Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #774, Ministry of Oops (‘Deathly Hallows’ Chapter 13, The Muggle-Born Registration Commission)
Cold Open
Micah: Well, I mean, the only thing that would have made it more Umbridge is if the Dementors all had little pink bows on their cloaks.
Andrew: [laughs] That would have been cute.
Show Intro
[Show music plays]
Andrew Sims: Welcome to MuggleCast, your weekly ride into the world of Harry Potter. I’m Andrew.
Eric Scull: I’m Eric.
Micah Tannenbaum: I’m Micah.
Laura Tee: And I’m Laura.
Andrew: We’re your Harry Potter friends, of course, discussing the books and the movies and the upcoming TV show. Follow us right now in your favorite podcast app or on YouTube if you don’t already for new episodes every Wednesday. And we will be Floo-ing into full TV show coverage every week beginning December 2. This week, get your Decoy Detonators ready, because we’re discussing Chapter 13 of Deathly Hallows, “The Muggle-Born Registration Commission.” But first, it’s time for this week’s Quizzitch question.
[Quizzitch music plays]
Eric: Here’s something we didn’t expect to learn from perusing Umbridge’s office. What’s the name of Rita Skeeter’s biography of Headmaster of Hogwarts Armando Dippet?
Micah: She’s been a busy bee.
Andrew: I’d forgotten she wrote a book about Armando Dippet as well.
Eric: Yeah, it’s fun to know that she’s on kind of a roll. So I guess maybe her viewers were just expecting she’d do one on Dumbledore.
Andrew: Don’t forget, last week we announced this year’s physical gift for Slug Club patrons. It’s the MuggleCast Pensieve, or you might call it a Pen-seeve. Whichever way, this journal is going to work for you. With the TV show approaching, we want to help you get your thoughts and feelings out about it, so this journal helps you do that. It’s got 18 pages dedicated to the TV show, as well as pages dedicated to future seasons of the TV show, so it’s not going to become irrelevant once Season 1 ends. And then the rest of the journal is a traditional journal for you to use however way you like. Slug Club members can order theirs right now, and we’ll get it to you by late November. The deadline to pledge and fill out the form is Friday, November 13. And thanks, everybody, for your support; we can’t do this without you. This journal joins tons of other benefits you get on our Patreon, so please check it out. This is the best time of year to become a patron because you get a physical gift, and you will every year that you remain a Slug Club member.
Chapter by Chapter: Seven-Word Summary
Andrew: So without further ado, it’s time for Chapter 13 of Deathly Hallows, “The Muggle-Born Registration Commission.” And let’s get started with our Seven-Word Summary.
[Seven-Word Summary music plays]
Eric: Dementors…
Micah: … patrol…
Laura: … the…
Andrew: … Ministry…
Eric: … sham…
Micah: … outside…
Andrew: … courtroom.
Eric: All right.
Andrew: Wow, Eric turned that deep with “sham.”
Eric: Sham. Why even have a trial?
Laura: Well, and it is a sham what’s going on. 100%.
Andrew: Yeah, no, I know.
Chapter by Chapter: Main Discussion
Laura: That’s actually… that Seven-Word Summary really sets the tone for the kind of chapter we’re getting into and the stuff that we’re about to see coming to life at the Ministry. But harkening back to last week’s episode for the last chapter, the plan that the trio have spent weeks planning has to go into improv mode pretty quickly at the start of this chapter, because while Ron has departed at the end of the last chapter to deal with the chronic rain in Yaxley’s office, Hermione, a.k.a. Mafalda, has been summoned by Umbridge to accompany her for the day’s blood status questioning, leaving Harry, a.k.a. Runcorn, to bluff his way past Pius Thicknesse in the elevator. And trying to think of anything to say to excuse himself, he says he needs to go see Arthur Weasley, and this is where Harry gets the first hint that Arthur is being monitored officially, because Thicknesse’s response to that is to say, “Well, why? Has he been caught having contact with an Undesirable?” And he goes on to say, “It’s only a matter of time. If you ask me, the blood traitors are as bad as the Mudbloods.”
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: Ah, ah. You know, there’s a little bit of a strategy in that, or a little bit of a “Once they get done going for the Mudbloods, they’re going to go for the blood traitors.”
Laura: Yep, the goalposts always shift.
Andrew: Give an inch, they’ll take a mile, yeah.
Eric: The goalposts shift… as soon as you dehumanize and it becomes widely acceptable for you to dehumanize one portion of the population, it becomes infinitely easier to get the machinery of the government to go after another group.
Laura: Completely.
Micah: Yeah, and for Harry – and we were talking about this when we were discussing the previous chapter – not really knowing your colleagues very well, he’s put face to face with the Minister for Magic right off the bat, and he needs to do some improv, because if not, he’s going to be in quite a bit of hot water. But I think this also, for teenage Harry, has to be a bit scary, because the Minister is point blank asking Runcorn if Arthur is up to no good, so his best friend’s dad, his surrogate dad for the last several years, is in not a good situation.
Eric: And his fate is in… if Harry slips up in any way, it could directly and worsely impact.
Laura: Yeah. Well, and he has to maintain his cover too, right? So he has to walk a very thin line of not saying anything to get Arthur in trouble, but he also can’t blow his cover. I mean, it’s already kind of tenuous when Harry is like, “Oh, no, it’s nothing like that.”
[Eric laughs]
Andrew: Yeah, right, right. “No, what?”
Laura: Yeah. And it’s like, clearly everyone at the Ministry is thinking this. They’re along the same line of thinking as Pius is.
Andrew: And Harry is prone to losing his temper, as we’ll see by the end of the chapter. So yes, it is a good point that it is possible for him to lose control and lose his cool and screw up here.
Eric: Furthermore, I mean, I was just going to say, in terms of being in front of the Minister, Pius is also under the Imperius Curse, isn’t he? Voldemort himself.
Laura: Right, he is.
Eric: And so, gosh, I was just thinking when I was reading this, what if Harry just muttered “Horcruxes” just randomly next to Pius? Would that activate Pius, or would he have to go back to Voldemort, or would it mean anything? Would it cause a commotion or something? Because there’s no reason for Albert Runcorn to know that word. For Harry… he doesn’t; I’m just thinking this in my head as a thought experiment of what exactly… how many layers removed from Voldemort are we right now? Is Pius reporting back? Is somebody viewing what’s going on through Pius’s eyes? Because if so, there’s two Voldemort’s in this elevator right now. [laughs]
Laura: Yeah. Eric, I was actually wondering the same thing, because Harry is not exactly slick in this moment, and I think if there’s any mechanism in place within a person who’s been Imperiused to flip the alarm to say, “Mm, something’s not right here,” this would be one of those moments, and it almost makes me wonder if so many people are Imperiused at this point that it’s impossible to have point of view into what every single one of them is experiencing. But you would think that if there were someone Voldemort would want to keep an eye on, it would be the Minister, or the stand-in Minister. So this is an interesting moment. It could simply just be that so many people are Imperiused at this point that they can’t keep real-time track of what everyone is doing, and that may be the only reason.
Micah: So what would have been a more appropriate answer? Maybe that “Nothing that I know of right now, but I’ll be keeping my eye on him”? I just don’t know Runcorn’s personality.
Eric: Just don’t say Arthur Weasley.
Laura: Or also… yeah, that’s my… why say Arthur Weasley? [laughs]
Micah: Oh, that’s a great point.
Eric: He could have said Neville Longbottom, for all of Harry’s… you had 30 days to plan this! What’s your reason for being…?
Andrew: What have you been doing?
Micah: Well, it has to be consistent with the floor that he’s on, right? That’s why.
Laura: Right, but you would think it would seem… it wouldn’t be suspicious for him to say, “I need to go talk to Dolores,” right?
Eric: Oh, God, right.
Laura: So that could be a hidden-in-plain-sight moment for him.
Eric: Right.
Laura: But I digress. Harry, where he’s actually going, he’s not looking for Arthur; he is heading for Umbridge’s office because he wants to search it for the Horcrux. And he just feels kind of childish in this moment when he’s heading for her office on his own, and he remarks in his own inner monologue that the plan that they’ve been devising for the last few weeks feels childish because they never accounted for this, and I think that we pretty well discussed this on last week’s episode, that this particular part of the plan was a pretty big oversight.
Eric: Does it make it okay that Harry feels like the plan was childish? Does that let Harry off the hook for feeling that way? It’s like, it is a childish plan. And as a reader, I’m like, “They should have done this better.” It doesn’t give me great confidence in the heroes of this book that they’re going to overcome all of these other odds they have against them if this plan is so feeble and falls apart immediately. I mean, they don’t necessarily learn from this; the entire book is like this. And there’s something to be said for the heroes being up against great odds, but at the same time, I don’t think Harry feeling foolish during the moment and not learning from it makes for good storytelling, necessarily. They didn’t expect to be separated. They say that. What did they think they were going to do as a group together? Three random people have nothing to do with each other, walking around as a group, never having to leave the same room. All three of them were going to find themselves in Umbridge’s office? That doesn’t make any sense.
Laura: Yeah, that wouldn’t be weird.
Andrew: Fixing a leak and some other things.
Micah: Especially they all can’t fit under that Invisibility Cloak, presumably, as adults.
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Laura: Right.
Micah: So it’s really not the best laid plan. I just want to see in the TV show Runcorn walking down the hallway banging his head, being like, “Stupid plan.”
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Eric: That would make it better. I agree with that.
Micah: I don’t know that it’s childish; it’s just it wasn’t thought well through. And that makes me wonder, did all three of them even need to go to the Ministry in the first place? Couldn’t this have been a one-man or one-woman operation into the Ministry? Lower risk for sure.
Andrew: I think it could’ve. Just Harry with the cloak, I think. But Hermione in particular would never have let him go by himself, I think, as we see time and time again.
Micah: Right, they always have to be together. But this idea of selecting three random Ministry employees, it just didn’t work. I mean, it does work, but with a lot of complications, as we’ll see.
Laura: Yeah. Well, we’re about to enter Umbridge’s office, but before we get there, I want to talk about what’s happening directly in front of her office, literally right under Mad-Eye’s eye, which is now being used effectively as a peephole replacement on her door.
Andrew: Eugh.
Laura: There are propaganda pamphlets being printed and assembled by about a dozen Ministry workers right in front of Umbridge’s office, and these propaganda pamphlets literally read, “Mudbloods and the Dangers They Pose to a Peaceful Pure-Blood Society.” I know we’ve talked on the show before about how much of this imagery is ripped from real history; it’s very much inspired by things that we’ve seen happen in the past. In particular, these books are heavily inspired by the events of World War II, and the rise of Voldemort is very much a parallel imagery of the rise of the Nazi regime in Germany and Europe, right? Something I thought was interesting… I looked this up from the Holocaust Memorial Museum. Hitler actually wrote that “Propaganda’s task is not to make an objective study of the truth, in so far as it favors the enemy, and then set it before the masses with academic fairness; its task is to serve our own right, always and unflinchingly.” That last line really reminds me a lot of the whole “Magic Is Might” slogan that we got to learn about last chapter.
Andrew: Yeah, “We are the all powerful. We are the almighty.”
Laura: Yeah. Well, and if we’re looking at history, this real-life propaganda extended to newspapers, pamphlets like the ones we’re seeing here in the book, but even also to films, music, and other forms of entertainment.
Eric: Cartoons. I’ve seen a cartoon or two that were really meant to appeal for a younger audience, but also were flooded with offensive ideals.
Laura: Totally. Yeah, and the idea was to mobilize public support of the Nazi agenda and to gain the acquiescence of millions of others as bystanders to racially-targeted persecution and mass murder.
Eric: And we see that here, too… there’s a moment where…. and Umbridge is presumably… the reason this is happening in front of Umbridge’s office is because presumably she’s overseeing this. She’s out of her office at the moment but she probably has some very strong opinions about how these people should do their jobs. But we see that the people doing this don’t really care for Umbridge. They say something like, “Ah, that old hag,” and it’s just like, “Oh, careful. Careful what you say. She might overhear you.” But they’re nevertheless actively putting together these propaganda books that will be used for horrible purposes. The people that don’t even believe in the cause necessarily… nobody sitting there is going, “This is the best thing ever. I completely agree with every word in this. Ha ha ha! We have an important duty.” People are scared, and they’re going to work, and they’re doing what they’re told to do, but they’re not resisting. If they don’t agree with it, they’re not doing more, because they’re worried.
Micah: To that point, you don’t have to believe the propaganda to help spread it, and fear will turn ordinary people into participants, and that speaks to what you were just saying, Eric, about how you have these Ministry workers who probably don’t like Umbridge, probably don’t believe in what it is that they are helping to mass produce here, but Umbridge has created this environment where disagreeing with authority comes with significant risk.
Eric: Right. It’s the unquestioning person in power.
Andrew: Yeah, and everybody knows that Voldemort has taken over the Ministry, so if you’re messing with Umbridge, you’re probably messing with Voldemort. I mean, your life could literally be on the line by acting out.
Eric: Oh, yeah.
Laura: Well, and also, I think there’s probably a good portion of these people who are thinking, “I’m not Muggle-born, so I’m not at risk.”
Eric: Yep. “Doesn’t matter to me.”
Laura: “And if I keep my head down and do what I’m supposed to do, it’ll keep my family safe, and that’s the most important thing.” And that just harkens back to the poem that we reminded everyone of a couple of weeks ago about how “First they came for this group of people, and I said nothing because I wasn’t one of them. But then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me.” That’s really what we’re seeing play out here.
Eric: I think if there’s a lesson, it’s that you have so much power as a collective group to resist, but these division tactics, which are extremely effective, and that have been rolled out, that we even see from these Ministry workers in front of Umbridge’s office… they are fearing for their own individual safety, and I’m not saying nobody should, but they’re all collectively powerful, and if they were to band together and resist, they could maybe affect change, or at least be a thorn in the side instead of accomplices of or participants of. That’s a good word, Micah, for this kind of horror that’s being unleashed.
Laura: I also wanted to focus a little bit on the plant metaphor that we see in these posters. So there’s a rose that is being strangled by a vine that’s got fangs, and this garden and weeds metaphor is also ripped straight from Nazi ideology. Richard Walther Darre – I don’t know if I’m saying that last name correctly; feel free to correct me if anyone knows – he served as the Reich Minister for Food and Agriculture under the Third Reich, and frequently used agricultural metaphors to argue that human populations should be actively bred and managed, just like livestock or crops. Additionally, Nazis loved their propaganda. They loved using this imagery to promote eugenics programs, not only to dehumanize certain groups like Jewish people, but also to say, “Hey, we should not allow disabled people to breed because we don’t want those features coming forward in our perfect Aryan race.” So again, this is another example of how the author is not inventing this particular kind of storytelling. She was looking at history and saying, “This is the model for what’s happening in the wizarding world right now.”
Micah: Yeah, even going back to the point about cartoons earlier, there are a lot of instances where the Jewish people were portrayed as these blood suckers, these parasites, carriers of disease, and in many instances, the depiction was of them looking like vampires. So it was really harsh stuff that was being put out there, and it seems like we’re about to enter that territory as it relates to Muggle-borns, and as was stated earlier, that’s a gateway to the persecution of others. The Muggle-borns is just the first stop on this road trip.
Eric: “Mudbloods and the Dangers They Pose.” It’s like, frame it like it’s not even a question, right? “You are in danger for knowing a Muggle-born person.”
Laura: Right. And I know that especially when we’re talking about the rise of Voldemort and the Second Wizarding War and all of these things, we talk a lot about how this was inspired by the events of World War II. But as Andrew likes to say, time is a flat circle, and history does repeat itself, and there are present day examples that we can look towards. Here in the United States, the Department of Homeland Security and ICE have used some pretty atrocious language in their recruitment tools. A good example of this is materials they put out that literally said, “One homeland. One people. One heritage. Remember who you are, American.”
[Eric laughs]
Andrew: Yeah, and I mean, there’s even imagery that goes out that can easily be compared to what images and photographs you see in history from Nazi Germany.
Laura: Totally. Well, and they try to galvanize support around some of the videos that they’ve put out of loading shackled people onto planes and trying to make that imagery feel inspiring to people.
Eric: Right, the cruelty… that’s kind of what I think is going on with Umbridge in this courtroom in this chapter, is it’s a sham trial, was one of my word contributions for the Seven-Word Summary, because it does not… there’s nobody going into this court that’s going to be sufficiently proving their case. If you’re here, you’ve already lost.
Micah: On top of this, the Ministry is still functioning, people are still going to work, and this has become the new normal under Voldemort. And it’s part apathy, but then it’s part protectionism as well for these people. They don’t really have a choice at the end of the day. If this is their job, what’s your alternative? You don’t show up? And if you don’t show up, then what happens? They’re going to come after you.
Eric: You get put on a list.
Andrew and Micah: Yeah.
Laura: Well, we can move into Umbridge’s office now.
Eric: Oh, great.
Laura: Of course, we know Harry sets off those wonderful Decoy Detonators to make it easier for him to get in there undetected. And what Harry discovers in there really adds insult to injury for everything that he’s already seen so far. I mean, of course, I already mentioned Mad-Eye’s magical eye in the place of the peephole. Harry spies a copy of The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore, and he also finds the file on Arthur in Umbridge’s office, confirming that he’s being tracked. And Harry also sees his own Undesirable Number One poster up on the wall, and Umbridge has put a cute little pink kitten note on it that says, “To be punished.”
Andrew and Micah: Aww.
Andrew: Again.
Laura: It’s like, she is really vindictive, because of course she wants to punish him, but she really just had to make sure that she put that note on there. [laughs] Just in case she forgot.
Andrew: Yeah, right. Yeah, that’s a good point. Undesirable Number One, pretty cool name too. If I were undesirable…
Micah: Good screen name.
Andrew: Oh, yeah.
Eric: It’s a screen name; it’s an album cover for a debut album. Undesirable Number One.
[Ad break]
Eric: Is Umbridge regressing? Is she, I don’t know, a childish maturity?
Laura: Oh, yeah.
Eric: Because to be punished… “You must be punished. Bad boys must be punished.” It’s like, “Really? Dude, you’re an adult woman.”
Laura: Oh, she’s extremely emotionally immature. And clearly, a lot of this is still… she has an ax to grind with Harry for how things went for her at Hogwarts.
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Laura: He embarrassed her. Well, Harry does his best to scan the office for signs of the Horcrux locket, but no luck, no joy, and it’s not long before Pius Thicknesse walks in to leave Umbridge a note. And for the second time in these couple of chapters, Harry is very nearly spotted disappearing under the Invisibility Cloak. Thicknesse sees his elbow and does a double take and is like, “Hmm.”
Eric: I just…
Laura: It’s a good thing he’s not more curious.
Eric: Yeah, right? Harry, you’re not even doing the basics, dude. Be more careful.
Micah: Keep the cloak on, number one. Especially because if we go back to Order of the Phoenix… and Harry notes this when he walks in; the plates with the kittens are up on the wall, and they were spies for her in Book 5. Why would they not be spying for her now? Now, I know she’s in her happy place down in the courtroom…
Andrew: [laughs] Her happy place.
Micah: … but this seems like a pretty big risk. And I understand it’s not Harry; it’s Runcorn. But still, he needs to be more careful in this moment. Yes, 100%, it makes sense that he searches the office, but he does need to be more careful. This speaks to the flaws in the plan.
Andrew: Figuring out a way to expand the Invisibility Cloak could have solved a lot of issues over the years.
Eric: Yeah, put an Extension Charm on it or something.
Andrew: That’s what they should have spent months doing, not watching the Ministry, but figuring out how to make the cloak larger.
Eric: Agreed.
Laura: Well, Hermione already did it with the bag…
Andrew: Right.
Laura: … so presumably, you could do… I don’t know. Maybe you can’t do that to a Hallow. Who knows?
Micah: But a Hallow should be self-adjusting.
[Andrew and Micah laugh]
Andrew: Should it?
Eric: That’s true.
Micah: I mean, it is…
Eric: Yeah, the Elder Wand is, and the Resurrection Stone is too, because it pulls from your heart or whatever.
Micah: I just remember having a really bad taste the first time I read this and knowing that it was Mad-Eye’s eye that was on the door.
Andrew: It’s sick. It’s sick.
Micah: You’re taking the signature feature of one of the most accomplished Aurors in the wizarding world at this time, and you’re mounting it above your door as a trophy, basically saying. And it’s meant to serve as a boasting means of authority, I would assume, on the part of Umbridge.
Eric: I mean, it’s a conquest. It’s a conquered adversary’s body part. It is a trophy. That’s a great… she’s found a way to utilize it still. She’s found a way to subvert… to basically weaponize a body part.
Micah: And pervert it too, right? Use it for the purposes of keeping an eye on all of these Ministry workers.
Laura: Totally. This is a great callback to earlier in the book when… I think it’s Bill who says they tried to collect Mad-Eye’s body, but they couldn’t find it. And now we know what probably happened to it. And also, if we’re talking about Nazi imagery, Nazis loved using body parts of their victims as trophies. It’s disgusting.
Andrew: Gross. Everything in this chapter is gross.
Laura: Yeah, it is.
Eric: Makes me want to camp for ten months. Forget about the world.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Andrew: Get away from everything. Screw it!
Laura: Leave the world behind. Well, after this, Harry and Ron are briefly reunited in the lift, where they also run into Arthur, so convenient timing. And Arthur actually gives Ron advice about how to deal with Yaxley’s meteoro… I can’t even say this word that I wrote. Yaxley’s rain issues in his office.
[Eric laughs]
Laura: And he also mentions that this has been happening in a lot of people’s offices lately; it’s not just Yaxley’s. Is this an intentional effort to sabotage from within?
Andrew: Maybe. Maybe some rebel scum.
Eric: It could be a saboteur.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Micah: A little resistance.
Andrew: Yeah, or is it just symbolic of the…? This sounds crazy, but is the building reacting to the current state? [laughs] Of how it’s running?
Eric: No, I think that’s it!
Andrew: Really? Okay.
Eric: I really think that that’s true.
Laura: Hogwarts does that.
Eric: Hogwarts does that. Imagine the Ministry being built with the explicit purpose of serving all wizardkind, and now members of wizardkind who are listed as undesirable or Muggle-born are being traipsed in, their wands broken, and thrown into Azkaban with a sham of due process. So if you were a building that had weather patterns, those would function like emotions. And the fact that so many offices are just weeping… I’d love to believe there’s a single saboteur around the way that we learn that Neville and Ginny are causing problems for the teachers at Hogwarts this year, but I just like the idea also even more that the building and offices are raining because the building is weeping because government is weeping because this is a blight…
Andrew: I love it.
Eric: … on what the building’s purpose was supposed to be used for.
Laura: I love that. I think we can declare canon.
Eric: Nice.
Andrew: Oh, okay. Hell yeah.
Micah: Ooh.
[“I declare canon!” sound effect plays with thunder]
Andrew: Oh, and there’s rain in this, so it’s perfect.
[Laura and Micah laugh]
Eric: There we go!
Micah: Little thunderstorm action?
Eric: Love it.
Micah: I was wondering if the Ministry had its own version of Peeves, but I like this idea that the Ministry is reacting because of…
Laura: Right.
Micah: … all of the nefarious things that are happening within its walls.
Andrew: No, that’s a fun thought too, Micah. There’s a Peeves running about. That wouldn’t surprise me at all, with the size of that establishment.
Eric: Oh, yeah.
Laura: Sure. Well, when we see Peeves, he does this at Hogwarts too. It’s his own little resistance.
Eric: Yeah, magic is chaos, and so there’s so much magic in this building, there’s so many artifacts that have been confiscated… one of them could go off and it would be a huge problem.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Laura: Well, y’all, I want to just give Arthur Weasley his flowers right now because this is a brave man who stands on business. He is not having it with Runcorn in this elevator. As soon as Ron, a.k.a. Reg, has left, Arthur rounds on Harry, a.k.a. Runcorn, and Harry is immediately uncomfortable with how Arthur is looking at him, and he gets on his case about turning in Dirk Cresswell after looking up his family tree and finding some evidence of a lack of blood purity there, and he says, “Dirk Cresswell is ten times the wizard you are.”
Andrew: Ooh!
Laura: And he also goes on to say, “If he survives Azkaban, you’re going to have to answer to him, and if he doesn’t, you’re going to have to answer to his kids.”
Eric: Wow.
Laura: He’s threatening him. In a world where… Arthur behaving this way at the Ministry is really dangerous for him.
Andrew: I mean, this line that Dirk is “ten times the wizard you are.” This also just reminds me of how immigrants get treated in this country as less than, when in fact they’re not, and in so many cases they’re needed, and very talented people here…
Eric: Yeah, and dedicated, hardworking.
Andrew: … and they never get painted that way by certain people.
Laura: Right.
Eric: No, yeah, they’re absolutely the exact sort of people you want not only in this country, but protected, cared for, provided for, so that they can continue producing in such a good way in everything.
Andrew: Yeah, contributing to what makes America great.
Eric: And living, because it’s human right to survive. I’m reminded of… this Arthur Weasley thing is like you finally see the man that punched out Lucius Malfoy. He had some better judgment there, but Lucius kept goading him into a fight in Book 2, and Harry feels like he’s about to be on the receiving end of one of those blows. Arthur clearly would punch out Runcorn if he could get away with it, really give him a piece of his mind and a piece of his knuckles. [laughs] And I wrote in the notes here that I think this makes Arthur Weasley not just previously goaded, but also GOAT-ed.
[Andrew laughs]
Eric: He’s the best. We love him. Greatest of all time, Mr. Arthur Weasley.
Micah: It’s definitely his Gryffindor side shining through…
Eric: Yeah!
Laura: Totally.
Micah: … which we don’t see very often.
Andrew: No.
Micah: Because we just don’t spend a lot of time with him, but when we do, he’s often portrayed as this goofball, right?
Eric: He’s polite, fairly…
Andrew: With an office job. Older man, compared to the kids.
Micah: Good dad.
Eric: Keeps his head down.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Eric: Remember, Percy called him, what, not ambitious enough, right?
Laura: Right. And it’s like, I don’t know, he’s pretty ambitious where it really counts.
Eric: He’s standing up…
Laura: And I think it says something for someone like Arthur… it would be very easy for someone like Arthur to say, “You know what? I’m a pure-blood. My family is pure-blood. If we just toe the line…”
Eric: Throw Muggle-borns under the bus.
Laura: Yeah, exactly. “We could be okay if we just keep our heads down.” But he’s like, “No, I want to punch Nazis in the face, and I hate them.”
[Andrew laughs]
Laura: And I just… it makes me love him so much. I love this moment with Arthur. Well, Harry tries to warn Arthur that he’s being tracked in this moment, and it’s very clear – because of the messenger, right? – Arthur perceives it as a threat, which, to be honest, he should.
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Laura: I think that’s the healthiest way. But do we think Arthur is even surprised? Is he remotely surprised to hear that he’s being tracked? Of course he’s being tracked.
Andrew: Right, right.
Eric: I think it does surprise him.
Andrew: Ah, I don’t think… well, maybe… he’s got to know people are at least keeping an eye on him because, as is noted in this chapter, he does associate with Undesirable Number One, and they probably like that he’s coming into the office so they can keep an eye on him and seeing what he’s up to. So yeah, I think he wouldn’t be surprised to know he’s being tracked.
Micah: But maybe hearing it from somebody like Runcorn for the first time…
Eric: Makes it real?
Andrew: Yeah, definitely.
Micah: … makes it real, yeah, exactly. And that said, I would imagine that he would assume, much like other members of the Order, that they are aware that somebody is keeping an eye on them.
Laura: Something struck me about all of these lift conversations, because it just feels very performative. Everyone’s performing for each other, and it just feels like this is another way of communicating the Ministry’s atmosphere of paranoia, right?
Andrew: Yeah, you can’t trust anybody.
Laura: Right. And theoretically, if you work at the Ministry and you’re down with the mission, why wouldn’t you trust everybody? But it’s very clear none of them trust each other, even the people who are on the same side.
Andrew: They’re all forced into this. Some of them know that they’re not pure-blood, and so they’ve just got to toe the line and keep their head down, and that’s it. And it must be a very weird environment to be in where you can’t even talk to each other openly and honestly because you don’t know who to trust, or because these people might not agree with your opinions.
Micah: You know what they really need?
Andrew: What?
Micah: Cell phones, because that’s what most people do in elevators nowadays, and it drives me insane.
Eric: Just on their phones?
Andrew: Why, Micah? Why does it bother you? Why?
Micah: Because the first thing somebody does when they get in the elevator – and maybe this is just where I work – they take out their phone. What do you need to do in the 15 to 20 seconds it takes you to get from the floor you’re getting in the elevator on to the lobby that is so important on your phone? And it becomes like a trend, a sickness that goes from one person to the next, where they all start taking out their phones.
Andrew: Wow. [laughs]
Micah: My point is, have a conversation with somebody. Say hello. Say good morning.
Andrew: Okay, okay.
Micah: Say, “Have a nice evening.”
Eric: So you’re an old school… Micah, you’re an old school conversationalist. You want to meet people. You want to interact with people. “We’re all in the same building together; let’s talk.”
Andrew: This is an interesting pet peeve.
Micah: Oh, it drives me insane.
Andrew: I like that we’re learning this about Micah. Wow. Okay, okay.
Laura: I think you’re right, though.
Andrew: So do you try to socialize with these people in the elevator for the 15 seconds?
Micah: Yeah, of course.
Andrew: You do?
Micah: Or I’ll say “Good morning” to somebody or “Have a nice day” when I’m walking out of the elevator. I do not take my phone out in the elevator.
Andrew: Wow.
Micah: Most of the time it doesn’t work anyway. [laughs]
Eric: Doesn’t even have a signal.
Andrew: Well, I was going to say… that was the point I was going to bring up, yeah. Interesting. Wow, okay. That’s Micah’s pet peeve.
Laura: I think it’s kind of a social crutch so that people have a reason to not interact.
Andrew: Yeah, totally.
Laura: And I think you’re right, Micah. It’s kind of like yawning. You know how when one person yawns, it makes everyone else yawn?
Eric: Or even says the word “yawn”? [yawns] Laura, thank you.
Laura: Yeah, sorry, Eric. But yeah, I think you see one person pull their phone out, and you’re like, “Well, okay, I’ll look at mine.”
Andrew: “Well, what’s going on on my phone?”
Eric: “This is what we’re doing now.”
Laura: I’ve totally been the person to do this. And for the record, I’m not actually looking at anything when I do this; it’s just something for me to do with my hands.
Andrew: Uh-huh. Right.
Laura: [laughs] I’ll keep that in mind next time I’m in an elevator with you, Micah.
Andrew: Yeah, me too.
Laura: I won’t take my phone out. Well, speaking of who’s around, Harry is headed towards the dungeons in order to reach the courtrooms, and when he gets to the main hallway, Harry immediately notices this feeling of despair, but then he quickly realizes that Dementors are actually lining the hallway leading up to the courtroom where questioning is happening, and these Muggle-borns are all lined up along the walls of this hallway, waiting for their hearings as these Dementors are patrolling up and down the line. The setup totally screams Umbridge because it is both orderly and terrifying.
Andrew: I think Micah and I are aligned on this, right, Micah?
Micah: Yeah. Well, I mean, the only thing that would have made it more Umbridge is if the Dementors all had little pink bows on their cloaks.
Andrew: [laughs] That would have been cute.
Micah: But I do think we’re aligned, Andrew. I think there’s something that’s particularly cruel about using Dementors here because they’re not just guards; they’re not just security.
Laura: Right.
Micah: Their very presence strips people of hope and happiness, so this is an intimidation tactic.
Andrew: Yes, it’s totally to throw these people off and make themselves screw up when trying to defend themselves in the sham trial. It’s really bad.
Eric: In an ordinary court, you would see this… there’s this presumption of justice, right? There’s presumption of fairness, there’s a presumption that you’ll have your day in court, you’ll be able to speak your case. But when there’s people or creatures employed that will put you on edge, make you never feel safe or secure, this is not… there’s an assumption of guilt here that wouldn’t exist in a fair kind of court, and you’re being put at a great disadvantage. We’ve seen the wizarding world pull this kind of crap before with Harry and his trial to get expelled in Book 5, but they did not have Dementors there. They did not… this is how far it’s fallen from justice.
Micah: It’s almost like walking the Green Mile.
Laura: Yeah, and I was going to say, too, if we want to talk about real world comparisons again, I think that there’s a lot of commentary we could make about the conditions of detention facilities, the conditions of prisons, and how they ultimately don’t set the accused up for the best possible outcome, right? People are starved. People are freezing. Children are separated from their families. In some cases, children have to appear in front of immigration judges by themselves, right? So there’s just a whole lot that’s happening here that again is being pulled straight from the history books, and it is unnerving to see. But I think also this is the brilliance of literary analysis, is that it allows us to, I think, unpack and empathize with and understand what being in this situation might feel like.
Eric: Yeah. It’s a good thing that the wizards don’t have TV, because I’m pretty sure these proceedings would be televised. Umbridge would love for more people to see how cool she’s being. Just gross.
Laura: Oh, yeah. She would love to behave like the Capital from The Hunger Games for sure.
Eric: Yeah, exactly.
[Ad break]
Laura: Well, Harry – kind of on instinct, which is a very Harry moment – decides that he’s going to slip into the courtroom right behind Mary Cattermole when she’s called in for questioning, and he notices that not only are the Dementors in the hallway leading up to the courtroom, the Dementors are also lining the perimeter of the room. And Umbridge has cast her Patronus, which is of course a cat, to keep the prosecutors warm and the accused freezing.
Andrew: Meow. Yeah, that’s another messed up part. We were just talking about the intimidation tactic, but also for Umbridge just to set up this shield so she doesn’t have to experience it, just these other people.
Laura: Right.
Andrew: And meanwhile, she’s not even pure-blood. [laughs]
Eric: Yeah. Well, the hypocrisy is disgusting.
Laura: Well, while Mary is being questioned – and I mean literally being accused of stealing her wand and stealing magic from a witch or wizard – Harry slips into the prosecution benches behind Hermione, and nearly… I think it’s another circumstance where he almost blows their cover, and he knows he’s going to do it because he’s like, “She’s going to jump. I know she’s going to jump when I get back there.” And she does; she nearly knocks over an ink pot. But they recover, and Hermione takes the opportunity to say, “Oh, Dolores, what a lovely locket! Tell me about that.” And this is when Umbridge tells us a little bit about the locket and gives us a false history of it. She says the S stands for Selwyn, another pure-blood family, that she’s claiming to be related to. She’s literally using a stolen Horcrux as a pure-blood prop here.
Micah: No surprise.
Laura: And then she goes on to say, “I wish I was related to more pure-blood families.”
Andrew: Oh my gosh. And Micah, what is her actual lineage?
Micah: Well, probably because you’re half-blood, so she can’t let that get out. That would be a bit problematic for her in her situation. Or maybe not; I mean, Voldemort is half-blood too. But yeah, the background on Umbridge is that her mother was a Muggle-born, her father was a wizard, and her brother actually ends up becoming a Squib. And there’s this whole backstory on Umbridge that folks can read, and I know we’ve talked about when we’ve done a character analysis of her. But it’s definitely hypocritical, to your point, Andrew, for her to be sitting up there and casting decisions about the future of these fellow witches and wizards. And we know the outcome, though; that’s the horror in all of this, is that nobody here is getting a fair trial. And we see it from the person who’s coming out of the courtroom as Harry is sneaking his way in behind Mary, and we recognize that Mary is not going to be able to convince Umbridge otherwise.
Laura: Right.
Micah: This is just like “Absolute power corrupts absolute,” and it’s just feeding her. I’ve got to imagine the thrill that she is getting from all of this is feeding that Patronus, and making it as powerful or as… what’s the word that was used? Glowing?
Eric: Vibrant.
Micah: This is just very sickening. And yes, this is all happening under Voldemort’s Ministry, but I feel like Umbridge would do this without Voldemort. [laughs]
Andrew: This is all Umbridge. Oh, yeah.
Eric: Well, but then it’s a question, isn’t it? Because she is under the influence, for several months now, of the locket. So I’m not one to…
Andrew: But she’s still evil.
Eric: Yeah, yeah, no.
Andrew: I think if she got permission to do… if she could get away with this, she would, no wonder who’s running the show.
Eric: I’m wondering if this level of depravity is truly in Umbridge, or was truly in Umbridge prior to her associations with the locket, or whether this is the sick, twisted way that her mind works when it’s on… I want to say drugs, but Horcruxes.
Andrew: [laughs] “This is your mind on Horcruxes.”
Laura: Yeah. Honestly, I think she did have it in her, because I mean, look, she was already doing v1 of this two books ago.
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Eric: She wants to punish people.
Laura: Right? I mean, she literally sent Dementors to Little Whinging.
Eric: Oh, yeah.
Andrew: And punish in painful ways too. It’s not just like, “Oh, you’re in detention.”
Eric: Humiliate, destroy.
Andrew: “I’m going to make you bleed.”
Micah: She’s got a lot of trauma going on; that’s for sure. But I was going to ask, what do we think she’s thinking of in that moment in order to be able to initially cast the Patronus?
Laura: I think she’s in her happy place here.
Micah: So you just think it’s “I’m here in this moment; I’m getting to…”
Eric: Terrorize?
Micah: “… terrorize all these people”?
Andrew: And she’s the boss. She’s in power. I think with that comes a lot of confidence.
Micah: She gets off on it.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Andrew: This is her show.
Laura: And we saw that with how she showed up as a professor too.
Andrew: Right.
Laura: She wants to lord over people. Well, this lie from Umbridge about the locket really brings Harry’s blood to a boiling point, which I understand, given the fact that he had “I must not tell lies” carved into the back of his hand how many hundreds of times by this woman a couple years ago.
Eric: Right.
Laura: And he’s just like, “You know what? F this. Stupefy.” And he Stupefies Umbridge and Yaxley. I think that this plan probably… if Hermione had had time to scold Harry, she would have, but there is no time for it. The problem here, though, is that with Umbridge Stunned, her Patronus is gone, which means the Dementors are free rein now, and they immediately descend upon Mary Cattermole. Harry, of course, is able to produce his Patronus with ease; Hermione does get hers out with some difficulty. And Harry makes the split second decision to say, “All right, Muggle-borns in this hallway in this courtroom, follow us. We’re getting you out of here.”
[Andrew laughs]
Laura: So they escort these Muggle-borns to the atrium, and this is where they’re met with a new problem. They reunite with Ron, and Ron is like, “Hey, y’all. Uh, word has gotten out that there are intruders at the Ministry, and they are shutting everything down.” So when they get to the atrium, the exits are being closed down; they’re trying to stop people from leaving. Harry pulls rank as Runcorn to say, “Hey, these people need to leave before we close those exits.” So ultimately, Harry saves a lot of lives here.
Andrew: Yeah, yeah. It’s awesome to see.
Micah: Yeah, very smart in-the-moment thinking, too, to say, “Well, if you don’t keep these grates open, I’m going to Dirk Cresswell you.”
[Andrew and Micah laugh]
Laura: Yeah!
Eric: That’s so good.
Laura: Yeah, he literally does that. He’s like, “I’m going to… I’ll do to you what I did to him.”
Eric: And I’m sure there’s rumors; people would have talked. Like, “Oh, did you hear about what he did…?” It’s brilliant, actually.
Andrew: So on the Patronuses, Harry does note for Hermione, conjuring a Patronus has always been the spell she has trouble with. Any thoughts on why that is? Is it because it’s a less by-the-book type of thing?
Micah: Can’t she struggle with something? [laughs]
Andrew: Yeah, but I’m curious! I’m just curious because it’s not really addressed.
Eric: No, we have to know what’s the reason! I feel…
Andrew: And does she have trouble maybe gathering up the right memories to do it?
Eric: I like to think she has a lot of happy memories to pull from. I think it’s just the circumstantial stuff, right? So this isn’t a thing where you can learn an incantation, practice the wand movement, and be good always forever after. The ability to conjure… even Harry does struggle sometimes with conjuring a Patronus when he’s faced with incredible odds or is in a pinch, and so Hermione, I think, just doesn’t have Harry’s reaction… reflexes. The further Hermione gets from the classroom, the further all of her magic falls apart.
Andrew: Oh.
Laura: Yeah, I agree with you. I think Hermione is someone who tends to crack under pressure, right? I mean, we see that as far back as Book 1 with the Devil’s Snare, where she’s like, “We haven’t got any wood to light a fire!”
Andrew: She can be pretty reactive. I mean, we were just talking in the last chapter about how she… I was criticizing her for being so hard on Harry when she realizes that Harry is accessing Voldemort’s mind again, so yeah.
Micah: I also think it comes down to the fact that Harry is pissed in this moment, and it’s pure emotion flowing out of him, which I think helps in the casting of the Patronus, whereas, as you all were talking about, Hermione is probably very frantic in this moment and doesn’t necessarily have a clear head with everything that’s going on.
Laura: I want to bring us to an end here to this chapter just by calling out a “Max that” moment. We really need to see Harry helping the Muggle-borns escape the Ministry before they get locked in.
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Laura: We didn’t get this in the movie. It would be great to see this in the show.
Eric: It’s such a good moment. It’s Harry being a hero and actually saving people. He doesn’t get to do this till May 2, ten months from now.
[Laura laughs]
Andrew: It is surprising this didn’t make it into the movie.
Laura: Right?
Andrew: I mean, this is important. This is a righteous moment. This is, you know, “We broke the system.” It’s a good rebellion moment.
Micah: High risk.
Eric: Yeah, extremely high risk.
Micah: I forgot about this scene altogether.
Laura: Right!
Andrew and Eric: Yeah.
Laura: Well, because in the movie they do focus on Mary Cattermole and their attempt to save her and get her out, and so I think they just kind of let her be the stand-in for all the rest of the Muggle-borns that get rescued. But I think it’s a more powerful message if you show how many people get saved here.
Micah: Right. And the direction is – I mean, going back to the conversation earlier – “Go home, get your kids, get your family, and leave the country if you need to.”
Eric: “Get out.”
Micah: Which, again, it ties into World War II and Nazi Germany…
Laura: Totally.
Micah: … when the Jews, as well as others, literally had to flee because there was no alternative.
Eric: Yeah. The hope is that another country will take you in or be better and less horrible than this one. It’s pretty sad.
Laura: Yeah. Well, I just want to give us one final thought here, just because this has been a theme for the last couple of episodes. Calling back to last week, Andrew, you brought up that point of sometimes you’ve just got to rip the bandaid off when it comes to acting on a plan.
Andrew: Right.
Laura: When it comes to Harry and Hermione’s disagreement about waiting, who do we think was right, ultimately? I mean, they get the Horcrux, right?
Andrew: Yeah, the job does get done. Harry saved some people. I think it was an exciting read, these last two chapters. These are kids trying to formulate a plan with no adults, seemingly, by their own choice.
Eric: All right, I believe somebody can break into… sorry to cut you off. I believe somebody can break into the Ministry today, but if it happens again, say, 20 years from now, and other kids get into the Ministry and get out unscathed… I’d be very surprised if it would happen twice, is all I’m saying.
Andrew: Yeah, somebody in our chat in our Discord earlier did mention, “It’s easy for us in our 30s to criticize these kids.”
Laura: Of course.
Andrew: Which of course we do do a lot, and it is interesting reading this as an older person.
Eric: We criticize because we care.
Andrew: Yeah. TLDR, it all worked out in the end. So I think it was fine, the plan. The only thing I would say is it should have just been Harry with the Invisibility Cloak going in, I guess.
Eric: Yeah, I don’t know if Ron and Hermione would let him go alone.
Micah: Should have gone to Umbridge’s house.
Andrew: Yep, that too.
Eric: Yeah. I mean, I just think of all these people that Harry rescues would have been probably thrown in Azkaban, and so it’s good… I think he was right because he could do some good here. He’s not right because he had a great plan that succeeded; I think it succeeded as an afterthought. But he did manage to save some lives.
Andrew and Laura: Yeah.
Lynx Line
Laura: Well, that wraps up this week’s chapter, and brings us to this week’s Lynx Line question, which you can answer by supporting us over at Patreon.com/MuggleCast. This week’s question is: Umbridge has kitten plates. What cute decor item immediately tells you someone is evil?
Andrew: [laughs] This is a fun question. What was tripping me up was the “cute” part of cute decor item. So I have settled on fake flowers or plants. That’s suspicious.
Laura: What are you saying?
Andrew: I’m saying it’s kind of two-faced. Like, “Oh, look at my plants,” but they’re actually not real. There’s just something wrong… and look, I will also add, I have some fake plants, but mostly real ones. I just think it’s tacky to have fake plants. But again, I do have some.
Micah: Well, you’re evil. You’re Slytherin.
Andrew: Yeah, yeah. Totally.
Laura: I mean, I have exclusively fake plants because I’m not good at keeping them alive.
Andrew: Laura, Laura, Laura.
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Laura: So I choose the fake plants so that I don’t kill the real ones.
Andrew: Uh-huh. I see.
Eric: An act of compassion.
Laura: But maybe you’re on to me. I’m evil.
Andrew: Sorry, that’s all I could think of. I really like Eric’s.
Micah: That’s okay.
Eric: I think that we can all agree on… in fact, I don’t think I’ll find any detractors in this, but it is also something that is, I think, ultimately kind of cute, which is the Elf on the Shelf.
Andrew: That’s a good one.
Eric: It’s cute, right? Those guys are a little cute. But the story behind them is very sinister; Santa has a helper that will watch you and make sure that you’re good every year, and so it’s like a sentinel deployed to keep children in line with a rosy cheeks and smile on its face, and it’s tiny and it’s creepy and it’s always looking at you. Yeah, those people are evil, I’m declaring.
Andrew: The kids love ’em.
Laura: For me, I’ve got to go with any time somebody’s home or office is exclusively decorated in artwork that has inspirational slogans on it.
Andrew: [laughs] Oh, I thought Laura was going to be coming for me because of my fake plant comment.
Laura: No.
Eric: Yeah, like a Super Mario riding Yoshi figurine…
Andrew: “Whoever has Bruce Springsteen posters on their wall.” [laughs]
Laura: Oh, no, no, not that. No, think about the old poster – I think we’ve all seen it – of the people skydiving, and it just says, “Teamwork,” right? That kind of “Teamwork makes the dream work” shit. If that is exclusively how you decorate your home or your office, I’m suspicious of you.
Andrew: Agreed.
Eric: You don’t find those posters inspirational, Laura?
Laura: No. No, rage-inducing, actually.
[Laura and Micah laugh]
Eric: Who hurt you?
Laura: Corporate America hurt me.
Eric: Fair enough.
[Laura laughs]
Micah: I couldn’t really land on “cute,” to Andrew’s point, but I think anybody who has clowns, whether it’s dolls or it’s framed photos of a clown… something just doesn’t sit right with me.
Andrew: Okay, interesting.
Laura: I know you mean those little decorative clown figurines, and there are some people who collect hundreds of them.
Micah: Lots of them.
Laura: Yeah, yeah, it’s creepy.
Eric: It’s just like, “Are these…?” Yeah, they’re kind of sinister.
Andrew: Well, Micah, next time you visit Vegas, I think you need to stay a night in the world famous Clown Motel, which is an hour outside of Vegas in Tonopah, Nevada. And… oh, it’s three hours away. Okay, not too close. But I did drive by once, and it looks pretty terrifying. And I think you would hate it.
[Andrew and Micah laugh]
Micah: Great, let’s go.
Andrew: Okay, so turning to patrons now. RachelPuff said, “Not an item but a lack of items – boring beige decor trend. Have a personality, please!”
Eric and Laura: Yeah.
Eric: ThatBatLady says, “‘Live Love Laugh’ signage.”
Laura: Oh, that’s a good one.
Eric: Yeah, that’s crazy.
Micah: John agrees with Rachel. “A lack of items. No art or books doesn’t look good.”
Laura: Matthew says,
“Those displays of decorative spoons give me the willies. Who travels the world collecting little spoons? Monsters, that’s who.”
Eric: Yeah, okay.
Andrew: Rachel said,
“For me, it’s a lack of items. An office with nothing on the walls or no personal effects on a desk is fishy. Or just sad. Unless it’s a shared workspace and you’re not allowed to personalize it.”
Okay, fair enough.
Eric: Yeah, yeah. Cassandra says,
“I dislike those decorative boards with sayings on them like ‘Live Laugh Love,’ or ‘Our Home is Made for Happiness.’ They could be just covering up the darkness below.”
Wow, people really don’t like that performative, general audiences, one size fits all…
Laura: You know what? I agree.
Micah: I know what our next patron gift should be. A “Live, Laugh, Love…”
Andrew: Oh my gosh. “Live, Laugh, MuggleCast.”
Eric: “Live, Laugh, Lovegood.”
Andrew: Oh, yeah, “Live, Laugh, Lovegood.”
Micah: Zachary says,
“Anything LA Dodgers-related. There’s only one team with the blue and white and it’s the pinstriped Bronx Bombers.”
[Laura laughs]
Micah: Well, Zachary, I feel like you got your wish since the Dodgers are not in the World Series.
Eric: I feel like you got what you wanted with this latest sweep.
Andrew: Go Brewers.
Laura: And finally, Carlee says,
“Neutrals-only/all beige. I’m an elementary teacher so I’m thinking specifically of teachers that decorate with ‘rainbows’ but they’re not actual rainbow colors… they’re all drab, beige-ified versions of the rainbow. That, and AI-generated decor!”
Andrew: Oh.
Laura: That’s a good call-out, actually. There’s some really bad AI-generated decor out there.
Andrew: Hmm. I haven’t seen that stuff. But yeah, I know a couple people with homes that are just like… there’s no personality, no family photos, no personal photos. It’s interesting. Anyway, listeners, if you have any feedback about today’s episode, you can contact us by sending an email or a voice memo to MuggleCast@gmail.com. Also, feel free to reach out via Spotify or YouTube or DM us on social. Next week, Chapter by Chapter continues with Chapter 14 of Deathly Hallows, “The Thief.”
Quizzitch
Andrew: And before we wrap up, it’s time for the answer to this week’s Quizzitch question.
[Quizzitch music plays]
Eric: For the question: What is the title of Rita Skeeter’s biography of Armando Dippet, the guy who was headmaster before Albus Dumbledore? The answer is Armando Dippet: Master or Moron? That’s pretty funny because I think that title goes… it’s almost more offensive than The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore.
Laura: Right.
Eric: Master or Moron? If I were Armando Dippet… we don’t know if he’s dead or alive, but if I were Armando Dippet, I’d be pretty insulted by that.
Micah: Chamber of Secrets, moron.
Andrew: Also, the fact that she also wrote a book on Dippet, I think, lends authority to the book on Dumbledore.
Eric: Yes.
Laura: Of course.
Andrew: It’s not like it’s her first rodeo about reporting on Hogwarts.
Micah: Dumbledore is going to sell better, though.
Andrew: Oh, definitely.
Micah: Nobody really cares about Dippet.
Andrew: Well, not us, but I guess…
Eric: He does not seem to have left a legacy, except the murders that…
Micah: Which could be scandalous, I guess, if you get the right people to talk.
Eric: I guess, true. The correct answers were submitted by Carlee and HallowWolf, but we did get one of my favorite honorable mention answers, which is Becky suggested, “Dippin’ it Like Dippet.”
[Andrew and Laura laugh]
Andrew: That’s fun.
Micah: That’s actually better.
Eric: Thanks to all who are playing Quizzitch live, and if you’re playing at home, hope you got it.
Andrew: Visit MuggleCast.com for links to our social media, our Patreon, our transcripts, our favorite episodes, and lots more. Don’t forget, now through Friday, November 13, you can become a patron and sign up to receive the MuggleCast Pensieve. This is a journal we’re going to be sending out to all Slug Club members. It’s going to help you gather your thoughts on the TV show; the book has prompts in it for each episode. We’re really proud of this, so please visit Patreon.com/MuggleCast and become a member. Support us today. Thank you, everybody, so much, and thanks for listening. I’m Andrew.
Eric: I’m Eric.
Micah: I’m Micah.
Laura: And I’m Laura.
Andrew: See y’all next week. Bye.
Laura and Micah: Bye.
Displaying MC_774.txt.