicated to different elements, like the wanted posters that we first saw in Prisoner of Azkaban, or Credence Barebone’s documentation. There’s so much of that. Weasley Wizard Wheezes, Educational Decrees from the fifth movie, the Black family tapestry, the Marauder’s Map, and so much more. Lots of pull-out items to explore too, which is fun to see. And you also learn about how they met one another and how they got the gig working for the Wizarding World. So if you love their artwork – and who doesn’t? – definitely check out The Magic of MinaLima as well. Pound for pound, I mean, you get your money’s worth with this book because, like I said, the pages are packed with details. You can spend so much time looking at each page.
Eric: I was going to ask, how heavy is it, pound for pound?
[Andrew and Eric laugh]
Andrew: Not as big as Order of the Phoenix. I’d probably put it at Prisoner of Azkaban Illustrated Edition.
Eric: I see. Okay.
Andrew: All right, well, before we get to MuggleMail, little heads up for Apple Podcasts users: For just $2.99 a month, you can now receive ad-free MuggleCast and early access to each new episode of the show right within the Apple Podcasts app. By subscribing to the show, you’re supporting us just like our patrons do. Of course, you can pledge to our Patreon to receive many more benefits, but if you’d prefer to support us through the Apple Podcasts app, we’ll hook you up with no more advertising, and you’ll get each episode of MuggleCast on Mondays instead of Tuesdays. Just tap into the show, and you’ll see that subscribe button. Thanks for your support, no matter how you support us.
Listener Feedback
Andrew: And now let’s get to some MuggleMail – enough of us talking; let’s hear from our listeners – and we’re going to start with a voicemail from David on magic’s origin.
[Voicemail plays]
“Hi MuggleCast. My name is David from British Columbia, and this is a crackpot theory following up to your discussion from Episode 576 about where magic comes from. I think that magic comes from the metabolism of the wizard. You look at the most powerful wizards like Voldemort and Dumbledore, and they’re both described as being incredibly thin. You’ve got characters like Slughorn who don’t do as much classical magic because they just do Potions, and they’re described as more overweight. You also have these kids having these massive feasts on a daily basis, and none of them are really described as being overweight. The only overweight characters are characters like Neville, Crabbe, and Goyle, who are all known for not being very good at magic. Now, yes, this does have some problematic implications for body image, but it does seem that the more magic you’re using, the more energy it’s taking from your body, so the more food you have to eat. And so, I mean, the kids don’t take gym class or anything, so it only makes sense that magic comes from the food that they eat. That’s my theory. Thanks for listening.”
[Voicemail ends]
Eric and Laura: I love this.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: It’s so interesting.
Micah: When I was pulling voicemails, I just was waiting for Laura to respond to this, because this is in direct response to the episode that we did with Marc.
Laura: Yeah, no, I love it, especially the point about just how much the kids are eating and how much food is prepared at Hogwarts. I know we were wondering about food waste because it seems like they kind of prepare food in excess, but maybe not? I agree with David that there are some problematic things around body image and the way that people of various body sizes are represented in the books, but I think that you can still pull out this nugget of truth that if you’re trying to find a way to explain the source of magic, the energy has to come from somewhere. Just like when you’re working out, for example; when you’re working out consistently, you tend to eat more because you need more fuel to power those workouts. I think it’s probably a similar thing with magic. I also had a similar thought about Quidditch, because I was… I was actually thinking about this in the shower this morning before the show, but I was like, “How do these kids…? They’re athletes, and yeah, they go to Quidditch practice, but you never see them working out.” [laughs] And I’m like, you would think that they would have to do something to at least maintain their cardiovascular expenditure that they’re making every…
Eric: Stamina?
Laura: Yeah, exactly, to maintain their stamina, and I was like, “All we ever see is them actually playing Quidditch.” So it is a great point; I love this theory. And also, David has a great podcasting voice. [laughs]
Andrew: He does.
Laura: I just want to point that out.
Andrew: David, start a podcast.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Andrew: But yeah, but just extending David’s theory, if it’s going to take energy to cast spells, then it’s going to take a lot of energy and burn a lot of calories to be flying a broom, because a broom is magic.
Eric: It’s just so funny to think that Harry and all of the kids at Hogwarts are just covertly sort of next to the books just eating insane amounts of food, just absolutely crazy eating all the time because they need to do their spellwork.
Laura: Yeah, and it makes me wonder about Hermione in Goblet of Fire when she was refusing to eat. If this theory holds true, I wonder if this impacted her output.
Andrew: She was intermittent fasting.
[Everyone laughs]
Eric: Only eating between 6 and 10.
Micah: There is definitely a lot of food, but part of me wonders, too, because we’re seeing it through Harry’s eyes, and because he’s been deprived for so long living with the Dursleys, if it’s not actually that much food, it’s just how Harry interprets it because he’s not been fed growing up. Let’s be real.
Laura: Valid.
Eric: That’s fair too, I think, especially at first.
Andrew: This next voicemail is a pretty fun one.
[Voicemail plays]
“Hi MuggleCast. My name is Karen. I’m a listener from Canada. I’ve been listening to the podcast for about ten years, but I’ve never called in before. When I heard this situation, I knew I had to get your take on it. My best friend recently went out on a first date with a gentleman who seemed nice enough, but when they got to talking about their interests, she mentioned that she likes the Harry Potter books, and he said he had only read the adult versions of the books because they had more sophisticated language and a darker tone and story than the children’s versions.”
Laura: What?!
“Now, this is obviously not true, but he was adamant in his opinion. And so I was wondering, if you were in that scenario on a first date and someone had this strong opinion about something totally false about the Harry Potter series, how would you approach it?”
[Andrew laughs]
Laura: I would die on that hill.
Micah: Do you have the security nightmare sound effect?
[“It’s starting to sound like a security nightmare!” sound effect plays with sirens]
Laura: I would die on the hill arguing that, and then I would leave the date.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Andrew: Yeah, yeah. This guy’s a liar. I wouldn’t go back to this…
Micah: Yeah. Actually, I was just going to say, it should have been the Dumbledore liar…
Andrew: It should be the liar, yeah.
[Dumbledore Lie Count sound effect plays]
[Everyone laughs]
Laura: Do we add to the Dumbledore Lie Count?
Andrew: I would have stood up at the table and said, “You liar!” and then stormed out of there.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Eric: This is unfortunate.
Micah: And then asked him what book that’s from, and if he can’t answer…
Laura: I bet this guy went out and bought the adult versions of the books that do have different cover art. Remember, they made those because they didn’t want adults to feel embarrassed to be reading Harry Potter in public? He probably bought that and assumed that the text was different. I wonder if he even read it. “Did you even read it?” [laughs]
Andrew: I know, I would wonder that too. But maybe… we hear often about how, “Oh, Harry Potter is for kids,” and people just assume it’s kids’ language. So maybe, if I’m being generous, he did pick up the adult cover editions and read it, and was like, “Oh, this isn’t for kids; this is for adults.” He was just pleasantly surprised to learn that the writing in these books – particularly in the later ones – is actually for adults, for people of all ages.
Laura: You’re being very generous.
Andrew: But that’s a generous defense, yeah. [laughs]
Eric: I think this guy’s going through some stuff. He’s got to work on himself. He’s not ready to be out there dating.
Andrew: He’s a liar. Do not see this guy again.
Eric: He’s got to understand the way the Harry Potter books work. Otherwise, how are you going to ever have a prosperous relationship with that guy? That’s my question. I don’t know. I would run.
Micah: And for her, she’s a fan, so naturally she’s going to know that he’s full of it, so why would he even try? If in fact he is lying – and Andrew, I think you made a potentially compelling case for him – but she would know right off the bat that there’s no difference between the books, so what is this guy trying to sell me? I wonder if she started probing, asking, “Oh, well, what’s your favorite book, then? What was the biggest difference that you enjoyed?”
Andrew: Right, right.
Eric: I think she said that he was adamant that it was the case that the words had changed, in which case she probably told him, “Oh, you know, the only thing different about those is the covers,” and then he was like, “No, no, no, the writing is…” In that case, he’s doubling down.
Andrew: But on the other hand, you try to be polite because it’s a first date.
Micah: True.
Andrew: You don’t want to…
Eric: Yeah, somebody can be a fan and a self-described fan without a purity test. We’ve got to also get out of the habit of really getting down to people and quizzing them on stuff. But it is a funny little terrifying tidbit of this guy thinking that the adult books contain different writing.
Micah: I think it depends on how he delivered it too. If he’s coming across as trying to be like, “Oh, well, I’m a tough guy, and I only read the adult Harry Potter…”
Eric: “I read only the adult Harry Potter books.” [laughs]
Laura: Yeah, context is always king. But the fact that he apparently remained so adamant after being given information by somebody who knows what they’re talking about is a red flag. This has been MuggleCast’s new segment, Madam Puddifoot’s relationship advice corner.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: Let’s actually do that now!
[Laura laughs]
Andrew: Yeah, I am begging listeners: Share more Harry Potter-related stories from dates that you go on if you get any good stuff like this, or people pretending that they’re fans of Harry Potter. I would love to hear those stories. In terms of what I would actually do, I may just string him along and be like, “Oh, yeah, really?” And like I think maybe Micah or Eric was saying earlier, “What’s your favorite chapter? What’s your favorite book in this adult series?” And then I would just be quietly thinking to myself, “Oh my God, I have the best story ever for MuggleCast. I can’t wait to tell this on the pod!”
Laura: [laughs] Stay toxic, kids.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: Oh my God. I’m actually watching our inbox, and we have about 25… nope, 45 new emails about relationship advice, Harry Potter. So we’ve opened the flood gates.
Andrew: Excellent.
Laura: Man.
Andrew: We’ll get to it this Valentine’s Day.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Andrew: All right, next voicemail.
[Voicemail plays]
“Hey, MuggleCast. This is Caitlin, and I have basically been listening to you guys since day one. We are all about the same age, we’ve all grown up together, and I was even an original member of the Pickle Pack, so that’s how far back we go. Anyway, if you want to feel old, I have a 10-year-old son now, and the other day I was in the car listening to your 500th episode from last year, and he gets in the car, and he was like, ‘So are you guys all going to be in your fifties when they release the 1,000th episode of MugFest?’ So you guys are MugFest to him. Anyhow, as I’m gearing up to watch Season 5 of Cobra Kai on Netflix, I just keep thinking about how cool it would be if they basically took the same exact premise from Cobra Kai and applied that to the Harry Potter universe, so you had a whole story starting with the characters in the current timeline as adults, but you’re telling it from Draco Malfoy’s point of view, and also having these flashbacks where you can see how, ‘You know, Harry really was a jerk in that situation. We were only getting the seven books through Harry’s perspective, but now we can see things through the antagonist’s perspective.’ But it turns it on its head into this… taking him from an antagonist to this lovable anti-hero. And anyway, I just think that would be such a great idea for Warner Bros. to do a TV series that’s like the Draco Malfoy ‘Draco Kai.’ So anyway, I would love to hear your guys’ thoughts if you guys are fans of Cobra Kai. And hey, thanks for sticking around all this time and being here for those of us who have stuck with you. It really means the whole world to be able to turn on a podcast and just feel like I am home again and like a kid again, so thank you guys. I love you all. Take care.”
[Voicemail ends]
Andrew: Thanks, Caitlin. That was sweet.
Laura: Caitlin is over here getting me emotional. [laughs]
Eric: While we’re playing sound effects, why don’t we do the “Max that” idea? This is a wonderful idea that Caitlin has presented.
[“Max that” sound effect plays]
Andrew: Max that, here at MugFest.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Eric: MugFest!
Laura: MugFest. I think we should change our name.
Andrew: Micah, you watch Cobra Kai, right? Or you have?
Micah: Yeah, I love Cobra Kai, and I think the idea that Caitlin throws out there is a really, really good one. One of the things that Cobra Kai just does such an amazing job of is the nostalgia factor, bringing back characters that were in the Karate Kid movie, probably going back 30 plus years at this point. And also, I think… when I talk about nostalgia, right, these were movies that were put out in the ’80s, and so there’s a lot of really great references to the ’80s and the ’90s, especially with one of the lead characters, Johnny Lawrence. He just doesn’t seem to have evolved into present day, and so he’s still trying to do things the way we would do things in the ’80s and the ’90s. I’m not sure necessarily how we could tie that to Hogwarts. But I think maybe the movies would need to be out for a little bit longer of a period of time first, and then we can go back and revisit the story through Draco Malfoy’s perspective, and maybe even bring back some of the older cast, which would have been the younger cast at the time.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Eric: Well, does Tom Felton indicate in his autobiography, for those who read it, that he would be interested in doing something like that?
Micah: I have not read that part yet, but it doesn’t mean it’s not in there. I’m only about halfway through the book.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: There you go.
Andrew: You’ll get that at the end in the epilogue.
Laura: [laughs] 19 years later.
Micah: I will say, I was really shocked at just how big the whole Cobra Kai fanbase is, because I put out a tweet going back a couple months ago when I started watching, and I was like, “Where has this show been? This is in the top five shows I’ve ever watched,” and it got 1,000 likes, which is not normal for my social media engagement. [laughs]
Andrew: Look at you, Micah! Look at this influencer.
Eric: Wasn’t it retweeted by one of the actors in the show too?
Micah: It must have been somebody who works on the show or one of the actors. Yeah, I think so.
Andrew: All right, well, thank you for that, Caitlin. We have one more voicemail today from Karina.
[Voicemail plays]
“Hey y’all. This is Karina, a German Hufflepuff listener and a huge fan of the show. And your recent discussion about the first book’s title and how and why it was changed in the American edition got me thinking that maybe you might find interesting, in case you didn’t know, that in the German translation, they used yet another word. So they didn’t use the German word for philosopher or sorcerer, but they called it something like ‘Harry Potter and the Wise Man’s Stone,’ and interestingly, in Dutch they did the same. And I did a little research just now and found that the historical Philosopher’s Stone – the imaginary thing that alchemists were seeking – was called ‘the wise man’s stone’ in German, or is called ‘the wise man’s stone’ in German. So I guess that’s the reason why the publisher chose that term instead, and who knows how many other different titles are out there in other languages that we don’t know of, right? So yeah, that’s all. Thank you so much for everything, and bye.”
[Voicemail ends]
Andrew: Thank you, Karina.
Laura: I always love hearing about localization efforts like that. It’s really interesting, and I think they clearly did a good job of making sure that the title was going to resonate with people.
Eric: Especially those familiar with the legend too. If that is what the Stone was historically called in that language, then they would go to that for the book title. That makes a lot of sense.
Micah: I just love that we have our German listeners saying “Hey y’all” now to start their voicemails.
[Eric and Micah laugh]
Laura: I know. It’s spreading, y’all.
Andrew: It’s going worldwide. Well, and I’m half-German, so I enjoyed hearing Karina’s lovely German accent. I’m going to send that voicemail to my grandparents.
Micah: She could do a podcast too. She has a podcast voice.
Laura: Yeah, honestly.
Micah: Her and David.
Eric: Everyone has a podcast voice. Pick up a microphone. Go forth and podcast, y’all.
Laura: [laughs] All right, y’all, let’s get into some emails. Our first email comes from Clare, who’s getting in touch about Hermione’s Christmas gift in the first book. Clare says,
“Peace and love, y’all! But I think Hermione’s Christmas gift to Harry definitely should have gotten a 5 for utility! The last frog in the box that Harry ends up giving to Neville contains Dumbledore’s card, which is where Harry recognized Nic Flamel’s name from! P.S. Listening to MuggleCast brings me so much comfort and happiness every week. Thanks for all that you do!”
Andrew: Thank you, Clare.
Laura: That was sweet.
Andrew: And I think that’s well-reasoned.
Laura: That’s a good call-out, yeah.
Micah: Are we going to be rating Harry’s gifts now every year?
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Andrew: We should just rate everything.
Eric: Only if people enjoyed that segment, and it seems like…
Micah: Well, clearly they did.
Eric: Yeah, yeah.
Andrew: This email is from Deborah about Hedwig delivering Harry’s Christmas gift, speaking of that.
“While listening to Episode 578 where you spoke about the gifts Hedwig brings Harry, you mentioned that you thought it was due to ensuring the protection he got from being at the Dursleys’. My headcanon is that Hedwig knew it was a day of celebration and would go to Harry’s summer home to get him a gift. Since the Dursleys never gave Harry real gifts, I imagine them handing Hedwig literally whatever was in their hand at the time. If they wouldn’t give her anything, I think she’d pester them, and perhaps peck at their hands, until they inevitably hand over something for her to bring back to Harry. They were small, but I think of it as her doing what she could to take care of him. Even if the Dursleys didn’t really care about Harry at the time, Hedwig made the effort to make sure Harry had something ‘special.’ Love the show, and am enjoying us all getting to go through the books together again. Thanks! Deborah.”
Thank you, Deborah. I agree.
Laura: Love it.
Andrew: That’s a good theory about Hedwig too. Looking out for her number one.
Eric: Even though he does not reciprocate.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Eric: Usually, usually. This next email comes from Rin. She says,
“Hey y’all! I have a question about something that has always bothered me. In the Halloween chapter, when Harry and Ron save Hermione from the troll, why doesn’t Hermione use her own wand to stop the troll? She obviously has proven to be the best of the trio at magic at this point. So why wouldn’t she have used the Levitating Charm herself instead of instructing Ron? Did she not have her wand with her? Is there something that I am missing? Thanks, Rin.”
Rin, to this I would say Hermione does not always perform the best under pressure. And as an example to this, I would point to the “There’s no wood” comment that she makes at the end of this book, where the Devil’s Snare is creeping in, and she’s like, “Right, fire!” So Hermione is an exceptional witch, probably the brightest of her age, but it’s the pressure of the troll being directly above her, about to crush her, that renders her inert. And I, too, would be freaking out so much and not necessarily using all of my faculties in a moment like that.
Laura: Yeah, and I think she’s even described as being plastered against the opposite wall, paralyzed in fear. She’s not even making any kind of attempt to escape because she is just so stricken in this moment. And I think Eric brings up a great example. She does get better about this through the books; maybe that’s something that we can look out for as a growth moment for her.
Micah: She’s definitely stressed. There’s no question. Or sorry, she’s in shock. Well, she’s stressed, too, because she was just in the bathroom for hours on end, crying her eyes out because of what happened.
Eric: She’s depleted, yeah.
Micah: She’s taken by surprise. Yeah, and I think this is probably the first real situation she’s been in, too, in the wizarding world – Eric, to go off of what you were saying too – where she’s actually in some kind of danger, and she doesn’t know how to respond. It’s the whole… yes, she would be good at casting a spell, but to me, this is more of that street smarts situation than it is a book smarts situation.
Eric: It’s practical application of all the magic that she knows in her head. She just is not familiar enough with actually casting the spell.
Micah: Exactly. All right, our next email comes from Matt, talking about why Hagrid really went to get Harry. He says,
“Hey y’all! I’m a bit late on this topic, but listening to the mail episode I suddenly came up with my theory that truly explains why Dumbledore sent Hagrid to pick up Harry. Harry is just a convenient excuse for Hagrid to have a reason to go to Gringotts and pick up the Sorcerer’s Stone. Dumbledore only trusts Hagrid to get the Stone, but he will be noticed if he goes to Gringotts. But if Hagrid is traveling with a famous, previously unseen young wizard who needs vault access, then he becomes the world’s most invisible giant. Harry’s celebrity status is the ultimate distraction. Otherwise it wouldn’t matter who got sent to pick up Harry, and so Dumbledore is already finding great ways to use Harry! What do you think? Thanks for everything, y’all! Matt (Hufflepuff)”
Andrew: That’s a really great theory. Nobody’s going to think twice about Hagrid if he’s just taking Harry into the Gringotts vault. He’s kind of a double agent.
Eric: Yeah, the hiding in plain sight of it all is really nice.
Andrew: Yeah. Great, great theory, Matt.
Laura: Using Harry as a distraction again. Dumbledore using Harry as a pawn in the game of life. [laughs]
Andrew: This one’s okay, though. This one’s okay, though.
Eric: Why, because he’s nice to Harry and tells him…?
Andrew: No, because… well, Harry has to go get his gold anyway, so he has perfect reason to be there and for Hagrid to take him. I’m the Dumbledore apologist on the panel. Speaking of MuggleMail, I saw an email saying, “You guys are too tough on Dumbledore.” I’m not. I’m a Dumbledore apologist. I’ve always got Dumbledore’s back.
Laura: [laughs] I’m just imagining Dumbledore being like, [imitating Dumbledore] “Hey, Hagrid, while you’re at Gringotts, could you just pick up this thing for me?”
Andrew: [laughs] I like your Dumbledore voice. It’s very tired.
Laura: Yeah, well, I mean, I assume he’s tired. He’s old. All right, our next email comes from Sarah regarding why Ron is allowed a rat at Hogwarts. Sarah says,
“Hey y’all! Why is Ron allowed to take a rat to Hogwarts as his pet when on the letter it only says to bring owls, cats, and toads?”
I think Scabbers is a legacy pet. I think he was grandfathered in. [laughs]
Andrew: That’s what I’m thinking as well. The Weasleys… there’s a long line of Weasleys; they might get a little leniency. And of course, there’s the Pettigrew of it all. Putting aside the Weasleys, I can see parents writing to Dumbledore, “Hey Dumbledore, my student – my son or daughter – who’s about to go to Hogwarts is very excited, but they really love this pet. Can they please bring this pet?” And I can see Dumbledore going, [imitating Dumbledore] “Oh, yeah, that’s fine. No worries. Yeah, they can come.”
[Laura laughs]
Andrew: Because Dumbledore loves the chaos of it all, and of course, Dumbledore is happy to bend the rules.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Andrew: So he’s going to be like, “Ooh, little rats running around. That sounds fun.”
Micah: Scabbers is a hand-me-down, right? And I think if we look at Ron in particular, he gets a lot of hand-me-downs from his older brother – other older brothers, I should say. And I was thinking more about this, too, this whole idea of the Weasley family being in possession of a rat; it kind of speaks to financial situation too, that all they can afford is a disgusting rat. The connotation of that, to me, says a lot about what J.K. Rowling is trying to say about the Weasley family. Just from a financial standpoint; we know they’re lovely people. But I think, digging a little bit deeper, there is something there, the fact that his pet is a rat.
Eric and Laura: Yeah.
Laura: Do we ever find out exactly how Percy came to be in possession? I can’t imagine that Scabbers, a.k.a. Peter Pettigrew, snuck into a pet shop in a vie to be purchased by a family. I’m imagining he just kind of turned up in the garden one day, and they were like, “Oh, a rat!” [laughs]
Eric: Turn up in the garden, show a little bit of intelligence, endear himself to Percy.
Andrew: Just doing some quick googling. I don’t know if there’s a firm canon answer.
Eric: Well, because if you think about it, Wormtail always needed to be close to a powerful wizarding family because he was keeping tabs on Voldemort’s return…
Andrew: Right.
Eric: … so pretty much within a few years, finding the Weasleys makes the most sense.
Laura: And the Weasleys are probably the most likely of the highly connected pure-blood families to have taken a rat in, right? I can’t imagine the Malfoys doing that, for example.
Eric: And they’re at enough of a distance… even though they were in the Order the first time, or associated with Dumbledore the first time, they were in enough distance that they wouldn’t know about Wormtail’s Animagus transformation.
Andrew: And by the way, I have some news for everybody about the “Hey y’all.” The other day I did remove it from the contact form. We’ve played it out. It’s been fun.
[Laura laughs]
Eric: Oh!
Andrew: Everybody’s welcome to continue adding “Hey y’all” if you want, but it’s no longer built into the form.
Laura: Andrew is getting too annoyed as we read every email.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Andrew: I mean, I just don’t want to run the joke into the ground. We’ve had our fun with it.
Laura: Yeah. Well, unfortunately for you, that’s just how I talk, so it’s going to keep happening. [laughs]
Andrew: I have no problem with it; we just don’t need to make our listeners start their emails with it for the rest of time.
Laura: Right, right.
Andrew: But actually, on that point, this next email is from Amanda, and she says,
“First of all, my goodness, I loved seeing that ‘Hey y’all,’ but my Canadian heart couldn’t just leave it there! So on that note… Hey, MuggleCast! On Episode 582, ‘Have a Broomstick, Potter,’ it is discussed that there’s not much difference between first and second years playing on the Quidditch teams when it comes to their age, but I think there is an argument for there being flying lessons throughout first year. If this is true, students can get used to flying, flying techniques, and Madam Hooch can scope out who would be adept at playing on the school teams the following year. I like that Harry was pushed through to play, as it added some great action in the books, and as discussed, it allowed for Harry to be really good at something in the wizarding world, which was important for him. I’d love to know your thoughts!”
Laura: Yeah, I suppose that’s fair. And as a point of comparison, maybe y’all had a similar experience, but I remember being in high school, for example, oftentimes with school athletics, freshmen were not allowed to participate. You had to audition… or not audition. What’s the right word for sports?
Andrew: Try out.
Laura: Try out, thank you. I was a drama kid, so “audition” is the word that comes to mind for me.
[Eric laughs]
Laura: But yeah, they would have to try out, and it would be towards the end of their first year, and then in their sophomore year, they got to start playing sports. Did anyone else have a similar experience?
Andrew: No, but I know what you’re talking about. I think I saw similar things in my high school. Laura didn’t play Quidditch, but she did star in “Quidditch: The Musical.”
Laura: Fortunately for everyone, I never starred in a musical, because I cannot sing.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: So this next email comes from Anonymous the Hufflepuff.
“I just started listening to MuggleCast yesterday. I’m really enjoying it, and my favorite segment is definitely the trivia. I had some theories about the latest chapters. On the fact that Malfoy probably knows the Unforgivable Curses, I think yes, he does, but slipping forward to Goblet of Fire, I know that in Mad-Eye’s first Defense Against the Dark Arts class, he tells them about the Killing Curse, and says that they could all get their wands out, pointing them at him, and he doubted he would get as much as a nosebleed. When you guys were talking about the flying class being a plot point for Harry to get on the Quidditch team, I think that’s what it is, but if Minerva hadn’t seen him flying, Wood would have if Harry had decided to try out for the team later in the year. I think first years could try out; they just don’t usually have enough experience to be good enough for the team. Thank you for your podcast!”
Yeah, it’s definitely possible.
Andrew: Yeah. And it’s also fun to wonder: Would Harry have decided to try out for the team later in the year, like William asks?
Eric: And knowing that they are looking for a Seeker, that the Gryffindor team doesn’t have a Seeker as of that time, there would be a notice on the billboard in the common room for sure, and Wood – knowing how intense Oliver Wood can get – would probably be stalking around looking for people, tossing a ball at people to see if they catch it.
[Andrew and Eric laugh]
Eric: Like, “Hey, new Gryffindor! Heads up! Okay, do you want to be a Seeker?”
Andrew: Yeah, and we’ve spoken about how McGonagall is very competitive when it comes to Quidditch. I would think at some point she’d be like, “Hey, Wood, you should let Harry run through a tryout, because his dad was a Quidditch star, so maybe he’s got it too.”
Eric: [imitating Hermione] It’s in his blood.
Micah: I do like the point that’s raised about the Unforgivable Curses, though I still think Malfoy would have tried something if in fact he and Harry ended up dueling that night. If not one of the Unforgivable Curses, certainly something maybe that he’s been working on in his own at home growing up, and he knows would inflict a lot of pain on Harry. So I just don’t think it was a wise decision for Harry to be like, “Oh, yeah, you know what? I’m going to go out and tussle it up with a pure-blood wizard who’s grown up knowing probably all sorts of spells, and I actually don’t know a whole lot of anything.” Bad decision, Harry. Bad decision. All right, this next email comes from Josh, who talks about proper Sorting. He says,
“Hey y’all! I was listening to Episode 580, ‘Sorting Too Soon,’ and had a thought. Is it the job of the Sorting Hat to equally divide the first year students into the four Houses? So if a person had Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff traits, would the hat put you in the House that needs students? Otherwise, would there have been years in Hogwarts history where a House got few or no new students that year? Just a few thoughts. Love your podcasts!”
And we also had a similar question come from listener Tyler, so we had a couple of questions about how the Sorting works in terms of balancing out the Houses.
Eric: I think what Josh is asking: Is the Sorting Hat the Pottermore Sorting system, or is it real life, very variable kind of Sorting system?
Andrew: Right, right.
Laura: Oh, that was such… people were so heated about that in the day, and you can’t blame them, because anytime you looked at the number of members of each House, they were pretty close to equivalency across the board.
Andrew: And Pottermore was trying to even it out because there was a competition on Pottermore.com, so they had to create a level playing ground. But we all take our Hogwarts Houses very seriously, so we don’t want to be Sorted based on what House needs some more people. That was a big problem. Now, in Hogwarts, I would think there has to be a little bit of weight being applied to even out the Houses, because there’s a point system there as well.
Eric: Yeah. I want to take it for its word where it really does Sort you where they think you’ll succeed the most, which means there will be a year where more people are Ravenclaw or more people are… by maybe five or ten or twenty kids.
Micah: It just could be this book, because she was introducing the Houses, so she couldn’t just slight one of the Houses in favor of the others.
Laura: Yeah. But then it raises the question, if the Sorting Hat is Sorting on a scale depending on where it needs people to go, if you were a first year, say this year, and you got Sorted into Gryffindor, wouldn’t you wonder, “Hey, if I went to Hogwarts a year earlier or a year later, would I have ended up in another House?”
Micah: That’s a good question.
Laura: I have questions for the Sorting Hat. [laughs]
Andrew: I’ve said it before; I’ll say it again. Sometimes we Sort too soon.
Eric: Aw.
Laura: [laughs] Yeah, you’ve said that, right?
Eric: That’s definitely an Andrew line, yeah.
Andrew: I’m taking that as my own.
[Eric laughs]
Laura: All right, our next email comes from Biglimpen from South Carolina, in defense of Petunia Dursley. They say,
“Hey y’all! First, let me start with a thank you! I definitely almost crashed with laughter while driving home listening to the podcast when Laura added the ‘Hey y’all.’ One of my jobs is at a bar where I check IDs at the door. In the south, ‘Hey y’all’ WAS just a common greeting. Now I will have to come up with an excuse for my uncontrollable laughter.”
I’m so glad that you didn’t crash.
“Laughter aside, I’m writing because I can’t sit idly by while Petunia gets so much hate. I get it, we have to love Harry to a degree, especially since his name is the title. However, I feel as though this leads us to only view Petunia through his lens. But we can’t just so easily jump over Petunia’s feelings as if she is not human. I feel a lot of pity for her. Here is a woman who once was an only child, and like Dudley, was most likely praised and worshiped by her parents (yes, a small assumption, but it explains her extremes). She then has a little sister, which means she is no longer the most important, at least in the eyes of her parents. She is then made to feel not only unimportant, but a lesser person because her sister is magical and she is not. We talk about her possibly being envious, but not enough about why she may be envious. Petunia is the elder sibling, so that would make Lily about 11 years old around the time she goes to Hogwarts, which means Petunia is a teenager. So in her most formative years growing into adulthood, this is how she feels she is being treated by her family. Now, do I think her family did this on purpose? Not at all, but I had an ex-girlfriend teach me a phrase a long time ago that I never forgot: ‘You said, but I heard.’ Now, she takes all those feelings into her adult life, but manages to overcome them. In a Molly Weasley kind of way she is successful. She finds herself with a husband who loves her, and a young son for whom she would do anything. THEN, all of a sudden she is tasked with taking care of the love child of her sister…”
I don’t think Harry was a love child, but I’ll let it go.
“… the woman she attributed most of the blame to for making her feel so small, insecure, and forgotten in the earlier stages of her life. I know she is an adult and should not behave in such a manner as to treat Harry so badly. Also, maybe she should sympathize with his situation, knowing what she had been through herself. However, I just wonder when she looks at Harry, is she an adult or a young teenage girl staring at the reasons for all her insecurities and shortcomings in life? Most people can be brave on paper, but it is rather hard to be brave in real life, and she faced her demons every time she looked at Harry. It is easy to blame magic as the point of contention, because it is obvious. However, I believe Harry just being in the house is a struggle for her on more than just the front of magic. I hate to say this because I love Albus, but I don’t truly think Dumbledore knew what he was asking of Petunia when he left Harry on her doorstep. Thanks for reading. Love you guys. You make my ride to work awesomesauce!”
This is lovely.
Eric: Yeah. Thanks, Biglimpen, for that deep dive on Petunia.
Laura: I know, deep dive defense of Petunia. Yeah, I think… we’re all a product of our upbringing in one way or another, and I think… are we all oldest children on this panel? Are we all the oldest?
Eric: Oh my goodness. I am.
Laura: I think we are. We’re the oldest siblings, right? So to an extent, I think we can all relate to the idea of going through those teen years and feeling like, “Oh my God, my younger sibling can do no wrong. It’s constant praise. They get away with more than I got away with when I was younger.”
Eric: Yes, definitely that one.
Laura: So that’s a really normal reaction for people to have. And I think that Biglimpen points out… it’s a really astute observation to point out that Petunia never outgrew it, because it was such an extreme example. I think mostly, most of us hopefully grow out of this, but it is very real. I love that you pointed that out.
Eric: Maybe Dumbledore thought he was therapizing. He’s like, “This will be good for Petunia. She never got over it.”
[Laura laughs]
Andrew: I do think sometimes we are very hard on Petunia, maybe a little too much. While Laura, you were reading that email, some of our listeners didn’t love this email, because they point out – and I think rightfully – that… Court was saying, “She was abusive. There might be complex reasons for that, but there is never an excuse.” Yeah, Petunia still did treat Harry terribly, and shame on her for that. But yeah, she’s got a complicated history.
Micah: I like this email because it challenges us to think in a different way about Petunia, and almost going back to the voicemail we got earlier from Caitlin about doing a series through the eyes of Draco Malfoy. We’re looking at things through Petunia’s lens here, and potentially how she was so affected by her own upbringing, and that certainly informed how she grew up and how she does treat Harry. And I think we talked about it on a previous episode, though: This was an opportunity for her, though, potentially to reintroduce herself to the wizarding world, and she didn’t decide to take advantage of it; she chose to go the other route and treat Harry like a lot of crap and try and act as if the magic wasn’t something that was going to manifest itself. And once it does, she tries to continuously deny it and have nothing to do with it. She could have taken Harry to Diagon Alley. She could have gone to Hogwarts maybe at one point if she was a good guardian, but she’s just too frustrated by what happened in the past.
Eric: That’s actually a great point. I really wonder if Petunia… I mean, Petunia could have seen Diagon Alley. She could have seen Gringotts. She could have, as Harry’s shepherd and guardian, really gotten into some of those spaces that she was barred from previously. But I wonder if she turned that down when Lily went too and offered to show her places. So just a lifelong rut that she’s been in.
Laura: In defense of Biglimpen – because I see the comments in the Discord here – I would just point out that it’s a really good exercise, even academically, when you’re analyzing a text, to try and understand the formations and the actions of why characters do things the way they do, even if you acknowledge that there’s no justification for it. I don’t think anyone here, including Biglimpen, is trying to justify Petunia’s actions; it’s more trying to dive in deeper into the character and learn about her motivations, and although it is a choice that she’s behaving the way she is, looking a little deeper and understanding where that choice comes from, even if there’s zero justification for it and we can still agree she’s, at the end of the day, a bad person for what she’s doing here.
Eric: Yeah, I agree with MustBeAWeasley92 in the Discord, who says, “Go to BetterHelp.com, Petunia.”
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Laura: Really. For real.
Andrew: /MuggleCast. [laughs]
Eric: A little bit of understanding of mental health would have done the world a favor, but that sort of thing wasn’t talked about when Petunia was growing up. So we’ve got two more emails here on this show, and the next one comes from…
Andrew: Snape with a Perm.
Eric: Okay, I wasn’t… I thought that was the subject.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Andrew: That’s what I thought too. [laughs]
Eric: Snape with a perm, and I’m thinking, and I’m sweating, going, “What’s their name?” Okay, Snape with a Perm says, “Hey y’all, hey y’all.” Oh, so there’s the arbitrary “Hey y’all,” but then they actually said, “Hey y’all.”
“So I saw a video on YouTube that brought up an interesting point: Isn’t the Hogwarts Express super inconvenient for students who already live close to Hogwarts? Why would they have to travel down south to London just to go back up north again? I’d love to hear your thoughts and possible explanations for this.”
Guys, is it ever said that every student has to take the train to get to Hogwarts?
Andrew: We know Harry didn’t year two.
[Andrew and Eric laugh]
Eric: I mean, in general.
Andrew: Clearly there’s some options. My first reaction is it’s part of the experience. That’s part of the Hogwarts experience. You start a new year at Hogwarts, you take the train. I would want that. Sometimes when you fly… let’s say cross country. Let’s say you start in LA and you’re going to Florida. Sometimes you get on these dumb flights where first you go to Seattle, you have a layover, then you go to Florida. That just happens sometimes. So I don’t know, I think if I was a student and in this situation, I’d probably want to be on the train, because you’re with your friends; you’re seeing them all there for the first time. You want to be there for the grand arrival.
Eric: If you look at the population centers of the UK, it’s just that there are so many millions more people down near London and the south than there are in the middle of nowhere, Scotland, by many orders of magnitude. So the Hogwarts Express exists as a convenient method to get a large amount of students – but not all – to Hogwarts. Surely there’s students that actually lived in Hogsmeade, which is the only sole wizarding village in the UK. There are people that live there and can just go down the street to Hogwarts to attend, or the Floo Network that’s connected to a grate somewhere in Hogsmeade. Surely there are students arriving each year this way, but our heroes prefer the London and the Hogwarts Express route.
Micah: Yeah. I’ve got to imagine as you get older, though, you want a quicker way to get to school. I don’t know, you Portkey over…
Andrew: True.
Micah: … or do something that doesn’t require you to be on a train for hours on end.
Andrew: It was a big deal in high school.
Micah: Driving, right?
Andrew: Right, when you hit junior year, I guess it was, you were allowed to drive and park at school.
Micah: Screw the bus.
Andrew: No more buses! I get to leave the house later, I get to listen to my own music, I get to stop at McDonald’s on my way in…
[Eric laughs]
Micah: There you go.
Eric: Maybe that’s it. I think Court agrees with you, Andrew. She says, “I’d most definitely be asking my mom to drive me to London regardless, so I could have that train experience.” And then I’m adding to that, maybe there’s some fast food you can only get in London.
Andrew: I would stop at PrĂȘt.
[Eric laughs]
Micah: Speaking of buses, though, I bet there’s also just a safety component to it for parents of knowing, “Hey, your kids are getting on a train, it’s somewhat supervised, and it’s going to Hogwarts,” versus just leaving it up to them to figure out how to get there, especially those early years.
Andrew: Or what if there’s souvenirs for sale on the Hogwarts Express? Like the 2022 Hogwarts School Year shirt, exclusively available on the Hogwarts Express.
Eric: The Hogwarts Railways sweater. [laughs]
Andrew: Yeah, or a collectible coin. I wouldn’t want to miss out on that kind of thing.
[Andrew and Eric laugh]
Micah: One more email to go here – it’s a fun one to end on – from Levi, who says,
“Hey y’all! Did you know in Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, when Professor Quirrell says ‘Troll in the dungeon, troll in the dungeon,’ Dumbledore replies by sending everyone to their dormitories, however the Slytherins’ dormitory is in the dungeon, so is Dumbledore sending the Slytherins to their doom? Also, I love your podcast. It’s so great, I listen to it every day. Thank you for being the best podcast.”
Well, thank you, Levi. It’s a great question he asked, though.
Eric: It’s kind of a security nightmare when you think about it.
Laura: I’m just imagining one of the professors, probably McGonagall, being like, “But Albus, the Slytherins’ dormitory is in the dungeon,” and Dumbledore just steeples his fingers and looks at her with a twinkle in his eye.
[Everyone laughs]
Laura: He’s just like, “I know.”
Eric: I saw that reproduced as a… what is that comic strip? “Life as a Background Slytherin” or something, where a lot of it is Dumbledore and McGonagall and it’s stuff exactly like that. Yeah, I love it.
Micah: Is this a connecting the thread to Deathly Hallows when they sent…? Was that just a movie-ism when they send the Slytherins to the dungeons?
Laura: I think that was just a movie-ism.
Micah: Okay, that’s what I thought.
Andrew: Yeah. [laughs]
Laura: I don’t think any of the… most of the Slytherins fled. I think they left. It was true that I think Pansy was like, “There’s Potter right there; let’s get him,” and I think Minerva told them, “You guys can just leave.” I think she just told them to get out.
Micah: Right.
Andrew: Perpetuating the Slytherin hate in the movies.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Micah: I like Laura’s interpretation, though, of Albus just kind of rubbing his hands together and…
[Laura laughs]
Micah: Just a few less Slytherins to grow up.
Andrew: [imitating Dumbledore] “Ooh, I can’t wait to see what trouble this causes.”
Laura: We’ve got to reform the Slytherin House reputation, guys.
[Andrew laughs]
Laura: Let’s just start fresh. [laughs]
Micah: But you know what that is, Andrew? It is a security nightmare to send your students to face a fully grown mountain troll.
[“It’s starting to sound like a security nightmare!” sound effect plays with sirens]
Andrew: I hear you, Micah. Well, on that appropriate note for this show, that does it for MuggleMail this week. Next week on the show, we’ll discuss Chapters 15 and 16 of Sorcerer’s Stone, and then the following week we’ll wrap up Sorcerer’s Stone with the final chapter and looking back at the book. If you have any feedback about today’s MuggleMail or next week’s chapters, you can send an owl to MuggleCast@gmail.com, or you can use the contact form on MuggleCast.com. Now, unfortunately, without the “Hey y’all” pre-written, but you are still welcome to type it if you wish. To send a voice message, record it using the voice memo app on your phone, and then email us that file. Or you can use our phone number, which is 1-920-3-MUGGLE; that’s 1-920-368-4453. Micah recently saved our phone number, by the way, so thank you, Micah. Because who knows if we’d be able to do another “MUGGLE” number? It’d be way less fun.
Micah: Well, thank you, Andrew, because you really stepped up to do the actual saving. I just alerted you to the problem. You solved it.
Andrew: [laughs] I hope I solved it.
Micah: With that text message, which I won’t read on the air. It’s not appropriate.
Eric: You’re both great. Thank you both.
[Andrew and Eric laugh]
Quizzitch
Andrew: Okay, it’s time for Quizzitch.
[Quizzitch music plays]
Eric: Last week’s question: Which real life wizard rock artist wrote a classic spurned love ballad titled “1991 Charlie Weasley”? The correct answer is the wizard rock band Tonks and the Aurors, a.k.a. Steph Anderson. And congrats to all who did know the answer to this. It is a very fantastic song, which includes the line, “For my birthday, you got me a dragon skull, and for our anniversary, you just forgot.”
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: Listen to it now; it’s on Spotify. “Charlie Weasley doesn’t really love me. He only loves his dragons.” “1991 Charlie Weasley.” Correct answers were submitted by Buff Daddy, Camille, Karen… Karen who wrote us our voicemail, actually. Hufflepuff MuggleCast fan from Germany, self-identified. Caddy Hermione, Magizoology 101, Forrest the 10-year-old, Ravenclaw from Nebraska, Norbort the dragon – oh, Bort – and Salty Slytherin. Congrats to everybody. Next week’s Quizzitch question: When McGonagall gives detentions to the trio and Neville in Book 1, she says she’s “never heard of such a thing before.” What is the thing to which she is referring? And submit your answer to us on the Quizzitch form, MuggleCast.com/Quizzitch, or go to MuggleCast.com and choose “Quizzitch” from the main nav bar.
Andrew: Sounds good. And make sure you’re following the show for free in your favorite podcast app, so you never miss an episode. And if you use Apple Podcasts or Spotify, please do leave us a review. We really appreciate those. Also, don’t forget to follow us on social media. We’re MuggleCast on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok. Thanks, everybody, for listening to this episode of MugCast. I’m Andrew.
Eric: Don’t you mean MugFest?
Andrew: MugFest, MugCast. Whatever you want to call it, we’re here for you.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Eric: I’m Eric.
Micah: I’m Micah.
Laura: And I’m Laura.
Andrew: Bye, everybody!
Laura: Bye, y’all.
Micah: Happy Halloween!
Andrew: Don’t forget to do ten reps with your Order of the Phoenix Illustrated Edition to improve the strength of your biceps.
[Eric and Laura laugh]
Eric: I really should do a workout video that’s just using that as weight. I’ll just go record that now.
Andrew: Stack them all on top of each other; just press from the center. That could be a good chest workout.
Eric: Oh, you’re so right.