Transcript #247

MuggleCast 247 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because 2011 officially marked the end of an era, this is MuggleCast Episode 247 for December 24th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast! It’s our final show of the year 2011 and we’re going to send it out with a bang. We have our annual MuggleCasties awards. Is this the fourth or fifth annual? I can’t seem to remember this.

Micah: I remember looking it up at the end of last show.

Andrew: And you forgot already?

Micah: Yeah.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I want to say this is the fourth annual.

Andrew: Yeah, I think that makes more sense.

Eric: This is the fourth. Sorry, you guys were cutting out there a little bit.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: But yeah, this is the fourth annual MuggleCast Year in Review.

Andrew: Cool, and with the MuggleCasties, and it’s always fun to get people’s feedback and then discuss the poll results as we’ve done over the past few years. I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Okay. And Micah, please, fill us in on the news. We’re at the end of the year here and Harry Potter is pretty much over, so…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: There hasn’t been much news.

Micah: So, let’s move on to the awards.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah. No, no, give us the news.


News: The Wizarding World of Harry Potter Orlando Expansion


Micah: Well, one of the hot topics over the last couple of shows has been the expansion of the Wizarding World in Orlando and there’s some more news that’s been coming out in the last couple of days, a little bit about Poseidon’s Fury, which is a ride at Universal Studios Islands of Adventure. It’s going to be closing, there’s supposedly a new roller coaster. Andrew, what’s going on down in Orlando?

Andrew: Well, there’s been a lot of rumors and we’ve talked about them before. Of course, Universal did confirm a few weeks ago that they are going to expand Orlando but they didn’t say exactly what they’re going to do. And we’ve talked about the Hogwarts Express train on the last episode and all that good stuff. The latest rumors are that – and these seem to be more than rumors. These seem to be from sources from a reputable theme park website. They said:

“Railroad engineers have been on property extensively designing a train track that would run backstage. You would be looking out of the train and seeing a video component as you went down the track. Whether that would be similar in technology to ‘King Kong’ at Universal Florida remains to be seen.”

And they say King Kong because that ride – it’s a 360 degree enclosure, and maybe not 360 exactly, but it’s like a – when you’re going through this ride, it’s all video screen surrounding you, so that’s what they could do with the Hogwarts Express. You go into this tunnel and you’re just surrounded by, say, the English countryside. So, that has a lot of potential, I think, to get to the new park.

Eric: Absolutely.

Andrew: There is a new roller coaster planned for the Jaws area and that’s what’s rumored to be taken over – the rumors say that Harry Potter will take over the Jaws area. Universal already announced that Jaws is closing, so now the big question is, “What are they going to put there?” and that’s what people think. And then finally, something that I’ve personally been saying for a while, Poseidon’s Fury has got to close!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And this latest report says that Poseidon’s Fury which is right next to the existing Wizarding World will indeed be closing down, which…

Micah: Now, just as a follow-up to the Jaws ride closing, there was a bit of news stating that Steven Spielberg owned that area of the park, so the chance of it becoming anything Potter related was not very good. Did you see that?

Andrew: Hmm. Yeah, I think I saw you guys post it on MuggleNet, right?

Eric: Yeah, there was another…

Andrew: So, I mean…

Eric: There was a conflicting report, too, which is that we also heard that when Steven Spielberg heard that there would be a Potter area in the park, I think he offered his area where Jaws was to them. So, it may be a case of them coming back in the next year and saying, “Oh, by the way, can we still have this? Can we – are you using this?” [laughs] that sort of thing.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: As far as King Kong goes, did I go on a different King Kong ride than…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …you guys did?

Andrew: Well, I think the one this is referring to is the one at King Kong 3D at Universal Hollywood and that’s like a train-track thing. I don’t know what the King Kong ride is at Orlando.

Before we move along with the news, we’d like to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many New York Times Bestsellers. For listeners of MuggleCast, Audible is offering a free audiobook so you can try out their amazing service. One audiobook to consider is Happy Accidents by Glee star Jane Lynch, part comic memoir and part inspirational narrative. This book is equally for the rabid Glee fan and for anyone who needs a new perspective on life, love, and success. So, why not get it for free and listen to it just like you do MuggleCast? To do so, or to grab any book of your choice, visit AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. We thank Audible for their support of the show.


News: Warner Bros. Studio Tour London May Ruin the Magic


Micah: Well, according to The Telegraph, they think that this upcoming Potter studio tour, which will be at Leavesden Studios opening in March 2012, could potentially ruin the magic…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …that the series has created for so many people around the world. What do you guys think of this?

Andrew: I thought…

Micah: Could be some truth to that.

Andrew: Yeah, I thought this was a well thought out article because when you think about it – you go to the theme park and it really is an immersive experience. It’s the music, it’s the people, the wizards and witches walking around the park, the Hogwarts Express is alive, and just everybody is really excited to be there. You can drink Butterbeer, you can be in Harry’s world, it’s very immersive. And then this studio tour, it’s cool. It’s so cool that these are the actual sets, but it’s like, is the lighting going to look like it did in the movies? Is there going to be music? Are people going to be dressed up in character? Is this going to feel – how is this going to feel compared to the theme park? And I don’t know if you’re going to get an immersive feel like you do at the theme park and I think that maybe somewhat of an issue. I mean, but again, it is cool that these are the actual sets.

Micah: Yeah, I agree. I think that people who have immersed themselves in the series over the last several years or ten years I think are really going to go with the intent to just enjoy and to see what the sets have to offer and walking through…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …the actual place where the movies have been filmed. I think maybe it could ruin it for some people. It just depends how you perceive the series and I guess if you’re younger maybe it can ruin it just a little bit. If you don’t have a full understanding of – but at the same time, I would think if you don’t have a full understanding, it would be cool to walk through a place like Dumbledore’s office or the Ministry of Magic or any of those other sets. But yeah, I agree with what you said. I think the article does make a compelling argument.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, I think ultimately two different people are going to go to the park versus the studio tour. I wanted to say it’s fortunate that the studio tour is in backwards – an hour outside of London that nobody will see it [laughs] or fewer people will go there to have the magic ruined for them than do attend the park on a yearly basis. But ultimately I think because of the studio tour and its nature is to show how they achieved the special effects – one of those areas is going to be the green screen booth where you can hop on a broom and obviously see how they do that. It’s in its nature to deconstruct the magic. So yeah, absolutely I think people will maybe walk away maybe regretting that they’ve seen it, do you think? Is that too intensive feeling to say if they’re coming away – oh, now that I know how they did that, it’s not magic, or what? I mean…

Andrew: Hmm.

Eric: …it’s still – because…

Andrew: Well, yeah. I mean, that’s the thing, too. I mean, you have this idea of how these things look after seeing them in the films so many times. I mean, for a lot of people that are going to be seeing these, they’re going to be walking on the sets having seen the films ten, twenty time a piece. So, you want to live up to their expectations and I think that’s a very tall order that may be kind of hard to fill. But again, it’s the fact that you’re on the actual studio lot where these films were shot. I mean, that’s hugely intensive.

Eric: Yeah, I…

Micah: I mean, even the mayor of London was there not too long ago.

Eric: Oh, our favorite…

Andrew: Right. Well, yeah, he did that…

Eric: Our favorite mayor of London. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, that’s another related news story, actually. They announced that Diagon Alley will be there and Gringotts, but I wonder which parts of Gringotts. Is it just the front?

Eric: Yeah, I wonder.

Andrew: Or what?

Eric: Probably…

Micah: Well, they say that the set will take center stage. Does that mean that it’s going to be sort of the focal point of the tour? Is it going to be the first place that you step into once you enter Leavesden Studios? I wonder how they’re going to sort of set this all up. Is it going to be telling a story in a way? Is it going to be following the series as we’ve seen in the films?

Eric: That’s a good question. I think if it tells any story, it will be the story of how so many people had to come together, the makeup room, the green screen room, the sets themselves. And I think the other thing that’s going to be rewarding – I mean, some people might actually come to the studio tour to see that, to see the Great Hall because it’s the real Great Hall, but also to then turn the corner and see that it’s – oh, it’s scaffolding, it’s not real stone. The detail on the foam or whatever it is that they use looks so real in the movies I think maybe that would be an interest point all and of itself, is that all these people forged a huge fakery, as it were. But it’s real – but it’s not, so…

Micah: Yeah, and just going back to the whole idea of ruining the magic, I think we bring this question up almost every time something else is announced or released, is what’s too much with respect to Potter? How far are you going to take it? We did it when the theme park was announced. Now you have the studio tour, the exhibition is touring out there, you have the expansion in Orlando, you have [laughs] the new park coming in Los Angeles. You’re going to say to yourself, when is enough enough? And it just doesn’t seem to matter to fans out there because Potter seems to have such a strong hold still with all their fan base.

Eric: I mean, I have a few interesting points to make about that, first is that the different things you can do for Potter are fortunately located at opposite ends of the globe geographically. So, with the exhibition…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …that’s been able to travel which is good, a couple of months here, a couple of months there, and finally it’s overseas, it’s no longer in North America. So, that’s good. And then obviously for the London people, there’s the studio tour and for Floridians in particular but also East Coasters and the entire Americans, there’s the park. So, fortunately – I mean, I don’t think anybody – well, less and less people are actually doing each and every one of these things that there is to do. Fortunately because it came to Chicago and because – I think Americans are more likely to have done everything so far up until this studio tour. It’s going to be really difficult to get over there and do that. So, I think it will be less of a situation where it’s like overkill to some people. And then in terms of how we view the studios, the other thing is that a lot of these are coming from different areas, so Leavesden obviously – or Warner Bros. – saw the potential to create this studio tour. But somebody completely different said we got to do this exhibit, somebody completely different said we have a theme park and there’s room for a Potter section of that. So, it’s not necessarily that there’s one person milking everything that came out of the series, and considering that Deathly Hallows doesn’t look like it’s going to get an Oscar anymore, which is my speculation, it’ll be good to see that there’s some way of showing the massive work that went into the series, because I don’t think the Academy is going to grant the producers and directors their wish of finally recognizing what a feat these films were. I think the studio tour is the only thing that’s going to do that in the end, which is sad but it’s what it is.


News: Daniel Radcliffe to Host SNL, Named Entertainment Weekly‘s Entertainer of the Year


Micah: All right. Well, switching gears here a little bit, it was announced earlier this week that Dan Radcliffe will be hosting Saturday Night Live, and…

Andrew: [in announcer voice] It’s Saturday Night Live!

Eric: [in announcer voice] Daniel Radcliffe!

Andrew: [in announcer voice] With a bunch of Harry Potter skits!

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: …it comes on the heels of him being named the Entertainer of the Year by Entertainment Weekly, and it seems as though it comes at the appropriate time, though. He’ll be heading off Broadway, right, in the next couple of weeks?

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: So…

Eric: He’ll be heading off Broadway.

Micah: …it makes sense.

Eric: Yeah, and then right…

Micah: Do Saturday Night Live before you leave.

Eric: I was going to say, because he’s still – the next month, he’s booked all throughout the UK – or actually, early in February is the world premiere of The Woman in Black, that film that he recorded prior to doing How to Succeed. So, he’s wrapped up sort of in the promotional circuit of that immediately afterwards. So, I’m glad they were able to find this time when he’s still in New York, because I’m sure right the day later, he could be on a plane.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s big. Yeah, it’s a nice surprise and he’ll do great. I was just surprised he’s doing it in mid-January, I kind of assumed he would want to go back to the UK right after he’s done with How to Succeed, take a little time off. But no, he’s sticking around, so good for him for keeping busy even after that run.

Micah: Has he ever…

Andrew: What else is going…

Micah: …hosted it before?

Andrew: No, never. No Harry Potter

Eric: No. He’s appeared…

Andrew: …actor has…

Eric: …on some sketch shows in Britain, and actually quite a few: Extras, and I think QI and a few of the other shows out there, but not Saturday Night Live. I’m super excited. I hope there aren’t that many Harry Potter skits, because he’s good for other things, too. So, who was it that was on and they did a Harry Potter skit? It wasn’t Emma, though. She didn’t – it was unrelated, right? Nobody else hosted Saturday Night Live. There have been a few Harry Potter skits on Saturday Night Live before, have there?

Micah: Oh, I’m sure over ten years…

Andrew: Yeah, there have.

Micah:[laughs] there probably have…

Andrew: Yeah, there’s been quite a – there’s been two or three that stand out…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …in my mind.

Eric: I’m trying to remember.

Micah: But the other thing that we mentioned there was that he was named Entertainer of the Year.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Any surprise?

Andrew: Well, I mean…

Eric: I was surprised just because they really accentuated his hard work on Broadway, because he – [laughs] to do 250 plus shows which he’s done of How to Succeed, the same show, the same music, the same – I couldn’t do it. I don’t think – many people couldn’t do it and he’s been wrapped up with that this entire year, all of 2011. So, when you think of an award like Entertainer of the Year, [laughs] there’s really nobody else you can go to, not to mention the fact that that one movie came out in the middle of the summer which was his final outing. So yeah, I don’t think there was any question.

Micah: Well, not only that, it was the highest grossing film of the year, it shattered records, it was the final film in the Potter series, so he was part of one of the highest grossing films of all time. So, you couple that with what you just said as well as – he probably worked on The Woman in Black at some point this year, right? Or…

Eric: It was filmed…

Micah: Was that all wrapped up…

Eric: Yeah. Well, it was filmed – I don’t know what – he launched the story contest which is what they ran from…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …mid-October and it runs to January. So, he was doing some of that, he’s appeared on YouTube with those videos promoting that, and that’s in addition to his daily [laughs] How to Succeed-ing, sometimes twice a day. So yeah, he’s been super busy. But they filmed that over the course of, I think it’s six weeks last year in October, November-ish.


News: Alan Rickman Voted ‘Sexiest Man on Broadway’


Micah: All right. Well, the last piece of news…

Andrew: So, what else is going on?

Micah: …that we have here…

Andrew: This is my personal favorite.

Micah: This your favorite? I knew you put this in here. [laughs] Broadway.com readers have voted that Alan Rickman is the Sexiest Man on Broadway.

Andrew: [laughs] I just think it’s funny.

Micah: Professor Snape.

Andrew: And I just wondered why didn’t – Daniel Radcliffe is also on Broadway right now, too, so I was just wondering why Daniel Radcliffe – he didn’t even make the top four.

Eric: Who were the…

Andrew: Alan Rickman had…

Eric: Who were the top four?

Andrew: Yeah, Alan Rickman had 27% of the vote. He beat Hugh Jackman…

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: …with 26% of the vote. And then Priscilla Queen of the Desert‘s Nick Adams had 24%, I don’t know who that is. So, there was 23% of the vote left over and I assume Dan had to be in there somewhere.

Eric: Was Alan Rickman reached for comment about this prestigious award?

Andrew: [laughs] I don’t think so. I think he probably just laughed it off.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: Yeah, he beat Hugh Jackman, that’s crazy.

Micah: All right, so we end the news in 2011 on a light note there.


Top Seven Moments of 2011


Andrew: So, there you go. So, that’s the year in news. But there’s still a lot to reflect on and that’s what we’re going to do in this episode. We’re going to reveal the results of the MuggleCasties, but first, we have the top seven moments of 2011 on a whole. Now, I guess we want to go from – I guess we don’t have to go in a particular order. These are just the top seven moments that stood out to us most. First of all, of course, the – well, we’ll start with B, guys – Deathly Hallows – Part 2 hitting theaters. It was the final film after ten years of Harry Potter movies, seven books being turned into eight films. We’ve talked about it to death, but it really was a momentous year for the Harry Potter fandom, maybe more so than the year Book 7 came out, 2007, because it’s just – this was the end of the big stuff. And to think back to 2007, I remember we were all like, “Where does the Harry Potter fandom go from here?” But I think some of the best years were truly after Book 7 came out.

Eric: It would be interesting to compare, as you just did, 2007 to 2011, because I was going to say that in one month, within the space of two weeks, we had Movie 5 and Book 7 come out. I don’t think it’s easy to top that kind of a thing. But when you look at it as being the final film, being slightly bigger than the fifth film, and the final book being matched up against Pottermore, which was a huge announcement that was kind of unexpected but it was leading up to the final movie coming out. They might tie, they might come close. They definitely come close together. This was a good year, I think, for Potter fans, especially because if anything there’s – not a silver lining but it promised that Potter was not over because there’s still kind of something to look forward to over the horizon which is good, which is just like in 2007 when we had two more – or three more movies to go.

Micah: Yeah, I agree. I think that what you just said, we had three movies to look forward to – well, at the time, we only knew that there were going to be two more, we didn’t know that the last one was going to be split. But I think that comparing them would be a little bit difficult because we were waiting for the end of the story really in 2007, to find out, “Was Snape good or evil? Does Harry live or die?” All these big questions that have been building up over ten or more years. So, now you finally get to 2011 and it’s the last movie. I think, though, with the last movie there comes a bit of a finality to it, in my opinion anyway, because now everything has been wrapped up. You’re not going to get any more books, you knew that in 2007, you’re not going to get any more movies, and so what’s next? And it seems like, to your point, Pottermore and the announcement of Pottermore came at the ideal time. I don’t think that that was a coincidence. And it’s continuously giving people something to look forward to down the road and sort of a lot of the other things that we’ve talked about already: expansion in Orlando, a new park in Los Angeles, the studio tour opening in 2012. There’s still a lot of things on the horizon. It’s not like the ship has sailed.

Andrew: And then off of that moment of 2011, and of course – Deathly Hallows – Part 2‘s shattering of the box office records. Opening night, it made $43.5 million. Opening day total was $92.1 million. Opening weekend was $169 million domestic, $483 million worldwide. It grossed in the end to $1.3 billion worldwide which made it the number three film of all time behind Titanic and Avatar. So, I mean, it was a huge success and rightly so. We kind of saw that coming, we knew that just like with the first film and everybody was really curious, everybody was also curious to see how the film would end. So, that’s why there were such strong box office numbers, and also a lot of hardcore fans who have been with the series over the years just wanting to see it multiple times.

Micah: Yeah, I think I saw it three times and you go back to Order of the Phoenix, how long did it take me…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …to see that movie in theaters?

Andrew: That was strange, yeah.

Micah: Yeah, I don’t know why that happened, but…

Andrew: Me neither.

Micah: Yeah, and the other piece I think that we didn’t mention was it became the highest grossing film franchise of all time, finally passing Star Wars and as we discussed on a previous episode, Star Wars didn’t just – wasn’t just released in the late 70’s, early 80’s. It was the prequels that eventually came out but it also had Episodes 4, 5, and 6 re-released in the late 90’s, so you’re talking about nine films, really, compared to Potter‘s eight. And I think it speaks a lot for the series as a whole. It’s going to be interesting because I think that as more and more of the James Bond movies continue to be released in the future, I think eventually it’s going to catch up to it, but Potter kind of stands alone by itself for right now.

Eric: Do we know where Bond is at? I mean, there were twenty two official films for the Bond series. Are they not anywhere near that currently? Or has nobody put that list together about how much those movies have grossed?

Micah: No, I think it is in existence somewhere. I know Potter passed it several years ago, I just remember a post being made – I think it was Andrew who made it. There was a split image of Dan Radcliffe on one side and then whoever was playing James Bond at the time on the other.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: And it had just [laughs] moved past James Bond, so there is a list out there somewhere but I think James Bond was kind of second behind…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah:Star Wars.

Andrew: The problem is, too – I mean, Daniel Craig is about to sign on for another five Bond films…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: …so it could surpass Potter again. That is the franchise that just…

Eric: Right.

Andrew: …never dies. Okay, so moving on, [laughs] let’s talk about Pottermore next.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So, that…

Micah: Oh boy.

Andrew: That’s, of course, a huge moment in the Harry Potter fandom because there was so much hype leading up to the release of Pottermore. They did do a good job of the hype and the mystery surrounding it. They had the various fan sites participating, and we learned each letter of Pottermore. It was kind of the classic clue hunting that you had to do back with J.K. Rowling’s original site, J.K. Rowling.com. And everybody knows how it went. It launched in Beta, it was kind of a mess, and now it’s still not open to the public. And what do you guys think overall about Pottermore, putting all the negativity aside? Let’s all say something good about Pottermore.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: What did it do for the fandom, right? It added a spark to the fandom, right?

Micah: It really did come at the right time, and as I said earlier, I don’t think it was by coincidence that it was announced right around the time that the last film was going to be released, because it gave people something to be interested in beyond Deathly Hallows – Part 2 and I think that if you go through the experience – I think there was a lot of excitement because Andrew, you just spoke about how you had to do the clue hunting even though it was hacked and…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …somebody got the name out there [laughs] relatively quickly. There was that excitement about something related to Potter that fans hadn’t experienced for a number of years. And you go on, you find out this name, and then you had to go through the whole process of becoming a Beta user. You had to make sure that you found the clue at the right time and you had people staying up to all weird hours of the morning all across the world and…

Andrew: Yeah, that wasn’t fun. [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, exactly. But I think it was fun in some way because there was an excitement about…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …what this was going to be, what was it going to provide fans who had not had anything really since Deathly Hallows was released in 2007. I guess you can include Beedle the Bard but I don’t really think that that book counts. So, it’s been four years since we’ve had anything and the experience overall I think we’ve talked about it enough, I’m not going to go into it. But as far as getting backstory, getting that information that everybody who’s been a fan of the series wants to know more about, I think that it does that and it’s going to be interesting to see in 2012 how much more new information J.K. Rowling releases…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …through Pottermore.

Eric: And I know a lot of people, too – as you said, they compared the experience of finding the clues for Pottermore to being like we’re back on her website during the heyday before all the books had come out. And what Pottermore did for me, I think for a lot of other people, was since it had been four years since we really had any direct content from J.K. Rowling, it really convinced me that she still cared, because to announce Pottermore, to go through – to start Pottermore, start this team of people to work on this several-year project, whether it’s five years, whether it lasts seven years, however long it is, to start something like this, and then to announce it, and to go through all the trouble of making it and doing it and providing this content. It just shows that she still cares about Potter and that is something – not necessarily that I questioned it, but because nothing, including her own Twitter, indicated that she still cared, it was very comforting to see that yes…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …J.K. Rowling still cares about Potter, she still wants to interact with its fans, and that was the biggest moment for me about the whole thing.

Andrew: Okay. Now moving on, the Wizarding World expansion announcement. That was something else that was a huge – the build-up, there was a lot of rumors leading up to it. Like we said earlier, there’s been a lot of rumors particularly over the past few months and they sort of picked up. And that’s going to be exciting because again, now the theme parks are a huge aspect of the Harry Potter fandom and it seems like they have really big plans for this expansion. They know that Harry Potter is a huge success now, so they can really – it seems like they’re going to basically double the size of the existing park and that’s just going to be wonderful. So…

Eric: Yeah, Harry Potter, HP, has proven to be bankable.

Andrew: Mhm.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Who knew?

Eric: Well, I think, too – do you think – I mean, it’s not just Harry Potter fans who are visiting the park which is the cool thing, is that other…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …people, non-fans are going in and getting kind of educated as to the little nuances of British culture. Or even if it’s not that British and it’s more magical, still, they’re getting an education [laughs] by going into the theme park which is really good.

Micah: They’re getting schooled.

Eric: They’re getting schooled, as you said.

Andrew: And on a related note, the – even more recent – well, actually they were announced at the same time, the new theme park in Hollywood!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Hogwarts is coming to Hollywood!

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: And again, it’s just great…

Micah: You can see it out your window, Andrew, as it gets built.

Eric: [imitating Andrew] Hollywood!

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Micah: You’re going to be able to…

Andrew: I felt like Oprah when I said that.

Micah: You could do like a time-lapse thing.

Andrew: [laughs] A time-lapse? Yeah. No, but again, it’s just going to be really great for the fans and having a West Coast location is going to introduce a ton of new people who otherwise would never get the opportunity to do this. I mean, there’s a ton of people living on the West Coast who would probably never think about going to the East Coast to a theme park because there are theme parks already here. So, that’s another – and it’s a good sign for the future of Harry Potter parks around the world as well. I know in The Wall Street Journal article that originally leaked this information, they said that if Hollywood was also a success, they were going to look into adding parks around the world. So…

Micah: That’s awesome.

Andrew: …good news. And let’s see, the studio tour. Now, [laughs] this is something we also talked about earlier, but again big announcement and it’s England’s finest Harry Potter attraction now.

Eric: Yeah, and it’s at the studio where Potter was recorded. Actors reported there daily to film these things. The other cool thing about it is that it’s opening in March of next year, it’s not four years away as is the Universal expansion. This is something we’re going to see a return on a lot sooner, and by “return”, I mean a return on our excitement for it because we can go there, tickets are already on sale or made available. And yeah, it’s going to be something really tremendous.

Micah: Yep. I mean, like you said, Andrew, [laughs] we touched on it a lot earlier talking about what the pluses and the minuses are, and whether or not it’s going to kill the magic…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …that a lot of people [laughs] have for the series but I think it’s going to be really cool and just listening to what a lot of the actors and even the producers have had to say about opening it up to the public – I mean, they seem really pumped and they really like the idea I think, especially Warwick Davis. He said he might even do tours there.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: In a joking way, I’m sure, but to think I guess as being an actor and actress to have the ability to go back to those sets pretty much anytime that you want.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: I’m sure that they don’t have to pay for admission there. [laughs] So, just to go and revisit that anytime that you want has got to be a pretty cool experience.

Andrew: That is cool, yeah, especially when you have grandkids. Dan Radcliffe can take his kids back and be like, “Look what I used to be a part of.”

Eric: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: And finally, Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration. This was in a way the first ever official Harry Potter conference, so to speak. I mean, it was a multiday event in Orlando around the release of Deathly Hallows – Part 2 on DVD, and it was also Warner Bros.’ way of kind of sending off the series once again. I feel like there’s been a lot of send-offs this year, but this felt like the most final of them all. Eric was there, of course. Eric, do you think they will do these in the future maybe? More Home Entertainment Celebrations or just more multiday park events?

Eric: I don’t know.

Andrew: Official ones?

Eric: That’s a good question. This seems pretty – it didn’t feel like the last one. It felt really well done, though. I think it was kind of a bigger send-off than I thought it would be, actually. They had several events planned, not just for the press, but also for the public in terms on Q&As. And there were over a hundred press outlets there which is just a huge number of people to kind of logistically make time for between all the celebrities and stuff. So, I don’t know if they’re going to do it again, but it would be a shame not to, because they seem to have a real mastery over the layout of the park and making sure that everything kind of went really, really smoothly. I’d feel really kind of hurt if I never made it to another official celebration again from Warner Bros. But at the same time…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …it was done really well, so I also kind of just would feel nostalgic for the first one. So yeah, it was a good celebration. Again, it was bigger than I thought it would be, but it had its purpose and it was a bit interesting to see – because of all the celebrities that were there, to see – to watch them reflect on being in the park which is nothing to do with the actual movies, but still to do with Harry Potter.

Micah: And this was the first real event, right, that was in the park since the opening took place?

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …in terms of real event and you bet. I mean, they built the stage that they had for the grand opening, they brought that back. They had special lighting, special signs that was like the Ministry of Magic wording that said, “Magic is happening behind this wall,” or something. It was crazy. It was really kind of fun how they transformed it to – they made it their own which is unique, I think, because you never think of the Harry Potter – I mean, who else would make the Harry Potter park their own but Warner Bros.? So, that was really cool.


2011 MuggleCasties: Biggest News Story


Andrew: And now we turn to the fourth annual MuggleCasties. This is – we have a variety of categories. We asked everybody to vote in the poll over a 48 hour-ish period. Very pleased to say that we got over 8,000 responses.

Eric: 8,000 responses. You guys are awesome.

Andrew: 8,000 people voting, yeah. So, that was a great response, so we have some very – I would say very fair results here after getting results from a good sample of Harry Potter fans. The first category is Biggest News Story, and we just ran through some of them but in the poll, we listed: Pottermore, all the theme park news, Deathly Hallows – Part 2 being released worldwide, and then the Potter films going into the Disney Vault. And for anybody who doesn’t remember that story, that’s Warner Bros.’ decision and actually just about a week to cease production of Harry Potter DVDs in the United States. And they will go back on sale in the future, but for now you have to hurry up and buy them or else – because they’re going into the Warner Bros. Vault forever. So anyway, the winner with 47% of the vote…

[Eric makes drum roll noise]

Andrew: …biggest news story is [pauses] Deathly Hallows – Part 2 released worldwide, with 47% of the votes. And Pottermore had 36%, theme park news had 10%, and the Disney Vault story had 6%. So, no surprise there. I mean, it’s the final film.

Micah: No. I mean, I don’t think there’s much to talk about here.


2011 MuggleCasties: Biggest Impact on the Harry Potter Fandom


Andrew: Yeah, that was kind of a throw-away one. We knew that was going to happen. [laughs] Next category is Biggest Impact on the Harry Potter Fandom. The nominees were: the Wizarding World expansion and the opening of the Wizarding World Hollywood, Deathly Hallows – Part 2 shattering box office records, and Pottermore Beta opening. So, these were sort of similar stories as the previous category. And the winner of this was with 49% of the vote, Deathly Hallows – Part 2 shattering box office records.

Eric: So, in terms of impact on the fandom, what impact did that news story have on the fandom? I guess it meant that…

Andrew: Well, I think it’s a good send off. It shows that Harry Potter – it made it through eight films very, very successfully. It didn’t drop off, you know what I mean? It wasn’t like the more films came out, the worse it did. It was great to the very end.

Eric: Okay, that’s a good way of seeing it. I understand.

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, I was surprised Pottermore did as well as it did in terms of having 29% of the vote.

Eric: Well, I mean, I think…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …it is a big deal for that reason. It may not have been fully realized yet this year, but it’s a promise for the future.

Micah: Or you could argue, though, that you’re surprised it didn’t do better, but maybe all the negativity surrounding the Beta launch caused it to…

Eric: Yeah…

Micah: …not do as well in the poll.

Eric: …I think that’s probably what happened, which is interesting. We have to stop bashing it, [laughs] give Pottermore a chance to come back and be the biggest story of 2012.


2011 MuggleCasties: Best Returning Actor, Deathly Hallows – Part 2


Andrew: Mhm. So, next category is Best Returning Actor for Deathly Hallows – Part 2.

Eric: These are the specific movie awards and going back to – yeah…

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: …just as a reminder, because the past few MuggleCasties, we were blessed every year with a new film to sort of talk about. In 2007, we had Movie 5. I guess maybe there was one year where we didn’t, but when there was a film that came out that year, we’ve done sort of specific Best Actor, Best Scene, that sort of thing, awards, and these are those for the final Harry Potter film.

Andrew: The nominees are: Dan Radcliffe, Michael Gambon, Alan Rickman, and Ralph Fiennes. The winner was [pauses] Broadway.com Sexiest Man Alive…

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: …Alan Rickman with 70% of the votes.

Eric: 70%

Micah: Wow, 70%

Andrew: That surprised me. Was that because he died?

Eric: Best Returning Actor. The way I view that category, too, is which actor – which of all the returning actors – which actor really stood out in this latest film. So yeah, I guess I’d say – especially with the scene where he’s cradling Lily, Alan Rickman deserves this award.

Micah: See, I actually – when I voted in this…

Eric: Me too, actually.

Micah: …I actually voted for Ralph Fiennes.

Andrew: Yeah, I think he had the most impressive growth. I did as well.

Eric: But how did he do? How many percentage?

Andrew: Oh, Ralph Fiennes got 5% of the vote, but not as bad as Michael Gambon who got 2% of the vote, and Dan Radcliffe got 23%. So, Rickman obviously had a clear lead there.

Eric: Yet again, Dan Radcliffe is in Alan Rickman’s shadow. We’re going to start something. [laughs] We’re totally going to start something here.


2011 MuggleCasties: Best Returning Actress, Deathly Hallows – Part 2


Andrew: Best Returning Actress for Deathly Hallows – Part 2. The nominees were: Emma Watson, Julie Walters, Maggie Smith, or Helena Bonham Carter. This was actually a tighter race, but the winner was Emma Watson with 50% of the vote exactly, followed by Maggie Smith with 24% and Helena Bonham Carter, very close behind with 22%. Only about a hundred vote difference between those two. And then Julie Walters, unfortunately she only had 4% of the vote, but I guess she wasn’t that big of a role, character, so…

Eric: Yeah, I guess not. I mean, she does have that famous scene, of course, but it just seems…

Andrew: But that’s interesting how Dan Radcliffe got 23% of the vote as Best Returning, but Emma Watson got 50% of the vote as Best Returning. You know what I mean?

Eric: I think – yeah, I think it’s a real mode of confidence on Emma – or rather satisfaction between the fans and what Emma did in the last film.

MuggleCast 247 Transcript (continued)


2011 MuggleCasties: Best New Character, Deathly Hallows – Part 2


Andrew: Next category is Best New Character from Deathly Hallows – Part 2. The nominees were: Griphook played by Warwick Davis, Aberforth Dumbledore played by Ciar·n Hinds, [laughs] the Gringotts dragon played by himself…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: …and the Hogwarts statues played by themselves. And again, very close this category was, and the winner was Aberforth Dumbledore played by Ciar·n Hinds with 33% of the vote. [laughs] The Hogwarts statues…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …came in second with 26% of the vote, Gringotts dragon came in third with 21% and Griphook, fourth with 20%. So…

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: …pretty close match there.

Eric: …that’s really not so bad.

Andrew: I think…

Eric: Well, we came up with those…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …poll options. [laughs] I just thought, wouldn’t it be weird if the statues beat out Ciar·n Hinds, you know? Because it’s the option where we have these CGI characters obviously not replacing an actor, but trumping them if they had gotten all the votes. But fortunately the fans all really liked Ciar·n Hinds’ performance, and so – it was kind of unfair for us to make them compete with the production crew which is a team of people, but they did so successfully.

Micah: What’s interesting, actually, in the LEGO Harry Potter game is once you’ve defeated all the levels, you can actually go back and roam around Hogwarts, and one of the things you can do is you can actually ride the Hogwarts statues and use them as if they are…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …actual characters.

Eric: Interesting. I haven’t made it that far yet in that game, but I’ll look forward to doing that.

Micah: That’s been my LEGO Harry Potter plug…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …for this episode. [laughs]


2011 MuggleCasties: Best Interviewee of the Year


Andrew: Next category is Best Interviewee of the Year and this is just the person who gave the best interviews throughout the year to anyone, not to a particular outlet. We do have a category for that for MuggleCast in a moment. Best Interviewee. The nominees were: Alan Rickman, Daniel Radcliffe, J.K. Rowling in the “A Conversation With…” on the DVD, the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD, and David Yates. And the winner by a long shot was J.K. Rowling with 65% of the votes. Next was Alan Rickman with 17%, Radcliffe with 16%, and poor David Yates with a measly 2%.

Eric: I’m interested…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …in the results. I’m a little surprised by these results, to be honest, because I think one of the – in the poll option, didn’t we say in “A Conversation With Daniel Radcliffe and J.K. Rowling” – that’s really her only interview that stands out. It’s possibly the only interview she really did this year, which shows that people like it. But when I think about Alan Rickman, the interviews he gave, there was that tell-all TV special – what outlet was that that interviewed him and they finally got him to completely open up? That was a very recent thing.

Andrew: Hmm. Yeah, I know what you’re talking about. I can’t remember the outlet, though.

Eric: Yeah, but I just – I heard everybody who saw that was like – they were crying afterwards. You come up with – and then of course there was the TIME magazine – wait, was it TIME – or not, it was Entertainment where they travelled the globe to meet all the…

Andrew: Oh, that was Empire Magazine. That was something in the UK.

Eric: But for that…

Andrew: Yeah, that was cool.

Eric: …Alan Rickman – and I consider that to be kind of an interview where he wrote that letter about – we have just wrapped or something, and I’m very emotional. So, I thought as a standout person to be forthcoming in interviews, Alan Rickman has the most improvement by far, I think, because he was keeping very silent about the whole thing while the films were in production and finally he just let it all out in a series of interviews this year. So, I did vote for him, but obviously many people just were so happy to see J.K. Rowling talking about Harry in that video.

Micah: And probably the person who was interviewed the most out of any of these was the one who got the fewest amount of votes.

Eric: Do you think? David Yates?

Andrew: Yeah, and I actually thought he would do better because when he does do interviews, they’re always pretty interesting because you get a lot of good behind-the-scenes info, given that he is the director. So, I think…

Micah: I just think any time you throw J.K. Rowling in a category…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, she’s pretty much going to win.

Eric: Well, I hope that’s true for the J.K. Rowling Award coming up. [laughs]


2011 MuggleCasties: Most Interesting Potter Star on Twitter


Andrew: Yeah. All right. Well, moving along, next category is Most Interesting Potter Star on Twitter. The nominees were: Warwick Davis, Jessie Cave, Evanna Lynch, Will Dunn, Tom Felton, and Emma Watson. Very – I’m impressed by the winner, actually, here. The winner was Evanna Lynch with 44%…

Eric: Nice.

Andrew: …of the vote. And rightly so. She’s a very honest, fun person on Twitter and I think people appreciate that. Tom Felton got 33% of the vote and he, too, is pretty honest but Evanna is just a little more fun and real. Emma Watson had 15%, but she’s usually just promoting stuff.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: She’s not really – she’s not saying what she’s up to or…

Eric: Andrew says she doesn’t use her Twitter…

Andrew: …that kind of thing.

Eric: …the way she should. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …I want her to be more open.

Eric: Me too, me too. And who else was – who was in fourth place?

Andrew: Fourth place – the rest all did very bad. Warwick Davis had 4%, Jessie Cave and Will Dunn had, like, 2%.

Eric: I like following Warwick a lot, but I think on the whole, Evanna – her tweets are the most memorable, I think, this year. I mean, when she got into Pottermore and was sorted into Gryffindor – I mean, I still remember those tweets. They were hilarious and I think even more recently, just a couple of weeks ago, she was in traffic on the LA freeway and tweeting about it, and it was just hilarious.


2011 MuggleCasties: Best MuggleCast Interviewee of the Year


Andrew: Yeah, stuff like that. Yeah, she’s actually tweeting about her life. That’s what’s cool about her, I think. Next category, Best MuggleCast Interviewee of the Year. Now, all these nominees we have had on the show. Thanks largely to Micah who did a good job organizing and conducting these interviews.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: So, I win the award?

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Yes, you win Best MuggleCast Interviewee Organizer of the Year, absolutely. No, but the Best MuggleCast Interviewee nominees are: David Yates, Oliver Phelps, Will Dunn/Arthur Bowen – they were in the epilogue, by the way – and Evanna Lynch. And the winner was with 43% of the votes, Evanna Lynch.

Eric: Hmm.

Andrew: And of course, that was our interview with her at LeakyCon. Again, a very fun interview.

Eric: Who’s the second place?

Andrew: 30%, second place, Oliver Phelps, third place was David Yates with 22%, Will Dunn/Arthur Bowen with 5%. So…

Eric: No kidding.

Andrew: …on the whole, good batch of interviews.

Micah: Yeah, considering that I conducted three of them and I was there for the fourth at LeakyCon, I don’t know, I disagree [laughs] with the…

Andrew: Really?

Micah: …outcome of it. Yeah.

Andrew: What would you say?

Micah: I would say the best overall interview was probably with Oliver Phelps.

Andrew: Yeah? Hmm. Why is that? Just information-wise?

Micah: Yeah – no, I thought it was just a good conversation. It was kind of a very relaxed talk and it felt as if it was just two people having a conversation with each other as opposed to – the David Yates one was a little bit more scripted. The Will Dunn/Arthur Bowen one was very good. But yeah, I don’t know, I kind of felt that that was the best one.

Eric: Yeah, and I mean, Evanna Lynch – we had her on the episode…

Micah: What do you think?

Eric: …as like a co-host. It was great having her, she came in about halfway through to the LeakyCon episode, and that was just amazing. It was less of an interview, though, but it was still good to have her on the show. Obviously, people must have really responded well to that episode to have voted in the way that they did, but I’m happy because it really was a big deal having her sit in with us and the fact that she had – she decided to wear her original MuggleCast shirt. It turns out that she had from years back – we offered her the LeakyCon shirt and she said – and we actually gave her one and then she said, well, actually, I’m going to wear my own and it was the original with the old iPod shadow ads. And she chose her own wardrobe for the live MuggleCast, but it was…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: So, what you’re saying, though, is she actually listened to the show…

Eric: Evidently.

Micah: …years ago, and was a big enough fan…

Eric: Yeah, that’s what I’m saying.

Micah: …to order a T-shirt.

Eric: So, we were really just flattered, really honored that she had decided to – and make effort to be on our show. We’d love to have her back, of course. But yeah, so she won this category. Great going.


2011 MuggleCasties: J.K. Rowling’s Best Moment of 2011


Andrew: Next category is J.K. Rowling’s Best Moment of 2011. The announcement of Pottermore, the interview with Dan Radcliffe on the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD, the heartfelt speech at the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 London premiere, and finally her two tweets…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: …this year on Twitter.

Micah: Which were the same, by the way.

Eric: Did she re-tweet herself? Is that possible? Could you do that? Yeah, they were the same.

Andrew: It may be possible. And the winner was with 59% of the votes, her heartfelt speech at the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 London premiere. It’s on YouTube, you could probably Google it if you want to watch it again, but it’s her just thanking the fans, naming the main seven: Radcliffe, Watson, Grint, Wright, Lynch, Lewis, Felton? I think that’s seven. So, it was a really heartfelt speech, and Radcliffe, Rupert – Dan, Rupert, and Emma were all behind her crying…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …and it was a pretty epic moment. I have to admit, it was very, very impressive. That’s when it hit me that things were over.

Eric: Awww.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Didn’t she have – what did she say at the very end that people latched on to? There was some quote that she gave, I can’t remember exactly what she said.

Eric: I thought…

Andrew: I’m not sure.

Eric: …it was just the seven or whatever it was that she had said about them, that she – oh, yeah.

Micah: Because she said something about Hogwarts always being…

Andrew: Home.

Micah: …their…

Andrew: Hogwarts will always be there – something like that.

[Eric laughs]


2011 MuggleCasties: Best Overall Franchise Performance by an Actor


Andrew: It was more touching than we’re making it. [laughs] Next category is Best Overall Franchise Performance by an Actor. The nominees were: Dan Radcliffe, Alan Rickman, Michael Gambon, Rupert Grint, or Ralph Fiennes. We also had an Other category but nobody…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …scored that well in there. Now, this is…

Micah: [laughs] Well, actually the Other category did better than somebody…

Eric: [laughs] Really?

Micah: …that was listed as one of the main five you just said.

Eric: So, who is it? Let’s figure this out.

Andrew: Really? I’m confused. Oh, yeah, yeah, okay. And by the way, this category is about overall performance out of all eight films, who did the best. And the winner with 49% of the vote was Alan Rickman. Dan Radcliffe had 29%, Grint had 13%, and Gambon and Fiennes had 2% and 5% respectively.

Micah: And Other had 3%…

Eric: Well…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …so Other…

Eric: …was Other the same…

Micah: …beat out Michael Gambon.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …Other, though? Or was it – yeah, I doubt it.

Andrew: No, I doubt it.

Eric: But still that’s…

Andrew: No, I think it was a variety – yeah.

Eric: Returning – again, Alan Rickman with the win. I don’t know that I agree with that. In terms of overall performance, I would have had to have handed it to Dan or somebody.

Andrew: Well, maybe just because of his character arc over all eight films.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Just him being so mysterious and then the question of, is he good or is he bad? And then in the final film, you learn why he is good and that he did love Lily. So…

Micah: Well, see, I would have – when I voted, I immediately eliminated Ralph Fiennes and Michael Gambon just because they weren’t in all the films.

Andrew: Hmm.

Micah: To me, to be a Best Overall Franchise Performance…

Eric: I don’t know…

Micah: …you have to be there the whole time.

Eric: …if you have a memorable enough…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …performance, memorable enough character…

Micah: Well, that’s like saying…

Eric: Well, you can’t…

Micah: …Dobby wins.

Eric: Dobby could win, right? I mean, I think, too – the other thing is that Voldemort…

Micah: Well, technically, if people voted.

Eric: …as a character doesn’t even have a body until he is portrayed by Ralph Fiennes. So, there is that thing to consider which is that technically, Ralph Fiennes’ character was in all eight films, even if he wasn’t portraying it. Same with Michael Gambon, but that’s okay. I’m not going to fight the issue.


2011 MuggleCasties: Best Overall Franchise Performance by an Actress


Andrew: Next category, similar category, Best Overall Franchise Performance by an Actress. And the nominees were: Emma Watson, Maggie Smith, Julie Walters, and Helena Bonham Carter. Again, interesting. This is in line with an earlier poll. The winner was Emma Watson with 57% of the votes, and Helena Bonham Carter came in with 21%, Maggie Smith came in third place with 17%, Julie Walters with 3%, and then Other, 2%. Emma Watson, everybody just really liked Emma throughout all the films. She won the category earlier about Best Performance by an Actress in Part 2 and now this, Overall Performance, as well. So, I guess she really is…

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: …the female star of all the films.

Eric: …it’s official, now that you heard it on MuggleCast. But I think – our listeners have voted.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: The interesting thing is that I still hear a lot of negative things about Emma in the films and I wouldn’t bring this up unless it were to say – call the action. Everybody who voted positively in Emma Watson’s favor just go spread the love. Tell people that she’s so awesome because she is. But also because she’s won this poll, let her know. Tweet at her and let her know, and maybe she’ll come on the show and thank you all herself.


2011 MuggleCasties: Most Anticipated Potter Event of 2012


Andrew: We’re nearing the end now of the 2011 MuggleCasties. The next category is Most Anticipated Potter Event of 2012. The nominees are: more information about the Wizarding World Orlando/Hollywood, Pottermore’s official launch, the opening of the Warner Bros. Studio Tour London – The Making of Harry Potter, and Deathly Hallows – Part 3: Voldemort’s Revenge

Eric: [laughs] Oh no!

Andrew: …which I did not know about until I read this poll, so that’s interesting. But the winner was Pottermore’s official launch with 39% of the vote, [laughs] 27% of the vote unfortunately was thrown away…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …with the Deathly Hallows – Part 3: Voldemort’s Revenge, [laughs] and in third place with 20% – or realistically, it was actually 20% – or it was actually second place – opening of Warner Bros. Studio Tour London. And then fourth place was, of course, more information about the Wizarding World parks.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: So, that’s good. I mean, I guess there’s quite a few people who still really want to see – who still aren’t inside Pottermore.

Eric: Yeah, definitely.


2011 MuggleCasties: The J.K. Rowling Award


*54.40

Andrew: I do see e-mails about that every once in a while. And then finally, the J.K. Rowling Award. Now, each year we bestowal this award on the person who has – who exemplifies J.K. Rowling-like qualities: great writing, beauty, passion, cleverness…

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: All things you would say about Ben Schoen.

Andrew: [laughs] Yes. And the nominees were: J.K. Rowling, Lady Gaga, Stephanie Meyer, Kim Kardashian, and Ben Schoen, our own Ben Schoen. [laughs] And the winner of the J.K. Rowling Award for the fourth year in a row is [pauses] J.K. Rowling with an amazing 85% of the vote.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Second place, very surprisingly…

[Micah laughs]

Eric: No kidding!

Andrew: …Ben Schoen with 8%, so…

Eric: He came very close.

Andrew: …he actually did quite well. To think…

Micah: I’m glad I had you…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …put him in there.

Andrew: To think he did better than Gaga, Stephanie Meyer, and Kim Kardashian…

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: …is quite amazing.

Eric: Wow. But I am glad – yeah, fourth year…

Andrew: So congratulations, Jo.

Eric: …in a row, the J.K. Rowling Award goes to J.K. Rowling. I was worried this year because we totally left it up to people, didn’t we? I mean, if everybody wanted to spite us, we really would have given that award…

Andrew: We did.

Eric: …to someone else. But I think it’s true.

Micah: Well, I’m happy that…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: I’m going to start a campaign for Ben, I think, [laughs] so next year he can take it. He had more of a vote than the other three combined if you look at it.

Eric: I have to plug my own YouTube channel. There’s a video on there – when we were waiting for J.K. Rowling to come out of – not Carnegie Hall, it was the year before, for “Harry, Carrie, and Garp” at Rockefeller…

Andrew: Radio City.

Eric: Radio City, yeah. We were waiting for the door to open because it was rumored that she would be coming out of the side door, they had done some kind of tech rehearsal earlier in the day. So, all of us were out there, it was a blistering hot summer day, and eventually we just got so tired of waiting – she never ended up leaving the building or coming out that door, but instead Ben went up there sort of in between the two crowds and we filmed him – or actually, I filmed him coming out, pretending like he had just closed the door and was coming out…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …and then all of us screaming at him, “Ms. Rowling! J.K. Rowling! J.K. Rowling!”

Andrew: Oh, that’s funny.

Eric: So…

Andrew: I haven’t seen that.

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: What’s the title of it?

Eric: It’s “Jo Goes, Schoen Shows: Benjamina Rowling.”

Andrew: Oh, I see it.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I see it, yeah, on the YouTube channel…

Micah: [laughs] Benjamina Rowling?

Andrew: …EricJScull.

Eric: [laughs] Benjamina Rowling.

Andrew: His YouTube channel.

Eric: But yeah, so that was like a precursor to his – it’s not the first time he’s nearly upset JKR [laughs] with his portrayal, or his defining of JKR-like qualities. Super fun.


Listener Tweets: Looking Forward to 2012


Andrew: It’s actually a really funny video, yeah. Yeah, that’s classic. [laughs] Well, for those who follow us on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast, we asked people, “What are you most looking forward to in 2012?” We had the poll but we wanted to get Twitter responses as well. TheLadyLysy said:

“Leaky in Chicago! So psyched!”

So, that’s LeakyCon she’s referring to, and that’s in August. iBhangu wrote:

“WB Studio Tour London will be the highlight from ‘Potter’ Perspective for 2012.”

hugs2015 wrote:

“I’m really looking forward to actually getting into Pottermore because I was out of town for the Beta.”

OllieGasparich said:

“I’m looking forward to ‘LEGO HP’ coming out for iOS!”

It’s kind of an obscure…

Eric: Oh, interesting. Okay, yeah.

Andrew: Which is the iPhone operating system. Braysmores writes:

“I’m looking forward to see how the fandoms keep going strong with updates and news about Pottermore and theme parks.”

TiffyMarie123 wrote:

“Hearing about plans for the theme park expansion and building. Also, photos from the studio tour.”

Kyra RenÈ said:

“I’m looking forward to the studio tour, more specifically, the Great Hall. *starts wishing for money so I could actually go*”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Quite a few other selections here. sweetmilano90 said:

“More books being released on Pottermore!”

Yeah, hopefully we’ll get Chamber of Secrets in 2012. So, there you go. Lots of things to look forward to in the next year and really beyond with all this theme park stuff, too. I mean, what are you guys most looking forward to in 2012?

Eric: Yeah, I don’t know.

Andrew: For me, it’s the theme park news.

Eric: The theme park? Oh, to find out more about it?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Well, yeah. I mean, I think it’ll be great to learn more about what is going to be made in each of those parks, but in terms of actually having something for next year, I think Pottermore and what we’re going to have access to. Is it just going to be Sorcerer’s Stone, which all the Beta users have already had access to? Is it going to be Chamber of Secrets? How are all that going to play itself out? Because that’s actually something that we can look forward to in 2012, whereas news is just like, well, it’s great but you’re still not going to get to experience it next year. If they say we’re going to build a Gringotts ride, that’s fine, but you’re still not going to get to experience it until several years down the road. I’m looking for something that’s actually going to happen.

Eric: Which will be Pottermore.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, I’m interested in finding out…

Micah: Hopefully. I mean…

Eric: Yeah. I mean, like you said, is it going to be – will it be – will we get Chamber of Secrets? Will it just be Sorcerer’s Stone? Will it be the same Sorcerer’s Stone that Beta users saw, or will it be improved and with more content? That’s what I want to know. I would even venture a guess and say that 2012 is going to be the year of Pottermore.

Andrew: Hmm.

Eric: They’re going to finally…

Andrew: Yeah, I think…

Eric: I’m going to hope…

Andrew: …that’s a fair assessment.

Eric: I’m hoping because – and I would hate to be proven wrong, but I hope that they can at some point in 2012 get their act completely together, officially launch the site, because it’s been rather delayed these past few months, and to actually just really launch it, have a really strong response, renew sort of the fans’ faith who have been turned away or anything, I have complete confidence that they can totally impress us. So, I’m looking for 2012 – to answer your question, I’m looking forward to Pottermore and I hope that it’s the year of Pottermore, next year.

Micah: Yeah, I’m interested also to see how people respond to the studio tour opening, what their experience is like walking through the sets. I’m sure we’re going to…

Eric: If it kills the magic? [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, exactly. Is it going to kill the magic? Are people going to walk away with something that they have been looking forward to doing for ten years since the movies first were released, to have that ability to walk through the sets. And somebody put J.K. Rowling’s next project on here. I think – unless you’re not counting Pottermore as her next project. I mean, what else could she possibly be working on? It seems like we have this question every freakin’ year.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Well, it’s because…

Micah: “What’s next for her?”

Andrew: Well, maybe this will be the year.

Eric: Three years ago when she started her Twitter, all she said was I’m working on stuff and then we still haven’t…

Micah: Right.

Eric: …heard what that is. So…

Micah: But I think it’s possible certainly that we can learn about what her next project is in terms of actually writing. This is most likely stuff that’s on Pottermore that’s been stuffed away in a box in a room in her house somewhere that has already been written. We’re talking about an actual book being released possibly by her or something else that she’s been working on. So, I think it’s about time. It’ll be, what, five years fully since Deathly Hallows was released?

Andrew: Yeah. Well, we say that every year.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “It’s about time. It should happen this year.”

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Well, we will truly say…

Micah: Anything else?

Andrew: No, I think that’s…

Micah: Anything else? I mean, you know the eight film super collection is…

Andrew: Yeah…

Micah: …going to be released.

Andrew: …but that’s all small stuff. I mean, that is something…

Micah: And have they done Ultimate Editions yet…

Andrew: No, no.

Micah: …for the last two films?

Andrew: Yeah…

Micah: So, those are…

Andrew: …so that’s something else…

Micah: To look forward to.


Show Close


Andrew: Also, to look forward to is the MuggleCast website, MuggleCast.com. It has everything you need. We recently updated the transcripts. They are all pretty much up to date. Well, we’re close. We have 243, 244, 245.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Quite a few in there, and everybody…

Micah: Yeah, I do have 246, I just haven’t posted it yet.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Micah: I want to give people time to listen to the episode…

Andrew: Cool.

Micah: …before posting the transcript.

Eric: Create…

Micah: But…

Eric: Amping up some demand there, Micah.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Yeah, we’re slowly filling out the database there. All of them are listed, not all of them are linked to yet, but they’re doing a great job lead by Tracey…

Andrew: Cool.

Micah: …who’s sort of taken the reins and done a great job in terms of getting us caught back up, and hopefully within the next few weeks, we’ll be caught up and every show you could possibly want to listen to in written form. So, I guess any show you want to read instead of listen to us talk, you’ll have the ability to do that. So, they do a great job and we can’t thank them enough for it.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Yeah. It’s the ability of it all.

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: I can Google…

Andrew: Yeah, thank you.

Eric: …everything.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. Thank you to the transcript team. Also there, you can click on “Contact” to send in some feedback about this show or any episode that you hear, and we may just read it on the next show. Also, you can find links to our iTunes page where you can subscribe and review us via iTunes. You’ll also find our Twitter which is Twitter.com/MuggleCast, and our Facebook which is Facebook.com/MuggleCast. And finally the fan Tumblr, MuggleCast.Tumblr.com, filled with lots of pictures, new and old, from over the years. [laughs] There’s a lot of obscure stuff.

Eric: Yeah, we’ll have more holiday – I have some holiday photos…

Andrew: [laughs] I love it.

Eric: …I stumbled up on of us at different – of like a Christmas party. I’ll probably submit to there. Really cool.

Andrew: Cool. It’s all fantastic.

Eric: But wow.

Andrew: Thanks – yeah, another year of MuggleCasting. Good job, boys.

Micah: So, we will officially at some point next year be that lucky number seven years old.

Eric: Oh wow, that’s something to look forward to. Seven years.

Micah: It’s scary.

Andrew: It is.

Micah: Actually. [laughs]

Andrew: It’s very scary. Thanks everyone for sticking with us for another year of MuggleCast. We’ll be back next year with more episodes and more fun, more Harry Potter, and more…

Andrew and

Eric:

Magic.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And from MuggleNet.com, I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: We’ll see you in the new year for Episode 248! Feliz Navidad!

Eric: [laughs] Happy Holidays, everybody. And Happy 2011!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #246

MuggleCast 246 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because we answer the question, “What’s bigger news, a theme park in L.A. or expansion in Orlando?” this is MuggleCast Episode 246 for December 9th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 246! This is a very special episode recorded late at night in December, a cold winter’s night. We’re here to discuss the big Wizarding World news that was made earlier this week. Eric, Micah, and I are here. Hello, excited gentlemen.

Eric: Yes. Hello.

Micah: I thought you were going to cue that song by the Counting Crows when you…

Andrew: What’s that song?

Micah: “A Long December.”

Eric: Oh.

Micah: When you were making that comment earlier.

[Eric makes music sounds]

Andrew: Hmm.

Eric: Yeah, got it.

Andrew: I don’t follow the…

Micah: I don’t know what Eric is doing, but that sounds…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …nothing like the song. [laughs]

Eric: I think that was – you know what?

Andrew: That’s the song in his mind.

Eric: I confused Counting Crows and Collective Soul. That’s my bad. That’s my flaw…

Andrew: It’s okay.

Eric: …for the world to see.

Andrew: Well, we are going to talk about the Wizarding World, there’s a lot to talk about, of course, L.A. and also Orlando. It’s a transition time for the Wizarding World Orlando and a creation time for Wizarding World L.A.

Micah: I think we’re going to have some interesting discussion about this because I think the big question is going to be, is it bigger news that the one in Orlando is expanding or that there’s one coming to Los Angeles?

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Ooh.

Eric: Which is hotter news…

Andrew: That’s a hard question.

Eric: …on this cold winter’s night?

Andrew: Let’s… [laughs]

Micah: Not where…

Andrew: Let’s all ponder that.

Micah: …Andrew is.

Andrew: Well, yeah, it is kind of chilly here. We’ll ponder that while we get through some other news first. Micah, tell us what else has been going on that’s worth discussing.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: There’s been a lot of stuff, but it’s a lot of crap.


News: Pottermore Site Updates


Micah: Well, let’s start with Pottermore and…

Andrew: Ooh.

Micah: …I’m going to try – because it is late at night and I’m not as hyped up…

Andrew: You’re mellowed out.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Yeah, a little bit mellow here. They put out a release earlier in the week, a blog post – actually, I think it might have been even over the weekend – about the fact that they are going to be down for a period of time, And this is got to be somewhat disconcerting news to people who are still new to the site, maybe they’re just getting acquainted with it, more so to the people who are not Beta testers. I’ve seen a couple of e-mails where people say, I was away over the summer, I came back hoping that in October I was going to be able to access Pottermore as a new user because I didn’t get a chance to get in during the Beta period, and now I’m going to the site, and it’s down and I can’t even register, and I can’t even get access probably until sometime next year. I just want to know what is going on with the site. What changes are they possibly making to it? And why hasn’t it come online fully yet? It’s very frustrating for a lot of people out there.

Andrew: Mhm. Well, it seems like there are just server problems. I mean, that seems to be the clearest issue and we know when it launched, it was down frequently, we were getting that purple message of death, so to speak, “Pottermore is unavailable. Please try again later.”

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And I think that’s what they’re fixing.

Eric: Yeah, and according…

Andrew: It’s not – they’re not adding features.

Eric: No. Yeah, according to the release, it says, “The work we’re carrying out is technical, so there won’t be many obvious differences to the site but to help us test our work, we’d really like you to log in and explore the site once it’s back online.” So, I think it’s clear that they are actually – they are testing – they are improving the capacity of the site, maybe it’s load time, maybe it’s how many people can be on at once because – and about people being disappointed that it’s not up yet, I stated before, okay, take it down as long as you need to, but once you launch it, don’t fail again. Once you launch it – make sure it’s strong before you launch it and then there won’t be any of these problems that we keep seeing or purple screens or any more of this downtime that’s jarring and disappointing.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: And here’s the thing, though, it is going to be down for a week and it first went down as scheduled on December 3rd, and so probably until at least the 10th, if not to the beginning of next week. But with all of the work that’s been going on on the site and the fact that it’s not going to officially open until some time in 2012, when they open, are they just going to open with Sorcerer’s Stone or are they going to include Chamber of Secrets? How are they going to work this out? Because you have a lot of people now who have been in the Beta period for several months who are going to be eager to get a new book when the site officially opens and not go through the whole experience all over again with Sorcerer’s Stone.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, they have to have a big relaunch. I think their safest bet may be to just throw some extra material from J.K. Rowling in there from Sorcerer’s Stone

Eric: I agree, yeah.

Andrew: …because Chamber of Secrets will take too long to develop. I mean, there’s artwork, there’s all that content, the code has to be written, that’s a huge amount of stuff. So, at least if they added J.K. Rowling’s stuff, maybe that could be a little easier.

Eric: So, like…

Andrew: I don’t know if it is, but it seems like it.

Eric: …keep the same moments, obviously, but yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Or just add stuff, yeah.

Andrew: Add stuff to the moments, yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I haven’t – really, honestly, I haven’t completed Pottermore yet, so – for Sorcerer’s Stone from the Beta testing.

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t know if I have either.

Eric: So, I’m excited. I mean, I’m still kind of excited to get to the later chapters.

Micah: And one final thing I just wanted to add about this because I know we do get a lot of e-mails, we’re not trying to bash Pottermore. There are a lot of good things about it, but I just think the way that it’s come across so far has been less than enjoyable for a lot of people.

Eric: Great things about Pottermore, I’ll list them: number one, it makes a good paperweight, number two…

[Micah laughs]

Eric: …if you’re [laughs] really, really bored to tears…

Andrew: No, no.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Be fair. I think a real list would be the new content is great, it’s nice to see this very in-depth website from J.K. Rowling. And actually, my list doesn’t go very far.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: But look…

Andrew: It’s nice to be Sorted…

Eric: Yeah, I think we’re all…

Andrew: Go ahead.

Eric: …genuinely – as fans of the Harry Potter series, we are genuinely excited to see this in a position where it succeeds.

Andrew: Yeah, sure.

Eric: So, we’re all excited to see this team who continues to bring them down. It’s actually a good thing because it shows that they’re still working on perfecting it and…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …it’s comforting knowing there’s a team behind this that are caring about the site, continuing and…

Andrew: Right. Every day.

Eric: …doing – they just want to make it do what they said it was going to do, and…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …that’s very good on them.

Andrew: All right, what else is going on in the news?


News: Sotheby’s to Auction Multiple Rare Harry Potter Books


Micah: Well, a little bit of auction news if people are interested in bidding this holiday season for some interesting Harry Potter gifts.

Eric: 500,000 pounds.

Micah: Sotheby’s…

Eric: 500,000. Do I have 500,000 pounds?

Micah: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: Do I have 500,000? Do I hear 10,000? 10,000?

Micah: I don’t have 500,000, so I would not be able to purchase. But it initially started off, the report, that Sotheby’s was going to be auctioning off a very rare deluxe first edition of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone and now that whole auction platform has expanded to include more than just that book, so there’s multiple books that are available, including a complete set of deluxe Harry Potter volumes, the first four, so I guess Sorcerer’s Stone through Goblet of Fire, signed by J.K. Rowling. And I’m assuming that the proceeds are going to charity, but I’m not seeing that anywhere in the post that I’m reading right now.

Eric: This deluxe edition – I’ve never really – I don’t think I’ve ever seen this art before anywhere.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, the cool thing about it is that it’s the first edition, too. It’s a first deluxe edition.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: And all this artwork is from the original illustrator and it’s pretty beautiful. It’s great, it’s really great. And the artwork is just fun to look at because it is really the first interpretation of Harry Potter, of Jo’s story, way before the movies came along, as were several of the U.S. and U.K. books but this is just a really special set.

Eric: So, currently it’s going for – oh, 30 to 50,000 pounds.

Andrew: That’s the estimate, right?

Eric: The estimate…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …for the deluxe edition of Philosopher’s Stone.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Wow.


News: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Included in Top 10 Films of 2011


Micah: Okay. Well, the final bit of news, there was a recent article that Deathly Hallows – Part 2 may have taken one step closer to being nominated for Best Picture because the National Board of Review named the final installment in the Potter film series one of the top ten films of 2011. Now, the National Board of Review is often looked at as a prelude to the Oscars. So, this whole Oscar push is starting to gain a little bit of steam for Deathly Hallows – Part 2 and I’m sure it’s not going to stop. It’s just going to keep on going all the way until – when are the awards? February? March?

Eric: Are they February? Andrew, do you know? Oscars.

Andrew: Yeah, I think so. Yeah.

Eric: I thought they were, too.

Micah: Did I make that up?

Andrew: Or February, January. Something like that. But yeah, it’s soon, and David Yates, David Heyman, David Barron, and Helena Bonham Carter were actually in L.A. for a couple of things. They were here for a BAFTA ceremony which I attended, but also something that I attended was a Deathly Hallows – Part 2 screening held by Variety, which is a big trade publication in Hollywood. And it was the screening of the film, of course, and then a Q&A afterwards, and the three Davids plus Helena spoke, answered questions from the audience, and it was really a nice time and Helena is just so funny.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: She is just on fire.

Eric: What did she look like? I mean, this time because…

Andrew: Oh, she looked like her…

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: …normal self. I mean, she wasn’t dressed as Bellatrix.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: But that was just another example of a way that they’re being very – it’s kind of another little Oscar push.

Eric: Yeah, because they have this presence in L.A. now, that they’re building.

Andrew: Yeah, right. And the billboards everywhere and…

Eric: This is a good transition into our top news story.

Micah: Well, just to make note there that the Oscars are Sunday, February 26th. I looked it up.

Eric: The end of February.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Eric: And they’ve changed hosts a couple of times. Who’s hosting now? Does it say?

Andrew: Billy Crystal, right?

Eric: I thought it was but then I heard that somebody else…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …was doing it instead.

Andrew: No, no, no, it was first Eddie Murphy.

Eric: Yes, that’s what I heard.

Andrew: And then Billy Crystal took over because Eddie Murphy bailed out because of drama with the producer…

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: …and all this.

Eric: Yeah. I have that Rolling Stone magazine with Eddie Murphy on the front and I read the whole…

Micah: Billy Crystal is the man.

Eric: Billy Crystal is the – well, he’s tried to test it, too.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s done Oscars…

Micah: He went to my high school.

Andrew: Nice.

Micah: Yes.

Andrew: Okay. So…

Micah: That’s a little MuggleCast nugget for you.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, well…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: …hopefully he’ll give you a shout-out at the Oscars.

Micah: I doubt it.

Andrew: All right. Before we continue with today’s news, we’d like to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than, get this, 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many New York Times bestsellers. For listeners of this podcast, Audible is offering a free audiobook to give you a chance to try out their great service. One audiobook to consider is Inheritance, Book 4 in the Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini. It was just released and those of you who are big Eragon fans will not want to miss the fourth and final book in the series. It’s the much-anticipated, astonishing conclusion to the worldwide best-selling Inheritance Cycle. So, to get Inheritance or any other book of your choice, visit AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast, and we thank Audible for supporting the show.


Main Discussion: The Wizarding World of Harry Potter to Open at Universal Studios Hollywood


Andrew: Now it’s time to talk about, of course, the big story: Wizarding World of Harry Potter coming to Los Angeles. Now, does anybody remember when these rumors started? I’m not talking about a couple of weeks ago. I mean, there was never really any concrete info about the Wizarding World possibly coming to Los Angeles…

Eric: No, it was definitely out of the blue.

Andrew: …from what I remember.

Eric: I remember – I mean…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …there were plenty of talks about it being overseas, the mayor of London a couple of years back said it should, then there was – the rights to have a ride were being considered in India or somewhere to have a single Harry Potter attraction there. But I mean, I think from the outset – we always talked about it on MuggleCast but as I recall – I mean, one of your concerns, Andrew, living in L.A. was the size of the park, that it might not be feasible to really do one because I believe you had mentioned that Universal Studios Hollywood is quite cramped.

Andrew: Yeah, and it’s kind of in a hilly area, so that kind of hinders the amount of space they can work with, too. But last week, The Wall Street Journal broke the news that a Wizarding World park was going to be announced by Universal and Warner Bros., they were closing in on a deal. Interestingly, Disneyland was also in talks to be getting the park, which just…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …blew my mind because I couldn’t believe that Disney would, a) make the same mistake twice by not…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …winning [laughs] over Universal, but then also just that Warner would step away from Universal and say, “Hey Disney, it’s time for you to have a go at this.”

Eric: Right.

Andrew: But I think it was ultimately for the best. I imagine they would have had to make some big changes if it were to be in Disney because Disney would have wanted creative control.

Eric: Yeah, they would have had to have…

Andrew: I would have to think Universal owns rights to a lot of this stuff.

Eric: You’re right, they would have had to have all different merchandise.

Andrew: Yeah, so it just wouldn’t have worked.

Micah: Mickey already has a wizard costume, though, doesn’t he?

Andrew: Right. Yeah, he could have been…

Eric: Awww, The Sorcerer’s Apprentice.

Andrew: They don’t need Dan Radcliffe.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: They could just use – so that didn’t work out, but that’s fine. I think Universal doing the second park had to be done. Let’s see, and then so – I guess we’ll run through the details first.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: What we know so far.

Micah: Which is…

Andrew: We don’t know much.

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, very minimal, I was going to say.

Eric: What happened today? Because you were at the park this morning, right?

Andrew: Yes, I was at the park, which I was thrilled to be able to go to because it’s literally twenty minutes from my apartment, so it’s, like, oh wow, a few years I’ll be able to…

Eric: Get a Butterbeer.

Andrew: …bounce over there whenever I want.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Micah: Who knew Hogwarts was right down the road…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …from you all this time, Andrew.

Andrew: I know, all this time. I used to be excited about the Hollywood sign, and now…

Micah: Those people who did Finding Hogwarts, [laughs] all they had to do was…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …come and visit you!

Andrew: They didn’t have to travel abroad, yeah. So, what we do know – we know a little, but we actually know a lot because the park is supposed to be very similar to what’s in Orlando right now, so that tells us a lot. There’s going to be the Hogwarts Castle, there’s going to be Forbidden Journey, there’s going to be rides and shops, there’s going to be cramped entry ways and exit ways, and [laughs] people are going to get in the way.

Eric: That’s the thing, and I don’t want to cut you off here, but I mean, remember in Florida there were four-hour lines to get into the park and those lines were the length of the park. So, if Universal Studios…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …Hollywood is smaller than Islands of Adventure in Florida, we’re going to have some serious trouble, not to mention there’s more people…

Micah: Now…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …in L.A. than there are in…

Andrew: Well…

Micah: Can I ask a somewhat stupid question?

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: Does Universal Studios Hollywood have an Islands of Adventure section, or is that exclusive to Orlando?

Andrew: That’s exclusive, yeah. So, let’s talk about where they’re going to build it. This info actually did come out today, not from Universal during their event, but when the Washington Post was talking to a couple of Universal people afterwards, Universal President – I don’t have his first name – Meyer said, “We’re not landlocked,” in response to, “Oh, do you have room to build this?” He said, “We’re on 400 acres on this lot and 200 of them are still not developed.” So, that’s pretty big and I mean, if you look at it on Google Earth, you will be hard-pressed to find 200 acres of land or half of a park…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: …available. So, I don’t know totally what he’s talking about, but…

Eric: I think he means they’re going to have people commuting. [laughs]

Andrew: But – yeah, I guess. I don’t know. But anyway, he goes – the L.A. County Supervisor chimed in as well. He said they’re going to be knocking out the Gibson Amphitheater, and the Gibson Amphitheater is right next to Universal. It’s kind of attached to it actually, but you can’t really just walk up to it, you have to go through separate gates. And I actually made a whole map on Hypable because I’m obsessed with all this news.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And so that does take up a good chunk, so if they were to cut that out – and the Gibson Amphitheater is very old, even though they still hold events there, they most recently hosted the MTV Movie Awards there…

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: …so it’s still used for big events. So, they’ll knock the Gibson Amphitheater out and they’ll have all that room behind it because behind the Gibson Amphitheater is really nothing, just a lot of Universal backstage stuff. So, it’s actually a cool plan and it will definitely work, I think, and you can even see some undeveloped land right behind it, so maybe that was part of what he was referring to.

Eric: Yes.

Andrew: But yeah, I’m feeling good about the size thing now, now that he’s answered that question.

Eric: Yeah, the L.A. Times had – their list of questions, actually, earlier in the week, their first question was, where – or the second one was, where will the land be located?

Andrew: Yeah. And they did – I mean, at the event today, they had said it will be within the existing Universal property, so that put to rest immediately, “Are they going to build this elsewhere?”

Micah: Yeah. Well, here’s the big question I have about this: It’s going to be essentially a replica of what exists in Orlando. Other than for convenience for people who live in Los Angeles or California, proper, I guess, and sort of everybody that’s closer to the West Coast, what’s the draw there versus going to Orlando, especially with the news that the Orlando park is going to be expanding and have more to offer than what’s in Los Angeles?

Andrew: Yeah. Well, one thing to keep in mind is – and this may be a stretch, but for all we know, the Orlando expansion, whatever they’re planning for that, could also be put into Hollywood.

Eric: That’s true.

Andrew: We don’t know for sure. Or they could have at least one extra ride, so…

Micah: That’s what I’m saying, I’d like to see something…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …that’s different about Los Angeles that’s going to…

Andrew: Yeah, I agree.

Micah: …offer people…

Eric: I mean, historically, don’t they actually just duplicate the rides, though? I think if…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: I mean, because Terminator 2 3D is in Hollywood, right?

Andrew: Mhm. That’s actually right where the event was today.

Eric: Oh okay, because… [laughs]

Andrew: Right outside of it.

Eric: …on the L.A. Times site, it says that that’s actually due to be torn down contractually.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Okay.

Eric: So, but things like that – the rides are more or less the same, but they still both work because they’re on opposite coasts.

Andrew: Yeah. And I mean, that’s the thing, they are on opposite coasts. So, let’s say if you live anywhere in the Midwest, even anywhere in the western half of the country, I would assume you would probably be more inclined to go to L.A. for the Wizarding World. I mean, and you have other attractions or theme parks here as well. You’ve got Six Flags, you do have Disney.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: You have Knott’s. I mean, there’s quite a few. Sea World.

Eric: It’s true, and…

Micah: Absolutely.

Eric: …if you’re in town or in the state for something like Comic-Con or VidCon or…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …any of those and you want to…

Andrew: [laughs] VidCon.

Eric: [laughs] …go by and see the Wizarding World, then you don’t have to go to the other side of the country to do it. So…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, I was also going to throw in there, it might be a bit of a stretch but I really don’t think it is, people from Japan, people from Australia…

Andrew: Oh yeah.

Micah: It’s a lot easier…

Andrew: Hawaii.

Micah: …to go to Los Angeles – exactly.

Eric: Than it is to Florida.

Micah: Than it is to go to Orlando.

Andrew: Yeah, and we can’t forget, it’s not like everybody in the world has been to Universal Orlando to go to the Wizarding World. So, there’s going to be…

Eric: Although waiting in line, it would seem like that. [laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah. But there’s going to be an incredible amount of people who will be inclined to go just because it is in Hollywood and they won’t be making that decision, they’ll just say, “Oh, it’s in Hollywood.” A lot of people can road-trip. I mean, it’s just a simple ride through the desert for most people if they’re outside of L.A.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: So…

Eric: Now the other thing about L.A., of course, is the stars, Andrew.

Andrew: [laughs] The celebrities.

Eric: The stars, they – some of them – quite a deal of them live in L.A., don’t they? [laughs]

Andrew: Right. So, what are you saying? We’ll find them there? We’ll bump into them?

Eric: Will we be seeing – yeah, will we be seeing more of that?

Andrew: Yeah, I would think so.

Eric: Not to mention Evy Lynch, I’m sure they’ll build her, like, a penthouse or something in Hogwarts.

Andrew: In Hogwarts Castle, yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: If she were to ask. But…

Andrew: So, we know where the park is going to be, generally, we know kind of what’s going to be in it. I mean, do you guys think it was the best idea for the second park to be in L.A. or should it have been elsewhere?

Micah: That’s the key question, isn’t it? My other question I was going to ask you guys was, how does this affect orlando, though? Because by in large, to me, Los Angeles is a bigger attraction to people who are vacationing or who are coming from overseas than Orlando is. It just has more to offer, you just pointed out a lot of the other theme parks that it has. But there’s a lot of other things, I think, that draw people to California on the whole, don’t you agree?

Andrew: Somewhat. I mean, Orlando is the theme park capital of the world, there’s no doubt about that. I mean, Disney World is just a monstrosity and it pummels Disneyland in sheer size alone. But yes, there is certainly a ton of compelling things out here for people to do and I’m sure Universal Orlando is a little peeved about – ultimately it’s true, they will lose some business, some people will decide to go to L.A. over Orlando. But Universal Hollywood is going to suffer that a little bit, too. So…

Eric: Yeah. Yeah, you’re right. I think – I don’t know. I can only see this as kind of a positive thing to kind of spread people out. I mean, [laughs] look, it’s another opportunity for Butterbeer. Butterbeer on two coasts now instead of just one in the real world, so I’m happy that Hogwarts is duplicating, that the magic of Harry Potter is spreading. But also it might actually take the lines down just a little bit in Florida, especially over summer which actually may help things.

Andrew: Yeah, that could be nice.

Micah: To answer your question, though, I’m sorry I directed it off of it, but I think that in Los Angeles – the problem that a lot of people are going to have is that now you have two Potter theme parks in the United States. You have nothing in the U.K. and nothing in the rest of the world as it stands right now. You have the studio tour coming to the U.K. in March of next year, but that doesn’t provide, I think, the – it’s not the same. I mean, it’s a different experience than what the theme park is going to provide, and so I’m wondering if there are plans for that down the road. I know there was a couple of other countries discussed where there are already Universal parks, about adding the Wizarding World there as well in the future…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …because it doesn’t seem like they’re going to stop at just Los Angeles. But I think U.K. based fans are started to get a little aggravated that nothing [laughs] is being done in their country.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean…

Eric: At the risk of sounding ignorant, I don’t really think that theme parks are that big overseas. I mean, America…

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Short of Japan, theme parks, roller coasters, it just seems like the emphasis has been on the United States for a very, very long time for those kinds of attractions. And with the new park coming to L.A. it will be a quick flight over the water, a quick fifteen-hour flight over the water…

[Micah laughs]

Eric: …from Japan. So, maybe actually having it on the other coast – because you said, it is closer to Hawaii, it is closer to Australia, it is closer to Japan, New Zealand, and Fiji.

Micah: I’m not trying to be the U.S. ambassador for British theme parks here, but…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …I’m just noticing things that we’re seeing, people making comments on Facebook, Twitter…

Andrew: Well, and if you…

Micah: All these places…

Andrew: And if you look at the sheer success of theme parks around the world, America owns it. [laughs] They are just – people come to America for theme parks. If they want to go somewhere in the world for theme parks, chances are they will go to America. There’s the most stuff here, simple as that, and it’s thanks to Disney and to some extent, Universal and those other ones.

Eric: So, here’s a question I had, because we all know this to be true and this is kind of – I guess it will transition into talking about Florida. But Florida has just seem to be consistently overwhelmed by the success of their Potter park since day one. I mean, they had Butterbeer mugs that were supposed to last two years and they lasted one week [laughs] which is why they had to go to the different-style mugs. And all that stuff, the merchandise, everything, has just – their quarter profits that they posted, all way above their expectations. So, in doing this in L.A., is it saying that Universal Studios Hollywood needs the money? Is it kind of a sure bet instead of doing something original? Or what do you guys…

Andrew: It’s a sure bet, that’s what it is.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: I mean, some Universal exec last week called Harry Potter, the Wizarding World in Orlando, a “reset mechanism,” as in they add it to the park and it revitalizes the park. And so that’s what they want to do here. I mean, they’re just printing money every time they…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …produce one of these new parks. However, they do need to move fast. I mean, one of the other things we haven’t talked about yet is the opening date of this park, and it’s supposed to be somewhere between 2015 and 2016. And that’s kind of a long way away and there’s not movies to keep people excited, so it’s, like, will the excitement be there? I mean, I’ve been wondering, am I going to be living in L.A. in four or five years?

Eric: That’s true.

Andrew: I mean, [laughs] it’s just such a long time from now, I don’t know where my life is going to be in four or five years.

Micah: Yeah, and you also – you asked me this question, I think it’s an important one to bring up, what’s the state of these websites going to be…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …in that timeframe? Because…

Andrew: Yeah, it’s a long time.

Micah: …not to say that the sites aren’t going to be around, but are they going to be as active and involved as 2011?

Andrew: Yeah. And I’ve been trying to think of an example to relate this to, how time just passes and – but I really can’t. I mean, I guess what you can say is that, for example, Disneyland, they reopened a classic Star Wars ride called Star Tours, they redid it inside and out, digitally, the storyline, and everything. When they reopened it, it was a huge opening all over again. I mean, Star Wars stars were there, some of the biggest fans were there, camped out hours ahead of time. So, I think they can hold their popularity and people are really drawn to living in these stories, what they stared at on screen for so long, finally, they can actually be inside and it’s great.

Eric: Yeah, that reminds me, speaking of Star Wars reminds me of Episode 1. There you have it, it was twenty-five, twenty-six years since Return of the Jedi when Episode 1 came out, and the buzz just kind of kept getting bigger.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: I belonged to a Star Wars fan club or something when I was in, like, third grade and I got these updates on the filming of Episode 1. But it was huge, it was absolutely huge, and the fans are just waiting for it. I think it would be smart, in closing for me about this Hollywood park, if they do do it differently.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Maybe if they still had the same rides, fine, but change something big like the layout, the direction, or…

Andrew: Yeah, I bet it will be adjusted slightly in that regard.

Eric: Yeah, and just kind of – definitely make it more of an open space, too, as well because I think one of the things Florida lacks is a really solid outdoor eating area, something that – or even like a common area because everybody around you is always going to a specific place, and there’s not really much time to kind of sit down and take it in.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, I like that.

Andrew: Well, I mean, I think to some extent, it will stay the same in many regards because they like that perspective of how where you enter near the Hogwarts Express in Orlando and you see Hogwarts in the distance, and below that is the buildings of Hogsmeade, it’s a beautiful entrance. But yeah, I do agree it should be mixed up somewhat.

MuggleCast 246 Transcript (continued)


Main Discussion: The Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Orlando Resort to be Expanded


Micah: Well, that’s a good tie-in to the Orlando expansion which we should touch on a little bit more because there’s been…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …more information than just, “It’s going to expand.” There’s been a lot of rumors as to what exactly the Universal executives are going to do, and you talked about walking into Hogsmeade and seeing the Hogwarts Express right there, and one of the things that they were talking about in a few of these articles was tying the old Universal park in Orlando to the Islands of Adventure via the Hogwarts Express.

Andrew: Mhm. And I’ve been a big fan of them knocking out the Poseidon’s Fury ride which is right out front of the Hogwarts Express and that stuff because it just seems outdated. But I mean, this new rumor pretty much blew my mind. So, they announced a few days ago that they are going to remove the Jaws ride at Universal Studios, that’s not the same park that the Wizarding World is in. And then just a couple of days later when they made this Wizarding World Los Angeles announcement, they also said, oh yeah, and also Wizarding World Orlando is going to expand – a significant expansion. And there’s these rumors that are very strong, I’ve heard from multiple people, the Screamscape site and a couple of these employees who work there, that this is true, they’re going to be knocking out the Jaws ride and building the London side of Harry Potter. And the coolest part of it all is that the two parks would be connected by Hogwarts Express.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Yeah, and it’s about a half a mile distance between the two parks, between the Wizarding World and where Jaws is right now. So, that could be a nice little trip. I imagine the train would be moving slowly. But the other angle to this and where Universal is brilliant and where it may piss off a lot of people, is that you would have to have two park tickets to get into both parks.

Eric: It’s true.

Andrew: You would have to have a two-park ticket to ride the train.

Eric: It’s true, but at the same time, the two-park ticket is really the only way to get your money’s worth, in my opinion.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean…

Eric: These days…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …with tickets, you need the multi-day pass, multi-park pass…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …to really even justify spending a hundred dollars to get in.

Andrew: No, I agree with you, but I’ve seen a lot of comments where people are saying, “I cannot believe – how could they do this and build…”

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: “…two separate parks?”

Eric: Well…

Andrew: “And we’re going to be forced to…”

Micah: This is exactly…

Andrew: “…buy two park tickets.”

Micah: …what you were talking about before with revitalizing Orlando, revitalizing Los Angeles. That Universal Studios park is about as outdated as it comes with respect to rides, and I think what this will do is it will help pick things up in that particular park.

Andrew: Yeah, absolutely.

Eric: On that exact topic, when I was in the regular Universal park just a couple of weeks during the Home Entertainment Celebration, I went into the Universal – the regular park, Universal Studios, to kind of look around – I was actually shopping for Christmas, don’t tell my mother.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: And [laughs] I noticed, actually, that the main gift shop – when you walk in, there’s this huge gift shop. There was Harry Potter merchandise, quite a bit of Harry Potter merchandise in the regular Universal park which currently…

Micah: So, that’s a tip for people, actually…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …who don’t want to wait in line…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …in the Wizarding World.

Eric: Yeah. Well, it’s a tip but also the thing about it is my reaction was negative, it was, “What is this Harry Potter stuff doing in the regular Universal thing?” Because without a ride to justify it, without something to anchor it in the Universal’s regular park, clearly and disgustingly, that’s where the money is going.

Micah: But…

Eric: So…

Andrew: Yeah, but remember – I mean…

Eric: …Universal is just like…

Micah: There’s one in the airport, too.

Eric: …”Oh, people like Harry Potter stuff.”

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: “Let’s put a…”

Andrew: That’s what I was just going to say.

Eric: That’s a little different, that’s a Universal store. This is in the regular park, it’s, like, hey, nothing in this regular Universal park is worth selling, worth this shelf space. Due to all this demand for Potter stuff, we’re going to put extra stuff over here. You may not even have a ticket to see The Wizarding World of Harry Potter but now you can buy a little “Norbert that comes out of its egg” puppet and all these brooms and shirts and wigs and skirts and sweaters. I was a little upset because there was no Hogwarts to back it up in the park. But – and that’s already there. But if they have this sort of Muggle side of the world, I’m super excited for it.

Andrew: Yeah, and it kind of makes sense to have the two separated in terms of realism so there is a little journey, and the Hogwarts Express is obviously perfect because I mean, let’s say they build Platform 9 and 3/4. [laughs] That would be really cool on the Jaws side. Yeah, it’s a cool idea. Now how about some of these rides? I mean, one of the ones that was rumored and we’ve talked about before is the one in Gringotts or something related to Diagon Alley.

Eric: Yeah, I guess it really didn’t make much sense that they would do a Gringotts ride if they only really had Hogsmeade as a setting, you know?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: They would need sort of the Diagon Alley setting to be able to do the Gringotts coaster.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: So, this idea, I love.

Andrew: Yeah, the more I think about this, too, just because imagine stepping out of the existing Wizarding World and then five feet later, you’re in Diagon Alley. It just wouldn’t really feel right, I don’t think.

Eric: Right. But to take a train or to – because the other thing is that the Jaws ride is in the far back right of the – I want to say – I don’t know the cardinal directions. It’s the back right end of the corner of the park – of the regular park.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And the park is to the right of the Universal Islands of Adventure on the left and the Wizarding World is in the back left of that park. So, it’s the furthest possible distance from the park entrance and also from each other if they were to build it where the Jaws ride is…

Andrew: Yeah, it’s kind of…

Eric: …which is really cool.

Andrew: It would have to go backstage for a good – the whole thing, the train ride would have to be backstage. And they’d also have to knock out a lot of buildings backstage because – unless it’s going to go above them. But then I think they’re going to do some sort of tunnel where you obviously don’t want to be riding the Hogwarts Express through the back area [laughs] of Universal…

Eric: [laughs] Yeah.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: …where there’s people walking around in costumes with no heads on.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So, I think they would do some sort of tunnel and…

Eric: And have it be like a video thing?

Andrew: Yeah, because I was thinking in Disney when you ride the train, in some parts, you go through these tunnels and you see these sort of stage areas, like you go through a dinosaur world, and you see all these dinosaurs and stuff, and you’re passing by them.

Eric: Oh, cool.

Andrew: So, I think it could be something like that, maybe.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Obviously not with dinosaurs, [laughs] but…

Eric: No, here I was thinking they would have to teraform the back lot to get it to look like the viaduct and things like that. But you’re right, if they just have a tunnel but maybe instead of the windows of the train, it’s like a video screen or something…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …that shows you the English countryside, that would be…

Andrew: Yeah, that would be cool.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: So, my understanding that how they’re going to lay this out is – at least in concept for right now, you would have London and you would have the opportunity to go into an area that would take you to Platform 9 and 3/4, you would get on the Hogwarts Express and you would also have off of London the entrance to the Leaky Cauldron, and somewhere in there would lead you out to Diagon Alley and I guess Gringotts where the ride would be. Is that kind of what people are thinking about? Or am I just making this all up in my head? [laughs]

Eric: I really wonder – I wonder how much of it would be Muggle London because we’re talking about Diagon Alley and that’s actually still magical. I’m wondering how much of the park would be sort of like Charing Cross Road or any of those kind of famous London – because I think when you’re heading towards Jaws, there’s The Mummy ride and The Mummy is – obviously as a film – is set in London, in Britain, so I’m thinking that those buildings – I don’t really remember if they look British at all or if there’s cobbled streets or anything, but they could really theme that whole area to look more British and then by the time you get to the park – or the Harry Potter side of things…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Even if it’s…

Micah: I’m just reading this here, it says:

“Phase 2 of the ‘Wizarding World’ would include a new section of the park to take over where the ‘Jaws’ and ‘Amity’ portion…”

I guess…

Eric: Amity.

Micah:Amityville Horror, right? Is that what they’re talking about?

“…portion recently closed down. The rumored plans include a reproduction of London, which would house Diagon Alley – a ‘true’ location for Ollivander’s Wand Shop, Gringotts Bank with an amazing new roller coaster cart ride, and the Leaky Cauldron. Additionally, they would add Platform 9 and 3/4 where patrons would pass through the Muggle side and be whisked away to Hogsmeade Station via an actual train ride on the Hogwarts Express.”

Eric: So, we’re talking about…

Micah: This is massive work.

Eric: …two rides.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, that’s huge.

Eric: But we’re talking about two rides, though. Two rides because we have the Gringotts ride which is the only one they’d really have to develop hard, think hard to develop because they’ve got to build it underground or in the wall or whatever they do – however they do it. But then the train ride, which would work. But I think they could actually get away with only adding two more rides…

Andrew: Yeah. No, I agree.

Eric: …but just have it be a nice themed area with obviously the Leaky Cauldron to eat at and all the shops in Diagon Alley.

Micah: Right. [laughs] They see dollar signs in those merchandise shops.

Andrew: Yeah, of course. And I think they would move Ollivander’s to the London side.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And then maybe put something else there or probably just expand that store that’s there. [laughs]

Eric: Well, they said a true location, I think they just mean a bigger store [laughs] because…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …those waits for Ollivander’s in Hogsmeade is three or four hours on bad days.

Andrew: Yeah, they could just do a second one, I guess, that would certainly help alleviate the wait. Or just redesign Ollivander’s completely in the London side and make two or three Ollivander’s, but obviously you don’t see all two or three of them, you just go into one entrance and you’re directed into room one, two, or three.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Yeah. So, a lot of big rumors going on. It’s – again, 2014 – I think The Wall Street Journal report said 2015 and the L.A. Times said 2014. And then I saw a report today saying 2015/2016, so a lot of this stuff is very…

Micah: Is this for the expansion or for the L.A. park?

Andrew: Both. I heard the expansion was 2014, which I guess could make a little more sense because I mean, they already know – well, they know when they’re closing up both parks.

Micah: I was just trying to remember how fast it took the Orlando park…

Eric: To do it the first time?

Micah: …to develop because I thought we were looking at a further timeline, and it actually ended up being created and opened a lot sooner.

Andrew: Yeah, I’m not sure. It was announced May 31st, 2007.

Eric: I thought so. Or right before the last film.

Micah: And it was open…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …in the spring of 2010, right?

Andrew: Yeah, but it was, like, June, right? And it was, like, late June.

Eric: So…

Andrew: So, that’s just over three years.

Eric: Three years…

Andrew: So, that’s not bad, actually. That was pretty quick, yeah.

Eric: That would put it into the 2014/2015 range.

Andrew: Yeah. Yeah, that’s right.

Micah: For the expansion, obviously, it depends how much work they would need to do and how fast they start it.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, I think the expansion probably would have been a lot easier if they weren’t doing it over at Universal Studios.

Eric: You think so?

Andrew: Well, yeah, just because – well, I mean, just because of the sheer size of it. I mean, they’re going to have to add…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …so much, they’ve got to build that entire – they have to take out a tremendous amount of stuff to make room for the Hogwarts Express. That’s going to be an amazing construction feat that they’re going to pull off. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, but the thing is I’m sure that the merchandise that they’ve sold thus far has already paid for [laughs] this addition to the park and the next two.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: You know?

Andrew: Absolutely.

Eric: It’s spectacular.


Listener Tweets: The Wizarding World of Harry Potter in Los Angeles


Andrew: Well, we got some comments from those who follow us on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast. Bradyboy writes:

“I live on the East Coast, won’t impact me much, although the crowds will be much better in Florida when I go.”

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: That’s the spirit!

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, maybe. I’m not sold that this is going to alleviate the crowds. But…

Micah: Well, remember, [laughs] just as we were discussing, you have a few years before those crowds lessen in Orlando.

Eric: [laughs] Go down.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Thomassholan wrote:

“Stoked! An HP theme park within a couple of hours of San Diego, and it won’t cost an arm and a leg to go. Once I’m in the park is another story.”

Oh, because he’s going to be spending a lot of money. taylor_waylor18 said:

“Looking forward to it!”

steings said:

“I hope they have unique experiences at each park and L.A. is not carbon copy of Orlando.”

The_Demon_ wrote:

“So excited! Hogwarts will be a thirty minute drive instead of a five hour flight! Went to ‘Wizarding World’ Orlando once. Can’t wait to see how it compares.”

SnailSavvy wrote:

“My first thoughts were: There can only be Hogwarts!”

I guess she meant one Hogwarts.

“But I will still be going. I wish the U.K. would get a theme park instead.”

And finally, mariaggonzalez says:

“I couldn’t be happier about not having to travel 3,000 miles to go to the ‘Wizarding World’!”

So, see you guys, lots of locals here are very thrilled…

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: …about this.


Butterbeer Tastes Different in Los Angeles?


Eric: Well, the other thing – during the event today, were they passing out Butterbeer? Because I saw…

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Eric: …your pictures.

Andrew: This is the best part.

Eric: They had the costumes, right?

Andrew: Yeah, they had the costumes and I wanted to take a picture of one of them, but I felt like it was kind of creepy, [laughs] so I decided not to.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: But yeah, at the end – and when they invited media to it, they called it a Butterbeer toast to the Wizarding World, they didn’t really want to announce it. But they brought out Butterbeer at the end and I have to say, it was so nice to have these fresh Butterbeers. They look just like they came out of the Three Broomsticks in Orlando, just have them here in Los Angeles. I was so thrilled to see that.

Eric: So, that Butterbeer didn’t sit on a plane or a train for, like, 35 hours?

Andrew: No, I think they made it there.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I think they made it there in the park.

Eric: Which is dangerous.

Andrew: And I hate to…

Eric: I would hate – yeah?

Andrew: Go ahead.

Eric: I would hate to be the courier with that recipe or something, [laughs] carrying it across…

Andrew: Yeah!

Eric: …the other side of the coast because spies would want that, you know?

Andrew: [laughs] Right. But I have to say and I hate to put a damper on this, but – and this is not just me, this is two other people.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We were all in agreement that the Butterbeer tasted different. Now, it’s the same cup.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: It’s the same froth, but something about the soda, it was off. And I jokingly suggested maybe it’s the L.A. water.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: But I don’t know if that’s actually [laughs] what the issue is.

Eric: So, it was off. Hmm.

Andrew: Yeah, it was off. Ben – I brought that up to Ben earlier tonight. He suggested, “Well, maybe it’s because in Orlando, you’re sweating so much…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “…that it just tastes so much more refreshing, whereas here…” [laughs]

Eric: Poor Ben.

Andrew: “…your body is okay, so…”

Eric: He’s had a rough go with things in Florida.

Andrew: Anyway, so over the next couple of years, we will continue to update you on this. Hopefully sooner rather than later…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …we’ll see at least some concept art about either the expansion or Wizarding World L.A. I mean, because when they announced Wizarding World Orlando back in 2007, we got concept art right from the beginning, so…

Eric: Yeah. Yeah, that’s true.

Andrew: …hopefully we’ll see some L.A. stuff soon.

Eric: Maybe. MuggleCast…

Andrew: By the way, J.K. Rowling commented on this…

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: …in the press release, she said, “I am delighted that The Wizarding World of Harry Potter has been so popular with fans since the opening in Orlando last year, and I am sure that the teams at Universal and Warner Bros. will bring their expertise and attention to detail to Hollywood to make this new experience equally as exciting. P.S. Sorry Micah about Pottermore.”

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Eric: Wow, she included that right in the whole…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …press release.

Andrew: I thought that was nice. I guess…

Micah: That is…

Andrew: …she knows the way to get to you.

Micah: Yeah. Oh, she knows.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: But…

Andrew: Okay guys…

Eric: Yeah, what’s J.K. Rowling doing, huh? Seriously.

Andrew: I guess planning another theme park. Maybe this is what she’s been busy with. Just kidding.

Eric: She could update her Twitter. Seriously.


Show Close


Andrew: Yeah. Well, don’t forget to visit MuggleCast.com, it has all the information you need about this show.

Eric: Yes, of course.

Andrew: We have another episode this month, it is going to be our Year in Review show and also our third or fourth annual [laughs] MuggleCasties.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: This is, of course, where we give you a variety of categories, you know, the J.K. Rowling award.

Eric: Award. Very, very secretive.

Andrew: Yeah. Most Shocking Story, all these different categories related to Harry Potter, and we’re going to be doing the polls online this year and then we will announce the winners on the show. And it will be a year in review and that will be out in a couple of weeks, and that will be it for 2011.

Micah: Crazy.

Eric: Right. Onward to 2012.

Andrew: I think that will put us at close to thirty episodes for the year, so that’s not bad.

Eric: It really isn’t bad.

Micah: Okay, I’m just looking at this right now. The first annual MuggleCasties were in 2008, so this would be…

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: …the fourth.

Andrew: Whoa.

Eric: I thought so. Very nice.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: 2008, 2009 – oh. Well, that’s cool.

Eric: We’ll have to copy those old categories and…

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: …see if we can work some new ones.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, definitely. All right. Well, from Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: We’ll see you next time for Episode 248 – 7.

Eric: Live from the Wizarding World

Andrew: 247.

Eric: [laughs] 247. Live from the Wizarding World California. See you in four years!

Andrew: Yes. Goodbye.

Eric: No.

Micah: [laughs] Bye.

[Show music continues]

Transcript #245

MuggleCast 245 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because Ben and I are starting a new fan club, this is MuggleCast Episode 245 for November 27th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction and periodicals. For a free Hugo Cabret audiobook, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleHugo.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 245! We are officially the Harry Potter podcast with the most Harry Potter podcast episodes! Woo!

Eric: Yay!

Andrew: Woo-hoo!

Matt: It’s only taken six years.

Andrew: Well, there was – we were the leader for a good point…

Matt: Oh.

Andrew: …and then PotterCast went on tour and went on, like, an eighty-city tour…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Those don’t count though.

Andrew: …and then released all the episodes. Huh?

Micah: You can’t count “on tour.”

Andrew: Yeah, do those count?

Eric: Well…

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t know if that counts.

Eric: …we did have that 12 hour MuggleCast, right? Or the 24 hour…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Where Episodes 113…

Micah: Yeah, but that was only broken up into about two or three episodes.

Andrew: I think…

Eric: I think six or twelve, to be honest. But…

Matt: Wait…

Micah: No!

Matt: …twelve hours. Yeah, if – I mean, if you think about it, if an episode consists of one to one and a half hours, that’s at least ten episodes that you can count.

Eric: Yeah, I’m really sure…

Andrew: Yeah, but we broke it into…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: We broke it into three or four parts, I think. In one of the episodes, I remember it was exported incorrectly, so it’s faster and so we sound like chipmunks…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …for, like, two hours. And we got a million e-mails about that but I didn’t really know how to fix it because it was kind of too late.

Matt: That was actually the first episode I was ever on.

Eric: Was one of the…

Matt: And…

Andrew: The 12 hour ones?

Matt: The 12 hour one. You called me and – although that was during the chipmunk era, so everyone thought I sounded like a chipmunk.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: So yeah, guys, we’re ahead of PotterCast. Is PotterCast ending? Is it…

Andrew: [laughs] No, let’s not start that. No, I just – it was just a – I mean, it’s true, but it was a joke. I’m just noting the occasion for no reason in particular.

Eric: No, I think – well, do you think we’ll be the first to 250, though?

Andrew: 250?

Eric: Yeah, we should be the first to 250.

Andrew: I’d say so, yeah.

Matt: How about 300?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. Oh God, that seems so far off.

Matt: We can do a tour.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Yeah, do a fifty-city tour. Just…

Matt: Just crank it all out.

Micah: And we could break each tour stop up into about four episodes.

[Andrew and Matt laugh]

Matt: Or we just do one episode with one episode lasting a minute.

Andrew: Well, this is not a standard episode of MuggleCast, really. We have a couple of special features. We’re going to – Micah is going to run through the LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7. He reviewed it and we’re also going to talk about the futures of “The Big Seven” stars kind of as a main discussion. And we have some e-mails to catch up on and who knows what other surprises we have for you. Don’t get your hopes up, though. I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Matt: And I’m Matt Britton.


Review: LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7


Andrew: All right. So, we are going to skip news this week. We’ll get to it on another episode. It has been kind of slow, so no particularly huge stories to talk about. But Micah, you reviewed – I assumed this is you, or was this Eric?

Eric: No.

Andrew: One of you…

Eric: Totally Micah.

Andrew: Okay. Micah, so you enjoyed the LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7 video game and you want to tell us how it was!

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Did it meet your expectations first of all?

Micah: Yeah, it did meet my expectations. I think part of the problem with the other Harry Potter video games is – we’ve talked about pretty much at length on this show and past episodes with the EA games. It’s just – there’s something about them that – but this game just feels like you’re having a good time, it’s fun. It’s also easy and I don’t mean that in a bad way but you can tell that the game is geared for you to go through and to really just have a good time. And it’s made for fans of Harry Potter, by fans of Harry Potter. And I think that’s one of the major differences. Eric got a chance to interview the game director Arthur Parsons down in Orlando and he’s a huge Harry Potter fan. His team consists of all Harry Potter fans and I think that’s where the key difference is. And I know that Eric and Matt both got a chance to play Years 1-4. What did you guys think of that?

Matt: Mhm. I loved it. Although – I mean, it’s very immersive so you can spend so much time playing other mini-games and stuff. It’s definitely not just Books 1-4, and 5-7, and then you’re done. Once you finish a level, that opens you up to other places to play games and such, especially – I think all the LEGO games do that too, don’t they?

Eric: Yeah, like…

Matt: For Indiana Jones

Eric: …free-play mode?

Matt: …and Batman.

Eric: Yeah.

Matt: Yeah, free-play and then you get to do other levels and stuff. But no, I really enjoyed it.

Micah: Yeah. And – go ahead, sorry.

Eric: Well, I was going to say the Arthur Parsons interview is on the previous episode of MuggleCast, isn’t it? Didn’t we…

Andrew: Yeah, or 243.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: One of the two.

Eric: Yeah. So I mean, that’s – you get a sense there and yeah, they took what they did in the first game and they just improved upon it. And that’s kind of one of the good things about making more than one, is that you learn from critics and stuff like that.

Andrew: So, it was the same exact team, right? 1-4 and 5-7 had pretty much the same teams?

Eric: Yeah, pretty much from what I understand. He didn’t mention anything. Arthur…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …didn’t mention any difference and that’s kind of a good thing too because from the stories that he told, they’re just super, super, super passionate.

Micah: Yeah. And in the review, I refer to the EA games more as being a corporate carbon copy of the movies. And it’s true, but LEGO does follow the movies as well, but I think the difference is that they allow you to do more that you would want to do if you were a fan of the books. So, there’s really just the smallest detail that’s in there that you’re not going to get in the Electronic Arts game. You have two hundred playable characters that are able to be unlocked. Everything from let’s say Professor Trelawney or Professor Slughorn to the woman that serves the trio when they’re inside the cafe in Deathly Hallows: Part 1. I mean…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …you’re talking the most obscure – you can play as Fang, you can play as Witherwings, you can play as the peacock that roams around Malfoy Manor, so – or even I think in the interview, Arthur Parsons mentioned you can play as Ginny’s Pygmy Puff. That probably sounds a little dirty to say but… [laughs]

Eric: Well, no…

Andrew: It does.

Eric: Yeah, her pet…

Matt: Oh. No.

Eric: If you’re playing as Ginny, you push the button to get your pet out and she takes it out of underneath her shirt, and it’s her Pygmy Puff.

Micah: Right.

Eric: I’ve seen it happen.

Micah: And humor… [laughs]

Eric: But…

Micah: …has been a focal point of all the LEGO games, not just Harry Potter. There’s a lot of funny scenes that take place throughout the game. And one thing that they’ve done, and I don’t think it was in the first one, is now you have the opportunity to use Dark magic, so you have to actually unlock more of the evil characters in the series like Bellatrix or Voldemort, and then you actually have to go and purchase the character once you’ve unlocked them.

Eric: Mhm. And you get…

Micah: And you go back through the game.

Eric: It’s like…

Micah: You can’t do everything in the game.

Eric: …gold studs, right? It’s like golden studs that you have to collect by blowing stuff up…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: …and that’s your currency, yeah.

Micah: But there are actual things that you are prevented from doing unless you unlock these characters, so as Matt was saying before, it’s very time-consuming.

Matt: Right.

Micah: You’re going to spend hours.

Matt: Which is great. I mean, you definitely get…

Micah: Yeah.

Matt: …what you paid for.

Andrew: Now on the other hand, I’m looking at the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 game review and it just – bad ratings just like the rest of them, really. I mean, this one got a 4.0 on GameSpot and they say that – they call it, “Conceptually ridiculous, exceptionally tedious, incredibly short, three hours of gameplay, fails to capture the tension and excitement of the novels.” In these games, the spells act like guns. “Expulso isn’t an exploding spell: It’s a rapid-fire machine gun.”

Eric: [laughs] Whoa!

Andrew:Confringo isn’t a blasting curse: It’s a grenade launcher.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew:Stupefy isn’t a stunning spell: It’s a pistol.” [laughs]

Eric: Wow!

Andrew: And not like a physical gun. I mean, they’re still holding wands but that’s the way the spells shoot…

Eric: They are more like…

Andrew: …according to this review.

Eric: They are really more like first-person shooters, you know?

Andrew: And Apparating is just, like, short-distance moving around a field. It’s just ridiculous.

Micah: Well…

Eric: Wow.

Micah: And see the difference is with – in Year 5 when you start out in this game, you don’t have all your spells. You’re very limited in your arsenal, but then your…

Matt: Mhm.

Micah: …arsenal expands to a lot of the spells that you had in LEGO Harry Potter: Years 1-4 once you decide that you’ve had enough of Umbridge and how she is going about running Hogwarts, so it’s like once that change occurs – and it’s a very inventive way to do it. And then all the rest of the spells that you learn, you have to learn from Professor Flitwick in Charms class.

Matt: Mhm. It’s very good, and the more spells that you learn and accumulate, the more you can immerse yourself and do other things, too.

Micah: Yeah, absolutely.

Andrew: So Micah, you give this game a thumbs up? A recommendation?

Micah: Yeah. I mean, just…

Andrew: A buy?

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, exactly. It’s just fun. I mean, that’s what video games are supposed to be. I know – the way you just described Deathly Hallows: Part 2 from EA sounds like a – what’s the big game right now where everybody goes online and they’re playing, blowing people up?

Matt: Oh, Mission Warfare?

Andrew: World of Warcraft?

Eric: Modern Warfare?

Micah: Modern Warfare, yeah.

Matt: Modern Warfare, there you go.

Micah: So, I don’t know. That’s not how Harry Potter should be on a video game for. [laughs]

Matt: No. Maybe that’s what they were trying to do, was trying to get…

Micah: Maybe.

Matt: …that whole niche in the gaming community.


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – Daniel Radcliffe


Andrew: Let’s pause for a minute to remind you that this week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of spoken audio entertainment, providing digital versions of tens of thousands of audiobooks for download to your computer, iPhone, Android phone, BlackBerry and iPod. Listen whenever and wherever you want just like the podcast you are listening to right now. Audible has more than 100,000 titles to choose from. Every genre, Audible has it covered. Today we have a special offer and a special promotional URL from Audible. Download the Hugo Cabret audiobook free today and try Audible free for thirty days. Hear it before you see it in theaters. The reviews are astounding, it has a 97% on Rotten Tomatoes which means it’s fantastic. But MuggleCast listeners know that it’s always great to read the book before you actually see it in theaters. For a free Hugo Cabret audiobook, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleHugo. Again – it’s a different URL this time – it’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleHugo.

As we discussed at the beginning of the episode, or as I teased at the beginning of the episode, one of the things we wanted to talk about today is the futures of “The Big Seven” stars. And now we say “The Big Seven” because you may remember at the Deathly Hallows world premiere this past summer, J.K. Rowling referred to “The Big Seven” stars/characters: Dan, Emma, Rupert, Evanna, Matt, Bonnie and Tom. She characterized those as “The Big Seven.” So, today we wanted to talk about where their futures are because obviously Harry Potter is over now, so what’s next for each of them? And we’ll start with Dan, the biggest of “The Big Seven” easily. And we all know he’s had – he’s done a really good job, I think, of moving on from Harry and he started even before the franchise was over. Of course, he was in Equus in London and in New York. And then afterwards he went to How to Succeed, the musical on Broadway, still going on right now through the end of December, then he is finished. And then he has a film in the can which is coming out in February called The Woman in Black. And then recently – and this is kind of a new news item – he said – he heavily hinted actually. He is, “very likely to take on a gay role in a film next year.” So, he’ll portray a gay character and he did not say at all who it would be.

Eric: Hmm.

Andrew: He just said it’s a gay character.

Eric: So, he was promoting The Woman in Black and he said this?

Andrew: Yeah, it may have been during that. I’m not sure.

Matt: It’s going to be the life story of Lance Bass.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: But actually, I think it’s a really good idea by Dan because I think he’s trying to go completely opposite of Harry in all ways, so the musical, Equus where he had to be nude, this gay role, The Woman in Black, it’s a very creepy thriller…

Micah: He’s dressing up as a woman in black?

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: No.

Eric: He wants to…

Matt: That’s Halloween.

Eric: No, but he does want to diversify, you know? You need to get…

Andrew: Yeah.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: …out of that shell and I don’t think anybody doubts that he can do it because he has done it. But it will just be very interesting to see him in, like you say, all sorts of different types of roles.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: And that will really give him the strongest – not only resume, but for moving forward for a couple of years from now.

Micah: Yeah, I was going to say I think he is the one who is probably the most likely – and he has already proven this – to test himself.

Matt: Mhm.

Micah: To push the envelope a bit to really challenge himself. And that’s not to downplay any of the other actors or actresses we’re going to talk about. I just think that he’s willing to take a risk.

Matt: Mhm. I think he’s very excited to explore other roles and he’s definitely hitting every – trying to hit every spot in the spectrum.

Andrew: And he’s been asked a lot, “Would you take on another fantasy series?” And I think he has said no and I don’t blame him because you don’t want to just be identified as someone in a fantasy series and something that Harry Potter is so rare. I mean, he could star in the next Percy Jackson which is flop.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Although a fantasy film could definitely benefit from him starring in it, I think.

Matt: Well, any film can benefit from him starring in it.

Andrew: Well yeah, I guess. I mean, The Woman in Black I don’t see doing huge at the box office.

Matt: Well, it will do a lot more than it would have done if he didn’t star in it.

Andrew: Mhm.

Matt: But do you guys – I seriously do not think that it’s possible for Daniel Radcliffe to shed away from Harry Potter. Do you think that he still has that – is he trying to not be remembered for Harry Potter

Eric: No, no, I don’t think that’s it at all…

Matt: …and remembered for other things, too?

Eric: …and I think some of the special features – I think his conversation with J.K. Rowling. He said as much he’s not trying to get away from Harry Potter but – because he’ll always be grateful for the experience. He’ll always take that experience that he’s had working with all those people close to his heart. But I think the other thing is is that that’s not going to be the only thing in his life, you know?

Matt: Right, he wants to have a career.

Eric: He really wants to take what he has learned and apply it to other things, which is really cool.

Matt: Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, that’s cool.


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – Emma Watson


Andrew: Let’s talk now about Emma Watson. Micah I know is leading a new fan club. Never mind, bad joke. So, Emma Watson, she…

Micah: Ben and I actually started it up.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Oh, cool.

Micah: I don’t know where you’re going with this, but… [laughs]

Andrew: I don’t know. Like a, “Emma, we know you can break free of Harry Potter,” that sort of thing. I don’t know.

Matt: Dot com.

Andrew: So, one big film that she’s going to have next year in 2012 is The Perks of Being a Wallflower and this is based on a very popular book. And the book is interesting in that it’s set up like a diary and – she’s not the writer of the diary but she plays one of the bigger characters. I’m in the middle of reading it right now. It’s a really good book. There’s a lot of anticipation around it because there’s a great fan base already there. The addition of Emma Watson in it, I think, is very beneficial to it. And yeah, so that’s coming up. I think that will be a great next move for her. And then also a film that’s out now, or out very shortly, is My Week with Marilyn and she has a smaller role in that, but…

Eric: Yeah, I remember reading The Perks of Being a Wallflower, actually, and it would have been in ninth grade or so. And I remember it being very moving to me at the time and also because the main character Charlie, who is writing this diary, goes through some really moving changes in his life. But also a lot of it comes from this character Sam, who is the character that is being played by Emma Watson. And it’s a very coming of age – and by coming of age, I mean at times it’s sexual, at times it involves drug use – kind of performance, and so it is going to be one of those steps away for Emma Watson from the bookish Hermione role that was kind of not sexual at all. And also the idea that the film is actually being filmed in Pittsburgh which is where the book is set. And it’s being directed by the author of the book, so it’s going to be – hopefully. I have high hopes that it’s going to be an exact or a very faithful adaptation, considering this director has written the book and the screenplay, so there’s that.

Andrew: The studio behind it is Summit, which is the studio behind Twilight so they have some experience with book-to-film adaptation. You can decide on your own…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …if Twilight did a good job or not.

[Matt laughs]

Andrew: But Summit doesn’t really have a hand so much in the adaptation, that is more up to the screenwriter.

Micah: Are those the vampire movies?

Andrew: Yeah, that’s the vampire movies, yeah. And there’s no release date, but the film is in the can. I mean, they shot it, I assume it’s pretty much finished. They – Summit just hasn’t decided when exactly in 2012 to release it yet, so…

Matt: Right. I mean, they do have promotional stills of the movie.

Eric: Yeah, didn’t Emma recently talked about her role in the book?

Andrew: Yeah, there has been…

Eric: Or there was a positive experience, I think she said.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, I think she really enjoyed it. And there has been a little bit of press for it but not much because you still don’t have a date for it, really. And then a side note, and this is another recent news story, David Yates said recently he has a really great script for Emma Watson. He said – let me try to put on my Pooh Bear voice.

[Matt laughs]

Andrew: [poorly imitating David Yates] “I’ve got a really great script.” [normal voice] No, that’s awful.

Matt: What is that? [laughs]

Andrew: I don’t know. “I’ve got a really great script for Emma Watson. I just have her voice in my head for this part, an amazing role and she’ll knock it out of the park.” So, Yates really wants her to be involved and I think Emma would be inclined to work with Yates again.

Matt: I think so.

Andrew: So…

Matt: I think Emma probably has the best platform for making it, I think, the most out of “The Big Seven.”

Eric: Is that – do you think?

Matt: I think so because for Dan, he has a bigger chip on his shoulder because he was the central character in the entire series. He was the title character. And for the supporting roles, it’s not as hard for them to break out because they weren’t center stage as much.

Eric: Well, we mentioned Equus with Dan, obviously, and his Broadway roles. Emma was one of the models for the – was it 2010 season of Burberry? So, she’s done some modeling which was interesting.

Matt: Yeah, that is interesting. I think…

Eric: She still is appearing in sort of French commercials…

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: …for beauty products.

Matt: Well, I think that’s great. I think for Dan, I think he’ll probably have – be more proficient in Broadway and theater once he gets older.

Andrew: Yeah, he seems more like a Broadway type of person to me, personally.

Matt: But regarding Hollywood or mainstream films, I think maybe not soon, but once she gets older too, I think – in the long run, I think Emma would have a more lasting career.

Andrew: She is kind of more Hollywood. She does feel more Hollywood.

Matt: Well, I see her being like one of like Kate Winslet and…

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Matt: …those kind of actresses.

Eric: Yeah. Well, I did see – speaking of that, I did see My Week with Marilyn.

Andrew: Oh, how was it?

Eric: It was good, it was a screening. She plays – it’s like a smaller character but it’s an important one because it’s basically about this guy who becomes intimate with [laughs] Marilyn Monroe. And Emma does not play Marilyn Monroe, so she plays sort of a costume assistant or something who this guy is initially infatuated with and goes out, but she gets her heart broken. But it’s a good role. There are clips on the Internet of her in the role. Kind of small role but Kenneth Branagh is in it, he plays Sir Laurence Olivier. So, it’s kind of a high-profile film in a way, but it still feels kind of obscure or different or out there. But yeah, she has a good role in that, too.


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – Rupert Grint


Andrew: So, now let’s talk about Rupert Grint. He has one role – well, he has a couple of things. He has a couple of projects in 2013 and one in 2012. One in 2012 is called Into the White with Gunner Robert Smith, and the two in 2013 – at least the more interesting one, the larger one appears to be Postman Pat: The Movie. Now most Americans are probably thinking, “What on earth? Postman Pat? Bob the Builder? What? Is there a connection here?” And actually yes.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Well, they seem similar to me, actually. Postman Pat is an animated children’s series and they are – television series, rather. And they are turning it into a movie and actually it stars a couple of Harry Potter stars: David Tennant, Jim Broadbent and of course, Rupert Grint. And I believe Rupert Grint has the lead role as Postman Pat himself, so…

Matt: Okay.

Andrew: Do you guys think Rupert is going to continue with a film career or does he seem not so interested in pursuing it?

Micah: I don’t know. Why don’t we ask him?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Well, we certainly don’t have to – or he certainly doesn’t have to. But one of the things that he did and this is a movie that came out sort of over the last year, I want to say. It’s a film called Wild Target and he appears with Bill Nighy who is a hitman and it’s really about sort of escaping, running from these other criminal characters. And Rupert plays this really large role in this movie. He’s kind of just – I want to say a careless stoner, at first. But he gets involved in sort of the escape attempt of Bill Nighy’s character who I believe fails to kill one of his charges. See, they’re accidental – it’s kind of like a comedy but there’s a ton of action in it. And I was just surprised, watching this film, how good Rupert was in the film. And we’ve known he’s done other films, too, such as – what’s the one where he’s with Julie Walters?

Matt: Oh, Driving Lessons.

Eric: Driving Lessons. It was really good and obviously very early during Potter. Something like Wild Target just kind of showed me that he can still – he just has a really unique role in that film and I would like to see him continue to get work, maybe not as – my prediction is that he won’t be in as much of stuff as some of his other co-workers, for sure. And like I said, he doesn’t really have to be in anything. But I will still enjoy watching him, I think, and not having grown up with Postman Pat, who knows how that film will be? But we’ve seen prominent actors lending their voice to characters in animated films and it goes well for them, you know? And it’s just another way to reach a different audience.

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: There is…

Micah: Yep. He also seems to do a lot of charity work as well.

Matt: Yeah.

Micah: A lot of things that he draws and…

Matt: I could see Rupert doing a television series or something.


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – Tom Felton


Andrew: It just doesn’t seem to me that he – as a child he got into it and I could see him just not really being – he can live off Harry Potter money for the rest of his life [laughs] if he wanted to very comfortably. It just seems like he – well, let’s move on now to Tom Felton, on the other hand. Tom Felton has a smaller role than Rupert, Emma and Dan, but he’s really pursuing acting. I mean – and he seems very Hollywood. He has quite an impressive list of films coming up. There is at least six or seven listed just on IMDB. In 2012, there is Night Wolf, The Apparition and Labyrinth. And then in 2013, there is Grace and Danger. And there is a couple of others: Evac, which is listed for this year, and From the Rough.

Matt: Wait, Labyrinth?

Andrew: Yes.

Matt: Is that a remake? Is this the Jim Henson remake or is this something else?

Andrew: It’s a T.V. series, it’s coming out next year. There was a few photos online the other day.

Matt: Oh, okay. Yeah.

Eric: From what I understand, yeah, no relation to – and when that image came out, which I know we’re going to talk about, I was concerned because he’s got long hair, kind of like David Bowie at one point. But I don’t think they’re the same at all, but it is a film called Labyrinth.

Andrew: So, there are new photos of him in Labyrinth and he looks good.

Eric: He’s got…

Andrew: I mean, he looks crazy.

Eric: …long brown, sort of medieval looking…

Andrew: Unshaven, bloody face.

Matt: Dirty.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: [mocking Matt] Dirty.

Matt: Dirty.

Eric: Yeah. But way to diversify, right? And I mean…

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: …even Planet of the Apes, Rise of the Planet of the Apes film, he’s in it and he’s a fairly important character in it, and seeing him get this work is really good. But you’re right, he does appear to be working really hard at – and really wanting to pursue his acting as a result of all these projects he’s got lined up.

Matt: Well, he already had an acting career before Harry Potter, too.

Eric: That’s true. That is true.

Matt: His resume wasn’t very big or anything, but he was actively in roles before Harry Potter.

Andrew: Yeah, it just seems like he is very committed to making a big career for himself and I know he’s in L.A. quite frequently…

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: …having meetings when not about future films. And don’t forget, Planet of the Apes as well. That came out earlier this year. Got good reviews. He didn’t have that huge of a role but it was a Hollywood film.

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: very Hollywood.

Matt: He has said in interviews that he is actively trying to pursue the whole Hollywood acting career.


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – Evanna Lynch, Matthew Lewis and Bonnie Wright


Andrew: Now, let’s talk about three others. Evanna Lynch, she plays Luna, of course. No – at least according to IMDB, nothing yet for the future but she – it’s been clear she’s been out in Los Angeles trying to make some moves, meeting with people, all that good stuff.

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: And then there is Matt Lewis. He has a 2012 film called Wasteland but that’s about it for him. And then Bonnie Wright. She has two 2012 films: Geography of the Hapless Heart and The Philosophers.

Matt: God, didn’t get too far from Harry Potter, did she?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: The Philosophers? What’s that about?

Matt: It’s looking for a stone.

Andrew: I don’t know. [laughs] Yeah, where is the stone? I found the stone. The end.

Eric: Oh wow, this is the plot summary for The Philosophers: “At an international school in Jakarta, a philosophy teacher challenges his class of twenty graduating seniors to choose which ten of them would take shelter underground and reboot the human race in the event of a nuclear apocalypse.”

Andrew: Hmm.

Matt: So, it’s a comedy.

Eric: Actually she’s starring with Daryl Sabara who was in the Spy Kids films but has now grown up, and James D’Arcy who looks familiar.

Matt: Oh, Freddie Stroma!

Andrew: He’s from Harry Potter, yeah.

Matt: He played Cormac.

Andrew: In – now maybe this was just the screenwriter’s fault, I don’t know. But Bonnie Wright in the Harry Potter films has always sucked to me. She’s never been a good actress, I can’t believe when Jo said she was one of “The Big Seven.” I was, like, “Are you kidding? Is this a joke?”

Matt: Well, no. Okay, well, first of all, when J.K. Rowling says, “The Big Seven,” regarding to the literary characters…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Because Ginny is?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, it’s probably muddled for Jo. But the thing is, and if you watch The Women of Harry Potter documentary that’s on the latest Blu-ray release, I was blown away because I found myself being most interested in what Bonnie Wright had to say. So, there’s that. I mean, she’s really, really smart. You just get…

Matt: Her interviews haven’t really… [unintelligible]

Eric: You just get the impression that she was completely for whatever reason underutilized, under-placed in the Potter films. Blame anybody. But the films are not about Ginny and any time spent with Ginny is very awkward. She gets a lot of flack from people, I’m sure.

Matt: Even the character gets a lot of flack.

Eric: The character does, too. But in the books, it’s such a strong character.

Matt: Not a lot of people like her.

Eric: And she seems to be a very intelligent girl, so I’m looking forward to her in particular moving on because I want to see what she can really do.

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: I think you’re just attracted to her.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: This is your hormones talking.

Matt: No, I think Eric is right. We haven’t seen Bonnie Wright actually act, like had the spotlight, had a role, seeing what she can do. We’ve seen her being underused in the Potter series. Her character was definitely – she definitely got taken for granted.

MuggleCast 245 Transcript (continued)


Main Discussion: “The Big Seven” – J.K. Rowling (Bonus Star)


Andrew: And a final bonus star in this segment, J.K. Rowling! Now we know she’s doesn’t have a film career.

Matt: She’s doing a movie?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: No, she’s not going to be a movie star. But it’s been a while since we’ve talked about what’s next for J.K. Rowling because we’ve kind of been distracted by Pottermore over the past few months.

Matt: Because we haven’t heard anything from her, though.

Andrew: Allegedly, what’s been keeping her pen and paper – “Pen and paper is my priority at the moment,” I guess that ended up being Pottermore. But you got to think…

Matt: [laughs] That was online.

Eric: That was not pen or paper.

Matt: [laughs] It wasn’t really pen or paper.

Andrew: Yeah.

Matt: It was a mouse.

Andrew: But you’ve got to think she’s still writing stuff for other books, but will we see…

Micah: She’s busy testifying.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah. Oh, that’s for another day. But do you think she is going to release a new book in 2012 or 2013 now that Pottermore is kind of sort of going? Do you think she has a future book that we may see in 2012 or 2013?

Matt: Not 2012.

Eric: But why not?

Matt: If anything, probably…

Eric: What has she been doing?

Matt: I don’t know. It just seems like if she was releasing it in 2012, we’d be hearing something.

Eric: Well…

Matt: Like a rumor already.

Eric: I am shocked too that we have not heard anything because even those pen and paper priority tweets are over a year old, aren’t they?

Andrew: Mhm.

Matt: She’s tweeted the same tweet twice.

Eric: But over the course of years…

Andrew: No, more than that.

Eric: …she’s been this.

Matt: Oh, more. Okay, well – yeah, but she always tweets the same thing.

Eric: She’s clearly working on something. I thought she was working on a children’s book. I think she even said in an interview she was working on three different things.

Matt: I remember years ago that she said she was doing like an adult crime drama or something.

Andrew: She said, September 2009, “Pen and paper is my priority at the moment.” So, nobody would have guessed that – hearing pen and paper is her priority at the moment, you would assume back in September ’09, oh, we’re going to hear about a book…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …in a year or two.

Eric: That’s 26 months ago.

Andrew: Nope. [laughs]

Eric: 26 months ago.

Andrew: [laughs] Over two years!

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: And wow, that’s pretty crazy to think about. That was straight up misleading.

Matt: Mhm.

[Andrew laughs]

Matt: But I mean…

Andrew: That was a lie!

Eric: Well, and Pottermore…

Matt: The reason I don’t think we would something within a year at least is because she’s a high-profile author, she has a huge fan base. If she was writing anything, we would have heard at least a hint or a tease of some sort…

Eric: I don’t know.

Matt: …if it was coming within a year.

Eric: Maybe she just doesn’t want to advertise it or produce it or have…

Matt: Geez, do something! Update your site!

Eric: Yeah, that is true. Even though she’s got Pottermore – and I don’t think she can ever get rid of Pottermore now, even though it seems like it’s going away. I think she is stuck with it.

[Andrew and Matt laugh]

Andrew: You just want it to go away.

Eric: [laughs] But her home website should be more about what else she is doing. That can be less Potter related because her site wasn’t really ever Potter related. It was about her, it’s her desk you’re seeing, but…

Matt: Right. I mean, we can find, like, what? Post-it notes or something about what she’s doing.

Eric: It should be about her upcoming projects, even if they’re not related to Potter and…

Micah: I think the Twitter account, though, was made specifically because she had people who were impersonating her, so she just wanted to create an official account.

Matt: No, that’s exactly what it was.

Andrew: That’s fine…

Matt: No, you’re right.

Micah: I wouldn’t really go ahead and worry about any official information being put out there just because as you guys mentioned, the last three tweets have all been the same thing. And maybe next year is the year. I mean, it’s five years since Deathly Hallows was released. In 2012, it’s also going to be, what? 15 years since Sorcerer’s Stone was released, so we’re getting all these anniversaries obviously coming up. I can’t believe it’s going to be five years [laughs] since Deathly Hallows was released. That’s just scary.

Matt: Oh God, we’re getting old.

Micah: Yeah, we are. [laughs] But I would like to see something new. What Matt was talking about just before…

Matt: Or just hear about something new. I mean, we don’t need something new – I think it would be asking for too much if we get something within a year, but at least some news of something. Just update your Twitter or update your site or just update us.

Eric: I wonder what she’s writing.

Micah: The Beedle The Bard doesn’t really count because wasn’t most of that already written before Deathly Hallows?

Andrew: Yeah, it was just a short thing.

Matt: Even an encyclopedia would be nice.


Listener Tweets: “The Big Seven”


Andrew: So, we asked people on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast, who do you think has the most promising future of the stars and why?

Micah: J.K. Rowling.

Andrew: othlaholly said:

“Out of the trio I’d say Emma on the big screen and Dan in more of the Broadway type thing. Dan just looked so comfortable up on the stage for being such a newbie! Emma just seems like a natural movie star to me.”

Matt: Well, that’s what I said.

Andrew: DumbledorkAdams said:

“Emma Watson. She’s already branched out into other fields such as fashion, and just needs to diversify her film catalogue a bit.”

Eric: Ooh.

Matt: Oh.

Andrew: silverdoe25 said:

“Dan Radcliffe. If you’ve seen him in ‘How to Succeed’, you know why.”

[Eric laughs]

Matt: Aww, but – so I don’t know.

Andrew: ceilidh_brenzzz says:

“Dan’s passion and enjoyment for what he does is definitely going to get him far! After all, he has a fantastic resume!”

Eric: That’s true.

Andrew: jrgreen2010 says:

“Dan Radcliffe. He has an amazing resume since the ‘Potter’ films and doing great on Broadway.”

potions_class says:

“Emma Watson! She is ‘One Take Watson,’ after all!”

Eric: [laughs] One Take Watson?

Andrew: [laughs] Here’s a great one. Oh my gosh, this one is crazy. [laughs] This one is from McGregorsWench:

“Sean Biggerstaff! He may not make blockbusters but he chooses projects that showcase his talent and is believable in the roles!!”

Eric: I wonder if I could…

Andrew: Wow!

Eric: If I tried, I wonder if I could find something else that Sean Biggerstaff has been in.

Matt: I totally believed his role though when he was flying on that broomstick in Part 2.

Andrew: Yeah, it was very believable.

Matt: I was immersed in that.

Andrew: I saw – he was in a short film or a short web series or something like that…

Matt: Oh, it was something…

Andrew: …a couple of years ago.

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: And it wasn’t – I mean, I guess I believed it.

Matt: Something like a grocery store or something.

Andrew: I believed his career was over. Ooh. That’s mean. TanvirSKhalsa – something like that – says:

“Emma Watson. Acting in movies along with her education equals great decision. Her experience working with the best actors in Britain is great.”

So, we got quite a few. If you want to participate in the Twitter responses that we include on pretty much every episode, just follow Twitter.com/MuggleCast. Speaking of Pottermore, Micah, would you like to read the first e-mail to wrap up the show today?

Micah: The first e-mail is going to wrap up the show?

Andrew: No, no, what I meant was…

[Matt laughs]

Micah: Oh. [laughs]

Andrew: …as we enter our final segment that will wrap up the show.

Micah: That’s it, we’re done.

Matt: The final stretch.

Micah: We’re not even going to answer Rachael.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]


Muggle Mail: Positives about Pottermore


Micah: All right. [laughs] E-mail comes from Rachael, 26, in the U.K. She says:

“Hi guys, I have just recently caught up with a back-log of episodes since September and there sounds like there is a huge amount going down in Pottermore. I put off registering for the test period because I was away in Japan the entire time testing was open. I did this thinking that I would be able to at least register when I got back to give me something to do on my days off as well as listening to you guys. I have to say that it is disappointing that they extended the testing. Also, your comments on it make it sound like it is a mess. Nothing is wrong with honesty but is it really that bad? What are its positives?”

And she also goes on to say that she listened to us, speaking of places where you listen to MuggleCast, on Mount Fuji.

Andrew: Oh, cool!

Micah: That’s pretty cool.

Andrew: Yeah. Positives with Pottermore. We tried to throw positives in because they are there. I would say the chief positive among them is that there is tons of new content from J.K. Rowling. And we’ve been clear about that, there is that new content. However once you read it, it’s not really worth reading it again. And probably the other positive is the Sorting Hat, assuming that the Sorting is accurate. The wand selection, assuming that is accurate. So, those three to me. Any other positives, guys?

Matt: The artwork is really nice.

Eric: The artwork is nice. I think they – like you said, there is all this content from Jo. They just need to make the case a little bit stronger for having Pottermore instead of a book in print, like an encyclopedia in print, I think, because we’re not sure.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: We’re a little skeptical at the moment that Sorting – is Sorting accurate? Or – and things like that. They just need to answer those questions, I think, and make it a little bit more – give us more of a reason to come back and enjoy, and really appreciate what it is that they are doing online instead of saying we would have rather had a book for this encyclopedia. Because the content from Jo is great. It really, really, really truly is and I’m looking forward to seeing more of it. But is this something that really needs to be on this Flash server, always overloading programme, or would it really be better in a book?

Micah: Well, I also think the other thing people need to keep in mind too is that they’re going to keep releasing books over the next – I don’t know how long it’s going to be once, let’s say, Chamber of Secrets comes out in early 2012. What’s the time lapse going to be in between books? Because you’re going to have to keep people’s interest over time and I think right now, that’s what they’re lacking.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: That could be part of the reason why they’re still in beta, is they don’t have something that’s going to keep people there for the time in between books and after even.

Matt: Mhm.


Muggle Mail: Episode 244 Praise


Andrew: We also got some e-mails about our last episode, Episode 244, with our first ever Harry Potter DVD commentary. I’m just going to jump through all three real quick. Daylon, 17, of Arizona said:

“I just want to let you guys know I really enjoyed the ‘Part 2’ commentary. I learned so much and saw things you pointed out that I would have otherwise not seen. It would make me really happy if you did that for all the movies. Now that we know future happenings, it would be cool to go back and point out things that occur later because of a specific scene or character.”


Muggle Mail: Wrong Prediction by Trelawney


Andrew: Thomas – and now this must be a typo – age 107, from Maryland says:

[in an old man’s voice] “Enjoyed the commentary. Well done.”

[normal voice] No.

“There are many troubling aspects of this film that deviate from the books. I understand a lot of them for filming reasons, but there is one that is simply a glaring mistake. In the Pensieve of Snape’s memories, there’s a scene where Trelawney is making a prediction but it isn’t the one Snape overheard that set the whole saga in motion. It’s the one she made to Harry in Book 3. “Servant and master shall be reunited once more.” Seems like a pretty big error.”

What do you guys think about that? I didn’t even notice that.

Matt: I didn’t care.

Andrew: Is he right?

Eric: Yeah, yeah, I saw her but it’s – and I don’t know if you can hear Trelawney speaking and if you can, that would be an error because it’s obviously the wrong prediction. But you can see Emma Watson – and it’s a shot from Prisoner of Azkaban – making that prediction which is interesting.


Muggle Mail: Fred’s Death Scene


Andrew: Jessica, 15, of Indiana wrote about Fred’s death scene.

“In your ‘Part 2’ commentary, Eric talked about the scene where Voldemort was telling the Death Eaters to retreat, but Alecto killed Fred then anyway. That actually was not Fred who she was fighting, but George. James commented on Twitter that it was him who was fighting her. Also, if you look at the earlier scene, George is wearing the same colored jacket.”

So, there is some proof as the twins…

Eric: Okay, so the twins – what I thought was the…

Micah: So, I was right.

Eric: Yeah, what I thought was the twin’s death scene was not as moving…

Andrew: Was not.

Eric: …as I hoped it was. So, whatever. Okay.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, it was really hard to tell. I mean, we just saw a Weasley twin there freaking out.

Matt: I thought you guys noticed he didn’t have an ear.


Muggle Mail: Radio Announcement, Attendance at Hogwarts


Andrew: Oh, that was not there. Micah, you want to read the next e-mail from Chaelin? “Chai-lin”? “Kaylin”?

Micah: “Kaylin”?

Andrew: “Kaylin”?

Micah: Let’s go with “Kaylin”, 15, of Maryland and he or she [laughs] says:

“Just listened to the DVD commentary. Loved it. Made me laugh. Anyway, when you were talking about the ‘Lightning has struck,’ the boy says ‘River,’ who is Lee. Lee never returns and also, wouldn’t they say in this ‘Royal’ or even ‘Romulus?’ Just my thoughts.”

Okay. I guess that’s referring to when – who goes over to the radio to announce that Harry is back?

Matt: That guy.

Andrew: We don’t know, do we? I mean…

Eric: Lightning has struck?

Micah: Is it just a random person?

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, maybe in the book this person is named, but I’m not sure.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: All right. But other part of this person’s e-mail talks about something that a lot of people wrote in about:

“Also, you were talking about how you wouldn’t want to send your kids to Hogwarts, especially the first years, but in ‘Deathly Hallows’ it says that all students have to go to Hogwarts. It’s a law that the Ministry, under Voldemort’s control, made. Thought you should know that.”

Eric: So, that answers that question. Also one of my mistakes.

Matt: He says, “River?” I thought he said, “Repeat?” Because, “Lightning has struck! Repeat, lightning has struck!”

Eric: Repeat, lightning has struck? Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, that would make more sense. [laughs]

Matt: River?

Andrew: [laughs] Eric, next e-mail?


Muggle Mail: Knowledge of Horcruxes


Eric: This one comes from Ryan, aged 21, the U.K.:

“Hey guys, just a small comment. Although Voldemort feeling when a Horcrux is destroyed works well in the final film, he presumably didn’t feel anything when the ring was destroyed in ‘Half-Blood Prince’, or he would have known then that they were hunting Horcruxes and made sure the other ones were safe.”

That’s a good one. That’s actually a good point. They’re thinking only as far as the current film goes because Voldemort would have known what they were up to far sooner than he does in the movie or in the books. Good point.

Matt: Well, do you think that maybe just Voldemort knew that Dumbledore was doing it but he didn’t know that Harry knew?

Eric: Well, no. I mean, I think even in Book 7 – when Voldemort finds out, it’s like the ground falling out from under him and he only finds out – what is it? Because he comes across? Or he just goes to check on one of his old Horcruxes and it’s not there or something? So, he has that flip-out moment and then immediately flies to Hogwarts. So…

Matt: Well, it seems obvious that the more Horcruxes are destroyed, the more he feels it. Maybe early on, he just didn’t feel it as much?

Eric: Well yeah, he doesn’t feel it at all in the books because he’s not supposed to be…

Matt: Right.

Eric: …close to…

Matt: And you don’t even see Voldemort being affected when the necklace gets destroyed either.

Eric: Right. He is super surprised that anybody found out his secret and that’s the real thing of it all, is that – yeah, if it had happened – if the movies were consistent and he felt the destruction of the other Horcruxes like the ring, then he would have found out quite a bit sooner and they wouldn’t have the chance to defeat him.

Matt: Mhm. Yeah, because he doesn’t even find out until after they leave Gringotts.


Muggle Mail: Lily’s Eye Color


Andrew: Verah, 22, of Toronto, Ontario in Canada, says:

“Hey guys, I loved the ‘Deathly Hallows: Part 2’ commentary. I had a fresh take to the DVD since it didn’t have its own commentary. The only thing that I wanted to say was the fact that you guys were discrediting Geraldine Somerville. I know there were a lot of issues with the fact that Lily Evans as a little girl didn’t have blue eyes, but if you look at a picture of Geraldine, she has very blue eyes which are very similar in color to Daniel Radcliffe’s eyes. I think the fact that young Lily’s eyes were brown was because the casting directors were focusing mainly on getting a very cute red-headed girl to play Lily and forgot to take into account Lily’s eyes color matching Harry’s. They did focus on it when casting Geraldine and I just wanted to make that clear.”

Matt: Well, it’s…

Andrew: I mean…

Matt: …exactly the fact.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, I completely agree with that as well.

Matt: It’s exactly what they did. It’s not that it’s a good idea. I feel like the eyes probably could have been a focal point when they were casting.

Eric: But we got a few other e-mails about eye color can change when you grow up, so…

Andrew: Yeah, that’s grasping for straws. [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] But we did.

Matt: From brown to blue…

Eric: We did though.

Matt: …that’s a pretty dramatic change.

Eric: We did. We did get those e-mails.


Muggle Mail: Snape’s Escape


Andrew: Alex, 15, of Concord, finally, writes:

“Hey MuggleCast, I’m a long time listener, first time commenter.”

You guys can do first time, long time. That’s a short abbreviation for that kind of thing.

“During Episode 244, I was watching the movie along with your commentary and saw something that surprised me. When Harry shows himself to Snape in the Great Hall and McGonagall starts to duel him, it is Snape, not McGonagall, that knocks out the Carrows. If you watch closely, Snape counters McGonagall’s spell, waves his wand behind his head, and that knocks out the Carrows!”

Well, that’s…

Matt: Yeah, I noticed that the last time I saw it. One of my friends told me about it and it’s true, he actually takes out the Carrows himself while he’s dueling McGonagall.

Eric: Does it appear to be…

Matt: It’s awesome.

Eric: …a conscious decision of his?

Matt: It’s – well, once you see it, it is obvious that it is a conscious thing because he wants to duel them out so he doesn’t leave the Carrows to hurt anyone before he leaves.

Andrew: Oh, that could be true.

Matt: It’s awesome.

Andrew: Cool.

Micah: Yeah, that is pretty cool. I was going to say on the other e-mail, and I don’t know if there is confusion, the one just before. Geraldine Somerville plays the older Lily Potter, not the younger one.

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: Right?

Matt: Yeah, Geraldine plays his mom.

Eric: Yeah, so that’s what the e-mail…

Micah: It’s Ellie Darcey-Alden that plays young Lily Potter, so I just want to make sure – because the way that Verah phrased it in this, sounds like she’s talking about the younger one.

Eric: No, the…

Andrew: And…

Eric: When they cast the first film, when they cast Harry’s mother, they did make sure that – they paid more attention to the eyes. But when they cast the young Lily Potter in this film, they did not.


Show Close


Andrew: Okay, so a couple of short related announcements before we wrap up. First, a transcript update, Micah.

Micah: Yeah, I know we’ve been not as up-to-date [laughs] as we’d like to be but the two most recent episodes, 243 and 244, which includes Eric’s interviews with Arthur Parsons as well as some interviews from the Quidditch World Cup, and the more recent one being our DVD commentary, they will be available shortly – and shortly, I mean by the end of the weekend here.

Andrew: Cool.

Micah: And we’re just going to work on getting all the others that we’re missing in between up as soon as we possibly can, so…

Andrew: Very good.

Micah: I don’t know why you’d want to read along [laughs] while you watch the movie. It might be a little bit more difficult…

Andrew: Oh, don’t transcribe that one.

Micah: …to do that and listen.

Andrew: Are you going to transcribe that one?

Micah: No, they’ve already done it.

Eric: Oh wow!

Micah: It’s already been done.

Andrew: Oh my goodness!

Micah: Yeah, so…

Andrew: Well, that’s great! Cool.

Micah: Thank you, though.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: I know we always – we don’t always get a chance to thank everybody…

Andrew: Yeah, thanks to…

Micah: …that does work so hard.

Andrew: Yeah, it really is a great resource for fans who are maybe hearing impaired or just want to – prefer to read the transcripts.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: And a little tease for what’s coming up in December, we will have a standard show. We’ll talk about news, maybe Chapter-by-Chapter, very fun segments. We haven’t really planned it out yet. And then our year-in-review episode with the third annual – or fourth annual, I don’t know which it is – MuggleCasties! [laughs] And that’s fun. In that, we give you a variety of categories to vote in, all Harry Potter related and you tell us which one you think is the best of the year.

Matt: Oh, it’s that time again, isn’t it?

Andrew: It is.

Eric: I wonder who’s going up for the J.K. Rowling Award this year.

Andrew: Yes…

Matt: Hmm.

Andrew: …I wonder.

Matt: There’s some competitors.

Eric: There might be.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Maybe Lev Grossman will get it.

Andrew: Okay. And final reminder, you can visit MuggleCast.com for all the information you need about the show. Don’t forget to subscribe and review us on iTunes. You can also follow us on Twitter which is Twitter.com/MuggleCast, like us on Facebook which is Facebook.com/MuggleCast, and follow the fan Tumblr which has recently had many contributions from Eric…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …at MuggleCast.Tumblr.com. I’m on to you, Eric!

Eric: I just – what it was – I was going through old hard drives and I found the original T-shirt image and – yeah, they have a “Submit” button on the MuggleCast [unintelligible] so I thought I’d…

Andrew: Yeah, it’s fine.

Eric: …participate.

Andrew: It’s all good.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: It’s all good. Lots of good stuff on there. And thanks to Allie and Angel for running that. It’s – people love Tumblr – will enjoy the fan Tumblr if you listen to MuggleCast.

[Show music begins]

Micah: And shameless self-promotion, if you want to read my full review on LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7, it’s up on MuggleNet.com and we’ll put a link to it in the show notes.

Andrew: Of course. “Always,” in the words of Snape.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Thanks everyone for listening! From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: From MSNBC.com, I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Matt: From TMZ, I’m Matt Britton.

Andrew: And we’ll see everybody next time for Episode 246! Goodbye!

Eric: Bye!

Micah: Bye!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #244

MuggleCast 244 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because we don’t stop talking for two straight hours, this is MuggleCast Episode 244 for November 20th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Micah: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast’s big Deathly Hallows: Part 2 DVD commentary! We’ve never done a Harry Potter commentary before, so this is exciting. Eric, Micah and I are here, and how this works is you get to watch the movie along with us. And to start out, we have to sync up the film so everybody is watching the same exact thing, the same exact frames. So, the way we’re going to do that is ask you guys listening at home, put in your DVD – and it has to be the DVD version, by the way, it can’t be Blu-ray – and hit “Play” to start the movie. And once you see the water, the very first frame – once you see the water, press “Pause” and then we’ll tell you in a moment on “three” to press “Play”, okay?

Micah: Before we start the commentary, we’d like to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, and featuring audio versions of many New York Times bestsellers. For listeners of MuggleCast, Audible is offering a free audiobook so you can try out their amazing service. One audiobook to consider is A Game of Thrones, the first book in A Song of Ice and Fire series by author George R. R. Martin. In a land where summers can last decades and winters a lifetime, trouble is brewing. As the cold returns, sinister forces are massing beyond the protective Wall. To the south, the king’s powers are failing, with his most trusted advisor mysteriously dead and enemies emerging from the throne’s shadow. In this land of extremes, plots and counterplots, soldiers and sorcerers, each side fights to win the deadliest of conflicts: the game of thrones. Recently adapted into a television series by HBO, immerse yourself into the world of Westeros before Season 2 hits screens this March. So, why not get it for free and listen to it just like you do MuggleCast? To do so, or to grab any book of your choice, visit AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. We thank Audible for supporting the show.

Andrew: So, on “three” – we’re assuming now you have it paused to the very first second that you see the water.

Eric: Paused to have it – yeah, very first second.

Andrew: Right. And then on “three” in a moment, press “Play”. So, one, two, three. Okay, everybody should be beginning now, yes?

Micah: Yes, very eerie music.

Andrew: Yeah. I need to put my headphones in, I just realized I haven’t done that. Oh, there’s the Jenga puzzle.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And what we’ll be doing this whole time is just talking about the movie while it’s playing. Hopefully we have things to say about it or else [laughs] this is going to be a funny commentary.

Micah: Yeah, we’ve got to remember…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …not to watch the movie and – just watch the movie.

Eric: Yeah.


Opening Montage


Andrew: So, everybody should be seeing the W.B. logo now, yes?

Micah: Yes.

Eric: Yes. So, let’s talk about this. This W.B. logo, kind of the unexpected character in all of these films. It always looks different, right? It grows with age.

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: I think in Half-Blood Prince, it was rusty. What is it this time?

Andrew: Well, it looks pretty put-together but it’s definitely very dark. It’s – I remember in the first film, I believe it was a bright W.B. logo.

Eric: Yeah. I think the second film, it was up in the sky. I think that was when they really started playing with it. It was above Little Whinging.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And right now…

Andrew: This music…

Micah: Yeah, you’re hearing what David Yates spoke about in our interview, that woman that they flew in all the way from Japan.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And it’s just beautiful, I love it so much. And that shot of Snape is so iconic. And didn’t he say just the other day that they were thinking of getting rid – or in the original script, they didn’t have Snape but then Yates insisted on it, I think.

Eric: Yeah, because he wanted to set Snape up as sort of one of the main characters of this act.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But the other thing is if they didn’t open at Hogwarts – [laughs] the good thing about them opening at Hogwarts is that Harry Potter Part 1 – Deathly Hallows: Part 1 – doesn’t have any Hogwarts, so people have just gone – to doing a marathon, they have gone two and a half hours without Hogwarts. It’s so funny that they had to fit Hogwarts in the first few frames [laughs] of the second film because it’s just, like, “Ahhh, there it is…”

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …you know? You just feel so – like you’re watching a Potter film again. So…

Andrew: And it was very clear that now Snape is in charge, so it was a good reminder as well.


Shell Cottage


Micah: So, now we’re at Shell Cottage. We just got a shot of Harry looking into the mirror, seeing Aberforth.

Andrew: Whenever I look back at this scene – whenever I watch this scene now, I think of all those paparazzi photos that came out of that when they were shooting…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …this exterior, and Bellatrix…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …was there and…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …Griphook.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Luna.

Andrew: I remember Evanna – I think at LeakyCon she was, like, “I have the first line of the film!” [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Which was funny.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Also, it’s good to see Bill and Fleur.

Andrew: I love how their house has no – the ceiling is clear, you can see right through it. It’s just windows.

Eric: They have no privacy? [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, at least that part of it.

[Prolonged silence]


Talk with Griphook


Eric: Harry is not in a good mood.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: Griphook looks like he is meditating a little bit here.

Andrew: I think he is, right? I mean, what the hell else…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …could he be doing?

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Sleeping.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah.

Andrew: Is that how they sleep? Like that?

Micah: Warwick Davis just passed out…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …mid-scene.

Eric: Yeah. They poked him beneath the camera and…

Andrew: Oh no…

Eric: …he sprang to life.

Andrew: …what’s my line again? Crap.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: It’s – the interesting thing is that he’s still got his wound from Part 1. It’s just being consistent where Bellatrix slashed him with her dagger on his cheek.

Micah: I like the fact that they kept this line in, “You buried the elf?” because it showed kind of Harry’s personality and they tried to make that apparent that the goblin in the books was very surprised by the fact that he showed that kind of treatment towards a creature.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, because Griphook is all about the humans subjugating lower wizards and by all about him – I mean, all against – it’s one of the reasons that – maybe it’s the only reason that Griphook even helps Harry, which is very important. That line that they added, “It’s complicated,” what do you think about that? It kind of – I like that it sums it up really – it gets it accomplished.

Andrew: I got to be honest, I found this whole scene to feel very scripted.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I don’t know. Just the way they’re trading off lines and – “It’s complicated,” thing, I know that usually got in a laugh with the audiences. I don’t know.

Micah: But…

Andrew: I wasn’t…

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: …too big of a fan.

Eric: …I know what you mean because – I mean, doesn’t this sequence – it takes weeks in the book? Hallows and Horcruxes, and Griphook and Ollivander, and figuring this all out. But it’s very clear they’re at the beginning of the movie now because, like you said, things are very snappy.

Andrew: Mhm.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Definitely Warwick Davis – the makeup here and there are few special features not on the DVD but – that you can find about those prosthetics and stuff, and it’s just amazing.

Andrew: He loves…

Eric: Amazing process.

Andrew: …talking about it.

Eric: Yeah. Well, he has sit under it for four hours…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …like second skin.

Andrew: Yeah, I guess you may as well make it worthwhile.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Tries to tempt him with gold.

Andrew: Did Harry really think that was going to work? Was that in the book?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I’ll give you money.

Micah: He works at a bank, he can get gold whenever he wants.

Andrew: Right, yeah.

Eric: Right?

Micah: Even if it’s not his. I’ll borrow from this vault today.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Another vault the next.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: They’ll never know.

Eric: Is that what you think they do? [laughs]

Micah: Well, they’re not herding for money, I don’t think.

Eric: No, that’s true.

[Prolonged silence]


Talk with Ollivander


Andrew: This is a – this scene is purely for the audience to understand what’s going on, where the three are sitting there in the stairwell to – some little exposition for the viewers.

Eric: Yeah. And this is just interesting, Fleur is almost – I don’t know. I didn’t really get this. She’s upset that they’re being so pushy or something. She’s just, like, “He’s weak.”

Micah: He’s an…

Eric: “You shouldn’t…”

Micah: …old man though.

Andrew: Yeah, he looks…

Eric: Well – he is. Should they have – let’s talk about that. Should they have made him more spritely like he was in the first film? Or is he too old? Did they overdo it…

Andrew: No…

Eric: …for Ollivander?

Andrew: …I think – he’s stressed, he had to face Voldemort, I think he’s just weak. It’s kind of reflective of the film. You know how we were saying [laughs] the W.B. logo, it’s like that where he’s been through a lot in the past seven years.

Eric: Yeah, that’s true. It has been all seven years since we’ve seen him, so…

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, even the actor – I assume he’s still a healthy man, but…

Eric: That’s what it brings into question though and just, like, “Oh my God, poor Ollivander!” But yeah, the other interesting thing here – and it’s coming up when Harry says, “You’re lying,” about the Deathly Hallows. That’s just – that moment, [laughs] it’s…

Micah: Well, I thought this was a really crucial moment that people can miss if they weren’t necessarily paying attention where they’re talking about allegiance of Draco Malfoy’s wand and how it’s sort of…

Eric: Oh.

Micah: …changed over to Harry now.

Eric: Here I was not paying attention to that. [laughs] Yeah, it is important and – well, I mean, it’s important in the way that – honestly, you get the explanation at the end of the film so it’s not really that important. But it’s important for them to have put this in because it just shows again that they’re following the books.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: [imitating Ollivander] “Those of us that have studied wandlore…”

Andrew: I was wondering – like with Griphook, I was wondering what Ollivander was doing before Harry walked in because Ollivander was just chilling there in the chair.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Was he counting the shells on his…

Micah: Well, Fleur was in the room too.

Andrew: Oh, right.

Micah: I don’t know.

Andrew: Ooh.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: A little TLC.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Whoa, whoa.

Micah: He is the wand-master.

Eric: Playing with the Veela, okay.

Andrew: All right, Micah.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Calm down.

Micah: All right, I’m done with the jokes for right now.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: More later.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, more later.

Andrew: More to come…

Eric: So…

Andrew: …in the second hour.

Eric: God, if we still did the caption contest, this would be a caption about the starfish on the left talking to the seashell. He’ll be, like, “Hey! I got to be in this scene. Yeah! My family is so proud of me. How about you, seashell?” He’ll be, like, “You may not know this, but I was actually at the hut on the rock in Sorcerer’s Stone. So proud to be back.” Yeah, but just Dan’s acting – seeing how Dan’s acting has improved. He’s accusatory but he’s also sympathetic at the same time towards Ollivander. And Ollivander just says flat out, “He tortured me. Yeah, what are you going to do?” But the inner – [laughs] the inner jerk [laughs] is about to come out when Harry leaves, obviously, but just right now it’s so real. I was so glad that they got the Ollivander back because I think David Yates talked about that at some point too, about not getting John Hurt back. They said they really wanted to get the first actor to show – because it almost doesn’t work otherwise. Because you can get an old man, you can get a Hagrid-looking man, but unless it’s the original guy who looks so different…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …you can’t – it’s not going to – it can’t resonate as well.

Andrew: Well, and it’s also kind of like the – it’s a testament to how epic these films are. And we’ve touched on it before how – they’ve really been able to keep every actor, they haven’t had to replace anybody. Of course, Richard Harris unfortunately because of this death and then, of course, Jamie Waylett because of his drug problems, he played Crabbe.

Eric: Drug and bomb problems.

Andrew: But other than that, nobody had to be replaced, nobody pulled out of the film saying, “Oh, I don’t want to do this anymore.” It just shows how much the actors and actresses truly cared about this series and wanted to see it through.

Micah: Yep. And this was actually…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: What we’re watching right now on the beach, there was a deleted scene or two that helped explain things a little bit more to the audience. And what did you guys think? Would they have made more sense being in here?

Andrew: What was the scene? With the two-way mirror, I think? A little more…

Eric: So – yeah, first it was – actually there were – yeah, three mini-scenes because it was Bill Weasley and Fleur, Fleur gives Hermione the black clothing – just a black robe or black underwear that she has hidden away, gives it to Hermione to dress up as Bellatrix. Bill cautions Harry about doing a deal with a goblin. He says to Harry, “You got to really be careful how you worded it.” And then the next scene is Harry at Dobby’s grave, he’s looking into the mirror. Ron comes up, I think – or no, first it’s Luna, he just talks with Luna. Luna is kind of on her way back to school. Great line by Evanna Lynch, she says – or he says, “You know it won’t be the same that it was since you left?” and he’s referring to Hogwarts, and she says, “Neither will I.”

Andrew: I think it would have slowed it down a little bit.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I mean – you know, “The pacing, the pacing.” [laughs]

Eric: Well…


Gringotts Break-in


Micah: And that quick scene we just saw right there, Warwick Davis actually talked to you, Eric, about being able to go under the Invisibility Cloak and how cool…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …that was for him to…

Eric: He was happy because Griphook is a character, finally, that matters to the plot. And I think he said too, he’s enjoyed playing Professor Flitwick, he’s enjoyed playing other side characters, the choir director in the third film who was not Professor Flitwick at the time, they later molded the two characters. But characters who ultimately have no bearing on the main characters…

Micah: Right.

Eric: …and sort of the plot as it were, so I think it was rewarding for Warwick Davis, he said, to be in a kind of situation where you’re affecting the plot and also to ride under the Invisibility Cloak as you said…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: …because [laughs] it’s a status symbol of sorts.

Micah: And this whole scene right here, they basically reconstructed Gringotts from the first film. And I think if you have a chance to watch the feature “The Goblins of Gringotts”, it really explains a lot about how they went about casting for this particular scene and all of the goblins that you do see in this particular shot, as well as when you spoke to David Yates he also mentioned how much work went into recreating the set.

Eric: Yeah, it’s one of the classic stories of how so much work goes into about four seconds on film. This seems a little bit longer than that, but just the idea – they actually had I think it’s forty-five sets of prosthetics, sixty actors total in this sequence. But about this scene and how it relates to the book, this is obviously very, very different in the book. In the book, doesn’t she present her wand? Because she has Bellatrix’s wand on hand.

Micah: Right, but – she does now because the scene we just saw with Ollivander, he checks and he says that it’s Bellatrix’s wand.

Eric: Yeah, but she doesn’t present it here and I think – isn’t the reason that – they know that the real Bellatrix has said that, “My wand has been stolen,” so if somebody does present the wand then they’ll know she’s an impostor.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Is that how that works?

Micah: I’m pretty sure…

Eric: Okay.

Micah: …you’re right. Now this is just…

Eric: Yeah, something like that. But…

Micah: …an awesome scene and it would make a really cool ride. Andrew, I know you’re pushing hard for this one.

Andrew: This is the ride right here! No, seriously. I mean, this is really what it’s going to be.

Eric: Yeah. They would have to dig for it though. It would just take…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: I mean, they’re halfway there with that Poseidon’s Journey ride. I mean…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …all it practically needs is a new coat of paint.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I mean, just kidding. They would have to actually knock out the building and everything, but…

Eric: You’re actually right though. They have – that’s like a cave, isn’t it?

Andrew: Yeah. And imagine the ending of the ride where you’re being chased by the dragon out of the cave, out of Gringotts. It’d be so cool.

Eric: I’m sold.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I’m sold.

Andrew: You go through…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …the water. I mean, it would be a perfect interactive ride!

[Eric laughs]

Micah: You could drop right here.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, you fall.

Eric: [laughs] All your enchantments…

Andrew: You put your bag…

Eric: …are washed away, yeah. That should be how you get off the ride though. They just – the seats tilt forward.

Andrew: It would be cool if you had clankers, you pulled them out of some area of your seat and you had to shake them at the dragon. And then…

Eric: You need to get the dragon…

Andrew: …if you didn’t, it would burst fake fire on you or something.

[Eric laughs]

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: “Oh no, you look like you again.” Well, that was fun while it lasted.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Facial hair.

Andrew: I liked you better the other way.

Eric: The Final Frontier.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: [imitating the goblin] “What are you lot doing down here?” [laughs] [normal voice] It’s funny because The Thief’s Downfall or whatever washes away enchantments but you can just go and shoot another spell, and start enchanting yourself again as soon as you land…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …because obviously they Imperio him right away again.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Oh no! Griphook!


Gringotts Dragon


Micah: So, were you guys really looking forward to seeing the dragon in this film?

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, we weren’t surprised by it because we saw it beforehand but…

Micah: Now this would be…

Eric: Going back on the…

Micah: …one of the scenes though aside from the battle that would probably be showcased in terms of special effects, right? For, let’s say, the Oscars.

Eric: Yeah, David Yates drew attention to that too. He ranked it – well, the Gringotts – the upcoming scene inside the vault, even on the DVD, or the Blu-Ray I should say, in the documentary, they talk about how that was the most – or its “Maximum Movie Mode” where they say that was the most difficult scene in the entire film to actually pull off. They had the most meetings about the vault scene. But regarding the dragon, David Yates had said too that there was a whole team devoted to it, and I think also in “Maximum Movie Mode” you see there’s a particular moment where the dragon, when it finally escapes, has this breath of fresh air. And that realism, the idea that they – oh, it just really sold it for the audience.

Andrew: Yeah, we talked about that on 242 as well.

Eric: I remember too, the dragon – just going back through MuggleCast history, when we first saw it on the book cover…

Andrew: Yeah, the deluxe edition I think it was.

Eric: The deluxe edition book cover and we knew – we didn’t even know that there would be a dragon in the book, right? That was the first kind of…

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: …”Oh, there’s a dragon in this book!”

Andrew: And then I remember somebody started looking it up, it may have been you, Eric. You may have been looking at dragons in the wizarding world.

Eric: Yeah, we wanted to identify it because – and I thought I settled on the Antipodean Opaleye. It’s an Australian dragon with obviously glazed-over eyes and we thought it was that because – I mean, it kind of matched the description in Fantastic Beasts and we know that J.K. Rowling wrote Fantastic Beasts with the rest of the series in mind, that there are characters, creatures that we meet later that were written in that book before the books were written. But however, what it ended up being, of course, was this Gringotts dragon which has glazed-over eyes but only because he spent his whole life underground, so it’s not an Antipodean Opaleye, it’s – who knows what kind of dragon it is.

Micah: Yeah, I think it was Episode 99 we spent – you, Laura and myself – probably over an hour analyzing that whole deluxe cover edition. I think it was one of the better episodes, it might actually be on the Wall of Fame. Or if it wasn’t 99, it was very close.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: I know 99 is on the Wall of Fame.

Eric: I think we should also talk for a second here because this is – [laughs] again…

Andrew: A book change.

Eric: …this is the scene that had – this is – well, it’s a book change. They don’t remain trapped in the vault and I don’t understand why Griphook betrays them here because that line is changed too. I…

Andrew: It’s a little twist, I think. It’s typical filmmaking. “Oh, they trusted – ” because remember Harry said just a few minutes – “Just get us into the vault. We’re trusting you, Griphook.”

Micah: Well, that’s where the key scene between Bill and Harry would have worked because the viewers would have been able to recognize, oh, Bill warned him about making sure you were very clear with the deal that you structured with Griphook in terms of, “Oh, I’ll get you into the vault but there’s no guarantee I’m going to get you out.”

Eric: I also think – and it’s unfortunate to me, this goblin here for about five seconds. But then I also think it’s setting it up because later we have to see Griphook dead, so maybe it just helps the audience not be very sympathetic about that. Because in the next scene – I mean, look at how – look at what being greedy, getting Godric Gryffindor’s sword really did for you, Griphook. Voldemort killed you all the same.


Dragon Flight


Micah: Yeah, in this scene – I thought we got a couple of e-mails about how people were disappointed because it was actually Ron’s plan to get on the dragon and they…

Eric: Right.

Micah: …made it Hermione’s in the movie…

Eric: It was…

Micah: …so it kind of – making Ron appear not as…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …intellectual, I guess, as he comes across eventually in the last book.

Eric: Yeah, that’s exactly what the e-mails said and I remember that, and I just laughed.

Micah: And this is just…

Eric: I mean, not that it’s…

Micah: …awesome…

Eric: Oh God.

Micah: …from a special effects standpoint, watching the dragon climb out here. Jurassic Park, here we come.

[Andrew and Eric laugh, Eric makes trumpet noises]

Micah: Well, remember when the T-rex shows up and…

Eric: Yeah!

Micah: …you get…

Eric: And it’s…

Micah: …those tremors? It’s kind of like that.

Andrew: It’s exactly like that, yeah. It may…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …almost kind of be a reference to that.

Eric: I expected like a glass of water…

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: …but of course, the goblins don’t drink.

Andrew: Watching this during the test screening was not fun because it was very much not complete, so it was just bad. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, I loved that though, with the subtitles…

Andrew: Yeah, but…

Eric: …you know?

Micah: And here you go, here is this breath of fresh air.

Andrew: Here is the breath, yeah.

Eric: Yeah, where is it? Where is it?

Micah: We’re about to get it.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: Right there.

Micah: Ahhh, a hard day’s work.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Look at that, look at that.

Andrew: It’s a nice break.

Eric: It’s just panting, it’s just like…

Andrew: I’m glad they did that.

Eric: I made it. I made it halfway.

Andrew: See, you wouldn’t have gotten that if they didn’t split it into two films. That was a precious…

Micah: Aww man…

Andrew: …precious couple of extra seconds.

Micah: …all those people’s houses!

Andrew: [laughs] I know!

Micah: I hope they have dragon insurance.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: No repercussions. It’s sort of like when – in Chamber of Secrets when Ron and Harry are flying with the Ford Anglia and all the Muggles can see it, and there’s really no repercussions.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Unless – did Snape say they had to wipe all the minds of all those people? Maybe, I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah. Well, speaking of dragon insurance, do you think they have to be notified that there is a dragon [laughs] in captivity nearby? All those shops? I mean, it’s Diagon Alley. I guess they probably figure, right? Dragon insurance, gosh.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Dragons are actually banned from the major populous – in the wizarding world, aren’t they? I mean, they’re kept – Charlie works with them, they’re kind of sheltered – or reservations for dragons. But on the whole, for obvious reasons, dragons are controlled, the population is very controlled by wizards. Oh man, this is – this reminded me of the locket strangling Harry in Part 1 because again he’s underwater and Voldemort has some kind of epiphany.

Micah: Well…

Andrew: I love this scene so much.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: The way they did the Horcrux, Voldemort’s P.O.’d scenes with Harry’s connection I just thought were so well done.

Micah: Yeah, and it gives you deeper insight into the one that’s at Hogwarts. But I like the change in the sense that Voldemort can feel when a Horcrux is being destroyed. I know that wasn’t the case in the book but I thought it worked really well for the movie.

Eric: It does work well in the film and I think even Harry’s little homing sensation, how he’s able to find the Horcrux essentially in the vault by hearing it, listening for the little [makes “psst” noises] – but at the same time then, it also helps sell the fact that the part where we’re eventually getting to where Harry is a Horcrux. And it’s one of those things that just – it was a choice that really worked, I think, for the film. It just really, really worked because it helped them – it helped the audience to kind of understand without a whole lot of explanation that Harry had an unusual connection with them.

Micah: I wonder how angry they were that they had to probably jump in some cold water just for this scene.

Eric: Actually, this is – this scene – they said in the “Maximum Movie Mode” this was filmed on one of the coldest days in one of the coldest seasons in the backlot of the studio, and that they actually did narrowly escape real hypothermia from filming this scene. And I think it was because of the way the camera is moving around and around and around. But yeah, they said that by far, of the two last films, this was probably the hardest shot to really do just because it was so cold. And they’re in England too, they’re not filming in Florida or Ecuador or South America like Breaking Dawn. But it’s just – you can imagine it’s so rough, they’re so cold. [laughs] Warwick Davis told a funny story here of Voldemort walking on this blood. Watching the film I’m just, like, “Oh my God.” Malfoy – Lucius Malfoy is so proper and look what Voldemort has done to his house with all this blood everywhere. But Warwick Davis told the story of how during filming, because there was so much blood on the hardwood floor, [laughs] Ralph Fiennes actually slipped once…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …and just completely fell over while filming that scene. But then David Yates has also said that they actually had to mop up a lot of that blood because it was too much for the ratings…

Andrew: [laughs] It was too much.

Eric: …they were going for, yeah.

Andrew: Too much blood!

Eric: You can always – the thing is though, you can always mop up some blood, right? Just get it all out there and then take it away later instead of trying to digitally put blood in that…


Arrival into Hogsmeade


Micah: You know they actually used the noise from Mandrakes for that alarm?

Andrew: Really?

Eric: Really?

Micah: No, I just…

Andrew: Look at all these…

Micah: …made that up.

Andrew: Oh.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Oh damn.

Andrew: Got excited.

Eric: Really though?

Micah: It sounded like it though.

Eric: Is it called – what is it, the Caterwauling Charm? Or no?

Andrew: That’s the annoying sound charm.

[Eric laughs]


The Hog’s Head


Andrew: Okay, not a big fan of this scene. I wasn’t really in the book either because they just suddenly trust Aberforth right here. I don’t know. It seems very odd. There’s a little hesitation but they’re still letting the trio in and it’s – I know they’re in a desperate situation, but it just seemed like kind of a bad move.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, I think that the bad guys though, they shoot first, ask questions later, so for anybody…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …to acknowledge them, just be, like, “Come here, Potter. I take that…”

Micah: But again, tying it back to the deleted scene where Harry explains a little bit more to Ron about what he’s seeing in the mirror saying he swears that he sees Dumbledore, would help with this scene, I think, a little bit.

Eric: Yeah, because Hermione – when they get down the steps, Hermione says, “Oh, did you see him? He looks just like…”

Andrew: Yeah, that’s true.

Eric: Hey, the back of Hermione’s head. They actually managed to do a sequel for [laughs] Hermione’s – the back of her head. Her hair was braided in the reflection.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: [imitating Aberforth] “You bloody fools.” [normal voice] He’s lecturing them.

Andrew: He looks so much like Michael Gambon. I was really impressed by that…

Eric: That’s the thing. He doesn’t…

Andrew: …because the real-life actor doesn’t look like him…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …at all.

Eric: No, he doesn’t.

Andrew: And they talk about that – I think there was a feature released on Harry Potter: The Quest, where Ciar·n Hinds talks about getting into that role and the amount of makeup, and how he was really impressed by how well they did, so…

Eric: Yeah, it’s also one of the focus points on the Blu-ray. There is basically, I think, three prosthetics he says. It’s – the forehead was the main thing but also the eyelids because Michael Gambon has the eyelids that are sort of heavier, very distinctive.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Very distinctive.

Micah: Is Harry not hungry?

Eric: Yeah, I don’t understand this.

Andrew: He’s just angry.

Eric: Harry is a Horcrux. Even – he can’t starve, he doesn’t get hungry.

Micah: I like the…

Andrew: Well, I think what it’s saying is he’s in the middle of a mission right now. He doesn’t want to stop to take a break.

Micah: I like…

Eric: Yeah, maybe.

Micah: …the sarcasm here by Aberforth. “Nice job?”

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: “Easy?”

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I like that line. I like that line a lot.

Micah: Now again, another deleted scene. I think it was the same dialogue but they were actually all at the table as opposed to…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …standing up.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, there is one line about Ariana, I think, that they added that was – it’s not in the final film but it’s – again, pacing. Still, I think most of the backstory does really – I feel like it comes through. I mean…

Andrew: Mmm.

Eric: …what’s important that Aberforth has a beef with Albus, you know?

Andrew: Yeah, and that’s definitely there but we know very little about Ariana.

Eric: Yeah. But I mean, even the books is vague about what exactly happened to Ariana. We just know that she was…

Andrew: Well – but we got that story. We got the story about the horsing around that was going on.

Eric: Yeah. And she was damaged, she was unable to control her power.

Andrew: Whenever I see – you can’t see it right now, but whenever I see the Butterbeer on the table there, you could see it at the beginning of this scene, I think of the Wizarding World park.

Eric: It’s true.

Andrew: I feel like it’s a subtle reference to the Wizarding World

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …because it looks exactly like it…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …except for the mugs.

Eric: Well, what was it? I think – to be honest, I think they said that they had used one of the – when we did the theme park preview before it opened, Stuart Craig and them – we were told that they used the actual – the theme park Hog’s Head – to design the Hog’s Head in the film because…

Andrew: Oh, good.

Eric: …obviously they designed the theme park before they had to shoot the last film, so there probably are some really close comparisons you could draw, even though we had been in the Hog’s Head a couple of times before…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: …in Movie 5.

Micah: I think you get good insight though into the relationship here when Aberforth says that Dumbledore – the other Dumbledore – sacrificed many things on his quest for power.

Eric: Yeah, it’s one of those lines that really, really covers all the basis there. We just – it’s a movie, we can’t get the final story so I was happy with that line.

Micah: Yeah, I think it just really summed it up for those people who are kind of looking for that backstory on Dumbledore to be in the movie. I think that kind of made it very clear what kind of a past he has had.

Eric: He’s got such a big portrait and such a little mirror next to it. Do you think he should just get a medium-sized portrait to have a little bit more space for a mirror? I mean, you got to groom yourself after all.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Never mind.

Andrew: What an analysis. Well, maybe he has a mirror somewhere else in the house. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, maybe. I don’t know.


Entering Hogwarts Castle


Micah: This scene always got the biggest cheers, I thought, at least when we saw the movie in Orlando when Neville showed up.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: In the book, it’s a cheer moment though. I mean, it’s the scene where you put the book down and start clapping…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …because really Neville is just [laughs] this badass figure all of a sudden and he’s – I think in the books there’s more of that too, where Neville just – in the movie he just talked about one of his cuts or something. In the book I think he goes quite on about that where he’s, like, “Oh yeah, I got this here for doing this misdeed and got this over there, lasted for weeks, but I got her good.” It’s just kind of really, really badass. “Let’s have a bit of fun, shall we?”

Andrew: I’ve said before, I’ve never really been a fan of Neville and this film is no different. I don’t know why and I think it’s almost the way that Jo wrote it. And I’m sorry, I know that upsets a lot of people but it’s just, like, get out of the way. Who are you? [laughs]

Eric: What?

Andrew: I don’t know. Maybe it’s Matt Lewis. Something – I just can’t get over it.

Eric: Now one thing I can’t get over is the use of the original music in this scene. I hate it. I absolutely hate it.

Andrew: Oh, but it’s like Harry has returned to Hogwarts just like his first time. It was just as exciting.

Eric: I understand why they picked it but the movie to me is completely different now. Everybody has grown up. There should have been – I mean, if you’re talking about Alexandre Desplat and his score, which the filmmakers especially David Yates have been completely all about. I really don’t think there’s a whole lot of score in this film and – because a lot of it is the action. I understand it’s just like an editor’s job. If you can’t see it, that means you’ve done a good job. But the fact that they’ve chosen that moment to do the original John Williams [imitates “Hedwig’s Theme”] is just really kind of – for me, it just – it was a chance for this film to be different and instead it was trying to be the same.

Andrew: Hmm. I mean, I was hoping – and I think we all were hoping – to see some references to earlier films in this final film, the whole full circle thing, nice little…

Eric: But…

Andrew: …references to past films. I think that was…

Eric: I’m cool with them playing the music, but it sounds like they were playing the exact same track. The difference…

Andrew: Yeah, I see what you mean.

Eric: If he were to re-record…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …that and do it with slightly different instruments maybe but also have it be the same theme, that would be one thing. Instead it really does just feel like it’s a scene from the second film.

Micah: But this was weird for me because Luna just all of a sudden is at Hogwarts when…

Eric: Is at Hogwarts.

Micah: …before she was at Shell Cottage and without that scene in there that’s part of the deleted features, it’s just…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: “Well, how did you get from Shell Cottage to…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: That’s true.

Micah: “…Hogwarts?”

Eric: Yeah. I mean, I think the other thing that confuses too is in a couple of minutes when we see the rest of the Order is also in the castle, it’s, like, where did they come from? But it’s…

Micah: Well, you have that moment just when we were watching that scene where they go on the radio and they say, “Lightning has struck!” That’s the alert to the Order to come to Hogwarts.

Eric: Yeah. I think George…

Andrew: Which is – I’m glad they included that because we don’t get any of that in…

Eric: The actor George Harris who plays Kingsley Shacklebolt mentioned in one of the press conferences in Orlando that he really wanted to – or he thought it would be cool to be on the Potterwatch because Kingsley is, I think, one of the head leaders of Potterwatch when they’re in the forest, isn’t he? I forgot what they call him.

Andrew: Not sure.

Eric: But yeah, essentially I think they were talking about some of the scenes that were really cool moments for their characters.

[Prolonged silence]


Confrontation in the Great Hall


Eric: Gosh, Alan Rickman.

Andrew: He’s not centered! [laughs]

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Under the…

Eric: Maybe in the…

Andrew: …Great Hall glass.

Eric: You’ve got to watch the fullscreen version if they still do the letterbox.

Andrew: I just think about the poor first-years who are here and have to go through this nonsense. They have no idea about Harry really or – they’re too young for this super dark stuff and Snape is yelling at these poor first-years.

Eric: Yeah. That’s the interesting thing is that…

Andrew: That’s not a film critic. It’s just like a…

Eric: No. Yeah, general mood critic as well.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Because I mean, why would you send your kids to Hogwarts if it’s the kind of situation where they’re teaching the Unforgivable Curses on the first-years? Not that there are a whole lot of other options for schooling your children in Britain, in wizard school. But I just think that this is very much a place you wouldn’t want to send anybody to. And we saw in previous films, previous books that parents were pulling their kids out of Hogwarts but that was due to something little like not trusting Dumbledore’s judgment. Here you have got full-blown Death Eaters running the school.

Micah: Well, what do you think it would have been like though, just talking about the cast to actually be in this scene and seeing Alan Rickman doing what he’s doing right now? You’d have to be pretty scared.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah. I mean, those kids probably weren’t even acting, they were just legit scared.

Eric: [laughs] In “Maximum Movie Mode” of this film, David Yates just – they’re focusing on this scene and David Yates is just going on and on about how Alan Rickman’s delivery is really, really, really, really, really cool.

Andrew: In the test screening, that deleted scene where you see Harry join all the students before entering the Great Hall, that was in the test screening and I liked it because you knew kind of what was coming, whereas in this final version it was a shock, which on one hand is good for moviegoers but I kind of like knowing that Harry was in that group prior…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …to Snape’s speech.

Eric: Yeah, he has a costume change too where they’re in the Room of Requirement and he’s wearing his regular clothes, and now he has a robe over them.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: I think there was a scene on the staircase where they gave him somebody else’s robes to wear.

Andrew: So, let’s talk about this duel. J.K. Rowling said that in the script it was going to be Snape versus Harry, and then she saw it and she was, like, “Uh-uh, woman power!”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We need to go with what’s in the book here and that’s Snape versus McGonagall. Even though Harry is kind of involved in the duel. If McGonagall suddenly fell, Harry would have whipped out his wand and…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …taken care of Snape, but I was glad…

Eric: Well, she said it was…

Andrew: …that it was…

Eric: She said it was an early draft of the script, but yeah.

Micah: And even in the book, right, it’s McGonagall, Slughorn and Flitwick, I think. I could be wrong there with one of them but it’s the three of them who duel with Snape, and Snape bursts out one of the windows and flies away like a bat.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: If I recall, they’re in a hallway though too. It’s not…

Micah: Yeah, they’re not in the Great Hall.

Eric: They’re not in the Great Hall, far more condensed, far more actors – or sorry, professors – going against Snape but same deal. This is – now, many people don’t like this, how Voldemort is essentially – as a character is introduced by the screaming of innocent young girls. It’s so eerie but I also thought that this was not really something that was ever addressed by anybody. I never asked Yates about this or we never see them talk about how scary this is. Why do you think they intro-ed that? Do you guys like that or not?

Micah: I do.

Eric: Where they have the children screaming?

Micah: Well, not necessarily the children screaming but I think you get that brief moment of triumph where Snape is gone, but then all of a sudden it turns back to dark right away.

Andrew: Yeah, I didn’t – the screaming scares me every time…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …because it’s so sudden and high-pitched, and not expected. But I liked it. I thought it was kind of unclear at first if it was just Harry who could hear it or everyone, but I guess the screams are supposed to indicate that everyone can sense it.

Eric: Do you think they’re screaming – is it a pain because…

Andrew: Yeah, I would say so.

Eric: Because he’s like in their head.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Or something like maybe the two people out of a hundred can’t handle telepathy.

Andrew: [laughs] Exactly. No, I think that’s right.

Micah: Here’s a bit of a comic relief.

Eric: [laughs] “Students out of bed!” David Bradley, I’ll tell you. At the Home Entertainment Celebration, he was such a genuine guy, such a generous kind of kind…

Micah: He’s pretty good at karaoke from what I’ve heard too.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, I just – [laughs] I’m so happy that he’s a part of this.

Micah: Now why does he call her “mom”? Is that a British thing?

Andrew: Yeah, I think that’s a British – like ma’am.

Eric: I think the – also, isn’t it – in one of the James Bond movies, they call M, Judi Dench, “mom”. It’s just – it’s respect, it’s like…

Andrew: It’s like ma’am!

Eric: It’s like saying ma’am. Well, it’s like saying “mom” too in a way, I thought. But also like ma’am.

Andrew: I – this may seem obscure but I’ve always wondered – I want to know what went into designing Harry’s battle wardrobe because he’s wearing the same thing for, like, an hour, so…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …I’ve always wondered, did they design it with flexibility in mind with…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: What made them decide Harry needs to wear corduroy, a sport jacket and then a T-shirt underneath? I know that sounds weird but…

Eric: That’s a lot of layers.

Andrew: …this is the most iconic scene probably in the franchise, this entire hour and – did heavy thinking go into designing his battlements wardrobe, you know? I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: That’s really interesting to me for some reason.

Eric: Heavy thinking – well, it’s a Harry Potter film so heavy thinking went into everything. But I’m completely with you here. I mean, I never really thought about it but we’re actually watching him wear three layers [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …for, like, an hour and a half. And he has to – obviously he had to shoot in that for months and months and months and months. Yeah, who knows, right? I mean, who is to say that – I mean, since when are stripes the symbol of leadership either, you know? I think Matt Lewis was talking about finally getting to wear stripes, you know? [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: And this is where Neville’s a BAMF. But…

MuggleCast 244 Transcript (continued)


Battle Preparations


Andrew: So, this scene with McGonagall on the front steps, I was there when they were filming it and I was so excited because it’s just McGonagall’s moment and seeing the statues come to life in a moment here is just so epic. I love the shot where the camera is on the ground, and you see the…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …statues just jump and land very firmly.

Eric: Now when you were watching them film it, could you hear what they were getting?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Or…

Andrew: Yeah, because it was McGonagall and Julie Walters and Warwick Davis. And yeah, you could hear what they were saying. That whole background behind them where the bridge is, that was all special effects later on and obviously [laughs] the statues were added later on. But…

Eric: That’s a shame.

Micah: It’s another thing that they could showcase for special effects.

Andrew: What, the statues?

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Interestingly, the giants – again “Maximum Movie Mode”. What do you want? I watched it.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: But they talk about the giants and how they were going to do them completely digital and settle to actually do some live capture for them. The special effects team, they are just so competent though, you know?

Micah: Yeah. And even right here. I mean, you look at them shooting out these spells to protect the school.

Andrew: Very cool with visual.

Eric: And all of it is digital, by the way. We’re not just talking about the bubble which is obviously digital. Hogwarts exteriors in this movie are all digital, completely all digital. It’s…

Andrew: Again, something else that was annoying to look at during the test screening [laughs] because it wasn’t done.

Eric: [laughs] We saw wire frames and grey, right?

Andrew: Yeah, and just – yeah, a bunch of nonsense.

Eric: Well, the captions helped. They really did, the subtitles.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Luna is about to lay the smack-down here.

Eric: This is probably my third favorite moment of the film. He’s just brushing her off, brushing her off, brushing her off. [poor imitation] “Harry Potter, you listen to me right now!” [laughs] He’s like, whoa.

Andrew: [laughs] I love the extras running around in the background.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We must act urgent!

Eric: [laughs] We got to get out of here!

Andrew: Like where – oh, never mind. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, I know. You’re right.

Andrew: It’s such mayhem. I always wonder, where are they running? [laughs] What are these people – where are they going in such a rush?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I mean, obviously they’re battling, but…

[Eric laughs]

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Regarding that costume, Warwick Davis said the only thing that is actually his is his own chin.

[Andrew laughs]

[Prolonged silence]


The Grey Lady


Eric: The reason I don’t think that that worked with, “There’s not a person alive who’s seen it.” Cho was not giving a riddle when she said that, so it’s this big reveal. “Oh yeah, we’ve got to talk to someone who’s dead.” But I thought it was played off as though Cho were riddling somebody when she said that to begin with. But no, she wasn’t, you know?

Micah: Yeah, and…

Eric: It’s one of those things.

Micah: Well, this also ties back to the scene that they showed when they dropped into the water, and you got a look at the Grey Lady and the Ravenclaw banner, and now you’re finally…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …coming face-to-face with her.

Andrew: Played by Kelly Macdonald.

Eric: Where else can I see her, Andrew?

Andrew: Boardwalk Empire.

Eric: No kidding.

Andrew: And in…

Micah: Probably on the Internet too.

Andrew: …Disney/Pixar’s 2012 film, Brave.

Eric: Brave. Well, can I…

Andrew: She has the lead – she voices the lead girl.

Eric: I was going to say…

Andrew: It’s their first original film. It’s going to be really good, I think. First original film in a few years. But yeah, she was great in this scene.

Eric: The – they really played the backstory of the Grey Lady really well, I thought. There is still a little bit more in the book than there is in the film. The interesting thing about this – okay, when she goes off and she’s sort of floating in mid-air there, and she goes over there, somebody said something and I don’t remember where it was, but they said the reason they did that where she goes off – she’s not really, really, really levitating. The idea is that there once was a bridge there at Hogwarts that perhaps when she was alive…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …there would have been a bridge where she just went. So, even though we see her going out through the window over this huge gap which is, like, why wouldn’t she fall? The idea is that there is some kind of temporal displacement going on, where she’s kind of at Hogwarts in her time. And it just furthers the idea that these two separate plains of existence, separate realities are coming together. So, I thought that was awesome when I heard that. I was, like, oh my God, you know?

Micah: And this is…

Eric: You never…

Micah: …really now the first look we get at Voldemort outside of the cut scenes that we saw in the water and then obviously the film opening with him in Dumbledore’s tomb.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Nick Moran, who plays Scabior, said that there were actually something like 3,500 actors for…

Andrew: Seriously?

Eric: [laughs] Yeah, for one of these sequences where they are running down the hill.

Micah: It’s the 4th of July!

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Cook some hot-dogs.

Micah: Did they…

Andrew: I wonder how they got so many – how Voldemort rounded up so many people.

Eric: Well, that was really the thing reading the books. Because in the books it’s a big deal that Voldemort is taking over because presumably his reign of terror is not restricted to England. But the tough thing is that these are books that are set in England. You almost can’t comprehend Voldemort taking over the whole world, right? Because again, he’s just one person and you think of the world being so amazingly big. So, in the film when you’re seeing these 3,500 people, it kind of I think helps sell it a little bit more because these people all turned out on one hillside to fight behind him.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: The Grey Lady – this scene is just so intense. I felt really unsure that the Grey Lady was going to give Harry the information.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Or at least give a hint. You can tell…

Eric: And when she screams at him, yeah. It just completely…

Micah: I Google Image’d Kelly Macdonald, by the way. I just saw a completely different side [laughs] of the Grey Lady.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh no.

Micah: Oh yeah.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Oh yeah.

Micah: Come on, I’m trying to add some humor in here. But I also – they left out the whole backstory really with the Bloody Baron and how that…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …tied into all this.

Eric: Well – I mean, the thing about the Bloody Baron, he had that sweeping – in the Harry Potter: Page to Screen the book, there are shots that they did of the actors in costume for what would later be green-screened in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone the film. Bloody Baron is seen for about five seconds sweeping, so it wouldn’t – because he hasn’t been in any of the subsequent films, they didn’t – and also the pending battle because right now students are getting ready to die. I can see why it was omitted.

[Prolonged silence]


More Battle Preparations


Eric: Also…

Andrew: Kingsley.

Eric: [in deep voice] Kingsley.

Andrew: These random attic…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …walking ways, walkways [laughs] though the castle.

Eric: Every castle should have one, right? I mean, there have got to be areas like this in every castle, don’t there?

Andrew: Yeah, I guess so.

Micah: I like this line here by Lupin.

Eric: Yeah. The quality of one’s convictions that determines the success of battle. Who said that? Me.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Fred and George.

Micah: The last time you’ll see Fred alive.

Andrew: Is this foreshadowing? “Are you okay, Freddie?” And, well…

Micah: I think so.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …he’s not going to be okay in, like, a half-hour. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, of course it is.

Micah: They didn’t really shoot that scene for Fred, did they? Or they just never included it in the final cut.

Eric: It’s unclear and – I’ll explain that in a minute. I do want to say that this is – I said Luna telling Harry off was my third favorite scene. This is – the second favorite scene is the opening of the Chamber of Secrets just because I was so happy. Remember in the book, it’s off-scene – or off-screen. You don’t read about them. They show up to Harry and they’re, like, oh, by the way, we went down to the Chamber of Secrets. Actually getting to see it on film is amazing.

Micah: I like this scene right here, watching the Quidditch pitch fall.

Eric: Why do they burn the Quidditch thing down, man? You just…

Andrew: It’s a riot.

Eric: Some man just… [laughs]

Micah: It’s a war.

Eric: Some man just wants to watch the world burn.

Andrew: It is war and it is another ending. I mean, we saw the Quidditch pitch in so many of the films in the beginning of the series, very bright and happy, and now at the end kind of blah.

Micah: Now, another deleted scene that isn’t in the films is when they are setting up all the explosives.

Andrew: Which I liked because that’s a good reminder of why this bridge [laughs] collapsed so easily after Neville just sent one spell.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: I like how…

Eric: Well, yeah…

Micah: …Scabior knew to stop but allowed everybody else to run forward.

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t – yeah. I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I don’t think that would have actually happened.

Eric: I think he’s a diva, he wants more spotlight. And the less people who are next to him, the better he looks. Well, I think the thing is too – again with special effects, sometimes they go by so quickly. When Neville – upcoming when the bridge does explode, you can see that Neville’s spell actually hits a fuse which actually is wired to something but it happens in, like, two seconds here or two split-seconds, so you don’t see it.


The Chamber of Secrets


Micah: I like how nobody cleaned up the basilisk skeleton. They just left it there.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah. I mean, if Slughorn…

Micah: For future use, you know?

Eric: …knew about this – well, if Slughorn knew about this chamber he would have pawned off all those fangs, so it’s kind of a…

Andrew: Well, why not leave it there? I mean, it’s kind of…

Micah: And we didn’t touch on it earlier, but the scene on the staircase where Hermione mentions that Ron had come up with the idea to use the basilisk fang on the cup.

Eric: Hmm, I missed that.

Andrew: Yeah, Hermione was spinning with Ron coming up with the idea.

Micah: It’s Hurricane Voldemort.

Andrew: [laughs] Which I remember there was, I think…

Micah: Or Typhoon Voldemort.

Andrew: Yeah, remember when there was a rumor or something? Like, oh my gosh, there’s going to be a typhoon Voldemort. Everyone was, like, oh my God, what are they doing in this film?

Eric: We saw it in the trailer, yeah. But…

Andrew: It doesn’t really look like him.

Eric: No. But it’s just the idea that Horcruxes are such…

Andrew: This…

Eric: …powerful pieces of magic that when one dies, you get this afterglow or this – just like in the forest scene where there is that huge monster and it fades away. Or they do it again in the Room of Requirement with the fire, how there is still…

Micah: Uh-oh.

Eric: …some kind of residual Voldemort. Man, he’s pissed.

Micah: Yeah, he’s not too happy. See, that’s why I thought the whole destruction of the Horcrux and him feeling it worked well in the films because you see his immediate reaction. Again, another…

Eric: And…

Micah: …deleted scene here where Tonks shows up, they cut that out.

Eric: Yeah, the other thing about Voldemort too and making what you were just talking about, Micah, is that you can see him almost – in the book, it said when there is – another Horcrux is destroyed, he is less and less human each time. You can see him react to one of his – part of his soul dying and how his next movement is that much more maniacal, that much more fierce and angry because he is less and less alive, but also less and less human.

Micah: Right.

Eric: It makes him more dangerous.

[Prolonged silence]


Voldemort’s Followers Invade Hogwarts


Eric: I want them to sell little pieces of shield that you can throw through the air.

Andrew: Like film cells? How they sell film cells?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And just the whole – Neville, we see Neville, he’s so strong and he’s such a fighter. And then all of a sudden, the barricade’s gone and he just runs for his life. And…

Micah: Well, if you had that many people [laughs] running after you, wouldn’t you run away?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Well – no, I know this but you should have thought about that when there’s 3,500 people there.

Eric: Is there a weight limit?

Andrew: You shouldn’t have been getting closer and being, like, “Ha!”

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: “What are you going to do now?”

Eric: Okay, so it’s slightly more drawn out but yeah, that’s the fuse.

Andrew: And here goes the bridge and classic moment coming up when – oh, did he fall? Did he fall to his death? And you see his hand and his wand, and…

Micah: Nobody is even trying to help him, by the way. They’re all just standing there…

Andrew: I know, everybody is just standing.

Micah: …watching him. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, that’s funny.

Eric: Yeah, they’re not, like, here, come on! They’re not sending spells. We might hit him but…

Andrew: They should of been, like, “Accio Neville!”

Eric: [laughs] A summoning spell for – yeah, it would have worked too.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: I know you’re not about this moment, Andrew, but I loved it. Because I think what sold it is how quickly he disappeared from the shot when the bridge collapsed and he just fell. It wasn’t – it’s almost like one second he’s gone. I just thought – if you can stage a falling, you can stage a recovery. It helps.


The Battle of Hogwarts


Micah: Now there are the giants you were talking about who are actually played by actors.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: I thought they were all CGI.

Eric: Well, they talk about – in one of the documentaries that are in this home video release, they talk about how Grawp was all CGI or motion capture in Order of the Phoenix – or no, sorry, Half-Blood Prince. No, it’s Order of the Phoenix. And so I think – it was the special effects team, they propositioned – or they basically went to, I think it was David Yates, and said, look, okay for the giants we know we could do it all digital but it will look more real if we actually do film some actors. And they did some tests and they showed…

Micah: Yeah, Kingsley.

Eric: I love this. Kingsley and Arthur Weasley battling here, amazing.

Andrew: And the giants, they are swinging Quidditch hoops, by the way.

Eric: Oh, no way!

Andrew: Yeah, we were debating that in the trailer. And I mean, if you watch it in the movie or the Blu-ray or even the DVD, I think it’s very clear. And they are half-broken but that’s what they are.

Eric: That’s crazy, I thought they were…

Micah: And here comes a part that a lot of people had an issue with too, finding…

Andrew: What’s the…

Micah: …Luna.

Andrew: …issue here? Finding who? Oh, Luna. [laughs] Oh, right. And…

Eric: Well, that…

Andrew: Which was described later as a summer fling.

Eric: Yeah, that’s upsetting but many people don’t catch it because it’s British too. He says, “I’m mad for her.”

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: “I have to find…”

Micah: I know I keep pointing out deleted scenes, but there was another one [laughs] that would have been in here with the Slytherins breaking out of the dungeon after Filch puts them there.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, the interesting thing is that where Malfoy Apparates is actually from that deleted scene…

Micah: Right.

Eric: …where Malfoy Apparates, grabs – so you think they’re just in a random part of the castle but they are actually – normally they would be in the dungeons if they had kept that scene.

Micah: Here comes another Ron intellectual moment.

Andrew: And then Hermione is, like, “Hahahahaha. You’re so amazing!”

Micah: Maybe she transferred some of the intelligence…

Eric: When she kissed him?

Micah: …to him down in the chamber.

Andrew: Via saliva.

Eric: Yeah. David Yates is, like, okay, from this moment forward, Ron can make intelligent decisions.

Micah: No, they’re just one person now.

Eric: [laughs] Ronmione.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: “Come on!”

[Prolonged silence]


Room of Requirement


Eric: In the – I asked Arthur Parsons to give me a demo of the Room of Requirement here. He said earlier in the game when they first arrive at Hogwarts, one of the side tasks is that you have to wake up sleeping students [laughs] because they have the hammocks.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: And now in this one it’s just – again in the documentaries, all the props that they got – I mean, they unloaded I think it’s something like seventy-two crates of props from all the previous films to construct this scene. And they went to auction houses and they went to places, and just got all this furniture that they have stacked here. It’s amazing. It’s just amazing.

Micah: Yeah, I think when you just look around, there’s the statue – the Hogwarts statue that you see on the ride, the Forbidden Journey ride as you’re walking through the queue.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Just saw some pixies.

Eric: I love the pixies.

Andrew: “Cornish pixies?” And you see the boar, I think…

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: …at some point. I don’t know if we missed it but…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: And also some chess pieces, I think, are in here.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And yeah, I thought it was a cool tribute, I think I said it on a previous show, to all the other movies that they have…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …this stuff in here.

Andrew: I agree.

Eric: Trying to look out and find that one thing that I haven’t seen before, and I’m sure there is hundreds of thousands but just this – Harry can hear the Horcrux. He can feel the Horcrux.

Micah: Yeah, I like that too in this movie because it kind of gave away for people to realize in the end that Harry was a Horcrux as well. I think you mentioned…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …that earlier, Eric.

Eric: Yeah, it helps sell it. But this prop, this diadem – and I got to admit, reading the book, what the heck is a diadem, right? I mean, that’s why there is that line in this movie. [imitating Cho] “It’s like a tiara!” [normal voice] But it just looks so…

Micah: What if you don’t know what a tiara is? Then you’re…

Eric: Well…

Micah: …really in trouble.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Then you’re…

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: I like that line, “It’s perverse,” right? It’s just like that – “It doesn’t quite understand me,” you know what I mean? It’s kind of like he’s got this – Draco is misunderstood.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: [imitating Goyle] “Come on, Draco. Don’t be a prat!” [normal voice] Goyle. Is that the Mirror of Erised behind him?

Andrew: Yeah, it looks like it.

Eric: The frame of the Mirror of Erised?

Andrew: I think I saw the mirror there.

Micah: Now what did you think of this? Ron running off, “That’s my girlfriend!”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, that was okay, but the way he was thrusting his wand forward – [laughs] ahh whatever, he’s in love. Give him a break.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: People…

Eric: There is a couch too. Somebody is on the couch, you might as well jump on it. Oh, I love that. The Doxy – I mean – no, the pixies were nesting in there. It’s just that element of realism where you believe that this could actually be a real world.

[Prolonged silence]

Micah: There you go, Andrew. There’s the boar.

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Now again, this is another scene that could be used to showcase the special effects.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah. They’re good. I feel like they put – again, that’s another Wizarding World reference to me because people see it in the movie and then go to the theater – or go to the Wizarding World and be, like, “Oh my gosh! I’ve seen that in the movie!” It’s just…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …exciting for the people.

Eric: Are you talking about the boar?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I think so too and I think it’s good that the…

Micah: Now is that Umbridge’s stuff that was on the table there?

Andrew: I don’t know.

Eric: Probably. Yeah, it looks – no, Trelawney’s because you see all the teacups.

Andrew: Oh yeah, it could be. And the Butterbeer too. You see the Butterbeer in the film and then you see it in the park. It’s, like, “Oh wow!”

Eric: Yeah, it’s good that they completed the theme park before they completed the films so that they could have those kinds of things…

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: …in the actual…

Micah: This is cool.

Eric: …major motion pictures.

Micah: That dog or whatever it is.

Eric: Yeah. Kind of a movie-ism where the Fiendfyre takes the form of different animals. But just the idea that it is a crazy wall of fire – my favorite special effects shot is where Goyle is trying to put out – he’s throwing his wand and the fire just keeps coming from it. It shows a real lack of control, lack of ability…

Micah: Now…

Eric: …to control the forces.

Micah: …was it Goyle who actually gets killed in the book or was it Crabbe? I can’t remember.

Andrew: Hmm.

Eric: It’s a good question. I knew the answer once, of course.

Micah: Should Google it.

Eric: I feel like – I’ll Google.

Andrew: Yes, it’s Crabbe who dies.

Eric: It’s Crabbe who dies?

Micah: So, that’s why they changed it.

Andrew: Changed – oh, yeah. Because Crabbe [laughs] no longer exists.

Eric: Hmm. “He became reckless and neglected the potency of his Dark Arts, releasing cursed flames to incinerate his opponents that he couldn’t control which led to his demise.” That’s from the Harry Potter Wiki.

Micah: [laughs] I like how he…

Andrew: Ron gives it that…

Micah: …pucks the diadem…

Eric: Pucks the… [laughs]

Micah: …into the fire.

Eric: Three Voldemort heads.

Andrew: And then the Voldemort heads. [laughs]

Eric: The cool thing – again behind the scenes, it was – one of the physical stunts that they had to do was chuck Harry and Ron out of the Room of Requirement because they’re on their brooms at the time and they had to throw them with – they basically launched them off of a platform, the doubles, [laughs] into the hallway when the doors close behind it.

Andrew: There has been a rumor lately that Nagini is the snake that Harry released in Sorcerer’s Stone. Do you guys think that’s true?

Eric: That was discredited from…

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: Now what is that? Poor Pius just got killed.

Andrew: He’s angry. Voldemort just wants…

Eric: He needs to…

Andrew: …another Horcrux.

Eric: He needs to try – I felt bad for Pius too, Micah. Don’t worry, we’ll have T-shirts and a blood-drive or something, but…

[Micah laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Voldemort is feeling so vulnerable. In fact, I remember people laughing at that sound he makes when he’s, like, “Uhhh.” Where he’s just kind of shocked and it’s that intake of breath. And I thought that that was tremendous acting from Ralph Fiennes because he needs to prove that he still has power, that he’s still capable of being evil. And that’s why the first thing he does is kill somebody again because he needs to prove to himself more than anybody else, but also to everybody else, that he can still do it.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s just angry. He’s just letting out some anger.

Eric: He needed to…

Micah: Now why wasn’t Nagini kept in the orb in this film?

Eric: Oh, like the protective orb?

Micah: Yep.

Eric: I mean, I feel like…

Andrew: It would have looked weird.

Eric: …she’s already such a special effect. It doesn’t…

Andrew: And she has to crawl along the ground. It would have been weird if she was just floating the whole time.

Eric: Well, I think it’s still really relieving when Nagini leaves his side because you do see her in all these scenes right next to Voldemort. So, they still sold the idea, the concept that she was very well-protected.

Micah: Now what’s with the lifting of the sleeve here? Is that to kind of show that he’s decaying or what?

Eric: I thought he was about to – because most – all the Death Eaters have the Dark Mark there.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: But obviously Voldemort doesn’t, so maybe it’s about him feeling his own mortality?

Micah: And he slaps Lucius.

Eric: Yeah. That line, man. “How can you live with yourself, Lucius?” and he just says, “I don’t know.”

Micah: I think even part of Voldemort is disgusted with Lucius.

Eric: Well, that’s the thing. It’s true. It’s exactly what you said. He is disgusted with Lucius. He – it’s almost like he blames Lucius for letting him – I don’t know. He’s just – Lucius never stands up for himself. This whole time he’s being bullied by Voldemort and I don’t think – there’s no respect. There’s just no respect from Voldemort to Lucius, and…


Heading to the Boathouse


Andrew: Right here, Quidditch pitch.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Sorry to interrupt, but…

Eric: Quidditch hoop. Unbelievable.

Andrew: The Quidditch hoop, yeah.

Eric: I always took it to be like a native object, like a native…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …weapon that maybe the giants would have constructed in giantland, you know?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: It turns out no, it’s just – you destroyed this. [laughs] It’s just totally a Quidditch hoop.

Andrew: This – I’m surprised Harry, Ron and Hermione get through this so – you know how we were talking about Ron dying? This should have been where Ron died.

Eric: Yeah, smoosh. Just kind of…

Andrew: They run through this battle, throwing spells around. I don’t know how they could possibly be sure who is on whose side, and…

Eric: I wonder if they had trolls in this final battle, how they would have made them look different than giants because the giants kind of look troll-esque.

Andrew: They wouldn’t be as big.

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, I was going to say.

Andrew: But I guess it would just be confusing.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Lavender Brown. Many…

Andrew: A little Twilight reference.

Eric: [laughs] Well, actually…

Andrew: It was a joke.

Eric: …Lavender dies in the book.

Andrew: No, I know, but it just made me think of Twilight because – sucking the blood.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: This scene, very cool. Aberforth has his moment.

Micah: Well, I remember in the trailer they cut it so it looked like Voldemort hit Fenrir Greyback…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …in that scene.

Eric: We were, like, what? Friendly fire, friendly fire.

Andrew: Yeah, you couldn’t tell in the trailer at all.

Eric: Kingsley has lost his hat. I just realized that. Kingsley’s hat is gone.


In the Boathouse


Micah: Now we’re going to go check out the home of the Hogwarts rowing team.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: What’s their – they need a Latin slogan. You’ve got to come up with it.

Andrew: Welcome to the boathouse. We haven’t shown it to you before…

Eric: Well, I think…

Andrew: …but we think it’s a good place for Snape to die. They were talking this up…

Micah: It’s in the video games, actually.

Andrew: When they were talking this up, they were saying you get to see Hogwarts burning in the background as Snape dies. And I was, like, “Oh, cool.” But you really don’t see Hogwarts burning…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …in the background as Snape dies, and that was a disappointment because I was kind of looking forward to that. I had this visual in my head that I thought would be quite beautiful.

Eric: It is in the games, which is interesting, even as far back as Chamber of Secrets the game. And we’re talking about when there was only one type of game for each movie release, not fifteen. But you go down to the boathouse and it looks just – I mean, you’re not – you don’t go inside it, but it’s exactly in the same place and I feel like even on the posters, there was a boathouse, right? I mean, early on? So, you know there’s going to…

Micah: It’s interesting, that moment right there when he says, “My lord,” you can tell that he knows that he’s about to get it.

Eric: To get it. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, this is a turn.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: The other thing about having Snape’s death be in this boathouse is that water symbolizes life in a lot of ways, so this raising and lowering of the tide, this water-lapping sound in the background just kind of – it is a place for life and death to be decided.

Andrew: Hmm, interesting point.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: Snape’s hair is long and a mess.

Eric: Snape’s hair, for the first time it looks right to me.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: [laughs] Is that wrong?

Andrew: No, that’s – I agree.

Micah: I didn’t get this line right here, “Only I can live forever.” Snape didn’t have any intention of trying to live forever.

Eric: Well…

Micah: And there he goes.

Eric: …he did though because…

Micah: Quick slit of the throat. How could he not even defend himself though?

Eric: Well…

Andrew: Because he knew…

Eric: He has to know about the Horcruxes, he has to know he has no shot. I mean…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Oh, the other thing, doesn’t it sell – it helps sell that – it actually helps Harry because it helps sell the notion that Voldemort wins. And when Voldemort gets proud, he makes mistakes.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: But there is definitely no way for Snape to know that Harry is watching. I don’t know if there is in the book, but it’s very lucky that Snape waited this long…

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, that’s true.

Eric: …to show him the memory. But there is no reason for Harry to ever show up, and sort of cradle him and get these memories off…

Micah: But you almost wonder what the alternate plan was…

Eric: You do.

Micah: …to show Harry the truth.

Eric: But yeah, just the finding of Snape’s memory…

Andrew: This shot when Harry and Snape are looking at each other, you don’t see the actual shot that they used but on billboards and in that Oscar booklet, they used that and I think it’s one of the better shots of Harry looking into Snape’s eyes as he’s dying.

Eric: Do you have a scan of that?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Okay, I’ll look that up.

Micah: Hermione, come on. Get the vial.

Eric: But the tear – just talking…

Micah: You just happen to have one in your pocket.

Andrew: And don’t get the blood, for God’s sake.

Eric: Yeah. We’ve said though that – remember this, Andrew? The tear is digital, so…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …there was no crying in this – Snape’s death scene.

Andrew: Yeah. [laughs]

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Stuart Craig was, like, “I cried when I watched them film this scene.” And it’s, like, wait, you’re crying and not even Alan Rickman was crying?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Come on.

Eric: That’s the real thing is when you take into account what everybody else said about this scene and to think that not even Alan Rickman could – was supposed to cry because the tears are supposed to be these memory tears of digital proportions. I don’t know. It just…

Andrew: And here we go with Lily’s eyes, “You have your mother’s eyes,” and this was something else that we learnt recently. J.K. Rowling said Harry’s eye color is not that important, but his mom’s eyes need to look similar to his.

Eric: There is a significance to it.

Andrew: And they didn’t even do it!

Eric: It has to be a significance. There will – I agreed with you when you said that, but Geraldine Somerville – we’ve only seen maybe five minutes total of her in the entire film. Maybe they are…

Andrew: Yeah, but this is side by side and Lily’s eyes are brown, I think.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: The actress’ eyes are brown.

Eric: Are they?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Well, I think too, maybe it’s that thing where if you had known Lily, you would have…

Andrew: Is that…

Eric: …seen the resemblance.

Andrew: Was that Fred’s death scene? Was he dying right there, or was it just Voldemort taking over?

Micah: I think that was actually George.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Eric: He was – I think it’s Fred and the reason – but he’s just been disarmed, he’s not dying. And the reason that that is powerful, I think – the reason that it’s supposed to be powerful is because Voldemort is disarming his forces. He is saying okay, now there is time to go pick up your dead and stuff. But Fred has just been disarmed, he has lost his wand. And he is ordering his Death Eaters to retreat to the forest but I think – Alecto Carrow, is it? Not Amycus, Alecto is the female. Seeing a disarmed Fred there, they are obviously – they have just been dueling and I don’t think – I think it was her evilness that she just kept going and actually killed him because he doesn’t have – you see him lose his wand and in the next scene, he is dead. I just think that that – to me, that that makes a lot of sense, is that she would have just gone on and killed him, and then left.

Micah: Mhm.

Eric: It’s so isolated, the boathouse. Oh my God.

Micah: And now there is nobody around. It’s all quiet.

Eric: Cleaning bill. 1-800-GOT-JUNK?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Got a few new holes in here. Clear that [beep] out. It’s the start of term next year.


Mourning in the Great Hall


Andrew: I like this scene because you see quite a few of the teachers.

Eric: Yeah, how about that?

Andrew: You see Trelawney, I remember. We’re not seeing it yet, but…

Micah: Hey, Filch got in on the fight.

Andrew: There is Filch, yeah.

Eric: Hmm, nasty gash.

Andrew: We’re going to see Sprout in a second. Yeah, there is Sprout and Trelawney. Thanks for coming back – what’s her name, Emma Roberts?

Eric: Emma Thompson.

Andrew: Emma Thompson.

Eric: Yeah. Wasn’t she one of the two – her and Rita Skeeter, they didn’t really care much about…

Andrew: Yeah, they were both hinting that they weren’t going to come back.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: Did Rupert do a good job of crying here? I think so.

Eric: Yeah. David Yates talks about that too, how even though Fred didn’t get a death scene, it’s really part of the reaction, that Ron’s reaction is what you’re going to use as your springboard for your emotion. That seeing his reaction is in ways is more powerful than…

Micah: Lupin and Tonks look really creepy right…

Eric: Creepy?

Micah: Yeah. I mean, just…

Andrew: That was their death scene.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: In fairness, they didn’t get it in the book either, so…

Eric: Oh yeah, to answer the question before, I think I recall hearing that Chris Rankin was surprised that he did not appear in the final battle at all, which leaves me to believe that there was originally some kind of scene shot or planned during the battle, for Fred and George to die. But who knows, right?

Micah: Yeah…

Eric: But I think it involved the whole Weasley family or at least Percy’s – what’s the word? Redemption.

Andrew: I mean, it may have been shot. Did Chris say he definitely didn’t film one at all? Because you know how Stanislav, who plays Krum, he shot it but it didn’t appear – he shot, not the battle, but…

Eric: In the wedding.

Andrew: …in the wedding…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …he was supposed to appear.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Which we saw…


The Prince’s Tale


Andrew: Now…

Eric: …but yeah.

Andrew: …this…

Eric: Pensieve?

Andrew: This Pensieve – yeah, it’s different from Half-Blood Prince. It was this standing thing, but now this one is a floating – [laughs] it’s like a flying saucer.

Eric: Interestingly, it is and it isn’t different. And this is one of those things where this is the first time in the films they draw attention to it. But during Half-Blood Prince there is one scene where the shot opens on Harry and Dumbledore and the Pensieve, but if you look closely, the Pensieve is just this floating disc. And it’s such a weird choice for them to make…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …to turn it into…

Andrew: See Lily’s eyes? Brown.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Petunia was even a bitch back then.

Eric: Wow. And Snape lived in a tree. Not a pineapple under a tree, just a tree.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Helicopters. That’s advanced magic there, turning – making something alive.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Awww, young love.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [singing] “Let’s get together and feel all right.” This scene – I mean, I think this was really well-shot. I’m glad that it was done in full color, not like what Snape’s Worst Memory is. It was kind of like this storybook of – not to mention it was, like, five seconds long in Order of the Phoenix. But this is all really kind of – this sells Snape’s childhood and I think it’s probably one of the best – it was probably the best sequence in the whole film, wouldn’t you say?

Andrew: Yeah, I loved all these historical scenes, so to speak, especially the stuff that happened in Hogwarts like Lily and James meeting…

Eric: And getting Sorting. You have to think – they filmed getting Sorted during the…

Andrew: All over again, yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: It’s really cool.

Eric: The last movie.

Micah: Sirius and James.

Eric: And James.

[Prolonged silence]

Micah: That’s a nice shot.

Andrew: From Sorcerer’s Stone.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: I’ve always wanted to see them dancing, the shot – a behind-the-scenes of them dancing [laughs] because they did it for the first film, and it’s in the book at the end of the first film but you never see it.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Alan Rickman, man.

Andrew: These Snape-Dumbledore scenes are great.

Eric: Yeah.

[Prolonged silence]

Micah: He looks a lot younger there too.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s – the hair is shorter, I think they may have put a little extra makeup on him, maybe.

Eric: He does look younger, I’m glad they were able to pull that off and I was worried that they wouldn’t.

Andrew: Maybe that’s why they made his hair longer in Part 2 so they could differentiate between this older Snape, present-day Snape and then the young-adult Snape.

Eric: [imitating Lily] “Mama loves you. Dada loves you.” [normal voice] She has blue eyes, or her eyes look light there.

Andrew: Hmm, it’s true. It’s a side shot though, can’t say for sure.

Eric: Can’t be sure, can’t be sure. Oh, boy.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: He’s into astronomy, big globe. He looks so young here.

Andrew: I wonder if he was actually crying in this scene.

Eric: [laughs] I’m sure he was. He’s a competent actor.

Micah: Now they said they actually shot these during Half-Blood Prince, is that true?

Andrew: Really?

Eric: I wonder. I can’t believe that it was…

Andrew: Who was they? I mean…

Eric: …scripted.

Andrew: …if Yates said it, then it must be true. But I don’t see what the advantage would be. I mean – actually – I don’t know because – I mean, “6”..

Micah: Well, because most of Hogwarts is getting destroyed, isn’t it?

Andrew: But would a script be written?

Eric: Yeah, it doesn’t make sense that they would script it so early.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Because they don’t – who knows what – David Yates didn’t even know he would direct the final film. Why would you have that extra work done? I love how he just passes over James’ dead body [laughs] like it’s half a…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: He’s coming up the stairs. Oh yeah, there is James. Okay, but I have to go find Lily now.

Micah: Yeah, but why would they redo all of this stuff?

Eric: Why wouldn’t they? They have the full support of the budget of the…

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, the Dumbledore’s office set, that has always been there. They have deconstructed the Ministry scene set and put it back together. They – no expenses spared. Just because they don’t have the room to keep all these sets…

Eric: You must…

Andrew: And plus, Michael Gambon wanted to come back to film some stuff for Part 2.

Eric: Well, that was the thing that not necessarily differentiates the books and the movies, but we all knew that Michael Gambon would have to be a big part of the seventh book because of all the Dumbledore backstory at the very least…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …if not King’s Cross. It turns out the backstory wasn’t in, but King’s Cross and these flashbacks were.

Micah: Well, if anybody that is listening wants to check in on that and see if that is true that some of these scenes were shot during Half-Blood Prince

Andrew: Well, where did you hear it?

Micah: I just remember hearing it somewhere.

Eric: I recall hearing that too, but I don’t – thinking about it again…

Andrew: Yeah, I’m going to say no because who knows if David Yates was signed on as a director at that point and…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I mean, that just seems odd.

Eric: It’s just that these scenes fit these films and this sequence so well that it is…

Micah: That’s a scary stuffed animal.

Eric: Yeah, a lot of things children have like clowns and things with scary…

Micah: I hate clowns.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah. Sorry, you just had to hear that outburst there.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: It’s from Movie 4.

Andrew: This was a chill sort of moment when Dumbledore broke the news.

Eric: [poorly imitating Dumbledore] “When the times comes, the boy must die. Yes, yes.” [normal voice] There’s like a fun house, it’s all crooked here.

Micah: It’s weird.

Andrew: It looks like it.

Micah: It’s a completely different Snape.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: What do you mean? No, I – he’s always had a wig so it’s a different wig.

Micah: No, no, no. I mean, just from a character standpoint, from what you’re used to seeing…

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Micah: …throughout the other seven films.

Andrew: Which added to the epic-ness.

Eric: Baby Harry right there is, like, “Who’s this man cradling my mommy?”

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: “I don’t understand. Is that my Dada?”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Look, there’s the line, “Pig for slaughter.” Oh yeah, oh yeah. I say that that is a MuggleCast reference right there.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: The doe. They didn’t really sell the doe, I don’t think.

Andrew: Why does Snape send the doe?

Eric: Well, he sends the doe to show Dumbledore that he is genuine, that he is genuinely in love.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: But baby Harry still doesn’t know who this man is.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: But at the same time, is there another relation I am missing other than the fact that James Potter had a stag patronus so that Lily represents the doe because she’s the partner of the stag and that Snape has the doe patronus, that it represents Lily? Isn’t that three degrees of separation, or three times removed logic there?

Micah: I mean…

Eric: Am I missing something?

Micah: I think that’s the reason.

Eric: Okay.

Micah: So, we’ve just learned that Harry has to die…

Eric: Has to die.

Micah: …and Voldemort must do it.

Eric: And look at this where I think Harry – or Dan – just sits down. He’s just, like, I know if I don’t sit down right now I’m going to fall over. And he just – he’s still wearing his three layers. Now would be a good time to take a jacket off.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s probably sweating.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah. No, he’s going to die and…

Eric: That’s good acting.

Andrew: …die in this outfit.

Eric: [laughs] Now he really wishes they had chosen a better outfit for him to die in.

Andrew: Yeah. Let me go change real quick before I go die.

Eric: He could, right? He could just – the whole Hogwarts is his for the taking.

[Prolonged silence]

MuggleCast 244 Transcript (continued)


The Trio’s Goodbye


Andrew: This was a really special moment for the trio. Hermione and Harry both know what has to be, what has to happen now.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Of course, Ron is a little behind.

Micah: Did you get choked up a little bit here?

Andrew: Did I? No, I didn’t cry once. I did get chills a couple of times. Eric, at this point, had flooded the theater.

Eric: [laughs] Oh, come on.

Andrew: I was – what’s it called when you’re floating in the water?

Eric: Drifting?

Andrew: No. I don’t know. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah. But it is very – it’s good acting between Dan and Emma. And Rupert kind of – Ron and Harry don’t share any lines unlike in the book, but I think it works because I think Ron also gets what’s going on.

Micah: You could do, like, a bro-hug or something.

Eric: Do they?

Micah: No, I’m saying they could.

Andrew: But I think…

Eric: Oh, they could?

Micah: You can see they understand.

Eric: Yeah, I think that – I don’t know.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Ron has to be there for his Hermione. It’s all empty. I guess this corridor replaced the moving staircases. Is that because there are portraits and everything?

Andrew: Yeah, we really don’t see any moving staircases, do we? In this film.

Eric: That would have been cool though, having some of the moving staircases mid-move be toppled and destroyed by the spells.

Andrew: Yeah, that would be cool.

Eric: Although even the moving staircases could be a ride at the Wizarding World park…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …if you think about it. I mean…

Andrew: That would be a fun house.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, something like that.

[Prolonged silence]


Forbidden Forest


Eric: I never liked this in the book, I open at the close. Again, it’s just like somebody left Harry out of the – or somebody left the readers out of the decision-making process. I guess it makes sense that you can only open the Snitch when you’re prepared to die or whatever it is that Harry says. But why would you ever enchant a Snitch to only open when somebody is ready to die? It just doesn’t make much sense to me.

Micah: Yeah, what if he dies before?

Eric: Yeah, right?

Micah: Then the Snitch would never open.

Eric: The Resurrection Stone.

Micah: Yeah, and this is kind of where the Deathly Hallows were put aside for the Horcruxes because you don’t really get a full understanding, I don’t think, of the fact that Harry possessed all three of these things because the Invisibility Cloak is kind of just glossed over.

Eric: Yeah. But I would argue even in the book it’s not spent too much time on. It almost means nothing that he did at one point have all three of the Hallows. It means nothing because he chooses not to – okay, why does his hand go through his mom’s hand? I – they are not ghosts, they are actual…

Andrew: But it is to show that they’re not actually there, I think, for the viewers.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: That’s the most important part. They’re there but they’re not. They can’t walk in and help Harry fight Voldemort, you know?

Eric: It’s funny because Adrian Rawlins who plays James Potter has one line where he’s, like, “Go get him, son,” and I just always envisioned Dan looking back and be, like, “Sorry, who are you?” Because by this point, I just feel like people would be so confused thinking that Snape and Lily were the thing, that Snape could be Harry’s father, that – and they have him in the background. James Potter just, “You’re nearly there, son.” That’s his only line in – they have everybody else’s more prominent than him. It just – what is James Potter to the Harry Potter films, really? Because they cut the backstory with the Marauders, it was just…

Andrew: Isn’t father enough of a…

Eric: I guess. The father of Harry Potter. I guess so. I think it’s that in the books, they just – Lily and James Potter, they have such a – this – they’re famous before their son was and it’s just omitted from the film because of time and death. But you’re right, he is Harry’s dad, so…

Andrew: [laughs] Enough said.

Eric: How many times can Gary Oldman be tear-inducing, right? I cried when he died, I cried when he said, “We’re in here, your heart.”

Andrew: You did?

Eric: Oh yeah!

Andrew: It’s happened to you?

Eric: Yeah, this happened to me.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: “Always.” She shares a line with Snape.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: This is the thing though, the paradox of the films which is that the Resurrection Stone is just lying in the forest, the Elder Wand by the end of it all is floating in the lake, you know? The Deathly Hallows are totally – it is sequel potential is what it is because they are just…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: They are there at Hogwarts. Someone needs to…

Micah: What, like one of the merpeople [laughs] finds the Elder Wand and repairs it?

Eric: Yeah, exactly.

Micah: It starts a whole new book series.

Eric: This is an interesting moment because Voldemort thinks that Harry isn’t going to show up. There is that extra line, “Oh, I thought he would come. Huh. Okay, what next?” Then of course, he shows up.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: He’s got such nice ears.

Andrew: I love how Bellatrix is kind of in the picture, and then [laughs] she looks back and then moves out of the frame.

Eric: Yeah.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: [imitating Voldemort] “Harry Potter, the boy who lived, come to die.” [normal voice] This is where all the trailers for this movie start.

Andrew: Poor Hagrid.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, the trailers – I loved how the trailers started here actually.

Eric: [imitating Death Eater] “No sign of him, my lord.”

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: He’s so haunted. Ralph does that thing with his eyes that he’s done ever since Goblet of Fire where it’s like they are so – lose makeup where they are just in their sockets but it gives the impression that he can see the fear or the pain that he’s about to inflict. And Harry doesn’t even [unintelligible]

Micah: It takes so long just to cast the spell.

Eric: Yeah. [imitating Voldemort] “Avada Kedavra!”


King’s Cross


Micah: And I like this scene. This is probably my favorite scene in the film aside from the break-out at Gringotts.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s quite beautiful.

Eric: It’s good to see Michael Gambon playing such a book Dumbledore…

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: …which I think is the highlight for me. But they do change that line which I have real trouble understanding at the end.

Andrew: I love that. I mean, we talked about that on 242.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I thought that was really special.

Eric: This Voldie-fetus. Fetal Voldemort.

Micah: Just fry it up with some eggs and you’re all set.

Eric: [laughs] Oh my God! What would you even call that? Quiche Voldy?

Micah: Voldie-pot pie? I don’t know. [laughs]

Eric: They said in the – this scene – it’s one of the things – it’s just a puppet actually. But they said it stank because it’s some kind of rubber that they had to pour this fake blood over. It’s just more disgusting stories…

Micah: Yeah, I wouldn’t want to have to be responsible for creating that in the prop department.

Eric: You kidding me? They thrive on that kind of stuff. It’s like everybody wants to be a horror movie prop-maker.

Andrew: It looks very real. We actually got to see the Voldemort on set.

Eric: Oh, did you?

Andrew: Yeah, that wasn’t special effects. I mean, maybe the movement was but…

Eric: Right. No, I think they said it was a puppet under – somebody was controlling it under the platform.

Andrew: It looks less – the DVD/Blu-ray version looks less white to me as I remember in the theaters. Maybe because the theater was just so big your eyes were just washed out, but in here it looks different.

Micah: Yeah, it almost looks blue.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, it does. It matches more with what they are wearing.

Eric: I was going to just say that too. Why are they wearing blue…

Andrew: Harry is naked in this scene in the book, right?

Eric: Well no, he finds clothes. He starts naked.

Andrew: He starts naked.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: See, I don’t see – this whole film was ruined for me. I was expecting that.

Micah: It’s kind of…

Eric: Yeah, I’m sorry.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: It’s a rebirth type of thing, right? Sort of a Christ resurrection…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …reference.

Eric: Blue is water, water is life, that sort of thing. Michael Gambon’s eyelids are blue – or eyelashes, eyebrows. What am I trying to say? Are very blue. He sounds very much like Aberforth in this line, “Where would it take me?” and he says…

Andrew and

Eric:

“On.”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: That sounds so much like Ciar·n Hinds doing Aberforth Dumbledore to me. I don’t know why.

Andrew: It says so little, but so much.

Eric: Yeah. Dumbledore, just this long walking away.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: See, what Dumbledore is saying here is – Harry needs help and Dumbledore is saying we will give you help. But we don’t just give anyone help at Hogwarts. We give people help who deserve it.

Eric: But at Hogwarts…

Andrew: Crabbe is not going to get help.

Eric: But Hogwarts should give help to everybody.

Andrew: No, it shouldn’t.

Eric: Well…

Andrew: It shouldn’t help Voldemort.

Eric: It’s a certain – you’re defeating your own character. You have to give in to ask for help in the first place. If somebody has that moment of humbling, of that modesty to ask for help, they should be given help even if they are Crabbe, even if they are a Slytherin, which is why I think, “Help will be given to all who ask for it,” is completely sufficient the way it is and that it shouldn’t need to be changed.

Andrew: We asked for – on the last episode of MuggleCast, we asked people – or on Episode 242 we said send in – what do you think Dumbledore’s line means? And Lindsey, 25, from San Antonio said:

“Neville Longbottom always comes to mind when I hear this line. Dumbledore makes the original statement in Harry’s second year and Harry recalls those words when he is in the Chamber of Secrets facing Tom Riddle. After asking for help, Fawkes appears with the Sorting Hat which Harry subsequently pulls from the Sword of Gryffindor and kills the Basilisk. Shortly after the King’s Cross scene in which Dumbledore amends his statement, Neville without asking for help but clearly deserving of help, happens to find the Sorting Hat, pulls the Sword of Gryffindor from it and uses it to kill Nagini. It’s a very close parallel.”

Eric: Oh, so it’s that…

Andrew: Thanks Lindsey.

Eric: He’s, like, almost too proud to ask for it but yet he still…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …deserves it?

Andrew: Well no, just that Neville deserved the help.

Micah: I liked this scene also just because of sort of the iconic lines that Dumbledore has.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly. Me too.

Eric: “Words are our most inexhaustible form of magic.”

Micah: “Of course it’s happening inside your head. But why on earth should that mean that it’s not real?”

Eric: Yeah, it was good reading that in the book. It’s one of the most quoted…

Micah: And what you were saying actually, Eric, before, I think, where a lot of people got confused between Lily and Snape versus Lily and James was just in that dialogue between Harry and Dumbledore when he’s talking about Snape’s Patronus taking the form of a doe…

Eric: That’s cleared up in the book?

Micah: …and how it was curious. No, no, no, I think that’s where people got even more confused because…

Eric: Oh.

Micah: …when Harry says, isn’t it curious that Snape’s Patronus takes the same form as my mother’s? And Dumbledore says it’s not curious at all.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Because we did get e-mails saying, but does that mean that Snape is Harry’s father?

Eric: It’s not curious at all. Duh Harry, duh.

Andrew: Uh, duh.


Procession


Micah: And this – I know Helen McCrory said a number of times it’s her favorite line from the films.

Eric: [imitating Narcissa] “Dead.” [normal voice] Why is she a brunette? Why didn’t they make her go all blond? Sorry, I just – I would be remiss if I didn’t ask that question.

Andrew: She has black hair.

Eric: I know she has black hair, but why make only some of it blond?

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t like it. It’s like an Oreo.

Eric: [laughs] I love Oreos.

Andrew: [laughs] Then what’s your problem?

Eric: [laughs] My problem is I just thought she was full-blond.

Andrew: I’m just kidding. See, look, Neville deserved it. He found the hat, somehow it got out there.

Micah: Well, in the books too, it’s – Harry is not the one that usually ends up killing the Horcrux. I mean, he did with the diary but Dumbledore destroyed the ring, right?

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: Ron destroys the locket. I think it’s Hermione that destroys the cup. I can’t remember who destroys the diadem and then it’s Neville who…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …kills Nagini.

Eric: So, you’re saying – in the books too, there is such emphasis placed on it. It has to be Harry, this is Harry’s journey. I think the emphasis is primarily placed on him by Dumbledore, but you see that so many different people get their crack at killing a Horcrux in the end.

Andrew: That shot we just saw of Harry – or of Hagrid carrying Harry, used on a lot of billboards in L.A. [laughs] Again, that Oscar push.

Eric: Really?

Andrew: And I think they are using that because it’s, like, “Hey, look guys, we’re killing our main character. How cool is that?” [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, we went there. We went there. We didn’t…

Andrew: Yeah, we went there.

Eric: Also that shot that you bring up, the one thing they saved Hagrid as a character from being killed. I know whenever remember MuggleNet did – whenever we used to do polls, who will die in Book 5? Who will die in Book 6? Hagrid, Hagrid, Hagrid was the favorite to die. But J.K. Rowling said it was never in the cards because she always had this image of Hagrid carrying Harry’s supposedly lifeless body to this courtyard, and that it’s tied in with Hagrid carrying baby Harry to Privet Drive.

Micah: And this is, of course, the scene that everybody [laughs] references when you interview them, how much they enjoyed a specific scene. This is always the one that always seems to come to mind.

Eric: Yeah, they say that Ralph Fiennes, just his portrayal, the way he acts – this is in “Maximum Movie Mode” too. They say you never know who he is going to look at, who he is going to play off of where he is doing this thing.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, he was commanding the stage here.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: He owned it. This is such a unique performance that I’m not sure anybody expected. It’s just wonderful.

Micah: And Bellatrix is just off on the left acting like him.

[Eric imitates Bellatrix’s high-pitched laugh]

Andrew: Yeah, it’s beautiful. I love it. I think they captured it perfectly.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Few things I call perfect in this Harry Potter series, but this I find perfect.

Eric: Here is Chris Rankin.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: [imitating Lucius] “Draco.”

Andrew: Get the heck over here!

Eric: What are you doing? What are you – come on, I’m putting my hand out. You know how often I put my hand out for you.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: He is mama’s boy though.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Come to Mommy.

Eric: Draco. Draco, come to Mummy.

Micah: But don’t forget to hug Uncle Voldemort…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …on the way over.

Eric: Oh, it’s so… [makes squirming noises]

Micah: [laughs] You can tell he wants to laugh, right there. Alfie Enoch.

Eric: Everybody else is, like, yeah.

Andrew: David Yates, he answered this in one of the interviews down in Orlando. He said that audiences in different countries took it differently because hugs – there are different signals of gesture – a different type of gesture in various countries around the world. Of course in America, everybody laughed. But in different countries, some people took it more seriously which I found interesting.

Eric: Why? Did he name a specific country that he hopes that we view this film in to…

Andrew: No, no, no. But he said not every country was laughing which makes sense because different cultures have different greetings and gestures and…

Eric: That makes a lot of sense actually.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Was that on E! that he…

Andrew: Maybe. I’m not sure.

Eric: That is cool all the same. I like this – the reason I like this scene – it is my favorite scene in the movie is because that line, “Well, Neville, I’m sure we’d be fascinated to hear what you have to say.” He is so proud of having just killed Harry Potter that Voldemort allows this kind of defiance.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: He’s feeling nice. He’s just hugged Draco, he’s feeling nice. He wants to – when it becomes apparent that Neville is not stepping across to join him but to defy him, he could have just killed him. He could have just killed him. But he didn’t, he lets – he hears him out. And the fact that Neville creates such a rousing speech from it is great. But I think Voldemort’s pride being his undoing is the greatest moment of this film.

Micah: So Andrew, not liking Neville necessarily, what did you think of this scene?

Andrew: This was okay.

Micah: He is so creepy right here.

Eric: “Because you’re wrong! Harry’s heart did beat for us!”

Andrew: Neville needs to get that head – that can’t be safe.

Eric: That’s the thing here, look at Voldemort’s face.


Final Showdown


Andrew: Look how Harry and Neville are kind of choreographed. They both sprung to life… [laughs]

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …at the same moment.

Eric: This is finally – I know when watching the film the first time, I had this experience where I was, like, “When will that snake ever, ever leave Voldemort?” But Voldemort is so distracted by Harry that he just runs at him.

Andrew: Yeah, in hindsight, I would have liked to see the final battle take place right here. Not this extra chase that we see in a few moments. But first maybe – first Neville gets the snake and then they kind of all move into the Great Hall, and then Harry and Voldemort finish it off there instead of this extra thing, especially with the cliff fall and…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …with Voldemort tying him up in the robes. This was totally just to get the film to two hours, I think.

Micah: Yeah. And just calling him Tom in front of everybody…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …which was left out.

Eric: Yeah. I don’t know, Harry is a little sure of himself when he says that in the books, like a show-off moment. Dumbledore called him Tom, so I can call him Tom. The other thing about why it doesn’t work in the book, in the Great Hall, I think, is because anybody – at that point when Voldemort is mortal, anybody could have killed Voldemort. And anybody probably should have. Enough talking, don’t let Harry have his victory speech, just somebody cast a damn killing curse at Voldemort because if you do, it will actually kill him and it will actually be the end of all – these twenty years of terror. So, I think it’s important that they’re alone.

Micah: Yeah, and I think David Yates even brought that up when we spoke to him back in July. He was saying how you almost needed them to go off and fight because these two have been going at it for however many years now at this point and it just provides closure. And even from a movie-standpoint, you need to have this one-on-one battle taking place and why not do it throughout Hogwarts?

Eric: Well, it’s just death – also, I was just thinking death is a very personal thing. It’s odd to say, but when Voldemort dies and he has that look where he is scared of what’s happening to him at the very end, it’s very intimate that it’s only Harry who watches this and it also provides better closure for Harry, having suffered so much to be able to – to be the one person to kind of witness this.

Micah: This was a – I didn’t like this.

Eric: What, Neville waking up? Yeah, I think all of us had a problem with this actually. Because Neville has just been blasted into – but there is somebody else in the background on fire. [laughs] What?

Micah: I think it’s just the way that it’s shot.

Eric: It’s shot in like – what, because it’s in slow motion?

Micah: Yeah, and it’s just kind of a…

Eric: Because he looks a little groggier than…

Micah: …hero’s moment.

Andrew: And I would have liked to have seen a battle in the Great Hall because we really don’t see much other than that shot in the background…

Eric: Yeah…

Andrew: …out of focus.

Eric: …in the film, the Great Hall is reserved for the med ward, you know? The medical…

Andrew: And now we’ve talked about this a lot but…

Eric: Yep.

Andrew: …Voldemort would kill Harry right here.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Unless – you could maybe argue that Voldemort wanted to make a show of it and do it in front of everybody. That could be a valid point but otherwise, it just doesn’t make sense.

Micah: Anybody think it’s weird they’re trying to stab a snake with a snake fang?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: It’s a bigger snake fang, it’s not the same snake.

Andrew: Let’s pause for Molly.

Eric: [laughs] This is what happens when you put actors in a room together. You just get them to have all sorts of fun. [whispers] Love that.

Andrew: Now how about the crumbling and the smashing into pieces and…

Eric: Yeah, it’s two separate spells, right? One kills her, one destroys her. But the choice – and we’ve talked about this on MuggleCast, the choice to make Bellatrix explode and the choice to make Voldemort explode so that there is no corpse is in some ways less powerful. I don’t think that’s what they’re going for, but there is nothing more powerful than seeing a dead Voldemort body lifeless, right? The idea that he evaporates as he does is less powerful because then it’s, like, oh, he could be coming back, right? He is – is he part of the environment now just like he was before?

Andrew: And here is the fall.

Micah: Yeah, and just before this sort of the fighting that went on, to have the physical contact was a little weird.

Andrew: Yep, I…

Eric: Well, that’s…

Andrew: They can’t get physical.

Eric: That’s why they…

Andrew: Jo is lying when she said she had no problems with this film.

Eric: [laughs] Was she – well no, that’s why they cut the, “Why do you live? Because I have something worth living for.” That was the moment where David Yates said, “Wait a minute. Okay, now we’ve gone and done it. We made it…”

Micah: That’s creepy.

Eric: “…a little too physically close,” where – it was the moment where Voldemort would have actually crushed Harry’s face if they had put it in the movie, so that’s why they cut it. But that was a creepy moment where they merged, but again it sells the idea that they are so alike.

Micah: And I think when we spoke to him also, he talked about how as they are flying throughout Hogwarts, they are sort of intertwined with each other which is symbolic in the sense that they are for most of the series as well.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Great moment, both looking at each other very firmly in the eye and then shooting the spell at the same time.

Eric: They really cut it…

Micah: I think they are…

Eric: …down to the…

Micah: There was another deleted scene right about there as well, with them running away from Nagini.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, you’re right.

Andrew: Yeah, really short, right?

Eric: It was funny though. She said – or Ron’s, like, “I have to say something!” and she’s, like, “Don’t say anything you wouldn’t say if we weren’t being chased by a giant snake!”

Andrew: And perfect timing, Neville swoops in and kills Nagini before she kills Ron and Hermione.

Eric: Now the thing is now that Nagini is dead, Voldemort is mortal. Is there another spell that is fired here or did Voldemort just lose this battle?

Andrew: No, there’s another one.

Eric: No, no, I think he’s dying.

Andrew: No, but Harry sends one more.

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay. Now…

Micah: But I think it’s also the fact that the allegiance of the Elder Wand lies with Harry and Voldemort has cast Avada Kedavra so it’s about to rebound on him.

Eric: Yeah, it’s the undoing. I love that look where he’s – the cool thing is that his wand flies from him and…

Andrew: This – yeah. I’ve got to say, I really would have liked to see one more spell out of Harry.

Eric: But Harry…

Andrew: The final hit.

Eric: Yeah, but Harry is not a defensive person and that’s why he always uses Expelliarmus. It’s an offensive…

Andrew: But he’s offensive.

Eric: Oh yeah, he’s…

Andrew: He didn’t need to defense…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: And Voldemort is not human…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …either, so it wouldn’t have made sense for him to just fall over even though…

Andrew: And this…

Micah: …he does have a body in the book.

Andrew: …shredding into paper, I wasn’t thrilled with that.

Eric: It was an excuse to do 3D. I think…

Micah: So, you would rather have a body?

Andrew: Well, yeah. I mean, in the book it’s a body, right?

Eric: Yeah…

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: So…

Eric: …it’s a body.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’s totally a body.

Andrew: I mean, what’s – I guess maybe the question would have been, like, oh, what are we going to do with the body? Are we going to show it? Or what did Voldemort’s body look like?

Eric: That’s the thing, it’s the – Voldemort’s last practical joke on the world is [laughs] what are we going to do with his body, you know? But…

Andrew: Summer fling. Neville and Luna…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …even though they don’t touch each other. [laughs]

Eric: It isn’t going to last. But she’s, like, banging her knees together and he’s, like, yeah, I got the Sword of Gryffindor and I deserve it, Dumbledore said. Chris Rankin.

Andrew: Molly is smiling…

Eric: Katie Leung.

Andrew: …even though her son just died.

Eric: Well…

Andrew: And sunlight for the first time.

Eric: Small victories. And yeah, it’s… [laughs]

Andrew: Aberforth got in a little bit.

Micah: All the professors there.

Andrew: Yep. Sprout is actually drinking straight vodka.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: That is not coffee or tea. This hug between Harry and Hagrid I love because it’s like a throwback to Chamber of Secrets.

Eric: Yeah, I’m glad they don’t play that damn music. Or are they?

Andrew: But I wish Hagrid would have said something to Harry.

Micah: Harry has got a cup too.

Eric: There is nothing to say. Oh hey…

Andrew: They’re all getting drunk.

Micah: I didn’t notice that before.

Eric: Harry has got a cup. Look at that.

Micah: Poor Filch. Got to clean…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …the whole thing up himself. [laughs]

Eric: He’s a Squib. [laughs] He can’t use magic, that’s the thing. That’s what really sucks about it. Ron and Hermione have just been having sex the last half-hour.

Andrew: [laughs] Oh God.

Eric: She’s glowing.

[Prolonged silence]


Explanations about the Elder Wand


Eric: This shot – Andrew, you remember this in the test screening with all the green screens?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’s like the ground they are standing on is the only thing that’s real and everything else is corridors of green screen or walls of green screen.

Andrew: Mhm.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: A little more explanation, wrap up the plot.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: “The wand never belonged to Snape.”

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: I’d love to be a guy in a canoe ruining this shot right now.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [laughs] In the back.

Andrew: Get out of the picture!

Eric: [laughs] Attention, we are shooting a Harry Potter film, kind of an important scene. Get out of the picture!

Andrew: You should see merpeople. Is that the Great Lake?

Eric: Yeah, yeah, they should be rejoicing, having a party.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Or a buffet or they should have…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …their cups.

Micah: I know a lot of people also wrote in saying they were surprised Harry didn’t repair his own wand which he does at the end of the book.

Eric: Yeah, that pissed people off because now he really has no wand.

Andrew: He has no wand.

Eric: Yeah. But I mean, talking about allegiances, anybody who found those two pieces of the wand should have its allegiance because the first thing they’re going to do is repair it, so…

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, when he breaks the wand, you see some smoke…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …sort of come out of it. Maybe that was the way of saying that it’s done for.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: [laughs] They could add a teaser at the end of this where you see Crabbe walk up and find the two pieces of the wand. [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Or like Jumanji.

Andrew: To be continued.

Eric: Like the end of Jumanji where the game washes up in, like, China, washes up on the shore in China. There should just be, like, the tribal drums and somebody finds the Elder Wand.

Andrew: And there we go, the final shot.

Eric: That’s just like – to me, this scene of the movie represents the book to me, where it’s the end of our story, you know? It’s just like…

Andrew: And they’re looking on.

Eric: They can’t – if they take one step forward, it would be no longer canon, you know?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Because that’s where the book ended.

Andrew: Mhm.


Epilogue


Eric: And nineteen years later. I was surprised because I thought we would make it all the way to the epilogue without getting a behind-the-scenes on the epilogue. Fortunately in “Maximum Movie Mode,” the epilogue behind-the-scenes is actually three or four times as long as the epilogue itself, so they do…

Andrew: This building right here is where they had the junket for Deathly Hallows which… [laughs]

Eric: No kidding?

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, which is kind of a funny little thing. Sorry, I cut you off. I just wanted to get that in while the shot was up.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, cool. No problem. Does he have a badger? Sirius or James?

Andrew: I missed it, I’m not sure.

Eric: Yeah, it doesn’t look like an owl. It definitely does not look like an owl or a cat or a toad. It’s pretty much – I’m pretty sure it’s a badger.

Micah: It’s a ferret.

Eric: A ferret? [laughs]

Micah: It looks like a ferret.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: He might have an owl.

Andrew: I think this epilogue, the older appearances ended up turning good. It was subtle.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: The voice deepening was subtle.

Eric: They really, really did overdo it the first time and I think that’s sort of come out since these special features and things are on the disc. But they really overdid it…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …the first time when they shot it actually at King’s Cross.

Micah: Now the first time, was Teddy Lupin in there?

Eric: According to the kids – but we – no, that part – and I remember your interview with the children that said that. But no, in the – we haven’t – there is still not a shot that’s supposed to be Teddy Lupin very obviously in any of these special features but I’ll look for that on the Definitive Collection.

Micah: Yeah, the interview that we did with Will Dunn and Arthur Bowen.

Eric: Yeah, they said that in the initial epilogue there was a moment between Harry and Teddy Lupin actually. Got to tie my shoe because it’s past 2015 and they don’t have power laces.

Micah: I think one of the things that both Arthur, who we see right here, and Will said was that somebody had to stand in to tie the shoe because Dan didn’t know how to tie his shoe.

Eric: Really?

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Dan didn’t know?

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Oh, I think – well, not to tie his shoe but just to tie his shoe backwards, was it? Or – because tying somebody else’s shoe is a little bit different.

Micah: Yeah, that’s what it was. Yeah.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, it’s not really different. You could just tie his shoe like you’re tying your own but it’s kind of a funny – the Sorting Hat takes your thing into account. It’s like a cheat code, it’s like you’re giving your kids – God, he spoils his children. Seriously.

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t know if that was good. I mean, I guess it’s comforting to him, but…

Eric: I like the line, though, “The bravest man I ever knew.” Obviously it’s in the book but it just shows that it doesn’t matter what house you’re in.

Andrew: Yeah. Harry should have been, like, “Don’t worry, it’s just like Pottermore.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “You’re not really sorted into your House.” [laughs] “It’s just so there’s a fair fight for the House Cup.”

Eric: Look at that, Chocolate Frog animation. That must have been so cool to do that.

Micah: I like how Albus Severus and James Sirius are already hitting on the older women.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: Because those have to be at least sixth or seventh years in the car with them.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: It’s – oh Micah. It looks like Jeremy Piven in the background.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Oh no. See, this music I was okay with being the direct track from the end of the first film.

Micah: And that shot right there too was very [laughs] focused on Harry and Hermione as opposed to – Ron was kind of in the background.

Eric: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: As usual.

[Micah laughs]


Show Close


Andrew: Always the third wheel. Well, that wraps up our Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 commentary. Hopefully, everybody enjoyed it. That was fun.

Eric: Now listen to us read the credits! [laughs]

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I already closed out the movie, so…

Andrew and

Eric:

Oh.

Micah: …sorry.

Andrew: Wow, Micah couldn’t wait to finish. [laughs]

[Micah laughs]

Eric: It’s okay. Geez.

Andrew: Yeah, that was a lot of fun and we hope everybody enjoys it, enjoyed the extra flavor of information since there was no commentary on the DVD whatsoever.

Eric: Yeah, unless you want to take into account “Maximum Movie Mode”.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Which – the things they do though. They added the timing of the film so they stop it, they rewind it, they pause it, they go back, they go forward, all sorts of stuff.

Andrew: And just a reminder, all the information you need about the show can be found on MuggleCast.com. If you have any feedback about what we discussed during the commentary, just click on “Contact” at the top and you can fill out the form. Get in touch with us that way and we’ll do some commentary feedback on Episode 245, I guess. Thanks everyone for listening! From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: We’ll see you next time for our Sorcerer’s Stone commentary!

[Show music begins]

Micah: [laughs] We’re starting…

Andrew: Just kidding.

Micah: …it all from the beginning.

Andrew: Yes. No, not yet anyway.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Maybe.

Micah: Maybe.

Andrew: Yeah. And we’ll see you next time…

Eric: Maybe for the 15 year anniversary because the 10 year…

Andrew: Right.

Eric: …anniversary was yesterday so we really got to get on that. [laughs]

Andrew: There you go.

Eric: There you go. Cool.

Andrew: See you next time for Episode 245! Goodbye!

Micah: Bye!

Eric: Bye-bye!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #243

MuggleCast 243 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because Quidditch and LEGOs are enough for one episode, this is MuggleCast Episode 243 for November 17th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 243! This is a special episode. We have two interviews conducted over the past week, one by Keith actually, right? In New York, Micah?

Micah: Yeah, Keith Hawk was with a number of the MuggleNet staff, including myself, at the Quidditch World Cup which took place at Randall’s Island.

Andrew: Cool. And who won the Cup, by the way?

Micah: Well, no surprise, [laughs] Middlebury College won…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …the fifth consecutive Quidditch World Cup. But they did lose their first game ever which…

Eric: So, they had been completely undefeated.

Micah: They – yeah, never lost a match. I don’t know what their official record is, but they had never lost a match in five years. They, of course, are the founding institution of Quidditch – Muggle Quidditch, anyway. And they lost their first match on Saturday to Michigan…

Andrew: Okay, wow.

Micah: …so that was the big news of the day on Saturday. But they got it back together on Sunday and made their way through the play-offs, and of course, defeated the University of Florida for the Quidditch World Cup.

Eric: Guys…

Andrew: Cool.

Eric: …I’m just thinking, they have to be the least interesting team to follow if they’re always winning. I mean – well, and the most rewarding team to follow. But here you have a team that started the game, [laughs] started the College Quidditch and they’re so good at it that they never lose? I don’t know how Quidditch ever got off the ground like that. [laughs]

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Right? Because wasn’t everybody else who wanted to be a part of it – they lost. They came in and…

Micah: Yeah, but…

Eric: …weren’t as…

Micah: …I think if you look around at just the number of people that were there both from a team standpoint – they had close to a hundred teams from four different countries: Canada, the United States, Finland and Australia. And the…

Eric: Those were the four countries?

Micah: Those were the four countries. And just the number of different colleges throughout the U.S. were represented – I mean, you would look around and you would see Franklin & Marshall, you would see Syracuse, you would see Michigan, you would see Penn State. All these schools were represented and – Arizona State battling SUNY Geneseo. I mean, I don’t even think you’d ever get that in a normal college mash-up, so – and any other sport I’m referring to. And it is a serious sport, people take this very, [laughs] very seriously.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: You’d be surprised…

Andrew: Yeah, you know…

Micah: I mean, Andrew, you went last year and so did I, and we kind of experienced it for the first time. And you go into it thinking, well, how much am I really going to enjoy this? Is it really that of an intense sport? What am I going to see? And I think you have to go into it with an open mind because what you experience is something completely different, I think, than what you would expect to experience.

Andrew: Yeah. No, I was really impressed last year and I was sad I couldn’t go this year.

Okay, so before we get into the first interview, we’d like to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, and featuring audio versions of many New York Times bestsellers. For listeners of MuggleCast, Audible is offering a free audiobook so you can try out their amazing service. One audiobook to consider is Inheritance, Book 4 in the Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini. It was just released and you Eragon fans out there will not want to miss the finale, so why not get it for free and listen to it just like you do MuggleCast? To do so, or to grab any book of your choice, visit AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. We thank Audible for their support of the show.

Here now is Keith’s interview.


Fifth Annual Quidditch World Cup Interview: Matthew Ziff


Keith Hawk: All right, MuggleNet’s SnitchCenter here and this is the second day of the Quidditch World Cup. But right now, I am with Matthew Ziff. Matthew Ziff is a player for the University of Miami and – tell us a little bit about yourself, Matt.

Matthew Ziff: I am a junior at UM and studying Industrial Engineering, and I am a Beater and a Seeker, I’ve been since the beginning of UM’s Muggle Quidditch. And just – we’re having fun and…

Keith: How did you guys do so far this week?

Matthew: Well, right now, we’re 3-0 with our average scoring being over a hundred points. And we’re going up against Vaasa right now and we’re hoping to take it all home.

Keith: I heard a rumor, okay – I don’t know if it’s true – that you have a movie coming out this Thursday. Is that correct?

Matthew: Yes! I’m an actor, I have a movie coming out on Thursday called Hardflip, it’s premiering in L.A. It’s a skateboarding movie with John Schneider and Rosanna Arquette, and… [laughs]

Keith: And what part are you playing?

Matthew: I am playing one of – the main character’s brother. It’s kind of like a cross between an inspirational and a sport’s movie, so it’s going to be – we had a lot of fun, it’s going to be a really good movie, I think. The movie is premiering Thursday in L.A., it’s called Hardflip and it should be in theaters coming up pretty soon, so…

Keith: That’s great. Now you heard it right here on MuggleNet’s SnitchCenter, second day of the live World Quidditch Cup – Fifth Annual Quidditch Cup here in Randall’s Island, New York. Matt Ziff with the University of Miami, coming out with a movie.


Fifth Annual Quidditch World Cup Interview: Asher King Abramson


Keith: All right, we are on Field 4 getting ready for the UCLA-Middlebury match which is at 5 o’clock here of the first day, Saturday, and I am with Asher King Abramson. Asher, how’s it been going so far today?

Asher King Abramson: It’s been great so far. We bet Vaasa from Finland by – I think it was two hundred points or so, and then we’ve beaten Yale 60-40, so we’re looking forward to this. It’s going to be an epic match. It’s going to be amazing.

Keith: So Vaasa comes all the way from Finland and you destroyed them by two hundred points. What kind of a statement are you trying to send back there?

Asher: Well, we love them as people, we love that they play Quidditch. I think we showed them that we – I think with experience, they will get better. But we were happy to play them and I think we sent a message. [laughs]

Keith: Well, I’m glad they’re over here because it’s nice to have some international teams over here, but let’s get back into the Middlebury match.

Asher: Sure.

Keith: Middlebury plays a little bit different technique than UCLA does. Middlebury has more of a passing game, UCLA a little bit more big, strong, fast game. So, how are you looking to take on Middlebury in this game?

Asher: We’re definitely – yeah, you hit all the notes. We’re looking at their passing game, they’re very good at dropping off passes to each other, making good cuts, running behind the hoops, all that. We’re keeping an eye out for it, so it should be a great match and I’m happy to – I’m ready to go!

Keith: All right, good luck. Well, it’s the first time I’ve had an eye-to-eye contact with somebody today, so I’m glad…

[Asher laughs]

Keith: …to have it. All right, buddy.

Asher: Thanks!

Keith: Take care.

Asher: Yeah, yeah.

Keith: Good luck!


Interview with Arthur Parsons: Introduction


Andrew: Okay, and now our second interview was done by Eric further down the East Coast in Orlando at the Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration. Eric, intro this one for us.

Eric: Yeah, this one – this is the interview with Arthur Parsons, who is the Game Director behind LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7 and also the first game which was LEGO Harry Potter: Years 1-4. And he works over at TT Games and basically – it turns out he’s been doing this, he’s been working on video games for, like, twelve years, so he’s a total veteran, nice guy. And we interviewed him for about 15 to 20 minutes about this new LEGO game, and I know Micah and myself – we have played the first game and we were really excited to get our hands on the sequel which came out last Friday, so it’s the same day that all this stuff happened with the movie coming out on DVD, they also released this game. And it’s just a really cool interview because you just hear his passion. Arthur is so very passionate about the LEGOs, about the LEGO video games, sort of the improvements they have made to the original game. And also the fiction, he said – there were many points in the interview where he has said this happens in the books and so we just had to get it into the game. And I think the other thing that was cool about the weekend was that he had the LEGO game set up on two – sort of two displays in the press area, so all of the press – it was like in the Hospitality Suite, so everybody who came in to sort of sign in, check in, got to see – got to play the game, as well as some of the actors so he was tweeting about the actors coming in and playing the LEGO versions of themselves and stuff. So, it was really cool and – really fun game. And I think just – yeah, just listen to the interview because it’s really, really good.

Andrew: All right, let’s listen now!


Interview with Arthur Parsons


Eric: All right, I am here with Arthur Parsons, he is the Game Director at – TT Games? So, the game you have directed – most recently, that is – LEGO Harry Potter?

Arthur Parsons: Yeah, LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7. I also was the Game Director on Years 1-4, so back-to-back Harry Potter games which is brilliant.

Eric: Wonderful. So, you’ve done nothing in between? It’s always from one Harry Potter to the other?

Arthur: Yeah, yeah, we finished LEGO Harry Potter: Years 1-4 sort of May, June last year, and me and the team rolled straight on to Years 5-7 so we had a really good long time to make a brilliant sequel.

Eric: So, how has the first game succeeded and sort of – what were some of the fan reactions while you – I guess you were already working on the sequel when the first one was taking off.

Arthur: Yeah, the great thing about Years 1-4 was we did something new with it where we wanted the player to experience being a wizard, going to Hogwarts, going to lessons, learning spells, and just that whole sort of magical environment. Going around Hogwarts was so cool and such a big change from previous LEGO games where you sort of had lists of levels that you could go. So, fans of Harry Potter love the game because it was all about Harry Potter. Fans of the LEGO series love the game because it was something new, it had a completely different feel from, say, Batman or Star Wars or Indy. So, it was successful because it was new and it kind of shook-up the LEGO series with just this cool new feel. You could explore, you could wander into rooms, you could just go to lessons. It’s not an RPG but you felt like you were Harry and you didn’t know how to do your magic, and as you progress through the game you would learn new magic, new spells, new abilities. So, we sort of built on that for Years 5-7 to really sort of take it to that next step. People have been to Hogwarts and experienced it, now they need something new, fresh and exciting so that’s obviously where Years 5-7 comes in.

Eric: Well, I know – I love flying on the brooms and having that unique sort of character touches to the brooms in the first game. Is there still brooms in the sequel?

Arthur: Yeah, yeah, we’ve got brooms. We’ve also got Thestrals, so you can fly around on those. And it is – again, we’ve given every character a unique feel, so whether you’re playing as Ginny Weasley or Arthur or Tonks or Bellatrix, every character feels unique and every character has unique – Tonks, for example, if you stand there doing nothing, she gets really angry and her hair changes color, and then it changes back.

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: Because it’s all stuff that’s in the fiction.

Eric: Yes.

Arthur: I know the films, I know the books. I’m a massive, massive Harry Potter fan and so are most of the guys on my team, and so we want Harry Potter fans to see all the little attention to detail. Ginny Weasley has a Pygmy Puff, Ron now has Pigwidgeon as a pet, Lucius has a pet peacock, it’s…

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: All the little things that people won’t expect and it’s like – every time you play a character, there’s an extra surprise in there.

Eric: Yeah. Can you play as the peacock?

Arthur: Yeah, yeah, absolutely!

Eric: Oh!

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: No, really?!

Arthur: Yeah, yeah, it’s cool. It’s like…

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: You’re Lucius and you’re running around, and you can click, click, click. You get your pet out and just this bonkers peacock pops out…

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: …and you can run around as a peacock. It’s so cool.

Eric: [laughs] So, let’s talk about the characters then.

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: There were a massive collection of characters in the first game.

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: Have you improved upon it? Are the old ones back?

Arthur: What we did was – we love bettering ourselves in the LEGO series, so in the first game there was 167 free-play characters. I hold my hands up, some of those were, like, Gryffindor boy or Ravenclaw girl or…

Eric: Those are some of my favorites though.

Arthur: Yeah, they’re pretty cool but Years 5-7 has amazing characters, so what we’ve done this time around on the console versions, we have 200 free-play characters.

Eric: Wow.

Arthur: Now all of them are great characters, so whether it is Bellatrix or Professor Slughorn or Umbridge, whether it’s Blaise Zabini – all the characters are there. And the cool thing is they all do cool stuff. Professor Slughorn, you can turn into an armchair and it’s just like – there’s no need…

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: …but because he does it in the fiction, it’s – we thought we’d do it in the game. So yeah, 200 characters. And it was a bit of a job getting it to fit on a disc but every character…

Eric: Right.

Arthur: …that a Harry Potter fan would want to play is in there. Yeah, even characters like the Grey Lady. It’s just – you don’t expect to be able to play them, but they’re there and we have just crammed everything into it.

Eric: That’s amazing. So, obviously you guys reference the books a ton.

Arthur: Yeah, definitely.

Eric: Is it – but they – I think the movies, the games – because a lot of us are very visual since the movies have come out, the games seem to follow the movies but yet there is so much from the games in. So, Years 5-7 in Harry Potter, is it sort of a fourth – is there a fourth year in there because of the movie split with the…

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: …final film? Or how did that affect content or direction of the gameplay?

Arthur: Well, what we wanted to do is – the first game was massive, it was a really big game. The films clearly – obviously Deathly Hallows is split into two, so what we’ve done – again, internally it was like Years 5 through 8. Obviously there’s not an eighth year…

Eric: Yeah.

Arthur: …but there’s six strong solid story events for Year 7, Deathly Hallows: Part 1, and then there’s another six for Deathly Hallows: Part 2, so the game is – it’s actually bigger than the first game. But there are still twenty-four story events in there and there’s something like sixteen lessons. And then there’s all the – obviously exterior areas, whether it’s the forest when you’re camping in the tent, or whether it’s London, King’s Cross, Godric’s Hollow, the huge amount of real estate in this game. And from a direction point of view, we wanted to make sure that, say, visually people relate to the films. But from our perspective, we’re not just sort of aiming the game at, say, kids 6 to 12. They’re going to know the films but we also have to cater for fans. And the fans know the books…

Eric: Yes.

Arthur: …in incredible detail, so for us, we’re dealing with kids and fans of the LEGO series but we’re also scouring the books for every little detail. We manage to get stuff in there for fiction fans because these are the guys that as they are playing it, they will see something and it may be the tiniest little thing we’ve added, but they will be, like, “That’s so cool!” You know?

Eric: Yeah.

Arthur: “Yeah, I remember…”

Eric: Yeah.

Arthur: “…that from the book,” or, “I can’t believe they’ve added this in,” and so we try and meld the two together.

Eric: That’s good. I mean, that was my reaction of playing the first game – was, “I cannot believe that somebody else has read the same book I have!”

[Arthur laughs]

Eric: Because it’s the end thought to turn it into a game…

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: …because it’s just that recognition that rarely comes from video games, you know? Just sort of the deeper perspective and just the, “We get you,” you know?

Arthur: Yeah, absolutely.

Eric: “We’re fans too,” sort of thing. And I think that’s something too, with the interactivity because it’s LEGO, it’s fun, it’s just inviting, and people are just going to be completely surprised every time something like that pops up.

Arthur: Yeah, we’d hope so and – yeah, if Harry Potter fans like the game, it’s a job well done, you know? We will be happy if fans of the fiction are, like, “This is a great game. This really does justice to a great series of books.”

Eric: Yeah. So, what year of “5-7” or “5-8″…

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: …was the most challenging to produce? Was there, sort of, something difficult? Or maybe it’s the most areas to go to, or…

Arthur: I guess Deathly Hallows: Part 1 was the trickiest because there’s no Hogwarts, and it’s Harry, Ron, Hermione, and – obviously when Ron’s there. But they’re on the run and they’re not in Hogwarts, so we had to think about that and go, “Well, how are we going to tackle this?” So, what we’ve actually done – and it’s really cool – is we have an exterior forest area and it unlocks throughout the course of Deathly Hallows: Part 1, so the tent moves around the area. You can go in the tent and it’s a cool area, and you can do the cool Harry and Hermione dance which is ace.

Eric: What?!

Arthur: Yeah, it’s so cool. But in order to make sure people can go to Hogwarts, because we still want people to be able to go and do free-play stuff, and if you go into the tent at any point in Deathly Hallows: Part 1, you can go to the table and there is the Marauder’s Map. Open up the Marauder’s Map, and then the camera zooms into the map and then comes out in Hogwarts, and you’re playing as Ginny and Neville and Seamus and Dean Thomas, and…

Eric: I really…

Arthur: …you’ve been in Hogwarts.

Eric: …just got chills. I really…

[Arthur laughs]

Eric: …just got chills right now.

Arthur: And so it means that – yeah, Harry, Ron, Hermione can’t go to Hogwarts but everyone else can, so we let you go and play Hogwarts as though you were the rest of the cool crew and then at any point, you can just pop back and progress the story. So, that was quite a challenge, to sort of link that up as well as being able to sort of go back to London, go to the cafe and fight Dolohov, and explore around. So yeah, that’s – we’re all very proud of the fact we managed to tie that in and make it still feel like the rest of the game. But it was quite a lot of sleepless nights and scratching our heads, and…

Eric: I’m sure.

Arthur: We need to do this right and we managed to do it right, thankfully.

Eric: So, Voldemort – obviously a big difference from the first game. Now, he’s everywhere. He’s back, fully formed.

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: And I saw the advertisement that appears on the Blu-ray, where he’s looking in the mirror and Bellatrix…

Arthur: Yeah…

Eric: …catches him.

Arthur: …the “Game Face Trailer.”

Eric: That’s hilarious.

Arthur: Yeah, it’s cool.

Eric: Absolutely hilarious. Is he scary? Is he still a villain in this game? How did you sort of manage – because he’s a very dark character in the books.

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: How did you handle sort of the transfer from the books to the game?

Arthur: Well, there’s some really quite spooky moments in the game, so even just – like at the end of Year 5 when you have the showdown in the Ministry, Voldemort there – he has like – he just has this really evil face and the cut-scene team have done a fabulous job of bringing him to life. And so we kind of mix him with the more serious side but also with a little bit of a goofy side as well. Because at the end of the day, it was fun. We want it to be fun and funny, but we kind of melded the two together. There are some fabulous, fabulous shots where you’re interacting with Voldemort because we have a lot more interaction with him and obviously all the other bad guys from Years 5 through 7. So, we’ve tried to really create a menacing character without losing the fun and humor. And I think as people progress through the game, they will really enjoy every time they come across him. And even like the Dark Mark. The Dark Mark from Years 5-7 is immense. It’s so menacing, so spooky, you’ve got the cool Voldemort smokey monster in the section by the lake where they crack open the locket.

Eric: Yes!

Arthur: That is like – when I first saw what the art guys did for that, I was just, like, wow, this is just far more advanced than the LEGO game. It’s quite proper, sort of spooky and sinister, you know? And then you’ve got Harry and Hermione coming out of the smoke and you’re just, like, “Whoa!” And then obviously we do a LEGO thing and you create these crazy fans to blow them away.

Eric: Oh!

Arthur: It’s really cool, really cool.

Eric: I love that. How does Malfoy Manor look? Is that a playable area?

Arthur: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Right at the end of Year 7, we have a story event set in Malfoy Manor, so you’re running around the forest and you get caught by the Snatchers, and then they sort of take you back to Malfoy Manor. Harry gets the Stinging Jinx on his head, so his head turns into this big red block of LEGO.

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: It’s really funny. And then you go and get taken down to the cellar by Peter Pettigrew. And you’re there and you get to play as Luna and Ollivander and Harry and Ron. But you’ve got no wands so you’re kind of exploring the cellar, and then eventually Dobby arrives and knocks Peter Pettigrew out. And then you go up to the main area of Malfoy Manor and you get to duel. And it’s so cool. We’ve really tried to keep to the fiction, but at the same time, have a great deal of fun with it. It’s really, really funny.

Eric: Speaking of Gringotts, it was sort of a power-up area in the first game, so…

Arthur: Yep.

Eric: …how was that going back to break in? Was it – how did you sort of mend the two environments between the games?

Arthur: What we did was because we wanted it to feel new and fresh, Diagon Alley was completely rebuilt this time around and so we’ve turned it around 180 degrees, so you’re looking up towards Fred and George’s joke shop. So in Year 5, there’s no joke shop, it’s just all scaffolding and stuff. And then in Year 6 onwards, the joke shop is open, and you can go in and do cool stuff in there. So with Gringotts, what we’ve done is by switching it around and having the camera at the other end, the player isn’t – they’re not really aware of Gringotts. And then when you get to the start of Deathly Hallows: Part 2 and break into Gringotts, you get to go down, cool mine cart section. You get to go and break into Bellatrix’s vault. You then get to go and ride on the dragon, blasting all the Ministry guards. And it’s just – we’ve just tried to do the fiction justice the best way we can. And at the same time, it’s so funny. You’re racing around and just – you’re having fun at the same time. It’s like seeing all these key plot points and you’re, like, “Yeah, I remember! Yeah, yeah, this, that.” And playing it as a Harry fan when we finished it, I was just, like, “This is right! This is as it should be,” so hopefully everyone will see that.

Eric: So, LEGO has also done a game, LEGO Indiana Jones: The Adventure Continues.

Arthur: Sure.

Eric: Will there be an extended – another Harry game? How will that – or The Clone Wars.

[Arthur laughs]

Eric: With The Clone Wars for Star Wars. Will there be another Harry game after this?

Arthur: I really don’t know. At the minute, we are so fully focused on – now we’ve done the game – getting the game out…

Eric: Yeah.

Arthur: …so that everyone can enjoy it.

Eric: Yeah.

Arthur: We’re not looking any further ahead than right now. We want everyone to go out and play the game, really enjoy the game, and we’re just going to have a massive holiday because we’re all really tired. [laughs]

Eric: Oh yeah, are you – well, you’re obviously a big Harry Potter fan.

Arthur: Yeah.

Eric: Have you signed up for Pottermore at all? Or…

Arthur: I’ll be honest with you: I missed the deadline.

[Eric laughs]

Arthur: The early deadline because I was in work, like, 15 hours a day, all the guys on the team – we didn’t have weekends off. We were just so focused on the game, we just missed everything. So, now that we’ve got a bit of quiet time, I’m sure we’re all going to be signing up and just interacting like every other Harry Potter fan. Just trying to catch up with the world as well.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Arthur: Everything that’s going on, so – yeah, we’ve been locked away in the office and…

Eric: That’s good to hear…

Arthur: …it’s good to get out.

Eric: …for us, I think, because it means that there’s that much more attention…

Arthur: Yeah, that we cared! Absolutely, yeah.

Eric: And then on Twitter, I saw your image. Were you Luna for Halloween?

Arthur: [laughs] That was just a joke in the office. Someone came to Wizarding World on holiday and brought me back some Spectrespecs because obviously we’ve got Spectrespecs in the game.

Eric: Aww.

Arthur: It was just, like, I had to put them on. And we have a blond wig, it’s like this sort of – whoever sort of makes a boo-boo at work, they have to kind of wear a blond wig and a dunce cap…

Eric: The plot thickens! [laughs]

Arthur: …so I dressed up as Luna. You know, why not? It’s a bit of fun, isn’t it? [laughs]

Eric: It is. Thank you for your time.

Arthur: No, not a problem.

Eric: This has been…

Arthur: Pleasure.

Eric: …really wonderful. Let’s try the game!

Arthur: Yeah, absolutely.

Eric: We will.


Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration


Andrew: Okay, so those were our two interviews. Like we said at the beginning, this is our special mini-of-sorts MuggleCast episode catching up on some news and overall, Eric, how was Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration?

Eric: It was really exciting. I didn’t know what to really expect because it’s, like, well, it’s the last film on DVD. Is that cause for a celebration? But when you get these people together under one roof – and I think that was something that became evident in the press junket, so they had – was that you get these people who shared such – ten years of experience. And it doesn’t matter if the final film is on DVD or if they are just meeting for coffee, there are going to be stories that are told and there are going to be stories that resonate. And so to have a whole room full of press, get to talk to them even again, it just felt like a really cool thing. And the other cool thing is that they really dressed up the Wizarding World park really nicely, and Andrew, you can say what it’s like when they – you were there for the park opening. But just seeing The Wizarding World of Harry Potter with a red carpet through it is really something cool.

Andrew: Yeah, and in a way, you said it’s kind of like an ending of sorts but [laughs] it’s sort of a beginning, it’s celebrating the beginning of the future of Harry Potter which is home entertainment. [laughs] It’s no longer movie theaters, it’s really all about home entertainment. And not to say – I mean, I’m not saying there’s going to be some big home entertainment stuff to look forward to other than maybe that Definitive Collection next year, but it is kind of a beginning of sorts.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: A new era in Harry Potter.

Micah: And you look at the fact that it’s been ten years this week since Sorcerer’s Stone was released, so – and Andrew, I know you’ve talked about how you think that this is something that they can really continue to do year in and year out. Have an event at the park similar to this where cast and crew show up and celebrate the films.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, clearly like Eric was saying, it was a success, it was a lot of fun. A lot of actors turned out. I question some of their choices… [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] What? Whose choice is this?

Andrew: [laughs] …of stars who came. I don’t know. Stanislav, the guy who plays Krum…

Eric: He was awesome.

Andrew: It was a very…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I’m sure he was cool and a nice guy, I’m just – [laughs] these random choices! I don’t know. But yeah, no, it’s a cool event. I could see it being a yearly thing. I don’t see why Universal wouldn’t be interesting in such a thing.

Micah: Yeah. And Eric, you got the chance really quickly to interview several other of the cast and crew members one-on-one, in addition to the coverage that you did at the press conference and the red carpet, right?

Eric: Yeah, yeah, it was really cool. Those were sort of print interviews that I’m working on getting up. It’s been kind of a busy week. But yeah, we spoke with Warwick Davis, we spoke with him again on the red carpet. And also director David Yates who actually – we asked him about the Oscar coverage and I have to say, Andrew, you got that bug in my head about talking about the Oscars with him. That was the only thing I could talk about with him. Once I actually sat down, I was, like, “What’s happening with the Oscars?” And so we got some – we got an interesting response from him, yeah. He said he really is not – he’d be in support of fans trying to push along with the studio for the Oscars.

Andrew: Neat, neat.

Eric: So, that was really cool.


Show Close


Andrew: All right, so this has been MuggleCast Episode 243.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: Our next episode, 244, is our big Deathly Hallows: Part 2 DVD commentary and it’s going to be a lot of fun. We’re looking forward to it. So until then, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: See you next time for our DVD commentary, Episode 244! Goodbye!

Eric: Goodbye!

Micah: Bye!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #242

MuggleCast 242 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Andrew: Because this is the definitive Harry Potter podcast, this is MuggleCast Episode 242 for November 13th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 242! It’s a big episode because the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD is now available and we’re here to talk about it! Plus, a lot of other very interesting news, actually, to talk about. Big news about the theme park…

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: …big news about the future, all that. Yeah.

Micah: And more Pottermore.

Andrew: And more Pottermore. [laughs]

Eric: More Pottermore.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: All right. I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Micah, what is in the news this week?


News: Pottermore Insider Blog Update, Pottermore Beta Survey


Micah: Well, surprisingly, Pottermore is in the news. [laughs] A little bit of an update, their Insider blog, which has been pretty busy lately, has talked a little bit about – they had some downtime last week and they say now, though, that things are flowing a lot more smoothly. They had a server upgrade, and now that things are doing a lot better they’re going to turn their attention over to some other improvements, I guess some enhancements that they’ve been meaning to make, probably for the last couple of months. But the big problem was traffic and they seem to have rectified that problem somewhat.

Andrew: Well, that’s good. So, hopefully no more “This site is -” or what was that, the purple screen of death? “Please come back later. Pottermore is temporarily unavailable,” something like that.

Eric: A new server. Yeah, I would have thought they would have added, like, ten new servers.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: They probably did, and that’s fine. I’m glad it’s running better now, but there’s only 600,000 people in it, and probably a fraction of them are actually going into it. So, what’s going to happen when it opens to the public? Will it be ready then?

Eric: Ooh.

Micah: And that’s another question is, when is it going to open to the public? Because we’re already into November now, and it seems like Beta testing is going to remain open probably through the end of this year.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Do you think that’s safe to say?

Andrew: I think that’s safe to say. So, I don’t – they need – I don’t know what they need. They need to add new features, that’s what they need.

Micah: And what about for people who were waiting until October to get in…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …and now they’re – they don’t know when they’re going to get in.

Andrew: Yeah. So, basically they extended the Beta period for an unknown amount of time, and who knows what’s going to happen when it opens up.

Micah: It’s got to be pretty frustrating, though.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: If you’re a fan and for whatever reason – let’s say you didn’t make it in the first million…

Andrew: First 600,000. [laughs]

Eric: I think for me – yeah. I think for me, too, though, the promise of quality over – supersedes anything else.

Andrew: Yeah, I agree.

Eric: If it’s going to finally work when I get in – if I hadn’t been in the Beta. Did you guys take the Beta survey, though?

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: That recently closed. How was that? I hadn’t really taken a look.

Andrew: It’s pretty interesting.

Micah: Let’s take it!

Andrew: [laughs] Let’s take it.

Eric: [laughs] Let’s take it right now.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: It takes like a half-hour, it’s so long.

Eric: It’s closed. It’s closed, Micah.

Micah: Well, actually, I’m looking at the news post that you made on Hypable but you kind of paraphrased some of the questions.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: But I wanted to put those questions to you guys, I’ll answer as well, and just maybe take a few of them here and see…

Andrew: Keep in mind these were actually in the survey.

Micah: Right. See what you guys think about them.

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: “Has Pottermore encouraged you to read or re-read the Harry Potter books?”

Andrew: No.

Eric: No.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: No. “How are you enjoying going through the Moments and collecting items?”

Andrew: And I think that part of the survey was like, “Very satisfied,” “Not satisfied,” “Very dissatisfied,” and I think I scored that low because it was – you were just clicking on items and nothing really happened. It said, oh, you collected it, it’s in your bag now, and you’re like, okay, cool, now what? Next chapter, same thing. Repeat.

Micah: Yeah, and I think really where it falls short, too, is that there’s no retention value. There’s nothing that’s bringing you back to the site, at least for right now, and that’s something that I think they’re falling short with. And as far as collecting items, what’s their purpose? That’s the other thing.

Eric: Well, that’s like – yeah, I think it’s conflicting because the fact that you can collect items suggests some sort of either repeat value or that you’d be able to use them later. I mean, not all – just because some sites have a repeat, a visit value, doesn’t mean all sites need it. I feel like if Pottermore had this…

Micah: Well, this site needs it.

Eric: Well, does it, though? Because honestly, they have seven books to get through, they’re three months apart. What’s wrong with them just releasing each book, having everybody flock to the site, complete everything, learn everything – because it’s a learning experience. It’s like it echoes us reading the books for the first time – and then have these months of down period where there’s not a whole lot to do. If they could perfect it, what would be wrong with that?

Micah: Well, because I think one of the things that they’re trying to do here is create a community, and you can’t create a community if people are only coming back six more times after Philosopher’s Stone.

Andrew: And people can’t really talk to each other. I mean, you can leave a comment but that’s it, and you don’t know who these people are. So…

Eric: Well, I think they have to somehow extend the in-book experience so that there is that community, but I still would be all right if there were periods of downtime just because…

Andrew: So…

Eric: I mean, what we’re talking about on Pottermore is the new content, right? So, it all kind of gets dictated by how much there is to learn.

Andrew: So, some other questions that they asked: “If you’re returning to the site following the completion of Sorcerer’s/Philosopher’s Stone,” which I said no, I’m not coming back. I’m sure you guys said that, too, right?

Micah: Well, I didn’t take the survey.

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: But…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: You would have.

Micah: …I would have said no as well.

Eric: We would have, yeah.

Andrew: “Do you care about house points?” Again, I said no. [laughs] House points…

Micah: But see, this is the community aspect that I was talking about before. If there was more of a way to interact with the other members of Pottermore, I think that people would care about house points. It just seems like it’s lacking that interaction value.

Eric: It’s kind of like…

Micah: For me anyway.

Eric: What, like sitting in the Great Hall and looking to the table next to you and it’s the other house. Ewww, it’s the other house, your rivals right? But now when we’re on Pottermore, we can’t do that. We look off into the distance, we’re just staring at our screen. We can’t see everybody else who we’re competing against, makes it less interactive.

Micah: But also the dueling function doesn’t work…

Andrew: Yeah, it’s down.

Micah: …and that would be something I think would make people interested in house points. Potions, very difficult, but if you do brew them, you get house points. And I would think that they maybe want to start to incorporate things like classes, getting questions right, whether they’re trivia based or just…

Andrew: Oh, that would be cool. Yeah.

Micah: They need more, and I know it’s Beta, but if they’re looking to really launch this thing sometime in 2012 they need a little bit more.

Andrew: They actually asked about the potions. “Do you have an easy time brewing potions?” My favorite question was, “What impression do you get about Sony after partnering with Pottermore?” [laughs]

Eric: Whoa!

Andrew: And some of the options were: “Bold,” “Original,” “Creative.” [laughs] I put no to all of them.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: And that was truthful! Why would I get an impression that Sony is bold, creative, or original by…

Micah: You should have said…

Andrew: …having their logo on Pottermore’s website? That’s just stupid!

Micah: “Where are the e-books?” That should have been…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …your response to that.

Andrew: Yeah, it should have been, “Unreliable.” That’s the image I got about Sony after…

Micah: Well, it’s funny because that question and the one before it, “Have you seen the Sony logo on the site?” are probably the two answers that they actually care the most about.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Sony certainly does, yeah. I mean, they probably put a lot of money into this. So…

Eric: They just need to know that what they’re doing is paying off, but we kind of need to know what they’re doing. So, there is that.

Andrew: Yeah. So, I’m glad they did the survey, because I think they can really learn a lot from it and they’ll finally have statistical evidence showing exactly what needs to be done. It basically – the survey basically addressed every – I think, every single thing that I’ve had a concern with, and that’s good. I think there was a suggestions area and I’m pretty sure I did put in the thing that I talked about on a previous MuggleCast about the pets, taking care of pets. I know some people would find that stupid, but I, myself, would probably fall for it. I would be back daily.

Micah: Yeah, I think people are looking for that complete user experience, that complete Hogwarts experience, and it’s very limited right now.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Yeah, you can’t promise people, “Oh, you’ll escape back to Hogwarts once again,” and then not give them a complete escape. You need to have something in there for everybody.

Andrew: What else is going on in the news?


News: ‘Deathly Hallows – Part 2’ Oscar Push


Micah: Well, turning our attention a little bit towards Deathly Hallows – Part 2, it seems like W.B. is making a pretty big Oscar push right now for the final Potter film. You posted on Hypable a picture of a billboard that you came across when you were eating at your favorite local restaurant.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s Chick-fil-A, by the way.

Micah: Chick-fil-A.

Andrew: I just wanted to let everybody know.

Micah: Are they sponsoring this show?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: No, but me and Eric both like it.

Micah: They might be, in the future.

Eric: They should, yeah.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: They really should. Andrew, we should get on that.

Andrew: [laughs] Okay, I’ll look into it.

Micah: But you’re actually seeing a lot of W.B.-based promotion. I know they put a video together, they sent out a booklet, and it looks like they’re going to pull out all the stops as far as pushing Deathly Hallows – Part 2 for numerous Oscar nominations.

Andrew: Yeah. And a reminder, they said they were – well, not they, but Variety wrote an article a couple of weeks ago saying that this would happen – or a couple of months ago saying that Warner Bros. had every intention of making a “big push” for it to be nominated in all the categories that they’re pushing. I know, at least on the promotional material, they’re particularly highlighting Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Adapted Screenplay. And on the booklet that they’re handing out to potential Oscar voters, on the back of it they list everything that it’s nominated for, Best Supporting Actor, Best Actor, Best Actress/Supporting Actress, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, and a bunch of others. So, I’m glad they are doing this, but does it work? If I’m an Oscar voter, and I’m driving through Hollywood and I see this billboard, am I encouraged to vote for Harry Potter?

Eric: Yeah. I mean, I feel like in the same way that any advertising works or doesn’t work, right? You have people who are more affected by it, right? I mean…

Andrew: But are Oscar voters persuadable? I mean…

Eric: Yeah, I don’t know.

Andrew: They’re smart people, right? They can’t…

Eric: Are they?

Andrew: [laughs] I don’t know!

Eric: No, I mean, isn’t there this whole – I mean, a lot of people – I’ve seen books published about the runner-up for Best Picture and things, some questionable Best Picture – that’ll always be a highly-debated topic of what they choose and why. But, at the same time, I don’t know Oscar voters. I’ve never been one or met one, so I have no idea.

Micah: Well, one thing that I’ve noticed – and I don’t really know anything when it comes to movies, really – is that it seems like the field is weak. A lot of articles are saying that – especially as it relates to the Deathly Hallows, saying that this could be the movie’s opportunity, the best possibly since the films were created to really pick up some awards in 2012 because the field just doesn’t have the same movie power, I guess, as it has in years past.

Andrew: Well, I agree with that. I certainly agree with that.

[Prolonged silence]

Andrew: Good luck.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Good luck, Harry Potter.

Eric: Yeah, so we’ll see.

Andrew: Well, I guess – in closing, W.B. must believe that this kind of promotion works, otherwise why would they do it? I mean, they are this industry, they should know that if they promote it this much, it should certainly increase their chances. So, they’re doing it for a reason.

Micah: And look at what happened with Return of the King, how it completely swept…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …Oscars when it didn’t previously do very well, or win anything at all for the first two Lord of the Rings films. And Harry Potter hasn’t won an Oscar at all for any of the previous seven films up to this point.

Eric: Right, it’s kind of just like, oh, by the way, this series is the most amazing feat in filmmaking ever for Return of the King. It just got everything, and I’m not saying it didn’t deserve it, but you’re right, it was kind of a surprise that year because it was just like that whole year was dedicated to Lord of the Rings and wasn’t it kind of – I mean, I think I’ve heard people suggest that it was kind of – not back payment, but like, we’ve owed you this kind of recognition across from previous films. Previous films didn’t get much, da da da da dah, but here’s all of them this year [laughs] because – nice work.

Andrew: All right. Before we continue with today’s news, we’d like to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than, get this, 100,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many New York Times Bestsellers. For listeners of this podcast, Audible is offering a free audiobook to give you a chance to try out their great service. One audiobook to consider is Inheritance, Book 4 in the Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini. It was just released, and those of you who are big Eragon fans will not want to miss the fourth and final book in the series. It’s the much anticipated, astonishing conclusion to the worldwide, best-selling Inheritance Cycle. So, to get Inheritance, or any other book of your choice, visit AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast, and we thank Audible for supporting the show.


News: Harry Potter: The Definitive Collection Release Date


Micah: Harry Potter: The Definitive Collection is set for release in…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …2012, and this is no surprise. The Potter films will come back out of the vault, at least for a short period of time, and what do you guys think? There’s a small trailer about forty seconds long. There’s nothing really, with respect to a feature’s section of this package, and I don’t think we probably will see that until maybe after this DVD/Blu-ray has been on shelves for a little while.

Andrew: What do you mean? The one coming out now?

Micah: Yeah, the one that’s coming out, or – I guess this show will be after its release, so the one that was released on Friday.

Eric: Well, I wouldn’t expect to see any kind of feature list until a couple of months from now because I’d like to think, in my mind, that they’re still working on some of the stuff, because if it’s features they already have filmed and stuff, and arranged, they should have released it on this box set. I just think – and I did a little review of the Blu-ray/DVD combo that I think we all have, and that trailer at the beginning of it is kind of – to me, was tasteless a little bit because you just buy a movie – presumably you have just purchased this movie and it’s like, here’s where – you can buy the movie again in this big set. Hello! [laughs] If you had just waited, here is the collection you could have gotten. So…

Micah: Well, that’s why I’m agreeing with you. I’m saying I don’t think you’re going to see a list of features probably for maybe another two months or so until you get into the new year because right now, Warner Bros. is all about promoting Deathly Hallows – Part 2 on Blu-ray and DVD…

Eric: Well, I was…

Micah: …as well as the eight film collection.

Eric: I was surprised that there even was a set though, honestly, because if they’re worried at all about…

[Eric’s phone makes message sound]

Eric: Sorry. Because if they’re worried at all about bothering people, [laughs] they shouldn’t have included that trailer on this thing, because that…

Micah: And here’s my other question, is how does the eight film collection differ from the Definitive Collection? [laughs]

Eric: Well, the Definitive Collection is definitive.

Andrew: It’s just branding.

Eric: Isn’t it…

Andrew: It’s just – yeah. I mean, can you top “definitive”? So, theoretically this should be…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: …the last one…

Eric: Right.

Andrew: …ever. [laughs]

Eric: Can you top “definitive”? Director’s cut, maybe? I don’t know.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, that’s the thing.

Eric: Definitive…

Andrew: So, hopefully there are – listen, they’re definitely saving things for future releases, whether it’s new deleted scenes, new featurettes, all that stuff. They’re definitely saving…

Micah: Bloopers.

Andrew: Bloopers, right! So, I think they’re holding some of that back and that’s what you’ll see in the Definitive Collection next year.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And by the way, I will guess now that it probably will come out about this time next year. They’ll want it for Christmas, it’ll be a Christmas release, holiday season release.

Eric: You think so?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I think we’ve been cautioning people on this podcast, and everybody just has to kind of be smart with your purchase. If you don’t need all eight films on Blu-ray now, wait until the Definitive Collection comes around.

Andrew: Yeah.


News: Harry Potter Films Not Pulled From Store Shelves Outside of US


Micah: Well, Andrew, to your point, though, for people here in the United States if in fact that Definitive Collection comes out in December 2012, they may want to get Deathly Hallows – Part 2 [laughs] on Blu-ray or DVD because we reported on the podcast, I think it was the last show, that the Harry Potter films here in the United States are going to be going into the proverbial vault.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: And – but that won’t, however, be the case for those overseas.

Andrew: Yeah, lucky people.

Micah: Which is interesting. So, if you want, go and purchase the French version of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 on DVD and Blu-ray if for whatever reason, you don’t get it before December 29th.

Eric: Well, you will need a multi-region DVD player.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s…

Micah: Then fly to France and…

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Buy a DVD player…

Eric: Get a DVD player.

Micah: Find another…

Andrew: …and buy the power converter.

Micah: Yeah, find a Potter fan. I’m sure there’s a few there.

Andrew: Well, I’m announcing – starting next year, I will be making voyages on boats, like Christopher Columbus…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …eastward to get copies and bring them back to America. And I will be selling them for higher prices, but I will be bringing Harry Potter to America.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Eric: Sounds good.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: All right. And…

Andrew: It’s my new business.


News: Future Universal Harry Potter Theme Parks


Micah: …last bit of news that we have, the head honcho at Universal has said that there are plans in the works for more Potter theme parks. Now this is different than expansion.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Is that…

Micah: Universal chief Ron Meyer…

Eric: Is that an official title, “head honcho”?

Andrew: Well…

Micah: Yeah…

Andrew: …that’s what Deadline called him, so…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Wow.

Micah: He’s also referred to as Universal chief.

Andrew: Or Movieline. Yeah, whatever.

Micah: But I like “head honcho”.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: It just sounds cooler.

Andrew: What’s wrong with “head honcho”?

Eric: That’s…

Micah: No, I like it.

Eric: He went to business school to become head honcho, clearly.

Andrew: By the way, this guy is a little out there. He probably wasn’t supposed to say that other Potter parks are in the works, because he also crapped on multiple Universal films…

Eric: What?!

Andrew: …which he owns. Yeah.

Eric: [laughs] Which he owns.

Andrew: Sorry, it wasn’t Deadline, it was Movieline. Yeah. So, isn’t that interesting? So, they’re working on other Harry Potter parks. I thought this was huge news. But I guess just because it was such a short remark and…

Micah: Yes.

Andrew: …kind of off the cuff, it wasn’t that big a deal.

Micah: That was the remark.

Andrew: What? Oh. [laughs]

Eric: I don’t know. They don’t really have other Universal parks, right? Besides California and…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Is there an overseas Universal Studios?

Andrew: Well, no. But there was a rumor a long time ago – actually it sounded more credible than a rumor. I can’t remember exactly when it happened, it may have been about a year ago. Some park in India was apparently working with Universal to bring Harry Potter

Eric: Yeah, I remember that.

Andrew: I think it was India, yeah.

Eric: I remember that story.

Andrew: So, that could be one. But it was plural. The question was, “Are you working on other parks?” And the problem with bringing Harry Potter to Universal L.A. is that it’s really small.

Eric: Oh yeah, you’ve said…

Andrew: Now I haven’t been there, but that’s what I’ve heard. And if you look at it on Google Maps – I mean, it’s in a mountain, so they really can’t… [laughs]

Eric: Well… [laughs]

Andrew: There’s really limited room to expand.

Eric: Maybe they’ll do a Gringotts park, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’s all underground?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, exactly.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: So, they may – I think whatever they will do, if they do something in Hollywood, I don’t know if it will – unless they’re going to buy land elsewhere and just build – I mean, that would be amazing if they built a second park in L.A. separate from Universal Studios L.A., but who knows? I mean, at the earliest, this stuff could be opening 2014, 2015, 2016, so it’s still a long way off.

Micah: Do you think it’s possible that the one in Orlando will see expansion before there’s…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …another park somewhere else?

Andrew: Or at the same time.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Because – and remember, in the contract between Universal and Warner Bros. they have some agreement where the park has to see additions every two to three years in some form. And there have just been so many rumors about additions to the one in Orlando and obviously, Universal Orlando wants more additions, because it will bring everybody back.

Micah: Oh, yeah. And they can have another Home Entertainment Celebration.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Or some other celebration. But yeah, I think – well, that’s a good transition, isn’t it?

Andrew: What’s the next story?

Eric: Into the…

Micah: As far as…

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Eric: Well, as far as the celebration.

Andrew: Oh. Yeah.


News: Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration


Eric: So – yeah, with the film’s release on DVD and Blu-ray, which we’ll be getting to very shortly, they are actually having a celebration down in the Harry Potter Wizarding World theme park that’s called the Warner Bros. Home – or Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration. They’re having a few events and a few press events, and twenty of the actors and cast members – I guess I don’t know the difference – and filmmakers are going to be in attendance down in the Wizarding World for these press junkets, and there’s going to be a red carpet event. And honestly, I think Micah and I had the same reaction, and I think, Andrew, you, too. It’s kind of just another celebration, [laughs] you know? It’s all the Harry Potter films on Home Video. So, it’s really exciting they kind of want to go out with a bang, but this really is the end of the end of the end, as far as celebrations go.

Micah: For now.

Andrew: [laughs] For now.

Eric: I mean, can we really expect to see all these actors come back again?

Micah: Well, probably when the studio tour opens, they’ll do something.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Well – and also, I think – I predict they’ll want to do these Home Entertainment Celebrations every year, around every November, because if this one goes really well, they can sell these higher-priced tickets. Maybe they won’t have as many actors back as they are this time. But then again, the grand opening of the theme park, everybody said, “Oh, how many – will they all come back again?” And look, they’re all coming back again. [laughs] So…

Eric: So fascinating.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s cool. I’m sure it will be a fun event. Eric will be there. And I don’t know if this episode is coming out on Saturday or Sunday, but there’s a live stream from E!, I can’t remember what day it is.

Eric: Yeah, E! Online. I think it’s Saturday evening.

Andrew: Okay.

Eric: They’ll have that there.

Andrew: So yeah.

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: I hope it’s a fun event.

Micah: I mean, everybody seems to make their way down to the Wizarding World at one time or another. I know you have a story in here about James Cameron, the director of Avatar, and he was apparently scouting, I guess…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …the Wizarding World for his own theme park that Disney is going to open within the next few years.

Andrew: Yeah, Disney World’s answer to Harry Potter is going to be Avatar World…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …Land, whatever you want to call it. And it was just funny to me that James Cameron – it wasn’t like an official visit, there wasn’t publicity photos released by Universal or anything, but somebody at Universal the same time James Cameron was there took a couple of pictures of him inside the Wizarding World theme park. And it was just funny because a lot of people were saying when this original Avatar announcement was made that, “Oh, look, this is definitely in response to Harry Potter.” So, it was just a funny little thing. I was amused. But that’s what they need to do, they need to look and see what worked in Harry Potter World, and clearly the amount of detail and appreciation for the series that you see in it, I’m sure James Cameron and Disney are really going to be interested in being as loyal to James Cameron’s film as possible when they’re making the park.

Eric: Yeah, I wonder if they’re replacing Animal Kingdom, because they already have that huge giant tree.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Bad joke.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Bad joke.

Andrew: I kind of got it.

Micah: Are they going to make the tree fall down every day?

Eric: Yeah, daily.

Micah: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: At 1 PM and 6 PM. And the evening show is fireworks.

Micah: But – just on that real quick, I know we talked about it on a previous episode, but I remember one person writing in saying that while Avatar doesn’t have the same draw as Harry Potter from a fan standpoint, Disney just does so well from an overall standpoint that, because of the traffic that Disney gets on a regular basis, that new section of the park is going to do well regardless.

Eric: That’s true.

Micah: Do you agree with that, Andrew? Because you go pretty often to Disneyland.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, Disney – you can’t beat Disney no matter what. Universal – the Wizarding World, in particular, is a great park but you go to Universal and you just see so many differences, and it really makes you appreciate what Disney does in terms of park cleanliness, just how they treat their guests, all of that. It’s a much better experience. And hopefully Universal will get better in time, but right now Disney is definitely supreme.

Eric: Well, I think, too, with Disney, they have a lot of other parks and a lot of other really strong parks, where in the past we’ve said Islands of Adventure is kind of scarce at times in terms of having something that’s equally as exciting as the Harry Potter Wizarding World to go off to. I mean, I’ve always enjoyed Universal Studios Florida when I’ve been there and the rides there are really strong, but it just seems like Disney – just count them, they have far more official parks and lands to go and visit. So, I think in that way, Disney is a very clear competitor to Universal and, like you said, anything with Disney’s name on it is going to possibly hurt Universal but it’s also going to be fairly successful.


Main Discussion: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review


Andrew: So, that’s it for the news except for the biggest story which will be our main discussion this week, which is the Harry Potter

Micah: LEGO Harry Potter!

Andrew: Oh. [laughs] Yeah, that was released, too. [laughs] Actually, Micah’s getting a review copy of that and he’ll review it in a future episode. Anyway, Deathly Hallows – Part 2 came out on DVD/Blu-ray this past Friday in America. Sorry, UK people. I know you have to wait a few more weeks but…

Eric: December 2nd.

Andrew: We’re going to review it now and we won’t…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I don’t think we’ll spoil too much that’s not…

Eric: There’s a…

Micah: Nothing that’s not already, really, on the web at this point.

Eric: Right, because I did a 5,400 word review [laughs] on the site, on MuggleNet.

Micah: And people leaked videos.

Eric: That’s the thing, the videos of every single interview and – they just chopped up all the interviews on the DVD and put them on the web. I don’t know if Warner Bros. was behind all of it…

Andrew: And W.B. doesn’t seem to care.

Eric: Yeah. They’re all just…

Andrew: They’re on YouTube. They could easily get them off YouTube if they wanted.

Micah: They’ve let it go at this point.

Eric: YouTube is very…

Micah: They spent so long trying to get trailers and other things…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …off the web that they’ve just given up.

Andrew: And I’ve been taking transcripts and posting them on Hypable for some of the highlights [laughs] from the conversations, just been writing transcripts.

Micah: Well, text is a bit different. I think you’re okay with text.

Andrew: Yeah. And I’m not taking everything, I’m just taking a couple of highlights.

Eric: Video is just like – so much of it. It’s crazy.

MuggleCast 242 Transcript (continued)


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: “A Conversation with JK Rowling and Daniel Radcliffe”


Andrew: Okay. So, we’re going to go through some of the features that stood out to us. First of all, probably the thing most people were looking forward to, I know I was, the JK Rowling/Dan Radcliffe one-on-one conversation. They were speaking only to each other. There was no interviewer in the center, it was just a conversation between the Harry Potter actor and the Harry Potter author, which was a great idea. As for the timing of this, I’ve been trying to figure out when they actually did this, and based on – Dan made one comment about being on set recently, he said, so that made me think this was before the Part 1 film release. But anyway, all the information in it was brand new, and there were a few particularly interesting things that JK Rowling in particular revealed about the books. One was that Lupin was supposed to live, which was very interesting, but I mean, I think she made the better decision by killing him – by killing them both off, because as we discussed long ago on the show, it brought – it was a full circle kind of moment.

Eric: It was that, and I remember…

Andrew: Teddy loses his parents.

Eric: Yeah, that basically creates an orphan, and I think she said she wanted to show that war really did mean that people were losing their family, and that those were the stakes of a war. And it really reminded me of when we were trying to debate whether or not the trio would all survive, because we were thinking, okay, the three most involved people in this war – it doesn’t make sense that all three members of the trio would actually make it through all seven books because they’re on the front lines. And I think it just kind of echoes that sentiment where war is real, and that’s why certain characters that she didn’t expect to get it got it. But then remember what she said about Hagrid, why he survived. [laughs] She said he was never in the – never a contender for getting eliminated, which is in stark contrast to some of the fan polls. I know whenever we polled people, “Who’s going to die?” everybody was like, “Hagrid, Hagrid, Hagrid!”

Micah: Well, she said that…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …he would have been a natural choice if he hadn’t been the one who was responsible for bringing Harry to Privet Drive, because she always – again, talking about bringing things full circle – wanted to have Hagrid be the one carrying Harry’s supposed dead body out of the Forbidden Forest. So, you have sort of that connection again, that Andrew was referring to.

Andrew: Yeah, and that was great. That was very smart on her part. Let’s see, what other – this was the biggest: JK Rowling “seriously considered” killing Ron.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: This was a bombshell.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And she spoke, saying – what did she say? [laughs]

Eric: She said – well, later she said that she enjoys writing Ron, [laughs] because Dan asked her who she enjoys writing the most and she said, “Well, Dumbledore’s always been part of my head, but then I enjoy writing Ron.” And I said, “Hang on woman, you just said you were going to kill him for, like, five books!”

Andrew: And she said the reason she was considering is because she went through a dark period while writing the books…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …and she was just in this – she said, quote, “I wasn’t in a very happy place. I started thinking I might punish one of them off out of sheer spite.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And then she said, “Midway through the series, in my absolute heart of hearts, although I did seriously consider Ron. Anyway, I can tell you it’s a real relief to talk about it.”

Micah: So, he wouldn’t have even made it to Deathly Hallows?

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Is that what she was saying?

Micah: I thought so. I thought you just said mid-series.

Andrew: Well, no, I thought she meant midway through writing the series, she considered – like say she was writing…

Eric: Oh.

Andrew:Goblet of Fire, Order of the Phoenix, and she was like, “Yeah, Ron will probably die by then.” That’s how I interpreted it, but maybe not.

Micah: Right.

Eric: It’s just so weird…

Micah: Well, also, remember she thought of killing Arthur Weasley in Order of the Phoenix, too.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Mhm. Yeah. And just thinking about…

[Eric’s phone rings]

Eric: Jesus, I silenced my other phone, but this phone…

Micah: How many phones have you got?

Eric: Several. And so – anyway, just thinking about some of the characters, killing – she would have had to – if she had killed Ron earlier than Book 7 – I think you bring up a good point, because then she would have had to deal with the other characters’ reactions to his death, right? If she killed him in Book 5, Book 6 would all be like, “Oh, I wish Ron were here,” and it would be all depressing and sad, and she’d just have to keep going back to it. I think when she’s chosen to kill characters, it’s been those characters that the people who care about them are still able to move forward, whereas Ron just seems to be even more central to Harry and Hermione than Dumbledore or even Sirius.

Andrew: I believe that Ron – it was a good idea to kill Ron, or one of the trio members…

Eric: Really?

Andrew: …because I just think it was too perfect that the three made it through the entire thing. I mean, they were all – all faced so much trouble throughout the series, and especially in Book 7. I think one of them finally should have got what was coming to them.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: It just – it’s too perfect. And having Harry and Hermione suffer that loss, for Hermione to suffer the loss of somebody she loved, I just think it would have been great.

Eric: Wait, what loss did Hermione suffer?

Andrew: Well, maybe she wasn’t as in love with – I mean, losing Ron, because she certainly – by that point, she was having feelings for Ron.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: They weren’t married, but…

Eric: Well…

Andrew: I just think it was too convenient that all three made it all the way through.

Eric: Well, don’t pity the dead, Andrew. Pity the living.

Andrew: Right. Well, that’s why Ron should have died. Micah, tell us how George R. R. Martin, the Game of – the Song of Ice and Fire author, just kills people non-stop, right?

Micah: Well, without spoiling too much, he has no second thought…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …I would say, when it comes to killing a character. He’s not afraid to kill off the characters. It’s just – you’ll be reading the book, and you’ll think the character is completely safe, “Oh, I’m reading this chapter,” and all of a sudden, that character is dead.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: And he just – he does it because it’s a reality, and…

Andrew: Right.

Micah: …he’s not afraid to – he says, in almost every interview, that he’s just not afraid to kill off the main characters.

Andrew: Mhm. I think that’s great. [laughs] I’m sadistic.

Eric: Yeah, I wouldn’t say it’s a political thing, but there are some things you just shouldn’t do in literature. You can’t make these drastic decisions with no regard for the readership in some ways. I mean…

Andrew: But is it really worth not killing him just to appease the readers?

Eric: Well, I don’t necessarily think that Ron…

Micah: Well…

Eric: …should have died, but at the same time, you realize these – I don’t know, authorship is authorship, right? You have the final say in everything, you shouldn’t care what anybody thinks of you. But at the same time, there are these greater morals and greater things that appeal to a lot of people, and if people can get behind what it is you’re saying, you’re going to be more successful. So, I don’t know if that – I mean, that obviously comes into play a little bit with the Harry Potter series where she did have this tremendous fan reaction to the tiniest things, and you almost can’t take it into account. I think she says even in this interview when Dan asked her about having such a large fan base, she said she really tried to stay unaware of it for a lot of times because it would affect sort of her writing and change her sympathies for the worse.

Micah: Yeah, but tying it back just for a second to the A Song of Ice and Fire series, those characters – by the second book, let’s say, in the series – are immersed into war. And JK Rowling points out that one of the realities of war is that people die, families are destroyed, and I think that that’s why she did kill the characters that she did in Deathly Hallows. And I kind of agree with Andrew a little bit that it’s almost too perfect that the trio made it through completely intact.

Eric: Well, I mean, wasn’t I just saying this, too, that they’re on the front line so it doesn’t make too much sense?

Micah: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: Yeah. But then again, it’s not – I mean, there are winners in a war. There are victors and there are losers, and I think the victors – there are families that survive war. There are whole entire families that survive war, in real war. So, why wouldn’t there?

Micah: That’s fair.

Eric: I mean, also…

Micah: And the other thing we should also bring up is that Harry – did he die?

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Oh God.

Eric: Yeah, yeah!

Micah: Because I know somebody is going to write in and say, “Well, technically…”

Eric: Harry died.

Micah: “…Harry did have that moment at King’s Cross that you guys didn’t talk about.”

Andrew: Yeah. All right. Well, that’s fair enough. That’s actually a fair argument. But somebody should have died for good.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Oh, and as Rowling says on the DVD, Harry did have a death scene.

Eric: Yes. That was so funny. And I think one of the things I enjoyed most about this conversation with Dan Radcliffe and JK Rowling – they were telling the story about Matt Lewis, I guess. When JK Rowling approached Matt Lewis at the premiere of – I think it was Order of the Phoenix, and JK Rowling was so inspired to go and tell him that she’s got some great things for Neville in the upcoming book. And I think – didn’t she say he practically screamed back at her, “I don’t want to know!”…

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric:[laughs] and ran away. That was hilarious.

Andrew: This is something we kind of already knew, Alan Rickman did know about Snape and Lily, that Snape loved Lily…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …and that’s why Snape was the way he was towards Harry, treated Harry how he did.

Eric: What’s funny – didn’t Dan say that there were times when he imagined Snape – or, sorry. [laughs] Jesus. Where he imagined Alan abusing that?

Andrew: Not imagined, he did it.

Eric: Oh, he did abuse it?

Andrew: Alan would be on set and say, “Given what I know…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “…I think this should be happening this way.”

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Which is funny.

Eric: And that’s another thing they talked about in “Maximum Movie Mode.” They actually went back to that, and the idea that David Heyman and them didn’t know until a little later on. But I think David Heyman said, too, that’s one of the reasons that Alan’s performance is going to stand the test of time and it’s going to be so successful, is because they – Snape knows and Alan knows, and he was able to portray that even in the first few films. Going back, you can see that he knows. You can read more into his performance.

Andrew: JK Rowling also said that she really wanted Robbie Coltrane. She said that was actually one of the sticking points that she had. She kept asking for Coltrane even though they were looking for different actors, or they were considering different actors.

Eric: It’s interesting, there is a bit in Page to Screen about that, the Harry Potter: Page to Screen, Harper Collins’s second book. And there’s all sorts of concept art about Hagrid, but because Robbie Coltrane was so preferred by Jo, some of the earliest concept art still has him as the basis for it. So, he was like the first person they kind of cast, and it was due to her suggestion. I wonder, though, what she had seen in him that made him – I mean, I’m sure he’s quite well known, but still, in Bond he plays a cripple or a partial cripple. So, he’s not exactly – you can’t get any idea of him being super tall, right? Because he’s crouching and he’s sitting down…

Andrew: I mean, they would have had to make anyone super tall, though. I think what may have stood out for her was maybe his face.

Eric: Well, in real life, he’s very tall, though, right? I mean, that’s the other thing…

Andrew: I guess.

Eric: …is without extenders…

Andrew: Is he? I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah, I feel like he’s just got this reputation. He’s probably been in lots of things in Britain that she would know him from. I just…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: That’s what I was asking. But yeah, he’s just a massive guy. But anybody would look similar, wouldn’t they, in that much of a beard and…

Andrew: Yeah, but it’s also the personality he brings.

Eric: Well, that’s…

Andrew: It’s the acting.

Eric: Yeah. I love Hagrid, and Robbie Coltrane as Hagrid is just dandy.

Andrew: Yeah, he brings the spirit, and sure they buffed him up more, they made him taller, but that’s just the – he’s a very warm person, Robbie Coltrane. He’s just a great actor, that’s what it comes down to. That’s why Jo wanted him, was the acting, maybe not so much the physical appearance even though he certainly fit the part. I mean, they couldn’t have put Alan Rickman into the role of Hagrid. [laughs] They needed somebody who was a bit physically large to help out. What else did we learn here? JK Rowling told Dan that Harry would have a death scene. I’m – was that entirely new? I thought…

Eric: Yeah, I think I’ve heard that exact story before.

Andrew: Yeah, me too.

Eric: So yeah, it probably wasn’t – but again, hearing it – just like anything else, hearing it from them, the fact that they were in this room talking with each other for…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …this extended period of time blows away anything, any other news source that you could get it from.

Micah: Well, Dan also mentioned that prior to that, he played it up as if he knew what happened when he really didn’t.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah. Again, it’s relating to the other actors on set and stuff, and bragging. I think he said he did it at some point. He bragged that he knew what was going to happen, but I think he ended up being caught in the lie, later on.

Micah: And another thing that was interesting, he said that he felt closer to members of the crew than he was to some of the cast and that he was going to miss sort of the day-to-day interaction with members of the crew.

Eric: Yeah, that’s a really personal bit. He’s talking about his makeup team and how, I think, towards the end of the shooting for Deathly Hallows, the films, they mentioned sort of what their next project was going to be or something, but it was going to – basically, it wasn’t going to involve him, so he got very upset because this person who had put on his makeup for ten years – obviously it’s a very intimate thing because you’ve got to do it before every shot, every shoot – was going on to do something else without him, and he said that that really – that’s what hit him the most, I think, emotionally he said, in the interview. And JK Rowling completely understood, and I think – didn’t she say that she had been close to some of her – I mean, obviously it’s not the same closeness, but just – her team of people writing the books, and so she totally empathized with him.

Micah: Yeah. And then Dan mentioned how Leavesden was very isolated because there were no other films that were taking place at the same time, so you didn’t have the cast interacting with other casts, the crew interacting with other crew, it was just Harry Potter which apparently is unique.

Andrew: As we’ve really emphasized on the show, fans pick apart the details about the books versus the films, and they did talk about that a little bit during the interview. Rowling actually addressed Harry’s green eyes, and the gist of the story was that David Heyman, the producer, called Rowling and said, “How important is it that Harry’s eyes are green?” And she said, “It’s not important so long as whoever you cast as Lily has eyes that are similar to Harry’s.”

Eric: Right, because it’s the connection between their eyes that’s important.

Andrew: Yes. And some people brought up a good point when we posted it on Hypable, in the comments. It’s like, “Well, Lily’s eyes don’t look like Harry’s eyes, so what happened?”

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: So, that story is yet to be told.

Eric: Well…

Andrew: But, I mean, what do you guys think? Do Lily’s eyes, I guess in Deathly Hallows in particular, look like Harry’s?

Eric: You mean actress Geraldine Somerville?

Andrew: Yes, her.

Micah: I don’t remember, [laughs] to be honest with you.

Andrew: Yeah, me neither. I don’t even know how to compare eyes.

Eric: The movie’s not well lit. The movie’s not well lit. I think it’s one of those things where it’s like you have to trust the characters when they say that, right? “You have your mother’s eyes.” Okay, I have my mother’s eyes.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Micah: JK Rowling made the perfect comment, I thought, and look, we are more culpable than any other [laughs] group of people because we have torn the films apart on this show many, many, many times. But she even said it herself. At the end of the day, the books are too long to make into very faithful films, and I don’t think that you can kind of respond to that in any way. She’s the author and she realizes this, so that’s just one thing that people are going to have to deal with.

Andrew: A couple of other things here: Dan is allergic – Dan was allergic to his glasses at first.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: He revealed that, which was funny and kind of sad.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah.

Andrew: He didn’t know – they didn’t know what was causing the allergies around his eyes. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, turned out to be his glasses. Why – do you think it says something, like because it’s new to him, so like – because you don’t really get over an allergy, or you can, I guess, but it was like an allergic reaction. He had an allergic reaction to his glasses, but then after a little while it was okay. Or did they change like the type of what his glasses were made of because still to this day, he’s allergic?

Andrew: No, I don’t think he’s still allergic to this day.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: He just said at the beginning, so they must have changed the material that they were made of or something.

Eric: Well, he ended up getting over it because he said that’s the prop he was going to take with him.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Yeah, JK Rowling accused – didn’t she accuse all of them of already having things that they were going to take? [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, I’m not surprised by that.

Eric: Yeah. But everybody will admit to that freely when we speak to them, too.

Andrew: Dan and JK Rowling joke about being dictators, able to mobilize the Potter masses.

Eric: Yeah, that was interesting. That was like the Oprah moment, the JK Rowling/Oprah…

Andrew: [laughs] I was totally thinking that, too.

Eric: Wasn’t it?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Where it was just like, we have so much money, don’t we? We have so much… [laughs]

Andrew: Right, right. Oh my god, we’re so rich. [laughs]

Eric: But really, it was like that kind of – I wasn’t as uncomfortable about it, really, because you have to admit that what they were saying was partially, in a sick world, true. But yeah, basically I think – what did they say exactly?

Micah: They were talking about showing up at the premieres and sort of seeing – I think – and this might also provide some perspective on when this interview was. They were talking about the last premiere and how it poured, and…

Andrew: So, that was Half-Blood – or Part 1.

Micah: That was Half-Blood Prince.

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: Yeah. Or was it Part 1?

Andrew: Part 1, it rained, too. Not as much, though…

Eric: Right.

Andrew: …as Half-Blood Prince.

Eric: Oh, but they were saying…

Micah: But they were…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: How many people were there despite the rain, and that they could easily mobilize this many people. And JK Rowling was referring to, I guess, maybe she was on a book tour and she had seen all these people, and Dan was referring to the premiere. I don’t know specifically what the events were, but I know one of them was a premiere and they were talking about sort of the hundreds, if not thousands, of people that were there and how they could just march on the palace.

Eric: The palace.

Micah: I think Dan joked about…

Eric: I think Dan said something like that. Yeah, he said – because the enthusiasm was so great from everybody, even in spite of the rain, that if one of them, either Jo or Harry, had just said, “Today, we march!” then they could have taken everybody elsewhere.

Andrew: I mean, I assume they were joking but it seems like…

Eric: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Does this surprise them? I mean, they’re seeing their favorite author and their favorite actor, of course they are going to come out in the rain, it doesn’t matter.

Eric: Jo says – is it early in this conversation or early in “The Women of Harry Potter,” where she says that typically authors don’t have that much power, so…

Andrew: Yes, she does say that…

Eric: She thinks it’s totally not disingenuous – or is disingenuous, I forget – for her to be able to say that she is still surprised by any power that the series has afforded her. I thought that was a good quote from Jo.

Micah: Another interesting thing that I thought Dan said early on in the conversation was he was talking about himself, Rupert, and Emma, and he was saying how in the UK, the child comes before the celebrity whereas in America, the celebrity comes before the child, and that’s why they felt that they were able to kind of grow up out of the limelight, whereas – let’s say they had grown up in America, it would have been completely different. Do you guys remember that?

Eric: Yeah. I also remember about the films possibly being filmed in America.

Micah: Yeah…

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …she had a pretty adverse reaction to that.

Andrew: Yeah. That’s why I loved this because they both learnt so much from each other, too.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: We should get to the other features.


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: “Maximum Movie Mode”


Andrew: Yeah, we’re going long here. Okay, so – yeah, bunch of other stuff, you can see the rest for yourself. It’s all in the – it’s almost an hour, the entire JK Rowling/Dan Radcliffe conversation. Also on the DVD was “Maximum Movie Mode.” They had this on Half-Blood Prince, Part 1, and, of course, now Part 2. And I love this, I really do. I read in a review that the “Maximum Movie Mode” – it brings the movie to over three hours…

Eric: It’s two…

Andrew: …because there’s a…

Eric: Well, it’s two and a half hours.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: They count…

Andrew: I don’t know where I read that.

Eric: Well, there’s the things, though – is that they count the credits, so it’s like when you go on the menu and it says timestamp and it’s 2 hours, 47 minutes, they’re counting the credits. But also there are the focus points, you remember those? It’s like on Disc 1, they have the focus points. So, it’s not part of “Maximum Movie Mode” but they pop up during “Maximum Movie Mode” where you can go and view these focus points. But in addition to all the stuff they’re flipping and rewinding and going back and doing in “Maximum Movie Mode,” it also links to those focus moments which are provided separately on the main menu. So, yeah. And those total a half an hour, so that is your three hours right there.

Andrew: And it’s just – and the deleted scenes are inserted, too, seamlessly. And a little deleted scene kind of banner comes up, so you’re aware – in case you’re wondering why [laughs] some special effects weren’t done or why you didn’t see it in theaters. And it’s just great. It’s such a unique way to enjoy the film a second time. So, say you get the DVD and you watch it a normal time like you would in theaters, and then maybe a couple of days later you watch “Maximum Movie Mode.” And it’s exciting because you’re waiting for each new featurette to pop up, you’re waiting for the deleted scenes, and you learn a lot of cool information. And the actors who are in it – Matt Lewis, I know David Barron, the producer – they all have fun and interesting tidbits to share. So, I love “Maximum Movie Mode.” It’s really great. It’s a shame all the DVDs didn’t get them but it’s kind of a Blu-ray thing.

Eric: That’s the thing. Do you think in the Definitive Collection on Blu-ray, maybe they’ll do that? Would it be…

Andrew: That would be cool.

Eric: I mean, it would be cool.

Andrew: But they’d have to shoot so much.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: I don’t know, I guess they could.

Eric: More stuff of them standing. Yeah, well, this was the first time I saw “Maximum Movie Mode,” but I have the Part 1 on Blu-ray and I’ll probably buy the Part 6 on Blu-ray but maybe I’ll wait until the Definitive Collection.

Andrew: [laughs] Part 6?

Eric: [laughs] Or Movie 6 on Blu-ray. But still, I think that this “Maximum Movie Mode” made me want to see “Maximum Movie Mode” for the other ones because more than any documentary is going to do – documentaries are typically only about a couple of things, whereas “Maximum Movie Mode” they were able to take one scene, and talk about all the aspects of the scene, without it taking too much time, because it’s just a quick cut-away that says, by the way, about these masks on the goblins, or…

Micah: Do you feel that it interrupts the movie at all?

Eric: Well, yeah, it does but isn’t that the point? I mean, the movie itself…

Micah: Yeah. No, I was just wondering what your reaction was to it.

Andrew: Yeah, and that’s why you don’t watch it the first time you get the DVD.

Eric: Yeah. Definitely like…

Andrew: You watch it like…

Eric: But yeah. I mean, more to that point, I don’t think there were one or two minutes that went by without somebody interrupting and the film minimizing into picture and picture. That shows – it works two ways. It shows how much material there is to really talk about, and I was happy to learn all that stuff. But yeah, I guess if you don’t want an interruption to the film, obviously don’t choose “Maximum Movie Mode.”

[Micah laughs]

Eric: [laughs] If you want an uninterrupted version, play the version. But yeah, it was very thorough on this disc and it did make me want to go back and see, definitely, the existing ones already on “6” and “7”.

Andrew: And while I’m thinking of it, one disappointment with this one, and Part 1 frankly, is, Half-Blood Prince, the Blu-ray, if you had the Blu-ray you could tune in at a certain time for a live commentary hosted by Dan Radcliffe and producer David Baron. They did this only once and it was just for Half-Blood Prince. And again, it was live so you were watching the movie live with Radcliffe and Baron. It was really cool. And they were taking questions from Twitter or something. It was through this technology called BD Live and if you had the Blu-ray, like I said, you could watch it live with them. And they didn’t do it again and they should’ve! They should’ve done it for Part 2.

Eric: Digital Spy, which I think reviewed this set first, said there is an icon for BD Live.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s on there. I saw it. But I think that’s just so you can connect and you can post through Facebook. And I think you can watch it with other friends. You can sync it up to watch with other friends and talk about it.

Eric: Interesting.

Andrew: Yeah, but…

Micah: Well, it’s possible the Home Entertainment Celebration got in the way of the BD live chat.

Andrew: That’s true. Maybe it was like, “This is too much!”

Eric: [laughs] I mean – but there’s always the opportunity to do it later, right? Essentially – I mean, if it’s the internet…

Andrew: Yeah. Mhm.

Eric: So, that’s good.

MuggleCast 242 Transcript (continued)


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: “The Goblins of Gringotts”


Andrew: That’s true. How about “Goblins of Gringotts”? This was a featurette, a lot of Warwick Davis, a lot of the making of all the goblins, which I know Warwick talked about quite a bit while promoting Part 2.

Micah: I liked it. The reason why is because you learn that they’re all from an agency that Warwick Davis runs for small actors, essentially, and also getting to see that his wife was in the film, that his kids were in the film. I thought that was really cool. And just how much work went in Deathly Hallows – Part 2 to creating this Gringotts scene. I mean, they essentially went all-out. They talked about how – I think they said they only had nine goblins in Sorcerer’s Stone to going to around sixty in this film.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. And still, though, it’s not much more time spent seeing them on screen. It’s just to kind of – to fill out the world, and that’s what I enjoy most about this process, is there’s still – at the end of this ten or eleven minute documentary, we’re still talking about maybe sixty seconds on film, and this whole process of casting and casting the masks of which there were, like, forty-five prosthetic sets. It’s just unbelievable that all this stuff – and when you think of this movie being a multi-million dollar movie and movies these days costing millions of dollars, well, this is the kind of things that rack up that price because even the man hours alone to make the Gringotts scene possible had to be enormous. And you really – I think that’s why I liked this documentary, was because it really broke that down a little bit better for me.

Micah: Yeah, and you also got insight into some of the other actors that had done work in previous Potter films, and you could see that they’re a very close-knit community.

Eric: Yeah, definitely, seeing the actors. Even all the parts that Warwick Davis had played in the past. I think there were two more than I was expecting, so that was really cool.


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: “The Women of Harry Potter”


Andrew: The other big feature was “The Women of Harry Potter” and this was great. Again, a lot of new information. JK Rowling featured very prominently in this. Also, Helen McCrory who plays Narcissa Malfoy, Bonnie Wright who plays Ginny Weasley – what’s her name? – Helena Bonham Carter who plays Bellatrix, and someone else I’m forgetting. Oh, Umbridge. Who plays Umbridge?

Eric: Imelda Staunton.

Andrew: Yeah. And this was…

Micah: Don’t forget Emma Watson.

Andrew: [laughs] Emma Watson. Oh yes, how could I forget? And this was great. I mean, it included lots of good clips about women empowerment, feminism, JK Rowling shared something interesting details about Molly Weasley. We also – Emma Watson was saying how Bellatrix – or Helena Bonham Carter – was a very big influence on her, and she went home after dinner with Helena one night and took some notes about what she had learned from her. Stuff like that. It was really, really great. I’m sure all the female – frankly, anybody should watch it. It is very interesting. I’m glad they did it, too.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: “The Men of Harry Potter” would have been so boring.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: This was actually really good.

Eric: This was a quick thing, too. I mean, it’s twenty minutes, it just zooms through it, and it has sort of – you hear from all of the females involved in the films, and they talk about how they related to their characters and why, and how they related to each other and why. And just having JK Rowling host this – and she really does host this video, and she explains a bit about her process and that she is aligned with the feminist theory that women are not at all boring and that they completely compete with the men. I just liked hearing from Jo about this in addition to everybody else, and I thought that the second disc of this set was very JK Rowling-heavy…

Andrew: It was.

Eric: …because you’ve got this hour of this conversation between her and Dan, and then this Women of Harry’s World documentary, which again she fronts. So, I was just surprised, I guess, that this Deathly Hallows – Part 2 movie had so much JK Rowling content.

Micah: Mhm. And I’d almost like to see – moving forward, if it’s possible – sort of the unscripted conversation that existed between Dan Radcliffe and JK Rowling, because I thought that provided much more information, much more insight. It was sort of a very comfortable conversation and for them to possibly – it’s almost like you wish they would had done that in the past with different actors maybe with a member of the crew. I understand why it’s so special in this case because it is JK Rowling and Harry Potter, essentially.


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: “When Harry Left Hogwarts”


Andrew: Something we haven’t seen yet is – probably one of the cooler things that we’re looking forward to is “When Harry Left Hogwarts.” It’s a documentary by a famed director. He’s very, very well-known – stalling – Morgan Matthews.

Micah: Who?

Andrew: And a trailer was released – [laughs] who? Is that what you said?

Micah: It was a joke because you said…

Eric: Very acclaimed director?

Andrew: I kind of made that part up just to stall.

Eric: I got to tell you, I’m not looking forward to this because…

Andrew: What?!

Eric: For one specific reason, and that is that it’s a cheap marketing ploy that you can only get this documentary as part of the four-part Blu-ray set which I assume is just the Blu-ray/DVD combo pack but with one extra disc that has this documentary on it. And…

Andrew: Only at Target.

Eric: Only at Target. Come on.

Andrew: In the United States.

Eric: Yeah. I…

Andrew: Now, wait a second, that’s not Morgan Matthew’s fault. Warner Bros. bought it from him and then…

Eric: Okay, okay.

Andrew: …they decided to do a deal with Target. So, I don’t think the documentary by any stretch of the imagination is going to be some cheap marketing ploy, but yes, the way Warner Bros. is distributing it, that part is lame.

Eric: Okay, I should have said – yeah, it is unfortunate that this…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: This is sure to be a great documentary, I think, from the trailer and everything you can find online…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …about it. It really looks good. I mean, seeing the trio in the back of a taxi with bags over their heads to cover their identities.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’s just something – it’s the side of the fandom you just don’t see.

Andrew: The basic gist of it, and this is what I think is so cool, is that Morgan Matthews was there throughout the filming of the final two films. So, you really get a great behind-the-scenes look, and he was even there the day the set caught on fire. Remember when that happened?

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Weren’t you there, too?

Andrew: No, I was there, like, a week later, I think [laughs] or something like that. But yeah – I mean, he’s there and you see so much great stuff in it. All the actors: Robbie Coltrane, Alan Rickman, the dude who plays Malfoy, Jason Isaacs – no sorry, Malfoy dad. Helena Bonham Carter – I mean, they’re all in this, so it’s going to be a great documentary. I’m pumped. But – I mean, [sighs] I hate to encourage this, but honestly, I’m not going to go buy another copy at Target, so I’m just going to [laughs] download it online.

Eric: Yeah, it’s just so hard – they’re making it – in the current box set releases, they’re just making it very difficult for fans to get all that there is out there for these films, and that’s what I don’t – that’s my only problem with them.

Micah: Yeah, there definitely should be a place where you can get all of these features. If you want to go and buy, let’s say the Blu-ray triple play, it should have everything in it. It shouldn’t be that they’re exclusive to Target or Walmart or Best Buy…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …or whatever place you’re going to buy it, and that there should be fifty million versions of the DVD and Blu-ray.

Eric: For you to choose from.

Micah: That – I agree.

Eric: And then each of them have a trailer for the Definitive Collection which comes out next year. [laughs]

Andrew: Well, here’s our recommendation, I think it’s very clear. If you’re in the United States, definitely buy it from Target. You get everything if you get it from Target.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Period.

Eric: And that might not have been clear at first, but I think it’s clear now.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: You will get everything if you go to…

Micah: See, what’s interesting is if you get it from WB, you don’t get everything.

Andrew: I know.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah! That’s the real…

Micah: Can somebody explain that to me? [laughs]

Andrew: Well, Target probably paid some extra amount of money to have the exclusive bonus thing. It’s not like Target…

Micah: They’re WB, they own all that.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I know.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: But Target pays them to have this exclusive edition.

Eric: It’s true.

Micah: All right.


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: Deleted Scenes


Andrew: And it brings people into Target. I already go to Target no matter what. I food-shop there. [laughs] Okay, to wrap up – we’re getting towards the end of our review here. The deleted scenes. This is something everybody always looks forward to, and again, these leaked online as well and WB didn’t take them down, which is good for fans.

Eric: There are eight of them and they last a total of under five minutes.

Andrew: Yeah, I know. That was such a disappointment, but I think my favorite was the Hog’s Head with Aberforth.

Micah: With the green screen.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Micah: Where the portrait should have been.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Was this – this was the short one, though, right? It was, like, twenty seconds. And didn’t he just have, like, one extra line that wasn’t in the movie?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: But it was, like, a really important one about Ariana or something dying.

Andrew: Yeah, about Dumbledore wanting to – everybody he treats nicely he ends up screwing over. Or anybody he cares for he ends up screwing over, or something like that.

Eric: Hmm.

Micah: Ends up dying.

Eric: Ends up dying. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh, right.

Eric: Which they then get screwed over. But…

Micah: And he had that – same line he has in the movie. “Oh, nice job?”

Eric: Nice…

Micah: What does he say? He says something very sarcastic.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. “Nice job Dumbledore gave you?” Something like that.

Eric: Yeah. Well, there…

Andrew: “Easy?”

Eric: Aberforth… [laughs]

Micah: Easy, yeah.

Eric: Easy, yeah. I think that was probably from the first round of filming, too, because I think during “Maximum Movie Mode,” David Heyman goes into how they did reshoot the Aberforth scene – or it’s David Yates who says it, and how they did cut out things like that, little bit of backstory, that extra backstory on Ariana that didn’t make it into the film, just for the flow of the scene or whatever. But I think overall, I was really satisfied with the Aberforth content because one of the focus points is focused directly on him, and how they transformed him and stuff. So, you get the feeling that they did care a lot about Aberforth in this scene with Harry and him, but – that deleted scene was interesting, but I saw why it wouldn’t fit back in the movie.

Andrew: Any other scenes that stood out to you guys, the deleted scenes?

Micah: Well – yeah, the first one I was going to say because – it’s called “Shell Cottage” but you get more insight into Harry and how he shouldn’t trust Griphook. It’s almost like Bill is telling him, be very careful sort of the way that you worded your agreement with him, and we know that that comes back to sort of bite him later on, when Griphook says, “I told you I would get you into the vault, I never said I would get you out.”

Eric: Yeah, and just having Domhnall Gleeson have five extra lines in the film I think is a great thing because he’s a good actor. These actors are having their lines cut from the major motion picture as a result of pacing and that’s unfortunate for them, and I like that these were included. Obviously the fact that these deleted scenes are included here shows that there is some real performance or something worth seeing. It didn’t make it into the film…

Micah: You also get a couple more seconds of Fleur as well.

Eric: Yeah, right? Where she donates some of her clothing to Hermione.

Micah: And then also Harry and Luna at Dobby’s grave on the beach. There were two things there: one, you actually see Luna going back to Hogwarts which is something that if you’re watching the movie, you don’t really get because one minute she’s at Shell Cottage, and then the next scene after they break free from Gringotts, she’s magically at Hogwarts. And then also Harry talking about seeing Dumbledore in the piece of the mirror that he has, which I would think would help people who hadn’t read the books understand then more about Aberforth later on.

Eric: Mhm. I think that that kind of a thing, that the plot-line of the mirror kind of got lost between the cut of the film, because obviously in Part 1, he’s looking at the mirror and so that’s when – if that Shell Cottage scene where Ron asks him, hey, what’s about the mirror? – if that had made it into Part 1, I’m sure that that scene would have been kept in, you know what I’m saying? But since it’s been a film since he really looked into the mirror, it might not have needed explanation at the beginning of the film as much as it did.

Micah: And probably the only other one I think people would be interested in is the Hogwarts battlements…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …where Tonks shows up and she mentions Teddy.

Andrew: It was such a small scene. It really – you know, it’s one of those things it’s like, why not? [laughs] Does it really affect the pacing that much that you couldn’t include those two extra lines?

Eric: Yeah, that was…

Andrew: [pretends to whine] I don’t get it!

Eric: Well, if they’re doing…

Andrew: But that’s okay.

Eric: …something else – if the camera is doing something else and the audience’s mind – they have – what was I going to say? They have professors studying this kind of a thing, [laughs] so…

Micah: And I thought it was funny Seamus setting up all the explosives.

Eric: But he doesn’t have any extra lines. It’s a deleted scene… [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, and the other deleted scenes were just kind of okay, I guess. I mean, they didn’t really stand out to me.

Eric: No, and they fit so well back into the film that even in “Maximum Movie Mode,” they’re inserted into the film. So, overall I wanted a little bit more. But that reminds me, none of the deleted scenes – I was looking forward to a deleted scene about King’s Cross – or not King’s Cross, but the epilogue. But fortunately, even though there aren’t any deleted scenes about the epilogue – I did forget to mention that in “Maximum Movie Mode” there is about five or ten minutes at the end of the film devoted to the epilogue in “Maximum Movie Mode,” so it was – there is some extra content about the epilogue, after all. You just have to really search for it. But I think you get a look at – not Teddy Lupin, but Draco’s kid. Is it Scorpius? – and stuff just kind of in the background. Again, not really too much focus. Again, I’m looking forward to more of a documentary maybe on future releases. But as for deleted scenes, I was really hoping for something from – like we talked about the original epilogue with Will Dunn when we spoke with him, and he mentioned it, and it is on “Maximum Movie Mode” to some extent. They do have a bit there. So, I did want to mention that.


Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Review: Closing Thoughts


Andrew: So, overall, quality? Rating? Et cetera, et cetera. I mean, satisfied with this release, final standard film release on DVD? I am.

Eric: Yeah. It’s just I can’t shake this feeling that they’re holding out for something better, right?

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: That’s the thing that interrupts any proper review, I think, is the trailer for this upcoming set. I’m just like, oh, I can rate this right now, but wait a minute, how’s the Definitive Collection going to be in comparison?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: So, yeah, I think as far as content, it’s great. It…

Andrew: It was weird to watch this one in the comfort of my own home.

Eric: You think so?

Andrew: Yeah, just because – I don’t know. I guess because of the number of times we’ve seen it in theaters and just how it was only a few months ago that this came out and that this premiered, which seems so surreal. And now just to watch it at home, and it’s the last one – I don’t know. It’s kind of crazy. But I think it was great. The Blu-ray quality is fantastic. I loved how much JK Rowling was involved in the special features. She certainly didn’t have to be. She’s never really been involved in the DVD special features, but…

Eric: Well, let’s see if she – what if she wasn’t? I mean, what if she was not involved in this film’s special features? The only thing they’d have on Disc 2, besides the Pottermore trailer, would be Warwick Davis, 10 minute, Gringotts, and goblins, and…

Andrew: Well, they still could have done “Women of Harry Potter,” it just would not have been as good. And they could have done a one-on-one conversation, it just would have been with someone else. Who knows – I mean, they could have put Dan with David Yates or one of the producers. I’m sure it still would’ve been interesting, but of course, Dan and Jo is the best combination you can do.

Eric: Yeah, I agree. But I mean, if you’re talking about specific film-related content for a specific film’s DVD and Blu-ray release, don’t you think they could have fit everything into one Blu-ray disc?

Andrew: Mhm. Yeah. Well, the other thing is the reason that they don’t put it all into one disc is that they can leave the film as uncompressed as possible, so the one disc is just the film, they don’t have to compress it much, meaning compress the video quality to make room for the special features. So, that’s the reason for that. But yeah, one disc would certainly be easier. [laughs] I had a question: favorite scene now that you’re re-watching it in the comfort of your own home?

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: Like, you may have a favorite scene in the theater because it’s really big and you’re being – you’re in this surround sound. But what’s the – what’s your guys’ favorite scene now, watching it at home a couple of months after you last saw it?

Eric: Wow. Good question.

Andrew: It could be the same scene, but…

Micah: I really like the Gringotts scene. I like them going down to the vault, but then sort of the escape as well, and just seeing that dragon bust through the top.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And I know we talked about it, whether it was on the live show in Orlando or we talked about it since then, but just the detail that was put into the dragon kind of taking in that fresh air…

Andrew: Yeah, I loved that. Mhm.

Micah: …on top of the bank, he’s been chained up for so long, and those are the types of things that as a fan, you appreciate and you look at and you say, David Heyman, David Barron, Steve Kloves, those guys took the time to sort of include those things in there. But just that whole scene, re-watching it again, I just – that’s one of my favorite scenes in that film.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: How about you, Eric?

Eric: I like – I think I still like Neville’s stand when they’re all in the courtyard after Harry is about to die. I think that scene is very strong because Voldemort obviously has sort of a false giddiness about him, and so he allows Neville to speak his mind. When it becomes clear that Neville is not standing forward to join his ranks, Voldemort still has that ounce of humanity, that glee from moments prior that he lets him speak, and it becomes such an effective speech. I like that character point and some of the special features, talking about that scene, during “Maximum Movie Mode,” talk about how into it Ralph Fiennes got with that performance in the courtyard where at any moment, Voldemort could be looking at you if you were standing in the courtyard. He would play off of different people in the different takes, and so he’s very unnerving to people and I think that that plays through. I think just Ralph Fiennes – it’s probably his finest moment as Voldemort, in that scene.

Andrew: Yeah. Hmm. My favorite scene has to be King’s Cross, I think. I just love Dumbledore’s words to Harry. I love the calmness, I love the emotional release that you finally get at that point.

Eric: It’s good to see Michael Gambon again.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly. And his words are just so great. Now every time I watch that scene I think back to the junket where he said that he teared up when he first started saying his lines in that scene, when he says, “Harry, my dear boy.” He says he teared up the first time he said that, which I just love.

Eric: Oh, man.

Andrew: Yeah. And – yeah, so I think the speech at King’s Cross.

Eric: Do we know why yet he actually changed? Because he amended his line in front of Harry in that scene. He’s like, oh, instead of…

Andrew: I love that!

Eric: But why? What does it mean? I don’t understand the new wording of, “Help will be given to those who deserve it,” instead of, “those who ask for it.”

Andrew: Well, I mean…

Eric: Does that mean that some people are actually going to be turned away?

Andrew: Well, yeah. I mean, because evil people don’t deserve it. Look at Draco when he enters the Room of Requirement…

Eric: But Draco’s not evil.

Andrew: Well, in that scene, he was, though. Okay, that’s not the best example. But I think what Dumbledore’s saying is the good people will be helped at Hogwarts. I mean, look at what happened in that film. Everybody helped Harry because he deserved it. Help will be given at Hogwarts. I mean, everybody was helping Harry. They were defending the castle.

Eric: Okay. Yeah, I always think of that as some kind of incantation, though, that Dumbledore’s saying, you know?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: That’s going to evoke some really dependable ancient magic, which is why I was confused, because I was like, wait a minute, you’re dead. How can you change things now? But that was just me.

Andrew: That’s my take on it. I mean…

Eric: Yeah, I think it makes sense.

Andrew: People, please e-mail in and give your own takes on that. That wasn’t a line from the book, so we’d be interested to hear what you guys think. And that’s our DVD review show. Wow, I didn’t think we’d be talking about the DVD for that long, but evidently… [laughs]

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …there really was a lot of stuff.

Micah: Well, we’ll be talking about it longer on the next episode…

[Eric laughs]

Micah:[laughs] or two episodes from now.

Andrew: Oh, yes.

Eric: Wow. You should change, Andrew, just your phrasing there, not that I’m the king of phrasing, but you said “DVD” when actually [laughs] very clearly it’s now moving onward from DVD. So, I would suggest as a substitute, “Home Video” or “Blu-ray”. But I had the same trouble in my review. I was like, DVD this, DVD that. Wait a minute, there are no special features on the DVD. [laughs] I can’t actually talk about the DVD. But it’s been synonymous with Home Video release ever since the early new century, so…


Show Close


Andrew: So, coming up in the next few weeks, or actually in the next few days, [laughs] we’re going to have Quidditch interviews from New York City. Micah is going to be there, our intrepid news reporter, he’ll be interviewing some of the people at the Quidditch World Cup, the fans, some people involved. And that will be a special episode in and of itself, so that will be fun. And then the episode after that will be our commentary. We will be sitting down together via the wonders of the Internet and watching the DVD in real-time, and you will be able to watch it with us after we release this commentary episode. And what you’ll be able to do is hit “Play” on your DVD/Blu-ray player at the same time that we are, that we do, and you’ll be able to listen to our commentary. It’ll be a lot of fun and those will both be out in the next couple of weeks. And then of course, in December we have some fun shows: a year in review show and then one other. I’m forgetting what we’re going to do, [laughs] but it’ll be great whatever it is.

Eric: Christmas! [laughs]

Andrew: Christmas, yeah, something like that. I don’t know. Anyway, thanks everybody for listening. Don’t forget, our website, MuggleCast.com, has all the information you need about the show. You can follow us on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast, you can “Like” us on Facebook which is Facebook.com/MuggleCast, you can follow our fan Tumblr which is MuggleCast.Tumblr.com, and you can subscribe and review us on iTunes. Leave a review! I don’t think we’ve asked for that in a while.

Micah: Oh, that’s what another show can be, the LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7 review.

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Eric: I do want to see…

Micah: No.

Eric: …how they’ve improved. We talked briefly…

Micah: Well, for those people who – I don’t know if we mentioned it. For those people who do get the Blu-ray, there is a demo on the…

Andrew: For PS3 only.

Micah: For PS3 only, for LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7. So, if you’re thinking about getting the game, you can obviously…

Eric: Is it a long preview?

Micah: …take it a trial.

Eric: Do you know?

Micah: Sorry?

Eric: Is it a long demo, long preview? You said you played it.

Micah: It’s fairly long. I mean, you start in Godric’s Hollow and work your way to Bathilda Bagshot’s home, and that’s as far as I got, but there’s probably a few scenes in there that – and you can watch the story as well. They have that little sort of – what’s it called? They have a little…

Eric: Dancing?

Micah: …short video that you can watch that kind of explains the storyline through LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7. It’s very comedic. So, you can do that as well. You can do that, you can also play the game.

Eric: Oh, interesting. I loved…

Micah: Or you can go buy the game.

[Show music begins]

Micah: The game is out. It came out on Friday, so…

Eric: Yeah. Friday, November 11th. Eleven, eleven, eleven.

Andrew: Well, thank you everyone for listening. We’ll see you next time for Episode 243! From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And from MuggleNet.com, I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Oh wow, you’re serious this time.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Yeah, look at that.

Andrew: We’ll see everybody next time for Episode 243! Buh-bye!

Eric: Bye!

Micah: I was going to say Game of Owns, but…

[Andrew and Eric laughs]

Eric: Next time.

Andrew: You just did!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #241

MuggleCast 241 Transcript


Show Intro


[Show music begins]

Andrew: Because we’re questioning why we even bought the DVDs, this is MuggleCast Episode 241 for October 16th, 2011.

[Show music continues]

Eric: This episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. That’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 241! Eric, Micah, and I are here this week to fill you in on the latest Harry Potter news. Hello gentlemen!

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Hey.

Micah: Hello. [laughs]

Andrew: What’s with the uncertainty?

Eric: No, I’m trying to think of what words I can say without using the left side of my face. I went to the dentist earlier today. I’m still a little numb.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: So, if I sound funny, it’s that. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh. No, you sound all right so far. Are you missing teeth now?

Eric: No, no, no.

Andrew: Or did you get new teeth?

Eric: Yeah, I’m in good shape. The people down at Webster Dental in Chicago took good care of me today.

Andrew: [in a silly voice] Oh my God, shut up!

Eric: [laughs] I checked in there on Foursquare now, too.

Micah: And I was just waiting for Eric to go first…

Andrew: I see.

Micah: …and say hello. That’s why I…

Eric: He’s so polite, Micah. He gets in line just to say hello.

Andrew: [laughs] Well, from Hypable, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet, I’m Eric.

Micah: And I’m just Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Okay. No, you’re not. You have a plug later in the show!

[Micah laughs]

Eric: No MSNBC anymore?

Micah: Oh, yeah, yeah. No. Let’s do that again. [laughs]

Andrew: No, you blew it now.

Micah: Oh, yeah, we’ll talk about it later.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: You’re no longer affiliated with them.

Andrew: [laughs] All right, what’s in the news this week, Micah?


News: New Comprehensive Potter Blu-ray/DVD Collection Set in 2012


Micah: Well, Andrew, this may come as a surprise, but Warner Bros. is not done releasing box sets of the Harry Potter films. There’s going to be more in 2012, and apparently Harry Potter is not going back into that vault.

Andrew: Well…

Micah: That mysterious vault that we heard about, never to be touched from – [laughs] never to be touched from?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Never to be opened…

Micah: Never to be touched or heard from again. But that’s not true. They always open up the vault every once in a while.

Eric: So…

Micah: At least…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Go ahead.

Eric: Last week we were talking at length about these box sets – or on the last episode, we talked about these box sets they have planned for the November 11th release date, and we talked about them I think a good twenty minutes at least, right? I mean, we were talking about some of the features and the DVD and how this set – how there are always going to – I think Andrew correctly predicted there were going to be more.

Andrew: Yeah, and I mean, we know they do this. Warner Bros. does this all the time. But a little correction to what you said, Micah, I don’t think this really counts as “going in the vault.” I think what they were saying when the films were going to go in the vault is they were going to stop production of the individual copies, and presumably the big collections, too. Yeah, so they’ll cease production some specific date at the end of December. It’s after Christmas. And then they’re going to presumably not make any new copies of anything, I guess, until later in the year when they [in a dramatic voice] open the vault to release the super mega awesome edition.

Eric: Now, this awesome edition…

Andrew: Just in time for the holidays, 2012.

Eric: Right.

Micah: Well, here’s the exact wording from Warner Bros. They said:

“Hardcore ‘Potter’ fans will be pleased to know that 2011 is not the end of the ‘Harry Potter’ film franchise on DVD and Blu-ray. Warner Home Video plans to release a comprehensive ‘Harry Potter’ film collection, with even more extras and collectible premiums in 2012. More details about the collection will be available at a later date.”

Eric: Okay, hold the phone. Why would they announce that there was going to be this comprehensive set of Harry Potter films coming in 2012, before they release this upcoming collector’s set full of repackaged junk, as we deduced on the last MuggleCast? Why would they announce this new upcoming set, just even tentatively like they have, kind of, “Oh yeah, it’s coming”?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Why advertise that it’s going to have all these new special features, when you have another set to promote that’s coming out November 11th? Is there any remaining incentive for people out there who are listening to our show to buy these November 11th box sets of all eight films?

Andrew: Yeah, if somebody wants them for Christmas this year. I mean, that’s the one reason.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: And plus, I mean, people are impatient. They want the complete set now. They don’t want to wait until next year to get the complete set. So, I think Warner Bros. was a little strange for announcing this now, but I don’t think they are worried about it affecting sales. And by the way, this press release was really hard to come by. I e-mailed it to Warner Bros. and was like, “Is this true?” and they were like, “You know, I haven’t seen this before. Let me look into it.” And then I never heard back, so I don’t – it may have been mistakenly said. So, I don’t know what exactly went on. But anyway…

Micah: Well – interesting. I mean, I’m just going through the comments here on MuggleNet, and twixie09 says:

“I hate how they’re withholding content from the true fans, making us spend more money just to get another interview or a couple more deleted scenes. We, the hardcore fans, have supported ‘Harry Potter’ through thick and thin, and have supported it two hundred percent throughout the film franchise, and they’re treating us like this. If it weren’t for us, they wouldn’t have made as much money as they did across…”

Okay, it goes on.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Next comment, DudleyCool:

“I find this hilarious. Glad I never bought any of the Ultimate Editions. This collection had better have the extended versions of all the films including the three-hour Order of the Phoenix. At least give us all the unreleased deleted scenes and bloopers WB has been hoarding since 2001!”

Eric: Wow.

Micah: So, you’re seeing a lot of comments here that are similar to what we were talking about on the last show when we had no knowledge about this. We were just talking about this eight-film collection. So, clearly the fans in the comments are starting to get a little bit ticked off.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, the way I’m looking at this, unless you’ve lost your previous collections – I mean, if you want to – unless you’ve lost your previous DVDs in a house fire or something, and need a new collection and you’re entertaining guests and you want to do a Harry Potter re-watch – like Andrew said, prior to Christmas or something, then I can see making this eight collection, because it’s just one cool package. But otherwise – and I know what I will be doing, is I will be waiting until this unknown release date in 2012 to get this new box set with the special features. It just seems like you have to be two steps ahead of these people. You have to wait, somehow deliberately…

Micah: But you will get the Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray so you can watch it before that, or no?

Eric: It’s – maybe. I want to see the Dan Radcliffe, Jo Rowling thing. I might wait to see if that’s online, and if not, I will get the Part 8 Blu-ray – or Movie 8 Blu-ray.

Once again this podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many New York Times Bestsellers. For listeners of this podcast, Audible is offering a free audiobook to give you a chance to try out their service. One audiobook to consider this month, as Halloween approaches, is Carrie by Stephen King. King’s first published novel, Carrie, is centered around a high school girl, who apart from having a stressful home life and being teased by her classmates, develops psychokinetic powers, yet only wants to fit in. The audiobook of Carrie is narrated by Sissy Spacek, who portrayed Carrie in the 1976 film adaptation by Brian De Palma. For a free audiobook of your choice, such as Carrie or many other Stephen King horror stories, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. That’s A-U-D-I-B-L-E-Podcast.com/MuggleCast.

Andrew: What else is going on?


News: Ultimate Editions to be Released in UK in 2012


Micah: Well, as long as we’re on the topic of DVDs and Blu-rays, the Harry Potter Ultimate Edition DVDs Years 1 to 6 that have already been released here in the US are finally going to make their way over to the UK on November 14th, and again, it’s just – we talked a little bit about this on the show last week with Part 2 coming out on Blu-ray and DVD in the UK on December 2nd, but why were the Ultimate Editions never made available in the UK before now?

Andrew: I don’t know, it’s always been a question amongst the UK fans. My guess is that Warner Bros. Home Entertainment is based over here and so maybe they didn’t see as much demand for it over in the UK. That’s my best guess. Maybe they just wanted to wait to release all of them at the same time once they were in the UK. Maybe they consider the Ultimate Editions very much an experiment.

Micah: That’s a good point.

Eric: Yeah, it could be a situation where maybe, too, the UK – the board of film or whoever it is that oversees this kind of stuff wouldn’t let them just re-package old content until very recently. Maybe they had to pay them off and…

Micah: Now is there any difference in terms of – let’s say, somebody from the UK decided that they wanted to buy the Ultimate Edition and have it shipped over.

Eric: Yes.

Micah: They’re not going to have any issue, are they, or they will?

Eric: They are. The difference – it’s PAL versus NTSC, which is what I – the issue that I went through trying to get Philosopher’s Stone on DVD was that I went to Amazon.co.uk, this was early, early on, maybe 2003-ish, and I got it and I paid twenty – the equivalent of twenty pounds or whatever it was. So, I actually – [laughs] long story short, I ended up buying a multi-region DVD player to play that DVD, just for that DVD.

Andrew: That’s hardcore.

Eric: I don’t have any other PAL DVDs.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Just because I wanted the title sequence.

Micah: That is hardcore.

Eric: Just because I wanted the title sequence, when he’s a little baby and the scar, then it leads into “Philosopher’s Stone,” but I wanted to see if it was any different and so…

Micah: So hard for the British, it’s just really not fair.

Andrew: Well, we are the superior country, so…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …they have to work around us.

Micah: Please send your e-mails to…

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Just kidding.

Micah:Andrew at Hypable dot com.


News: Warner Bros. Studio Tour London: The Making of Harry Potter


Andrew: [laughs] All right, what else is going on in the news?

Micah: Lot of the news, really this week, has been around the studio tour, or as – wait, I have to cue this: Warner Bros. Studio Tour London: The Making of Harry Potter.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: Because we want to make sure that we stick by the corporate…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …official title of the studio and…

Andrew: Yeah, you don’t want to confuse people.

Micah: No, we don’t want lawsuits or anything like that. But yeah, a lot of news surrounding – really the last couple of weeks with the studio tour. They got an official opening date of March 31st, 2012, and a lot of promotion had been going on with the studio tour. There was a live web chat for the on-sale date of tickets on October 13th – so just this past week – and it was a very interactive chat, specific for the fans and the fan sites to be able to ask questions via Twitter. A lot of the fan sites were represented and got their questions in there as well, and it was a cool chat to watch. It was Tom Felton, Mark Williams, Julie Walters, James and Oliver Phelps, Bonnie Wright, Warwick Davis, and Natalia Tena, and they seemed to be having a pretty good time. We’ve seen some video surface over the last 24 to 48 hours with different stars going through and taking a tour, and Mark Williams really seems to be having a good time.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I saw him sitting down in Dumbledore’s chair, he was paging through all these letters. But I think fans are really going to like it. The attention to detail that’s been put into all these sets is something that you’re only going to get to experience by walking through, and I know that both of our sites – Richard was over for Hypable and Nick was over for MuggleNet, they got a chance to tour and both of their reports are available on the respective sites. And you really get a deeper insight into how much time and care went into creating the studio tour.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, it’s going to be really cool. It’s going to be an amazing experience. I mean, who doesn’t want to go to the actual sets and explore these things? And you kind of got that with the exhibition, you kind of got that with the Wizarding World, but this is it. I mean, I think they’ve saved the best for last, in terms of – I mean, you really can’t compare it to the theme park, but I think this is the ultimate Harry Potter fan experience, if you ask me.

Micah: Yeah, I don’t think that there’s any question because you’re walking literally where the actors did when they were filming all of these scenes, and in the chat they were all joking around, “Yeah, you might see me hanging out at the back of the studio, or maybe I’ll dress up as a tour guide one day…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, if they pay them.

Micah: “…and lead you around.” [laughs] Yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: But…

Andrew: It looks…

Micah: …it does seem…

Andrew: I think – I like everything that’s been out about it so far, all the reports and stuff, but it’s getting a little too much.

Eric: You think so? Like they’re revealing…

Andrew: All this promo.

Eric: …too much?

Andrew: Yeah, it’s time to keep quiet for a little bit. Let the tickets sell, sit back for a little bit, relax.

Eric: Yeah. I haven’t been watching, mostly because I don’t want to get spoiled on the off chance that I wake up one morning in London and I have a ticket to this thing.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: Because they sold out like crazy and I always plan for those sorts of random happenstance.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: Right.

Eric: But anyway, the way I thought of it – because I watched the trailer, it was the one thing I did see. Maybe – I think it was the actual trailer, maybe it was just the teaser, but essentially, the impression that I got was that these are things that – set pieces, props, that were too big to move. That’s why they aren’t in the exhibition that’s traveling, opening in Australia in a couple of weeks, is because things like the Great Hall, the actual, actual Great Hall have been at Leavesden for these years, and that’s going to be part of the studio tour. And the one piece that I saw in this trailer that I really, really enjoy, was the door, the entrance, to the Chamber of Secrets with the snakes. You may remember this, it’s from the second movie. I don’t even think they show it. Maybe they show it for half a second in Part 2 of Deathly Hallows. But where the snakes – basically, they’re locked in the door, they retreat a little bit, and then one snake comes completely around the door, and so apparently this is like actual mechanics here…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …because they show it in this trailer, and they show the snake going around the door. I want to know how they did that.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I need to see this prop in person.

Micah: Well, they show the guy flicking the switch, don’t they?

Andrew: Yeah, it’s just a mechanical – but I see what Eric is saying, and I mean, that’s what’s going to be so fun about the studio tour, is you really are going to get not just a look at the sets and be able to walk on the sets, you’re going to see how all the stuff worked. So, that will be really exciting for people to see.

Eric: And because – isn’t it a journey through props department as well, and things like makeup and stuff?

Andrew: Yeah, I bet – I would hope so.

Micah: And you’re getting it the same way that the actors did. This is one of the things that they emphasized, is they didn’t remove sort of the scaffoldings, they didn’t remove the lighting, they didn’t remove really anything. You’re getting to see what it would be like if you were actually in that scene filming it, except you don’t have a bunch of other people standing around you, but you get the feel as if you’re actually on set. It’s not – so to make sense of that, it’s not like the exhibition where you walk through and everything is kind of dressed up so that it fits in with a theme. This is literally like walking through a set that’s being filmed on.

Eric: Right. Like fiberglass, plywood…

Micah: Exactly, yep.

Eric: …where the camera ends, and I know a lot of these sets are like this, just from reading Andrew’s past reports, too. Where the camera ends, so too does the set. There’s only – on certain sets there’s just planking and scaffolding and stuff where you wouldn’t expect it, and that’s going to be the appeal, I think, of seeing these sets as they actually were, because honestly, there’s a lot more acting being done in these films than I think we would normally notice, simply because Hogwarts [laughs] doesn’t really exist. It’s these sets with scaffolding.

Micah: Mhm. But tickets are on sale, so go pre-book.

Eric: I thought they sold out?

Micah: They sold out of the allotment that went on sale earlier.

Andrew: The fan sale.

Eric: Okay, because now I’m confused. When was…

Andrew: There was a fan pre-sale, but it was open to anyone who followed the studio tour on Twitter or Facebook, and they sold out of that allotment of tickets. It could’ve been ten tickets for all we know. We have no idea how big this allotment was. But anyway, they sold out and then they did a whole big, “We’re sold out! We’re sold out! We’re so in demand!” and then the other tickets – then the tickets opened for everyone recently. So, they’re open now. You can get them, probably, for almost any day that you want.

Micah: And what did they say, it’s about a three-hour tour and they’re looking to get about five thousand people through every day?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: I mean, that seems like a big number. I can’t imagine five thousand people going there every day, but they may have been exaggerating. Anyway, what else is going on?


News: Charlie Redmayne Named New Pottermore CEO


Micah: Okay. Well, let’s talk about our favorite website, Pottermore.

Eric: [laughs] It’s my homepage.

Micah: Well, a little bit of an update: Charlie Redmayne, who previously worked at HarperCollins, has been named the new CEO of Pottermore, and according to Neil Blair, who is the Pottermore Chairman, he described Charlie Redmayne as, “a formidable talent in both the digital and publishing spheres, and this combined with his entrepreneurial spirit made him the ideal appointment for this role.” Now, I don’t really know much about the staff at Pottermore other than, of course, Melissa, but is this a move being made because there are some serious problems going on at Pottermore?

Andrew: Well, Pottermore has always had, apparently – I didn’t really know this – an interim CEO.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: They never really appointed a long-term CEO, so I don’t think this has anything to do with the issues, but I mean, I think this could be – I’m glad it’s happening now because everybody knows that there needs to be some changes with Pottermore. We’ve talked about them all so we won’t do it again, and hopefully this guy will step in and – he has a lot of experience in the digital realm, by the way. He used to head HarperCollins, one of their digital imprints, I believe, and I hope he gets in there and starts kicking some butt, and being like, “Hey, this is what we need to do. Boom, boom, boom.” I mean, having some fresh blood in there could be really helpful.

Eric: Yeah. Yeah, the interesting thing about this news article for me was that I never thought of Pottermore as being just a company that would appoint a CEO.

Andrew: Right, right, right. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, Pottermore, Inc.?

Andrew: Yeah. Wait, Pottermore has a CEO? Did JKRowling.com have a CEO? I’m so confused.

Eric: [laughs] Now I’m just confused. But yeah, it’s – like you say, change is good, right?

Andrew: Yeah. And I started – I didn’t finish, but I’m writing an open letter to the Pottermore CEO, kind of as a joke, but kind of serious, that I’m going to post on Hypable, and it’s basically just running down the changes that need to be done. And I know he’s not going to actually read it, but I know people will talk about it because it is a good time to start thinking about, “Okay, so what does Pottermore need to do to change? Now they have this new guy in command, what should he do?”

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So…

Eric: Yeah, it’s kind of like, “Welcome, but also here’s what you need to do.” [laughs]

Micah: He’s being thrown into the fire, essentially.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: I mean, with everything that’s been going on with Pottermore – and like you said, not to spend too much time on it – there’s a lot that needs to be fixed before the site does go live to the general public…

Andrew: Yep.

Micah: …and I hope, as was said here in this post, that he is the right person for the next phase of this project.

Eric: To shepherd the next phase, yeah.


News: Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration at Universal Orlando


Micah: So – all right. Well, speaking of corporate slogans – I don’t know if we were really talking about corporate slogans, but Rupert Grint is going to join the cast and crew down in Orlando for – Andrew, what is the official title of this event now? The Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration.

Andrew: That’s right.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: That’s right.

Micah: [laughs] Where there will be PowerPoint presentations inside the Three Broomsticks and…

Andrew: [laughs] Quarterly earnings reports.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Exactly.

Andrew: Wonderful. Well, it’s funny how I came across it. I was going on there to look up something and I went on the home page of what used to be called “A Celebration of the Harry Potter Films,” and I just noticed that the title had been changed to this very bland “Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration.” I’m like, “What? What is this?” So, I click on “Frequently Asked Questions” and the top question is:

“Is ‘Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration’ the same event as ‘A Celebration of the Harry Potter Films’?”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And Universal’s official answer is:

“Yes, the two events are the same. The title of the event has become ‘Harry Potter Home Entertainment Celebration’ to commemorate the Blu-ray/DVD release of ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2’.”

So, it’s just – our issue with it is just the name. “Home Entertainment Celebration” is just so corporate and bland, and I don’t see why “A Celebration of the Harry Potter Films” was a bad name.

Eric: Do you think it was because it’s so exclusive that not everybody can get in. I mean, this is something that – still, it just seems like it would be hard to attend this sort of thing, so maybe they’re making it more corporate to look good on press videos and stuff.

Andrew: Yeah, maybe. I mean, this just seems to me they really want to push that Harry Potter is now all about home entertainment. It’s no longer about the movie theater, it’s you being entertained in your home. I guess that’s what they’re thinking.

Micah: And this is a huge event. I mean, let’s talk about this for a little bit.

Andrew: It’s a Harry Potter conference, practically.

Micah: Yeah, they’re doing this down in Orlando at the theme park and they have a ton of cast that are expected to be there. We just mentioned Rupert Grint but also James and Oliver Phelps, Warwick Davis, Evanna Lynch, Mark Williams, David Bradley who plays Argus Filch, and Jessie Cave who plays Lavender Brown, and there’s more to come. And it’s just amazing that – this is like when they had the Part 1 DVD being released and they kind of combined it with the exhibition opening here in New York City. They made this huge deal.

Eric: You’re right!

Micah: And they had tons of cast and crew that were here. I mean, it seems like they’re doing the same thing, and I guess it’s just because, okay, this is the last movie, this is the last, essentially, Blu-ray and DVD. Let’s blow this thing out.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: You’re right. Remember those panels of, like, 23 actors going and sitting in New York City. That’s crazy.

Andrew: I think it’s also maybe a test to see how well – if this thing goes well, I can almost see them doing this every year, or at least Universal doing something every year. This event coming up is very much a team effort between Universal and Warner Bros. but I can see them doing this every year as like a – kind of like these Harry Potter conferences: LeakyCon, Infinitus, all these ones over the years. They may have looked at those and been like, “Well, wait a second, why don’t we just do this?” [laughs]

Eric: In our own park, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: On our own – yeah.

Andrew: And they can actually get the stars there and…

Micah: Well, I mean, who doesn’t want to leave cold and rainy England to go to sunny Florida in the middle of November?

Andrew: Are you talking about the stars, or…

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: That’s true.

Eric: Well, I wondered, too…

Andrew: So, it’s easy to get them over there.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: They probably get paid to do it, so…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I wonder if it was in their contract, though, as part of their obligation to promote the film, because I wonder now if the studio is looking at home video as being this market that needs more money thrown at it, and needs more attention to actually selling and promoting these films on home video as opposed to seeing them in theaters. I wonder if that’s sort of also potentially why they’re doing this, is to promote – because I mean, they renamed the event, “Harry Potter comes out on Blu-ray.” That’s the new title it plays, so you really kind of wonder what their goal is in terms of – I mean, they just want people to know that, that it’s out on home video for some reason.

Micah: Mhm. And it’s going to be a huge event. Those actors that we mentioned are just a handful of those who are expected to be there. So again, this is just a – to me, it seems like a little bit overkill.

Andrew: What’s overkill?

Micah: This kind of an event…

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: …for releasing a DVD or Blu-ray.

Andrew: Well, yeah. I mean, like you said, they want to have a blowout. It’s the last one, so it all ends here. All right.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: So, is that…

Micah: Again.

Andrew: …all the news?

Micah: That’s it.

MuggleCast 241 Transcript (continued)


Chapter-by-Chapter: “The Woes of Mrs. Weasley”


Andrew: And Rupert Grint is attending, I don’t know if you mentioned that, but that was a late addition. Okay, so now let’s move on to Chapter-by-Chapter. This week, we’re looking at Order of the Phoenix, Chapters 9 and 10, two very interesting chapters. As I was reading them earlier, I was like, “Ooh, I want to talk about that. I want to talk about that.” So…

Micah: So, go ahead, Andrew.

Andrew: Let’s start talking about… [laughs]

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: No, you go ahead please, Micah.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Andrew: You lead the first chapter. I will…

Micah: I think I ended up with the longer chapter.

Eric: I don’t know.

Andrew: That’s your fault.

Eric: Mine’s pretty long.

Micah: That’s my fault for just selecting the chapter without knowing. All right. Well, Chapter 9, “The Woes of Mrs. Weasley” – and when we last left Harry, he was leaving the courtroom and had been cleared of all charges against him for the Patronus Charm that he had cast earlier in the summer. And we talked a little bit about this on the last episode about Harry being tried before a full court, but Mr. Weasley, as he’s watching everybody pile out of the courtroom, is shocked that Harry was tried before a full court.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: So, I don’t know what more we can say about it, but you just get more of a feeling of how Harry probably should have just been reprimanded but instead, he’s put essentially on a full criminal trial.

[Phone rings]

Eric: The thing that I always saw as suspect here is that if you are in a wizarding family – basically what JK wrote about the Trace was that if you’re in a wizarding family, you don’t even have the Trace. It’s expected that you’re raised correctly and I guess the Trace is how they found out that Harry was using – it’s underage magic. Not only is it in front of a Muggle, but in general it’s underage magic. Just the idea that they don’t trace wizard-born kids at all so they can’t ever really hold a trial for them versus this treatment that Harry has gotten makes it even worse, I think, because they’re only watching Muggle-borns, essentially, or only watching people like Harry who – it’s just a disadvantage.

Micah: And one of the people that comes out of the courtroom is Percy, so we get a little bit more insight into the relationship, or lack thereof, between Percy and his father, and they both basically ignore each other. Now as Harry and Arthur make their way out of the courtroom area, they run into Lucius and the Minister, and the two of them are talking very intently with each other, whispering. And Lucius asks Mr. Weasley what he’s doing there, to which he replied, he works here, which I thought was a pretty good response.

Andrew: Yeah, it makes sense.

Micah: And then…

Eric: It’s the truth.

Micah: Yeah, it’s the truth. Lucius, though, then says to Mr. Weasley, “Not here, surely,” and he kind of motions towards a door and that door has large implications later on in the series, but clearly you can tell that something is going on behind the scenes that we don’t really know about. And the question that I have is, just what was Lucius doing down there as opposed to meeting the Minister outside of his office? It’s the same question that Harry poses to Mr. Weasley.

Eric: Yeah, it just seems so dodgy, right? We know how hard it was for Harry to get down to this courtroom. The elevators don’t even go down this far for crying out loud, so it seems very likely that Lucius is either scouting out the location – we know by this point, it’s been mentioned that some of the Order is standing guard over something, essentially this door, it’s revealed later. And either Lucius is looking around maybe scouting out weaknesses, or he and Fudge are down here because they’re conducting less-than-legal business.

Micah: Mhm.

Andrew: Yeah, and maybe…

Micah: Yeah, they’re…

Andrew: Maybe he just kind of takes pleasure in seeing Harry in this situation with Mr. Weasley.

Micah: Yeah. And to your point, Eric, there’s that mention of – Harry almost hears something along the lines of a clinking sound, thinking that Lucius is playing with gold that he has in his pockets, so you get that feeling that perhaps he’s paying the Minister off for some things that he may be doing that are less than legal, let’s say.

Eric: Yeah. Definitely. Creepy guy, Mr. Malfoy. I’d hate to think what he would be like to have as a dad, for crying out loud.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Just like walking around paying people and coming home and…

Micah: Right.

Eric: …expecting dinner on the table. Anyway, I got sidetracked.

Micah: Now, Harry raises another question and he says, why is it that – or could it be possible that Fudge, in dealing with somebody like Mr. Malfoy, could be under the Imperius Curse? And Mr. Weasley responds by saying, “Don’t think that we haven’t thought about that, but right now Dumbledore believes Fudge is acting of his own accord, which is not comforting.” And this just goes to a larger plot or character analysis, I guess, of Fudge saying that he’s willing to talk to known or prior Death Eaters.

Eric: That’s true. That’s very true. I mean, money goes a long way, I guess, even in the wizarding world, because Lucius was very determined to not let his status in society crumble.

Micah: Right. And Dumbledore saying that – or Mr. Weasley relaying Dumbledore’s concerns that Fudge, he’s acting of his own accord right now and that’s scarier than if he was under a curse.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, we’re getting a look at what’s going to become the downfall of Fudge.

Micah: Yeah. So, Harry ends up going back to Grimmauld Place, and everybody seems relieved, and they all knew that Harry was going to get off, but – I’m sorry, Harry says that everybody seems relieved, even though they all knew that he would get off in the end. Everybody was saying, “Oh, we knew that they didn’t have a case against you,” and, “Of course you would get off, blah, blah, blah,” so Harry makes a little bit of a joke there. During dinner, Harry thinks it – they’re talking about the trial and what happened, and Harry thought that it would have been dumb to say that he wished that when Dumbledore was standing right next to him that he would have spoken to him, or even looked at him. Do you guys think he should have brought this up? I mean, this is something that he kept to himself, he kind of thinks about during dinner. And might anybody else – Sirius, somebody else who was in the know as to why Dumbledore was not corresponding with Harry – might they have told him the truth? Might they have felt sorry for him?

Andrew: I’m sure they felt sorry for him, but I think – I don’t think they like to intervene with what Dumbledore is doing, so in this case, they were just letting it fly even though they knew it pained Harry. And, I mean, I’m on Harry’s side in this. He should know why Dumbledore is ignoring him. I mean, they’re best friends, and for this sudden change to be going on and Harry has no idea why, it’s just heartbreaking for Harry.

Eric: Yeah. And given what Sirius does in the next chapter, I wouldn’t put anything past him. But everybody else, like Andrew said, too, is they’re respecting Dumbledore’s wishes on this. And maybe they don’t know that this is paining Harry, because at this point Harry isn’t telling anybody…

Micah: Right.

Eric: …how he feels.

Micah: Well, do they know, also, as to why Dumbledore is not interacting with Harry? That would be the real question.

Eric: That’s – yeah, that’s interesting.

Andrew: Yeah. [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: Because surely somebody else must have noticed that he’s not spending any time with him. So, that’s interesting. I just compare it to Harry not telling Sirius when his scar hurts, a couple of years ago. There are these things that Harry keeps to himself and kind of chomps on throughout – for several months that he prefers to kind of deal with alone, I guess.

Micah: Yeah. Well, speaking of Sirius, he starts to become more detached as the start of term grows closer, and Hermione actually says that she thinks part of Sirius hoped Harry got expelled from Hogwarts so he could come live with him. Now, do you believe that?

Andrew: Well, I think she’s on to something.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We know Sirius is very lonely. We know he loves having Harry, as a godfather. And for him to now leave and go back to school where he’s not going to see him, I can see why Hermione would be thinking that and Sirius would be feeling that.

Eric: Yeah, I think Sirius definitely viewed the trial as a potential new beginning for Harry.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: I mean, if Harry had – if the verdict had been negative, I really don’t think Sirius – I mean, he would have been sorry that Harry’s life was in shambles, but he would have been the first person to say there’s light after this and we’re going to have a lot of fun now.

Micah: Right.

Eric: We’ll be outlaws together, Harry! Godfather and godson.

Andrew: Woohoo!

Micah: Yeah. But I think part of it is that the term is drawing closer and that means there’s going to be less people in the house for Sirius to interact with. Yes, the Order of the Phoenix does come and go, but most of them work full-time and so when they are there, it’s just sort of in passing or to have quick conversations. So really, Sirius goes back to being that loner again.

Eric: Hmm. Well, he’s got Remus.

Micah: Well, Remus is off trying to…

Eric: Oh, that’s right.

Micah: …rally other werewolves to his cause.

Eric: Yeah. Well, you know what? You give up your house to be the headquarters of the Order of the Phoenix, and people come and go, and it’s hard. It’s hard to be Sirius.

Micah: So we move on, and letters finally come from Hogwarts with all the supplies that they’re going to need for the upcoming term and we find out that, in addition to Hermione, Ron is made a prefect.

Eric: What?

Micah: And everybody is shocked by this. Fred and George, Hermione, Harry – and this was kind of a rough scene for Ron because…

Andrew: Because nobody can believe he actually accomplished something?

Micah: I don’t even think he believed that he was made prefect.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: But he defends himself, doesn’t he?

Micah: Yeah, he does, and there’s also a lot of humor from the twins that comes about in this scene, especially when Mrs. Weasley comes in and says, “Oh, that’ll be everybody in the family that was made prefect,” and Fred and George say, “And what are we, next-door neighbors?” But was he deserving? That’s the question. And I know we find out later why this happened, but this could be seen as another reason, just kind of adding to the pile, to make Harry upset with Dumbledore.

Eric: Yeah, it’s very true.

Micah: Do you think he was deserving, though? Both of you guys?

Eric: Like separately?

Micah: Yeah, let’s throw aside the real reason we find out at the end of the book. Do you think he deserved to be made prefect?

Andrew: No.

Micah: Anybody else he could have chosen?

Andrew: No and I mean, he knows – well, slash thinks himself – he didn’t deserve to be made prefect. I mean, I just – yeah, I don’t know. No. My short answer is no, I don’t think he deserved to be a prefect.

Micah: Well, who else would you have picked? Let’s say Harry is out of the equation. You have Neville, Dean, Seamus.

Eric: Lee as well, and Fred and George, right? I mean, they’re still – because you can be a prefect – are prefects only fifth-years? I mean, I’m sure not, right?

Andrew: No.

Eric: But there’s a Head Boy and a Head Girl. I’m trying to think how this works, to wrap my brain around this.

Andrew: Well, I guess the question is, who else deserves it?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Who else would deserve it?

Eric: It’s tough because you’ve got to get somebody who is close to Harry that isn’t Harry.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: It’s got to be Ron. I want to say, as an example of Quidditch in Half-Blood Prince, Ron is capable of good things, but he needs to be pushed, kind of. It’s like, give him a prefect-ship and see if he rises to this occasion. And I think Ron, at least for pride’s sake, is really rising to this occasion. But we see – I guess throughout the book, certainly in the next chapter – how Ron begins to deal with this extra authority, whether or not he is going to use it the right way or use it just to benefit his friends. So, maybe Dumbledore – and again, we find out later why. I don’t really particularly remember, but I’m thinking that in giving Ron this opportunity, it is sort of a “Hey, go out, be your own person,” sort of stick for him.

Micah: Well, I’m assuming everybody listening has read the books, so – [laughs] it’s really because Dumbledore didn’t want to give Harry any more responsibility, it’s that he felt as if Harry had enough to deal with as it was. To make him prefect would only increase that.

Eric: Well, I remember that, but that doesn’t explain why Ron is the prefect, right? Because now…

Micah: I do think it was to build him up, because he felt that if Ron could take on this responsibility, then he could do a lot more moving forward.

Eric: Yeah, but I mean, that goes back to what you’re saying. Isn’t that like throwing fuel to the fire for Harry, in not coming forward and explaining this to Harry? And you don’t even need to say, “Oh, I thought you had too much on your plate,” but just to explain why you would not even talk to Harry about making his best friend, who frankly doesn’t really deserve it, a prefect, both of his best friends. Harry is essentially alone, and not only alone in the way that he can’t talk to Dumbledore, but even in the next chapter, Ron and Hermione have to go off and do prefect things. Harry is alone and that’s counter-intuitive.

Micah: Okay. The other question I wanted to ask really quickly about this was, why was this storyline particularly dropped from the movie? Because it would have actually, I thought, built a little bit more towards Ron’s character.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, this would have been great. It’s kind of like in Half-Blood Prince where you see him join the Quidditch team. I thought that was a great example of showing Ron’s personality and getting some nice Ron moments in there. But he just – I can also see why they cut it.

Eric: Yeah, maybe they didn’t want to repeat themselves, too, because Harry is angry with Ron in Movie 4. It’s kind of like they had to take a movie break before Movie 6 when Hermione is angry with Ron. They kind of – the movies are very narrow, I guess, and so maybe they didn’t want to confuse people in the movie.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Or repeat some of the same emotions that they had shown in the previous film.

Micah: Yeah, so now we get to the point where Harry is alone in his room. Hermione asks to borrow Hedwig to send a note off to her parents, and he has sort of this debate in his mind as to whether or not he was more deserving than Hermione, if he was more deserving than Ron. And he really comes to the conclusion that with the exception of the things that he was able to do in all the prior books that had to deal with Voldemort, he’s really not a better student than Ron, and I don’t really think he makes much justification for deserving it more than Hermione, because obviously Hermione is very intelligent, the perfect student, and so on and so forth. But he kind of comes to the conclusion himself that, “You know what? At the end of the day, I can’t really make the case for me deserving it more than Ron.” But later, at dinner, Harry learns that Lupin was prefect during his father’s time at Hogwarts and his father wasn’t a prefect, so that made him feel a lot better about the whole situation.

Eric: Hmm. Surprising they made Lupin a prefect with his condition.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, that’s true.

Eric: Wouldn’t he have too much on his plate?

Micah: Now, there’s this side conversation going on during dinner between Fred and George, and Mundungus. And Harry eventually is called over, but he begins to worry afterwards what Mr. and Mrs. Weasley would think of him if they knew that he was the one responsible for backing Fred and George, and their joke shop. Would they still think of him as being one of their own children?

Eric: So interesting. But it’s kind of one of those things, right? Wait. Wait a year. Because you know their reactions after they first go in Half-Blood Prince, and see Fred and George’s joke shop. I think Ginny says it in the book. “But this is really incredible magic,” is what she says and I think Mrs. Weasley is beaming, and seeing the twins have their business – it’s really one of the best things that happens to any of the characters in the books, and so I think in a year’s time, if they knew that Harry had given them the money, they would have thought, “Well, it’s still too generous, it’s just like Harry,” but they would have appreciated him a little bit more. Now where Mrs. Weasley is really cross about it, who knows, right? I don’t think they’ll disown Harry because they’re not like Dumbledore to leave Harry alone in this sort of time of darkness. But I think it would have caused maybe a little bit more of an issue, but she would have demanded that the twins give Harry’s money back, I’m sure, rather than letting them use it for mischief.

Micah: Once Harry leaves that conversation, he is called over by Mad-Eye Moody, and Moody shows Harry this picture of the old Order of the Phoenix. And I believe it’s Sirius who does it in the movie at the train station, so they changed that up a little bit. And Harry eventually is shown his parents, but he looks at Moody a little bit oddly, and I think Moody was trying to do something nice here, but it just didn’t come across the right way. I don’t think Moody has a good understanding, probably, of emotion and things like that.

Eric: Well, why don’t you think it works?

Micah: Because Harry doesn’t have, I think, the reaction that Moody was intending.

Andrew: Yeah, he didn’t want to make him upset.

Eric: Well, no.

Micah: I think – yeah, exactly. The result was Harry kind of got a little bit upset, whereas I think the intended result was to make him see his parents and be happy, “Oh, there are my parents.”

Eric: [laughs] Yeah. I get what you’re saying. Still, it’s good to know – I mean, this artifact – that part of the movie for instance, when it is a little retooled with Sirius giving it, Harry does have that different reaction where it’s like, “Oh, okay. It’s my parents. They were part of a group,” and that photo later becomes inspiration for the DA or whatever. But…

Micah: Yeah, exactly and I think that’s why in the movie it worked better with Sirius giving it to him, but again, here it becomes a little bit of an awkward situation and Harry wants to get away as quickly as he possibly can. And so Sirius asks what they’re looking at and he uses that to kind of slip away, and then he comes across Mrs. Weasley who is crying in the drawing room floor – or on the drawing room floor. And we see – one of the things I left out earlier was when just before dinner takes place, Mrs. Weasley asks Mad-Eye Moody to take a look at something that’s in one of the cabinets in the drawing room, and he uses his eye and he sees that it’s a Boggart. And that’s what Mrs. Weasley went up there to take care of and now Harry has come across her sobbing on the floor, and the Boggart is taking the form of all of her family members, as well as Harry, dead. And I guess this is kind of the first insight you get into how serious things are, and how somebody who is normally such a strong character has these weaknesses, I would say, and how she’s concerned just like any other mother would be that this war is essentially going to take away people that she cares very deeply about.

Eric: Just like the last one took away her brothers.

Micah: Right. And they are mentioned actually, in that photo, although they don’t explicitly say that they are her brothers.

Eric: Yeah. There’s two interesting things there. One is that nobody – well, allegedly, nobody knows what a Boggart looks like when it’s in a cupboard, because it doesn’t take form until it comes out, and when it does, it takes the form of your greatest fear. So it’s interesting that Mad-Eye can whirl his eye around, I’m pretty sure Jo is playing with this, and he says it’s a Boggart, so he clearly knows what a Boggart looks like before it takes a form which would be great to know. But the other interesting thing is that Mrs. Weasley’s Boggart is all of her children dead, equally almost, which is why the Boggart is taking these multiple forms, isn’t it? Because she fears the death of a loved one and so it’s just cycling through all of her loved ones.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Yeah, which is – Molly Weasley is almost the perfect mother character because she doesn’t fear one loved one’s death over another. She doesn’t play favorites. She doesn’t – she fears…

Andrew: But would any mother?

Eric: Well, arguably. But at the same time…

Andrew: Yeah, I guess.

Eric: …even Harry is among them. Molly just doesn’t want to lose people to the spoils of war, which is what Micah said. It’s really about how serious things are and have gotten. But I just never saw a Boggart do that before, where it takes more than one form without being Riddikulus‘d.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: So, Molly is just a pure character. You’re supposed to be very, very moved by this.

Micah: Yeah, and that’s why the question arises from her, who will take care of all of her children if Arthur and herself were killed? I mean, you’re starting to get a very real taste of what’s going on here. And Lupin makes the point that he feels that they’re better prepared this time around than the last time that Voldemort rose to power. But really, are they? And – because Harry has this moment where he wonders if the people that he just saw in the photograph, that he just learned all these horrible things happen to, did they think the same thing, that they were prepared the first time around?

Eric: Yeah. Tough questions. Some questions just don’t have answers.

Micah: Mhm. So this whole thing kind of put things into perspective, and the chapter ends with Harry saying that it was amazing that barely an hour ago he had been concerned about a joke shop and who had earned a prefect’s badge.

Andrew: And now there’s a whole new set of drama for him to enjoy. All right, now onto Chapter 10 with Eric and Luna. Awww, touching!


Chapter-by-Chapter: “Luna Lovegood”


Eric: Luna Lovegood! Chapter 10 of Order of the Phoenix. This is really a character – this chapter differs very much from the previous chapter in that it’s really all about setting up the characters that are going to play a large role in this book. The book is still beginning, practically. They’re not even at Hogwarts yet. Obviously so much has happened, but so much more is yet to. So, Harry wakes up, it’s back-to-school day for the students. Harry wakes up, Ron is already fully dressed and talking to him, telling him to get moving. Apparently Ginny was knocked down two flights of stairs this morning by Fred and George’s trunks which they had bewitched to fly so that they didn’t have to carry them. Basically just a bunch of other stuff happens. Mrs. Weasley is rushing everybody around. Mad-Eye is waiting for Sturgis Podmore before they can go to King’s Cross. And when they finally do get out the door – Harry is leaving Grimmauld Place, and Sirius bounds out as a dog and tries to come with them. I guess Molly – Sirius is almost taking advantage of Molly here because she’s had a heck of a morning, not to mention the night before, but she’s just so stressed that she says, “Fine, you can come with us.” She objects at first, but what she says is, “Fine, you can come along, but on your own head be it!” So she kind of threatens Sirius. She’s like, “You are – you need to be responsible for your own actions here. You can come along.” Because she’s exhausted, she doesn’t want to fight this issue. But – so what results is Sirius basically getting to tag along with Harry. Clearly this is…

Andrew: Wait…

Eric: I mean, if Sirius is – go on.

Andrew: It’s kind of funny just the recent news story about the dog.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: In the news and now we’re talking about it. It’s just kind of funny. Anyway, go ahead.

Eric: Yeah. So, I mean, I guess this is – Sirius has been distancing himself from Harry previously, dreading this day, but of course on the day of he really appears to be in really high spirits. He basically starts chasing pigeons and cats to entertain Harry which is funny. And so Harry is with Mrs. Weasley and Tonks. Today, Tonks looks like an old lady, and they walk about twenty minutes, I think it says, to King’s Cross station. It’s always good to see the Hogwarts Express again. Harry kind of reflects on the trial and the fact that he’s able to actually be going back to Hogwarts. But when he’s getting on the train, again this time Sirius, still as a dog, bounds up – or jumps up on his hind legs and places his front paws on Harry’s shoulder. And Mrs. Weasley quickly shoos him down again, but she says, “Sirius, be more like a dog!” And Harry is kind of taken aback and when the train is leaving the platform, Sirius is like running along the platform chasing the train, actually drawing attention to himself, drawing heavy attention from everybody else. He’s this funny dog, but really the intention – and it’s important because later on Harry realizes – but immediately Hermione realizes that bringing Sirius or letting Sirius come along was probably a really bad idea.

Andrew: Yeah, and you’re seeing Sirius really – he’s out there for the first time in a long time where he’s able to enjoy himself and not really worry about being seen. So it’s like you’re seeing the old boyish Sirius in dog form, but you’re also seeing just a typical dog as well. Really interesting to watch his character in dog form enjoy this time out.

Micah: And bad move on the part of Molly to let him out, because of course Wormtail knows that Sirius can transform into a dog.

Eric: And as a result, the Death Eaters know that. And just like I said here, his behavior – like you’re talking about, Andrew, couldn’t he – he really did take advantage of Molly, because she was rushing and stressing about them all getting to school on time. I mean, what happens when you miss the 9 AM sharp – or 11 AM sharp train to Hogwarts? What happens? But Sirius basically abused that and took that to his advantage. Look, I’m saying, couldn’t Sirius really have spent a little bit more time with Harry, especially because he was feeling so alone from Dumbledore and Sirius was feeling so alone? Instead of behaving like a child these past few months and kind of staying away from – past few weeks, sorry – staying away from Harry. Shouldn’t they have just had a little more talk? Shouldn’t it have been Sirius to give Harry the photograph of his parents and say, I don’t know, maybe more encouraging words? This is really – he’s in Sirius’s house, for crying out loud. And if Sirius is not getting enough time with Harry, that’s nobody else’s fault.

Micah: Yeah. I mean, it goes back to what we were talking about before, with him just distancing himself from everybody else as the start of the term drew near, because – and this ties into what Andrew was saying earlier, with him just acting as if he is as young as Harry or even younger when he gets out to the train station and – he’s just immature. He hasn’t grown up at all in certain respects as we see later on in the book when he calls Harry “James.” It’s just – for him, he can’t get past the fact that he’s never been able to enjoy his young adulthood.

Eric: Twilight years, yeah.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, definitely. So anyway, on the train, Harry, Ron, and Hermione are together and Harry says, “Okay, let’s go find a compartment.” Ron and Hermione actually have to go and spend some time with the prefects in the prefects cabin. Ron says, “It’s not something I want to do, I’m not Percy,” and Harry kind of grins there, but still, Harry is alone because Ron and Hermione, his best friends, have to go and be prefects. So there’s obviously that little bit of regret, I guess, in Harry, and he’s walking along the corridor, he sees all these people gaze and gawk at him, and – let’s face it, he’s Harry Potter. He’s used to that by now, but what it makes him wonder is if people have really believed the Daily Prophet, because ever since Cedric Diggory’s death, as we found out in previous chapters of this book, the Daily Prophet is really saying mean things against Harry and his character, and against Dumbledore. So he’s starting to wonder how many of these students are going to be on his side, in a way, which plays in obviously soon enough. But he ends up – Harry goes to the last compartment, he sees Neville waiting outside the last compartment, and he says, “Neville, let’s go in here,” and Neville just kind of murmurs something. And then Ginny comes up behind them and she says, “Oh, it’s okay. We can have this compartment, it’s just Loony Lovegood.” So, they go in and we meet Luna Lovegood. She’s described as having “straggly, waist-length dirty blonde hair, very pale eyebrows, and protuberant eyes that gave her a permanently surprised look.” Luna “had stuck her wand behind her ear for safekeeping, had chosen to wear a necklace of Butterbeer caps,” and was “reading a magazine upside down.” [laughs] Also, she “did not seem to blink as much as normal humans.” These are all the descriptors that come to introduce one of, I think, our collective favorite characters, Luna Lovegood. Now, Luna is first introduced by Ginny, when Ginny said, “Oh, it’s just Loony Lovegood in here.” But then when Ginny opens the compartment door, she’s like, “Oh, hi Luna! Can we have these seats?” And also, “How was your summer?” So apparently Luna – Loony – has this nickname that Ginny has – but she’s being polite. So Ginny is not somebody who bullies Luna, but very clearly, Luna’s reputation precedes her. So, what do you guys think of this scene and what happens with Luna in this chapter?

Andrew: Well, is she reading the book upside down in the book? Is she reading The Quibbler upside down in the book?

Eric: Yes.

Andrew: That introduction just like in the movie and in the book was just so wonderful. It was like a perfect way to introduce the character. [laughs] I mean, immediately you get that she’s out there. Not just with the dialogue, but the visuals. Yeah, so – I mean, Luna – this was a great introduction.

Eric: Yeah. So, two things happen in this cabin. First is like a gradual – I guess through the rest of this chapter, Harry begins to notice how Luna is maybe not as crazy as she seems, because he ends up getting a look at The Quibbler and he sees in fact that what Luna was looking at were the rune charts. There is a notation somewhere that if you hold them upside down, it reveals a special incantation. Something big that happens is that Neville [laughs] reveals that he has a birthday present, actually, recently which is kind of a hint – I said it’s foreshadowing to the end of the book when we learn that Neville and Harry share more or less the same birthday. But Neville reveals that for his birthday he received a Mimbulus mimbletonia. Harry is kind of like, “Okay, Neville, I know Herbology is your forte, but does this thing actually do anything?” And Neville says, “Oh yeah, it does loads of stuff! Hold Trevor for me.” So Neville takes out something to prod the Mimbulus mimbletonia with, pokes it, and this dark green puss erupts from all of the boils. It’s described as smelling like manure, and it sprays everybody in the compartment. Just right then, Cho Chang knocks on the compartment door and wants to say hello to Harry. Obviously Harry is covered in this green crap, goo. So there’s just this moment here where Harry is not very happy. He obviously – I mean, Cho takes it nice enough. She turns red and says, “Is this not a bad time?” and Harry says no, and so she leaves. But there’s this moment where Harry is really resentful in the book. The book says, “He would have liked Cho to discover him sitting with a very cool group of people laughing their heads off at a joke he had just told. He would not have chosen to be sitting with Neville and Loony Lovegood, clutching a toad, and dripping in Stinksap.” So Harry is kind of – again, it’s a little bit of a preface for what’s going to happen later with him and Cho, in terms of – he wants to really grow, he wants to nurture that relationship, and he’s finding that certain events or certain things are holding it back.

Micah: Well, I think it’s a combination of things, though. It’s the tie between him and Voldemort becoming stronger, but it’s also just him maturing and going through this adolescent period where he’s showing these emotions.

Eric: So you’re saying he’s more aware in general of how he appears to other people?

Micah: No, I just think the way that he’s just acting is the way any teenager would be acting.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: You know, if you like a girl, you don’t – he has the reaction that a guy would normally have, and that’s – I want to be sitting with the cool crowd, you know? [laughs] What is Cho going to think of me if she walks in and she sees me sitting with the people the way that you just described? She’s not going to think very highly of me. And I think that’s a normal thought to have for somebody who is fifteen years old.

Andrew: Oh yeah. Again, we always forget this. They’re so young. [laughs]

Eric: That’s a good…

Micah: It’s not like that he’s matured and he’s in his twenties now. I doubt he would have the same sort of thought process.

Eric: Yeah. No, that’s a really good point. So, as I mentioned before, Ron and Hermione do come back from their prefect cabin. They mention that Draco Malfoy is a prefect. We talked about Ron deserving a prefect position. Do you think Draco deserves a prefect position?

Micah: Well see, this would get into who really makes the decision. Is it the head of the house, or is it Dumbledore?

Andrew: And would Malfoy want it? Would Draco want it? He doesn’t strike me as somebody who would really…

Micah: Well, he wants to pick on people.

Andrew: Yeah…

Micah: Give them detention… [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah…

Micah: …for no reason.

Andrew: …he likes to be bossy, but I just picture him as someone who would kind of maybe enjoy it for a few days and then kind of get over it.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: He just wants to boss Crabbe and Goyle around. That’s all.

Eric: Yeah, that’s true. And I mean, this isn’t the Movie or Book 6 Malfoy where he’s kind of burdened with the world. But at the same time, I think – doesn’t it say that Malfoy is actually a pretty good student if he is made a prefect? The other Slytherin prefect is Pansy Parkinson. But doesn’t it say that he is at least academically competent? And now that I think about that, didn’t Lucius make fun of Malfoy, make of Draco in Year 2, and say that, “Your grades should be better than that Mudblood Hermione Granger’s?” So, do you think that Malfoy has been trying to keep up with Hermione academically? Do you think he’s actually trying hard at school at this point?

Micah: It could be. I mean, you never really get an insight into how good of a student Draco is, other than that comment. I mean, you assume that he’s good at Potions, but who knows what else he is good at.

Eric: Right. But when Malfoy shows up at the cabin, he’s bullying. He basically – Ron has this moment where he talks about Malfoy being a prefect with Harry, and Ron is of the assumption that Malfoy is going to abuse that power so Ron says that he’s going to – first opportunity he gets, he’s going to punish Crabbe and Goyle, and try and get them first. I think the term is, “Get his mate before he gets mine.” So Ron is looking out for Harry here. When they get to Hogsmeade station, Harry is immediately looking around for Hagrid. Harry just needs some love, I think. He’s looking around for Hagrid, fresh, familiar face. What’s synonymous with Hogwarts start of term other than Hagrid? Well, Hagrid’s not there. Apparently this severely hair-cutted Professor Grubbly-Plank is in his position, and Harry doesn’t know why that is. So, it’s a little disconcerting. Harry does not get the – yet again, he doesn’t get the kind of attention or love he’s looking for. And finally, when they get to the school carriages, which up until very recently have pulled themselves, Harry notices that there’s a large horse creature, and he pulls Ron aside and he says, “What’s the deal with these things? Why would they need these horse things to pull the carriages that were perfectly capable of pulling themselves?” Well, Ron doesn’t see these horse things and Harry basically physically moves Ron, puts him face to face with a horse thing – which we know they’re called Thestrals – and Ron doesn’t see it. In fact, he asks if Harry is feeling all right. He gets on the carriage and Harry is flipping out, actually, because he has this genuine moment when he realizes that Ron actually doesn’t see this thing that he sees, and it sets the tone. Harry beings to really worry if he’s losing his mind. But of course, just as he steps on the school carriage to go to Hogwarts, Luna assures him that she can see them, too, and that Harry is “just as sane as I am.”

Andrew: Uh oh.

Eric: Oh no. New, crazy things….

Andrew: New thing to stress about…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …for Harry.

Eric: And that concludes Chapter 10.

MuggleCast 241 Transcript (continued)


Muggle Mail: Accurate Predictions on Episode 1


Andrew: And that’s Chapter-by-Chapter for this week. If you have any comments about anything that we discussed today, you can just visit the MuggleCast site, click on “Contact” at the top, and give us your feedback. And what will we do it? Well, we’ll read it just like we’re about to right now. We have some e-mails here from – in regards to last week’s – Episode 240, this first one comes from Rajitha, 12, from India.

“Dear MuggleCast, I have started listening to your show a couple of months ago and I love your show. I have also been listening to your old shows and, like two others, have noticed another prediction you made. In your first ever show you all said that Regulus Black could have taken the locket. Ben also said that Mundungus could have stolen the locket from Number 12, Grimmauld Place and sold it. We now know both of these predictions are true. This is my favorite podcast and I hope you never end it!”

Well, thank you, and there again.

Micah: Yeah, those were very popular theories, I think, back then.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s true. Absolutely.

Micah: And Ben went on to write a book about them. [laughs]

Eric: Well, I think the first one, right? Regulus Black, that was – I don’t want to say it was one of the most obvious mysteries, but I do feel like it was more obvious simply because there weren’t that many characters that we had known. Most of the appeal of R.A.B. lies in us actually knowing that character previously, right? I mean, it’s very easy for JK Rowling to introduce a brand new character with the initials R.A.B., but wouldn’t it be more special if they had already been mentioned before in the books? And so I think right after Book 6 came out, and this R.A.B. mystery came out, people were looking back in the books for an R.A.B. and really one of the only contenders that we didn’t know his middle name until that Dutch translation or whatever came out months and months – maybe a month or two before Book 7 – I forget what time it was, but basically Regulus Black was one of the only contenders for this, so if JK Rowling was using an already-existing character, R.A.B., Regulus Black was one of them. So, I do think that that mystery was – I’m not saying it’s more predictable, but – I am saying it’s more predictable. However, the Mundungus locket thing, that’s all Ben. That’s brilliant, and that totally came true. I don’t feel like we had any other reason to believe that that was possible.


Muggle Mail: Dumbledore’s Support of Snape


Andrew: Next e-mail is from Kaitlyn Kelley, 18, of Paducah, Kentucky.

“Hey guys! First things first, I love you guys and this show. Been with you guys for a while now. I live on a blackberry farm, no joke…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: [continues]

“…and I have listened to your amazing podcast while picking. In Episode 240 “Join the Weasleys,” when talking about the Death Eater trials, you forgot about Snape. Snape was clearly represented by Dumbledore. It was an unusual circumstance, I know. What do you guys think would have happened if Dumbledore hadn’t had supported Snape? Love to hear your thoughts! Keep up the awesome work!”

Yeah, absolutely.

Micah: So there are cases where criminals get defense.

Eric: Right, because Snape was very clearly – Snape would have been convicted – I mean, if he wasn’t at least convicted, he would have been sentenced to a term in Azkaban if it weren’t for Dumbledore. Very, very, very interesting. But I think, too, honestly do you feel like Dumbledore, knowing the particular things that Dumbledore knew regarding his love for Lily Potter, but also more importantly that he was the one who heard the prophecy, don’t you think that Dumbledore would have done anything to keep Snape by his side? Because didn’t we have the situation where people who witnessed the prophecy – that memory – this whole book is about that memory of the prophecy, about obtaining it. And if somebody, be a prisoner somewhere else, was able to get to Snape they really could have forced that memory out of him, about the prophecy and learn something that was extremely – would be extremely devastating to either the good side or the bad side. Don’t you think that Dumbledore – the reason he gave evidence for Snape was also because – and let Snape teach at the school was just so that he could keep that much of an eye and keep that much control over that kind of information?

Micah: Yeah, probably. But it’s also good to know that Dumbledore moonlights as a defense attorney…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: …because he is the only one we’ve seen…

Andrew: He has so many talents.

Micah: Yeah, but he is the only person we’ve ever seen speak in defense of somebody else.

Eric: Dumbledore, public wizard defender.


Muggle Mail: Apparition


Andrew: Next e-mail comes from who I believe it’s their Pottermore name, AurorStrike131.

“In Episode 240, during Chapter-by-Chapter, you said that Arthur Weasley wouldn’t Apparate to the Ministry because Harry can’t. Yes, you’re right, only one person needs to know how to Apparate. The best example is when Harry Apparates himself, Hermione, Ron, Dobby, and Griphook to Shell Cottage. The reason Arthur didn’t Apparate is because Harry is underage! Yes, you need to be seventeen to Apparate. Well, as far as I know, when you’re seventeen you can take your Apparition test but even if you don’t take the test, you can Apparate as long as you’re seventeen or older. This is implied in ‘Goblet of Fire’. I’m not sure which chapter, but it’s the one where Harry asks why Bill, Charlie, etc. are Apparating to the World Cup but they’re not. Sorry I can’t provide more details.”

Okay. Well, that makes sense, then.

Eric: Yeah. So, I guess there’s another example of people not Side-Along Apparating as early as Book 4. Then it could be because they’re – all participants in the Apparition have to be seventeen, possibly.


Muggle Mail: Pottermore App


Andrew: Next e-mail from Rilee Kennedy, 15, of Fayette, Alabama:

“Hey guys! I was listening to your latest show and you were talking about the Pottermore setbacks, and a sudden question hit me. Do you think they will make a Pottermore app? I, having an iPhone, think it would be great! I sadly have not yet joined Pottermore. Thanks for keeping ‘Potter’ alive after the series has ended and keep up the good work!”

Yeah, it’s just – well, here’s the main problem, if I may get techy for a second. The iPhone does not support Flash and Pottermore is all Flash, so if you were to open up Pottermore on an iPhone or an iPad right now, it doesn’t work, as some of you may have already tried. So, they would have to create a completely separate app, and will they do that? Who knows? They haven’t said a thing about it, so…

Eric: Cool.


Muggle Mail: Harry Potter DVD Box Sets


Andrew: Next e-mail is from Katryana, 22, of Palmdale:

“I was just listening to the recent episode. I was surprised that Andrew said that the box sets for the DVDs would not make as much money, and would most likely be a gift for younger generations. Personally, I don’t know if this makes me less of a fan, I stopped buying the DVDs after the second film. This is because I assumed that they would come out with a box set, so I’ve been waiting for this edition for almost ten years. I would assume that there are other fans who are my age and grew up with the series that have also made the same choice back then at different points. I think the box set will profit well, just as much as ‘HP DH Part 2’ will. Love you guys!”

Eric: Well, now I’m just going to say…

Andrew: I think she’s right.

Eric: Yeah, I’m just going to say the same thing I said at the beginning of the show: please wait, there’s another box set coming, and it’s coming next year sometime, allegedly, so I would really, really wait. If you want to get the definitive collection, it’s not this one that’s coming out in November.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, I guess now I’m wondering, why do I buy the DVDs?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I really only watch them once when they come out. But I guess it’s just because I’m a fan, and I want to buy it when it’s out.

Eric: Are you talking about you yourself, personally?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And most people.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I mean, how many times do you guys…

Micah: How much replay value is there?

Andrew: Right, how many times do you guys pop in the DVDs?

Eric: Well, I…

Andrew: You probably haven’t since it came out, right?

Eric: Right. I only really – now that I think about it, I bought the DVDs so that I could screen-cap them for the Caption Contest, but both that and…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …my screen-capping has gone the way of the dictaphone, here. I haven’t really had any use for the DVDs. Gosh, why do I own those movies?

Micah: I mean, I’ll watch the movies if I come across them on TV every now and then, but…

Andrew: Yeah, exactly! I…

Micah: I won’t sit down and pop them into the computer, or…

Andrew: Right. You know, Part 1 just started playing on HBO, and it – I watched bits and pieces of it because it’s easy. You just turn it on and you just switch to the channel, and it’s there. It’s easier than putting in a DVD.

Eric: They just have to…

Andrew: Which makes me sound really lazy, but…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: It was funny, I – my dad was watching it one night, and I walked downstairs where he was and he said to me, “Which one is this?”

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: So…

Andrew: You should have said, “Number one.”

[Eric laughs]

Micah: [laughs] Number one?

Eric: “It’s that dark?”


Chicken Soup for the MuggleCast Soul


Andrew: All right, final e-mail today is a Chicken Soup for the MuggleCast Soul. It’s from Brandon Hudson, 24, of Salisbury, Maryland:

“I have been a fan of yours for over three years now. The joy that you guys bring to my iPod and daily life are definitely helpful. I am a full-time working husband and father of two. On top of that, I also go to college full time and am managing to maintain a GPA of 4.0. After being asked by people numerous times how I am able to balance all of these things, I usually come clean and let them know about you guys. I tend to live everyday without stress because I listen to at least one of your podcasts while at work everyday, so I want to sincerely thank you for all that you have contributed to ‘Harry Potter’ and your fellow fans like myself. Listening to you guys on a daily basis really gives me the time I need to reflect and remember that there is nothing to worry about day to day, and I am always able to smile and laugh along with you guys. As a ‘HP’ fan from the very beginning, I can safely say that there is no other fandom like ours. I just wish that those who are not fans of ‘HP’ could experience the overwhelming community and friendship we share with one another. Looking back, it’s amazing that one boy wizard and a world of magic can bring so many people together. As a ‘Potter’ fan, I feel very fortunate for everything I am given that is in relation to the world of witchcraft and wizardry. We have amazing movies, amazing books, a theme park, Pottermore, and all types of merchandise. JK Rowling has made me feel special in my own way for being a fan of her work, and for that reason I am especially thankful to her even though I will probably never meet her. However, I am able to at least e-mail you guys and know that you will read it so I can express my gratitude. Once again, I would like to thank you all at MuggleNet and MuggleCast for all of the great times, and I can’t wait until the next podcast. ‘Potter’ Pride! Brandon.”

Eric: Wow. Brandon, thank you for writing this letter to us. I would say, judging by what you’ve got going on, that you say in the letter, that you are a tremendous example of a working guy, a father, and it’s really wonderful to get this e-mail from you. You’re definitely – you’re setting an example, I think, for others out there.

Andrew: Yeah. And good luck with school and keeping up with all the work. We all know it’s a lot to balance. And yeah, thanks for the support. I like to listen to podcasts, too, to help relieve stress, especially when I go to bed. I know we’ve talked about it before, it does help to fall asleep hearing people talk, and not in like, “Oh, they’re so boring,” way.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: And when you’re taking care of your kids, too, right?


Announcement: Upcoming Episodes


Andrew: Right. Exactly. Well, I don’t do that. But anyway, we want to remind you guys that over the next few weeks there’s quite a few special MuggleCast episodes coming up. Our next one, Episode 242, will be our Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD review. We will break down everything in the DVD. We will watch it once and then never use it again. [laughs] Also, next month we’ll do our first ever DVD commentary for Deathly Hallows – Part 2. That’ll be a special episode…

Micah: So, we will use it again.

Andrew: Oh, right. Yeah, we’ll use it twice.

Eric: [laughs] Oh.

Micah: [laughs] And then it becomes a coaster.

Eric: Maybe eBay, guys, right? A few signed copies out there?

Andrew: Yeah. And then tentatively, we’re going to have coverage from the Quidditch World Cup. Either that, or somewhere else. That one is still up in the air, but there will be an episode possibly from the Quidditch World Cup and if not there, then somewhere else. And then of course, our year-in-review episode where we’ll break down everything that has happened this year. It’s been another busy year of Harry Potter. And we’ll look forward to what’s to come in 2012.


Announcement: MuggleNet’s Pumpkin Carving Contest


Eric: So, this is the last episode…

Andrew: And then also…

Eric: …before Halloween, you said? So…

Andrew: Yes! Segue!

Eric: Yeah. Happy Halloween, everybody!

Andrew: Oh, I thought you were going to bring up the…

Eric: Oh yeah, that thing.

[Prolonged silence]

Eric: Happy Halloween, everybody!

Andrew: No, no! What’s in the notes here. [laughs]

Micah: All right. Well, since Eric is not paying attention to the doc, [laughs] kind of in conjunction with Halloween – I’m not sure how we’re going to do it just yet, but we plan on giving away a copy of Harry Potter: Page to Screen and I think the part that Andrew was referring to is that MuggleNet is conducting a Harry Potter pumpkin carving contest, and the top prize will also receive a copy of Harry Potter: Page to Screen. So guys, we have to come up with something here on the podcast, a means of giving away an additional copy of Harry Potter: Page to Screen.

Eric: I vote we just give it to that Hilary girl who came up with that MuggleCast pumpkin. You guys seen this? It’s on YouTube and I’m pretty sure she’s going to enter the contest, but she carved our faces and the lightning bolt and the words “MuggleCast” onto one pumpkin.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s awesome! Thank you, Hilary, for doing that.

Eric: [laughs] I don’t know how she did it, honestly. I want that kind of skill. But yeah, essentially – so MuggleNet is having this pumpkin carving contest. There’s this super cool MuggleCast pumpkin and yeah, I’m sure that if we put out head together, guys, we can figure out how to give another one of these HarperCollins books away. But obviously for an upcoming episode, so stay tuned for that!


Announcement: Game of Owns


Andrew: And finally, a plug for a new site Micah and Eric are working on. Micah, tell us about it!

Micah: Yeah, for those listeners out there who are fans of the Game of Thrones series, whether you read the books or got into the HBO television series, there’s a new website out there called GameOfOwns.com and it’s kind of a play on “Game of Thrones,” so all the information you could possibly want is there, on the books, on the television series, on the actors, and a lot of buzz going on right now with Season 2, which is going to be on TV in April 2012, but a lot of casting news and things like that going on. We’re working on some cool features as well for the site, but also gallery and forums. You can get together with feather…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Feather? [laughs] Fellow Game of Thrones fans and talk about whatever it is that you’re interested in with respect to the series.

Eric: So, Micah, you like – how would compare those books to Harry Potter? Because I haven’t read them yet, but do they compare?

Micah: [laughs] There are some different themes that run through the books. There’s some – a lot more adult content in this series than in Harry Potter, but I think for the more adult listeners on the show, then it’s something of interest, and give it a read or at least give it a watch, and watch the first episode of Game of Thrones on HBO because that’s how I got into it. It’s very similar to how I got into Potter. I saw the films and then read the books. I saw the TV series and now started reading – it’s called A Song of Ice and Fire series, but there’s currently five books that are out and there appears – there will be at least seven, so there is that tie to Harry Potter, I guess, but follow us on Twitter at GameOfOwns or just go onto the website, GameOfOwns.com. You can also like us on Facebook, so…

Eric: That’s O-W-N-S, for “Owns.”

Micah: Yes. So, Andrew, I know you’ve checked it out. You’re a fan…

Andrew: Yeah, I like it. Well, I haven’t read the books or seen the…

Micah: But you like the website.

Andrew: [laughs] But I like the website.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: But, yeah. No, it’s a project that I’ve been working on, as you said, with Eric, also Zack who’s a friend of ours, and Amy who’s another friend. So – or she’s Blaire now, I’m not sure. She changed her name. But…


Show Close


Andrew: Well, don’t – also remember that we – also remember another website. MuggleCast.com has all the information you need about this show…

Micah: [laughs] Does it? Really?

Andrew: Yeah. Well, I’m moving along here. Don’t forget, you can click “Contact” at the top and submit anything via feedback form. Also there, we have links to our Twitter which is Twitter.com/MuggleCast, Facebook which is Facebook.com/MuggleCast, and our fan Tumblr which is MuggleCast.Tumblr.com.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: Thanks everyone for listening! From Hypable, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: From Game of Owns, I’m Micah Tannenbaum. [laughs] That’s what…

Eric: Nice!

Micah: …Andrew was looking for at the top of the show.

Eric: Nice.

Andrew: That was. We’ll see everyone next time for Episode 242. Goodbye!

Micah: Bye!

Eric: Happy Halloween! [imitates a spooky ghost laughing]

[Show music continues]

Transcript #240

MuggleCast 240 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because Pottermore is still having some problems, this is MuggleCast Episode 240 for October 2nd, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode two hundred and… [laughs]

Eric: Forty?

Micah: Forty?

Andrew: I don’t even have the Google Doc open. I don’t know what I’m doing. 240, okay! There’s been a lot of news actually, and we’ve only been away for a couple of weeks and yet so much has happened. DVD news has finally been announced, a LEGO release date, more Pottermore drama we get to complain about…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …and be accused of not being fans of. And then we’re also going to bring back Chapter-by-Chapter this week and over the next couple of months, we’re going to do a couple of installments. I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Micah, what’s in the news this week?


News: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray Release Dates & Features Announced


Micah: You were talking about the DVD and the Blu-ray, and a lot of news coming out about the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Blu-ray/ DVD, and all these features and special editions, and now is really, I think, when we’re going to start to see WB maximizing all eight movies finally being released. But let’s start talking about the release date, actually. It’s going to be released November 11th here in the United States but then not until December in the UK, and a lot of people were upset about that, even people here in the US. I saw in the comments they were saying, “Well, these are British-based films. Why is the DVD and the Blu-ray coming out on December 2nd in the UK?”

Eric: So, British fans have to wait two weeks. Is that unprecedented, because haven’t they always released on the same day in both countries before?

Andrew: Yeah, I think they’ve always released pretty close, but I think the reason that this is happening is because they ñ for some reason – I want to say it has to do with the holiday shopping season. For some reason, they release in December. I feel like we’ve been through this before, maybe with the Half-Blood Prince DVD.

Micah: Do you…

Andrew: But it does – I do agree, though. I mean, they are – if you look at the international release date list…

Micah: They’re last.

Andrew: …the UK is the [laughs] last country to get it.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: And – I mean, I don’t know, does that encourage piracy or what does that do?

[Eric laughs]

Micah: No, the only thing I can think of is that with the US, there’s this huge event going on down in Orlando that’s tied to the release of the DVD and the Blu-ray, and I’m wondering if they’re planning something for the UK as well and maybe that’s why it’s on December 2nd. That’s the only thing I can possibly think of to have that kind of a gap. I mean, you’re talking about Belgium, Hungary, Brazil, Korea, all getting the…

Eric: And no offense to these countries. [laughs]

Micah: No, no, none at all. But it’s just weird that the UK has to wait so long.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, it absolutely is. I don’t really understand that.

Micah: But let’s talk a little bit about the features that are going to be on the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD/Blu-ray.

Eric: So this is not the box-set, right? This is just Deathly Hallows – Part 2?

Micah: Right. Let’s focus on the Blu-ray first. They have “Maximum Movie Mode” which was successful on Part 1 with Jason Isaacs but now it’s going to be done by Matthew Lewis. “A Conversation with JK Rowling and Dan Radcliffe” which there have been pieces that have been leaking out on the internet over the last couple of days. “The Goblins of Gringotts” which is going to be hosted by Warwick Davis. “The Women of Harry Potter.”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Nice.

Andrew: The inflection of Micah’s voice changed, I noticed.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Yeah. He was like, got to be more…

Andrew: Micah is going straight to that feature when he gets the DVD.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: You kidding? I am, too.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: “When Harry Left Hogwarts.” Sounds like a documentary. The “WB Studio Tour London – The Making of Harry Potter,” so I guess it’s going to be a sort of behind-the-scenes look at how this is all coming together at Leavesden Studios. And then of course, “Deleted Scenes” which everybody is looking forward to. And I know that the DVD will not contain the “Maximum Movie Mode” just like last time, but also it won’t contain the conversation between JK Rowling and Dan Radcliffe, but people can probably find that somewhere online after the Blu-ray comes out.

Andrew: It’ll be on YouTube.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: All right, before we move on with today’s show we’d like to remind you that today’s podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many of New York Times Bestsellers. For listeners of this podcast, Audible is offering a free audiobook to give you a chance to try out their great service. One audiobook to consider is The Night Circus, a book just released by Erin Morgenstern. Publishers Weekly calls it “a giant, magical story destined for bestsellerdom.” I actually just started listening to it and I can tell you, I agree completely. And actually this book has two connections to Potter: for one, Jim Dale is the narrator of the audiobook. He narrates the US version of the Harry Potter books, and two, David Heyman who has produced the Potter films is reportedly very interested in turning this book into a film. So, to get a free audiobook of your choice such as The Night Circus, which I do really recommend, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

I’m actually most excited for the conversation with Dan Radcliffe and JK Rowling. It’s an hour long. It’s just Dan and Jo talking one-on-one to each other. There’s no additional interviewer. If you’ve seen the footage it looks great, and Jo, I noticed, she looks a little mopey or something. It’s kind of weird.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: But other than that I think it’s going to be a really interesting discussion between the two. And I think it was a great idea, I’m really happy that they did that.

Eric: Yeah. When I read about that feature I thought, “Well, that’s just wonderful,” because here’s JK Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter series, and here’s Dan Radcliffe, who has portrayed Harry. Dan Radcliffe almost represents Rowling in sort of an unintended way. But, I think the grace with which Dan has used his role to establish a career for himself, in the same way that Rowling has built a career around these books – it just makes it so interesting to sit them in a room across from each other and to just talk, presumably unscripted or minimally scripted, about the series. And just the clips that have already been released have been very insightful, it seems.

Micah: Did you see the part where Dan started talking about Americans being cast, possibly – or I think it was filming, to take place in the United States. JK Rowling really doesn’t like the idea of there being sort of any American component to Harry Potter.

Andrew: I don’t blame her. I don’t blame her. I mean, the books originated there, that’s part of the reason, I think, they’ve resonated so well with fans, is that it does feel like a genuine British film. It is a genuinely British film series. I wouldn’t have it any other way. I wouldn’t want Americans in it.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Now, what about “Maximum Movie Mode”? Did you guys take a look last time with Jason Isaacs…

Andrew: That was really good because they had on the “Maximum Movie Mode” the last day of filming, I believe.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: It was around the scene, “The Ministry of Magic,” and the movie paused and there was a little featurette in “Maximum Movie Mode” where you saw them filming the last scenes in the Ministry – or filming for the last time, and it was the scene in the Ministry. And it was really good. It was really emotional. And I imagine they’re going to have little packages like that throughout the film again. Matt Lewis hosting it? All right. I don’t know. No comment, I guess.

Eric: [laughs] I mean, I didn’t – I still haven’t seen it. I actually acquired the 7 – Part 1 Blu-ray. It came to me. But I haven’t watched it yet, but I really want to. I like Jason Isaacs, but again Jason Isaacs isn’t exactly a main character. He’s got tremendous presence in the film, but – in the same way that Matt Lewis has tremendous presence in Part 2, right? But he’s not one of the trio.

Andrew: [laughs] That’s true. That is true. “When Harry Left Hogwarts,” that is a documentary.

Eric: It sounds like it.

Andrew: And that should be interesting. I guess that’s going to be – there haven’t been any other details, really, but I guess that’s going to be about them wrapping up the series. That’s the only thing I can think of.

Eric: My impression is that it’s about filming on location in the English countryside, because you’re talking about no longer being able to stay at Leavesden and shoot the majority of the film in Hogwarts. So “When Harry Left Hogwarts,” I assume it means going – basically finding all these locations for them to film when they’re camping. That was my impression, was that it was about Harry not returning to Hogwarts. Instead they had to find a whole new way to shoot these films because so much of – well, all of Deathly Hallows – Part 1 happens outside of Hogwarts. So I’m looking forward to it being a documentary about filming Part 1, essentially, where it’s – they had to find all these places because they couldn’t rely on the walls of Hogwarts to spend most of their filming. That was my theory.

Micah: I thought it could even be about Dan Radcliffe post Potter, following…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …what he’s done after he’s left…

Eric: Interesting.

Micah: …the sets at Leavesden.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Because we know he’s done several things since then.

Andrew: Okay…

Micah: So, the other thing listed here, just really quickly, was the kiss between Ron and Hermione. But where does that factor into what’s being offered in sort of the Blu-ray package?

Andrew: That’s in “Maximum Movie Mode.”

Eric: Yeah, it’s one of the cutaways, I believe. Is it David Yates who intros it?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: So, I mean, Matt Lewis is hosting but I imagine they’ll have some of the other actors come on and speak the same way that it was in Part 1. I think regarding the release date real quick, which we were talking about earlier, I like that it comes out on November 11th, because the date however you put it, even if you put it in Britain, it’s 11/11/11.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: So – and everybody knows that…

Micah: That was planned, of course.

Eric: Well, that’s lucky. It’s just lucky. It’s a lucky date.

Micah: Lucky for sales?

Eric: I’ll be purchasing my – oh, maybe they hope so, [laughs] although they’ve done – they have other tactics for making sure it sells which we’ll get into. But I’m going to purchase my Deathly Hallows – Part 2 at 11:11 AM on 11/11/11 for extra, extra good luck.

Micah: There you go! Now, what about this Harry Potter: The Complete Eight Film Collection? This is also going to be released on 11/11/11, and there’s a lot of stuff in here. And again this is WB marketing the films to the highest possible level, I think. What do you guys…

Eric: Would you say a lot of stuff, or a lot of options? Because there appear to be – because you can get all eight films, and then you can get all eight films with a pin, all eight films with a Christmas ornament, isn’t it? Or am I confusing that with the DVD Part 2 releases? Because they’re doing like five or six different DVD collections you can get, some with Hogwarts crest pins, some with a Christmas ornament. Have you seen
WBShop.com where they have these sort of – the different versions?

Andrew: Yeah, it’s a lot. Personally, I don’t know why fans – at least people who listen to this podcast, for example, would buy a complete set when we already have all the DVDs in the first place.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: You just need Part 2 and you just want the special features. So they’ll be good Christmas gifts for people who – maybe younger generations who are just about to get into the Harry Potter series, but otherwise I don’t think those are going to be too big a bestsellers. But I agree, the Part 2 DVDs, they’re going to be hot sellers. I mean, just like the movie – the ticket sales for when it was in theaters, it was so strong because it was the last one. I think it’s going to be the same thing where WB, honestly, probably won’t even have to try very hard. [laughs] People are just going to buy it because it is the last one and maybe they didn’t see it in theaters, or they do want to see it again.

Micah: And how do these really different from – differ, sorry, from the Ultimate Editions, looking at having this eight-film collection? There are things in here but I’m wondering how much of it is cross-over with the Ultimate Editions.

Eric: I wish I knew.

Micah: Or is there a lot of new stuff here?

Eric: Yeah, I wish I knew. I mean, my impression is that it won’t have the Ultimate Edition documentaries, right? Shouldn’t they just be for the Ultimate Editions? And so, otherwise – or in other words – aren’t the original – even if they are on Blu-ray, aren’t they just going to be ports in terms of features? Like, menus the same as they were on the DVD?

Andrew: Yeah – oh exactly, and that’s pretty much how the Ultimate Editions are. If you go…

Eric: Exactly!

Andrew: …look on the Ultimate Edition – the DVD menus, the special features disc – that came with the original DVD when it first hit store shelves. So…

Eric: So, we’re talking about eleven-year-old content here. Nothing has changed.

Andrew: Minus the documentary.

Eric: Minus the documentary. So…

Andrew: From the Ultimate Editions. So yeah, that’s basically what these are. And, for some people, that is good. If you don’t want to buy all eight separately and you’re buying them for the first time, and you’re a casual Potter fan….

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …this is a good thing to have.

Eric: I mean, is it $79.95? Is it $89.95? One of those two? It’s about $80, I think, on WB Shop to pre-order the eight-film collection on Blu-ray. I think it’s $80.

Andrew: Yeah, Blu-ray is $100.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: And this is the one with the castle on the front, and the boats going to the castle. And the DVD is $70.

Eric: Okay. I am looking…

Andrew: On Amazon.

Eric: I want them to do like a holographic comparison between when the boats are going to Hogwarts in Year 1 and the Hogwarts on fire in Year 2, because those posters are so similar.

Andrew: That would be cool. There will be stuff. I mean, look at Star Wars. They are just releasing new deleted scenes now…

Eric: Yeah, yeah, there’s like forty of them.

Andrew: …with that complete Blu-ray set.

Eric: I mean, I haven’t bought that set but I will.

Andrew: So you know WB is sitting on classic stuff. Maybe even stuff like bloopers and whatnot.

Eric: Well, it’s just when you brand yourself – when you say “Ultimate Edition,” “Collectors Edition,” “Director’s Edition,” “Hogwarts set,” “full set” – it’s all noise. It’s all just noise to me.

Micah: Yeah. Well, the one thing we did ask David Yates about when I spoke to him was…

Andrew: It is a lot.

Micah: …bloopers and he said, rest assured, we do have bloopers but we didn’t release them early on because we didn’t want to put the child actors in a difficult situation.

Eric: Compromising situation.

Micah: But now I think that they’re all in their twenties, you are going to see more of that kind of stuff be released. But my question is with additional scenes for all of these movies, are they new scenes, or are they just the scenes that have been deleted and inserted…

Andrew: No.

Eric: The additional scenes – you’re saying like the additional scenes that have already been made available as additional scenes on previous sets?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Okay, so…

Andrew: They’re not new.

Eric: Yeah, I assume they are just the…

Micah: I mean, I’m just going through here.

Eric: All the films have typically had – yeah. What’s it say?

Micah: It doesn’t say anything more than additional. And are the shrunken head interviews something that’s already been put out there on the Prisoner of Azkaban Ultimate Edition?

Andrew: Yes. Maybe not even the Ultimate Edition, probably on the Prisoner of Azkaban DVD.

Eric: See, that’s such a shame. They could certainly be more descriptive here. I mean, if they’re just re-packaging content I can understand their hesitation. But that’s just what it seems like, is re-packaged content, and I just get angry when that happens, that’s all. I just – a little twinge, a little twang in my temple of my head. There’s a vein there.


News: LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7 Release Date Announced


Micah: Let’s move on to LEGO Harry Potter. That’s also going to be released now on November 11th. A good move on the part of WB Interactive and TT Games to coincide it.

Andrew: And not delayed this time.

Micah: No, not delayed. It’s – well, for right now.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: I think the release date was rumored to be November 15th, so not too far off, but ultimately what they decided to do was market this game with the Part 2 DVD and Blu-ray. And from what we’ve seen so far, I think people are really excited about the game. They really enjoyed the first one, Years 1-4, and Years 5-7 closely follow the movies. And the difference, though, is that they do have a lot of book components to them. So, they follow the general storyline of the movie, but a lot of stuff from the books has been added in to kind of compliment it.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: For – yeah, for content.

Micah: And so I’m sure we’re all looking forward to that game, and we’ll have to review it once it’s out.

Andrew: Yeah, kind of.

Eric: I think I’ll probably – I do want to try it, I do want to play it, but probably not on Wii. I played the first one on Wii and I just – I couldn’t get very far. Actually, I own it, but I couldn’t – never really got really far and I feel like the Wii is limited to a certain kind of gameplay, where you’re using the Wii. I’m going to try – when I get Years 5-7, it’ll probably be on Xbox.

Micah: All right.

Eric: Just to try something new.


News: Dog Who Played Padfoot is Looking for a Home


Micah: Sounds good. Well, next story, the dog who played Padfoot is looking for a new home. This was a big story for the fans, I think.

Andrew: Awww. Yeah, everybody was really moved.

Micah: And his trainer or his owner for some reason – I think mostly due to work and other responsibilities, just felt that he couldn’t take care of Berry, which is the dog’s real name, not Padfoot, and…

Eric: Or Sirius.

Micah: Yeah, or Sirius. And he had to give him up, and he gave him up to a shelter along with Porridge who is I guess Berry’s counterpart, his friend, the white German Shepherd. And both of them have been involved in films throughout the years, not just Prisoner of Azkaban, and I’m sure we’ll hear a story in the not-too-distant future where one, if not both, of these dogs ends up getting adopted.

Andrew: I’m sure they got a huge amount of offers. I don’t even know how you would decide who… [laughs]

Eric: Who gets the dog?

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: Yeah. Based on some of the responses on the web to this news story, you can just tell – I mean, people were – people not living in the UK were like, “How do I get him? Can I ship him overseas? How does this work?”

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: They were just ready to take him. I mean – and I think part of that is awareness. Could this guy, for instance, the trainer, have reached out to the fans? I think he could have. I mean, I’m sure that’s probably – would be more of a hassle that he didn’t want to get into.

Micah: Well, I’m sure that’s why he did the story, if you look at it. Why even bother doing a story? Nobody’s going to really know that you gave up the dog from Harry Potter unless you go to a paper and do an interview about it. And it blew up. I mean, it’s all throughout the Internet. All different news outlets were covering it…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …so it wasn’t just some random paper in the middle of England.

Eric: Yeah. And I think Sirius is many people’s – I mean, it’s mine – favorite character in the series, so it’s not like its collecting memorabilia here, but okay, this dog does need a home and he’s so recognizable. Even that photo we found of him, you could totally tell it’s the same dog, and it’s a piece of special Potter and it’s also a great opportunity for this pet whose owner could not take care of him anymore.


News: Pottermore Beta Period Extended


Micah: All right. Last piece of news here, and I’m sure we’ll spend a couple of minutes on it. It relates to our favorite old-man-on-a-porch topic, and that’s…

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: …Pottermore. And…

Eric: No, I have nothing to add because I have not been into Pottermore since we recorded the last episode, so fortunately I will not delay this conversation.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Well, the big news is that the Beta period has been extended and I think a lot of that has to do with the fact that really Pottermore wasn’t prepared for the volume, the traffic, that was going to hit its site.

Eric: What?!

Micah: And so…

Eric: Really?!

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: …this period has been extended into October and the official registration period for those who are not Beta testers I think will open in the end of October, right? It’s probably right around Halloween would probably be my guess, just coinciding with events in the series. But people have to be a little bit upset. If you’re somebody who’s been waiting, let’s say who didn’t get one of those one million e-mails, and now you’re trying to get in and you go, oh man, I’ve got to wait another month to even register, because – and registration – here’s the problem, registration is not going to guarantee you immediate access to the site. You may have to wait weeks or months to get in. And my question to all this is, why? Why is this such a big issue? Is it server cost? Is it not having the resources to support the amount of people who want to go to this website?

Eric: At the risk of repeating myself, I just don’t feel like anybody was – they must have forgotten to bring somebody on board and that somebody would have been the person to tell them what people are actually going to want out of Pottermore because when we did get on through the – to be Beta testers, our biggest complaint I think on the previous show was that there just wasn’t more to do, that there was sort of the capacity – there was stuff that you’re shown but you can’t click, you can’t see more, you can’t learn more, and it was really a vast wasteland of empty Flash animation. That’s my opinion, that’s my summary of it. But basically just talking about how they’ve handled this Beta process, where even in the Magical Quill Challenge which wasn’t initially announced by JK Rowling, it seemed like she was taking something away then because not just everybody could sign up immediately. They had to be on at a certain time of day. Now it feels like they’re taking even more away and I just feel like very early on – the only thing they said initially was that there would be a million Beta testers and because they set that limit, they drew the line in the sand about that, they’ve had to stick with that. But I just don’t feel like that was a wise decision, given how much – how often the site is crashing or – how often has it happened for you guys where you go try to get on Pottermore and there is – it has to reload and fifteen seconds, fifteen seconds, server overload due to overwhelming demand. And I’m saying “overwhelming” is the wrong word here because they said they’d let a million people in, so there should be nothing overwhelming about it if they control the access from day one.

Andrew: The other issue is that if you go look in the Great Hall – we know there is a million people in Pottermore now. If you go in the Great Hall, you’ll see that only 586,000 people have been sorted. So, that means there’s 420,000 accounts that have not either been used or gotten sorted yet. And now that either means people got really bored once they got into Pottermore and couldn’t even make it to Chapter 7, or they…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: These are multiple accounts and I think both maybe an issue here, because when the limited registration period was open, the Magical Quill process, there was tons of people – everybody was really anxious about being one of the first to get in and I think a lot of people created multiple accounts just thinking it would increase their chances…

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: …and I guess they did. But now a million people really aren’t within Pottermore. And the other issue to this story, to talk about something new here, is that now the – they’ve decided to delay the e-books until 2012, which I’m sure Sony is not happy about because – or the Pottermore higher-ups are happy about because, I mean, this is really the reason that Pottermore exists, and now it’s being delayed. And…

Eric: Which is to launch – you’re saying to launch…

Andrew: The e-book store, yeah.

Eric: …the e-book platform?

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, it was supposed to launch in October when Pottermore opened up, and it’s not coming out until next year now. And this probably also means that Chamber of Secrets is going to be delayed as well.

Micah: Right. Well, and that’s a huge issue…

Eric: It would have to.

Micah: …for, like you’re saying, the higher-ups at Pottermore as well as Sony because they’re missing the holiday window to sell all these e-books.

Eric: Yeah, they had to have – exactly, and they probably had in their financial projections – that probably took into account this huge – this is the first time the Harry Potter books are available on e-book, officially, is through this up and coming Sony e-book store, right? So, I mean, all the projected earnings from that – we’re talking about – say everybody who has ever owned the Harry Potter books now wants it digitally, which – it’s not that many people, but still, I mean, that’s – if half the people want it on e-book now, look at the sales that they’re now not going to get until first quarter 2012 as opposed to final quarter 2011. That messes a lot of things up.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s bad. It’s a mess. [laughs] So – and yeah, I mean, so now when registration does open up to everyone later this month, you’re not even going to get in immediately. It’s going to be just like the Magical Quill process. I mean, the Pottermore Insider said it could be weeks or months…

Micah: Right.

Andrew: …before you get in.

Micah: And that’s where I agree. Eric brought up a great point saying, when you control the number of people that are going to have access to the site and then you’re not prepared for it, that’s just a really poor job on the part of the people at Pottermore and the ones behind setting all of this up, because how can you not be prepared for what you’re expecting?

Eric: You control the limits, essentially. But then the other thing is, too, this time that they’re taking, I really hope they fix stuff. Take all the time you need almost before official registration. I’m happy with no new content as long as once I get new content, it’s with the insight of the feedback that they’ve gotten. You know what I’m saying? I would really love if they would go back to Book 1 and add more stuff based on what we’ve seen so far. If they could add some stuff or…

Micah: Well, they do say enhancements and simplifications have been promised, so they are going to make changes.

Eric: Yeah, and that kind of thing is what I would like to see moving forward. It’s like fine, nothing like this has ever been done, so can we cut them a break? Yes, absolutely. I feel like many a breaks can be cut to them for taking on this massive project. But they did take it on, and they have a certain dignity to keep in terms of this. So, when they’re taking this extra time and delaying registration and all of this stuff, I really want to see something good come out of it, which is a really awesome site, better than ever, but also with the ability to handle the type of capacity that they should have always known to expect with Pottermore. But my question, too, to Andrew is, how new is this news story that they delayed? Did the Pottermore Insider – when did the Insider blog about this?

Micah: Yesterday.

Andrew: Yesterday.

Eric: Yesterday? Because that was what, September 31st…

Micah: 30th.

Eric: …that they’re – 30th, that they’re telling people that you can’t actually get in tomorrow?

Micah: [laughs] A little late on the notification for those who are waiting for normal registration.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: That’s what I’m saying and many people, I guess, assumed – because it was never mentioned when in October registration would officially open, but people assumed it was either the 1st or the 31st. I feel like that was a discussion that we had on the show, too, would it be Halloween or would it be October 1st? Because she said, “come October.” Well, now we know but also they just waited until the last day of September to tell us that we weren’t going to get in on October 1st? What’s going on here?

Andrew: All around, it’s just disappointing and…

Micah: The whole situation – and yes, it’s a Beta period for a reason but I think the whole process up until this point – it doesn’t seem like something that JK Rowling would be in charge of or behind. I mean, I understand it…

Eric: Or want to even be a…

Micah: Well…

Eric: …part of.

Micah: …she’s providing the content and that’s really her role but I just think that this whole situation from back when you had to discover what it was that she was revealing, and then the Magic Quill, and now getting access and getting that screen all the time – I think part of what they’ve done, too, is they will restrict it to certain – for people who have just gotten access to Pottermore. I think in some cases, they restrict people who have previously already entered the site so that these people can now experience it without the site crashing on them.


Chapter-by-Chapter: “The Ministry of Magic”


Andrew: Now we’re going to get into Chapter-by-Chapter. It’s been a few weeks or a couple of months, but if you remember we were last reading Order of the Phoenix and did Chapter 6 of the book, so that leads us to Chapter 7 now and Eric is going to take that chapter.

Eric: Great! So, where we left off – basically, Harry’s disciplinary hearing at the Ministry of Magic is coming up and in Chapter 6, which is the last chapter we did, at the very end of it, Harry discovers that Dumbledore actually was at Grimmauld Place. Harry has been sort of missing Dumbledore. Dumbledore has not been around that much. He finds out that Dumbledore actually came to Grimmauld Place and essentially put the nix on whether or not Sirius could accompany Harry, because Harry is dreading this upcoming hearing. But Harry just kind of doesn’t know why Dumbledore would show up and not say hi to him, or even be more supportive of Harry in this difficult time. So, that’s sort of what Harry is feeling. He is obviously very, very worried and of course the next day is when his hearing is. So, Chapter 7, “The Ministry of Magic,” is actually a pretty short chapter and reading through it, it’s just very, very funny because she is introducing us finally to the main place where wizards work, essentially going back to the boat ride that Hagrid took with Harry, and he was reading the paper and Harry said, “There’s a Ministry of Magic?” Well, five books later, now we get to read it – or now we get to meet it. So, that was really exciting.

My first question comes from – in the morning when they set off, basically Harry wakes up, he doesn’t sleep very well, everybody’s already awake, they said they didn’t sleep well, he tries to have some breakfast, can’t eat, and he begins to go with Arthur towards the Ministry. Now, he asks Arthur if he normally walks to work in the morning, because they are actually taking Muggle transportation to get there. And Mr. Weasley’s reply is, “No, I usually Apparate, but obviously you can’t.” So, essentially his reasoning for them not just Apparating into the Ministry is that Harry can’t Apparate. But isn’t there something in the books called Side-Along Apparition? That’s my question, because in the beginning of Book 6, Dumbledore and Harry Apparate and it’s a Side-Along Apparition where essentially only one person actually needs to know how to Apparate. So, is this a book mistake, or did JK Rowling maybe not create that at the moment when Arthur and Harry are walking to work, do you think?

Andrew: Hmm, I don’t know. Maybe Arthur wanted to give him the traditional entrance to the Ministry of Magic, being the phone booth. I mean, to me, it was more of an exciting – it was kind of like a classic Jo – like learning how people can enter through a phone booth that brings you down into the Ministry of Magic. I don’t know, I thought it was cool, and maybe that’s why Jo wanted to do it, too. It’s more interesting than the Side-Along Apparition.

Eric: Yeah, I agree. It’s probably more elegant, too. And there’s no question that Arthur, who had never used this entrance himself, would be fascinated by it, and I think that’s part of what sets the tone for this chapter, is that they’re walking through the Underground, and Arthur is commenting on the turnstiles and how everything is just fascinating.

Micah: Yeah, but isn’t it part so that it sets up what happens later on in the book, how the group of Harry, Ron, Hermione, Luna, Neville, so on, get into the Ministry? They wouldn’t have known how to get in otherwise if this doesn’t take place.

Andrew: Oh, good point.

Eric: That’s actually – that’s a really good point. So, there’s that. And then I guess the other half of Mr. Weasley’s sentence is that he also wants to use the Muggle way because Apparating into the Ministry would not look as good based on Harry is going to the Ministry to be disciplined for using magic. So, that made sense, but I just – it struck me that he said, “You don’t know how to Apparate,” as being one of the reasons.

Micah: It doesn’t make sense, though, because he’s with another wizard and he’s within a wizarding household, so why would it be an issue for him to use magic?

Eric: Mhm. So, at least for the reasons we described, I think it’s probably best the way it is in the book, but that was the question. Next, the minister – the visitor entrance to the Ministry of Magic is located in a shabby old telephone box on a street with a few shabby offices, a pub, and an overflowing dumpster. That’s my summary. So, Mr. Weasley – he picks up the telephone when they’re in this box. They’re crowded into this red telephone box, and he dials the number 6-2-4-4-2. And I’m asking – do you guys know that – there’s actually a special significance to this sequence of numbers, and do you guys know what it is?

Andrew: Of course! We – it used to be MuggleCast’s number, don’t you remember? 11-218-206-2442.

Eric: Oh my God. I forgot.

Andrew: Yeah, it means MAGIC, right, and Jo did not spell that out in the book, right?

Eric: Right, she doesn’t. He – it’s done in dialogue and Mr. Weasley says, “Okay, it’s a six, and then a two, and then a four and another four, and then a two.” So, you have to basically – you have to decipher because you’re reading it in dialogue and you’re not reading the numbers with hyphens.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s awesome.

Eric: So, it was a coded way of doing it. It’s brilliant, and yes, on a – not a touch tone phone, but on a phone that has an alphanumeric…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: I guess it’s called keys, 6-2-4-4-2 is MAGIC and that’s the number you dial to get down into the Ministry of Magic, so I thought that was…

Micah: Well, you can also do it on her site. I forget what it reveals…

Eric: Oh, right!

Micah: It reveals some hidden content.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: So, that was just sort of one of those moments of brilliance that I thought I would remind everybody, but you guys are old pros, and of course…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: …our MuggleCast number was that. So, whatevs. Once inside the beautiful atrium of the Ministry, Harry has to present his wand and his self for inspection. A badly-shaven wizard takes Harry’s wand, he puts it on some kind of a scale, but there’s only one scale as opposed to two, so it’s not balancing. And the instrument spits out a piece of paper that this badly-shaven wizard then reads. It says the core of Harry’s wand, and the length of Harry’s wand, and how many years the wand has been in use, because the wizard reads the paper and he asks Harry, “It’s been in use four years, is this correct?” But I’m just wondering what the importance of this examination is, if you guys had any thoughts on that. Why is years of use important, and what’s the purpose of figuring out how long the wand is? What does that matter?

Micah: Isn’t it just like a security check?

Andrew: Yeah, and it’s sort of like…

Eric: So, is it just…

Andrew: It’s you. I mean, the wand chooses the wizard. It’s a very important aspect of yourself, sort of like on a driver’s license in the real world where you have your weight, your eye color, your height. This is just another one of those things, I think, that they take into consideration when checking you in. It’s just a part of you.

Eric: So, that’s interesting. And that wizard’s name is Eric, by the way.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Excellent.

Eric: Which is cool. Except he’s kind of a jerk. He notices Harry and then Mr. Weasley is like, “Thank you, Eric,” and pulls Harry away. So anyway, they go on an elevator ride at the Ministry and this is where the majority of the chapters – because basically as they go on each level, JK Rowling writes what’s on each level…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …because the voice announces it, which is really, really cool and it’s – again, it adds to sort of the humor in light of all this anxiety that Harry has…

Andrew: Yeah, I was fascinated by…

Eric: …towards his…

Andrew: …just learning…

Eric: …court date.

Andrew: … all the floors and what is covered. I remember reading this for the first time.

Eric: Yeah, there is so much. There really is so much and it’s relevant to either this book or other books. There’s the Department of Magical Games, which obviously had a huge handle in the Quidditch World Cup the previous year. And speaking of level four of the Ministry, it “houses the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures, incorporating Beasts, Being and Spirit Divisions.” And I know a couple of episodes ago on MuggleCast, we had a question – I don’t know how long ago it was, but we did have a question about Moaning Myrtle, because in one of the books she expresses to Harry – it’s actually during Goblet of Fire, I think it is, when she’s in the bathroom. She says to Harry that she had haunted Olive Hornby after dying but that the Ministry made her return to Hogwarts and we wondered, “How would they do that?” Well, apparently – maybe the answer lies in this department, which is the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures, because as we see in this chapter of Book 5, it has a Spirit division. So, the Regulation and Control of Magical Spirits is obviously – they would have a hand in telling ghosts where to be and somehow controlling them. So, I thought that that answered a long-time MuggleCast question.

Andrew: Hmm, interesting.

Eric: Yeah. But things like that, they are just peppered in this chapter, and later on in St. Mungo’s the same thing happens where all sorts of important stuff in the Harry Potter world – or unimportant stuff, but it just fleshes out the world. So, then Harry gets to visit the Auror office which seems like a really cool place. Everybody has a cubicle in there. It’s either a bunch of wanted posters or some Quidditch teams, I guess, on everybody’s cubicle, which I thought was a really cool thing. Kingsley hands Mr. Weasley what turns out to be The Quibbler, actually, which is kind of a book too soon in a good way.

Andrew: Oh! A little foreshadowing, kind of.

Eric: Yeah, I think it’s about Sirius Black. Essentially they’re tracking Sirius Black, I think we find out later, but they obviously – Kingsley and Mr. Weasley, in this whole conversation that they have in the Auror office, have this sort of fake conversation where they don’t really know each other that well, which I thought was really interesting to read because Harry sees that they have to put on this face to be safe, essentially. Like I think at one point, Kingsley and Weasley – they’re there finishing their conversation and Mr. Weasley mutters, “Oh, if you can make it out of here by seven, Molly is making meatballs tonight.” So, it’s just very funny. And also they go to Arthur’s office and apparently – there’s these [laughs] Muggle artifacts, as there should be, but Arthur says that he and his roommate or cubicle-mate, Perkins, have been trying to get a window in the office but that the Ministry doesn’t think that they need one. Essentially there are these enchanted windows, he says, which is kind of cool because they’re underground, and I feel like real businesses – don’t – Micah, do you know this? Like real businesses have windows underground just to – because doesn’t it – it builds morale if you see sunshine, right? Have you ever seen any…

Andrew: I don’t think businesses are ever underground. You always have an office with a window because you do need that – you do need to feel like you’re not trapped in a cave or a dungeon or something, so – I mean, it’s definitely a good idea…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …that they did it and of course with magic it is possible, so…

Eric: Yeah, with fake lighting I feel like it creates more – psychologically if you have light in your – what looks to be sunlight or imitation sunlight, that it builds morale. So, then…

Micah: Well, one thing that I did notice on the last job that I had, they were redoing a lot of the floors and what they tried to do was create it such that more natural light was coming in, and I think that’s something that a lot of businesses these days do look to do, so that – it does boost morale, it is more positive on most days when there is sunlight. So, not to kind of go off on a tangent, but yeah, they do look to do those types of things.

Eric: So, finally, Perkins rushes into Mr. Weasley’s office and tells them that Harry’s hearing has changed both its time and its venue. The new location is in old Courtroom 10, which hasn’t been used in years.

Andrew: Uh oh.

Eric: So, to get – yeah, this is odd. Arthur’s like, “I don’t even know – it doesn’t make any sense.” So, apparently the elevator doesn’t even go as far low as these old courtrooms, and Arthur and Harry have to take the lift down to Level 9 which is the Department of Mysteries, comes into play a little later in the book, and they have to take – they actually have to walk down corridors and stairs from Level 9 where the Department of Mysteries is to get down to these old dungeons. And then the corridors are lit by torches, it’s very medieval, archaic, and Harry mentions that – or Harry feels as though he’s going down to Snape’s dungeon. So, sure enough – they’re actually already late for the meeting because the time has changed and they say they have to be there five minutes ago. So this is not a good way to start the hearing here and Harry – at the end of the chapter, he’s basically pushed in, shown the right door by Mr. Weasley who says he cannot accompany him, and Harry is finding himself all alone.

MuggleCast 240 Transcript (continued)


Chapter-by-Chapter: “The Hearing”


Micah: Yeah, so that really kicks off Chapter 8, “The Hearing” and Harry recognizes the courtroom that he’s in from when he went into the Pensieve back in Goblet of Fire. And he realizes that he is in the same room that the Death Eater trials were held in when he saw Bellatrix Lestrange and Igor Karkaroff and Barty Crouch, Jr. So right off the bat, he clearly is gone from being probably very uneasy to extremely uneasy. And he approaches the same chair that he remembers the chains kind of shooting up and tying the Death Eaters down, and fortunately for him, though, that doesn’t happen and he sits down before the entire Wizengamot, and at the head of it is Cornelius Fudge. And he also sees Percy and at the very least, [laughs] the last bit of hope that he has inside of himself is for Percy to kind of recognize him, and Percy doesn’t even acknowledge that he’s in the room. And you can kind of see really the initial change in Percy now. He’s gone from at least being somewhat cordial towards Harry to pretending as if he’s not even there.

Eric: Yeah. I think it’s so severe. I mean, these are the courtrooms that they tried [laughs] Death Eaters in, and now Harry is for a little misuse of magic here. It’s just very intense and suspense.

Micah: Right, but earlier in the book we hear for Harry not to even ask about Percy and now we can kind of see why.

Eric: Yeah, and just – again, in the previous chapter when they’re in Arthur Weasley’s office, there’s a picture of the Weasleys but Percy – Harry notes that Percy seems to have walked off so he’s not even in the picture. He’s not even appearing in pictures with the rest of his family. So it’s very clear that – and again in this chamber, that Percy is kind of – not exile but he’s disowned himself from almost everything they stand for. Or everything recognizable.

Andrew: And it’s sad and an interesting plot point because it’s like why would – seeing someone leave the Weasley family clan, it’s always been such a – I almost said “perfect” but – a happy family.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And then suddenly there is this drama and it’s surprising.

Eric: Yeah. Heck, if I knew there was an opening in the Weasley family I’d join in.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: I’d dye my hair red. Right? But it just seems like – yeah. Such a nice family.

Micah: So Fudge starts to make introductions – he introduces himself, Amelia Bones, and then Percy as well – and starts listing what the crimes are that Harry is being charged of. And all of a sudden, we hear the voice of Dumbledore, and Dumbledore really appears out of nowhere and says that he is counsel for the defense. And Harry notes that at this moment he feels something like Phoenix Song inside of him when he sees Dumbledore. But Dumbledore, much like his odd behavior at Grimmauld Place, refuses to meet Harry’s eyes and this becomes a larger plot point throughout the rest of Order of the Phoenix. And so Eric, you brought up the fact that clearly Harry’s time for his trial was changed and he just gets there on time. But there’s a little bit of a funny back and forth between Fudge and Dumbledore, and Dumbledore notes the fact that while he didn’t receive the owl that was sent to him, by lucky mistake he arrived at the Ministry three hours early.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: So did he in fact suspect that something like this would happen?

Eric: Yeah, I think the problem is that Fudge really wants to stick this on Harry. For whatever reason – and it could be coming out of this large issue that at the end of Year 4, both Harry and Dumbledore said that Voldemort was back. And that’s essentially what this hearing is even all about, is a real strong ploy to discredit Harry and maybe even expel him. And it makes Fudge a villain even more so than he has been in the past but it really starts to make him a villain because his ignorance is now to the point where it’s really affecting the natural order of things which is for Harry to go to school. And I feel like this scene is well represented in the film, where Michael Gambon as Dumbledore says surely it’s become standard practice to hold a full trial for a little case of student – essentially out of bed. But I really think that Fudge is showing how scared he is about everything, because changing the time – I think Dumbledore having known Fudge for so long could absolutely predicted that this would happen, and who knows if an owl was even ever sent. Fudge asked Dumbledore, “Oh, so you received the owl we sent?” That’s a quote-on-quote owl. Who says they ever sent one notifying Dumbledore of the change in time? They probably didn’t.

Andrew: And Fudge clearly has it in for Harry. I mean, the evidence against him is not strong at all. He was clearly acting in self-defense. And this just shows that Fudge just wants to nail him.

Micah: Yeah, no question. And this kind of brought up an interesting question when Dumbledore comes in, and says that he’s there to speak on behalf of Harry and argue in his defense. We saw the trials for the Death Eaters but there didn’t seem to be anybody to speak on behalf of them, and I’m wondering, is the [laughs] judicial system in the Potter world similar to the one we have, or how does that work? Because clearly they have committed crimes and we know that but every person is entitled to somebody speaking on their behalf, and it didn’t seem like there was anybody in the case of all the memories that we saw in the Pensieve.

Andrew: Who would, though?

Eric: Yeah, I’m sure that in dark times it would be inadvisable to associate yourself with other Death Eaters. I mean, unless it’s a case where you’re their family members. Like, that’s what made the trial of Barty Crouch, Jr. so interesting, was that his father was so ruthless that he would try his son and do so without representing him. And Crouch’s wife, pool gal, while she was alive had to sit in the crowd of that hearing. But again, it’s a situation where they didn’t – Crouch, Sr. had very little interest in protecting his son from the full extent of the law, and so perhaps back then they could have had a counsel but I feel like it would have been treated or met with impunity with this heavy dislike towards the Dark Arts because back then Voldemort was killing everybody’s family. Like, left, right, people were dead. So if you were to somehow defend a Death Eater on trial you may be…

Micah: It doesn’t matter, though. Every criminal has a defense attorney. It doesn’t matter what crimes you commit.

Eric: But in the wizarding world, do they? I mean…

Micah: That’s what I’m asking.

Eric: Yeah. I don’t know, I feel like they don’t almost because I mean, they’re already in Azkaban, right? I mean, when we see some of those trials like for Karkaroff…

Micah: Well, let’s say before that. They’re arrested, they have to go before a trial.

Eric: I think based on what we know about Sirius Black, right? Like, there were the witnesses, and the witnesses – obviously they saw the wrong thing or they reported that they saw the wrong thing. But the problem with that is that they wiped their memories because they were all Muggles. So immediately after collecting the reports from the Muggles that saw Sirius Black get arrested, they wiped their memories so all you have to go on, really to convict Sirius Black, is the word of the collectors, right? I mean, the people who collected the memories. It’s not a situation where you can have witnesses that were necessarily there at the same time. I think – although again what helped Sirius get convicted was that Dumbledore gave evidence in his trial. So, I just don’t know. It sounds like there was a trial then, if Dumbledore gave evidence, right? So perhaps in all these cases there are people to defend – I just don’t think – I mean, if your question is if everybody is entitled to a lawyer, perhaps, but I can certainly see why there wouldn’t be. I feel like the pressure to defend somebody like this would be too high for…

Andrew: In dark times.

Eric: Unless it’s…

Andrew: Like you said at the beginning.

Eric: In dark times, yeah.

Micah: Yeah. All right. Well, they start the trial and Amelia Bones is very impressed by the fact that Harry can produce a corporal Patronus. And I think you start to get a feeling that while Fudge is clearly against Harry, Amelia Bones is a fair-minded witch and is probably going to give him a fair trial.

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: And Fudge fails to believe Harry’s story about the Dementors and Dumbledore then decides: well, I’m going to call in our witness, and he brings in Arabella Figg. And she tells her account of what happened but it’s not very convincing and it’s apparent that she was coached. Should we be surprised that Figg was coached by Dumbledore?

Andrew: Should we be surprised? No, because the character of Mrs. Figg is a nervous one, a weak one. I mean, Dumbledore had her just keeping an eye on Harry at Privet Drive, and that’s really the only thing she could do, just keep an eye out and alert Dumbledore or someone else if there were ever to be trouble. So – but Dumbledore really needed her to stand trial because she was one of the witnesses so I think the coaching was necessary to help ensure that Harry would actually be proven innocent.

Micah: Mhm. It’s interesting because in an interview after the book was released, JK Rowling said that Squibs can’t see Dementors. But when you go back to what happened in that alleyway when Figg shows up, she knows that Dementors were there.

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: So it’s interesting – maybe it’s something that she can sense but not necessarily see.

Eric: Yeah, which is the problem with having her as a witness in this discussion because the last thing the Ministry wants to believe is that there actually were Dementors, right? And the witness is this Squib who actually can’t see but perhaps can sense Dementors. And so you have a situation where Harry knows he was defending himself, Figg knows that Harry was defending himself, and the Ministry knows that he produced the Patronus Charm, and it doesn’t make sense to produce a Patronus Charm in front of a Muggle unless you’re protecting yourself and the Muggle against Dementors. But it’s really a situation where it’s completely fair to pick the side that’s going to suit you best, which is what the Ministry does and it’s what Harry does. But Harry – we know that Harry is in the right but the Ministry – they’re in this situation where they know he produced the Patronus Charm, his defense is, well, there were Dementors, and that’s very inconvenient for the Ministry to accept when they can’t accept it.

Micah: So, you do get a lot of back and forth now between Dumbledore and Fudge, and Dumbledore ultimately says that he doesn’t believe the Dementors were there by accident, and Fudge thinks Dumbledore is mad. And then Dumbledore says, “We must ask ourselves why somebody within the Ministry ordered a pair of Dementors into that alleyway on the second of August.” So, now he’s really starting to challenge Fudge because if – he’s basically going through all the rationale that Fudge is providing and he’s saying, “Well, the only option that you’re leaving on the table, Minister, is that somebody within your command decided to send two Dementors to Little Whinging.”

Eric: Which is exactly what happened, as we know later, yeah.

Micah: So, does he know? That’s the thing. You know, Dumbledore is very smart…

Eric: But yet – but it couldn’t – he couldn’t know it was Umbridge. He couldn’t know specifically it was Umbridge, because if he knew specifically that it was Umbridge who ordered the Dementors, I don’t think he would have let her into Hogwarts.

Micah: Or maybe he would, to keep a closer eye on her.

Andrew: Dumbledore knows all. I think he absolutely knew, in some way or another. He’s so well connected, he could have a source inside the Ministry that confirmed this to him.

Eric: Maybe. But I think – isn’t – I mean, later on – we’ll have to review this later on when we find out, but I feel like Fudge certainly doesn’t know that Umbridge went and did that. Like, Umbridge was acting in Fudge’s best interest, right, but she did it secretly so that – because she was essentially achieving his goals without – but – that way he doesn’t carry the guilt of it, you know?

Andrew: Was it Dumbledore’s choice to have Umbridge in Hogwarts? I mean, wasn’t it…

Micah: No.

Andrew: Yeah. So, I mean…

Eric: Well no, but I’m sure he really could have prevented it, right? I mean, if he knew that…

Andrew: Maybe.

Eric: …she was the one who set the Dementors on Harry…

Micah: Well, that’s what we’re getting to in a little bit. But we are introduced to Umbridge for the first time, and she’s described as “…a large pale toad. She was rather squat, with a broad, flabby face, as little neck as Uncle Vernon and a very wide, slack mouth.” And I just thought it was interesting that right after Dumbledore says that it had to be somebody in the Ministry that did it, it’s Umbridge who speaks up. So…

[Eric imitates Umbridge’s cough]

Micah: Yeah, a little bit of foreshadowing there, that it was Umbridge who was responsible for this. And she…

Eric: She was provoked.

Micah: Imelda Staunton has that great line in the movie where she says, “Pardon me, Professor Dumbledore, but I…” What is it? “It sounds as if you’re insinuating that the Ministry had something to do with this.”

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And we can tell that she’s a bitch right from the start.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: So – [laughs] now, more back-and-forth continues between Fudge and Dumbledore about what Harry has been accused of, and whether or not he had the right to defend himself. And really the question I have is, what does Fudge hope to gain from convicting Harry here? I mean, you start to bring up a lot of what’s happened at Hogwarts previously, and Dumbledore makes the point that it’s not the Ministry’s business what Harry does at school, and that they cannot expel him for what he has done. And that’s where I really think it all begins. Going back to what you were talking about before with Umbridge being allowed to teach there, it’s not Dumbledore’s choice. Umbridge is forced upon him. And I think this is really where Fudge gets the idea, “Well, if Dumbledore thinks that it’s not our business what goes on at Hogwarts and that we can’t expel students, well, I’m going to show him. I’m going to put one of my officials right in the teaching ranks.”

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Right, right. And that makes sense. Yeah, it just – it makes sense that that’s a logical step.

Micah: Well – but back to the other question, what do you guys think Fudge hopes to gain from convicting Harry? I mean, he’s, what, fifteen at this time?

Eric: Well, he wants to discredit – he just wants to discredit.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: I think he senses, very rightly so, that – maybe even that he’s wrong about Voldemort, but just in general that Dumbledore is such this force for good here, that he’s clearly raising Harry to be his greatest defender, to – whether it’s for Dumbledore’s purposes or for the good of wizard-kind, Dumbledore has put all his stock in Harry, and Fudge is more inclined to believe that Harry’s a misfit. And so any chance that Fudge can get to disrupt this process of Dumbledore essentially raising an army against Fudge, starting with Harry, who is very clearly the poster-child, then he’s going to exploit it. He’s going to exploit that opportunity.

Micah: All right. Well, the next part that I want to talk about goes back to that quote that you mentioned before, Eric, that Dumbledore says. And really, what I think Dumbledore is doing is he’s trying to make it very plain and clear to the other members of the Wizengamot that are sitting there that something is really amiss, and the practices that Fudge has been using are really out of character of what the Minister should be doing, because he says, “In the few short weeks since I was asked to leave, it has already become the practice to hold a full criminal trial to deal with a simple matter of underage magic!” And what I want to know is – yeah, he’s the Minister, right? Okay, we get that. But how could he justify calling a hearing of the Wizengamot for such a minor offense?

Andrew: I think it’s for the same reason that Eric just brought up. He just wants to disprove Harry, he wants to prove that he’s wrong, and he wants to make a statement that if anybody goes out there and tries to prove that Death Eaters are attacking, or Voldemort’s back, or whatever, that they will take action and they will put you through a full trial or through a hearing.

Eric: And just like in the real world, right? Higher-profile cases get more attention.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And they’re therefore dealt with – they have higher security and lots more TV cameras. But I feel like it’s a higher-profile case from the start, so perhaps it also aided in them maybe – and I’m talking about the members of the Wizengamot – saying, “Okay, maybe this wouldn’t normally happen, but I -” they’re going to support the Minister, not just because he’s the Minister, but maybe it makes more sense since Harry is a high-profile case.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Well, he’s only a high-profile case because they’re making it one, and because he’s Harry Potter, obviously. But it’s…

Eric: Well, he’s… [unintelligible]

Micah: Yeah, it’s just – everything is being manipulated here. All the laws, all the rules, are being manipulated so that they can get a guilty conviction out of somebody who’s clearly in the right and is innocent. And I think…

Eric: I think this…

Micah: …that speaks to a larger issue.

Eric: It also…

Micah: I think…

Eric: Yeah, go on.

Micah: No, I’m just saying, paralleling it between our world and the series – we’ve spent many episodes talking about certain comparisons between what goes on in the wizarding world and what goes on in the real world, and how JK Rowling obviously took examples of things that have happened in history and sort of infused them into the series.

Eric: Well, I think looking at this in another light, which is the character building that this does for Harry – because I think that this experience, this negative experience, with being thrown to the wolves, essentially, by the Minister himself, allows Harry ñ first of all, it sets the stage for what is going to happen with Umbridge, which is that they had to disobey a teacher because she’s an evil witch, and disobey the government because she’s an evil witch who is not morally aligned. Harry has to be prepared, and he’s prepared by this to eventually set the Ministry, the law, the governing body of law, aside because it’s what he needs to do to fight Voldemort. So, I think this is one of those things that really sets his character up. It really builds his distrust in the government because they’re doing this to him. So, maybe that makes him more sympathetic to us as readers to get behind his disobeying the law, which he does later. He hasn’t done it in this case because as you say, he’s in the right, but perhaps in the future – and when he breaks into the Ministry, it’s all for a good cause and it can all be justified, and I think maybe that’s why this whole thing was important.

Micah: Yep. So, what ends up happening is they go to a vote and Harry is cleared of all charges, and that’s where the chapter ends. Dumbledore leaves the court room without ever saying a word to Harry, so that plot line continues to develop – or not develop, I guess, [laughs] depending on how you look at it. But it’s going to become a major issue throughout the course of Order of the Phoenix.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Excelente.

Eric: Great.


Muggle Mail: Jamie’s Accurate Prediction in Episode 6


Andrew: Well, that’s Chapter-by-Chapter, Chapters 6 and 7 – or 7 and 8 of Order of the Phoenix. And maybe in another episode or two, we’ll be back with another Chapter-by-Chapter. So, to wrap up the show, we’re going to do a couple of e-mails then a little preview to what’s to come on future episodes of MuggleCast to wrap up the year. First of all, this e-mail from BlackEyedLily, 49, of Palm Harbor, Florida. She writes ñ or he ñ no, it’s a she.

“In your last episode, 239, you read an e-mail from a listener commenting on listening to past episodes can reveal times that MuggleCast staff made very accurate predictions to events in Book 7. They referred to Episode 71, and a comment about whether Harry might be called on to sacrifice himself, but then not have to. I’ve got a better reference than that.”

Eric: Ooh!

Andrew: [continues]

“While I’m amazed that you discussed the “Harry is a Horcrux” theory as early as Episode 1, it is Episode 6 that blows me away. In that episode, Jamie speculates that Voldemort accidentally made Harry a Horcrux when he first tried to kill him, and that is why he has this special connection to Voldemort’s mind and shares skills like Parselmouth. I think that was an amazing theory very early after the release of the ‘Half-Blood Prince’ book. Love the show and the old episodes are still entertaining.”

I’m having computer issues so I can’t play the clip, but very well done, Jamie. [laughs]

Eric: Wow.

Micah: Will those computer issues be resolved by the time you edit the show?

Andrew: Yeah, I just can’t play stuff through. So, yeah.

Micah: Oh, okay. But the listeners will hear it.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, you should still play it on the episode.

[Episode 6 clip plays]

Andrew: Yeah, that’s a good point because – okay, so Voldemort – say Voldemort put a Horcrux into Harry. Well, if he wants to kill him so bad, then why would he try to kill one of his own Horcruxes? Hmm. I like that.

Jamie: No, he didn’t mean to put the Horcrux in, that’s the whole point.

Eric: I don’t think he meant to, either.

Jamie: He inadvertently made the Horcrux when his spell backfired. Slughorn said that to create a Horcrux, you had to kill and then knowingly put the part of your soul that you’ve created into the Horcrux, and why would Voldemort want to make Harry a Horcrux if he’s just going to kill him straight afterwards? The only thing that could possibly happen is that Dumbledore said that when he tried to kill him, he put a piece of him inside that he didn’t realize, so the only thing that it could be is that Voldemort inadvertently put part of his soul into Harry after he tried to kill him. And now that Harry is a Horcrux, it doesn’t really bear well for him surviving the series.

Eric: Which is probably…

Ben: We don’t know what process goes into making a Horcrux.

Jamie: No, exactly. But…

Eric: But Dumbledore said that he unwittingly or unknowingly transferred powers to Harry that night. He doesn’t really – no, that was in Chamber of Secrets

Jamie: And that’s different from the Horcrux.

Eric: …after he finds the diary, and Dumbledore says in Half-Blood Prince that he knew then about the Horcruxes or kind of figured it. But Dumbledore said he transferred powers, he didn’t say he transferred his soul or thing.

Jamie: Harry’s scar can’t be the powers that he’s got. The scar tells him when Voldemort’s close or it did, but the power that he has can’t only come from the scar, so it had to be something else that was put into him. It had to be part of his soul.

Eric: No. I don’t know.

Ben: I don’t know about that.

Eric: Just because Dumbledore said it would be very unwise to trust another living thing with your soul because you could probably do something about it. But then Harry would…

Jamie: Exactly, he’s a person.

Eric: Now he’s been practicing Legilimency against Harry, or Occlumency. Whatever.

[Clip ends]


Muggle Mail: Deathly Hallows: Parts 1 & 2 Released As One Film?


Andrew: Next e-mail is from Alison, 23, of Stone Ridge, Virginia. She writes:

“Hey MuggleCasters! First of all, I’d like to say that I have been a long time fan of the show and I always enjoy listening to your discussions on the series, films, and everything in between. Here’s my question: Do you think WB will ever release ‘Deathly Hallows: Parts 1 and 2’ as one film? Because I, like many other ‘Potter’ fans, would love to experience the two parts as one without having to switch DVDs. Well, just wanted to hear your thoughts.”

Since we did talk about the DVDs, I thought that was a good question. I mean, why don’t we see a set that’s just Parts 1 and 2 combined?

Eric: Well, could you really fit four hours of media onto a disc? And would you want to? Like, whether or not this film was on [laughs] VHS or LaserDisc or CDs, DVDs, you’re going to have to switch media. It’s a long…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …project. I don’t see – in other words, I don’t see the – I don’t see it as a hassle, to switch DVDs between the movies. You just plug it in, there’s a main menu, you just push “Play”, right? I mean, that’s all there is to it.

Andrew: It still would be cool, though, if it was an uninterrupted transition. I think for Blu-ray they could probably put both, but yeah, definitely not DVD.

Eric: Well, WB, knowing them and how they’ve marketed these sets with the Christmas ornaments [laughs] and the house pins, I’m sure that it’s not unlike them to possibly do that release in the future and I think it would be pretty cool, and depending on what special features come out with it, I think it would maybe even be worth buying. But in the meantime, I’m totally content. I feel like the – I don’t feel like it’s a problem to put the movies in back to back, and I think that’s never a better time to take a bathroom break…

Andrew: [laughs] True.

Eric: …than between two films.


Chicken Soup for the MuggleCast Soul


Andrew: That’s true. All right, and the final e-mail is a Chicken Soup today. Nicole, 16, of New York:

“Hey you guys, I just wanted to thank you for being awesome. I had a really tough day today because my cousin is leaving for Coast Guard boot camp tomorrow. The next time I see him will be in either late November or early December when he graduates. Then he will have five days with us until he is stationed. We won’t find out where he will be stationed until probably middle to late October. He will be serving for four years and I don’t know how often I’ll be able to see him. I don’t even know if he will be home for Christmas! We visited him today to say goodbye and on the car ride home, all of this was running through my head and I began to cry silently. Trying to hide it from my mom and sister, I rolled down my window and listened to an old episode of MuggleCast. You guys helped me take my mind off things and even made me laugh. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for providing me with comfort today, and for the endless entertainment every other day! I hope you guys continue for a long time, even though the books and movies have ended. Love you guys. Love, Nicole.”

Well, thanks Nicole, and we wish the best for your cousin about to be stationed and heading away.

Eric: Yeah.


Announcement: Upcoming Episodes


Andrew: We wanted to talk also today about – over the next few weeks, we do have several fun ideas for episodes planned, because there is a lot happening in Potter world over the next few months. First of all, of course, the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD. We will have a review episode where we break down everything on the DVD/Blu-ray and complain about it most likely, but also try to throw in…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …a few positives as well. [laughs] And also, for the first time ever, we are going to do a Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD – well, for the first time ever, we are going to do a Harry Potter DVD commentary, and we will do it for Deathly Hallows – Part 2. And basically what a commentary is, in case you don’t know – we will record ourselves talking about the film in real time as we watch it, so then you will be able to take that audio file and play it back with the movie, and it will be as if you’re watching it with us. And we’ll comment on different things that we see and point out little things, and it will be a lot of fun. No, we are not going to do this for the other movies. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, no? Really?

Andrew: Do you want to? I mean, that would be a huge undertaking.

Eric: No. The problem is, too, they’re two-and-a-half hour films…

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: …so it’s a lot to download…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …and a lot to edit.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I mean, maybe we could do the first one or – I don’t know.

Eric: Never say never, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But – yeah.

Andrew: But for now, no plans to do any other ones, just Part 2, and I think that’s probably – I mean, it’s so action-packed that a commentary is so perfect for it because you can really talk non-stop about what’s going on on the screen.

Eric: And not miss anything, yeah.

Andrew: And then also, we are planning to do some interviews from the Quidditch World Cup, which is going to be in November in New York City. It’s actually the weekend that the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD comes out. Micah and I went to it last year and it was so much fun. So, this year we’re going to bring a little microphone and we’ll talk to some of the players, the guy who runs it all, Alex Benepe – [attempts to pronounce “Benepe”] if that’s how you pronounce his name.

Micah: [pronounces correctly] Benepe.

Andrew: [pronounces correctly] Benepe. Wonderful, thank you. And we’ll talk to fans, too, just about the experience. It’s really cool and it’s so much fun. And so, we’ll do that, [laughs] tentatively, so long as we’re not going to that thing at Universal, but I don’t know. And then finally…

Micah: But yeah, it’s huge. I mean, you look at the venue transition, I guess you could say, from where we were last year, which was in a park, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: On the west side of Manhattan. And now they’re at Randall’s Island in this brand new stadium, and just going to be a weekend full of Quidditch.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And it is really fun to watch because you say to yourself, “Quidditch? How can you possibly make a sport out of this?” and “How can you possibly do this without flying?” And it’s – these are real athletes, and they hit each other…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: …and they’re not messing around. [laughs] And the other thing I thought was really cool that I learned about it was, because the person who kind of started this whole Quidditch World Cup idea was a comedian, that’s where all the play-by-play announcers come from. They’re kind of improv comedians, and that’s why they were so funny when we were sitting, listening to them do the matches last year.

Eric: Oh, that’s great. That’s great. And I saw this list of all these colleges that are now participating in the IQA, even the ones that are not even official yet. The number of actual colleges – and it just shows the spread of, the reach of Harry Potter, but also that so many people are getting into a sport that everybody seems to really like. And they’re competing, and they’re able to do this Quidditch World Cup. This is the fifth one! I don’t recall hearing about any of the other ones besides last year, so it’s just growing and growing and growing, and the change of venue reflects that. It’s going to be amazing. I wish I could go.

Andrew: Yeah, it will be fun. And then finally, we’ll also, of course, do a year in review episode, and that will probably be the last episode of 2011. But in between those four episodes, we’ll have two or three other episodes. So, there’s still a lot of MuggleCast coming out this year, probably seven episodes before the year is out. So…

Eric: Wow.

Micah: So, it’s actually going back to being on a little bit of a more regular schedule.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: It’s definitely not going to be monthly over the next couple of months.

Andrew: Right, exactly.

Eric: That’ll put us really close to Episode 250.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: We’re looking to do that, I guess, maybe January, February.

Andrew: Yeah, definitely. So, that’s…

Micah: Huge episode, JK Rowling will be on the show.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Oh, are you kidding? After what we’ve been saying about Pottermore?

Andrew: Yeah, no. Yeah, definitely not happening now.

Eric: The expose.


Show Close


Andrew: So, to wrap up the show, just want to remind you about the MuggleCast website. On MuggleCast.com, you can find everything you need about the show. On the right side, you’ll find the Twitter. Our Twitter account is Twitter.com/MuggleCast, our Facebook is Facebook.com/MuggleCast, our fan Tumblr is MuggleCast.Tumblr.com. And also on the MuggleCast website, you can find links to subscribe to us on iTunes, take the manual RSS feed, download old episodes. Maybe you want to download some earlier episodes, like the first ten, and hear our Deathly Hallows theories, those are always fun. You can find us making predictions that are very wrong…

Eric: Or come true.

Andrew: …or may be very correct!

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: And people should know that they’re there. We still get so many e-mails from people asking, “Well, all the episodes aren’t on iTunes. How do I get to them?” Well, you’ve got to go to the MuggleCast site.

Andrew: Exactly.

Micah: Every episode is available to be downloaded.

Eric: As well as transcripts, and I love reading those transcripts, actually. Like, actually reading. I can hear our voices and remember, but at the same time, the transcripts are a great resource as well, and you can Google search them, for crying out loud.

[Show music begins]

Eric: So, it’s a great way to find which episodes we said what on, if you have some fond memories you want to get back to.

Andrew: Well, thanks everyone for listening! From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com and Illinois’ apple district, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: [laughs] And from MSNBC.com, I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: Great. Glad to hear that’s going well, Micah.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: We’ll see everybody next time for Episode 241.

Eric: Bye!

Micah: Bye!

[Show music continues]

Transcript #239

MuggleCast 239 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Micah: Because we can’t figure out who NightSpell314 is, this is MuggleCast Episode 239 for September 19th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 239! It’s a new school year.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: The summer is over, ladies and gentlemen, and for once there is no new Potter film to look forward to at the end of the school year. Awww.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Or in the middle of it. Awww.

Matt: Forever.

Eric: You’re just the bearer of good news, aren’t you?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: What else is going wrong [laughs] this fall?

Andrew: Well, we used to – I think we used to do some kind of summer-ish segments or…

Eric: Maybe.

Andrew: Maybe not. But I know people – surely, people listen more often to MuggleCast in the summers because they have more time, because the majority of our listeners are in school, I would say.

Matt: Mhm. So, we’re in that elementary school.

Eric: Well, there’s never been a better time to re-listen to old episodes of MuggleCast.

Andrew: [laughs] That’s right.

Eric: Well, I mean, while you’re on the bus and stuff now, so that’s cool.

Andrew: Yeah, absolutely. I used to listen to a podcast every Monday morning on the bus on the way in, and it was really nice!

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: Mhm. Anyway, Matt, Eric, Micah, and I are here this week. We got some Pottermore to talk about. We have a lot of e-mails we have been meaning to catch up on, so we’re going to get to those. Also, we got a Favorites segment, and the news, of course. I’m Andrew Sims from Hypable.com.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull from MuggleNet.com.

Micah: I’m Micah Tannenbaum from MSNBC.com.

Matt: And I’m Matthew Britton from The Huffington Post.

[Everyone laughs]


Announcement: MuggleNet and MuggleCast Updates


Andrew: Okay. Well, first of all, there’s business to attend to. A lot of us have been shuffling around, you see. I was going to talk about Hypable, but I think the bigger news here is that Matt and Micah are at much bigger news outlets.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Matt: We’re better than you, see.

Andrew: Yeah.

Matt: So, how’s that?

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: We didn’t even announce that, we just moved.

Andrew: No.

Eric: Huffington, MSNBC, really? Wow.

Matt: Yeah. We didn’t post anything on anything.

Andrew: You didn’t get a goodbye post. At least I got that. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So anyway, there is some business to attend to. If you do – and you doesn’t? – visit MuggleNet, you’ll know that about a week or two – a couple of weeks ago now, I made an announcement that – shockingly. I still can’t believe it – I’m no longer a staff member of MuggleNet, and I’m working on my own entertainment site now, Hypable, as you’ve heard on the show before and probably on MuggleNet. But the good news is – concerning this podcast is that this podcast is still living on. MuggleCast has been around forever, as everybody knows, and Micah, Eric, and I have all been very big parts of it for a very long time. So, it is not changing, but we are – so there’s not really much to say in terms of the podcast, not much is changing, but we do want to let you know that we are going to make a couple of changes to the MuggleCast Twitter account.

Eric: And site. And site, in general.

Andrew: And the MuggleCast site. Right. MuggleCast is kind of going to exist on its own server. It’s kind of a technical thing that you won’t even really notice because you’ll still be going to MuggleCast.com and you’re still going to see the same site. So, a lot is the same, and we’ll update you as changes are made, but that’s what’s going on.

Eric: Woot.

Andrew: So…

Matt: I feel like our parents are divorcing or something.

[Andrew laughs]

Matt: Like your life is not going to be changed by this, just…

[Andrew laughs]

Matt: We still love you.

Andrew: The listeners are the children.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Don’t worry, children, nothing is changing.

Eric: Nah, I think my parents’ divorce is probably one of the best things that they did, so…

Andrew: Oh. [laughs] Well, in that case…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …I guess this is great! So, that’s what’s happening with that. And, like I said, with the website, you won’t notice too many changes but it will be moving. It’s going to be more of a behind-the-scenes change, but with the MuggleCast Twitter, we’re going to start tweeting news from MuggleNet and Hypable, Harry Potter news. And it’s going to be news that we’re going to be discussing here on the show. And speaking of the news, Micah, what is in the news? Now that you anchor from MSNBC, I imagine the news has gotten much better quality wise.

Micah: Absolutely. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, do you do the news or do you just do, like, the Dateline: To Catch a Predator stuff?

Micah: Both.

Eric: Oh. So…

Micah: I moonlight a little bit.

Eric: Are you going to ask me to have a seat?

Micah: No, no, you’re – do I need to ask you to have a seat, I guess is the better question.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, those are words you’re never going to want to be asked.

Eric: Never mind.


News: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Box Office Update


Micah: But anyway, in the last few weeks since we’ve done the show, Deathly Hallows – Part 2 eclipsed the $1.3 billion mark worldwide, and it’s the third movie ever to reach that milestone, and it’s closing in on $1 billion internationally. Obviously, here in the United States, it still doesn’t rank that high. It’s somewhere in the top 15 in terms of domestic gross, but it just keeps moving up the charts.

Andrew: But it’s at number three now, and it’s not going to pass Avatar and Titanic, so it’s just going to stay at number three, and that will be that.

Micah: Unless we all go to the movie theater right now.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: Although I don’t even know how many theaters it’s still in, at this point.

Andrew: And Titanic is going back into theaters, Avatar is going back into theaters – or did it already? I mean, there’s no stopping James Cameron.

Matt: No, Avatar already did a re-release in theaters.

Andrew: Oh, okay. But I don’t know if that’s going to count towards Titanic‘s total, but…

Matt: Titanic did re-releases and they’re also doing another re-release in 3D.

Eric: No kidding.

Andrew: Right, that’s what I mean.

Matt: So…

Eric: Well, I bet…

Matt: I mean, how many re-releases are we talking about?

Eric: Well, my theory is that Lion King is going to come back and just eclipse them all for the number one spot. That came out – is that this week or next week that’s coming out in 3D?

Andrew: This week.

Matt: This Friday.

Eric: That’s going to be awesome, man, Lion King in 3D.

Matt: I hear it’s not that stellar.

Eric: Oh.

Matt: I’ve been hearing some…

Andrew: The 3D is not that good.

Matt: Yeah, the 3D…

Eric: Oh. Why would they…

Matt: …conversion isn’t that good.

Eric: That’s a real shame to hear.

Andrew: But on MuggleCast 400, we’ll be talking about the Deathly Hallows re-release.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So, look forward to that.

Eric: Cool. [laughs] I’m counting the days, Andrew!

[Andrew and Matt laugh]

Matt: That’s the next thing to look for.

Andrew: All right. Before we move on with today’s show, we’d like to remind you that today’s podcast is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, with more than 75,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature and featuring audio versions of many New York Times Bestsellers. For listeners of this podcast, Audible is offering a free audiobook to give you a chance to try out their great service. One audiobook to consider is The Night Circus, a book just released by Erin Morgenstern. Publishers Weekly calls it “a giant, magical story destined for bestsellerdom.” I actually just started listening to it and I can tell you, I agree completely. And actually this book has two connections to Potter: for one, Jim Dale is the narrator of the audiobook. He narrates the US version of the Harry Potter books, and two, David Heyman who has produced the Potter films is reportedly very interested in turning this book into a film. So, to get a free audiobook of your choice such as The Night Circus, which I do really recommend, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, that’s AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.


News: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Deleted Scenes Revealed


Micah: Well, the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 DVD, which is supposed to come out I think sometime in the middle of November – the British Board of Film Classification updated their site with a listing of what deleted scenes we can expect to see when it is released, and did any of these jump out at you? I’ll just go through them real fast. “Shell Cottage,” not very descriptive. “Harry and Luna at Dobby’s grave on the Beach.”

Eric: Slightly…

Micah: “The Hog’s Head.”

Eric: …more descriptive. [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, so is “The Hog’s Head,” so maybe there was just a little bit of extended discussion between Harry and Aberforth. “Marble Staircase with Harry and Ginny,” “Wooden Bridge,” “Hogwarts Battlements,” “Slytherin Dungeons” – and I think that’s actually one that you saw in some of the trailers, right? With Filch…

Matt: Mhm. Yeah.

Micah: …and there was that explosion that took place behind him. That never made it into the movie. And then the final one, “Marble Staircase with Ron and Hermione.”

Andrew: [sighs] These aren’t good.

Eric: Exciting?

Andrew: I’ve heard some talk – isn’t somebody else – aren’t there other scenes that were apparently cut? How about the “Why do you live? Because I have something to live for”? Where is that on the DVD? Or does that count as part of the battlements?

Eric: Maybe. Maybe not.

Andrew: I’m just – this seems…

Eric: Do you feel like – well, do you get the feeling that they’re withholding for the sake of withholding so that ten years later, they have a better, more definitive deleted scenes?

Andrew: Yeah…

Eric: Because we know they do that on other films. But…

Matt: Well, I mean, would you rather have bad deleted scenes or would you have really good deleted scenes that you wish were in the movie?

Eric: That’s true. Well, I mean, we have the reason for them to not include the “Why do you live? Because I have something to live for.”

Matt: Because it was dumb.

Eric: The real problem is that – that it ever made it into the trailer and that the trailer people ran with it, and that scream and everything else that the trailer people did to get us excited for this. But that deleted scene, they just didn’t like it after they filmed, right? They didn’t think it would be entirely appropriate, so they cut it. And yeah, we know it exists and it’s not even in the deleted scenes, but I just think it’s for a good reason, right? I mean, that’s just something that they didn’t think would – maybe they’re embarrassed that they filmed it.

Andrew: I think they’re saving some stuff for the Ultimate Edition, perhaps?

Eric: Hmm.

Andrew: Which may be coming out at the same time, but there hasn’t really been – there’s been some news about the Part 1 Ultimate Edition, but not the Part 2 Ultimate Edition. But they’ve been releasing each Ultimate Edition in groups of two, so they did “1” and “2”, “3” and “4”, “5” and “6”. So, presumably they would do “7” and “8” at the same time, too, and maybe they’ll save it – I know a couple of people were saying that Arthur and Will, two actors in the Deathly Hallows epilogue – they said they were going to put the first epilogue in the deleted scenes, is that right, Micah?

Micah: Yeah, they talked about it when we spoke with them – was it last episode? Or two episodes ago? Because they had done the initial filming of the epilogue and then they scrapped it.

Andrew: Because it was horrendous.

Micah: Yeah, it was… [laughs]

Andrew: Apparently.

Micah: It didn’t end up working out too well, so they shot it at Leavesden. So, one of the characters that they talked about, Teddy Lupin, who I think a lot of people were looking forward to seeing in the epilogue, was in the initial one that they shot but then wasn’t in the one that they ended up using in the movie. So, maybe that’s Ultimate Edition material, who knows.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: Yeah, I think many times with these deleted scenes, too – some of them – I think it depends on the director of the studio, too, because you’ll see on certain deleted scenes of DVDs and now Blu-rays, there may be like a five-second clip – you know, some DVDs for some movies will have these really short extended scenes, I guess they even call them, that really are kind of pointless but some people feel like maybe the viewers would want to see that. And then others, maybe with these Harry Potter‘s, they’re having sort of more substantial scenes. So, even if we did get a view of Teddy Lupin in the original epilogue, it may just be a view, a shot, and because we don’t have the epilogue, the scenes surrounding that version of the epilogue, they’re never going to release it just because it wouldn’t fit. It would be, like, five seconds of, “Oh, that’s supposed to be Teddy,” but unless it’s in the original scene they’re not going to show it.

Andrew: It could also just be a special feature, like a featurette, like “The Original Epilogue,” and then we’ll see clips from the original epilogue.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: And then maybe the crew will talk about why it didn’t work, and what issues they were running into, because I remember around press time for it they did have a lot to say about it, just about how – actually, [laughs] everybody could not stop talking about how awful it was. I remember Dan Radcliffe saying that it was just so noisy because they were actually filming at King’s Cross, some of the costumes were off, Rupert was saying he looked half bald, and some of you probably saw the paparazzi photos. So, overall it was just kind of like a mess of a shoot, and I could see them doing a whole featurette out of that.


News: First Look at Deathly Hallows – Part 1 Ultimate Edition


Micah: Well, speaking of featurettes on Ultimate Editions – nice segue there, Andrew.

Andrew: Oh.

[Matt laughs]

Micah: There was a little bit of a clip released for the Deathly Hallows – Part 1 Ultimate Edition. It’s part of “Creating the World of Harry Potter” and it was released through Harry Potter: The Quest, that online interactive game that fans can participate in. And it just gave a look at the first press conference that the trio did, and it was with Chris Columbus and David Heyman as well. And it was interesting how Chris Columbus asked the media to really stay away from these kids and that this was really [laughs] the only time that they were going to be available to speak with the press.

Andrew: [in a sentimental voice] They’ve changed so much!

[Eric and Matt laugh]

Andrew: They – it was a nice clip and that’s why I like the Ultimate Edition documentaries, we’ve talked about them before. Basically, it’s one giant eight-hour documentary, and you get one hour of the documentary on each Ultimate Edition set so you have to buy them to get the whole documentary, and – yeah, so the “Growing Up Potter” will be on number seven, like you said, and it’s nice. It’s touching. And now, Part 8 is supposed to be about the fandom or something, so I don’t know if they’re going to be talking about the fan sites, but they didn’t interview anyone so [laughs] I’m kind of guessing not.

[Eric and Matt laugh]

Andrew: They didn’t reach out to MuggleNet, so…

Micah: It’ll all be on…

Matt: Pottermore.

Micah: …the ninth Ultimate Edition, which will never make it out of the cutting room floor.

Andrew: Well, no, because then they’re going to be moving into the super-mega-foxy-awesome edition.

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Yeah, which they’re actually saving the real deleted scenes for.

Eric: I really would like…

Andrew: And the bloopers.

Eric: Can I put that on layaway now?

Andrew: [laughs] Yes…

Eric: Reserve it?

Andrew: …on Amazon.

Eric: [laughs] Super-freaky-awesome – what was it?

Andrew: Mega-foxy.

Eric: Mega.

Andrew: I think that’s a StarKid reference. I may be wrong.

Eric: Ooh, okay.

Andrew: Yeah…

Micah: All right.

Andrew: …so I threw that in there. [laughs]


News: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Nominated for 14 Scream Awards


Micah: Well, the final bit of…

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah:Deathly Hallows – Part 2 news – and these awards aren’t that big, but Potter usually gets nominated at them every year – the Scream Awards.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Ooh.

Micah: Deathly Hallows – Part 2 picked up fourteen nominations, so…

Eric: Interestingly, they were all… [imitates Voldemort’s scream in the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 trailer]

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: The Scream Awards, get it? Scream. Scream Awards.

Andrew: I get it.

Eric: Because he screamed like fourteen times in that trailer.

Andrew: He did.

Matt: He did.

Micah: So I would think they’ll probably win at least one [laughs] at this award show. What’s interesting is in a lot of categories, I noticed they’re up against Game of Thrones, which is a new popular series from HBO. So, it’ll be interesting to see…

Andrew: Yeah, very popular.

Micah: …how they can do against them.

Matt: I love Game of Thrones.

[Prolonged silence]

Matt: Sorry.

Micah: No, you’re allowed to speak. You’re allowed to say that. [laughs]

Matt: Oh okay, yeah.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: No, you can’t talk. What?

Eric: No, no, Game of Thrones is awesome. I think we all watch Game of Thrones, actually.

Andrew: What else is going on in the news?


News: Harry Potter Page to Screen Release Date Announced


Micah: All right, final bit of news, the follow-up to Harry Potter Film Wizardry which is called Harry Potter Page to Screen is going to be released on October 25th. It’s essentially a massive encyclopedia of the Harry Potter films and much different from what people got in Film Wizardry. It’s a little expensive, $75 is probably steep for some people, but you know, Christmas is right around the corner.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And I think we’re at least giving away one copy on MuggleCast, so stay tuned in terms of I guess how we’re going to figure out what the rules are for giving it away. But we’ll give away one copy on the show.

Andrew: The first one was really good, Film Wizardry, and this is – I mean, this one better be all new material. It better not be the same stuff.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I mean, that’s kind of the impression you get, considering the covers kind of look similar and they call it a follow-up, which kind of makes me feel like it’s an expanded edition or something. But…

Matt: For 75 bucks, it better be.

Andrew: Well, the first one was really big, too, and I think this one will be as well. The first one was really good, so hopefully Page to Screen will be just as interesting.

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: And new material.

Eric: Yeah, right? Well, I mean, I think the good thing about bookstores is you can go in and open up the book before you buy it, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: So that helps.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: And I mean, even Amazon will have a digital look inside, but still in terms of – because these are heavy books, the weight, and the way it’s packaged. You’ll see that by just walking into your local bookshop.

Matt: Mhm. Just not Borders.

Eric: Aww.

[Micah laughs]


News: JK Rowling Among the Many Celebrities in Phone-Hacking Scandal


Andrew: One other story I wanted to bring up, this is kind of a more serious story, JK Rowling was named one of the celebrities in the British phone-hacking probe, which has been going on since July. I know everybody in England knows all about it. In case people in the US don’t, basically what happened was Rupert Murdoch’s company, News Corp., who owned News of the Word – it was uncovered that they were tapping phone lines and spying on private phone conversations of the families of dead military members, people in political positions, and also celebrities. And JK Rowling may be one of those people who News of the World were tapping in on, and so she was listed as a “core participant,” which means that she may have suffered – she may have been listened in on. Now, you can imagine why News of the World would be tapping in on JK Rowling. I mean, she’s a very high-profile celebrity.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Maybe at one point they were trying to get some book scoops, stuff like that. So JK Rowling has the choice, she can come forward and say, “Yes, me,”ù or, “A lawyer will represent me and speak on my behalf.”ù But as far as we know right now, it’s just a possibility and chances are, we’re not going to find out details of the exact phone conversations they were tapping in on. But it’s a big scandal over there.

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: I was actually over in London when it first broke, and oh my God, it was everywhere. The news was just – everybody was in shock. Yeah, so…

Eric: Yeah, that’s interesting.


Main Discussion: Pottermore


Andrew: …we’ll let you know what happens from there. Well, speaking of JK Rowling, she’s very busy working on Pottermore and that’s actually something else we’re going to discuss today as kind of a news item but also as a general discussion. I think everybody here is in Pottermore now, right?

Eric: [sighs] Yes.

Matt: Yes.

Eric: As of our last episode, that was not the case. I know Micah was very vocally waiting for his letter. And a couple of days later, he got it! So that’s awesome.

Andrew: So…

Matt: Might as well talk.

Andrew: So what houses are you guys in? I don’t think any of you were in it last time, right?

Micah: No.

Eric: Matt, are you in?

Matt: I was in, yeah.

Andrew: But were you on the last episode?

Matt: How long ago was I on the last episode?

Andrew: It was like three weeks ago.

Matt: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, I think Matt was here.

Andrew: Oh, okay. All right, so Micah, what house are you?

Micah: Ravenclaw.

Andrew: Ooh.

Matt: Ooh.

Micah: I correctly predicted.

Eric: Oh, look at that.

Andrew: And Eric?

Eric: I am actually in Hufflepuff.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [laughs] All right, all right, now is the time. Get your laughter out, come on, come on.

Andrew: Mikey is in Hufflepuff, too, which was shocking.

Eric: That’s what he said, yeah.

Andrew: Mikey B. And I think Ben is in Slytherin – or Ravenclaw? I can’t remember. But there’s been a lot of surprises.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. Matt, what are you in?

Matt: I’m in Slytherin.

Eric: No kidding? So…

Andrew: Yeah, that’s right.

Eric: And Andrew, you’re Gryffindor, right?

Andrew: I’m in Gryffindor.

Eric: So we have all four houses right now on this show.

Andrew: No wonder this show has always worked so perfectly.

[Matt and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Such a beautiful balance. See, we don’t need women, we just need people in different houses.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Micah: Oh, that won’t…

Matt: Yeah, to hell with Laura.

Micah: …get any e-mails sent.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: Well, I was going to say, though, I did have a choice between Ravenclaw and Slytherin.

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: And I…

Andrew: So why did you pick Ravenclaw?

Micah: Because it was the first one that came up. [laughs] I really had no…

Andrew: What do you mean?

Micah: Well, when you have the little blocks to select between…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …it was Ravenclaw, which was up first, and then Slytherin below it.

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: I don’t know. I mean, I thought if I was sorted in real life that I would always be in Ravenclaw, so I went with Ravenclaw.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: No rhyme or reason. It would have been cool to be in Slytherin, though.

Eric: So you went because it was the first thing to click, right?

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: That’s what you said? Because it came up first?

Micah: I was being sarcastic.

Eric: Because some of my Sorting questions – by the end of it, though, people were getting – some of their questions were like “Black or white?” “Night or day?” “Heads or tails?”

Andrew: Right.

Matt: “Left or right?”

Eric: [laughs] “Left or right?” Really, like…

Andrew: “Forest or river?”

Eric: That doesn’t feel much…

Matt: Yeah.

Eric: …like a choice to me.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: Like, what if I had chosen – if I had picked heads instead of tails, would that really have said enough about me to be in a different house?

Matt: Yeah…

Andrew: The thing about Jo, though, is that if you were to ask her why this matters, she would give you an explanation for why. [laughs] So…

Eric: Yeah. I just thought that that was funny because all the other questions I think during Sorting were really introspective. Like, you have seven answers, “What creature do you most want to study?” Or this, that, and the other thing. And then to get the last two, the most crucial two when I’m like, “Okay, I know that’s coming. I know I’m about to be sorted.” And I had “Moon or stars?” was one of the questions, and I was like, “Okay, the stars are pretty cool. A little bit cooler than the moon.” And then the next one was, “Black or white?”

Micah: Does everybody get the same questions, though, or did people get different questions?

Eric: I heard for the wand, everybody gets the same questions, but for Sorting it’s all random.

Matt: Yeah.

Eric: So – I mean, do you remember your Sorting questions? If they were…

Andrew: I remember “Left or right?” “Forest and river,” although that may have been for the wand, so I can’t…

Eric: Forest – oh, was that with the beach? You could go into the beach or by the castle.

Andrew: Oh yeah, yeah.

Eric: Yeah, it was the wand.

Andrew: So either along the beach, along the river, or through the forest.

Eric: Interesting.

Andrew: Something like that.

Eric: Yeah. But no, I got Hufflepuff, and I’m actually happy with it, I think, because it’s not so bad.

Matt: You always saw yourself, though, in Hufflepuff.

Eric: Well, I saw myself – I said – I didn’t really ever really, really, really Sort myself. I have the Gryffindor robes that I wear around everywhere, and so I was like, “Yeah, I’m a Gryffindor.” But I was kind of waiting on something like this to tell me where I belonged, and so that’s kind of cool.

Matt: Okay, so are we talking about – are we going onto Sorting now? Are we talking about how we like the Sorting thing? Because…

Eric: Well, why not?

Andrew: What do you want to say?

Matt: I’m actually not a fan of the Sorting at all.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Why? Is it for the reason I’m about to bring up?

Matt: No – bring up your reason.

Andrew: Okay. Well, here’s my thing, and I hate to burst everybody’s bubble, but I realize this: When looking in the Great Hall – when you’re in the Great Hall…

Matt: Oh, yes.

Andrew: …you can see how many people are in each house on Pottermore, and what worries me is that each house has a very similar number of people. As of right now there’s 94,000 in Gryffindor, 94,000 in Ravenclaw, 94,000 in Hufflepuff, and 93,000 in Slytherin.

Eric: Uproar. I call it.

Andrew: Now – yeah, this is the issue. This cannot be truly sorting each person because if it were, it wouldn’t be so perfectly even. The chances of everybody getting sorted so evenly is very – it’s not possible! Surely…

Matt: It’s delusional.

Andrew: …this world cannot be made up of so many Hufflepuffs and Ravenclaws, I’m sorry but it just…

[Eric and Matt laugh]

Andrew: It can’t be true.

Eric: You don’t believe that Hufflepuffs exist, do you?

Andrew: No, they’re fictional.

[Eric laughs]

Matt: I honestly think that a lot of the Harry Potter fans are Ravenclaw.

Andrew: I was joking about that. But nonetheless, it can’t be so even! [laughs] So, I’m afraid to say that – this is definitely the most accurate Sorting you will probably ever get, given that JK Rowling wrote these questions herself. But it is not a true Sorting because the reason they need to make the houses even in Pottermore is so that each house has a chance of winning the House Cup, of getting the most points.

Matt: Now, this really upsets me because no one really cares to win the House Cup more than they want to be sorted into the right house.

Eric: Accurately. You’re right.

Matt: Who the hell – oh sorry, who the heck, wants to win the House Cup if it means that you’re sorted into the wrong house? Ninety percent of the fans who went on Pottermore wanted to be Sorted. That’s what everybody wants to do, is get Sorted into the house that they should be in. When they read the books, that’s what they think of. They wish, “Well, I’m actually in Hufflepuff,” or, “I see myself as a Ravenclaw,” or something. They don’t care – they don’t think that far ahead, and we care more about what the proper Sorting is.

Eric: Yeah.

Matt: I just feel like they should have put more emphasis and I don’t know, just more work into the Sorting, than just like, “Okay, the whole reason why we’re sorting people is so we have an equal number of amounts, people can just compete for this House Cup.”

Eric: Yeah, they shouldn’t have pretended – if it’s not actually accurate – and if it is, woot – as Andrew points out, it’s highly suspect that people would be – or impossible that people would be evenly matched, so evenly sorted. They shouldn’t have pretended otherwise.

Andrew: Mhm. Now the points system, I’m not even sure – let’s talk about that. I’m not sure what the purpose of house points – I mean, it’s loyal to the book, each house gets house points for brewing potions and I think when you find things in Moments you get points, too. But I’m just wondering, is it really that important? I mean, I propose that Pottermore just get rid of points and…

Eric: [laughs] Well hang on, because – if they got rid of points, then what would there be to do?

Andrew: Well, you can still do those things, you just…

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: I mean, you can get your own personal points, but let’s just not compete for the House Cup.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Micah: Mhm.

Eric: Yeah, that’s possible, because didn’t they also – they said it wasn’t going to be an alternative reality game. But yet at the same time, you’re collecting things for your pouch or for your trunk, and you get the feeling that you’re going to have to use them later.

Andrew: Mhm.

[Matt laughs]

Eric: All these points, all this money that you have that you spend, and you have to buy some of the books on your school list before you can go to school. Things like that are just like an alternative reality game. So, I’m finding, again, that maybe Pottermore actually is something that we’ve been told that it wouldn’t be, or – it’s growing and changing, but it’s getting close to being what we initially, even on this show, speculated that it would be, which is what they said it wouldn’t be. It’s a lot less like an encyclopedia than we thought, I think it’s fair to say, or at least that’s my opinion.

Matt: Mhm.

Micah: Yeah…

Matt: No, no, that’s a pretty good assessment.

Andrew: Micah?

Micah: Yeah, I was just going to say, when you’re talking about having to get the books in Diagon Alley before you can go off to school, I thought that would be a little bit more interactive than just clicking on a store and selecting all the books that you need, maybe physically actually going into the store and having to search around for them. I feel like…

Eric: You mean like transporting through your computer screen and getting to walk around?

Micah: No, no, no, no. I mean, as you can go into Gringotts or Ollivander’s, but actually physically going into these stores and looking around the shelves for the books that you need. I just – I feel like as a whole, Pottermore lacks a lot of interactivity and there’s not enough really.

Eric: Well…

Micah: You’re clicking on a…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …Galleon here or you’re clicking on a Chocolate Frog card there, and it’s just like there’s not enough that’s going on. And some chapters there’s just nothing, it’s just…

Andrew: There’s nothing.

Micah: …text…

Eric: Yeah.

Matt: No, there’s not.

Micah: …which you already know…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …because you have the books.

Matt: Well, I feel like they should also have more side projects that you can be doing to make you want to come back. Like – honestly – I mean, I think Pottermore should have something like how they do with FarmVille on Facebook or something. They have Herbology or something in Hogwarts, where you just go and start planting your – I don’t know, your crops…

Andrew: Your plants, and go check on them later.

Matt: Your crops and stuff, yeah. And then spread the roots – plant your Mandrakes. Do something.

Andrew: Or let’s get Neopets in Pottermore.

[Eric laughs]

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: Let’s take care of the owl that you purchased back in Diagon Alley.

Eric: That’s true.

Andrew: Let’s – every morning I want an e-mail, “Hello Andrew. Hello CatSeeker211, it’s time to feed your owl.”

[Eric laughs]

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: Don’t…

Andrew: Then three hours later, “Hello CatSeeker211, it’s time to scoop up the owl droppings.”

Matt: Right.

Andrew: And then I have to go back into Pottermore and scoop up my owl droppings.

Matt: “Hello Andrew, your owl just died.”

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Because you didn’t feed it?

Matt: You didn’t feed it.

Eric: It was diphtheria, right, just like on Oregon Trail?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: [laughs] Really, the question I have, too – it seems like – so we want more interactivity, but yet the interactivity – the opportunity is already there, like Micah was saying. I mean, when you’re in that bookshop in Diagon Alley and you have to buy these books, why can’t we examine those books closer? Once we’ve purchased them – we’ve actually had to click on it and hit “Purchase”, and we had to go to Gringotts first to make sure we had enough money and all that stuff. But once you actually buy the book, all it does is let you move forward in the story. It’s not like you can actually look at that book, read some of it.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: Or even the items in your trunk. To actually be able to – you’re carrying around all these items you’ve found but you can’t actually click on them, find out anything more about them.

Matt: Yeah.

Eric: And I think that’s tremendously – not off-putting, but it’s like shutting us out.

Micah: It’s limiting.

Eric: It’s very limiting.

Matt: Well – yeah, exactly. A lot of the times when you’re on these screens, too – for each scene, all you have – all there really is one thing for you to click on. But there’s all this stuff going on onscreen, but your focus is only allowed to be on that one thing that’s allowing you to go forward. Like the one with the snake at the zoo, You clicked on the snake and then the scene was over.

Eric: Oh, speaking of that snake – okay, so it does a cute little dance. I like the snake…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …and how it dances. But I had such an issue just viewing the screen on Pottermore in many of these scenes. I actually ended up having to hook up my computer to my TV, which I’ve never done before, and I made the Pottermore a separate window just because I think, size-wise – or maybe that it is longer than it is wide, and so you always have to scroll down to kind of see everything. But I had a lot of trouble just following Pottermore on my computer screen just because of how it’s laid out, and I think reading-wise, it was tough to read. Did you guys have any trouble with that?

Micah: I told…

Andrew: Ummm.

Micah: Andrew, I had loading problems, not where it would say, “Pottermore is currently unavailable,” but just my browser would freeze up a lot. I don’t know if that was…

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: …just from the volume of people that were using it at the time or what it was, but it just – every time I tried to click to move forward – you know how you can view three different versions of each chapter?

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: It would just – it would lock up and…

Andrew: Hmmm.

Micah: …it just made it really – I don’t know, not fun.

[Matt laughs]

Andrew: Well, yeah, I’ve never run into that problem. I’m not sure what…

Eric: Now, I’ve heard from people who’ve had the same issue, but I haven’t experienced it myself. I feel like it’s a very common thing. People talk about their screens freezing up during Potions a lot, and – or during Sorting, even, and possibly having to retake questions, or have it be official or something. But on Twitter, if you just search for #Pottermore, the only thing you’re finding are people who say, “I’m frozen up,” or “I’m still waiting for my -” it can’t be a good experience for everybody. But at the same time, yeah, I’ve seen a lot of the “freezing” tweets. A lot of people are getting that. And still, when I click on Pottermore sometimes, I have to wait fifteen seconds or thirty seconds, and then the page will reload, and it will say, high volume this, high volume that. And look, I’ve already mentioned on this show that I don’t think that that should be an issue at all, is handling the high volume of people, because they knew from day one that there was going to be…

Micah: No, no way. I mean…

Eric: …a high volume of people on this site. There’s…

Micah: And it’s not like they’re lacking in funds to…

Andrew: Yeah, there’s money for this, right?

Eric: Well, I mean, do you want to point that out? Yeah, I mean, you do, right? Because it’s Harry Potter!

Micah: I just did.

Eric: Yeah.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: I mean…

Andrew: Well…

Micah: But what about – Andrew, I know you talked about this on the last show, but now that all of us are in Pottermore, the return value. I mean, I don’t think it’s very great…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …for people to want to come back, unless they start adding new features.

Matt: But – I mean, that’s as it is, though, right now. They haven’t updated really since they started giving…

Andrew: No, because this is it. This is Pottermore.

Eric: Well, that’s – see, I’d like to believe…

Matt: No, it’s not.

Andrew: Yes!

Eric: …that this is not it, though.

Matt: No, it’s not.

Eric: I really want to believe that come October 31st or whatever, that it’s going to be completely different. I want to believe…

Andrew: No. [laughs]

Eric: …that the Beta is completely different from Book 1, because…

Andrew: Keep believing. [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Okay, I will keep believing. But I’m saying I really want – I mean, why are you so – why do you believe that it’s not at all going to be different?

Andrew: Well, what could they possibly add? I mean, the only thing I could see, and I think this would be very smart, is if they added some new content from JK Rowling so they can have another media splash, make some news. Otherwise the only news when this opens to the public is going to be, “Hey, it’s open to the public now,” [laughs] and I don’t think – I think a lot of the Pottermore buzz is kind of over already because the people who really wanted to get in are getting in now and the reviews have not been spectacular, and the next time there’s going to be a big update to this is when they add Chamber of Secrets. I really don’t think they are going to be adding more features or anything because they have a hard enough time just getting people into the site now.

Eric: Well, that’s what it seems like, is that they’re just so overwhelmed that there really won’t be any updates because people are still having issues even staying on the site for any period of time, which is a real shame because there is so much – there are so many little blurbs of information that are just summary that they could totally expand on, and it just kills me to think that they would spend so much time designing these – this art for each Moment in the first book, but to not have it be even more interactive. And I’ve got to ask, is this us being crazy Harry Potter fans, “We want more, we want more”? Or do we have a legitimate argument here that we’re being shown these things but it almost draws the attention to just how empty these scenes are?

Micah: Mhm.

Andrew: Well, yeah…

Matt: Well…

Andrew: I mean, I suppose if they really wanted to, they could add another item or two that you could pick up in these more empty Moments. I know the emptiest Moments are the ones where you just pick up one Galleon and that’s it, and that’s really bad, I think. But I think going off of Eric’s idea, he was saying more information about some of these items – I’m looking at my trunk now and I have a Golden Snitch. It’d be nice to click on the Golden Snitch and get a little history about it.

Eric: Right.

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: Or a Prefect badge.

Matt: I think the reason why we’re a little underwhelmed by it all is because we know the potential that it has, and we know what it could be because it’s…

Andrew: Well, here’s what everybody really wants: they want the encyclopedia. [laughs]

Matt: Well, that’s good then. That’s good, then there’s a possibility that there actually might be an encyclopedia.

Eric: Well, let’s talk about…

Andrew: But it won’t be.

Eric: …the information. So…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …I thought the information that we do get from Jo is great.

Andrew: Yeah, it is great.

Eric: It’s really exciting and really interesting, and just as relevant as ever, and really well thought out. I mean, I laughed, I cried.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s classic Jo stuff.

Matt: You cried, Eric?

Andrew: It’s stuff you would expect to find in the encyclopedia and it’s written in a way that – it’s classic Jo, like I said. It’s classic Harry Potter. You would find it in the books or you would find it in an encyclopedia if that were to exist.

Eric: So, why is this information few and far between? I mean, we were told that she wrote 18,000 words, 180,000 words for…

Andrew: 18,000 words…

Eric: 18,000 words?

Andrew: …for Sorcerer’s Stone.

Eric: For Sorcerer’s Stone.

Andrew: So, it’s all here. I mean, you just sort of got to – it would be nice if there was a way you can kind of – I want a button up top that says…

Matt: Like a site map?

Andrew: …”New Content”.

Eric: Well, I feel like…

Andrew: No.

Eric: …if you “Favorite” it…

Andrew: Yeah, you can do that.

Eric: If you “Favorite” the new content, then you can browse…

Andrew: It’s a bit of a hassle, though.

Eric: Yeah, it is.

Andrew: So, I see in the Favorites area, you can – apparently, it didn’t remember my “Favorites”. I could have sworn I did “Favorite” some chapters. You can set “Favorites” there in…

Eric: But it’s like Facebook “Favorites” and Facebook “Likes”, too. Why would you rely so heavily on something else when you’re trying to do your own thing?

Matt: The art is really nice.

Andrew: The art is really nice. And they did it in such a way – I think they’ve said this in interviews, is that you can’t see the faces of people because Pottermore is about the books, and in the books you have your own imagination. So…

Eric: Yeah, that was really clever.

Andrew: …with the art, they did not want to ruin people’s imagination of what they had developed in their head while they were reading, so that’s why they took out the faces.

Micah: Oh, they should never…

Andrew: And that’s good.

Micah: …have made the movies.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Well, Mr. Warner Bros. disagrees with you.

Micah: Yep. But…

Eric: Overall…

MuggleCast 239 Transcript (continued)


Main Discussion: Pottermore (continued)


Andrew: Oh, actually, I did – jumping back to something real quick, I thought of a new feature they are going to add in October.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: It’s the e-book store.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh, I see.

Andrew: [laughs] Sorry. But yeah, that’s the new feature coming in October.

Eric: But yeah, I’m really optimistic that a lot is coming to Pottermore in October, because why wouldn’t it? I mean, it just doesn’t make sense to even allow a million people to get the exact same experience early that you would in October, because these books are coming out so far in between of themselves, you are just going to exhaust people. You are going to get people, “Oh, seen it, done it, been there, done that.” Come October, there’s going to be – granted, there are more than a million Harry Potter fans out there but I just feel like, as Andrew said, all the buzz is sort of over and the reviews are not that great. So, I just don’t think – there’s nowhere to go but down, almost, if you don’t provide any new content to what you already have. I mean, I thought Beta – and definition – the reason to do Beta testing is to get some serious feedback to make changes, and by making changes, I just assumed, for instance, that more than a quarter of the people would be in by this point. Or more than – what is it, is it half? It’s not even half.

Andrew: We are at, like, 380,000.

Eric: 380,000 out of a million, and we have a month to go. Get that feedback in time to make changes for your opening. When you open in October, have it be new and improved. I was under the impression that they had an army of coders and leagues of people just waiting to fix whatever would be broken, and it just doesn’t seem like that at all. It almost seems very vacant, very empty.

Andrew: The Pottermore Insider, that’s the official blog they update from time to time, they have issued some updates. For one, new invites are going out daily, so if you still haven’t gotten in, they are coming out daily now so you should be getting in.

Eric: About that, are they…

Andrew: I won’t say soon, but…

Eric: I feel like they really are going by day based on the Magic Quill, when you got in. That seems evident…

Andrew: I don’t know. It’s hard to say.

Eric: …now more than ever. It really does, though. But I’m just so – I wanted to pin that on that.

Andrew: And they did answer some questions because, like Eric said, they do use the Beta to make changes. And they did say they are going to make changes to the potions because the potions take a long time to brew, I think up to an hour, which just seems odd.

Micah: Yeah, you just forget about it. I mean, people – most people aren’t going to sit at their computer for an hour, and if they go away, they are going to forget about it.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Just have more content to keep us on the page for an hour.

Andrew: Mhm. And I think they said they are going to be using the Beta to make changes to, maybe, how many Galleons you start out with, how much things cost. They are seeing how users are interacting with the site, and making changes based on things that are already in there. So, it would be some amazing, cool surprise if, come October, it opens to the public, and oh look, there’s Chamber of Secrets ready. But that’s not happening. I think they have said Chamber of Secrets will be next year.

Micah: The…

Andrew: And I – well, go ahead.

Micah: No, the other thing that I was going to ask was, are they going to be profiling one character per book? I mean, I think that’s going to get a little bit more difficult as time goes on, because there’s so many characters that the readers are going to want insight into. I think the one that they focused on the most in this first book was McGonagall. You kind of got pieces of her story throughout Sorcerer’s Stone when you were going through Pottermore, but there’s obviously a lot more characters to get backstory on as you go through the other books.

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, I think it depends on whether Jo has material for that or if she wants to write up the material for it.

Eric: Well, she must – I mean, I’m only on – to be honest, I got sorted and I went to bed. It was, like, 3 AM.

Andrew: [laughs] Right, right, that’s what everyone did.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Everyone just got to the point where they get sorted and then sign off. [laughs]

Matt: And then we’re done.

Micah: You cried yourself to sleep from getting into Hufflepuff.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Even by that point, though, there are something like 25 different characters that are listed under – like, when I’m in viewing the book, whatever you’re going to call that. And it’s just like, if they had an off-mention in the chapter they start – you collect them, almost without…

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: …wanting to, so that you can click on all these characters. It’s a pain for me, because I don’t know what I have to click on to advance now, but there are all these huge characters and they’re just little stubs of info, but I feel like she could totally expand on them…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: …at any point.

Micah: They’re not very descriptive, most of them. They’re just more information – not even more information, they’re the same information I guess you would get if you read the book.

Matt: Which we assume you have.

Andrew: I will say – everybody has obviously been really excited to get into Pottermore, and it definitely is exciting when you’re going through it. I mean, some people who are listening to us talk now who aren’t in Pottermore may be like, “Oh.” Either, “Oh, they’re not Harry Potter fans!” or they’re thinking, “Oh, I shouldn’t be that excited.” But the truth is it is exciting to get in there and to read all the new content, and to get sorted, and to get your wand, and all that. And what I think we should talk about now is just return value, and that’s the thing I think we all have the issue with, because what happens is, as you know by now, you do go through chapter by chapter, each Moment, and you see the new content, you get sorted, you get the wand, you get your pet. And then once you get to the end of Sorcerer’s Stone, then it’s kind of like, “Well, now what? What do I do now?” And there really is no reason to return. And do you guys agree with me? Is there no return value here?

Matt: I haven’t returned since I got sorted.

Eric: And…

Andrew: Well, you’re just not much of a fan.

Matt: I guess not, you’re right.

Eric: Well, I guess that makes me neither, though, really, but – even though I only got…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I only got sorted a couple of days ago, but I will going back. But I was really trying to wonder about the return value, and I think that things like Potions or Duels are what they’re hoping will keep people over. I mean, building a community on Pottermore is kind of, I think, what they were looking to do, so that in between these bouts of new content, you can interact with people and duel them.

Micah: But…

Eric: I feel like that was the goal.

Micah: The major problem I think that they’re still facing is the fact that people don’t know who each other are, and it’s…

Andrew: Yes.

Micah: …such a task to have to go and find out…

Matt: Oh, yes.

Micah: …who your friends are. You don’t even know. I mean, I think early on when people were getting their names, they pushed it out on Twitter and Facebook and all those other places, but now there’s just no place to go…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …where you can find your friends.

Eric: You know what kind of friend you were. Either you wrote your friends’ names down or you didn’t, and I know what kind of friend I am.

Andrew: Yeah, I didn’t.

Micah: I didn’t.

Eric: I did not.

Andrew: Why? I shouldn’t have to.

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: That’s ridiculous! [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] “In this day and age…”

Andrew: And you know what?

[Matt laughs]

Andrew: Here’s the other thing that bothers me: they’re really big on, “Pottermore has to be safe for kids, it has to be a family experience,” and the truth is, look, Pottermore – Harry Potter fans are not kids. We don’t ñ why is this catering to the nine year olds when it’s the people 16, 18, and older who shaped Harry Potter? JK Rowling is not here to thank the nine year olds, she’s here to thank the people who bought the books, that were there at midnight, lining up, reading it overnight. I mean, this is ridiculous!

Eric: I don’t think that’s…

Andrew: AvisKey101, who is that?!

[Matt and Micah laugh]

Andrew: How do I know?! Should I accept this person? Should I go on Twitter and be like, “Who is AvisKey?”

Eric: Well, look at their owl.

Andrew: “Someone tell me!”

Eric: Look at their ñ don’t you know…

Andrew: Ugh!

Eric: Don’t you know how to tell people by their wands, anyway? But if they… [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, I guess I should.

Eric: They have this wand, if they’re a friend or not, an ally or an enemy.

Andrew: I mean, maybe if I slept with them, I should know their wand, but that’s the only way I could possibly…

Eric: That’s funny. No, I think ñ look, that’s not an unfair point. I think ñ okay, so one of the reasons that there’s not more content, more return value on Pottermore ñ do you think that ñ because Book 1 is ñ honestly, Book 1 is where I expected the most information from JK Rowling because she sat for ten years writing these books before they got published, so I just assumed that the most content about who she was, what she was doing before the books came out, would appear during this book. But it seems like either they’re going to appear later because maybe she would say, “Oh, this character originally – something else happened at this point,” or maybe she still doesn’t feel that that information is relevant to really talk about on Pottermore, in which case, is Pottermore not the right medium for some of the information we’re looking for?

Andrew: Yeah, I think for there to be return value, there has to be something to come back for daily, and what has that always been on the Harry Potter fan sites? The news! I don’t know what else ñ or return value could be logging onto Pottermore and being able to directly interact with your real friends. And yes, I guess Dueling would do that, but I ñ honestly, I haven’t even done Dueling yet because during this Beta period, it’s kind of been shut down and they’ve admitted that…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …it doesn’t work for anyone right now, but it will be back eventually. It just seems to me like there has to be something where you come back on a daily basis and it’s fresh. And I was joking about taking care of your owl, but I’m starting to think they need that…

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: …because I’ve ñ on my iPad, I occasionally play this game called We Rule and you have to farm. And for no reason other than ñ for some reason, I get pleasure out of it. I have to log in ñ I don’t do this anymore, by the way, but a year ago ñ I had to log in daily and I had to harvest my crops, and then plant new crops, and then come back six hours later and do it all over again. [laughs] And it’s pointless, it doesn’t ñ it’s not making money or it’s not rewarding me in anyway, but I just like to do it. [laughs] So, maybe they should let you take care of your owl.

Eric: [laughs] It’s funny, because…

Andrew: And sadly, I would probably take care of it.

Eric: [laughs] Talking about mental illness and how Pottermore deals with it or doesn’t deal with it, I’ll never forget Chapter 2, we’re in the Dursleys’ kitchen for – I think it was “The Worst Birthday,” and because you’re pointing at the screen, zooming and trying to figure out what to collect, I was roaming my cursor around and I came on the kitchen table, and the cursor started – it turned blue, and it says, “Ooh, you’ve noticed the salt and pepper!” And then the…

Matt: Yeah!

Eric: …button says “Collect.” [laughs]

Matt: Why…

Eric: Oh…

Andrew: Yay!

Matt: Why would you collect salt and pepper for your trunk?

Eric: …I’m a hoarder now apparently, Matt. I’ve noticed – uh oh, I’ve noticed the salt and pepper. Now I have to collect it. So, I…

Matt: I highly doubt Hogwarts is in short supply of salt and pepper shakers.

Eric: Salt and pepper! So, I collect – but it’s in my cart, it’s in my trunk with my alarm clock and bucket of whatever else it was I collected, and now I’m just waiting to use it. They have to be something. They have a team of people here. There has to be a use for what we’re collecting, and you’ve got to think Pottermore, releasing these books this way, it’s a long-term commitment towards excellence where even if we feel like it’s not what they promised initially, they’re going to deliver, right? I mean, they absolutely care about this sort of thing succeeding. It has to succeed. So, they’ll be working on it, right? I mean, it can only get better, right?

Andrew: Yes, I guess. I mean, they’re going to have to add some serious features other than the books to make it better. I mean, certainly having the books in there will make it better as well. In case you don’t remember, the books – the next book will be out some time in 2012. They haven’t really narrowed down when that’s going to be, but presumably once this opens to the public, that’s when…

Eric: Well…

Andrew: …work on Book 2 is really going to start.

Eric: …the interesting thing, too, is that we’ve lived off of just the books, and just the books for several years, right? I mean, it was – oh, four films, and arguably – or four years before the first book and the first film, but arguably things were still growing then. But I mean, even in terms of content-wise, right? We’ve lived off basically just the books, and maybe some of the movies, for ten or twelve years now. So, Pottermore drawing attention to, “Hey, we’re going to give you something to live off the books for again,” was kind of – was it a bad thing? Because we were able to do this sort of without Pottermore, almost, is to kind of relax and still go on living life and still go on loving Harry Potter.

Matt: Mhm.

Andrew: So, we could talk about this for – all day, but we’ll end it there for now and get to some e-mails. One other thing we wanted to mention, though, was that Pottermore – the Twitter account, Twitter.com/Pottermore, they’ve been doing house pride days, and today was – well, tomorrow being Friday, is Gryffindor Pride Day. So…

Eric: [scoffs] Friday.

Andrew: I’ll be there. I’m in Gryffindor, I’ll be there.

Eric: What happened to your CastleCloak?

Andrew: Oh, I… [laughs]

Eric: You mentioned it on the show.

Andrew: You know what? I never used the account. I did not cheat and get sorted again. I didn’t use the account because I mistakenly – I didn’t want to put it out there for the friend request thing, but then what I realized is that my new account – I connected it with Facebook, so I could see my real friends on Pottermore, and then my Facebook friends who are MuggleCast listeners, added me on it anyway, so…

Eric: [laughs] Oh.

Andrew: …it was kind of all for nothing.

Eric: Yeah, okay.

Andrew: But I didn’t cheat, I promise you.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: For the record, I am now CatSeeker. [laughs]

Eric: What’s the number?

Matt: CatSeeker?

Andrew: I don’t know if I want to say the number. [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Oh, you’re CatSeeker! Okay.

Andrew: I’m still catching up on the friend requests.

Eric: Just friend them on Facebook.

Andrew: And I’ve been adding everybody who sends me a friend request just because…

Eric: I’m going to friend request you right now.

Andrew: I mean, what does it make a difference if they’re friends with me or not?

Eric: Right, now that they’re…

Andrew: They have no Wall to write on, there’s – I guess everybody can just challenge and we can duel. I can duel all these people. [laughs] And I’ll beat you all.

[Eric and Matt laugh]

Andrew: Does everybody else want to say their names if they haven’t already?

Matt: Mine’s ThornSpell, but I don’t know the number.

Eric: My Hufflepuff is StrikeLumos. I love it.

Andrew: Micah?

Micah: Are we saying our usernames? Is that what it is?

Andrew: Yeah. If you don’t want to say…

Micah: No, I’ve said it on the show before. ShadowSpell93.

Andrew: All right. That’s a cool one.

Matt: [whispers] ShadowSpell.


Listener Feedback: Potions on Pottermore


Andrew: All right. Well, let’s move on to some e-mails about Pottermore. Enough with what we think, let’s see what the listeners think. This first one comes from N-G-O-C, 19, of Australia…

Eric: Ngoc [pronounced “Noc”]. It’s just Nogc.

Andrew: Ngoc.

Eric: It’s a Vietnamese name.

Andrew: Oh, interesting. [laughs]

“Hey guys, I just received my welcome e-mail for Pottermore a few days ago and have been steadily progressing through the chapters. However, I’m having a bit of trouble with potion-brewing. After brewing, the pop-up message tells me it will take about eighty minutes, and that I can leave the page and come back, but when I do, my potion and progress has disappeared! I’ve been listening to your podcasts probably well over a year now and didn’t know who else to ask about this. Cheers!”

I don’t think we can offer really any assistance. That may have just been a bug, but like the Pottermore Insider said, it will soon not take so long for potions to brew.

Matt: Was it intentionally 80 minutes or that was the bug?

Andrew: No, it was intentionally taking so long, and who knows why they decided to do it that way.

Eric: Yeah. That’ll be the real thing I’m looking for, is like a “Behind Pottermore” book where they’re like, “This is why it was like this.”

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah…

Micah: Melissa will write it.

Andrew: …and all the drama. [laughs] Melissa will write it. Pottermore, A History.

Eric: And JK Rowling will foreword.

[Andrew and Matt laugh]

Eric: We’re all jealous of her success.

Andrew: Micah, can you read the next e-mail?


Listener Feedback: Getting Into Gringotts


Micah: Next e-mail is from Emily, 19, of East Lansing, Michigan, and she says:

“Hey MuggleCasters, I know you’re probably getting a thousand of these e-mails right now, but I’m sending out a cry for help with regards to Pottermore. I made it to Chapter 5 and have found my shopping list – and the funny bit about clothing, haha – but I cannot move on to the next moment! The site, in theory, knows that I found the list, it’s in my trunk and everything, but Gringotts remains closed to me. Help from y’all or fellow listeners would be much appreciated! Have fun storming the castle! Emily.”

Matt: Aww, thanks, Em.

Eric: I don’t know – yeah, I was stuck there, too, but it was just because I hadn’t picked up the school shopping list, which you have to zoom in twice to get it. You’re talking about the north end [laughs] of Diagon Alley, or when you just enter Diagon Alley. And yeah, it says, “Go find your shopping list,” and it’s just laying on the ground. You have to zoom in twice to get it. But until you…

Micah: I think she says she has it.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, that’s what she said, but sometimes – because on Pottermore where you – there are the arrow keys to go to the next scene and the previous scene. That next scene arrow won’t – it’s locked sometimes until you find that item. It was locked for me, and so – but once I found it, it was unlocked, and if she’s still saying it’s locked, I don’t know what to do about that. It’s possible that there may be an item that you need. Oh, I think I know what it is, is that you have to actually – well no, do you go to Gringotts before you get your books? Yeah, you have to, right? So, I…

Micah: Yeah, because you need the money to do so.

Eric: Oh, try clicking on the Gringotts door, on the front door. I think there’s a man walking in there or something, and that may or may not be one of the little requirements you have to do.

Andrew: Pottermore Tech Support is here for you!

Eric: [laughs] “I am sorry that this happened to you.”

Andrew: That’s something else I didn’t really enjoy, is the switching between the shopping list and then grabbing the item, and then going back to the shopping list…

Eric: I was glad – well see, why isn’t it in your trunk? This shows how inconsistent they chose to be, which is that your shopping list…

Andrew: What, the items?

Eric: Yeah, in that scene, your shopping list is hanging down on the right side of your screen, when in theory it should be in your trunk with your other items but you should be able to examine all of the items in your trunk closer so that you could pull up your shopping list. It’s basically not using what they have. It’s not using the trunk, because it’s basically saying all the other stuff you’ve collected is crap, you’re not going to use it, but all the relevant plot details for moving forward, we’re going to hang from the right of the screen. And it’s like, well – and now I’m looking in my item list in my trunk, and of course the shopping list is in there! So, it’s not like they didn’t code it in, it’s just that you can’t view any of these things with more detail and actually use them in your quest yet.


Listener Feedback: Wands on Pottermore


Andrew: Erica, 19, of Austin, asks:

“The wands of the characters that have new content are listed, like McGonagall and Quirrell, but wands of other characters are not. Do you think more of the main characters will have more complete profiles as other books are released?”

And the answer to that is yes, I think it’s been said multiple times now that there will be content that opens up as you continue to explore.

Micah: Now where do you get that content? Because I don’t think I saw that.

Andrew: Like what?

Micah: What she was talking about in the e-mail.

Andrew: Oh, the wands of the characters that have new content? So, I presume when we learn about other characters, when JK Rowling writes new content about the other characters, then we’ll see their wand. So, when we get a profile on, let’s say, Severus Snape…

Eric: But Micah is saying he hasn’t seen McGonagall and Quirrell’s wand, right?

Micah: Well, maybe I just glossed over it when I was reading through the new information on them.

Eric: Okay.

Micah: It’s possible.

Andrew: Yeah. Well…

Eric: Is that part of the description, or is there actually a profile page for McGonagall then? Where it says that…

Andrew: Yes. Well, there is kind of a profile page, but – could somebody tell me right now where McGonagall’s chapter is?

Eric: Uhhh.

Andrew: I mean, this is the issue. Like, okay, I want to look up McGonagall, but…

Eric: What, you mean you didn’t “Facebook Like” it?

Andrew: …first I’ve got to find the chapter.

Eric: You didn’t “Favorite” it?

Andrew: [laughs] No, I didn’t.

Eric: Well, that’s the only way you can find things.

Andrew: Yeah, I need to learn that, apparently. Hopefully they’re going to add – let’s just get it over with. Just add an encyclopedia button, and let’s see all the new content from Jo…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …right there, just list it. Say “Click here to jump to McGonagall. Click here to jump to…”

Eric: But there’s thrill…

Andrew: “…Quirrell.”

Eric: …isn’t there? A challenge in unlocking it? And you guys said that was…

Andrew: Well, right…

Eric: …authentically Jo-like, right?

Andrew: Okay, so first, we unlock it.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Then it shows up in this encyclopedia index.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: That’s not much to ask for.

Eric: Without us having to “Favorite” it.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Because we’re going to “Favorite” it, it’s new content.


Listener Feedback: Pottermore vs. A Physical Encyclopedia


Andrew: This last e-mail from Sherryn from New Zealand, she says:

“As much as it pains me to criticize Jo, I have to say I’m really disappointed. While the graphics are beautiful, I completely agree with Andrew’s review that the site lacks revisit value. I have only visited Pottermore maybe once or twice since completing Book 1 within about four hours of entering. While I really tried to take my time and enjoy, there really is just not much to do, just random clicking and collecting stuff that has no discernible use.”

And she goes on and on a bit more.

“I really feel that if it comes down to Pottermore versus the encyclopedia, I would much rather have a book. As a 22-year-old law student, between university, working part-time, and trying to have a social life, I am not really interested in creating potions or partaking in pretend duels. I know Pottermore is aimed at all ages, but the overall simplicity of the features is a bit insulting. Now I am going to get to the controversial part of the e-mail where I admit to having several Pottermore accounts.”

[laughs] Oh, I should delete this e-mail right now.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: [continues]

“I know everyone who missed out is going to hate me right now, but I can’t do much about this really. I was mainly just really annoyed at the crappy name options I got served with, and curious to see whether the sorting process was as reliable as claimed.”

Oh, okay, now we’re going to get interesting.

“Anyway, in pursuit of my sorting theory, I have been sorted into a different house on three accounts. The first was Gryffindor, then Slytherin, then Hufflepuff. I find this all quite ironic, because I have always thought of myself as a Ravenclaw.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Uh oh.

“I remember Melissa from PotterCast saying she got sorted into Gryffindor every time she created an account in the trial period, so this leads me to believe there is something behind the idea that the algorithm possibly skews the sorting process.”

Eric: Yeah, I…

Andrew: So, she kind of – oh, we should have tested that out ourselves, then.

Eric: Well, I have two other accounts just sitting around. I should…

Andrew: You should try.

Eric: …log in and…

Andrew: Try to answer with – now, Sherryn doesn’t say if she answered the same questions…

Eric: Right.

Andrew: …each time. I wonder – I mean, that’s important.

Eric: That’s the other thing, is if I’m still honest, do I get the same house? If so, I have two accounts with the same house. What good is that, right?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Or how should I use these extra accounts? I don’t know, but…

Micah: I found out where that extra information was. When you pull up all the blurbs that you get on, let’s say, McGonagall, on the right hand side there’s this little column. It’s like what you would see almost on like…

Eric: “New from JK Rowling”?

Micah: …a wiki page, and it lists McGonagall’s birthday, wand, Hogwarts House, special abilities, parentage, family, hobbies.

Andrew: Sorry, where is this?

Micah: This is if you actually click on her name. Like, say you’re in a chapter which revealed…

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: …new information about her, and you know how it kind of lists everything out, where it’ll say “Discovered in Chapter 7”, “Discovered in Chapter 8”, “Discovered in Chapter 15,” which is where you get all new information about McGonagall? On the right hand side of each of those, it gives you just this little bio, this snapshot bio…

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: …of her, and I guess it does the same thing for Quirrell.

Andrew: There should be, like, a search, too. That would be nice.

Micah: Yeah, that would be cool.

Matt: Mhm.

Micah: Or I think what you were saying, where you go to your main page and you can see the new information right there that you’ve unlocked from JK Rowling…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: …and you can just go right to it, instead of having to go through and find it in all these chapters.

Andrew: Right. For example, another way I just got to it is I went to the common room, then I clicked on Godric Gryffindor and there’s, like, two sentences about him, and then on the right, it says “Also in this chapter.” I don’t know what chapter – oh, Chapter 7 apparently, because I guess this is where – well, I have no idea. And then on the right, like I said, you can see a list of characters and these are all the characters I guess in this chapter, or maybe – I don’t know. But anyway, there’s a link to Professor McGonagall there and twenty others, and then when I click on Professor McGonagall, I can see all the information just like you can. So – and the comments. I’m looking at the comments right now, and there’s one – “My Animagus form is Chuck Norris.” It’s like, these are useless.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: So…

Micah: Chuck Norris takes no Animagus form.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Yeah.


Favorites: Creature


Andrew: Okay, so moving on now, we’re going to play Favorites!

Eric: Woot!

Andrew: And we want to know favorite creature.

Eric: Now is this a specific – by name, like a creature we’ve met…

Andrew: Any.

Eric: …or a type of creature?

Micah: It can be whatever you want.

Andrew: Yeah, broad or specific. Micah, what is your favorite creature?

Micah: Kreacher.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: I’m just kidding.

Matt: Cop out!

Micah: Yeah, that was too easy. I like Buckbeak.

Andrew: Hmm.

Matt: Hmm. [laughs]

Andrew: Me too, I was fascinated by Buckbeak…

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: …when reading the book. Matt?

Matt: I don’t know, I didn’t even know [laughs] this was part of the show. I didn’t see this. I’ll probably say Fawkes, the phoenix, is my favorite.

Andrew: Good choices! Eric?

Eric: I’m going to say Boggart, actually.

Andrew: Hmm. I have to say the phoenix in general, though I am partial to Fawkes. I don’t know if we’ve ever really…

Eric: [laughs] Met any others.

Andrew: …learned about any other specific ones. But just the phoenix in general, just the specific Fawkes aside. I’ve just always found that the phoenixes are very beautiful and inspiring and solid.

Matt: Mhm. You know she didn’t invent the phoenix, right?

Andrew: No, I know.

Matt: Oh, okay.

Eric: I mean, maybe the specific rules about it, right? I mean, the rules that govern their nature in the books.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Speaking of – my Pottermore wand is phoenix feather core.

Matt: Oh, mine too!

Eric: Cool! Apparently, they’re very temperamental.

Matt: Oh no, mine is very pliant.

Eric: [laughs] It’s a different…


Listener Tweets: Favorite Creature


Andrew: We asked on Twitter: what is your favorite type of creature? kd213 said:

“Nifflers! Very creative, not to mention they have a cool name.”

lax_punky97 said:

“Hippogriffs! They’re proud and don’t take any crap, which is a trait I admire.”

AbbyforthD said:

“Definitely centaurs! Their culture seems absolutely fascinating, and the fact that they come to fight in the battle is so noble!”

Matt: Oh, I didn’t see that in the movie.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Not in the movie, I guess.

Matt: Oh.

Andrew: In the book.

Micah: Didn’t Buckbeak show up at the battle, too? Or am I making that up?

Matt: In Half-Blood Prince

Micah: Yeah, that’s right.

Matt: …I think it was.

Micah: The elves showed up, though, right? In Deathly Hallows?

Matt: In the book, not in the movie.

Andrew: And Oliver Wood, but he didn’t come back for the movie. StephAnne21 said:

“Ghosts because I like the idea of talking to someone who lived a really long time ago, or owls because they’re so useful.”

I forgot that ghosts would kind of count as a creature.

Eric: Creature? Yeah.

Andrew: Even though they’re not physical.

Eric: [whispers] Let’s get physical!

Andrew: You disagree, Matt?

Matt: I kind of disagree, but that’s fine. I mean, we’re not going into specifics.

Andrew: RussTurner says:

“Phoenix because they have magic we don’t fully understand.”

Ooh, good point!

Eric and

Matt:

Ooh.

Matt: Yeah, that was my answer, too.

Eric: Although house-elves have magic we don’t quite fully understand. And goblins have magic we don’t understand.

Andrew: So true.

Matt: Wands have magic we don’t understand.

Eric: Magic.

Matt: It’s not always clear why.

Eric: We just don’t get it.

Andrew: jimmyqex says:

“My favorite creature is Pigwidgeon, Ron’s owl…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: [continues]

“…because it is so tiny and crazy. I’m sad they left it out of the films.”

Matt: Yeah.

Andrew: BeccaKid47 said:

“Wouldn’t this be Episode 239?”

Yes, you’re right, that was a mistake that we tweeted.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: That wasn’t her…

Andrew: It said 238.

Eric: …favorite creature. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh, here’s one we haven’t mentioned.

“Thestrals.”

Says OhHeyItsMaddieK.

“They are misunderstood, but beautiful in their own way. I also love Kreacher and the way he changes.”


Muggle Mail: Oscar Buzz at Toronto Film Festival


Andrew: So, thanks everyone who follows us on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast. Before recording every episode, we ask a question and we read your answers on the show. Okay, now to wrap up the show, we have some e-mails to get to. Eric, could you read the first one?

Eric: First one is from Alison, 22, from Ontario.

“I’m working at the Toronto Film…”

Andrew: Toronto.

Eric: What did I say?

Andrew: Ontario.

Eric: Really? I’m sorry.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s weird.

Eric: That’s odd. The first one is from – because I was reading it. The first one is from Alison, age 22, from Toronto. She says:

“I’m working at the Toronto Film Festival, the starting gate for the race to Oscar, and can report that there isn’t a single film getting really great Oscar buzz. Toronto International Film Festival is where most, if not all, Oscar contenders are shown, and usually before the festival is over, clear front-runners emerge, and one can essentially predict the Oscar nominees from there. This year, however, there isn’t a single film getting consensus Oscar buzz, which suggests to me that ‘Deathly Hallows – Part 2’ has a very real shot at being nominated, and maybe even winning since the field is so empty. It may seem like a bold statement, but in the past, films like ‘Slumdog Millionaire’, ‘The King’s Speech’, ‘Precious’, ‘The Hurt Locker’, ‘Juno’, and so on and so forth, premiered here and were all but guaranteed nominations by the time the festival was out. But this year, that simply has not happened to the same extent, so fingers crossed!”

That sounds cool.

Matt: Yep.

Andrew: Yeah, good sign. Good sign. And hopefully we’ll be finding out. I mean, the Oscars aren’t until when? They’re still really far away.

Eric: Yeah, I think so. It’s just so odd. I mean, there were plenty of other films besides Harry Potter that came out, right?

Andrew: Mhm.

Matt: Mhm.

Eric: So, we’ll see.


Muggle Mail: Good Slytherins


Andrew: Tiani, 15, from Massachusetts, writes:

“In Episode 238, you guys talked about all of the Slytherins basically turning out as evil except for Severus Snape. But I’d just like to point out that Regulus Black was a Slytherin and he turned against Voldemort – against the “dark side” you could say – in the end, leading to his death. Just saying. Love the show and keep up the amazing work!”

Eric: [laughs] Let me recap. Now in 238, I mentioned something that the Slytherins were all evil, and then everybody else disproved me, very successfully. So, it was only me who said that, and I stand…

Andrew: And weren’t you joking?

Eric: Yeah, I was. Well…

Andrew: I mean, surely you didn’t believe that?

Eric: Pfft. Surely not.

Micah: He was in the midst – weren’t you dueling or something like that?

Eric: Something like…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It was dueling…

Matt: And Merlin was a Slytherin, too.

Eric: Yes! Pottermore.

Micah: Spoiler alert, if… [laughs]

Eric: Yeah. Right, oops.

Micah: …you haven’t gotten into Pottermore yet.

Eric: [laughs] But yeah, that’s cool. I stand corrected yet again.

Micah: All right.


Muggle Mail: Best Chapter Movie-goers Should Read


Andrew: Micah, can you read the next e-mail, from Cathy?

Micah: The next e-mail is from Cathy, 20, of Kentucky, and she says:

“Hello! I wanted to weigh in on the ‘Best Chapter a Movie-goer Should Read” discussion.”

Which we discussed on the last episode.

“My choice would be Chapter 16, “A Frosty Christmas” from ‘Half-Blood Prince’. This has the Harry versus Rufus Scrimgeour scene. When you read that part in the book, you get a real sense of who Harry is that you just don’t get when you watch the movies. Although Harry gets a lot of help from others along the way in all the books, he is strong and clever on his own, too, which we see here. And he’s way too committed to what’s right to let anyone, not even a greedy Minister of Magic, bully him. You can’t help but cheer Harry on while he lets the Minister have it! I love the glimpse of Harry as a leader that you get from that scene.”

Eric: Cool! That’s good feedback. I think that the prompt was a really good prompt to begin with…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …which was asked by one of our other listeners, actually. So, that’s cool.


Muggle Mail: Andrew’s Accurate Prediction in Episode 71


Andrew: Matt, can you read the next e-mail, from Justin?

Matt: Yes. Justin, 24, from Jacksonville, says:

“So I got into MuggleCast a bit late, and I really wanted to go back and listen to all your old episodes. It helps me get through the long days at work. I am up to Episode 71 and I just heard something crazy. You all are discussing the title of Book 7 and the hangman theory because Jo used the hangman puzzle to release the title. At the 27:16 mark, Andrew said something that blew my mind. He asks…”

Oh, of course Andrew put this in here.

[Eric and Matt laugh]

Andrew: I didn’t put this in here!

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Micah did. Go ahead.

Matt: [continues]

“He asks if in Book 7 Harry would be willing to sacrifice himself but by a miracle he won’t have to. If that doesn’t perfectly describe the end of ‘Deathly Hallows’, I don’t know what is. So I just wanted to pat you on the back, Andrew, even if the rest of the MuggleCasters ignored your idea at the time.”

[Eric laughs]

Matt: [continues]

“Love the show! Sad it has cut back to once a month.”

Andrew: You know, I’m pretty brilliant, and this is an example of that. I’m going to put this on my resume. No, it’s funny. When we record these shows, honestly, I forget what I say completely…

Eric: Well, you say so much.

Andrew: …especially after recording them…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

Matt: Well, you were only partially right. He did have to sacrifice himself.

Andrew: But by a miracle, he won’t have to. And I mean…

Matt: But he did.

Andrew: Well…

Eric: But it didn’t matter.

Andrew: He did sacrifice himself, though.

Matt: He did sacrifice himself. He died…

Andrew: But…

Matt: …but then he came back to life.

Andrew: He sacrificed himself but he didn’t. A true sacrifice would have been actually dying.

Eric: Yeah.

Matt: Oh, so he didn’t really sacrifice himself…

[Micah laughs]

Matt: …so it was all in vain.

Eric: Honestly, Matt, there was that child he abandoned, right, underneath the bench there?

Micah: He half-assed it, is that what you’re saying, Andrew?

Andrew: [laughs] No, I’m saying – yes, I guess I am kind of saying that.

Micah: No, but…

Andrew: It was a miracle, I would say.

Matt: Okay, but he did sacrifice himself by – he didn’t know he was going to live after that.

Andrew: Mhm.

Matt: As far as he was concerned, he was sacrificing himself.

Micah: I just – I think these e-mails are cool because a lot of times we’ll get these where people say how the hosts predicted what was going to happen and didn’t even realize that they were doing it. And I remember there was an e-mail not too long ago with Matt predicting where the Deathly Hallows split was going to be, and he nailed it exactly right. So…

Andrew: Mhm.

Matt: I am sort of brilliant.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Wow!

Andrew: Well, the – yeah, it was fun to do all that speculating back then, and it is fun to hear it now in hindsight. I think this may have been a discussion where we may have been talking about, “Is Harry going to die?” because that was something we did talk about a lot.

Eric: Yeah, we did.

Andrew: Would he die in Book 7?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And that may have where – I kind of thought Harry would die, because, I mean, that would have been the ultimate ending to the story.

Eric: I didn’t think he would, because he’s called “The Boy Who Lived,” right? I mean, it just would suck if he lived for a little while and then died.

Andrew: True. All right, Eric, final e-mail.


Muggle Mail: Places People Listen to MuggleCast


Eric: Final e-mail is from Phill, aged 23. He says:

“Hey guys, love the show. Second favorite podcast ever (Sorry!). I know you guys are always keen to hear some of the weird and wonderful places your fans listen to MuggleCast, so I thought I would let you know where I was listening very recently: crammed into the back of a four-engined Royal New Zealand Air Force C-130 Hercules transport plane screaming through the air, barely 50 meters above the Afghanistan desert, twisting and turning between the hills on a tactical flight into my deployment. Keep pumping out the hilarity, or it’ll be a very long winter. Phill.”

Wow.

Andrew: That’s pretty awesome.

Eric: That’s…

Andrew: Thank you, Phill.

Eric: …pretty awesome. Oh, and…

Andrew: I’d classify that as a weird place to listen to MuggleCast, but I would just say that’s downright awesome.

Micah: Yeah…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: …that’s really cool.

Matt: He’s not supposed to say where he was from, but he was circling above the Afghanistan desert.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Well, he’s not supposed to say where he’s based.

Eric: In the back of a four-engined…

Matt: Oh, his base.

Eric: …Royal New Zealand Air Force C-130 Hercules transport plane. Yeah, yeah. And future reference to our listeners, you don’t have to apologize for us being your second favorite podcast ever. You do, however, just have to tell us what your favorite podcast is, so we can go and stop them.

Andrew: Yeah, I’m wondering what his favorite podcast is now.

Eric: Right?

Matt: Probably a podcast that does it every week.

Micah: Smart Mouths?

Eric: It’s probably a podcast…

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Yeah, Smart Mouths. It probably is a podcast about C-130 Hercules transport planes. Let’s be honest here.

Andrew: Could be. I just Googled it. It looks like a cool plane.

Eric: Oh, really? I’m going to Google it.


Show Close


Andrew: Anyway, well, thanks Phill and stay safe out there as you fight the good fight. Don’t forget about the MuggleCast website. MuggleCast.com is where you’ll find everything you need about the show. At the top, you can find an Episodes link and from there you can get every episode. You can even go back and listen to Episode 71, and scroll to 27:16 and hear me make a prediction that made Jo quiver. On the MuggleCast site, you can also find links to our iTunes, our Twitter which is Twitter.com/MuggleCast, our Facebook, Facebook.com/MuggleCast, and our fan Tumblr which is MuggleCast.Tumblr.com. And also on the MuggleCast website, you can click on “Contact” at the top and from there you can fill out the feedback form to get in touch with us. And maybe, just maybe, we’ll read your e-mail on the next show.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: Thanks everyone for listening! From Hypable.com, I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: From MuggleNet.com, I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: From MSNBC.com, [laughs] I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

[Andrew and Matt laugh]

Matt: From Fox News, I’m Matt Britton.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: We’ll see you next time for Episode 240!

Micah: You changed that fast on that?

Matt: Hmm?

Micah: You went from liberal to conservative in the span of an episode.

Matt: Didn’t you get my post?

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: We’ll see everyone next time for Episode 240! Buh-bye!

Eric: Bye.

Micah: Bye.

[Show music continues]

Transcript #238

MuggleCast 238 Transcript


Show Intro


[“Hedwig’s Theme” plays]

Andrew: Because I’m reasonably supple, this is MuggleCast Episode 238 for August 27th, 2011.

[Show music begins]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 238! Micah, Eric, and I here this week to bring you the latest Harry Potter news, even though, oh, it’s been over a month since the last film was out. But that’s okay, there’s still plenty of news to talk about related to the film actually and also, of course, Pottermore and…

Micah: What’s Pottermore?

Andrew: [laughs] I guess you wouldn’t know, would you?

Micah: [laughs] No, I have no idea. I haven’t gained access to it yet.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Yeah, me neither.

Andrew: And so we’re going to have the news, and then lots of e-mails to catch up on and some fun segments as well, so it’s going to be a fun show. But first the news. Micah, what’s in the news?

Micah: You were talking…

Andrew: Micah.

Micah: What?

Andrew: [laughs] Nothing.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Do we not intro ourselves anymore?

Micah: Oh yeah.

Andrew: Mmm.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: I always forget that. I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: What’s in the news, Micah?


News: Deathly Hallows: Part 2 Box Office Update


Micah: You mentioned before the movie has been out now for a little bit over a month, the last film in the Harry Potter series, but Deathly Hallows: Part 2 still continues to do relatively well at the box office, I mean, it’s been out for over a month, so it’s expected that it’s going to drop off a bit. But it just passed the $900 million mark internationally. It’s the third film ever to do that, following Avatar and Titanic, which it currently sits behind on the worldwide all time grossing list. I don’t think it has any chance of moving past either of those two films, unless somewhere down the line Deathly Hallows: Part 2 is re-released. But what do you guys think about that? I mean, I think we talked a little bit about it on the last show – or maybe we didn’t because it’s been a bit since we did a show. The movie moving to number three all time, all the awards that it’s – sorry, not awards, not yet anyway, but records that it’s broken.

Andrew: Well, it’s not – it hasn’t surprised me really, this whole box office success, and I’m happy for it and it’s a great way to go out. It would have been quite embarrassing if it wasn’t the top film and if it wasn’t breaking…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …all these records, so…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …I’m happy with how it went.

Micah: Right. And, of course, it’s the top grossing U.S. movie of 2011. I don’t think that’s any surprise. If it’s the number three movie all time, it better be the top movie of 2011.

Andrew: Mhm.


News: Pottermore Beta Update


Micah: Next up, Pottermore. Andrew, I have no idea what this is.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I have not received [laughs] access to it yet. Maybe I sound a bit bitter about that, if I do I apologize because I’m sure I’ll get e-mails. But as is stated here, twenty-five thousand students…

Andrew: Yeah, it’s kind of odd. So, I mean, we all went through the Magical Quill process to make sure we’re one of the lucky one million to get into Pottermore, and they opened up Pottermore I guess – I don’t know, about two weeks ago now? Maybe – it was a little – it’s at least a week it’s been open. And so far, they’ve only let in twenty-five thousand of the one million.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Andrew: And the reason I know that is because I was one of those lucky people, and if you go into the Great Hall, it has a tally of the number of students that have been – that are enrolled, so to speak. But I think the other thing to keep in mind is that this is twenty-five thousand people who have been sorted, meaning they’ve made their way to the Sorting Hat Chapter. And another thing to keep in mind is that I guarantee you, out of this million, there are a boat-load of people who have gotten an e-mail so far and just haven’t registered. And I know you must be thinking, “Oh my God, how could they do such a thing?” but some people aren’t as hardcore, they may have just done the Magical Quill process and gotten in by luck. So, that’s why I’m guessing they’ve tried to reach out to maybe closer to forty or fifty thousand at this point, but so far only twenty-five thousand have made it to the Sorting Hat Chapter and been sorted.

Eric: So, once you get sorted, you’re given the common room, right? And that’s your local place to chill?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: So, what happens before you get to that chapter? How – is it just boring looking, or…

Andrew: No…

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Well, you don’t get your house colors on the top banner part, but you go through all the Moments leading up to the Sorting Hat, and it’s good. I’m not finished with it yet, I want to wait until I’m finished because it is – from everything I’ve read, it takes only about four hours to get though the whole thing because it’s basically just a lot of clicking.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: And…

Micah: Well, you’re experiencing the book all over again, right? You’re getting backstory that otherwise you wouldn’t get if you just opened up Sorcerer’s Stone and read it for fun.

Andrew: Right. The standout here, I think, is absolutely the new content that J.K. Rowling has added to it because there is a lot. And we’ve mentioned a couple of them that J.K. Rowling has teased leading up to this opening of it. McGonagall backstory, there’s a lot there. More on Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon. What else?

Micah: I saw some stuff on Quirrell, Professor Quirrell.

Andrew: Yeah, Quirrell. Yeah. Quirrell, ghost plots.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: There’s rules on wizards wearing wizarding clothing out in Muggle public, history on that, and why they do and do not do it. Backstory on Ollivander, Hogwarts Express, how that was created. So, a lot of stuff, and it’s very true to the spirit of the books. It’s what you would expect to find in say, a Harry Potter encyclopedia. It’s very Jo, it’s very – it’s just very good, and I’m impressed with it so far. The problem is they’re not opening up the Pottermore Betas quick enough. I would expect at least a hundred thousand people [laugh] would have been in this by now.

Micah: Yeah, that’s what I was going to ask, is they state that you can get in between now and the end of September. And I would think that if you’re somebody who has to wait that long, you’re probably going to get pretty frustrated with this whole process and say, “Well, if I’m not going to get in until the last week of September, I might as well just have waited until October.”

Andrew: Exactly. But I think at the rate it’s going, unless they make some moves quick soon, I don’t think – I don’t know if this is going to open up in time.

Eric: Hmm.

Andrew: I mean, I could see this being – the opening happening October 31st, an hour before the day ends.

Eric: Yeah, they’ve only said October, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: So, I just always imagined it would open up on Halloween.

Micah: Yeah. I mean, that would be a good tie-in to the series, but Andrew, you got the puzzle solved on day one. How have you – is it just that the people who got in on day one? Is that how it’s working? I mean, how are they figuring out – are they staggering it by when you got in, or is it just…

Andrew: No.

Micah: …random?

Andrew: It’s random. Yeah, it is random. I mean, yeah, I did get my account the first day Beta invites were available and no, I did not get it the first day. It took a few days – it took over a week, I think, so – and like I said, it’s only – maybe at this point let’s say forty thousand, fifty thousand e-mails have gone out. That’s not a lot out of the one million.

Micah: Well – I mean, my point was, are there people from day three and day five that have gotten in?

Andrew: Yes, definitely.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I haven’t heard as many of them have gotten in. I think a lot of people were the first day, but then when I started seeing that other people had gotten in, I think that that was no longer the case. But at first I thought it was just the people who did the first day of the Magical Quill Challenge, but…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: …it’s not the case. But yeah, still a ton of people left to go. But I thought what was interesting is that you wrote most of the students are Ravenclaws.

Andrew: [laughs] Yes, it’s an interesting – it’s good that they have these numbers in here because it makes it interesting. So, as everybody knows you do get sorted by a process that J.K. Rowling created herself, and if you do look in the Great Hall you see how many students are in each house and Ravenclaw leads the pack by about two thousand students right now which is interesting. And every other house is kind of neck and neck. Ravenclaw has around seven thousand and the other houses have around five thousand each. And speaking of Ravenclaw, one of the actresses in the Harry Potter films, Evanna Lynch, we all know she’s a big fan of the series, she was on a recent episode of MuggleCast at LeakyCon. She got into Pottermore and was sorted, and she was sorted into Ravenclaw which shocked her. She took to Twitter in a panic…

Eric: Oh, you mean Gryffindor? She was sorted into Gryffindor.

Andrew: Oh right, sorry.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, she wanted Ravenclaw…

Eric: Well, Luna is a Ravenclaw.

Andrew: …but she got into…

Eric: Luna who she plays.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: So…

Andrew: Yeah. So, she went onto Twitter and she kind of went on a rant. She sent out like six or seven tweets…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …saying – I’ll quote them.

[poorly imitating Evanna Lynch] “Ahhhh umm errrrrr…. Just got sorted. Slight identity crisis. Need to sit down and process this…

“I’m in Gryffindor. #Pottermore #confusion #shock #pride #happiness #LUNADONTLEAVEME!!!”

[normal voice] So, [laughs] she was very upset that she got into Gryffindor. For a moment at least, I guess because she’s always identified herself as a Ravenclaw, not to mention that she plays a Ravenclaw in the films.

Eric: Yeah. Or just with Luna, the fact that there’s this connection. Many people agree that she plays a really good Luna and I think she’s felt so close to that character, and now to be sorted into Gryffindor [laughs] it’s a little off-putting, but…

Micah: Well, she wears that hat all the time, though.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, the lion hat.

Micah: The lion hat, right? I mean, conflict of interest…

Eric: Nothing wrong with Gryffindor.

Micah: Or identity crisis.

Eric: Identity crisis, yeah. But…

Andrew: One thing I’ll say right now about Pottermore that’s really been bugging me is that when you get friend requests, you don’t know who they are…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: …because you have – you’re just getting – because it says, “UnicornKnight wants to be friends with you.” And it’s like, well, who’s UnicornKnight?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: How am I supposed to figure this out?

Eric: And you can hook it up to Facebook, right? But…

Andrew: Yes, that’s the one thing that does help, but an incoming friend request does not give you the name, I don’t think.

Micah: Can they send a message saying, “Hi, this is so-and-so”…

Andrew: No.

Micah: …with their request?

Andrew: No, no.

Micah: Oh, they should fix that. I mean, especially if you’re trying to deal with any sort of problems with children signing up.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: That was the whole basis behind this, right, that…

Andrew: Exactly.

Micah: …they didn’t want children’s names being put out there? They wanted to make the experience for all ages but if children are putting their names out there, it gets into legalities and things like that. But I can’t imagine that they’re not going to implement hopefully something when the site launches where you can send a message because otherwise it’s such a hassle to go and figure out who all these people are. You’ve got to send messages, essentially, to all your friends.

Andrew: Yeah. The one thing that does help, like Eric mentioned, you can connect with Facebook, but that only works when you connect with Facebook, then you can see your friends who are on Pottermore. You get their real name and then what their Pottermore name is. You can’t see that for incoming requests.

Eric: Right, so you don’t know who anybody else is.

Andrew: Yeah. So, that’s an issue. I mean, that’s a serious issue…

Eric: Well…

Andrew: …because – unless you and your real-life friends talk and say, “Hey, I’m…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “…DreamMarauder64. I’m sending you a friend request.” And you go, “Okay.”

Eric: Well – so the Beta – the whole reason they are doing Beta, even to begin with, is to get feedback, right? Figure out how it works?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: So, I heard from my friend who is on Pottermore that the feedback form on Pottermore is actually not open ended, that it’s only a drop-down list.

Andrew: Exactly. It’s actually really bad…

Eric: Oh, really?

Andrew: …because – well, what happens is you go onto one page and you click the Beta feedback link, and then it asks you questions specifically about the page, but these are the same questions for every page on the site. So, like you said, you can’t be like, “I don’t like the Potions here, because XYZ.” The questions are, “How much do you like this page?” and then you have the options: “It’s great. I like it a lot,” “It’s good. I like it.” “It’s okay. I don’t like or dislike it,” [laughs] and then, “I don’t like it very much.” And then there are questions: “How much do you agree with the following statements? I like the way the page looks. Strongly agree, agree, disagree, strongly disagree.” It’s just all this generic stuff, and it’s like, how is this helpful? [laughs] So, there is still a lot of work to be done here, but overall, it is really – again, like I said before, the great thing here is the content. It really is some interesting new material from J.K. Rowling that is very true to the spirit of the books and really, her old website. I mean, the clicking around and exploring, finding new secrets. I mean, that’s very old-school JKRowling.com.

Micah: One question I would have about Pottermore would be – the people who are experiencing this in the Beta version right now – obviously changes are going to be made when the site officially launches, but is there going to be anything new and unique about the site launching in October that the Beta users aren’t going to get right now?

Andrew: I don’t think so. I mean, I don’t know that for a fact, but I think everything here is pretty complete. I know people have been complaining about the Potions a lot. It’s a very cumbersome process to brew a potion, it has to be very precise, it has to be in the perfect order…

Micah: Damn Snape.

Andrew: …how you do everything…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Yeah, so there may be some minor changes, but…

Eric: So, if people are getting through this in four hours, does that mean that ñ I mean, it’s going to be three or four months between Book 1 and Book 2, right? Or is it closer to six months? Or ñ what’s going to retain the most viewers?

Andrew: Well, yeah. I mean, that’s an issue, too. It’s like you go through Pottermore, and then what? Honestly, I think once I go through everything – I do all the features, I brew a potion or two, I duel with a friend or two – I’m going to be done until the next book comes out. I don’t know what – in terms of replay value, as video gamers would call it, I don’t think there’s much here to be coming back for in five months, six months.

Eric: We’ll have to see how it grows.

Micah: Can you backtrack? Can you go to things that you’ve already experienced…

Andrew: Yes, absolutely.

Micah: …and re-read backstory, and things like that?

Andrew: Yeah. So, that’s good.

Micah: And where were you sorted?

Andrew: I was sorted into Gryffindor, which was very exciting for me because I’ve always identified myself as a Gryffindor, so I did not have any shock like Evanna Lynch did, or [laughs] countless other people, I’m sure. I was actually very excited. I screamed out loud, “Yes!”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: But to be honest with you, when I first got into Pottermore, I just wanted to get sorted. I just clicked through everything, I didn’t even read the new material.

Eric: Right, you had to go through seven chapters right? [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, and I mean, it’s kind of a lot because you have to go one by one, you can’t just skip to it. You go one by one when you’re first discovering everything, you can jump around as you please later.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: But at least in the beginning, you have to go in order.

Eric: Well, I think – the same as they do sorting, in future books, won’t it be like, “What’s your Patronus?” and “What’s ó ” wouldn’t that be really cool…

Andrew: Yeah…

Eric: …to figure out that kind of stuff?

Andrew: …definitely. Yeah, Patronus, I guess that would be – in Prisoner of Azkaban, they would add that, right?

Eric: Right. But then that’d be really cool because on your homepage or whatever it is, you could have your house colors and your Patronus could be sitting on a book. That’d be really cool.

Andrew: That’s actually a perfect idea, I see no reason why they wouldn’t do that. That’s another – that’s like the next big question after, “What house are you?”

Eric: Right.

Andrew: The next question is always, “What’s your Patronus?” Or – I mean, nobody really asks about your wand.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Nobody decides what your wand is. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, speaking of – how’s the wand process? Because I remember at that Pottermore intro at LeakyCon, they said that there were thirty-three thousand combinations of wands.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: And you get Ollivander’s backstory, which is great. Do you learn any more – a bit more about the wands?

Andrew: Yes, there’s a lot on the wands, specifically the wand woods. There’s a description – there’s at least a paragraph for every one of them and there are a ton of wands. So, people will be happy with that. I’ll tell you what my wand is, I only remember this because I took a picture of it.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I’m looking at it right now. I am fir with dragon core, twelve and a half inches, reasonably supple.

Eric: “Supple” means bendy?

Andrew: Yes, I think. And it will cost me seven Galleons.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: So…

Eric: Same as Harry’s.

Andrew: Yeah. So, it’s a cool experience. Now I’m looking forward to the Patronus.

Eric: Yeah. What’s going to be Book 2?

Micah: Well, what are you looking forward to in Chamber of Secrets then? You can’t just jump ahead one book.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Well, I don’t know. What features…

Eric: Ahhh, geez.

Andrew: What cool features could be in Chamber of Secrets? Riding the car? But this is a website, not a video game.

Eric: Well, maybe the potion is – you’re going to have to eventually brew Polyjuice, that’s why it’s so complicated now, right?

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: Because isn’t that supposed to be this complicated, month-long endeavor?

Andrew: Yeah, could be. The latest house numbers for Pottermore: there are 27,747 students, 6,500 Gryffindors, 8,100 Ravenclaws, 6,500 Hufflepuffs, and 6,500 Slytherins. I rounded.

Micah: So, it seems it’s getting closer…

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, I mean…

Micah: …to evening itself out.

Andrew: Ravenclaw has a lead of about 1,500-ish.

Micah: I was going to ask though – obviously, Andrew, you already – you always considered yourself to be in Gryffindor. Eric, what about you? I mean, stating it on the show, I’m sure we’ve done it before. But before you actually get sorted…

Eric: You know, I’m…

Andrew: Yeah, claim it now.

Eric: Claim it now? [laughs] I’m a ó I don’t know because I have those Harry Potter robes that are Gryffindor robes, but I’ve never really thought to really, really think about sorting myself, which is great. It’s a great opportunity to do Pottermore because then I’m like, “Oh okay, I’m this house,” but previously I never really identified with any house. I mean, I guess Gryffindor, right? But I just don’t know. So, I’m actually looking to Pottermore to tell me what house I’m in. I don’t really have an affiliation just yet in the books.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: I’ve always thought that I was in Ravenclaw, or I would be if I was sorted.

Eric: Yeah, I can see that.

Micah: So, it’ll be interesting. I wouldn’t mind Slytherin though either, to be honest with you.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: But I would shoot for Ravenclaw. I would tell the Sorting Hat [laughs] if I was in the book…

Andrew: Not Slytherin, not Slytherin. Not Raven ó or…

Eric: Well, apparently, the other thing about Pottermore is people can be Hatstalls, right?

Andrew: Yeah, that’s another thing she introduces in the book…

Micah: What is this?

Andrew: …where it takes – it’s this phrase called a “Hatstall” where – no, sorry, she introduces this in Pottermore, where a Hatstall is when the Sorting Hat takes more than five minutes to sort you. And I don’t know if this is related to the Hatstall, but some people who have gotten into Pottermore have been able to choose between two houses, so the Sorting Hat says, “I’m not sure which to put you in. Which would you like?”

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: Oh.

Eric: So, it’s possibly – it’s like a tie, essentially, with your sorting process.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: And I can’t imagine it happens too…

Micah: So, you do have a say then, in that sense?

Andrew: In that case.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: But that seems to be rare.

Micah: That’s cheating, isn’t it, kind of?

Eric: Oh, no.

Andrew: It kind of is.

Eric: Well, you’ve essentially gotten to the point where maybe you’re an even candidate, right? I mean, you could be – just like Harry Potter. You could be great in Slytherin, but you’re also kind of brave.

Andrew: Well, we’ll talk a lot more about Pottermore…

Eric: Yeah, once we actually get in. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, there’s still a lot more to be said. But we will – probably I guess next episode, hopefully everybody will have been inside Pottermore. We’ll find that out.

Eric: Hope so.

Andrew: What did – oh okay, we talked about that. All right, what else is going on in the news?


News: New Concept Art and Trailer for The Making of Harry Potter Studio Tour


Micah: Well, the other bit of news that we have is about The Making of Harry Potter studio tour, and some new concept art was released for it and you can find that on the website. But the big news was that tickets are going to go on sale October 13th. There was this event, I guess, called Empire Big Screen ñ is this a big event over in London? Is it an annual event?

Andrew: No, I think it’s kind of new, actually. This may have been the first one, I may be wrong but it’s not some epic event.

Micah: But Evanna Lynch was there, actually.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: She was part of this whole ñ was Warwick Davis there, too?

Andrew: Yes. Mhm.

Micah: So – and the guy who plays – what’s the goblin’s name who gets put under the Imperius Curse?

Eric: Oh. I just…

Micah: Bogrod?

Eric: Hmm, maybe.

Andrew: I think that character is played by Warwick’s wife.

Eric: No kidding!

Micah: No, no. It’s definitely a dude. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh. Well, I thought they said ñ I thought at the thing somebody said, “Oh, Warwick’s wife is playing this goblin.”

Micah: Maybe one of the others. But the one who gets the Imperius Curse – that actor was there as well, that was my point. So, there was this big revealing, I guess, or unveiling, that took place and they posted a trailer online as well. Actually, today, there was news that tickets, price-wise, are going to be about forty-six U.S. dollars.

Eric: No kidding!

Micah: To go to this tour which ñ I don’t think it’s that terrible, is it? I mean, I don’t think it prices out a lot of people.

Eric: No, it’s half the price of a sweatshirt that says, “Harry Potter: The Exhibition” at Harry Potter: The Exhibition. So…

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, I heard prices were crazy at the exhibition, by the way.

Eric: Well, so – yeah. I mean, the studio tour – now, you do have to get to London and then have to get out to…

Andrew: [laughs] Right, exactly.

Eric: [laughs] So, there is that, but I think…

Micah: Well, I’m sure there will be packages. I’m sure they’re going to put stuff together for people which includes their fare, hotel, and such.

Eric: Yeah. But the tickets are so, I think, acceptably-priced. It’s very heartwarming.

Andrew: The concept art looks great. It looks nothing like Leavesden is now…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: …which is reassuring. They’re really putting a lot of work and money into this. So, that’s really good, and if you see the concept art – I mean, it’s a huge building. Two big buildings. And so you can just imagine the sets that are going to be put in here. I mean, the Great Hall, which is what they already promised, Gryffindor Common Room, and I’m sure some other big sets. I think there was mention of the Chamber of Secrets set or the Ministry of Magic set.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: And they usually tear a lot of these down after they’re done using them just because there was only so much space in Leavesden, so they would often have to tear down a set and then reconstruct it.

Eric: Well, they learned that the hard way…

Micah: I always found that interesting, though.

Andrew: Isn’t it? Yeah, all that work and then…

Micah: The reason why is because they have money.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah. Well, and space. I mean, the cool thing is that when a movie – when you’re working on something as expensive as this, just in case something goes wrong, they have all the measurements and all the specifications of all the sets, are there. And that’s how they’re able to, years down the line, rebuild Chamber of Secrets or even Ministry of Magic, which they had to completely rebuild because it was destroyed or scratched or ñ I forget what they call it ñ at the end of Order of the Phoenix. So, if they did ever need to come back, they do just rebuild it. But it’s so cool that some of these sets are still there or are going to be there.

Andrew: The exceptions, of course, are the Great Hall, which has been there forever. Dumbledore’s office has been there forever, I’m sure that’s going to be there as well, and the Gryffindor Common Room. And like I mentioned, that also has been there forever. So, when you go onto these sets, when you visit this place, I mean, these are extremely iconic. Just all the time that was spent on these sets filming these scenes.

Eric: And the actors that have physically been there.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: And the other thing – didn’t Dumbledore’s office change at all, if it’s been there the whole time?

Andrew: I don’t think so.

Eric: I guess it hasn’t really changed.

Andrew: No.

Eric: It looks different to me but maybe that’s just…

Andrew: Well, maybe you’re thinking of when they shoot on the upper level.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: You know how he has kind of those stairs that go up?

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Maybe that’s what you’re thinking.

Eric: Yeah, I think you’re right. Yeah. So cool.

Andrew: But yeah, so it looks good and it’ll be really cool when it opens next year.

Micah: Yeah, absolutely. And last bit of news: Eric, did you want to talk about that?


News: The Woman in Black Teaser Trailer


Eric: Yeah, speaking of trailers, Dan Radcliffe’s upcoming film, The Woman in Black, which is coming out next February, there was a teaser trailer released which is really, really cool. You guys should check that out. They released it, I guess, last week, and I was really happy because I was looking to post more news and this kind of ñ I happen to “Like” The Woman in Black on Facebook and they said, “Oh, in a couple of hours there’s going to be a teaser trailer,” so I was really excited waiting for it. And I waited for it and I posted it, and almost ñ some of the first comments ñ because I always read when I post news, it doesn’t happen too often, so I sit, I wait for some comments to trickle in. And one of the first comments I got was, “This has nothing to do with Harry Potter.” That’s what somebody said. And I felt horrible, but I thought I’d ask you guys because I was thinking about this earlier today. You guys must have ñ I know you guys can relate, but…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [laughs] …one of the first people said, “This has nothing to do with Harry Potter,” and I was just ñ I was crestfallen, right? Because one of the visitors of the site who ñ they come expecting Harry Potter news and this is something about Dan Radcliffe, which I guess doesn’t have anything to do with Harry Potter, right? I mean…

Andrew: I think because it is Dan Radcliffe, it deserves to go on the site, but there’s going to come a point where you don’t need to post the fiftieth Dan Radcliffe Woman in Black interview.

Eric: [laughs] Okay.

Andrew: We don’t even post the fiftieth Deathly Hallows interview. It’s just all the same, you know?

Micah: Well, to that point, though – I mean, all the Potter sites posted about when he was ñ or he still is ñ on Broadway in How to Succeed in Business, so it’s the same thing.

Andrew: That’s true.

Micah: You’re covering the actor who has been the main star in the films over the course of their existence, so naturally you’re going to post news about and follow him at least through the next few years of his career.

Eric: I thought so, but I did want to bring that up because I think moving forward when we get these informations on the other actors and their projects, it’s just – I wondered if that kind of reaction was popular.

Micah: Well, I think people have a general interest though in let’s say, what Dan Radcliffe, Emma Watson, and Rupert Grint are going to do for the next few years and maybe some even beyond that. And there are sites that are out there that are strictly dedicated to them…

Eric: Right.

Micah: …but they played such a large role in shaping Harry Potter on the movie side that I think it’s only right that there are some stories about what they’re doing in their careers. But normally when I post a news story the first comment that I see is, “First!”

Andrew: First.

Eric: Yeah, first.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: [laughs] Well, I think that – yeah, and we can go in and remove that, but then somebody else will just say, “First!” So… [laughs]

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: …it’s kind of…

Micah: But it was a really scary trailer…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah:[laughs] to be honest with you.

Eric: Yeah, it was.

Micah: It kind of creeped me out a bit.

Eric: It was. Well I guess that’s the benefit of having friends and of having podcasts because we can call – you guys can defend me. But [laughs] I thought the trailer was really cool.

Andrew: So, that’s it for the news this week. Now we’re going to get into e-mails – and something I actually forgot to tease at the beginning of the show is, Micah, you did an interview with two more Potter stars!

Micah: Yeah, they’re just…

Andrew: Tell us about it.

Micah: After everybody heard all these other interviews that we’ve been doing, now it’s just non-stop.

Andrew: Everybody wants to talk to Micah.

Micah: Every – no. Well…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: What? No, but we got a chance to sit down and talk with Will Dunn and Arthur Bowen who play James Sirius and Albus Severus respectively in the Potter films – or not in the films, [laughs] in Deathly Hallows: Part 2, in the epilogue. And it was really a lot of fun getting a chance to talk with them, their experience with the Potter series. And kind of coming full circle a bit, playing the kids of the kids that we saw ten years ago.

Eric: Yeah, I’ve heard the interview and I think one of the coolest parts of it was Arthur Bowen, who said that they were filming the epilogue pretty much – or no, he was born about a week or two after filming began on the first Harry Potter film, or after Dan Radcliffe was first cast, I think he said. So, that was really odd in a really cool way.

Micah: Yeah, I think it was Will who was talking about how Ryan Turner, who plays Hugo Weasley, who is the youngest of their group, he was born just about the time that Dan and Emma were both cast in Sorcerer’s Stone.

Eric: [laughs] That’s so cool.


Muggle Mail: Essential Harry Potter Chapters


Andrew: Let’s move on now to e-mails, but first we should mention that we will get back to Chapter-by-Chapter. This episode kind of snuck up on us so…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …we didn’t have time to prepare it, but next time! Hopefully. Okay, first e-mail is actually from one of the MuggleNet staff members, Kat. She does the great “Fan of the Week” column on MuggleNet, and if you want to check that out, you can submit your own “Fan of the Week” profile and then it may be – you may be the Fan of the Week one time.

Eric: I’ll tell you, that’s how I got my start at MuggleNet, was being a Fan of the Week.

Andrew: Hmm, interesting.

Eric: So, it’s – good things happen! [laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] So, Kat said:

“I ran into an old co-worker and a friend of mine at the grocery store tonight, and we started talking about ‘Deathly Hallows: Part 2’. He’s not a book reader but is an avid fan of the movies. He had quite a few questions and while filling him in, I told him that he should just read the books! He said there was no way he was reading the books, but he might read a chapter or two just to get to the integral parts. So, I was thinking it might be a good conversation to figure out what chapters everyone would suggest to a friend such as mine. Everyone has favorites, of course, but what’s the most important? Would be…”

I don’t know what she means there. Oh, you guys would have…

“…diverse opinions, I imagine. Just a thought! Looking forward to the show.”

So, thank you, Kat for that suggestion. I think it’s a good idea. So, if you were to suggest a chapter…

Eric: Like the…

Andrew: …for somebody to read…

Eric: …essential Harry Potter chapter for some…

Andrew: I think it would have to be in Sorcerer’s Stone because otherwise you’re going to need some context.

Eric: Well, but this person has seen the movies and hasn’t read the books, so I think Kat’s question – isn’t it about if you’ve only seen the movies and aren’t planning on reading all of the books, what book chapter should you read to kind of get what you missed?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Or…

Andrew: Or just to understand why reading it is so great…

Eric: So much better.

Andrew: …maybe.

Eric: Yeah. But…

Andrew: I would suggest one of the chapters from either Order of the Phoenix or Half-Blood Prince where Dumbledore and Harry are kind of having one of those discussions about Harry’s purpose and what Dumbledore needs him to do. I think that would be really interesting for somebody to read.

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: I…

Micah: I think a lot of it, too, might be from Half-Blood Prince, taking a couple of chapters out of there because – and reading them because I think that so much was lost in the memories and them not doing that many of them in the movie. And I think it provided a lot of context for where they were going and what they were doing in Deathly Hallows, especially Part 2, because you’re having the hunt go on for the Horcruxes so rapidly, going from the vault to Hogwarts, to destroy the diadem, to destroy the snake, and then – I just feel like if there were those memories that were in Half-Blood Prince where you’re talking about the meeting with Hepzibah Smith, that was completely cut out.

Eric: And that was a really good scene in the books, and I love the Gaunt House when they visit the…

Micah: Right.

Eric: I guess he visits the Gaunts maybe more than once even. That is an incredible scene from Half-Blood Prince, the book. So, absolutely…

Micah: Right, it really kind of lays out Harry’s journey more than what the movies do.

Eric: And I mean – yeah, and that actually would help clarify sort of the plot of what’s going on in that way. And when I think of answering this question, I wanted to say “Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs” from Prisoner of Azkaban, that chapter where we learn about Harry’s dad, and Sirius and Remus being old school friends. And Lupin just tells that story of how coming to Hogwarts, Dumbledore made all these arrangements for him and it was really a great story. And then in Order of the Phoenix, there is “Snape’s Worst Memory” which is a fifteen-second clip in the film but it really raised some important questions and things that Harry had to deal with as his character, dealing with whether or not Snape was right about James and what to do about it.

Micah: Yeah, I think – obviously different chapters from different books would provide better insight into how certain things play themselves out.

Andrew: Mhm. All right, good opinions all around.

Micah: But people, send…

Andrew: Micah…

Micah: …stuff in, right? I mean, listeners, tell us! What – give us specific chapters. That’s your homework.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Micah, next e-mail.


Muggle Mail: Scenes That Should’ve Been in the Movie


Micah: The next e-mail comes from Sara, 24, of San Diego, California, and she says:

“At the end of Episode 237 you asked what you wished had been in the movie but wasn’t. I agree with whoever said I wish Harry had mended his phoenix wand, but another thing I really wish had been added was a part when Harry and Voldemort are fighting their end battle. In the book, Harry tells Voldemort that Snape was never on his side and that he was on Dumbledore’s side all along. I felt like it was such an amazing slap in the face to Voldemort and I really missed that in the movie. Couldn’t help adding my thoughts on that one. Thanks for the show, I love listening to you guys!”

Eric: That reminds me of – in the film, Voldemort almost apologizes to Snape before he kills him, right? He says, “Only I can live forever. I’m sorry, Severus,” and then kills him, whereas in the book it’s like, “You’re betraying me because the Elder Wand has your allegiance.” So, it’s almost like it’s a different relationship almost in that way. What do you guys think?

Micah: And, “Only I can live forever,” – I mean, Snape was not trying to be immortal [laughs] so I didn’t really understand the context of that line…

Eric: Yeah…

Micah: …saying…

Eric: …what was…

Micah: …Snape…

Eric: Yeah, it was…

Micah: Snape was not trying to…

Eric: It was like sympathy, though. It was sympathy because he was about to die, but it was almost like a mercy kill at the same time. It was like – Voldemort was like, sorry, Severus. You kind of have to go now. [laughs] Time to go! Only I can [laughs] live forever.

Andrew: Next e-mail – or yeah. Go ahead, Eric. Next e-mail.


Muggle Mail: Infamous Scream from Deathly Hallows: Part 2 Trailer


Eric: Danny, 15, from Illinois says:

“I was watching ‘Part 1’ the other day and found the source of the infamous ‘Nyaaaaah!’ scream complained about in the ‘Part 2’ trailer. The scream is actually in ‘Part 1’ after Harry’s and Voldemort’s wands connect in the Seven Harrys chase sequence. You hear the scream after the connection breaks and it’s somewhat drowned out as he fades into the distance.”

Oh. Yeah, I’ve heard that before. I think I actually went and watched Part 1, and it sounded different to me. But I’ve also heard that it’s actually at the end of the Order of the Phoenix when the big ball of fire becomes the big ball of water, but that was just a theory I’ve heard that – people have tried to place this scream because as we all know, it appeared like eleven times in the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 trailer. But…

Micah: But thankfully not in the movie.

Eric: Yeah, thankfully not the movie. It’s not in the movie, so thanks for that.

MuggleCast 238 Transcript (continued)


Muggle Mail: S.P.E.W. – Society of the Pottermore E-mail Waiters


Andrew: Next e-mail is from Jello, 14:

“Hello guys. Urgh, waiting for Pottermore e-mail is starting to feel annoying. I am officially a member of S.P.E.W. – Society of the Pottermore E-mail Waiters. Haha, saw that from Facebook. Can’t wait for the new episode!”

Eric: Oh, I see what she did there. [laughs]

Andrew: I included that because that was funny.

Eric: Yeah. [laughs]

Andrew: You two are in that, too. In S.P.E.W.

Eric: Yes.

Micah: Yeah, still waiting for that e-mail. I thought at least I could get it on my birthday [laughs] last week, but that didn’t work out.

Andrew: Awww, sorry.

Micah: Awww. You want me to take the next e-mail?

Andrew: Well, you get the next e-mail, at least.

Micah: Yeah, what a consolation.

[Andrew laughs]


Muggle Mail: Epilogue Suggestions


Micah: Next e-mail is from Claire, 12, of California. She says:

“Hi MuggleCast! I’m a big fan of your show like everyone else, and this e-mail is in response to Episode 237. You asked if there was anything in the seventh book that we wish was in the movie.”

I keep getting these e-mails.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: [continues]

“My answer is the very last bit of the epilogue where it says, ‘The scar had not pained Harry for nineteen years. All was well.’ This was one of the parts of the book that you remember that’s just stuck in your brain forever. And it’s not just because it’s the last line of the books that made the author one of the most famous writers ever. Rowling has the gift of turning something so plain and ordinary as ‘The end’ into something beautiful and enchanting. I think they could have done this effect by having Harry look a bit worried as he watches the train leave the station, Ginny tells him that their kids will be fine, then Harry would tell her that his scar hadn’t hurt for nineteen years. All is well. Thanks for reading, Claire.”

Eric: Hmm. So, turning “all was well” into dialogue as the closing line of the film. What do you guys think?

Andrew: That would have been kind of nice, but it had potential to get really cheesy, I think.

Eric: I think in the epilogue they were so worried about getting the makeup right, too, that they’re just like, “Oh yeah, we’re going to be minimalist with the dialogue here.” But it was…

Micah: Well…

Eric: It was a nice…

Micah: …keep in line – keep in line. [laughs] Yeah, you keep in line!

Eric: [laughs] Oh, geez.

Micah: No, keep in mind that the epilogue was shot twice, so it was shot once in the station and then it was shot at Leavesden Studios. And there are things, as Will and Arthur talk about in the interview, that were changed…

Eric: Yes.

Micah: …because of the location change. So, there was actually more dialogue in the first one. And there was actually another character in the first one that [laughs] didn’t make it into the second one. And so I’m sure that maybe they played around with this idea. I mean, Andrew, was it you who said that they shot something, like four different endings for the Malfoys?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Micah: So, it is possible that they did shoot a number of different endings to the movie.

Andrew: Mhm. Just decided what – I think in this case silence kind of worked best.

Micah: Well, it did because you had that same John Williams song playing as it did when the first movie ended.

Andrew: Yeah. And by the way, you gathered “all was well” without them saying it. I mean, in the scene…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: …all was well, so any reader probably thought it in their heads. “All was well.” Clearly all was well here. [laughs]

Eric: Interesting.

Andrew: You know?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So, it could have been like sort of…

Eric: That’s a good point.

Andrew: …silent acknowledgement.

Eric: That’s a good point.

Andrew: Mhm.


Muggle Mail: Listening to MuggleCast While Hunting Blackberries


Eric: Next e-mail comes from Mandy, 24, from California.

“Hey MuggleCasters, this is Mandy. I’ve been with you guys from the beginning and I love the show! I was at my fiance’s house the other day when he decided it was time for us to pick the last of his blackberry bushes and trim them back. On my way outside, I suddenly remembered Andrew saying, ‘If anyone listens to us while they hunt blackberries, let us know.’ So, I ran to my car and grabbed my iPod so I could listen while hunting blackberries. Just thought you’d want to know! Thanks for reading, and again, I absolutely love and look forward to the show. Mandy.”

Andrew: Excellent. Thank you, Mandy.

Micah: Any other requests this week, Andrew?

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: No, but actually on MuggleCast Twitter, somebody said, “Hey look, we’re in a blackberry field while listening to MuggleCast,” and this person included a picture of blackberries.

[Eric laughs]


Muggle Mail: Pottermore Review


Andrew: So, it’s been a good success, my request. Next e-mail comes from Pablo Ruiz, 18, of Colombia:

“I suppose you guys want reviews from us lucky users that are already inside Pottermore. Here’s mine: Jo never disappoints. The extra material she has provided is extremely interesting, especially all we learn about wandlore and it is a lot. The images on the site are amazing, too. As a companion to the book, I found it extremely useful and it does add to the experience. However, I have some complaints. First of all, brewing potions is really hard. One little mistake and you got it wrong. That’s not too bad, it’s realistic. But after waiting one-hundred minutes and doing everything right, you get five points. If you just enter potion-making and you click your wand right away, they give you one point for trying. It’s ridiculous! And I think they’re so scared for children that they didn’t realize there’s absolutely no way to interact with other people. You can be friends and give gifts to each other, but you can’t comment on other posts, send messages to other people, etc. To summarize, you can’t make friends through Pottermore, and what we all love from being part of the ‘Potter’ fandom is how easy it is to make friends based only in the series. But here you are, the first official Jo/’Potter’ site and no way of making friends.”

Eric: Awww.

Andrew: [continues]

“I know this is long but I hope you can use it. Pickles!”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Says Pablo.

Eric: So…

Andrew: It is a valid concern. You can’t really interact with people. You can challenge them to a duel but you can’t talk.

Eric: So, J.K. Rowling hates friendship. That’s what we learned.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Well, what do you guys think about, as far as what we’re going to do, reviewing content? Are we going to wait until all of us get in? Are we going to wait until the site officially opens up to everyone…

Andrew: Mmm, good question.

Micah: …to start talking a little bit about the content that’s provided?

Eric: Well, it’s too late to start talking about it. Well, I mean, I guess if we’re talking about specific content, like doing a review of the content?

Micah: Right.

Eric: Okay. Yeah, I don’t know.

Micah: Yeah – no, I would think – and listeners can feel free to e-mail us, but I would think that they would want to be in it themselves and utilizing it…

Andrew: True.

Micah: …before we talk about it.

Andrew: Yeah. So, we could still do reviews, but we won’t start discussing the specifics.

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: The specific new information…

Eric: Makes sense to me.

Andrew: …that Jo reveals.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: All right, so that’s it for e-mails. Now it’s time for Micah, your interview with Will Dunn, who plays James Sirius Potter, and Arthur Bowen, who plays Albus Severus Potter!


Interview: Will Dunn and Arthur Bowen


Micah: All right, we are now joined by Will Dunn and Arthur Bowen, who play James Sirius and Albus Severus respectively in Deathly Hallows: Part 2. Guys, how are you doing?

Will Dunn: Yeah, we’re good, thanks.

Arthur Bowen: We’re good, thanks. How are you?

Micah: Doing well, doing well. And I know it’s been, I guess, a month now, but you guys were recently down in Orlando for LeakyCon 2011. What was that experience like for you guys, kind of being immersed into the fandom and kind of getting an experience for what it’s all like? I know you were at the premiere in London just before that, but actually walking amongst all the other fans and kind of experiencing that for the first time.

Will: It was awesome. I mean, it was really weird because we’d never really experienced anything like that before, and then we came in and there were all these thousands of screaming fans at the opening of it, and it was just really – it was, I guess, an insight into how crazy the world of Potter can be.

Arthur: Yeah, exactly. What Will said, it just opened up a new world of how the people – the fans of Harry Potter are really mental.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: But mental in a good way though, right?

Will: Yeah, in a good way, of course.

Arthur: Yeah, in a good way.

Micah: So, was this your first trip, though, over to the United States? Had you been here before?

Arthur: Yeah…

Will: No, I hadn’t.

Arthur: No, I hadn’t, yeah.

Will: We hadn’t, no. It’s our first one, and it was great. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah, it was fun.

Micah: And you got a chance to go to the theme park, to the Wizarding World. What was it like comparing your time at Leavesden versus actually walking into the theme park for the first time?

Will: Well, of course at Leavesden there’s all the scaffolding, isn’t there?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: So, it’s kind of – it was more real, but of course it was so hot because we went there at night, and it was so hot so that was a little bit…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will:[laughs] of a downer, I guess. But yeah, it was amazing because obviously it’s real as they make them, they’re not entirely real, whereas this felt so much more real because it was sort of the full thing, I guess.

Arthur: Yeah, exactly. That’s pretty much what I was going to say.

Micah: What was your favorite part about the park? I mean, I guess ride-wise. Did you go on all the rides, or did you only go on a few? Which one did you like the most?

Arthur: Well, I went on all the Harry Potter world rides, so I guess my favorite was the red Chinese dragon, that was really cool.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Will: Yeah, they were pretty crazy. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah, it was really quick.

Micah: Yeah. Did you get a chance to go on the Forbidden Journey inside the castle?

Arthur: Yeah, I did, but that made me feel really sick.

Will: Yeah, he’d been on all the rides and…

[Micah laughs]

Will: …those ones are bad enough. And then he went on this one and it’s all motion-y…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …instead of being a proper roller coaster, so he came back and he practically collapsed…

Arthur: Yeah, I felt so bad.

Will: …at the Leaky Cauldron, which was a little worrying. [laughs]

Arthur: [laughs] Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, I had a hard time on the Flight of the Hippogriff, actually. I thought that that was a little bit more scarier than the actual Forbidden Journey, but I don’t know. That might just say that I’m not a roller coaster person.

Will: I think the spiders freak you out as well, don’t they?

Arthur: Yeah. Was the Hippogriff one the one which you had like no safety in it? Because in the dragon one you had like…

Micah: Yeah, yeah, exactly. The one by Hagrid’s hut.

Arthur: Oh yeah, that’s it.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: Now did you – you explored around the rest of the Wizarding World, I’m guessing. Did you go into Ollivander’s?

Arthur: Yeah, we did.

Will: Yes, we did.

Arthur: Yeah, and they like did all these effects and ringing bells…

Will: Whooshing and stuff like that! [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah, all that stuff.

Will: Yeah, which was great.

Arthur: Yeah, it was.

Micah: And did you go over and eat in the Three Broomsticks? Did you have Butterbeers? So, you guys got the full experience, then.

Will: Arthur attempted, but of course the only time we went there was…

Arthur: Yeah, was after I was feeling really ill, so I didn’t have a Butterbeer.

Will: Unfortunately. But it was very nice, very nice stuff! [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Very sweet.

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: You did – I guess you probably saw a lot of the other parks and things like that when you were down there. Is there anything comparable to that, I guess, over in England?

Will: No. Well, there’s Alton Towers and Thorpe Park, I guess.

Arthur: Thorpe Park, I guess, some of the rides are pretty good.

Will: There’s some pretty intense ones there, but…

Arthur: But yeah, altogether, all the theme parks…

Will: Nothing that’s based on something and it’s so realistic, I think.

Arthur: Yeah, yeah.

Will: Like, we don’t have anything like that in England, I don’t think.

Arthur: Yeah, and the rides are probably better.

Will: Yeah. [laughs]

Micah: Overall though, I mean, what was your favorite part of the convention? Or was it just being down there and getting to experience all this for the first time?

Arthur: Well, it was that and also the ball at the end.

Will: Which I couldn’t go to! I had to fly home early. That was horrible. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah, that was really fun.

Micah: Nice. No, I did as well. I flew home, I think, Saturday evening, so I missed out on that. So, Arthur, you were the only one there. I mean…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: It was good.

Will: He was the only one representing the three of us, but…

[Everyone laughs]

Will: Yeah. But the Q&As for me were awesome, I loved the Q&As.

Arthur: Yeah, the Q&As.

Will: And when we walked out that was really funny, when it’s “young Arthur Bowen,” everyone starts screaming!

[Everyone laughs]

Arthur: And also me and Will’s banter.

Will: Oh yes, the banter. I took the mick out of you a little bit too much then, didn’t I?

Arthur: Yeah, but then I got my revenge.

Will: He did.

Arthur: So…

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: Did you get tough questions? I mean, were they – did the fans really challenge you guys, or was there nothing that you guys couldn’t answer?

Will: There was a question about the shipping, about which – do you ship your characters’ parents?

[Micah laughs]

Arthur: Oh yeah.

Will: Which everybody sort of froze a bit at and I sort of said, “Can we not go into the Draco/Harry thing?” Because I really didn’t want to go into that.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: But yeah, I think that one for me was pretty…

Arthur: But the thing is…

Will: …odd. [laughs]

Arthur: …for some of the questions, I’m not being rude, but it was sort of the same answer for everyone…

Will: Yes!

Arthur: …so it was a bit awkward.

Will: Yeah, it was a little…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Well, it was quite funny by the end…

Arthur: Because you sort of had to say…

Will: …because everyone says…

Arthur: …”Yeah, basically the same.” [laughs]

Will: …”Yes, it was amazing!” [laughs]

Arthur: Yes, it was amazing…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: …when we did that.

Micah: Yeah. All right. Well, I want to kind of shift it to talk a little bit about the movie, Deathly Hallows: Part 2. The epilogue scene had to be shot twice, right?

Will: It did, yeah.

Arthur: Yeah, it did.

Micah: And – I mean, what was the decision behind that? I mean, do you guys know why they decided to – because once it was in the actual station, and then it was moved to Leavesden, right?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah. Well, it was ridiculously busy at King’s Cross…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …or something.

Arthur: Yeah, and also I thought…

Will: The makeup.

Arthur: Yeah, the makeup and…

Will: The makeup was…

Arthur: And they looked too – like Dan and Rupert, they looked too old.

Will: Yeah, I think the girls looked okay.

Arthur: Yeah, and they didn’t like the script.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: I think they didn’t, but I don’t know.

Will: Yeah, I think he wanted to focus more on you, didn’t he?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: He wanted to focus more on Albus’s story of going to Hogwarts for the first time…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: … so they changed things around a bit. Yeah, I think that’s – and also the makeup because the makeup was…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: I mean, it was…

Arthur: It was really cool but it got over the top.

Will: Yeah, exactly.

Micah: Now was it dripping on the floor, or – I mean…

[Arthur and Will laugh]

Will: Well, that’s the funny thing. On the first day, do you remember Dan had a fan?

Arthur: Yeah, yeah.

Will: Just so it wouldn’t melt on his face…

Arthur: Yeah, yeah.

Will: …which was really funny. But yeah, it was realistic but it was too old, really.

Arthur: Yeah, it was too old. They looked like…

Will: Seventy.

Arthur: Yeah, seventy.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: What was that scene like though, Arthur? I mean, like Will pointed out, the focal point of the epilogue really went to the conversation that you were having with your father. Was that kind of an intense scene to shoot? What was that like?

Arthur: Well, yeah, I guess it was a bit. It was pretty intense and I had quite a lot of pressure to get it right.

Will: You did good though, mate. [laughs]

Arthur: Thanks.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: Yeah, so it was pretty – yeah.

Will: It was – yeah, it was sort of – I remember a funny thing about that, actually. Was it that Dan didn’t know how to tie a shoelace?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And so his double had to step in just to do that little shot, which is very funny. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: Also, I had a cold in the scene…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: …and it looked like I had been crying…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: …which had quite a good effect. [laughs]

Will: Yeah, we all had terrible colds that week, so…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: Oh, so what was it, probably in the middle of the winter some time? Or…

Arthur and

Will:

Yeah, yeah it was.

Arthur: It was like just before Christmas.

Will: It was really snowy at Leavesden, actually. It was ridiculous.

Arthur: Yeah, it was.

Will: Yeah, so it was very snowy, so we easily got colds. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: I know that many listeners have asked about Teddy Lupin and according to a lot of reports that the websites got, he was cast in the film.

Will: He was, yeah.

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: Was he in the initial epilogue you shot and then just never made it to the final…

Will: Yeah.

Micah: …cut?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: He was in the original, wasn’t he? Because I was…

Arthur: Yeah, he was with you…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: …with owls and stuff.

Will: There’s a scene – I don’t really know if I can give it away, but he basically shares a look with Dan and I’m with him – with Teddy for that bit and I think they’re putting it on the DVD extras.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: I think Luke mentioned that they’re going to put it on the DVD extras, so…

Arthur: Yeah, he’s a good actor.

Will: He’s great. He did a really good job of that, yeah. A really good job.

Micah: Cool. Now what was your favorite part of the movie aside from the epilogue? Let’s put the epilogue out of it. [laughs] What – I mean, sitting down and seeing the film, which part did you like the most?

Will: That’s a tough one.

Arthur: Ummm…

Will: Go on.

Arthur: Okay, thanks. My part was probably the bit when Voldemort dies and then he crumbles into the sky.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: I don’t know. I think that’s really cool.

Will: Yeah, that was really good. That was really cool in 3D, wasn’t it?

Arthur: Yeah, it was.

Will: I don’t know.

Arthur: That was a really good bit.

Will: I love the general epicness of the whole movie. There was a bit when they’re all setting up the defenses and that was…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And the music. The music was so good. He did a great job, Alexandre Desplat. But yeah, I just think the bit when they’re sort of putting up the defenses because it’s just ridiculously epic, and the fight between Harry and Voldemort. That’s really good.

Arthur: Yeah. Yeah, that was really good.

Will: That’s really good.

Micah: Cool. Well – I mean, who did – I don’t know if that’s – I was going to say, who did you enjoy working with the most? But I don’t know if you’re – you’re probably not allowed to play favorites in that sense, are you?

[Arthur and Will laugh]

Will: Yeah, I don’t know. Well, Dan was a laugh, wasn’t he?

Arthur: Yeah, they were all really nice.

Will: They were. They were really welcoming, all of them.

Arthur: But I probably spent most of my time with Dan…

Will: Yeah, we all did.

Arthur: …because he is my dad in that sense.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: So, I had most of the scenes with him.

Will: Yeah, we had a lot.

Arthur: But they were all really nice.

Will: They were all great, they were all fantastic.

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: Now, what did you think about Deathly Hallows passing the one billion dollar mark? I mean, it’s moved passed Star Wars.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: It’s the highest grossing franchise of all time. All these records are being shattered, and it’s pretty impressive. One billion dollars is a lot of money, and it’s still going on. So, what do you guys think of all that?

Will: It’s ridiculous. I mean, I guess it’s sort of to be expected because it is such a huge franchise.

Arthur: Yeah, exactly.

Will: But it was absolutely amazing, the fact that they’ve got – it’s just a ridiculous amount of money, isn’t it? It’s like with football players – or soccer players. It’s like when soccer players get sold or bought they go for ridiculous amounts of money, but this is like…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …hundreds of times…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …multiplied by that, so it’s just really kind of mind blowing.

Arthur: Yeah, it’s like..

Will: And to be involved in that as well.

Arthur: …amazing. Yeah, exactly, to be involved in that.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, so how much of that do you guys get? Like 400, 500 million? I mean…

[Arthur and Will laugh]

Will: Yeah, something like that.

Micah: [laughs] You’re already looking at all the mansions and the cars, and everything that you’re going to…

Will: Absolutely. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: Now, you guys are both pretty active on Twitter.

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: What do you like about it? Is it the ability to interact with your fans? The ability to interact with the cast? Is it kind of a combination of all that?

Arthur: Yeah, I would say it’s a combination.

Will: Yeah, it’s a combination because obviously we can keep in touch via other ways, but…

Arthur: Yeah, exactly.

Will: …there’s always loads of people that are really keen to talk, and so it’s cool to chat to all of them and you get the really crazy ones that say, “Reply me! Reply me!”

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And then you get the ones that ask really good questions and…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …we can all join in with some banter and just stuff like that.

Arthur: Yeah, it’s fun.

Will: It’s great.

Arthur: It’s so much fun.

Will: Really enjoy it, yeah.

Micah: And as far as the other cast members, you guys seem to be pretty close with the…

Arthur and

Will:

Yeah.

Micah: It seems like some of the epilogue actors and actresses, you guys stay in pretty close touch with, and then also some of the other actors and actresses that are on Twitter from the series as a whole.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: It’s really me, you – it’s just all the epilogue kids…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …the flashback kids.

Arthur: I would say mostly me and Will stuck together.

Will: Yeah, we’re tight. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah, we’re tight.

Will: And then you’ve got Evanna and Scarlett – Scarlett Byrne, Chris Rankin…

Arthur: They are all really nice, and then you’ve got Ryan…

Will: Ryan of course, yeah.

Arthur: …and Benedict…

Will: Benedict.

Arthur: …and Bertie.

Will: And Bertie.

Arthur: He’s so funny.

Will: With his fantastic videos. Yeah, so we’re all really – I think we’re all really close, especially – I think Florida, because we were all staying in houses with each other and we all got quite a lot closer.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah, it was – yeah, we’re all very good friends now. Yeah.

Micah: Cool! Now, are you guys excited for Pottermore?

Will: Yes.

Arthur: Well, I don’t – to be honest, I don’t really know anything about it, so…

Will: Yeah. [laughs] It’s basically like a fan – sort of an interactive book, fan experience, isn’t it, really?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah, I’m really – I’ve got my e-mail, I’m going to be on it, which is fantastic. Yeah, I’m just really looking forward to seeing what it’s like because there’s been so much speculation

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And there’s been a few people that are on but I haven’t really seen much of that because I want to just sort of take it in when I get it. But yeah, I’m just really looking forward to checking it out and seeing what J.K. Rowling has got up her sleeve next. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah, it seems like – they did a panel on it at LeakyCon where they kind of gave a look into it so you could see what you could expect and now it just seems as if everybody is waiting for that letter, that early access to get into Pottermore.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah, I think for the people that have got in, it’s just fantastic because they will be ridiculously excited about that.

Arthur: Yeah, they were.

Will: But obviously the people that haven’t are just like, “No!”

Micah: [laughs] It’s frustrating, right?

Will: It is.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And also – they got easier, but the clues at the beginning were actually quite hard.

Arthur: Yeah, I don’t what we’re on about it, but okay, yeah.

Will: There were these clues at the beginning that you could get so you could get your username.

Arthur: What? [laughs]

Will: But they got easier, so there was only a couple that were actually tricky. But yeah, I’m still one of the people that haven’t got it. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

MuggleCast 238 Transcript (continued)


Interview: Will Dunn and Arthur Bowen (continued)


Micah: All right. Well, the next set of questions that I have are just really quick, rapid-fire questions. Both of you guys can answer this. What were your favorite books in the series? Or favorite book, sorry.

Arthur: Well, I haven’t read any of the books.

[Will groans]

Arthur: This is because…

Will: This was said at LeakyCon! [laughs]

Arthur: This was said at LeakyCon.

Micah: Do you want me to edit this out? Is that… [laughs]

Will: No, no.

Arthur: It’s fine.

Will: It’s fine. [laughs]

Arthur: It was said at LeakyCon. It was just that I’m not really…

Will: Voldemort scared him, basically.

Arthur: Yeah, basically, Voldemort scared me when I was really young and it just put me off the whole thing.

Will: It put him off the whole series. You saw the first film, didn’t you?

Arthur: Yeah, I saw the first film and then I saw Voldemort creeping into the house…

Will: Back of the head, yeah.

Arthur: Yeah, with his wand, and it just really scared me and…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: …it gave me nightmares. So…

Will: And so he’s just reluctant now.

Arthur: …that’s why I haven’t really…

Will: So, he is a fan, but he’s a reluctant fan…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …kind of thing.

Arthur: I mean, it’s great, it’s a really good book.

Micah: Speaking of that, though, I was going to ask you, is it weird knowing that right about the time you were born was about the time [laughs] that Dan was being cast as Harry?

Will: [laughs] Yes!

Arthur: That’s weird.

Will: Yeah, it’s almost exactly with Ryan because Ryan’s one of the youngest of us…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …and it’s almost exactly with him. He was born, I don’t know, a month or two sort of after or before Dan, Rupert, and Emma were first cast.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: So, I just think that’s ridiculous how long it’s lasted and how it’s come sort of full circle, I guess.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: It’s awesome, yeah.

Micah: And what about for you, Will? Favorite book?

Will: It would be – that’s tricky because I really like either the first or the seventh, probably, which isn’t a proper answer. [laughs] But honestly, that’s – seventh, just because it’s a great ending. [laughs]

Micah: And what about movie? Putting aside Deathly Hallows: Part 2.

Will: Ummm, Prisoner of Azkaban or the first.

[Micah and Will laugh]

Will: I keep doing two!

Arthur: Yeah, probably the same, Prisoner of Azkaban.

[Phone rings]

Arthur: It’s pretty good. That’s Will’s phone. [laughs]

Will: That’s my phone, sorry.

Micah: No problem, no problem. What about favorite character?

Will: Sirius, for me. I love Sirius.

Arthur: Mine’s probably Snape because he’s such a good… [unintelligible]

Will: Snape? Ben’s going to love that when he listens to this. Yeah, hi Ben!

Arthur: Yeah. [laughs]

Will: You like Snape! Woo! [laughs]

Micah: So – well, speaking of Snape, what did you guys think of how Alan Rickman portrayed him, specifically in that last film?

Will: Oh, he was amazing.

Arthur: Yeah, he was really good.

Will: That’s the best I’ve seen him. He was just…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: The bit when he saw Lily dead was just like…

Arthur: Yeah, that was really good.

Will: …oh! He was so good. I mean, he deserves nominations at least for that…

Arthur: Yeah, he does.

Will: …because he was just fantastic. Yeah.

Micah: Now you guys were in that IMAX showing, too, right? Down in Orlando. So, you were – having seen the movie before, were you anticipating all of those sobs, all the crying that went on?

Arthur: Well, we didn’t…

Will: Probably. I mean, I think…

Arthur: Probably, yeah.

Will: …you could imagine…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: …that there are such crazy fans. I think we had already experienced that they were so…

Arthur: Yeah, at the premiere, but then it was like a bit more than we expected.

Will: Yeah. [laughs] Yeah, definitely.

Arthur: Yeah, because they’re…

Will: Very emotional.

Arthur: Yeah, they were.

Will: Yeah, they were.

Micah: And what was the premiere like? I brought it up before, but I don’t think I ever asked you. Getting to Trafalgar Square it was, right? And seeing just the – I think David Yates had said that they found out later there was something like thirty thousand people there.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah, it was ridiculous.

Arthur: Yeah, it was.

Will: We’ve got this one story, haven’t we, of where we…

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: There was the three of us, and we were just walking this…

Arthur: Me, Will, and Helena.

Will: Me, Will, and Helena – me, Arthur and Helena. [laughs]

Arthur: [laughs] Yeah.

Will: But yeah, we walked down – there was just this little sort of, I don’t know, side-road or something…

Arthur: Yeah, or like a…

Will: …where there was like a sort of – all the fans had gathered around the edges of that with barriers and all of that, and we – the three of us just walked down – started walking down this road, and everyone saw us and started screaming, [laughs] didn’t they?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: So, that was just absolutely crazy to experience that.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: And we’re probably – we’d be very lucky to experience that again because it was just really, really surreal.

Arthur: Yeah, it was.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: And what about your favorite spell?

Will: Oh, there’s so many! I don’t know. Oh, I don’t know, that’s really hard! What do you think?

Arthur: Wingardium Leviosa.

Will: [laughs] Wingardium Leviosa, yeah. I don’t know, Expelliarmus because Harry uses that all the time. [laughs]

Micah: Favorite creature?

Will: Oh, what are they called? The – it’s quite a girly thing to say, but I quite like the Pygmy Puffs. They’re quite groovy little things. We got little baskets, didn’t we?

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: From LeakyCon.

Arthur: Yeah, with the…

Will: With little Pygmy – we had little Pygmy Puffs, [laughs] which was quite cool.

Arthur: Mine is definitely like a troll because they’re the coolest things.

[Micah and Will laugh]

Will: With the whole snot thing.

Arthur: Yeah.

[Will laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: That’s pretty cool.

[Will laughs]

Micah: And if you could have one of the Deathly Hallows, which one would it be?

Arthur: Cloak of Invisibility.

Will: Yeah, I’d go the same. Yeah, I think…

Micah: And what would you guys use that for? A bunch of mischief, I would assume?

Arthur and

Will:

Yes.

[Micah laughs]

Will: Oh, yes.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: All right. Well, really, the only other question that I had left was, what are your guys’ future plans? Are you still going to look to continue to act? Do you have other hobbies that you’re involved with?

Arthur: Well, yeah. Hopefully I’m going to get an agent so I can do a bit more acting and…

Will: Yeah.

Arthur: Good news for Will.

Will: Yeah, I got one. [laughs]

Micah: Oh!

Will: An agent.

Arthur: Yeah, he’s got an agent.

Micah: Congratulations.

Will: Thank you very much. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: So, hopefully that’s going to give me some new pathways. But yeah, I just want to continue acting, continue just getting experience, I guess.

Arthur: Yeah, because it was…

Will: It was an amazing experience to be on Potter, but yeah, definitely want to keep on acting.

Arthur: Yeah, it probably isn’t going to be the same as that.

Will: No.

Arthur: But it was…

Will: Yeah, Potter was a ridiculous, ridiculous thing. [laughs]

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: And what have you guys been doing since ñ I guess since Leaky, but also really since the movie came out? Just kind of relaxing? Gearing up for school?

Will: Oh yeah, chilling out.

Arthur: Well, yeah, because I had my Common Entrance before…

Will: Had exams to get into school.

Arthur: Before the movie came out. Well, after the movie, I just started relaxing…

Will: Oh yeah.

Arthur: …and just hanging out with people.

Will: Slobbing out.

Arthur: Yeah…

Will: That’s how we do it. [laughs]

Arthur: …exactly.

Will: Yeah.

Micah: All right. Well, I appreciate you guys coming on the show, and if listeners want to follow you both on Twitter, where can they find you?

Arthur: I’m abowen1998.

Will: And I’m WillDunn_ then you’ve got an underscore after that because somebody else took the whole WillDunn without the underscore.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: Yeah, you got the little underscore there at the end, people have got to remember that. But what we can do, also, is ó once we release the show, put both of your – both of those Twitter handles out for people and post it in the show notes as well. But really, guys, thanks so much for coming on, and you’re welcome to come back any time.

Will: Yeah. No, thanks. It’s been great.

Arthur: Thanks very much.

Will: Cheers for having us, Micah.

Micah: All right.

Will: All right.

Micah: All right, so we’ll edit that, and ñ I’m not exactly sure when the show will be released, but I can definitely shoot you guys a note and let you know.

Arthur: Okay, cool.

Will: Well, if you just DM me…

Micah: Yeah, yeah. And Arthur, you said you’re on Twitter as well?

Will: Yeah, I’ll let Arthur know.

Arthur: Yeah, just tell Will…

Will: In fact, I’ll give Arthur your account name so he can follow you so you can DM him as well.

Micah: Yeah, yeah, definitely. But, yeah – no, guys, I really appreciate you taking the time. I know you’re busy chilling and relaxing and…

Will: Yeah, we’re chilling, we are.

[Micah and Will laugh]

Will: Yeah. No, cheers for having us in. It was really good to come on.

Arthur: Yeah, it was good.

Will: Finally. [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, yeah. No, like I said, you guys are welcome back any time and…

Will: Yeah.

Micah: …come on when it’s not such a structured interview. We can just have you on and talk about the series, although, Arthur, you haven’t read it, so I don’t know!

[Everyone laughs]

Arthur: I sort of know the storyline.

Will: Yeah, he knows it. He’s seen the films.

Micah: Yeah, there you go. And Pottermore, at least – did you sign up? Did you say you signed up for Pottermore, or you didn’t? Not yet?

Will: I did, but…

Arthur: I haven’t.

Will: Yeah, he hasn’t, but I might give him a sneak peek. [laughs] Give him my account name or something like that.

Micah: You’d be getting backstory on stuff that you haven’t read, so… [laughs]

Will: Yeah, I know. But when is it public release? It’s like October or something, isn’t it?

Micah: Yeah, yeah, in October. But – yeah. No, that’s how you can experience it for the first time! I think you can read through most of the series all over again. So, that would be cool.

Will: It’s going to be awesome. Can’t wait for it! [laughs]

Micah: All right. All right, guys. Well, I know you said you had to catch a train back, so…

Will: Yeah. Got to go back. [laughs]

Micah: Did we get it in the right time frame there?

Will: Yeah, I think we’re fine.

Arthur: Yeah.

Will: Yeah, we’re absolutely fine. Absolutely fine. It was great. Yeah, perfect.

Micah: All right.

Will: All right. Well, great to speak to you.

Micah: All right, man. Take care, guys. Have a good day.

Arthur: Bye.

Will: And you. See you. Bye.

Andrew: All right. Micah, good job with your interview! That’s like practically three in three episodes.

Micah: Yeah. [laughs]

Andrew: You’ve been busy.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Oh, yeah. Well, we’re going to keep going.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Just wait to see who’s on the next episode.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Don’t say that.

Eric: Micah, you should interview your mom.

Micah: [laughs] What?

Eric: I want to know your mom. You should interview your mom for MuggleCast.

Micah: Okay. Well, I’ll make that happen.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Eric: Anyway…

Micah: Yeah. But I thought – again, I mean, they’re really excited about the series. They’re really excited about being a part of the films and it was just cool getting a chance to talk with them. I thought it was interesting how Arthur said that he had never read the books, and he still hasn’t read the books…

Eric: He gave us such a good reason though. [laughs]

Micah: …because Voldemort scared him as a child when he was – I guess when he saw the first film.

Andrew: Mmm.

Micah: So…

Andrew: Poor guy.

Micah: Yeah. But there’s no reason not to read the books now.

Eric: Well, I think with Pottermore it’ll be a better experience, right? Because it’ll be…

Micah: Well, that’s what I told him. I said now you have Pottermore, you can experience everything at once.


Favorites


Andrew: All right, a couple of fun segments now. First, Favorites. Eric, favorite place in Hogwarts or on the grounds?

Eric: This is a tough one because there are very easy answers, right? Like Great Hall or Room of Requirement. But I think my favorite place in Hogwarts or on the grounds is probably the staircases. Yeah, the staircases. They’re very – well, I guess it would be like the movies, but the moving staircases are just a really cool touch to the castle.

Andrew: Micah?

Micah: I would say the Forbidden Forest just because it’s forbidden. You’re not supposed to go there.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Troublemaker.

Eric: Troublemaker.

Micah: Or on the Quidditch pitch.

Eric: Oh, Quidditch.

Micah: Go out to sporting events…

Eric: Of course.

Micah: …and support your team – I mean, your house.

Andrew: I think mine would be Dumbledore’s office because it’s just filled with so much wisdom and the Pensieve.

Eric: Hmm.

Andrew: All those books and Fawkes is there.

Eric: And past headmasters.

Micah: You would chill with the phoenix.

Andrew: I’d chill with the phoenix, yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And now, favorite Horcrux? That’s an interesting question.

Eric: Hmm. I’ll say the diary. Is it sacrilege to not say Harry Potter?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [laughs] But yeah…

Andrew: That’s what I was going to say.

Eric: But yeah, the diary, absolutely. I think the coolest thing about the diary is that it was obviously a Horcrux, but that we didn’t know it was a Horcrux until Book 7. But it’s also the Horcrux we’ve heard the most from, I want to say, because it was not only a piece of soul in the context of, oh, it needs to be destroyed, but it was a piece of his soul that could really grow on its own, and that makes it really scary. So, favorite Horcrux is the diary.

Andrew: How about you, Micah?

Micah: Yeah, I would almost go with the ring, just because it also contained the Resurrection Stone and nobody knew that when – or I guess Dumbledore did know that, and that’s why he put it on. But yeah, I just think that the ring is cool. I mean, I think the easy-out is not Harry Potter, it’s the snake, right? Because everybody thinks snakes are cool, but no, I will go with the ring.

Andrew: Mine actually – I think the easy one, or at least mine, is Harry, just because it was a big question leading up to the book. “Is Harry a Horcrux?” We debated it a lot on MuggleCast and with our friends at Leaky on the Leaky Mug. I mean, it’s just…

Micah: Right.

Andrew: It was such a big crucial question and really, it created that whole scene in limbo. So, yeah, I’ll be predictable and say Harry Potter in this case.

Eric: I think it was a good reason.


Dueling Club: Marauders Edition


Andrew: So, now we will play the Dueling Club and this most recently happened on the live MuggleCast, Evanna Lynch took part in it. Eric, this is Marauders…

Micah: I was going to say something though, just – you brought up the one we did on the live show. But Andrew, I know we got stuck with Gandalf.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Was it you who said Gandalf or was it Ben who said Gandalf?

Andrew: I can’t remember.

Micah: You know what we should have said? Which would have made the absolute most sense to say and I think we’re all – shame on us for not saying it, who we should have picked.

Eric: Oh, Luna!

Andrew: Yeah, who?

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: You should have picked Luna.

Andrew: Oh!

Eric: You should have picked Luna, because then you would have played against Evanna [laughs] who obviously wants Luna to succeed, right?

Andrew: Right.

Eric: I get it now.

Micah: All right. Anyway, sorry. Go ahead.

Eric: Right. So… [laughs]

Andrew: So, Marauders Edition, Eric.

Eric: But yeah, Dueling Club: Marauders Edition. So, we have to pick one of the Marauders to duel against each other. And if we pick the same one we’ve got to go again. So, do you two want to do it first?

Andrew: Sure.

Micah: Why not?

Eric: Andrew and Micah.

Micah: So, are we saying the names at the same time, or…

Eric: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Okay, so on the count of three, you each give your Marauder. One, two, three.

Andrew: James.

Micah: Wormtail.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: All right.

Eric: You’re going to defend Wormtail, Micah?

Micah: Yeah, why not?

Eric: All right. Okay, okay, okay. Go ahead, Andrew. Why would James beat Wormtail?

Andrew: Well – I mean, first of all I think it’s very obvious in terms of skill set. Or no, let’s start with personality. I mean, Pettigrew has always seemed like a very insecure person and I think that to actually fight James would be very nerve-wracking for him. I mean, we’ve seen his insecurities throughout the book, whether he was speaking to Voldemort or he was speaking to Sirius. I just think that he would not be able to fight in a duel against somebody as calm, cool, and collected as James Potter. And then, we could also talk about the skill set. I think that James is a much more experienced wizard. There’s a reason he got the girl: he got the looks, he’s the complete package. Thank you.

Eric: [laughs] You’re welcome. This message has been approved by Andrew Sims. Okay. So, go ahead, Micah. Why would Wormtail win in a duel?

Micah: Well, all Wormtail would have to do would be to turn into a rat and scurry away, so he wouldn’t even stay for the fight. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh, easy. Easy.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Well, I think Wormtail is a very underestimated character in the series. I mean, his loyalty goes to those who he sees as holding the most power. I mean, at the end of the day, he would have to use more of his intellect, more of his cunning, to defeat somebody like James, which he ended up doing in the end anyway, and he’s the whole reason James and Lily are dead in the first place.

Eric: [laughs] Ohoho!

Micah: But we’re talking about a duel here between the two of them, and if we’re talking about them as Marauders, aside from the ability to turn into a rat and run away… [laughs]

Eric: Oh, you mean, like during their teen years?

Micah: …I don’t think he would stand much of a chance against James, to be honest. I am conceding in a way, but – giving my only reasoning being him being able to turn into an Animagus, and go run and hide.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Micah: Because you can’t take future events into consideration here, can you? I mean…

Eric: Well, so – well, yeah, by “Marauder’s Edition,” I meant like the characters who were the Marauders, not necessarily when they were the Marauders.

Micah: Yeah, but…

Eric: Like young James.

Micah: Right.

Eric: But yeah, I think…

Micah: So, I could say, yeah, he does end up killing him in the end, but that’s years down the line from when they would meet in this case.

Eric: Yeah, I – you know what? I think you both win, honestly. Good job.

Andrew: Oh. Aww, thanks.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Well, that leaves two others.

Andrew: All right, so we’re going to do one more?

Eric: Yeah, we’ll do one more.

Andrew: All right, on three, both of you state your Marauders. One, two, three.

Eric: Sirius.

Micah: Wormtail.

Eric: [laughs] Oh, Sirius and Wormtail. Hmmm.

Andrew: Okay, Sirius versus Wormtail. Eric, why would Sirius win against Wormtail?

Eric: Sirius has that dark quality to him that allows him to play both the good side and the bad side. And I think that having – being James Potter’s best friend, he’s obviously spent the most time with James, more than Remus and more than Wormtail. And so if James is the best wizard in this hypothetical situation, Sirius would be the one who has learnt the most from him. And yeah, I just think that Sirius would probably be really relentless. He’d put up a good fight, whereas Wormtail might be a little bit more hesitant and cowardly, and not put up as good of a fight, or not be as into sort of winning. Sirius has kind of an obsessive quality to him, as evidenced by when he chases Wormtail for a whole year, that one time at Hogwarts later on. But yeah, whatever.

Andrew: All right. Micah?

Micah: He would pretend that something is wrong and want Sirius to help him, and when Sirius got close, he would just do some curse to him. I don’t know. He would trick him. I mean, I think that’s Pettigrew’s only quality, is just that he can manipulate and he would find a way to manipulate the situation. I mean, [laughs] maybe Remus would have been a better choice for this duel.

Eric: No, I admire you for picking Wormtail twice. That takes balls. But still I think – you’re right. I think Sirius and maybe even James or Remus have sort of a capacity for sympathy for Wormtail, right? Don’t they end up saying that the only reason Wormtail was their friend was because they kind of felt bad for him? So, I think there is that quality where Wormtail obviously, again, did deceive them, so it’s possible it could happen in a duel situation. Interesting.

Micah: Right, right, and I think that part of the argument for Wormtail would be is I think that of the whole Marauder trio that’s left, Remus would be the only one to take Wormtail seriously in a duel. I don’t think that James or Sirius would look on him as being a worthy adversary.

Eric: That’s true, and that would be a flaw.

Micah: Right, because you never underestimate your opponent.


What If


Andrew: Now it’s time for What If, and this was submitted by Mariam of Mississauga. What if Snape was sorted into Gryffindor? Would Snape have had a better chance of being with Lily? That’s the main question. Now, I think it’s an interesting What If, but we would also have to keep in mind that Snape would probably have a different personality or maybe have come from a different background.

Eric: Well, that’s the thing, isn’t it? That Snape really was…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: …brave, which is why this What If kind of makes a lot of sense, right? Because if the hat would have chosen to – obviously, the hat saw this bravery or this capacity for bravery in eleven-year-old Snape, so if it had used that to sort him as opposed to his greasy nose or whatever, then maybe things would have been different, right? So – but at the same time, you’re right. I think Snape’s upbringing caused him to forever be that little edgy creature. It is said that Snape – or we see Snape crying when his mom and dad are in a verbally-abusive fight, an argument when Snape is very young, and I just think that his home life as a kid really affected how he saw the world. And the fact that he grew up with his parents detesting Mudbloods or whatever, he was able to use those terms a little bit more openly because he was familiar with them. Yeah, I think growing up in the isolation that he did kind of put the nail on the coffin for him being with Lily.

Micah: I think that also, though – let’s not forget that there are redeeming qualities about those who are in Slytherin, too. You can’t just say because he showed courage, he should have been in Gryffindor, right? I mean, who’s to say that somebody from Slytherin can’t do something great and can’t do something positive?

Eric: You mean, besides J.K. Rowling?

Micah: Why, you’re saying she’s in Slytherin? [laughs]

Eric: No, I mean – because you asked, “Who is saying that Slytherins can’t do something great?” and I said, “Besides J.K. Rowling,” because there are very few redemptive Slytherins, right? Snape is the only one.

Micah: Well, is he? I mean, Slughorn is not an evil character. Draco certainly – despite being an ass – is not – shows that he has redemptive qualities as well.

Eric: Speaking of ass, I think you just handed mine to me. So… [laughs]

Micah: Narcissa, I’m assuming was in Slytherin. Clearly, she’s not completely evil. And I’m sure there’s others, and I’m sure Pottermore will provide insight. I’m sure there’s others I’ve left out in the series that listeners can point out, too.

Eric: Okay. So, back to Snape.

Micah: So, Snape. Yeah, I mean, would he have had a better chance of being with Lily? I don’t know. [laughs] Maybe?

Andrew: Maybe. We’ll never know.

Eric: Very interesting.

Andrew: Yeah, he did.

[Eric laughs]


Listener Tweets


Andrew: Yeah. Well, yeah, that was an interesting discussion, and thank you again to Mariam for suggesting that. To wrap up the show, we have two more segments. First of all, we asked on Twitter – those who follow us on Twitter, Twitter.com/MuggleCast, “What do you think of Pottermore?” And we got some responses. Ashdc wrote:

“Pottermore is fun. The graphics are amazing. All the scenes are beautiful. But I got screwed over on the sorting! Wrong house.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: She didn’t say what house, though. So – Muttindale wrote:

“Disappointed in the impreciseness of the sorting. It seems to be hit and miss. Apart from that, I’m like a kid in a candy store.”

Charliane wrote:

“I love it, but I’m awful at brewing potions. Hoping for more activities and some of the Moments.”

goldentriox wrote:

“Beautiful pictures and great new content. It lacks music and interactivity throughout the story. Potion-making is awesome. Slytherin for the win.”

That’s another thing I wanted to talk about, the music.

Eric: Is there music?

Andrew: It’s a silent website.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: Completely, as far as I can tell.

Eric: Well, did Jo draw the art or did somebody else draw the art? Is that Jo’s art because…

Andrew: Jo did not…

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: …draw the art. [laughs]

Eric: Well, because she draws, right? I mean, she…

Andrew: But not that well.

Eric: Okay. [laughs] Well, there are always sketches from Jo, so I wondered if that was part of the intrigue on Pottermore. But if there’s no music – now, I would prefer they didn’t play the film music, actually, on…

Andrew: Yeah, that would be…

Eric: …Pottermore, right?

Andrew: …too predictable.

Eric: But something might be better than nothing.

Andrew: Yeah, and no sound effects either, I don’t think. Maybe I’m missing it. But I haven’t heard any sound effects, so it’s a bit odd but it’s Beta. Maybe they’ll add it. If they do go back and add it later, it’ll be a big pain in the butt because there’s just so much in there. So, we’ll see. Continuing on with a couple of more responses here.

“I think I need to…”

Oh, no. That girl didn’t get in.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Sorry, ConceitedKatelin. [laughs]

“I love it! J.K. I don’t have one. Sad face.”

That’s from Emily20. Here’s a negative one. Righto says:

“At first, Pottermore was great and exciting and wonderful and special. Now, it’s annoying and boring.”

Eric: Whoa.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s a bit hurtful. hrk85, Hilary wrote:

“I thought Potions on the Wii ‘Half-Blood Prince’ game was hard. Wii has got nothing on Pottermore. No wonder Seamus blew things up.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And like I said earlier, you have to be very precise with the potion, and in the specific order in doing this and that, and if not, it’s all over.

Eric: Is it mouse-clicking or is it keyboards, or what?

Andrew: Yeah, it’s mouse-clicking.

Eric: Oh, okay.


Spy on Spartz


Andrew: It’s – yeah, but it’s sort of like timing and all these other aspects. So, those are some people who contacted us on Twitter.com/MuggleCast after we asked them what they thought of Pottermore. Feel free to follow us on Twitter and we keep you updated on the show that way. And final segment of the day: a Spy on Spartz.

Eric: No way. Spy on Spartz, such a long time. Emerson Spartz is getting married, actually, in a couple of weeks. I think it’s over Labor Day weekend, and he is tying the knot. He is, of course, MuggleNet’s webmaster who began the site in 1999 when he was just a young itty-bitty homeschooler from Indiana. And now he’s getting married, the next chapter of his life. And Emerson, of course, runs Spartz Inc. which is a series of websites, not just MuggleNet. And he lives in Chicago, Illinois and he is getting married over Labor Day weekend, so that is a Spy on Spartz.

Andrew: Oh. Well, congratulations to Emerson, and we wish him and Gaby well. So, that’s it for MuggleCast Episode 238. A reminder, you can go to MuggleCast.com to get all the information you need about this show. On the right, you’ll find links to our iTunes, our Twitter which is Twitter.com/MuggleCast

[Show music begins]

Andrew: …our Facebook which is Facebook.com/MuggleCast, and our fan Tumblr which is MuggleCast.Tumblr.com. And also on the MuggleCast website, you can click on “Contact” at the top to get a feedback form where you can contact us. Well, again, that’s all on MuggleCast.com. Thanks everyone for listening! I’m Andrew Sims.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: And I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Andrew: We’ll see you next time for Episode 239. Buh-bye.

Micah: Bye.

Eric: Bye.

[Show music continues]