Transcript #354

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #354, Yates on Mute


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, the Harry Potter podcast discussing everything about J.K. Rowling’s wizarding world. Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 354. I’m Andrew.

Micah Tannenbaum: I’m Micah.

Andrew: And Eric should be here, but he apparently seems to have overslept or was murdered or something. We honestly don’t know; he’s not responding, so pray for Eric. Hopefully he will show up at some point during the show today. But we do have a guest this week, one of our patrons, Ken! Welcome to the show.

Ken: Thank you! Excited to be here.

Andrew: Podcasting from Boston, where it’s in the teens today, huh?

Ken: It is. It’s a little chilly here.

Andrew: Okay. Maybe that’s what happened to Eric; he froze to death.

Micah: Are you excited for the Super Bowl? Are you a football fan? The Patriots?

Ken: I can’t say I’m a big football fan, but I am torn because my family’s all from Philadelphia but I live in Boston, so it’s a split for both sides, I guess.

Micah: And Andrew, Philly, right?

Andrew: I’m Philly. I’m rooting for the Eagles.

Ken: Oh, you’re from Jersey, so you have to.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Micah: Yeah, I am too. I’m a Jets fan, so I do not like the Patriots…

Ken: Fair enough.

Micah: … so it makes it very easy.

Andrew: But I mean, the Patriots have won too many times already, so who wants them to win anyway?

Ken: I know; the Eagles have it coming.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. They’d better win. Wow, this is the straightest discussion we’ve ever had on MuggleCast. Let’s get back to Harry Potter.

[Ken laughs]

Micah: You’re welcome.

Andrew: Micah has been waiting for this moment for 13 years. [laughs] Let’s get your fandom ID, Ken. What are your favorite Harry Potter book and movie?

Ken: Okay, so for book and movie, it’s both the Half-Blood Prince. For book, second place is kind of Order of the Phoenix. They’re both just really… I guess Half-Blood Prince is where it all starts to get explained and you get more details, plus the whole Dumbledore at the end section is just… it’s a great book.

Andrew: Yeah. What are your Ilvermorny and Hogwarts Houses?

Ken: So Hogwarts, I’m a Ravenclaw. Ilvermorny, I’m a Pukwudgie.

Andrew: Is that a good combo? I guess so.

Ken: I’m not sure. I feel like a lot of people tend to match up, but I guess Pukwudgie is pretty common, so it’s fine.

Andrew: Yeah. What’s your Patronus? As decided by Pottermore.

Ken: Pottermore let me know that it was a white stallion. I honestly don’t know much about it, but we’ll go with it.

Andrew: [laughs] Most people know nothing about their Patronus. We have a big article on Hypable with a list of all the Patronuses, and we get so many people searching for, like, “What does white stallion Patronus mean?”

Ken: Yeah, I googled it and it was pretty vague. I guess there’s a lot of mythological references to white stallions, as far as warriors and the sun god and things like that, but I don’t know.

Andrew: Do you have a favorite piece of Harry Potter merchandise that you own?

Ken: Well, since it’s 12 degrees here, I’m going to have to go with my Ravenclaw scarf. But as you were mentioning – I think it was last week you talked about the understated Harry Potter merchandise – I’m a big fan of those pieces, so I have a Ravenclaw tie that I’ll wear to work sometimes…

Andrew: Ah, nice.

Ken: … and it kind of flies under the radar, but every once in a while somebody will be like, “Is that…?” Like, “It is.” [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. Do you have a Globus Mundi sweater yet? They’re all the rage. [laughs]

Ken: I do not. I’m going to the theme park this summer, so maybe I’ll pick one up.

Andrew: Oh, good. Yeah, yeah, good. What’s your favorite book cover? Getting back to our discussion from a couple weeks ago.

Ken: Order of the Phoenix is my favorite one.

Andrew: Oh, okay. That’s interesting that your favorite book and movie are Half-Blood Prince, but not favorite cover.

Ken: Yeah, I’m a big fan of blues, so a blue cover… it’s all very, I don’t know, soothing? [laughs]

Andrew: Hashtag monochromatic.

Ken: Yes.

Andrew: And this relates to our discussion later in today’s episode: Who is your favorite LGBTQ character in the Harry Potter series?

Ken: Well, since none actually existed in the text…

[Andrew laughs]

Ken: … I’m going to have to go with Scorbus, and I’m going to stand by it. They’re meant to be.

Andrew: Yeah, that was a trick question. I was expecting you to say Dumbledore, and then I was going to be like, “Oh, me too. That’s so crazy.” [laughs]

Ken: No, Scorbus.

Andrew: But you’re right. They don’t exist in the text.

Ken: No, all after the fact.

Andrew: And related to that, who is your favorite explicitly straight relationship in the series?

Ken: I mean, there’s so many to choose from. How can you choose? But I guess I would say Tonks and Remus. They’re pretty cute.

Andrew: All right. Well, welcome to the show. It’s nice to have you here. Thanks for your support.

Ken: Of course.

Andrew: And yeah, we’re going to talk about this Dumbledore drama that happened. I will tell our listeners now, I’m not going to be as critical as you might think. I have cooled off on the issue over the past couple days, after reflecting on it more and seeing J.K. Rowling’s responses. But there are things to be concerned about, and we’ll talk about those later. First, there really wasn’t any news over the past week after Celebration of Harry Potter, but there was one of these annual Harry Potter book nights that occurred, I think mostly in England, and Bloomsbury announced that the Harry Potter series has now sold a certain number of books worldwide. Would you two like to guess what that number is?

Ken: I’ll let you go first, Micah. [laughs]

Micah: I feel like I’m going to be way off. I’m guessing it’s in the millions.

[Andrew laughs]

Ken: It has to be in the millions.

Andrew: I would hope so.

Ken: Hundreds of millions?

Micah: Probably.

Andrew: Yes.

Micah: I’m going to go with 540 million.

Ken: I’ll go with 300 million, just to keep it interesting.

Andrew: Yeah, Micah was closest. It’s 500 million. They hit that milestone.

Micah: But I went over, so Ken wins.

Andrew: Yeah, all right.

Ken: Price Is Right.

Micah: Yes, that’s right.

Andrew: That’s pretty crazy, I guess.

Ken: Is that including audiobooks or…?

Andrew: No, I think it’s print.

Ken: Okay.

Andrew: I mean, it’s not as big as the Bible, but we’re getting up there.

Micah: Think of all the trees that were destroyed in the making of Harry Potter.

Andrew: Well, I bet that includes Kindle as well. Harry Potter still has a ways to go before catching up to the Bible.

Micah: Well, the Bible’s been around a little longer, too.

Ken: Just a few years.

Andrew: But according to this informational… this infographic I’m looking at, Harry Potter is the most popular book ever in print, besides the Bible, and this other one, Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tung?

Micah: Mao Zedong?

Andrew: Are you being serious? I don’t know.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Ken: Yeah, he was the ruler.

Andrew: Oh, see, I didn’t know that. Okay. Congrats to Harry Potter, but I do wonder how many of these are duplicate owners? How many…? So I feel like maybe 50 million of that 500 million are copies of the book sitting in a house that already has copies of a book, right? Because we all buy multiple copies.

Ken: Probably.

Micah: Yeah, that’s a good point. If you think about the seven book series, then how many people own the adult edition from the UK? How many own the kids’ edition from the UK? And then hardcover versus paperback? And the list could go on and on.

Andrew: Yeah, and you look at the popularity of the illustrated editions. I would love to know the stats, like, “One in five people who read the original series are buying the illustrated series” or something like that. All right, so just some interesting information I wanted to share. Congrats to Harry Potter. Maybe they should put a Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone in every hotel room around the world; you know how there’s a Bible in the desk of every hotel room? Why not put a copy of Harry Potter in there?

Ken: That’d be perfect; then I can stop packing mine.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Exactly. Andrew, I think you should start the trend; every time you go down to Orlando and stay at one of the Universal Resorts, I think you should just leave a book in the hotel room that you stay. Put it on top of the Bible.

Andrew: [laughs] If MuggleCast is willing to put up the money to buy these books that I distribute in every hotel room I stay in, then yes, I will.

Micah: I think Scholastic should sponsor you in this.

Andrew: [laughs] But you think about it, there have been studies showing that people who read Harry Potter learn empathy, are smart, make the world a better place… I think it would help the world if there’s a copy of Harry Potter in every hotel room.

Micah: And that’s going to lead probably into our next discussion.

Andrew: Yes. But first, I just want to mention there’s a movement going on in the livestream over at Patreon right now; we are starting the “Prayers for Eric” hashtag as we wonder where he is. Before we get to our news this week, Micah, we have a sponsor.

Micah: Yeah, before we continue, we’d like to let you know that this week’s episode is being brought to you by Bright Cellars. Have you ever tried an Accio spell without any luck? Well, now’s your chance to really make some magic happen.

[Ad break]

Andrew: Yeah, I mean, you mentioned how many times do you try to use Accio? I legit try to use Accio in the real world, so I’m glad that Bright Cellars is making that work for wine.

Micah: Definitely. I’ve witnessed this when I visit you…

Andrew: You’ve used Accio?

Micah: No, no, no. When I was visiting Chicago, we were hanging out, you were playing a game on your Nintendo Switch. You were trying to use Accio to get the remote, to get the controller, to do all these things, and I know poor Brooklyn had to get up off the couch, retrieve it for you, and bring it back.

Andrew: [laughs] I mean, that is the best spell in the wizarding world. No? It’s just so helpful. Fighting a dragon? No problem, summon your broom from a mile away.

Micah: I didn’t really buy into that, by the way.

Andrew: I didn’t either.

Micah: That was a shortcut, in my opinion. He really needed to have prepared better for that first Triwizard task than just summoning the broom.


Main Discussion: David Yates’s comments on Dumbledore’s sexuality


Andrew: Well, David Yates might be wishing he could summon some better PR people to help him get through interviews. The fandom was shook this week when Entertainment Weekly asked Fantastic Beasts director David Yates if Dumbledore’s sexuality would be mentioned, included, in this upcoming sequel this November, The Crimes of Grindelwald. He said,

“Not explicitly. But I think all the fans are aware of that. He had a very intense relationship with Grindelwald when they were young men. They fell in love with each other’s ideas and ideology and each other. He’s a maverick and a rebel and he’s an inspiring teacher at Hogwarts. He’s witty and has a bit of an edge. He’s not this elder statesman. He’s a really kinetic guy. And opposite Johnny Depp as Grindelwald, they make an incredible pairing.”

So I read this, and I was honestly not surprised initially. And then I started seeing other people take notice of these comments, and a lot of the Internet was pissed, and then I got pissed. The reason being, at this point in Dumbledore and Grindelwald’s “friendship,” “relationship,” whatever, they’ve already fallen apart. Grindelwald is off doing his thing; Dumbledore is now a professor at Hogwarts. Dumbledore’s love, in theory, his strongest love for Grindelwald, that has now already passed, so for Dumbledore to come into the Fantastic Beasts series and presumably tell Newt about Grindelwald, about his friendship? About his relationship? To not explicitly mention that he was in love with this guy seems BS. And in this world where we see Hollywood studios shying away from including gay characters in their films to not hurt the box office, you can’t help but think that they purposely are cutting it out or delaying it because they don’t want to hurt the box office. And it’s bull… shoot [laughs] because J.K. Rowling always preaches inclusion and acceptance, and she’s a champion of the LGBT community, so this has upset a lot of people, and I don’t blame them. Ken, how did you react to this news?

Ken: I feel like it was kind of a mix. I was definitely initially really annoyed, because I just assumed that that was going to be a piece of this film with… I kind of always just imagined that it would be information included with a flashback about Ariana and the fight that went down between everyone and ultimately her death. I guess that could come later in the film, but it just felt really frustrating that it was getting pushed again. But at the same time, I can’t say I was surprised because it is just so typical of a lot of movies just to mention it on the side, or have an allusion to it without directly addressing it.

Andrew: And the other problem with David Yates’s stupid comment – remember, he upset the fandom a couple months ago about Johnny Depp to the point where J.K. Rowling had to release a statement on her website, which she never does – this line, “Not explicitly. But I think all the fans are aware of that.” What? You’re saying that you don’t have to include it in the movie because fans already know? That is the biggest piece of nonsense. That is the stupidest excuse for not including it. Why adapt these into movies at all if the fans know everything because they read the books? Was this his excuse for not including Dumbledore’s funeral in Half-Blood Prince? “Oh, they already know he was buried. I mean, we don’t need to include that.” That was just a really poor choice of words.

Ken: At least for me, it just harkened back to a lot of the “I’m okay with it, I just don’t want to hear about it” kind of attitude, or “I don’t want to see it” kind of attitude, so it was a little teeth-gritting.

Andrew: Right, right. Gay Dumbledore wasn’t in the books and movies, but J.K. Rowling wedged it in after. “Dumbledore is gay in Fantastic Beasts, but fans already know that, so we’re not going to include that in the actual movie.” So like I said, there was a lot of backlash on Twitter, and in fact, J.K. Rowling noticed. A lot of people were coming to her on Twitter asking, “What the hell? This is a big mistake. Why are you doing this?” She released two statements over two days. First of all, she tweeted, “Being sent abuse about an interview that didn’t involve me, about a screenplay I wrote but which none of the angry people have read, which is part of a five-movie series that’s only one installment in, is obviously tons of fun, but you know what’s even more fun?” And then she included a GIF of somebody hitting mute, meaning she was muting abusive people. And look, people should not be abusive to her or to anybody ever, so while I agree people should not be abusive… well, let me read the second tweet before making my point here. Her second tweet was “Lucky I have no intention of doing it, then,” referring to removing Dumbledore’s sexuality. “Oh, and believing every bit of Potter clickbait? Foolish. Just saying. (Winky face.) #Dumbledore, #FantasticBeasts.” So what sat wrong with me about these tweets is that she’s mad at us, and I’m referring to the Internet on a whole, for getting mad at her director’s comments. It’s not our fault he said these things. She shouldn’t be… I think we deserve an answer here, and something that’s not sarcastic and calling content online clickbait. Her director said, “No, he’s not explicitly going to be gay, because fans already know that.” That is just a dumb statement, and because it’s her director, she should take the high road on this, and I thought she should have at least tweeted or maybe made another post on her website saying, “Hey, yeah, Dumbledore is going to be gay in these movies. Don’t worry about it. It is a five-part series. I’m going to work into it.” Right? I mean, I just think she approached this wrong.

Micah: I think that this was another instance where David Yates probably should have just not said anything. And this goes back to – you referenced it, Andrew – but his comments related to Johnny Depp, and now he’s making another comment about Dumbledore’s sexuality, and it seems to only lead down a road that causes this negative feedback, and rightly so in both cases. It’s frustrating to see, as you said, the director of a film series which has created this community that, as you noted here, has traditionally been all about inclusion, all about acceptance of all people from all walks of life, and yet we see these comments being made, and the reaction… it’s saddening.

Andrew: A lot of people are on J.K. Rowling’s side as well. I’m seeing somebody in the chat say, “Why would Dumbledore talk to Newt about his love life?” Well, yes, I don’t expect Dumbledore to be like, “So here’s what I’ve been up to with the boys recently,” but I think it’s absolutely relevant to this story. Dumbledore and Grindelwald are at odds. Why does Dumbledore have this relationship, this bad relationship, that he does with Grindelwald in this movie? It stems from this romance! That is why this story is so epic. He has to duel this guy he fell in love with. It’s completely relevant to the story.

Micah: It is relevant to the story, but at the same time, we don’t know what is going to be included in these flashback scenes – I think Ken brought that up earlier – between Dumbledore and Grindelwald. Going back to what happened with Ariana, we know that younger versions of both of those characters have been cast; you would think that they’re going to explore some of this in those scenes. The other thing that came to mind, too, is this confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald. It’s not coming until, presumably, the last film. They have a lot of time to be able to build up to this and to create this history between these two characters. I also thought about the fact that Jude Law spent a lot of time with J.K. Rowling, learning about Dumbledore. We haven’t seen Jude Law yet portray Dumbledore. In a way, Dumbledore needs to be reintroduced to the series, so there is still opportunity here for the relationship to come to the forefront. So Andrew, I’m just interested what you think about that.

Andrew: Yeah, I think J.K. Rowling hinted that, too, saying that this is a five-part film series in that tweet. So yes, I think she will eventually get to it, especially now that there’s been so much backlash. [laughs] However, she announced this in 2007, after the books came out, and there’s always been this lingering kind of disappointment, like, “Why wasn’t…?” Yes, of course, it wasn’t relevant to the Harry Potter stories, but it just… it’s like, why does she wedge it in after? Why mention it at all? And then Harry Potter and the Cursed Child happened about two years ago, and as Ken said at the top of this show, you really think that Scorpius and Albus are going to be getting together, or at least sort of falling for each other, but then it gets “No homo’d” at the end when Scorpius kisses Rose, which just barely makes sense because Rose is barely in the story. So there was that introduction after the books came out, there was Scorbus, and now there’s this. It’s like it was teed up and ready to go. It would have been so easy to please us. And we need some good news from this series. We need… this is one of the redeeming qualities about Fantastic Beasts and this being about Grindelwald, it’s that we would see Dumbledore’s interest in him. That would interest a lot of fans. So it’s just like, why couldn’t it happen now? Why are we waiting till 2020? Are we even going to be alive in 2020? I mean, Eric apparently died overnight. Like, poor guy, he didn’t get to see any of this come to light. Or maybe we’re waiting till 2022 for Fantastic Beasts 4, or maybe Movie 5. Who the hell knows? I just think, why are we waiting?

Micah: I mean, taking a step back for a second, don’t you think that it needs to be built up? Let’s say you’re coming into this series not having the subtext of the previous relationship, not knowing the Potter series. There are people who I’m sure are seeing Fantastic Beasts that have never seen Harry Potter, that don’t listen to these podcasts, that don’t know about the history of Dumbledore and Grindelwald. Don’t you think that it needs to have its proper buildup? I don’t think he’s saying that it’s not going to be included at all, and I think J.K. Rowling validated that part of it a little bit by saying, “Hey, look, I’m the one writing the script. I know what’s in it. This is a five-part movie series. Let’s get to that point.”

Andrew: Yeah. No, I think it does have to be built up. I don’t think Dumbledore should just walk on screen and be like, [emotionally] “I loved Grindelwald, Newt. He was everything to me, and he didn’t love me back.” But there could have been like, “Newt, I need to tell you something about Grindelwald. There’s a reason why I’m so shook over him. It’s because I loved him.” And everybody would be like, “Oh, shoot.” [laughs]

Micah: But don’t you still think that can happen? Or are you just taking Yates at his word here? I mean, maybe for Fantastic Beasts 2?

Andrew: Not for number two, because I would classify that as being explicitly gay. But maybe in this movie, Dumbledore will have a glimmer in his eye when he looks at a photo of Grindelwald or something, [laughs] and they’re going to be like, “Ew, you like Johnny Depp?” But yeah, I think the reason I’ve cooled off on this is because I do look forward to seeing how J.K. Rowling inserts this plot point in future movies. I just wish it was coming sooner, because it looks like we still have about two and a half years to wait, at best, before we get explicit comments from Dumbledore talking about his love for Grindelwald.

Micah: So one question I did want to ask you was if you could wipe the slate clean here, and there’s no Yates comment, there’s none of this that’s going on, and you’re looking ahead to Fantastic Beasts: Crimes of Grindelwald, what would you like to see with respect to this particular dynamic? This relationship?

Andrew: Well, first of all, I would have titled the film Fantastic Beasts: The Sexuality of Dumbledore. I think that would draw in a lot more viewers. [laughs] I think exactly what I just said: In a meeting between Dumbledore and Newt, Dumbledore is explaining how he knew Grindelwald – like you said, we’re getting these flashback scenes as well – and just a line. Just a line. “I loved him.” That’s it. I really think that’s all I would need. And Dumbledore looking a little pained in that moment, and Newt being like, “Oh my God, I know a gay person finally,” and then Queenie is like, “Yaaass, yaaass, werk.” [laughs] How about you, Ken? What would you have liked to see?

Ken: I mean, I think the best kind of films at this point that are identifying it or are addressing it are the ones where it doesn’t have to be an explicit plot line of the characters; it’s just a piece of their makeup and it’s not the whole story. It’s just, “This is an interesting piece about them, but it’s just one piece about them,” so still having that in there somewhere as a piece of their makeup, because it is important to who he is as a character and the story. Just having that in there somewhere is, I think, important.

Andrew: And it would be a huge moment for Hollywood, this major franchise finally including a gay character openly in the series. They would beat Star Wars. They would beat Marvel. They would beat Tolkien world. It just would have been incredible. Star Trek, in fairness, I think they did include something in their most recent film, but it wasn’t too heavy-handed. But it would just be major; J.K. Rowling has that power. She could make this amazing thing happen, and for some reason, she decided, “Meh, later.”

Ken: I think what makes it surprising for me is that she is so politically active and so politically minded that she is aware of what’s going on in the world and how important it is for not just the gay community, but also all different kinds of underrepresented groups to see themselves in literature and in films and have that recognization.

Micah: You were also making a point before the show about the timeframe in which this is all taking place and how that could potentially be playing a role into all this.

Ken: Right, keep in mind the film’s set in the 1920s, so historically, it wouldn’t have been something that would have been completely out in the open. It would have been a lot of what we’re thinking might be coming in this one, as those glances and long stares that have those undertone meanings that you’re supposed to read into it. So maybe it’s a little bit more historically accurate, but at the same time, I feel like she also mentioned something about the wizarding world being more progressive in a lot of ways than their Muggle counterparts, so…

Andrew and Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: And it’s her wizarding world; she can do whatever she wants. It is fictional. It’s filled with fantastic creatures.

Micah: Yeah, just to go off of Ken’s point, though, I mean, you see Seraphina Picquery, an African American female, as president of MACUSA, and when you compare that to the fact that we only elected an African American president eight years ago here in the United States, they are being far more progressive in the wizarding world, even in that time, compared to where we are today.

Andrew: Yeah. And I do also want to say that, in fairness and in praise of J.K. Rowling, she created a story and a fandom that welcomed all types of people. The fandom… I don’t know when I would have come out as gay if it weren’t for the Harry Potter fandom. It was an inclusive place. It was still hard to come out, but the people, the friends I made in the fandom, they helped make it easier. So to her credit, while I don’t agree with her choice for this movie, she has absolutely done things for the LGBT community and other communities. She created a community that is accepting of all people. Let’s see some other comments now from people on Patreon. Morgan says, and I think Morgan is right, “This could still very well happen in the second movie. I wonder if there will be some dialogue that does hint towards Grindelwald and Dumbledore’s relationship, but not explicitly. Maybe that’s all Yates meant? There’s definitely better ways to say it, though.” Yeah, so maybe we’ll get a hint, a longing stare at Grindelwald’s picture.

Micah: Maybe Yates should just be the one that’s put on mute for a while.

Andrew: [laughs] Right, I agree with that.

Micah: That’s the title of the show. “Yates on Mute.”

Andrew: [laughs] James says – getting back to the Star Trek thing I mentioned – he said, “Yeah, Mr. Sulu was gay in Star Trek Beyond. He was shown to have a male partner and a daughter, but it was only for about ten seconds.” And then, remember when Beauty and the Beast…? Wasn’t there some… there was a hint of Lumière being gay, right? It was just a glance or something? So it’s like there’s all these hints in these movies lately, but not something explicitly gay, and it’s time to get explicitly gay.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: What’s so funny, Micah?

Micah: Just the way that you said that.

Andrew: LeFou, sorry. LeFou, not Lumière. LeFou. This is why I love having the chat; people can correct me. All right, I think that’s all we have to say there.


Groundhog Day beasts


Andrew: In honor of Groundhog Day, we’re going to do a little fun segment that Eric came up with. By the way, still no response from Eric. [laughs]

Micah: Hope he’s all right. In all seriousness, this has now been, what, 45 minutes? And no response from him.

Andrew: Yeah, normally he’s like, 10 minutes late. Now he’s 46 minutes late. That’s real bad.

[Ad break]

Andrew: And I’m just thinking now, if we had Accio in the real world, I could Accio Eric right now, and he would fly a couple miles east. He would slam against my window; that would wake him up. Or he’d fly out of Lake Michigan ten feet under. God, I really hope he’s not dead.

Ken: You’d have a lot of Memory charms to do.

Andrew: Yeah. I really hope he’s not dead. It’s going to be super awkward.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: I’d have to do a lot of editing on this show. I joke, because I’m pretty sure he’s not actually dead. [laughs]

Micah: Hungover, maybe.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: And then next episode, 355, he’s going to have to explain what exactly he was doing the night before. But I guess we can read… I mean, probably not going to provide as much color as he would to this fantastic beast that he created for Groundhog’s Day.

Andrew: Yeah, he came up with this segment, too, so it’s a shame he’s not here. But could you do it in Eric’s voice, Micah? We all love your voice, but I think we’d like to hear your Eric impression, or if not your Eric impression, do it as Southern Hagrid or another one of your great characters.

Micah: Oh, wow. That’s a lot of pressure.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Geez. Putting me right on the spot here.

Andrew: I can’t do a good Eric. I just… he doesn’t… he has his own thing, for sure, but I don’t really know how to impersonate it.

Micah: And Southern Hagrid takes a little bit to get into, too. Don’t want to offend people. Although I’ve probably done plenty of that in this episode.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, I think you said something about God not being real or something.

Micah: No, I called the Bible fictional.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, that’s right. [laughs]

Micah: Well, let’s read Eric’s.

Andrew: I’ll read it in my best Eric.

Micah: Okay.

Andrew: [imitating Eric] Okay, guys, so for this segment, I had an idea. You know, Groundhog Day just happened. I loved that Groundhog Day movie a few years ago! [back to regular voice] Yeah, yeah, Eric, moving it on. Move along. [imitating Eric again] Okay, okay, okay. So the Punxatawner, P-U-N-X-A-T-A-W-N-E-R. Let me spell that again for everybody. It’s P-U-N-X-A-T-A-W-N-E-R. It’s native to North America. [laughs] This woodland creature pair bonds with another seemingly identical member of its own species. The two have a long courtship ritual, which involves chasing each other through wormholes that exist in the dark matter of each other’s shadows. So vociferously do they chase each other, at about two-thirds way through the winter season, that Muggles have not only noticed, but mistakenly propped up a pair of famous Punxatawners [laughs] in an annual festival. Once a Punxatawner successfully captures its partner by traveling through its shadow and emerging from the other end, it mates and becomes pregnant, and after a six month gestation period, gives birth to two also identical creatures. [laughs] And now I’m going to give you my favorite groundhog movies.

Micah: Groundhog Day?

Andrew: This is from WTAE Pittsburgh. What’s that, Micah?

Micah: Groundhog Day.

Andrew: Let me find my favorite Groundhog Day movies. And oh, you know what I also want to talk about? Groundhog Day scenes from television shows. [back to regular voice] Eric, will you please stop? We don’t want to hear that. [imitating Eric again] Okay, okay, okay.

Micah: [imitating Southern Hagrid] The Punxatawner, native to North America.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: [imitating Southern Hagrid] This woodland creature pair bonds with another seemingly identical member of its own species. The two have a long courtship ritual, which involves chasing each other through them wormholes that exist in the dark matter of each other’s shadows. So vociferously – dang, that’s a bigass word – do they chase each other, about two-thirds of the way through the winter season, that Muggles have not only noticed, but mistakenly propped up a pair of famous Punxatawners in an annual festival.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Oh, Southern Hagrid. That was great. I’m glad he joined for a little bit.

Andrew: That was good. That was great. It’s like a whole different Micah. That’s kind of freaky.

Micah: That was me? I thought that was Ken.

Andrew: [laughs] Ken, what is your creature?

Ken: Okay, so mine is loosely adapted from some Inca mythology. I’m not a super creative person, so I had to start from somewhere. So mine was the Amaru. It’s a distant cousin to the North American Horned Serpent, and it’s a beast with the body of a serpent, the head of a puma cat, and short, featherless wings that can cause it to be mistaken for a small dragon. It’s located in South America and has been worshiped since the Inca Empire. The Amaru is a creature that is capable of transitioning between environments, living most of its life on land by burrowing into riverbanks. However, when it senses the oncoming monsoon rains, it takes to the water and can be swimming through the rivers in the Amazon, hunting for fish, so the witches and wizards in South America celebrate the Amaru for its ability to predict the approaching monsoons, signaling the South American wizarding community the end of the dry season and the coming of the much needed rains.

Andrew: That was really good. You and Eric did some real research here for this. I like it.

Ken: Keep in mind, it’s loosely adapted, so…

[Andrew and Ken laugh]

Ken: No cultural appropriation intended.

Micah: I can’t even follow that, though.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, so mine is the Simbol. S-I-M-B-O-L.

Micah: Oh, really? Where’d you come up with that?

Andrew: The Simbol.

Micah: Oh. Sounds familiar.

Andrew: Well, and funnily enough, it looks similar to a Muggle podcaster, and every Saturday, around 10:00 a.m., he rises from bed and looks out the window, and depending on how late his co-host is to the episode, determines how much longer we’re going to have of the winter season. And this year, with somebody now 54 minutes late to the show, the Simbol is predicting 54 more weeks of winter.

Micah: You know there’s only 52 weeks in a year, right?

Andrew: [laughs] Well, it’s going to be a super long winter, Micah. Look, I’m just telling you what the Simbol is seeing from his other podcaster. It’s not my fault he’s this late. He raises his wand in the air, he yells, “Accio,” and if the late podcaster comes from the east, we remove ten weeks from the winter forecast. If he comes from the West, we add ten weeks to the winter forecast.

Micah: I just think at this point we’re probably not even going to let him on the show, right?

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: If he shows up?

Andrew: If he showed up right now, yeah, I would say no.

Micah: No, yeah.

Andrew: It’s too late.

Micah: It’s too late. Sorry. Well, I like that. I like that fantastic beast. I think it’s well done, Andrew.

Andrew: Thank you. The Simbol.

Micah: The Simbol. S-I-M, right?

Andrew: Yeah, S-I-M.

Micah: Okay. Well, mine is the Burrowl, and this fantastic beast was actually originally discovered by Newt Scamander. It is indigenous to upstate New York, and the Burrowl has wings, right? As most birds do. But these Burrowls spend their time, in the winter specifically, below the ground, and if, when coming above the ground, their wings change color from blue to red, it signifies the coming of warmer months. And not only that, but as this bird and his flock come from below the ground, if people are around, they engage in this dance, which is called the Burumba. I haven’t actually seen it in person, but I know that Newt knows how to perform it. He’s actually going to be putting out a single after Fantastic Beasts 2, and I’d be interested to see how this dance is performed.

Andrew: That’s interesting. I’m going to change mine to Simbowl, so Sim-B-O-W-L, so it’s like me plus an owl combined. Simbowl.

Micah: Well, so I took that from a burrow owl, which is actually a real creature, and I just combined it together like they would in Pokémon to create a Burrowl. And then I wrote down this whole description, and I can barely read it, so that’s why I was kind of fumbling along in my explanation.

Andrew: You wrote it on pen and paper? That’s so old school.

Micah: I did. I did. Well, I thought it should be… clearly, Eric set the tone here with typing it in, but I thought it should be more of a surprise. It shouldn’t be in the document.

Andrew: Yeah, fair enough.


Listener Feedback


Andrew: All right, so let’s get to some emails, and we also have some voicemails. Looking forward to hearing our listeners’ voices. First of all, we did get a couple of comments about Harry Potter Celebration. Micah and I asked on last week’s episode for people who attended if we could get their feedback. By the way, we only ran into one listener; I’m kind of bummed about that. I’m sorry we didn’t run into more of you.

Micah: They were waiting in line; that’s probably why.

Andrew: [laughs] I guess so, I guess so. Amanda sent a very long email, so I’m not going to read all of it, but she said that she headed down to Celebration kind of on a whim. She hitched a ride with her husband while he was at the Daytona race. And she was a little disappointed with the line situation after being so impressed by Disney World’s organization. On one night, they were sitting and waiting for the Hogwarts show to occur – this was on Friday – for the new Hogwarts light show to occur. They were sitting with a bunch of other people in the park waiting for it to start, and about an hour after waiting, an employee comes up to them, this whole large group of people waiting, and said, oh, there would be no lights that night, and they didn’t know what was going on. [laughs] So everybody left after waiting an hour plus for a Hogwarts light show to happen that never happened, and she had received a push notification on her phone telling her it was going to happen, so that was weird. And actually, I had a similar experience. Look, I love Universal, but it was a little disorganized. When we were there, I believe Friday night, later that night for a press event I was trying to figure out if the park would be open after the light show occurred, and somebody told us no, right, Micah? An employee who was standing right there, they were like, “Oh, yeah, the park’s only open just for the show, and then it’s closing down.” And I was like, “Well, I don’t know if I believe that,” because we just walked into the Leaky Cauldron and they had tons of food available, freshly cooked food. We end up leaving because we’re tired, but sure enough, the park was open till, like, 12:30 that night. Full. Everything was open. So that was strange.

Micah: I’ll read the next one, sure, from Philip, who’s a longtime listener and proud patron of the show. He says,

“Hey guys. Attended the HP Celebration for the first time this year and had an absolute blast. We spent 15 hours straight in the parks on Friday, from 9:00 a.m. all the way through 12:30 a.m.”

So yeah, Andrew, this ties into what you were just saying.

“We visit the Wizarding World at Universal Orlando about six times a year and this was by far the best visit we ever had. We did a little cosplay. Admittedly, it was subtle; we went as Hogwarts alumni and I was able to proudly support the green and silver of my noble House. The energy and passion from the fans was contagious and once again proved Harry Potter fans are some of the coolest people you could ever want to meet. I am a huge MinaLima fan and was able to meet them both (went a little fanboy on them). They were so awesome and talked to me one-on-one for quite a long time, even signed and personalized all five prints I purchased at the event. I totally agree with your observations that the opening ceremony went a little too corporate. The reaction from the crowd after the announcement that the Exhibit was going to Milan was lackluster to say the least. Fantastic Beasts had nowhere near the representation it should have had, and I can only hope they are saving it up for later Celebration events. Your idea of fan-based forums, like MuggleCast, is brilliant. The real energy of the event comes from the fans, and an amphitheater full of MuggleCast listeners would be a blast.”

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Yeah, agree with that.

“I hope you guys had as much fun as we did, and keep up the great work.”

Andrew: Okay, well, thank you for that feedback, Philip. Sounds like you had a great time, so glad to hear that. Have you been to the parks, Ken?

Ken: I haven’t. I’m going in July, so looking forward to it. It’s going to be really hot. Any main tips that I should take with me?

Andrew: Ahh. We actually get this question a lot, and we never actually answer it.

Micah: Have some hot butterbeer so Andrew doesn’t call you out.

[Andrew and Ken laugh]

Andrew: You could probably knock everything out Harry Potter-wise in about two days, so don’t feel like you have to be there for a whole week or something.

Ken: Okay.

Andrew: Get there early because you can probably knock everything out in a day if you really wanted to. So maybe get there early, knock everything out within six/seven hours, and then spend a second day re-exploring everything at your leisure. Diagon Alley, there’s so much to pop in and out of. Feels like a town, whereas Hogsmeade, it’s just like one street, whereas Diagon Alley is multiple streets. So just enjoy the ins and outs of Diagon Alley, I would say.

Ken: Yeah, I feel like I’m going to want to explore every nook and cranny and just see everything.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. The dark area of Diagon Alley, Dervish and Banges. It’s dark and cold in there, so if you need a break, just hang out in there. It’s also like a Hot Topic, I think I said to Micah. [laughs] So emo.

Micah: Yeah, but that’s a good call, especially… you said you may look at going during the summer months?

Ken: Yeah, we’re booked for July.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Ken: So it’s going to be hot.

Micah: Yeah, definitely hit up Nocturn Alley, because it’s air-conditioned over there.

Andrew: Yeah. Nice thing about Diagon Alley, too, is it’s very tall, so I feel like it’s a lot more shaded than Hogsmeade is. So maybe start your morning in Hogsmeade – which is probably the right way to go; you want to start at Hogwarts anyway – and then as the day gets warmer, get over to Diagon Alley, where it’s still going to be hot, but at least there’s a lot more shade. And my only other tip would be make sure you ride the Hogwarts Express both ways, because you see a different show on the train each way.

Ken: Good to know.

Andrew: Yeah. Ooh, we didn’t mention this, Micah: We had a train car on the Hogwarts Express to ourselves with two of our friends we were with. Haley, who’s a listener. We were with her.

Micah: And Robin.

Andrew: And Robin. That was fun. I’d never been in one of those train cars before, just with your own group of friends. Normally you have to share with a couple other people. I wanted to do something really goofy in there. We didn’t; we couldn’t think up something other than me laying across the seats, which was kind of gross, come to think of it. But yeah, that was a neat first time experience just having a train car to ourselves.

Micah: Yeah, it’s definitely cool to do, and would recommend, as Andrew… I don’t know that I’ve ever taken the train from Hogsmeade to Diagon Alley.

Andrew: Oh, should have done that for you.

Micah: Now that you mention that it’s a different show.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, there’s different stuff happening. All right, well, Ken, hope you have a good time there. Post some pictures in the…

Ken: Yeah, it should be fun. I’m looking forward to hearing the voices on the train. Was it Hermione’s voice that you guys said was off?

Andrew: Yes. [laughs] Yeah, you’re going to want to jump out of the train once you hear it. All right, here’s some voicemails now. Let’s listen to this first one.

[Voicemail plays]

“Hey, MuggleCast. My name is Asim. I’m from New York. I’ve been listening since Episode 1. Anyway, I wanted to add to the conversation about book covers from the last episode. After the last book had come out, I was looking for other ways to keep magic in my life, and I happened to stumble upon tarot cards. Time and energy previously used for book sleuthing was now used to study symbolism and the archetypes from the cards and even learning how to do readings. I hope Laura Mallory is listening. Anyway, my favorite archetype is the magician. Traditional depiction has the magician standing with one arm raised skyward, wand in hand, and the other towards the Earth. This position is often interpreted as him having mastered both divine and material energy to conjure what is needed. That’s something that I would call magic. He’s shown standing with relics representing all four suits from the deck, the cups, coins, swords, and wand, indicating that he has mastered the use of all four elements. This also alludes to the concept of the Deathly Hallows themselves. The moment in which we see Harry on the cover is essentially when he has become Master of the Hallows and a fully-fledged wizard, exactly what the magician represents. I always wondered if Mary Grand-Pré was conscious of these parallels during the design process. Anyway, let me know what y’all think.”

[Voicemail ends]

Andrew: That is very interesting. I don’t know how Mary Grand-Pré designed the covers, like what kind of inspiration she was looking at or looking for, but that was really well-researched, Asim, and thank you for sharing that. Studying tarot cards, very interesting way to expand your love for Harry Potter. All right, let’s listen to another voicemail. This caller left a couple of voicemails, actually.

Micah: Were they drunk?

Andrew: [laughs] No, 2:09 p.m., 2:07 p.m., 2:11…

Micah: Time means nothing.

Andrew: [laughs] I think he was thinking maybe, like, “If I leave a bunch of voicemails, I’ll have a higher chance of having them played.”

Micah: Oh, of getting on the show.

Andrew: Yeah, as if we get tons of voicemails, [whispers] but truth be told, we don’t get a ton. [back to normal voice] All right, here’s one of his voicemails. [laughs]

[Voicemail plays]

“Hey, MuggleCasters. This is Brad again, from Fargo, North Dakota. I just wanted to call and let you guys know how much I appreciate the show. Having access to old episodes is definitely awesome. I just relocated to Fargo, and I don’t know many people, so getting used to a new area is kind of difficult when you don’t know anybody, so you guys have definitely been helpful, keeping me company while I am off work, and I appreciate being able to listen to your show and get a few laughs and just listen to Harry Potter, and it’s awesome. Thank you very much, and I’ve been a long time listener. My first episode was when Jamie kept talking about Prison Break in Episode 87 or 85 or something like that, that live show that you guys did. It was hilarious and actually encouraged me to watch Prison Break, and it was awesome, so thanks, Jamie, wherever you are.”

[Voicemail ends]

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: We ask ourselves that question all the time.

Andrew: Man, Jamie was obsessed with Prison Break, and Wentworth Miller, who stars in that show. But thanks, Brad. I really appreciate that. MuggleCast… we’re what, 13 years old now? It’s been a constant in many of our listeners’ lives, so when they do move, like Brad was just saying, it can be helpful to still have that, and it’s certainly been a constant in our lives, and it’s been helpful in our own moves and life changes as well. So thank you for sharing that. And in one of Brad’s other 30 voicemails, he asked if we’re going to do Half-Blood Prince Chapter by Chapter. That’s the one we still haven’t done. I think we should, Micah.

Micah: Yeah, why not?

Andrew: Why not? Well, Eric would object, but he’s not here, so…

Micah: [laughs] That’s right.

Andrew: … we can commit to it.

Micah: Yeah, we’re doing it live on air, so can’t take it back now.

[Andrew laughs]

Ken: Is Eric reading all of it? Are you signing him up for that now?

Andrew: Well, the thing is, he has done this other podcast where they went chapter by chapter through the entire series, including Half-Blood Prince, so he doesn’t want to do it. But Micah and I are like, “Well, that’s not our problem. You decided to do it on the other podcast. We’re talking about our podcast, yo.”

Micah: Exactly.

Ken: You can’t pull a Scholastic and just print one new edition and then bail out on the rest of them.

Andrew: Right. But you know what? To clue people in to future show plans here, I’ve been slowly rereading the books, and there are certain things that I want to discuss on the show. So I think… we haven’t come up with a name for it yet, but I want to start doing a semi-regular segment where we’re looking at particular points in the Harry Potter series that maybe we look at in a different light now that we’re older, and we kind of ask ourselves, “What if this scene, for example, happened differently?” Or I’m finishing up Goblet of Fire right now; I’m thinking, “Wow, Rita Skeeter really sucks, and how irresponsible of the Daily Prophet to print these fake stories about, for example, Harry and Hermione’s relationship.” So stuff like this I want to look at again now that we’re older, so I think that would be fun. More to come in the future. Here’s one more voicemail.

[Voicemail plays]

“Hey, MuggleCast, it’s Jenny from Dallas. Been listening for a long time; love the show. I just had a thought: I’m rereading the books and listening to you guys and a few other podcasts. But Dumbledore talks about always using Voldemort’s name, and is very specific about using his name, always using his name. I know in the flashbacks, he calls him Tom. Why doesn’t he still call him Tom Riddle? It’s just bugged me for a while, and specifically with this reread, so love to know your thoughts, and I’ll be listening for an answer. Have a good day. Bye.”

[Voicemail ends]

Andrew: Why does he not call him Tom Riddle anymore? He doesn’t recognize who he once knew?

Micah: [laughs] The nose is missing?

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: No, but doesn’t he do that in Order of the Phoenix? He says, “It was foolish of you to come here tonight, Tom.”

Andrew: Yes.

Micah: I always thought… and again, it’s been a while since I’ve read the series, and I need to, and I’ve probably seen the movies way more times than I’ve read the books, honestly. But I remember in the series, the book series, that Voldemort being Tom Riddle was not as explicit as it is in the films. For example, at the end of Goblet of Fire… or was it the beginning of Order of the Phoenix? I forget. When Dumbledore is addressing the students, he calls out Tom Riddle specifically, and I, for whatever reason, when reading the books, remember that it was a well-kept secret that Tom Riddle was actually Voldemort until later on in the series, at least publicly.

Andrew: So you’re saying Dumbledore didn’t really want to get into the fact publicly that he used to be Tom Riddle.

Micah: I think so. And people who are listening right now can feel free to jump in, but for some reason, I remember that. Maybe I’m just making it up in my head.

Ken: No, I kind of do remember it that way, too, that it was such a close kept secret because he was trying to unravel Tom Riddle’s history? But I could be mistaken.

Andrew: In terms of him saying, “It was foolish of you to come here tonight, Tom,” that is, I think, putting Tom Riddle/Voldemort in his place, right? That’s Dumbledore not speaking down to him, but reminding him of where he came from, reminding him of their history.

Micah: Yeah, that’s what it was.

Ken: It’s a very teacher thing.

Micah: Yeah, not only that, but if you were to say that Voldemort and Tom Riddle were one in the same, you also then have to look at Tom Riddle’s history and the fact that he wasn’t pure-blood, yet this was what he was preaching as Voldemort. And so when you think about all the different families that he recruited to his cause as Death Eaters, these were all pure-blood families, but yet Voldemort/Tom Riddle is not, right? His father was a Muggle. So if that got out, if that was made public, it kind of undermines everything that Voldemort stands for because he’d be completely hypocritical, so I think that was part of it.

Andrew: All right, well, hopefully that answered your question, Jenny. Hopefully you’re enjoying the reread of the books as well.


Quizzitch


Andrew: Hey, Micah/Eric, it’s time for Quizzitch.

Micah: All right, so…

Andrew: Oh, wait.

Micah: What?

Andrew: He didn’t put in a new question.

Micah: No, there is.

Andrew: Oh, yes, he did. Sorry, sorry.

Micah: He did, he did, yeah. All right, so this is actually two weeks ago we asked this question. We didn’t do Quizzitch last week; Andrew and I were, as mentioned, in Orlando for the Celebration, so we forgot to do Quizzitch at the end. But Eric posed the question back on Episode 352: What character do we know that was chosen by all four Ilvermorny Houses? And the answer to that is Seraphina Picquery, who we also mentioned earlier on in this episode. And we have a few winners to call out. Eric explicitly wants to state that Jess B. on Twitter cheated because she answered during the livestream, so clearly Eric has very strict rules for this game. And then Anders Drew, Rebecca Jones, Crystal, Victoria Rose, Lindsey Mac, Ayden, The Lady Ash, Dawn Ivers, Tate Anderson, Felicia Grogan, Kate K., and Nedi_Spaghetti.

Andrew: That’s a fun name.

Micah: Congratulations to all of… that’s you, Andrew?

Andrew: No, I just said it was a fun name.

Micah: Oh, fun name. I thought you said, “That’s my name.”

Andrew: Oh. Seraphina Picquery. Perfect Picquery getting put in all four Ilvermorny Houses.

Micah: There you go. So this week’s question… so Jess B., do not answer during the livestream, or something. I can’t say what Eric is going to do, because I don’t know where the hell he is. This week: In Chapter 10 of Half-Blood Prince, “The House of Gaunt,” Hermione is seen working on an essay entitled “Principles of ______.” Please fill in the blank.

Andrew: By the way, I wanted to mention that Universal listened to our episode last week, and Micah and I kept bringing up “The door slamming, the door slamming,” which apparently didn’t come through on the recording. But Universal was like, “Oh, guys, I’m so sorry to hear about the door slamming. Next time you’re down here and you need to record, you can use our recording studio.” [laughs] I’m like, “Oh, well, that’d be fun.”

Micah: Good to know.

Andrew: But it really, really wasn’t a problem. We were just kind of having fun on the show. [laughs] But it was very nice of Universal to do that; they’re always very accommodating, and we’re glad that they want to have MuggleCast down there. And actually, speaking of people who listen to the show, the team behind those Harry Potter live concerts are interested in setting up an interview on MuggleCast with the creators of the Harry Potter film concert series, so look forward to that in the weeks and months ahead. Fun to have them on the show to hear how they make that magic happen.

Micah: Right. I would say that’s a really cool experience that I would recommend to all of our listeners if they have the opportunity, and they’re touring internationally with this. If you’re able to go see a film that’s set to the music of the Potter series, I thought the Orlando Philharmonic was really, really cool to listen to last weekend, and can’t say enough about that. So if it’s coming to your city, we’ll share the link to the schedule in our show notes and let you guys check it out. But they’re going a lot of different places over this next year, and it’s definitely worth checking out.

Andrew: And they’re only doing the first four movies right now, but they’re going to eventually move on to the rest of the series, so that’s pretty cool as well. You can collect them all if you really want.

Micah: Yeah, like Pokémon.

Andrew: Yep.

Micah: Pokémon gets so much promotion on this show; I feel like we need to strike a deal there.

Andrew: [laughs] I mean, it’s a cultural institution, so I don’t know if we really owe them anything. I think they’re doing fine whether or not we talk about Pokémon.

Micah: That’s true.

Andrew: But you can look forward to Harry Potter: Wizards Unite, hopefully coming later this year.

Micah: That’s true too.

Andrew: We’re also going to probably have an interview with the creators of Harry Potter: Hogwarts Mystery, whenever that is released. Ken, I hope you had a good time on the show today. Thanks for joining us and ending up filling in for Eric.

Ken: [laughs] My pleasure.

Andrew: If he doesn’t ever return, you can just take over full time. You were good. A good replacement.

Ken: Perfect. I look forward to it. [laughs]

Micah: And thanks for indulging my Super Bowl discussion earlier in the show.

Ken: My dad will be happy. Finally talking about football.

Andrew: Yeah, so thanks for coming on, and thanks for your support. We really appreciate it. Just a couple plugs here: Please check out MuggleCast.com for everything you need about the show. We have a new advertiser deals page, by the way. If you hear our promos on the show, if you forget the codes or the links, just go to MuggleCast.com and there’s a new link at the top called “Advertiser deals,” and you can get them all. And they all stay active, as far as we can tell, so even if we did an ad a few months ago, like maybe BarkBox or…

Micah: Casper?

Andrew: … Canvas People, or Casper, yeah. They’re all still active, so feel free to get discounts on products that we love.

Micah: Yeah, I think the real reason, Andrew, that you created this page is because every couple weeks, I’ll send Andrew a text message and I’ll say, “Hey, what’s the code?”

Andrew: Casper. You asked about Casper last week.

Micah: I did; I asked about Casper. I think I’ve asked about Canvas People before that. So this page was really made for me, but hopefully you all benefit from it as well.

Andrew: And I try to talk with Micah as little as possible, so I’m trying to cut out all the times… as much as I can, my talk time with him, so I made this page just for you, Micah.

Micah: Thank you.

Andrew: In the code, I hid a little text. In the HTML. “Damn it, Micah.” [laughs]

Micah: What does it say?

Andrew: It says, “Damn it, Micah.”

Micah: Ah, damn it, Micah.

Andrew: [laughs] If you want to support us a different way, we have our Patreon, Patreon.com/MuggleCast. You get lots of benefits over there, including a livestream. Thanks to everybody who joined us on this Saturday morning. And thanks to Ken, who has been a Slug Club supporter. We appreciate it. And here’s hoping we see Dumbledore the way J.K. Rowling made him to be in a future film, right? Thanks, everybody, for listening. I’m Andrew.

Micah: I’m Micah.

Ken: And I’m Ken.

Andrew: Goodbye.

Micah: Bye.

Transcript #332

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #332, The Hollow Goblet


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, the Harry Potter podcast discussing everything about J.K. Rowling’s wizarding world. This week’s episode is brought to you by Casper Mattress.

[Ad break]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 332. I’m Andrew.

Eric Scull: I’m Eric.

Micah Tannenbaum: And I’m Micah.

Andrew: Eric and I are together this week in Chicago.

Eric: Hey, let’s hold hands, Andrew.

Andrew: [laughs] We are sh… oh, he just touched me!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Eric has opened up his home to me, and his landlord has opened up his home to us, for us to record in.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: It’s amazing.

Andrew: Because Eric’s roommate is moving out.

Micah: How did you get to keep the apartment? That’s what I want to know.

Eric: It was a series of Game of Thrones-ian Martin-ian tricks, and I…

Andrew: He killed her.

Eric: I plead the fifth.

Micah: Wow.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Eric, that is just unacceptable.

Eric: No, actually, what it was was she got married, and her husband and her did not want me as a roommate, so they moved out.

Andrew: That makes sense.

Eric: Yeah, that’s what it was.

Andrew: Not just because it’s you, just…

Eric: That’s me; the third wheel.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Micah: Do you at least get to keep the dog? Or is that going with…?

Eric: No! It’s not my dog, dude. [laughs]

Micah: Well, I enjoyed the time I spent with the dog a couple months ago. He kept me company while I was stuck trying to get back from Salt Lake City to New York.

Eric: That’s right. That’s right.

Andrew: I’m about to move out here next month, and Eric has been showing me the town, and he’ll have a new dog to hang out with.

Eric: Yeah, Brooklyn!

Andrew: Woohoo!

Eric: In Chicago.

Andrew: We were at Market Days here in Chicago last night, which if you hear the name Market Days, you’re like, “Oh, okay, some nice farmers’ market festival. You can go and pick up carrots and lettuce.”

Eric: Well, that’s pretty much what Market Days really is, except none of the men are wearing shirts.

Andrew: [laughs] Right, it’s essentially Chicago Pride 2.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: And so we went knowing what it was, of course, and we passed a booth… so all these… so it’s called Market Days because all these local vendors – and big brands – are out and pushing their stuff, and Eric came across… what was… do you remember the name of it? The book one?

Eric: No. I have the receipt for it, though.

Andrew: It’s a vendor who has all these old books, hardcover books, and she cuts out the center of them to make kind of a secret hiding place. It could be a secret hiding place, or it could be just… it’s just kind of a cool thing. So we see Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows there, and we’re with, actually, a new friend of ours and a MuggleCast listener, V, and I’m like, “Oh, look, Deathly Hallows.” And I turned to V and I’m like, “Have you heard of that?”, jokingly, and he’s like, “Oh, well…” I was like, “Dude, I’m kidding. I’m kidding. I’m trying to mess with you.” But then Eric spots Goblet of Fire.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. And apparently… this woman was very pleased; she said Harry Potter was doing very well at this festival. These were the last two copies of… she didn’t say if she had brought all seven Harry Potter books, but yes, her trade is she hollows out books, creates a nice little hiding spot, and she said that Harry Potter had done particularly well that day.

Micah: So wait, so she is responsible for defacing multiple copies of Harry Potter?

Eric: I had that same issue at first.

Andrew: Well, here’s the craziest part; this is what cracks me up. So Eric buys Goblet of Fire. And then we turn to Eric and we’re like, “So how much was that?” It was $26. [laughs] So Eric paid $26 for a defaced copy of Goblet of Fire.

Eric: The funniest part is we were talking about it this morning, about going to talk about it on this show, and I thought, “Well, I could justify the purchase because if it’s $26 for a hollowed-out Goblet of Fire, but it would fit right in on my bookshelf, and so I could covertly put my US passport, my social security card, my birth certificate, and it would just fit on my bookshelf with all my other Potter books. Nobody would think twice.” But now that I’m advertising, now that I’m broadcasting this on the podcast…

Micah: I was just going to say, you just told thousands of people the fact that should they ever be in Chicago and look to mug you, they should look for your passport and your social security card on your bookshelf.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Now and only now have I purchased a $26 thing that I can never use, because talking about it is the worst part.

Andrew: But I said to Eric, “You could still use it for something; just don’t put extremely important valuables in it.” And nobody’s going to rob you.

Eric: I don’t know.

Andrew: But I also thought, “Wow, isn’t that a smart idea? You can go to Goodwill, buy these books for five bucks, then take a knife to them, [laughs] and then sell them for five times the price.”

Eric: Well, no, I mean, the thing is… let’s not make a negative comment on this woman’s craftsmanship. I think…

Andrew: Oh, no, it’s good.

Eric: Because they weren’t just hollowed-out pages; they were actually… so in the hollow she then put… she felt-lined the sides.

Andrew: Ohh.

Eric: And it’s got little gems, and it’s shiny and stuff on the inside. So it’s really like a cloth that’s in the… but it’s still a hollowed-out square, so it’s not just like the pages are still there, and…

Andrew: Yeah, I get what you’re saying.

Eric: It’s a little bit more…

Micah: All right, you keep trying to justify it, Eric. You’re doing an amazing job here.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: No, I mean, I’m just joking, but I just find it interesting that cutting out most of the text and most of the story actually increases the book’s value and…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Marketability. It’s fun. I mean, Etsy shop owners know this all the time with that stuff; there’s people who make the paper flowers out of Harry Potter book quotes, so when you’re looking at a bouquet of flowers, you can just slightly read down the petals, and it’s like, “Oh, name that chapter. Name that scene.” The coolest part about this book, though, was she didn’t cut out the first 20 or 30 pages or so, so you can still read Chapter 1 of Goblet of Fire. [laughs]

Andrew: So she hooks you in and…

Eric: Yeah, you hook in, and then you have to get another copy because this one is…

Andrew: [laughs] Buy another copy.

Micah: Well, what you can do now, though, is go to Cursed Child and take out the Goblet of Fire references and put them in there instead. How’s that?

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: There you go. That’s a great idea, yeah.


News


Andrew: All right, well, on today’s episode, we are going to be talking about how Harry Potter has changed pop culture. We’re going to have a main discussion on that, and we got some responses from our supporters on Patreon. First, one news item; bit of a slow news week. Forbes always does these lists of the highest paid this, the highest paid that, highest paid actors, blah, blah, blah. J.K. Rowling is the highest paid author of 2017. It’s the first time she’s been at the top of this list in a decade, since Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows came out. So what catapulted her to number one?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Well, you were clear to name it – oh wait, no, you didn’t – on the Hypable article.

Andrew: I trolled the hell out of Cursed Child on this one. I wrote, “J.K. Rowling is 2017’s Highest Paid author, thanks to Fantastic Beasts and that other one.” [laughs] But yeah, so Cursed Child. I think Cursed Child was probably the one that really helped her get to number one, because with Fantastic Beasts, you didn’t need to buy the movie script. Of course, with Cursed Child, it being marketed as the eighth story, everybody wanted to buy it at their midnight release parties. I do wonder how much percentage-wise… I bet Fantastic Beasts was maybe 10%, the script, and then Cursed Child was other 90%, but…

Eric: I just find it so interesting because she didn’t write the play, so she shouldn’t even be credited as an author on that play. And how is this money working, where it’s coming to her, making her the richest author…

Andrew: Right. [laughs]

Eric: … when in fact, it’s John Tiffany and Jack Thorne who should be on this list?

Andrew: Wouldn’t that be funny if they were number one and J.K. Rowling wasn’t?

Eric: Yeah, I mean, that would make sense, unless it’s under somehow the umbrella of J.K. Rowling, and then that’s also how the… but she actually wrote the script for Fantastic Beasts, so selling the book form of the Fantastic Beasts scripts makes all the sense to credit her. But with the Cursed Child, how does that money still go to her? I don’t know.

Micah: Yeah, I’m calling fake news on this article. I don’t think it’s accurate.

Andrew: Why?

Micah: Well, for exactly what Eric just said; she’s not the author of Cursed Child, so she shouldn’t be credited with the sales of it.

Eric: Maybe J.K. Rowling wrote Cursed Child under the pseudonyms John Tiffany and Jack Thorne.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Maybe in fact she just hired actors to pretend that they’re them, and it’s another Cormoran Strike series sort of thing.

Andrew: “Hey, James Patterson, are you the number one highest paid author this year?” “Oh, no, it was Jack Thorne and John Tiffany.” “Who the hell is that?”

Micah: Well, is this list just for new releases?

Andrew: Yeah, so James Patterson… so J.K. Rowling was number one at $95 million. James Patterson was number two at $87 million. Jeff Kinney, this guy… what a life this guy has. He writes these Diary of a Wimpy Kid books…

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: … and they’re just insanely popular with middle schoolers, so he’s at number three with $21 million. Then Dan Brown, Stephen King, John Grisham, Nora Roberts, Paula Hawkins… E.L. James, which is interesting because I don’t think she published any new books this year. And then tied for 10 are Danielle Steele and Rick Riordan, the author of Percy Jackson.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: So yeah. I mean, this could be the last time she’s ever at number one again, unless she writes another play, or writes that encyclopedia…

Eric: Or has other people to write the play for her.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Or they’re Robert Galbraith novels, though I don’t think they come close to the sales of anything Potter.

Eric: Probably not.

Andrew: Right, right.


MuggleCast’s 12th Birthday


Andrew: So you had in here birthday gifts? What…?

Eric: Birthday gifts? Oh, birthday gifts! Well, we got birthday gifts. The MuggleCast…

Micah: I thought you were talking about for me.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: No, we neglected to mention on the last episode of MuggleCast that the very day that that same episode of MuggleCast was airing was our actual 12th birthday.

Andrew: Yes!

Eric: So August 7, 2017 was the 12th birthday for MuggleCast, and even though we may have overlooked it, our listeners sure did not. And I went to – you guys know because I texted you – I went to the MuggleCast P.O. box on… it was Monday, because I got the text message saying my packages had arrived. And I was like, “Who? What? Who ordered packages? What’s going on there?” And sure enough, our listeners gave us so many really, really awesome presents for our birthday, so we got birthday presents. So I just want to shout out to Sophie, who wrote a very lovely thank you letter. Believe it or not, we got beer.

Andrew: We did. Not just any beer.

Micah: Did you try it? The Pukwudgie beer?

Eric: Not yet, not yet. We’re going to try the Pukwudgie beer.

Micah: Please do.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Or bring it to Orlando.

Andrew: We would’ve had them right now, but it’s a little early still, and I’m still hungover from Market Days.

Eric: Yeah. So our friend Kenny M., who’s a MuggleCast listener, patron as well, got the idea from Shannon, another Patreon listener, who was mentioning this brewery in Massachusetts called Down the Road, and they serve the Pukwudgie American Pale Ale. And so when I went to the P.O. Box and opened this box, [laughs] there were just four beers just in the box, shipped priority mail to us.

Andrew: And he totally lied when the post person said, “Is there anything liquid, fragile, hazardous?” [laughs]

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah. I don’t know how they did it.

Andrew: But good, good for breaking the rule.

Eric: But also, we heard from Becky, Bernard, and Kevin, and she thanked us. She thanked us, sent me some sweets, sent Micah a replacement Ravenclaw book…

Andrew: So nice.

Eric: … and pledged to re-donate to Millennial and MuggleCast Patreons. “PS: Bernard and Kevin are my cats.”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: So thank you, Becky.

Andrew: Yeah, she was really thoughtful sending you a new book, Micah.

Micah: Yeah, no, I have to say thank you. It’s going to go right on my shelf. I’m going to throw the other one in the garbage, or I’m going to burn it…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: … or maybe I’ll hollow out the middle and I’ll try and sell it down in the town square for 30 bucks.

Eric: Oh my God.

Andrew: I hear they’re a good place to put your social security number.

Micah: Yeah. But that is very nice; thank you very much.

Eric: Yes. And we want to thank all of our listeners who thought of us around this time, birthday. Very, very special. And our final shout-out has to go to Cherise, who we had on last week’s episode, actually. According to her, she says, “Congrats on podcasting for 12 years. I had started work on these guys -“ we’ll let you know what that means “- a couple of days before I got the email from Andrew, so it is pure chance that I was working on them before then, but I hope you guys like them. Thanks again for the amazing experience. Keep up the great job.” She sent us fully knitted Dobby the house-elf…

Andrew: Three of them.

Eric: … or rather Dobbies the house-elf, and they’re completely… I don’t know how she did it. They’re completely knitted, and they’re wearing tea cozies, which are also completely knitted, and come off, so you can undress Dobby if you want to.

Andrew: Yeah, she did a great job with this.

Eric: But it’s really insanely funny and hilarious. And we haven’t tweeted this out yet, but they look amazing. She sent little signs for them to hold; they’re double-sided. One says, “I support SPEW,” and the other side says, “Dobby is a free elf.” But she sent us each our own knitted Dobby the house-elf!

Andrew: Thank you so much, Cherise. By the way, what cracks me up is Eric always opens the gifts from the P.O. Box at the UPS store, which… [laughs] He always sends us pictures of the stuff and we see the UPS store in the background, and I’m just thinking, why do you do that? Are you trying to show off for the employees?

Eric: No, well, the employees there know me. It’s super funny; one of them is also a Harry Potter fan, and so she’s really interested when I get a package, what’s in it. But no, there’s a very cool little shelf thing that I can just open the package there. And you know this about me; I have no chill. I can’t take a box the half a mile to my home.

Andrew: All right. Well, we can’t wait to have those Dobbies.

Micah: I think you’re trying to impress her, honestly, Eric. I think that’s what it is.

Andrew: I think so too, Micah. I think he’s trying to show off a little bit. That’s okay. That’s cool. Thank you, everybody. We really do appreciate it. It’s awesome to continue doing MuggleCast 12 years down the line now. It’s hard to believe it’s been that long.

Micah: And my birthday is only in a few days, so if you feel like sending more stuff, please do.

Andrew: You’re also turning 12, right?

Micah: Yeah, that’s right.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: I’m just joking. I’m just joking. No need to send anything.

Eric: Oh, your birthday is not in a couple days?

Micah: No, no, it is, but when I said about sending stuff, you don’t… nobody needs to do that.

Andrew: [laughs] Okay.


Main Discussion: How Harry Potter changed pop culture


Andrew: On today’s episode, we are going to be talking about pop culture, how Harry Potter has influenced pop culture and the Internet. We have some interesting things to talk about there, but first we have to take a moment to tell you about this week’s sponsor, Casper Mattresses.

[Ad break]

Andrew: So on today’s episode… by the way, I slept on Eric’s mattress last night. Not a Casper mattress, but a comfortable one.

Eric: Oh, okay.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: That’s all right. Good. I’m glad you slept well.

Andrew: We spooned and everything, Micah. It was great.

Eric: I took the couch.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: Maybe you can do the same in Orlando.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh, great. Micah wants the second double bed to himself. That’s how that works.

Andrew: No, no, Eric and I can sleep together in Orlando.

Eric: Hashtag MuggleNet Live.

Andrew: We can share a bed.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, no, yeah.

Andrew: No, here.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: You don’t have to go sleep on the couch.

Eric: No, the couch is great, though. I never get an opportunity to sleep on my couch.

Andrew: That’s CasperCouches.com.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: So we want to talk about how Harry Potter has changed pop culture. Where do we want to start here? There’s so many angles we can go. I guess… let’s just start off with the bare bones: What has Harry Potter explicitly changed about pop culture? Not necessarily the Internet; we’ll get to that.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, I’ve noticed – as I’m sure we all have – just in growing prevalence, nerds are normal. Nerds are normal. And while Harry Potter can’t take the entire credit for that, the pop culture and the way that we relate to fantasy novels, movies, books, film, TV – everything – has changed completely since… in the 20 years since Harry Potter has been around, so that’s a huge trend. And you could definitely view it through the lens of Harry Potter and how… I mean, Harry Potter simultaneously made books cool again, and also gave rise to some of the most well-trafficked fansites and fan podcasts and fan productions on the Internet. It’s kind of cool.

Micah: Yeah, and just to go along those lines, a couple of comments that our patrons made. We asked this question over on Patreon, and I’m summarizing a little bit, but to go off of what you said, Eric, Becca Watson used the phrase “normalizing nerd culture,” which I thought was interesting. And then Roger, who notes that he’s one of our older listeners, he’s a journalist who’s been covering Harry Potter from 1998, and two things stand out to him: “Harry Potter made reading cool,” as you mentioned, “as it may never have been since Dickens.” That’s going back a little bit.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: And second, “The idea of mass fandom around a book series and all its spinoffs was unprecedented.” He has two kids, 26 and 22, who have aged out of Potter, but he still follows it keenly, and was surprised every week that MuggleCasters find something fresh and insightful to talk about.

Eric: Aw.

Andrew: Thanks. Yeah, well, on the point of reading, I think that’s one of the things you hear most from people who started reading Harry Potter, that Harry Potter helped them develop a genuine love of reading, which they probably never would have otherwise. Because when you were in elementary school or middle school, you had to read books, and of course… look, obviously, there’s a ton of amazing books out there that kids should read and enjoy, but Harry Potter just struck something in all of us that inspired us to continue reading beyond Harry Potter.

Eric: Yeah, it’s almost like a how-to on good literature, Harry Potter is. You get a couple really well-rounded characters, some humor, a really good sense of how to write and construct a novel, and it pays off leaps and bounds. And then a little bit of fantasy, too; little bit of escapism thrown in there, but with some real stakes and heart, I think, is what it is. I think Harry Potter, it was very clear that the author cared about what she was writing, and in turn, we cared about it. And that was a really good way for pop culture Internet to start off the Internet age, was with a book series that is so well-loved.

Andrew: Yeah. A couple of people who are listening live are wondering how that guy’s kids aged out of Harry Potter. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, I was laughing about that, actually. I’m 29; I could run laps around his kids.

Andrew: I definitely know people who were more into Harry Potter ten years ago than they were now. I mean, of course; that’s natural when you grow up. Things change, your interests change, your priorities in life change, so you’re not tracking the latest news or listening to a Harry Potter podcast every week.

Eric: We had five or six other cohosts, I think, that would all fit into this category. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. Well, that’s actually… I’m just thinking about Jamie. Jamie still loves Harry Potter to death, of course, and he knows how much Harry Potter has done for him, but he’s not checking MuggleNet for the latest news anymore. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: And yeah, because you just… like I said, your priorities in life change. So I get that.

Micah: Yeah. Leave Roger alone, okay?

Andrew: [laughs] Come on, Roger, get your kids back into it. I wonder, though, if Roger’s kids saw Fantastic Beasts, because why wouldn’t you want to go see a new Wizarding World movie?

Eric: I am so surprised by how many people I talk to that haven’t seen the new Fantastic Beasts. I can’t believe it.

Andrew: Really?

Eric: Yeah, people who are genuinely… I’ll have a conversation with them about Harry Potter and how much they like it, and I’ll be like, “Well, you know the Fantastic Beasts movie,” because I’m talking about it, and they’re like, “Oh, I haven’t seen that yet.” Or they’ll ask what MuggleCast talks about these days, and I’ll say, “Oh, you know the Fantastic Beasts film?” And they’re like, “Ah, I still haven’t seen that.”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Like, how do you…? Get on it! You got the memo. You know it’s the Harry Potter world, written by the same author.

Andrew: Yeah, people… but still, it’s sort of like Lord of the Rings versus The Hobbit. If you love The Lord of the Rings, you’re not necessarily dying to see The Hobbit, I don’t think.

Eric: Sure.

Andrew: Movie-wise, I’m talking about. I guess that may not be always true. But I feel like… in the case of my sister, she’s seen all the Harry Potter movies, but has not seen Fantastic Beasts.

Eric: I think we get desensitized, too, to our own impressions when pop culture… when something becomes so marketable as Harry Potter, we… you ever watch TV and realize after you’re watching a show on TV for an hour that you didn’t even really barely notice the commercials?

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Those commercials are all designed to get your attention, but we just tune it out. I feel like people have gotten that way with new Harry Potter stuff, and maybe we’ll talk about that a little later, about how the Internet freaks out.

Micah: You think so, though? I would disagree with that, because I don’t think it’s to the point of being overwhelming. I don’t think it’s constantly in the news, at least. And we all podcast; we all pay attention to it. I don’t think it is out there beating you over the head like some other things are.

Eric: Well, I mean, anytime… all it takes is a couple of clickbait articles that aren’t as promising as they sound for me to turn off and want to turn off all of Harry Potter ever. Every time Jo sneezes, somebody misinterprets it as a big reveal, and Buzzfeed has it, and HuffPost has it, and all of a sudden the Daily Mail is reporting it, and it’s going out into print publications in the real world about J.K. Rowling’s misquotation.

Andrew: Well, but you forget that’s how she actually accidentally revealed that Dumbledore was gay. She sneezed that reveal. [laughs]

Eric: No, she flat out… give her some credit.

Andrew: [fake sneeze] “Dumbledoresgay.”

Eric: Give her some credit. She was…

Andrew: [laughs] Kidding. I’m kidding.

Eric: The first thing she asked was, “How old are you?” to that kid. Yeah, but I just think… yeah, it’s pretty sensationalized, the popularity of Harry Potter. It might be difficult for some people to grasp how extensive… how something could actually exist and be as relevant and awesome as it was 20-25 years ago, so maybe that also gives people an aversion and they try and turn off. But in addition to that, Harry Potter, how it changes and how we’re continually interacting with it is… I guess it is an endurance trial for some of us.

Andrew: Cody also said he honestly thinks that Potter helped make our generation very liberal.

Eric: They did a study on that, didn’t they? Recently?

Andrew: Yeah, I was just going to say, I don’t have the data in front of me, but there have been studies showing that people who have read Harry Potter understand compassion.

Eric: And dictatorship. There was legitimately a study. One of the universities did a study that said Harry Potter readers specifically understand the dangers of dictators and are less likely to vote Trump.

Andrew: Really?

Eric: Yeah, that really came out before the election.

Andrew: Yeah, I mean, if you think about that… one of my favorite pieces – I guess you can call it art – is that statue in the Ministry of Magic, where you see the statue that says “Magic is Might,” I believe it was? And somebody’s standing on top of it and all the Muggles are suppressed underneath the stone, and that just really spoke to me. That’s at the Harry Potter Studio Tour, by the way. But yeah, I would agree; I do find that most people I know… it could just be my bubble, but I do know most Harry Potter fans are liberal, politically speaking. We do have a friend, Kevin, who is a Republican. [laughs] Still loves Harry Potter.

Eric: That guy’s an anomaly in general.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: This was Time Magazine, by the way. Time Magazine on July 20, 2016. Headline, “Harry Potter Readers More Likely to Dislike Donald Trump: Study.” “The study, which will be published in the political science and politics journal called PS…” It was University of Pennsylvania. Hey, shout out to Pennsylvania. “… said that readers might see parallels between Trump’s political style and the books’ villain, Lord Voldemort.” That’s the other thing about these books, okay? Because there’s so much in them that as you grow with them, there’s more things that you can take out upon further reading, and pop culture… that’s new to culture, to have something that’s so multifaceted, I think, at least. You know how many movies or even TV shows were aiming so high that not just to hook viewers or readers on the first go round, but every subsequent go round? Harry Potter does that. And I’m not sure there was art in pop culture before then that was really designed or capable of handling that bandwidth.

Andrew and Micah: Yeah.

Micah: And I would just say liberal, too, could be interpreted as accepting. I think generally, the fan community as a whole is extremely accepting of all kinds of people, and I think that is pretty commonplace when you’re bringing together people around a common cause, regardless of what their backgrounds may be, and I think the Potter community as a whole has sort of been a beacon for that.

Eric: Definitely.

Andrew: There’s one more we highlighted here; JY noted that Harry Potter was a gateway fandom. That’s borrowing from the term “gateway drug.” If maybe you joined the Harry Potter fandom and you really liked the community, so you were like, “Oh, well, are there communities for other passions I have?” Whether it’s Star Wars or something very obscure, you can really find on the Internet – and I guess this will transition into the Internet side of this discussion – the Internet, you can find a fandom, a community for anything, especially on Tumblr. “F yeah: insert fandom here.”

Micah: Yeah, and fandoms existed prior to, even online, but I think – which we’ll get into – Potter really caught the wave of the Internet unlike any other fandom before it. And before we move on, I wanted to pull up this episode – I finally found it – Episode 162, because we were just talking about politics, and we spent an entire episode drawing several comparisons between the politics of the real world and the wizarding world, and we talked about everything from racism to ethnic cleansing to Nazism to corruption, and biased media and educational reform. So if people want to take a look back – maybe I’ll even go listen to that episode again – it’s probably pretty timely, given everything going on in today’s society. That was Episode 162.

Eric: That’s almost exactly half our podcast ago.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: 166 would have been half our podcast to go, so that’s crazy.

Andrew: So like Micah said – Micah, I like that term you used – Harry Potter “rode the wave” of the Internet. The Internet was coming up at the same time that Harry Potter was. Fandoms like Star Wars were around before the Internet, so they weren’t necessarily… they weren’t growing simultaneously. Harry Potter really helped develop the idea of a fansite, which we’re going to talk a lot more about a little later. But so since the Internet and Harry Potter were coming up at the same time, it’s a little hard to say how Harry Potter exactly impacted the Internet.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: But it is fair to say that the Internet has directly impacted Harry Potter. We all know each other thanks to the Internet. A lot of people… MuggleCast exists thanks to the Internet. All the websites do. Since Harry Potter – and this goes back to earlier in the discussion – it wasn’t necessarily cool at first.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: It took a while. In order to find fellow Harry Potter fans, you had to look on the Internet. And for a lot of us… I’m 28 right now; when I first started looking on the Internet for Harry Potter stuff, I was finding fansites like MuggleNet, and I think there’s one called Harry Potter Fan Zone. Some very obscure ones that I used to absolutely adore. I used to think their designs and just the communities were so cool. I made my own Harry Potter fansite before I got involved with MuggleNet; the first one was called Harry Potter’s House, and then I forgot to renew the domain.

Eric: Aww.

Andrew: So I had to change the name.

Micah: What’d you change it to?

Andrew: The Potter Profile. TPP.

Micah: Oh, okay. That sounds cool, though, actually.

Andrew: Yeah, it was more adult. I was growing up; I was like, 15, so I was like, “Okay, it’s time to mature.”

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Oh, gosh.

Andrew: But so people use the Internet to meet each other, and that’s how we all met every single cohost of MuggleCast.

Eric: Met each other, yeah. Because I mean, this podcast would not exist, could not have existed… every host was in a different state. No two hosts were in…

Micah: Or country.

Eric: Or country! Exactly.

Micah: I would say that that’s another huge piece of it, too, is the Internet allowing an international community of people to come together, I think, unlike previous fandoms that may have existed. Not to say that that opportunity wasn’t there, but you had a lot of people who were growing up too. I think that’s a huge part of it, is that all of us were growing up with the Internet and learning at the same time, so all this was new and was different. I mean, I noted here that, to set the stage, when we first started this podcast 12 years ago, Facebook was just a year old, Twitter was a year from existing, and obviously things like Instagram and Snapchat were a pipe dream. iPhones did not exist. So think of how far we’ve come in that period of time, and the ability for Potter as a fan community to align with all those things, to take advantage of all those things, I think really helped propel it. The books were their own success, but I think it was just magnified so many times over by these tools, these resources.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, even looking back at MuggleCast history… and this has to be what tracks the most. One of the most fun things I can imagine somebody now getting out of early MuggleCast is our announcements for each of those pieces of technology, or as they slowly get mentioned. Who’s the first person to mention an iPhone on an episode of…? I mean, I’m sure it’s Andrew.

Andrew: Probably me.

Eric: It’s probably Andrew, yeah. Or Kevin, right? Where he’s like, “In the future, there will be phones…”

Andrew: “I saw the leaked plans.”

Eric: [laughs] But anyway, it’s just… it’s a time… what’s the word, where you put it in the ground?

Andrew: Time capsule?

Eric: Capsule, thank you… of technology and how it’s growing up with us. Things like Pottermore and the announcement, there had never been something like that. Or J.K. Rowling’s website; there had never been interaction between a huge world global celebrity and her direct readership before. That cut through all the levels of red tape that usually exists between celebrity and fan, in a really frankly warm and hardy way. And looking at our own podcast history, too, all the little bits of technology that existed… we had at one point… there were fan listings and forums that were old phpBB forums. The podcast itself… I don’t know if… we all had MySpace accounts, right? Did you have any Xangas?

Andrew: I had a MySpace.

Eric: I mean, growing up, that was part of what you did and part of your identity. And there’s people who roleplay Harry Potter on MySpace or chat rooms or any other… there’s flash animation. Do you guys remember TheFifthDistrict.com was…? They had that “Badger, badger, badger, mushroom, mushroom.”

Andrew: I never heard of that.

Eric: Oh, well, somebody did a Harry Potter version, which was “Potter, Potter, Weasley.” And I mean, it’s just… whatever it was, whether it was early YouTube videos or Frapper maps, where you could track where the listeners were or where you were coming from…

Micah: Yeah, I remember that.

Andrew: Oh yeah, we were like, “Follow us on Frapper.” That was cool.

Eric: That’s probably still a thing. We’ve got to look up and see if we still have a Frapper map.

Andrew: I’m looking.

Eric: There’s probably 6.5 billion people who said that with an… or no E.

Andrew: No E?

Eric: Yeah, F-R-A-P-P-R. That was a huge Internet thing back then.

Micah: Or even think about how we record this show? I mean, yeah, we still use shitty Skype, but…

[silence]

Micah: … the evolution of how people…

Andrew: It literally broke up as you said that.

Eric: It was breaking up as you said that. It was the funniest thing.

Micah: Yeah, of course it was. Of course it was. They’re listening to us. The whole connection is going to drop in the next five minutes, or five seconds, I should say. But just the evolution of how people listen to us then versus now. You can only get us, what, on an iPod or on iTunes back in 2005, versus today, there’s so many different ways that you could listen to us.

Eric: Well, and that was cutting edge. A podcast in the iTunes directory was cutting edge. That was the latest version of iTunes had that before we started.

Micah: And we got a shout-out, didn’t we, during one of the Apple Talks?

Eric: Yeah, it’s on YouTube. You’ve got to look it up. “MuggleCast Steve Jobs.” Just Google… Just YouTube it. “MuggleCast Steve Jobs.” It’s on there.

Andrew: [imitating Steve Jobs] “There’s even podcasts for Harry Potter! Can you believe it?”

Eric: And we’re right there, right at the top. MuggleCast. Andrew Sims, Ben Schoen, Kevin Steck. All there.

Andrew: But Harry Potter really didn’t influence podcasting, I don’t think. Harry Potter definitely fit naturally in with podcasting, but Harry Potter definitely influenced fansites. And after Harry Potter, there was Twilight; there was The Hunger Games; there was Divergent; there was 50 Shades of Grey. [laughs] And particularly with Twilight, there were so many fansites for Twilight, and it was heavily inspired by what the fandom over in the Harry Potter community was doing. I know one of the biggest Twilight fansites, the Twilight Lexicon; Laura and Jen, who founded it, they were big, big MuggleNet followers, and so when they saw Twilight coming up, they knew that this was something that they should do for that fandom. And so looking at the lasting legacy of Harry Potter online, definitely fansites, forums, fanfiction communities… all this… Harry Potter was just so deep that you could create fansites and whatnot and have them be very successful.

Eric: It provided a template.

Micah: People are going to mention Lord of the Rings. People are going to mention Star Wars. You brought them up before, Andrew. But I think the key with Potter was that the story was still being told, right? Yeah, the movies were being created, but to me, it was really rallying around the books and the story and the fact that you could spend all this time online, looking around, discussing with people, theorizing what was going to happen next. I don’t think that existed in the same way for Lord of the Rings or Star Wars, because it had already been written. It was already final; you already knew what was going to happen. And in this case, you didn’t.

Eric: Right, as being a mystery. And what I think you mean is there wasn’t an Internet when Star Wars was still coming out, so there was not this global community able to get… I mean, maybe they did it through magazines; the early Star Trek and Star Wars fans had magazine publications and fan publications. But in terms of the web, I mean, Harry Potter was the first presence on the web that was the first massive presence on the web. It set a template for how you do fan stuff on the web, and there’s plenty of other examples of it influencing the publishing industry. Like you said, all those other books that got greenlit afterwards may have never been had it not been for the success of Harry Potter

Andrew: Yeah, it’s true.

Eric: … as well as the rights holders themselves. I mean, Warner Bros. sued the early fansite webmasters. Cease and desist letters were sent to 12- and 13-year-olds in 1999, telling them that they were violating copyright by having a Harry Potter fansite, and it was a huge learning curve. Those rules, those laws, hadn’t been written yet to protect and to understand what fair use was. All of this stuff exists now, largely because of people interacting with new media in new ways – including Harry Potter – at the dawn of the Internet.

Andrew: Yeah, and I know Melissa from the Leaky Cauldron likes to bring this up: The Harry Potter fansites, particularly Leaky and MuggleNet, were the first ones to actually get set visits, to visit the movie sets, and that was just kind of unheard of back then as well. And I know one of our listeners emailed in, Sofia, about the creators and the consumers starting to work together more. This is a perfect example of that. The studios, after suing, [laughs] finally realized that they can actually be helpful, and now… there hasn’t been a “new Harry Potter,” in a few years. Divergent kind of was; Twilight kind of was. And I just mean there’s an online community with fansites, and these studios today work with these fansites now because they know hardcore communities are in there.

Eric: Your name is in The Hunger Games, isn’t it? Or is it Divergent?

Andrew: Oh, yeah, the Divergent movie. Yeah, because for Hypable, I got invited to the Divergent set, actually, here in Chicago. So what they did was there’s this ranking board in the movie, and Tris looks at it at one point and there’s a bunch of names like “Tris” to see how their training is going, how many points they’ve scored, or whatever. And then the extra names… so they have the characters like “Peter” and “Tris” and all these others, and then there’s the fansite people’s names like me. I’m actually ranked pretty high on that list, and I’m pleased about it.

Micah: Nice.

Eric: [laughs] Somebody knows you and gave you a high score.

Micah: See, but that’s just an amazing example of the fact that they now are more collaborative in terms of working with fan communities and fan websites, because they know that the more that they do that, just, I think the more success that they’re going to have. And they’re reaching their core fan through these sites.

Eric: Yeah. Well, and it was proven that websites don’t hinder but rather help Harry Potter fans. The three years between books, the two or three years between books, the fandom… I mean, I know Harry Potter is great and all, but it really could have died if you didn’t have those people or these resources where you could constantly talk about it and think about it and do more. I think that we directly contributed to keeping the fire stoked for Harry Potter for each book and each movie.

Andrew: And I think right now you see this happening with Game of Thrones, because you don’t know what’s coming on the TV show, so there’s all this theorizing out there that you haven’t seen in a while. And I say Game of Thrones… obviously, there’s theorizing for lots of TV shows, but Game of Thrones, it’s so popular. It is Harry Potter-level for television. That’s just…

Micah: Yeah, it could be argued to be one of the most popular television shows in history, and to be the biggest thing that’s facing them is the fact that George R.R. Martin has yet to release the sixth book, never mind the seventh and final one… they have a lot of challenges in my mind that they’re facing with these last two seasons this year and next year, but that’s for another time. But you mentioned earlier, though, the set visits; how about the fact that both Emerson and Melissa were invited to go to J.K. Rowling’s home and interview her not long after Half-Blood Prince was released?

Eric: I’m still so shocked.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: No, I mean, think about that. That doesn’t happen if those websites don’t exist, and then obviously, those websites don’t exist without the Internet. So you just think about going back to the point that was made about being able to have those direct lines of communication, or maybe they’re somewhat indirect in a way, but it’s the same kind of thing with Jo and her website very early on, and now social media being able to connect directly with her, with those that were in the films, the community has become so much closer because of the Internet and because of social media.

Andrew: Yeah, and by working closely with the fansites, you will get interviews like Emerson and Melissa talking to J.K. Rowling. That’s something that you wouldn’t get with a Katie Couric on The Today Show or Lester Holt on the nightly news. You get a genuine interview with genuinely interesting questions that the real fans actually want asked.

Eric: Absolutely.

Andrew: And that’s why I would love to have J.K. Rowling on MuggleCast. Come on over, girl.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: We’ll ask her the hard questions, like is Lavender Brown alive or dead?

Andrew: I am so confident when I say this: We would have the best interview with J.K. Rowling ever.

Eric: I think so too.

Andrew: I’m not joking. It would be fantastic. We would ask the best questions that people have always wanted answered; it would just be the greatest thing. And I bet that’s why she doesn’t do it, because she knows it’d be so good that she would just be exposed. It’d be the Battle of Hogwarts; it would all end there.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: There’d be no more questions left for her.

Eric: That is the boldest statement I think has ever been made on MuggleCast.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Yeah, I mean, look, I want to know once and for all what is the name of Aberforth’s goat? I think we need to put it to rest.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Which one? You know there’s more than one. They have a shorter lifespan than Aberforth.

Micah: Hey, look. There’s one, and then there’s the rest. I mean, come on.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: No, but I think those are the types of interviews that an author like J.K. Rowling, and the cast and the crew, they want to do them. Because Evanna mentioned it when she was on the show a couple weeks ago; it just feels more natural. It feels like you’re having a conversation, as opposed to getting the same damn questions thrown at you over and over and over again. It’s a conversation you’re having with people who enjoy what you’ve done just as much as you do.

Andrew: With all this said about fansites, for how beneficial they’ve been for the communities, I actually do think that fansites as we know them are on their way out, and that’s all thanks to social media. Back in the day, you had to go to MuggleNet to get the latest Harry Potter news. Now you just like and follow pages on Twitter and Facebook and Instagram, and we all operate within these apps now to get our latest news.

Eric: Social media has really killed the fansite. We were there to see it start…

Andrew: Grow and die.

Eric: … grow, and die.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: It’s like a…

Andrew: [in an old man voice] That’s how old we are.

Eric: [in an old man voice] A character in the Harry Potter books. [back to normal voice] But really, that’s been the great thing, is to see what’s next, and also to ride that wave, too. Struggle to figure out…

Micah: What’s social media going to do?

Eric: Yeah, how to stay relevant.

Micah: I agree with that. I also think, though, that there’s a bit of nostalgia, thinking back to J.K. Rowling’s website, and really, fansites being used for things like book release dates, like book titles. I remember going onto J.K. Rowling’s website and trying to figure out what the title was going to be. I think it was for Half-Blood Prince. Is that possible? Yeah, I think you had to solve a puzzle. She always did an amazing job of making you do all these little puzzles and find these clues in order to get titles and things like that. But I think about trailers. Trailers were exclusively released on fansites.

Andrew: Mm… no.

Eric: Certain ones, yeah. Certain ones.

Micah: Well, initially. Not exclusively. They were initially put out, right? I mean, much like giving it to a media outlet, they gave it to a fansite.

Eric: There was that one where they gave everyone a letter or something of the… whether it was the Fantastic Beasts film, but like, 12 fansites participated in this. Hypable had one; MuggleNet had one. It was a piece of puzzle that only when viewed together… it was one of the Cormoran Strike books titles or something like that. I mean, they gave those…

Andrew: Are you talking about Pottermore? I think you’re talking about Pottermore.

Eric: No, you know what I’m talking about? I actually just remembered: The Kazu Kibuishi book covers…

Andrew: Ahh.

Eric: … were released exclusively at certain fan events.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, yeah.

Eric: Or key websites had the ability to reveal what the book covers were. I mean, something as small as a book cover…

Micah: But Pottermore too, though. Andrew, to your point, Pottermore was a collaboration of fansites being given bits of information, and you had to go to all of them to figure out exactly what it was.

Andrew: And Pottermore, when they were launching, they worked closely with the fansites to give them previews before they announced it. I got a preview, and I had to sign an NDA so I wouldn’t say anything about it before it was actually released. And by having the fansites on their side, then they’re just creating a more positive message out there for the fans, especially when… because the studios are inviting you to the set visits, to the junkets, to please you, so you’re going to write positively about what they’re doing. It is manipulation…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: … but at the same time, you get to really… you can do a good job reporting stuff that a typical website, say ComingSoon.net or one of these others where it isn’t genuine fans, they’re not writing something as thoughtful, as passionate as you are from this ad or from an interview. And same thing goes for coming up with questions.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: So one thing we wanted to ask ourselves is all this talk of fansites, and they are kind of failing, but let’s say…

Eric: Is this the fun segment time?

Andrew: This is the hypothetical question…

Eric: Hypothetical question game.

Andrew: If you were to make a fansite about something today, in the year 2017, what would it be? And the rule is it would be the only site out there for what you’re creating it for, so let’s say it’s the only Harry Potter fansite. And it wouldn’t be popular, because as we were just saying, fansites are kind of dead right now.

Eric: Oh, no, it would be popular.

Andrew: It would?

Eric: What did we say? Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Okay.

Eric: If you could create today the most massively successful fansite for a topic, what would it be? Right?

Andrew: Yeah. Well, okay. Well, yeah. I mean, I’ll say mine would be a Bruce Springsteen fansite. [laughs] But I would also do it if it wasn’t going to be popular, because if you’re really passionate about something…

Eric: Welcome to Bruce’s House.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: You’ve got to get that domain.

Andrew: Yeah, BrucesHouse.com.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: No, I would still want to do it because I’m passionate about it. Like, when Emerson started MuggleNet, he didn’t do it because he thought it’d be super popular; he just did it because he was passionate about it.

Eric: It’s amazing to analyze what made MuggleNet MuggleNet, too. I think it was just the name, right? Just a catchy kind of…

Andrew: It’s a great name.

Eric: Net.com, some people… that confuses people.

Andrew: Oh, yeah. People still…

Eric: Nobody to this day capitalizes the N, except for everyone who’s ever contributed to it.

Andrew: Not even Emerson does on his own website. Can’t believe it.

Eric: Not even… [laughs] We discovered that the other day.

Andrew: Well, and people would usually call it Muggle.net? I would get emails referring to us as Muggle.net; I’d be like, [in a nasally voice] “Uh, no, excuse me, it’s MuggleNet.com.”

Eric: Yeah, that was me. But Bruce Springsteen… are there not Bruce Springsteen…?

Andrew: There are.

Eric: Well, what are they called? What are they…? Tell us.

Andrew: Well, there’s one called Backstreets.com; that’s the big one, and they still have a phpBB forum.

Eric: Whoa.

Andrew: And I still visit it daily.

Eric: You guys, listeners, he’s going on it right now.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Welcome back, Andrew. You have been… the headline is “The Promised Land.”

Andrew: Yeah, it’s a song.

Eric: And he goes to the Backstreets forums, and he’s on the Promised Land.

Andrew: PhpBB is the system that all forums have been built in. MuggleNet’s forum, COS forums, was built on phpBB.

Eric: The MuggleCast fan forums were on there.

Andrew: And I mean, forums… speaking of fansites dying, forums are another thing that’s died because people just talk on social media now, but there are still some forums that are alive.

Eric: Isn’t Reddit just like a big different way of…?

Andrew: Yeah. I know the Britney Spears site, Breathe Heavy, they have a very popular forum too.

Eric: Her website might be more popular than she is right now.

Andrew: Exhale, it’s called.

Eric: Exhale, okay. Breathe Heavy, Exhale.

Andrew: Anyway, so yeah, mine would be Bruce Springsteen. What would be yours, Eric?

Eric: Gosh, I need a moment. I can’t…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I know I had hours to think about this when we planned this. But do you know what yours might be, Micah?

Micah: Whatever the next big thing is.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: You just want to make money.

Micah: No…

Eric: [singing] Money off the thing… the next big thing, yeah.

Micah: Maybe there would have been a time where I would have said Game of Thrones, but I feel like that’s already well-established, and there’s a lot of great sites out there now.

Andrew: Right, well, the question is if you were making the first one, first and only, and it was going to be popular.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: So then it would be Game of Thrones? The big Game of Thrones one is what, WinterIsComing.net?

Eric and Micah: Watchers on the Wall.

Andrew: Watchers on the Wall… [typing sounds]

Eric: Trying to think what I would… I know what I would do.

Micah: Maybe Legend of Zelda. How about that?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Legend of Zelda fansite; that’s really cool.

Andrew: I would do a Nintendo one. I like talking, writing about Nintendo.

Eric: Yeah, that’s what I would… I used to… I grew up going to a website called Cheat Code Central.

Andrew: Ahh, that was the coolest site ever.

Eric: Wasn’t that the coolest site ever? It was the coolest site ever, Cheat Code Central. That was the website I had always wanted… yeah.

Micah: I want to ask Andrew, though… we’re talking about this, and Eric, it’ll give you some more time to think about your answer.

Eric: No, no, I legit… that was my answer; I was getting into my answer. But what were you doing to ask Andrew?

Micah: Oh, okay. No, I was going to ask about Hypable, though, and how really, all of this has led to creation of your site and all the fandoms that it serves.

Andrew: Yeah. Right, well, Hypable, when we started it, we wanted it to be a MuggleNet for all fandoms. That’s how I’ve been pitching it to people for years, [laughs] because we want to have that fan voice, that genuine fan voice, for a bunch of different fandoms. And in the early days, we were trying to cover every little thing about every fandom that we were covering, like, “Okay, there’s these new pictures for this TV show, and now these new pictures,” just the little things like you would’ve on MuggleNet. But now we’re trying to just more focus on passionate fan-written articles about TV shows, books, and movies, because it is impossible to cover every little thing for certain fandoms. So it’s still a MuggleNet for multiple fandoms; we’re just changing exactly how we present that. But even, I think, MuggleNet these days, you guys write original articles about particular topics within Harry Potter.

Eric: Yeah, try and have unique thought pieces and unique content.

Andrew: Because there isn’t news right now.

Eric: Well, and also, I mean, that’s what separates us from just a cold BuzzFeed or a cold… I mean, Buzzfeed is too… that’s the other thing, is people who grew up with Harry Potter alongside us are now the managing editors of online websites, and you see so many Harry Potter articles on Buzzfeed because look at who wrote them; well, old friends of ours, listeners of our show, visitors of our website, and friends, and it’s crazy to see that go. But getting back… so I would absolutely do a video game website, absolutely. Like a fansite for all the games that I used to play as a kid. Probably a Crash Bandicoot website is what I would do.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Crash Bandicoot.

Eric: I would have the world’s leading… but purist, only the first four. Only the Naughty Dog titles, and the Activision one that just redid those in HD, the N. Sane Trilogy; it’s great. But yeah, absolutely, video game fansite. That was the fansite I always wanted to have made for sure.

Andrew: James is also pointing out on the… he’s listening live, and he’s pointing out that IMDb recently removed its discussion boards, which was controversial, because they wanted to push their social media activity instead. Yeah, I remember when they did that a month or two ago. Basically forums. That was surprising because those IMDb discussion boards were big, but…

Eric: All I ever saw in there was people trashing each other.

Andrew: Yeah, they weren’t very… they weren’t always that great, but people liked… I don’t know. I thought… I popped in from time to time.

Eric: I liked the opportunity because it was like, if you go to a movie that you just saw, its discussion board on IMDb, it’s like, “This is the definitive conversation people are having about this movie.” Of course, it wasn’t by far at all, because the people you get on there are just your casuals with nothing better to do. But I mean, yeah, there’s some interesting questions being asked.

Micah: And maybe thinking back on it, would a Trump site have been worthwhile?

Andrew: Yeah, well, if you were the first to create a Trump fansite, absolutely. There may have been an Apprentice fansite.

Micah: Oh, I’m sure there is.

Andrew: I know, there are reality TV…

Eric: That’s actually a really good point.

Andrew: There were/are reality TV fansites…

Micah: Survivor.

Andrew: … like for The Bachelor and all them because there’s so many.

Eric: It’s probably called “The Rose,” and the other one is called “The Island,” I’m sure.

Andrew: [laughs] I mean, just to start wrapping up, Harry Potter, I think, has definitely had a profound influence, and we’re going to see it continue to have an influence as Fantastic Beasts continues. Pottermore could potentially be a defining moment for these major brands. There’s an official Star Wars website, but they don’t have a resource like Pottermore right now, certainly not something as interactive as Pottermore is.

Eric: Actually, StarWars.com is really, really good about that, releasing exclusives.

Andrew: They do break news on there, but I mean, I don’t know. I guess it’s a false equivalency, but where are their Hogwarts House Sorting quizzes and stuff like that? [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, those directors, too, are running rampant on social, Instagramming… that’s been the new cool thing, is for film writers, directors, and showrunners to directly post to social photos of their lead actors on set in the Millennium Falcon cockpit, this, that, the other thing. It’s just… it’s all changing, and I think people will be watching what J.K. Rowling is doing and how J.K. Rowling is doing this, because she’s led the way in the past for these changes to occur, so I think we should just do what we would have done anyway, and keep an eye and see where this grows from here. I mean, 20 years and no signs of stopping.

Andrew: All right, well, I think that concludes our main discussion. Feel free to email in, MuggleCast@gmail.com, or use MuggleCast.com. You can also tweet us or Facebook us: Twitter.com/MuggleCast, Facebook.com/MuggleCast. No matter how you contact us, we’re reading all of them. We also do have that voicemail line; we’ll get back to playing some of those in the weeks ahead. And by the way, if you have a main discussion idea for us, if there’s something you’d like us to talk about, let us know; we’d be happy to take your suggestion into consideration. Our voicemail number is 920-3-MUGGLE. That’s a U.S. number, so if you’re overseas, put a one in front of it: 1-920-368-4453.

Eric: Andrew, it’s so fun having you here in Chicago, and…

Andrew: [laughs] Just reminded me of something.

Eric: What?

Andrew: Eric told me last night what my housewarming gift is once I move here.

Eric: Oh, God.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: We should absolutely talk about this.

Andrew: Eric told me last night that to welcome me to Chicago, he’s going to give me a key to the P.O. Box.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: I was like, “You know, that’s very thoughtful, and that’s actually very sweet, but I know you love checking the P.O. Box. I don’t want to take that away from you.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So I’ll maybe have the key; I’ll put it on my dresser or something, but I won’t access it. You can still go to it yourself.

Eric: It’s a symbolic key. It won’t actually be the key; I’ll just make you think it is.

Andrew: Yeah, right.

Eric: It’s a symbolic gesture.

Andrew: Yeah, fake key. [laughs]

Eric: “Welcome to Chicago.” But yeah, actually, speaking of the P.O. Box, if you are feeling so regretful that you didn’t send us a birthday thing, you don’t need to. Save your money.

Andrew: Oh, stop, Eric. That’s so guilty-trippy.

Eric: Save your money! I’m just telling people to save their money! But our P.O. Box, which we announce spottily, is 4044 North Lincoln Avenue, #144, Chicago, Il, 60618. You can address it to either MuggleCast or me, Eric Scull, and we will get it. But I don’t know about sending more beer, but we’ll let you know how the Pukwudgie tastes.

Micah: Please do. What do you mean, you don’t know?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Well, the other thing is, it’s nice to see Andrew here, but Micah, I’m going to see you. We’re all going to see each other in less than three weeks at MuggleNet Live, which is the MuggleNet Live 2017: 19 Years Later on September 1 in Orlando, Florida. We’re going to take the train from King’s Cross Station inside the Universal theme park and just really have a blast all night in Diagon Alley with unlimited butterbeer, a feast of food, and riding the rides. It’ll be a great new thing; there will be…

Micah: We’ll also be doing a podcast.

Eric: We will be doing a podcast, yes.

Andrew: For everyone.

Eric: Yeah, so the actors and cast and crew will be there, and they’re listed on the MuggleNet Live website…

Micah: Otherwise it just sounds like you’re saying we’re going to the park to have a good time, without mentioning…

Andrew: [laughs] That is all.

Eric: Well, okay, okay. You’re right, Micah. Selling point. We’re going to be doing one of these podcasts there, and maybe one of the cast members there will join us. We’ll get Sean Biggerstaff to teach us how to play Quidditch. Who knows?

Andrew: Yeah, sounds good. All right, good stuff. Thank you, everybody, for listening 12 years later. We appreciate your support. To hell with 19 years later! Talk about 12 years later.

Eric: 12 years later.

Andrew: And I’m finally getting a key to the P.O. Box. So beautiful.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Thanks, everybody, for listening. I’m Andrew.

Eric: I’m Eric.

Micah: And I’m Micah.

Andrew: Without Eric on a delay, he’s like, right on top of me. We did that twice.

Eric: I’m usually on a delay.

Andrew: [laughs] “I’m Andrew, I’m Eric.” See everybody next time for 333. Goodbye! 3.

Transcript #326

 

MuggleCast 326 Transcript

 

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #326, Newt, with Evanna Lynch

[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, the Harry Potter podcast discussing everything about J.K. Rowling’s wizarding world. New episodes of MuggleCast are made possible thanks to listeners like you. Please visit Patreon.com/MuggleCast to support the show and help us grow. In exchange, you’ll receive exclusive benefits including an ad-free version of our podcast.


Show Intro


Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast, Episode 326. I’m Andrew.

Eric Scull: I’m Eric.

Micah Tannenbaum: I’m Micah.

Andrew: And we have a special guest this week. If you’re familiar with Harry Potter, you will know who this person is. Welcome, Evanna Lynch, to the show! Hi, Evanna.

Evanna Lynch: Hello! I’m so excited to be here. Thank you for having me.

Andrew: We are so excited to have you. Of course, you played Luna Lovegood in the Harry Potter movies over the years. And what are you up to these days? I know you’re working on a couple of projects.

Evanna: Yeah, I’m still acting. I’m doing a play at the moment in London called Disco Pigs. Yeah, just that, and then I’m doing… I’m sure other people know because I bang on about it enough. I’m an animal activist, vegan activist, so I’m working on my own podcast, which is… I guess this is how this came about, because Eric has been helping me, teaching me all the technology.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Cool. Awesome.

Evanna: But I just realized, I don’t think… have I ever been on MuggleCast before?

Eric: Well, you were on the live show at LeakyCon 2012 in Chicago.

Evanna: Oh, okay.

Eric: I remember because you brought… [laughs] We asked you if you wanted one of our Seven Year shirts, and you said, “No, I’ll bring one of my own,” and you had the original MuggleCast shirt with the silhouettes. I don’t know how you got it.

[Andrew laughs]

Evanna: I still have it! I probably bought it, guys. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, probably. Well, and that’s the thing; for anyone who doesn’t know, Evanna is a true Harry Potter fan. She heard about the Luna Lovegood open casting call through MuggleNet all those years ago, right?

Evanna: Yep. Wouldn’t be here if not for MuggleNet, yep.

Andrew: So crazy. So crazy.

Evanna: Yeah, I remember I used to… it was just my routine every day. I’d get home from school. First thing I would do, boot up my dad’s… it was one of those ancient computers, his desktop.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Evanna: And I would immediately go to MuggleNet and catch up on the news. And you guys are responsible for my geekery, for me going on set and knowing all of the cast birthdays. I was such a weirdo.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: Because you know the way you would wish the characters’ birthdays? And you would also wish the cast happy birthdays? So I would both be like, “Oh, did you know it’s Neville’s birthday today, Matt?” And I would also wish them their own birthdays. I was so weird. And I was really proud of knowing that; I didn’t realize that would freak people out. Yeah, that’s all your fault.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Well, sorry, sorry. You brought the fan experience onto set, so that’s pretty cool.

Evanna: I know, yeah.

Eric: I think it was a much-needed component of those films.

Evanna: It was the only thing… so I was a very insecure teen; I just wasn’t confident in myself in many ways. But I was confident in my Harry Potter knowledge and trivia, and yeah, I liked to flaunt it around the set. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, well, and I remember when I went to the Order of the Phoenix set visit – that was, of course, your first movie – and the publicist was like, “All right, everybody go easy on Evanna. She’s new to this. She’s shy; ask her easy questions.”

[Evanna laughs]

Andrew: And I do remember you were so shy. [laughs] But you were young!

Evanna: No, but I was also probably starstruck by you, Andrew. I think I probably told you that.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Evanna: Genuinely. You, and then also Melissa and John from Pottercast. When I met you guys, I was freaking out afterwards in the corridor, and I had this chaperone because I was underage when I started filming, and she was like, “Who are these people? What’s wrong?” [laughs] I was like, “You don’t understand; they’re Harry Potter fandom royalty, and they just interviewed me!”

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: Oh, that’s amazing. I told a story a few weeks ago on MuggleCast briefly; tell me if this is right. I hope I got it right, that you were listening to MuggleCast on set one day, and like, Emma Watson comes up to you and is like, “What are you listening to?” And you’re like, “Oh, MuggleCast,” and then you guys listened together for a little bit or something? Was that right? Did that happen?

Evanna: Probably. Because in the makeup rooms in the morning, everyone had their… like, Dan would listen to this rock – I don’t know what it was – punk rock kind of stuff. And I introduced everyone to wizard rock, and probably to MuggleCast. And I think also, because didn’t Ben have a crush on Emma? And I was kind of trying to set them up.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: I was trying to talk Ben up to Emma.

Andrew: Oh my God, I was not aware that you were trying to set them up. That is hilarious. [laughs]

Evanna: Yeah. I didn’t get very far with that. I’m not much of a matchmaker, yeah. But no, I definitely did tell everyone about it.

Andrew: That’s great.

Evanna: And I remember it always used to be so annoying when I would do interviews with you guys, because you guys would be in the same chat as just journalists who hadn’t a clue about the fandom and they just were given these briefing notes. And I just wanted to get super geeky and talk about the real… I don’t know, just the real in-depth fan and the in-jokes and everything. And we never could.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, there were journalists on set who would not know anything about Harry Potter.

Evanna: Completely.

Andrew: That was always so frustrating, because then they would turn to us in between interviews and be like, “What’s that character do? What’s this character do?” I’m like, “I’m not telling you; read the books.” [laughs]

Eric: Should’ve given them the wrong information so… [laughs]

Micah: Yeah, there you go.

Andrew: “Harry Potter has no magical abilities. He’s a Muggle.”

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: Anyway. Well, speaking of all this fandom stuff, what did you think of Cursed Child? I assume you saw it.

Evanna: I did see Cursed Child, yeah. I never read it, because I knew I was going to see it. And I just heard so many people say you have to experience it, so I saw it. And I mean, have you guys seen the play? Or did you just read it?

Eric: Andrew has.

Andrew: I did.

Evanna: Okay. So I just thought it was so… it really creates the universe. The magic was so beautiful, and it felt like real, traditional wizard magic, almost like the way when you go see a magician show, there’s just all this…. I don’t know, there’s a quality about it that’s really alluring, whereas obviously, in the films, it was all so high-tech and polished. And I like that it felt authentic. Just old-fashioned magic. That was really beautiful to me, and it really helped create the world. And it felt very different from the film universe, definitely. And oh, I loved Scorpius. He was my favorite.

[Andrew laughs]

Evanna: I thought he was so sweet. And he had such a vulnerable quality to him, and I think it was… I just love how Jo’s compassion, her heart for everyone, for making you feel for everyone, really just shines through in her characters, and especially through him, whereas the Malfoys were such a detestable family before. And to see someone who is kind of weak – or not weak, but just softer, sensitive, and not all the qualities that his family values. I loved him. But on the other side of it, I had a big, big problem with Harry, and that really… [sighs] I just felt he was so… God, I’m struggling for words here. But just the way he didn’t… he was trying to separate Scorpios and Albus. I was like, “Dude, were you not there for all the Sorting Hat songs?”

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: The Sorting Hat that spent years composing these poems or songs or whatever you want to call them about…

Eric: Unity.

Evanna: Unity, yeah. That togetherness. And also, I just felt like Harry has been through this. We’ve already… that was such a big theme in the books, and I just really felt like Harry was wiser than this. And after everything we’ve been through, after he’d had all his fits of rage [laughs] and seeing that people divided isn’t a good thing and that the Houses separating people necessarily isn’t a good thing.

Eric: Yeah, I think that’s very fair. I mean, Harry, throughout his years, befriends students from other Houses. That’s the whole point, you know? Dumbledore’s Army; he befriends Luna… and he certainly makes his peace with Slytherin House because he names his child after Snape. So I think you’re right; I think he’s a little… Harry in Cursed Child – and this reads through in the in the script as well – a little too out of it. And you can tell that it…

Micah: He seems stressed out, right?

Eric: Yeah, but it very clearly, I think, exists to serve the plot. And that’s apparent, where it’s just like, “Oh, we have to separate these two kids now so that they’ll want to be together more.” I don’t know.

Evanna: Yeah, but it just was out of character for me. I just could see it coming, and I don’t like that in stories when I know what the big blowup is going to be, [laughs] that it’s like, “You shouldn’t have been trying to keep these people apart, and that’s going to work against you.” But I guess it’s also… I mean, it presents the idea that just because he’s older, doesn’t mean he’s going to be wiser or he’s not going to always know what to do. It might be that he just has more baggage. But for me, it just didn’t feel true to Harry.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s going through a phase. No, I think you’re right. And I do agree with your positive points, particularly the magic on stage; seeing that actually happen, it’s like, “Wow, how did they do that?” Because they can’t cheat with special effects, with digital effects.

Evanna: Absolutely, yeah. It’s really cool.

Andrew: So it’s pretty impressive.

Andrew: And then, of course, Fantastic Beasts. Do you love it?

Evanna: I loved Fantastic Beasts. I really did!

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Evanna: I thought it was so good! I just love Newt. I was so happy to have a really awkward hero. Even how he speaks, he’s just not confident. He’s not. He’s only in his element when he’s in the animal world. And I think you see that he deals with humans because of his passion for saving animals and protecting them, protecting animals. But he’s just not… he is just awkward, just interesting. And I just thought the animals were also just… for me, it always expands the world when you see the creatures and when you learn more about the creatures, and to see their culture, it’s, I think… Harry Potter has always been thought of as such a quintessentially British thing, and yes, that’s Harry Potter, but that isn’t the wizarding world. It’s just so exciting to have seen that expansion for me.

Andrew: Yeah. And so on today’s episode, we will be talking about Newt to wrap up our character discussion series.

Eric: Perfect.

Andrew: And it’s so great to have you on this episode, Evanna, because you love animals, like you said. So it works out very well. And it’s also so glad we’re having you on now because we just found out a couple of weeks ago that they’re doing open auditions for these teenage Fantastic Beasts roles: teenage Newt, Leta, Grindelwald, Dumbledore…

Evanna: So cool.

Andrew: … which I’m sure you must be theorizing a lot of the potential storylines that J.K. Rowling might be getting into. But I was wondering, do you have any advice for these teenagers, since you yourself went through this? [laughs]

Evanna: Yeah, I don’t know. Advice… I would just say to be true to your interpretation of the characters. Obviously, it’s a little bit different, because they don’t exactly know the characters; they don’t have all the information on them. But I would say play in your imagination. Create someone who you feel is realistic and true to what you know about them in their history, and just go and do that. Don’t worry about being right or being what they want. That was what I did, and that’s what I think they really picked up on, that I just was like, “I’m not going in to please these casting directors; I’m going in to be true to the spirit of Luna.” And I just had this weird confidence that I knew Luna better than anyone, and if anyone had a different interpretation of her, that they were wrong.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: That was just what I felt. And I actually said that to them, which is really out of character for me. It sounds really cocky. But as I say, it was just this faith I had, where I went in and they were asking me about her and my interpretation; I was like, “It’s up to you to disagree with me, but if you go a different way with Luna, I respectfully have to say that you’re going the wrong direction.”

Micah: You would have boycotted all the future films, right?

[Andrew laughs]

Evanna: God, it would have been painful. It would have… I would have…

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: I don’t think I would have enjoyed those films anymore.

Micah: Who was in the room, though, that you said that to? Just out of curiosity.

Evanna: It was David Heyman, David Barron, David Yates. The three Davids, yeah.

Micah: Nice.

Evanna: And I think Fiona the casting director was there at the same time.

Andrew: Your statements were warranted, though, because I think everybody agrees that you are Luna. It’s just amazing. [laughs]

Evanna: Yeah, I mean, I personally don’t feel like I am Luna. I feel like that’d be really bigheaded of me to say, because I see her as such an aspirational figure. She’s someone who just really inspired me to just embrace anything I felt uncomfortable about myself, and she still does. But it was just this feeling… whenever I read the books, I got this huge sense of relief and happiness and inspiration whenever she came on the page, because she was so accepting of everyone around her and so curious and so open to diversity. And I just was… I felt really fierce for the fact that I just didn’t want somebody who’s just an actress just being like, “Oh, awesome, this will advance my career,” and scheming about it.

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: I just was like, “No, Luna is so much bigger than the actress. Luna is so much bigger than whoever plays her that you just have to put her first. You have to put that energy, that beautiful light that she brings to the world to her situation around her, you have to embody that.” So yeah, I would say… I mean, advice for people auditioning, just go as geeky as you want. [laughs] Just study and realize it’s not really about your talent or your experience as an actor; it’s about your passion for the character. And knowing these people, these creators of the films as I do, they just so appreciated that when they saw that in me that I was fierce about protecting her spirit. And yeah, as I say, her story was greater than mine. And they want someone who has ideas. They don’t want someone who’s just going to stand up and interpret it; they want someone who is going to add more to it. Like the fact that I went to my first screen test, my earrings… you know that I made the earrings, so I had made these pigs with wings. I really thought that was… for me, that was a little symbol of “Oh, impossible, the impossible is possible!”

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: I was so geeky about it. And they immediately pointed them out, and they loved them, and they encouraged me then as soon as I got the role; they were like, “All right, get to work; make some Luna accessories.”

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: That’s great.

Evanna: And then the same thing when they couldn’t exactly figure out the lion hat, how they wanted it to look, they came to me. And they want someone who has specific ideas on the character. And David Yates, to his credit, he always said to me – and I think having worked with other directors, this is a rare quality in a director – that he always said, “You know Luna better than anyone in the world purely because you’re playing her. You are part of her; she’s part of you.” And he never forced any directions on me. And if he was unhappy with the way I was playing something, or if he just didn’t feel like it fit right, all he would do was question me. He would question and question till we got to somewhere where we had a mutual understanding, until I would go like, “Oh, yeah, actually, she wouldn’t do it like this. You’re right.”

Andrew: That’s amazing.

Evanna: So yeah, go in there, own that character, and just really believe that you know them better than anyone, and you can do the best version of your character, I think.

Andrew: That’s great advice. You’re speaking very fondly of David Yates; you must have been thrilled to hear he was coming back for Fantastic Beasts.

Evanna: Oh, definitely. Yeah, he really cares for it and he really knows it. And yeah, he just knows how to treat actors, which is so nice because so many directors just yell at you and tell you you’re wrong. [laughs] Or just they force you to do… and he really is such a collaborator with actors, and he sees through things. He always talks about the quality of actors. I remember when a while ago… oh, I think it was at the Fantastic Beasts premiere and afterwards, and I was saying how I really liked Queenie’s character, and he was talking about “Yeah, it’s interesting; she’s got a real Luna quality to her.” And I was like, “Oh, that’s…” because they’re very different in many ways, but it is sort of that essence, I think, that he was talking about, and I love that he tunes into that.

Andrew: Cool. No, that was all very well said. How’s J.K. Rowling doing? You hang out with her much?

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Evanna: Well, I see her at all the Lumos events because I’m an ambassador for Lumos now, myself and Bonnie Wright, so I see her there a lot. But she’s always very stressed and everyone in the room is trying to talk to her, so I just say hi and I tell her my new thoughts. My recent thing has been I’ve become obsessed with Housing, because…

Andrew: [laughs] House Sorting?

Evanna: House Sorting. Well, yeah, I don’t want go on about this, but basically… well, so I started dating someone a year ago, and then was completely shocked to discover he’s a Slytherin.

[Andrew laughs]

Evanna: He took the test and I was blown away. I was like, “I am dating a Slytherin?” [laughs] Because I’ve always had Slytherin friends, but they just seem a little bit ruthless for me. But then I realized, I’ve really changed as I’ve grown up. I used to lean more towards Gryffindor, Ravenclaw, and kind of Hufflepuff; a lot of my best friends are Hufflepuffs because they’re supportive and loyal and they’re lovely friends. But I started to realize that I’m lately more attracted to the Slytherin qualities of being ambitious and being tough and yearning for greatness, that kind of thing. And I don’t know about you guys, if you do this thing where every now and then if a Facebook Harry Potter House quiz crops up, I just want to check to be like, “Oh, I wonder. Oh, let’s see.”

Andrew: [laughs] Make sure everything is still on the up and up.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Evanna: Yeah, exactly, to check in on your mental health.

[Andrew laughs]

Evanna: I do this, anyway. I check on it. And I always get Gryffindor; that just doesn’t change. I’m definitely Gryffindor. But my secondary House, which used to always be Ravenclaw, has lately been Slytherin, and I’ve been like, “OMG, what is going on?”

Micah: Uh oh.

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: Yeah, like, do I need to see a psychologist? What’s going on? Seriously.

Eric: You’re going Dark. Going to the Dark Arts.

Evanna: So I got a bit of this with that, and so I’ve been writing to her about that. And I’ve been telling her how accurate I found it is; how learning that my boyfriend is a Slytherin taught me so much about him, just taught me what he values and taught me how he makes choices. And I was like, it’s really a lot more accurate than astrology. I feel like horoscopes are so vague, and Housing is just perfect. I don’t know. I’d love to hear your thoughts on this.

Andrew: She must have loved hearing that, knowing you thought it was better than astrology. [laughs]

Evanna: I mean, maybe, yeah. But she’s obviously thought… the more I get into the books, the more I’m like, “This is such a brilliant…” obviously, yes, it’s better that everyone just unifies and reaches common ground, but it does help you understand how people make choices.

Andrew: Yeah, for sure. Evanna, I have a confession to make.

Micah: Uh oh.

Evanna: You’re a Slytherin. Oh, go on.

Andrew: Well, actually, yes. I did convert to Slytherin earlier this year.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Eric: A new Slytherin, yeah.

Evanna: No, I’m totally pro-Slytherin. I told you; I was like, “I have become the biggest Slytherin apologist.”

Andrew: Oh, good, good.

Evanna: Yeah, so I’m waiting to hear her thoughts on that. But yeah, we still write letters. Sorry, go on. I interrupted you.

Andrew: Good. Oh, no, I followed your boyfriend on Instagram a few months ago because he’s very attractive.

Evanna: He’s so pretty, I know.

Andrew: He’s so pretty!

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: And that’s the thing also… that’s so funny. I have to tell him that; he’ll be delighted. But he also has such a typical Slytherin response to that whenever I tell him how pretty I find him. He’s like, “Get in line, sister.”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Whoa!

Evanna: Or he just says something… [laughs] And it’s joking, but it’s such a Slytherin response, where I’m gushy and being so affectionate, and he’s like, “I know, I’m kind of perfect.”

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Evanna: It’s really funny.

Andrew: Ah, that’s great.

Evanna: That’s so cute, though. That makes me laugh.

Andrew: We have lots to talk about today with Evanna, but first we want to tell you about this week’s sponsor.

[Ad break]


Main Discussion: Newt Scamander


Andrew: So let’s move on to… let’s talk about Newt now. Let’s talk more in-depth about Newt. So like I said, this is our final… we’ve been talking about particular characters, Evanna, on each episode, and we’ve reached the final one here. So I wanted to start off with name origins, because looking at the different parts of his name, I mean, gosh, they perfectly align. [laughs] Newt’s names and how we see him.

Eric: We know with J.K. Rowling, too, everything is intentional. Everything is highly, highly well chosen.

Andrew: Right, exactly. Though, there is one part that I want to get into when looking at the name origins here. So “Newton” was derived from the Old English place name meaning “new town,” and that one is like, “Oh, okay, well, he came to a new town in Fantastic Beasts.” [in a nasally voice] “He went to New York.”

Eric: [laughs] We’re ticking that box real early.

Andrew: Ticked, yep. Artemis was a goddess in Greek mythology, the daughter of Zeus and Leto and the twin sister of Apollo. She is the goddess of the moon, hunting, the wilderness, and the gift of taming wild animals. Hello. [laughs] In myth, Artemis spends most of her time hunting, which she has in common with Newt, although he seeks wild animals for conservation rather than sport. And then Fido, this is the part I thought was interesting. It’s of Latin origin, meaning “I trust” or “faithful.” Now, I was wondering, what’s the connection here? Are we going to see something faithful come through in a future movie, or does it mean faithful to animals?

Eric: I think it’s his Hufflepuff shining through. That’s what I’m thinking of, because Hufflepuffs are very loyal, and in that case, loyal to be extrapolated to mean faithful as well. But as well, the Latin “fidelis,” meaning truth. I think that Newt, in spite all odds, is very true to himself and true to his own character in the way that, Evanna, you were just talking about as well being with Luna, how you approach the character. Luna is also her own person; she is very much herself. And Newt is that. So I think gifting this second middle name to Newt is a way of saying that this character is true to himself.

Andrew and Micah: Yeah.

Evanna: Wait, hang on a second. I need to backtrack. Where did you get all these names? Are these in Fantastic Beasts the movie or the book?

Eric: I think in the book.

Andrew: In the book, yeah. Not in the movie. Yeah, but I’m trying to relate it to the movie because now we’re focusing more on that.

Evanna: Okay.

Eric: So the only thing in the actual Fantastic Beasts book is that… well, I mean, they added something new. They added that foreword by him. But I think in the biography section, it just says, “Newton Artemis Fido Scamander.” That’s his name.

Evanna: And did you say…? And so Artemis is a girl’s name? A goddess?

Andrew: Well, a goddess in Greek mythology, yeah.

Evanna: Interesting.

Andrew: Yeah. Were you going to say something, Micah?

Micah: I just think that the names play really well to his character. And I thought the Fido one was just a little fun thing that J.K. Rowling threw in there; it’s your everyday basic dog’s name, right?

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: “Here, Fido! Here, boy! Here!”

Micah: No, but the fact that that would be one of his middle names, which obviously, you guys mentioned, we haven’t really heard much about at all in the films, but it’s there. And I don’t know. It adds to his character, that’s for sure.

Eric: I like that.

Andrew: And then his last name, of course, is Scamander, and anyone could immediately pick up on that when first hearing his name. It’s very similar to salamander, which is a type of lizard.

Evanna: By the way, are salamanders real in the Muggle – in our world?

Andrew and Micah: Yeah.

Eric: I think so.

Evanna: Okay. They actually change colors and feed on flames? That sounds so wizardy to me.

Eric: I don’t think they feed on fire. I think that’s the J.K. Rowling affectation of that.

Evanna: Oh, okay. Sometimes I get so confused where I’m like, “Wait, were phoenixes real and are they extinct?”

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: It’s always those questions.

Evanna: This is one where I’m like… that’s so J.K. Rowling, salamanders.

Eric: Salamanders are that creature that exists; they study them in Care of Magical Creatures, I think, in one of the years, but they’re totally real. It’s one of those real creatures that was just appropriated for the wizarding world for some reason. I would love to know why she did that.

Andrew and Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: For sure.

Micah: And Scamander is also Luna’s future last name, isn’t it?

Evanna: Hell yes.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: Yes, it is. Rolf, yeah. I was going to ask, do you think when Jo wrote Newt, that when she wrote Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, do you think she always knew that she would go so in-depth into his story? I’m sure you’ve already talked about this on the podcast, but I just always wonder, when she sets up these new characters, do you think she puts a pin in it and is like, “I’d like to explore him someday”?

Andrew: She’s said in an interview or two that this was the story she always wanted to write next, if there was going to be another story. And of course, she always kept that quiet until the series actually happened. She never really said that prior.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: But part of me wonders, does she mean she wanted to write Newt’s story, or does she want to write the whole Grindelwald/Dumbledore battle? Because that’s obviously where this is going. So I’m still not sure, but I guess she is really fascinated by the character of Newt.

Evanna: Yeah, she has to be.

Eric: I wanted to talk about, of course, Newt’s Hufflepuff-ness, because the big thing for me when I first saw this film, or when we first learned that it was going to be a thing, is that Newt Scamander is a Hufflepuff. And that’s my House affiliation, according to Pottermore. I was very surprised when I got it because I had been dressing as a Gryffindor for years.

[Evanna laughs]

Eric: But apparently, wearing the robes does not a Gryffindor make. But upon reading, immediately, the Hufflepuff welcome letter on Pottermore, I found a lot of things to be true about my own character. But also, the Hufflepuff welcome letter on Pottermore was the very first time that, I felt, J.K. Rowling took the proper amount of time to give Hufflepuff their due. Hufflepuff is kind of just… they’re left out. Theirs is the only…

Micah: They have an off-Broadway play, though, Eric.

Eric: They do have an off-Broadway play now.

Evanna: They what? Explain this, please.

Andrew: They do; it’s called Puffs. Go ahead, Micah. He saw it.

Micah: Well, since I’m the ad person for this show. Yeah, so I don’t know how many years ago it was, but it’s been around for a bit of time now. They did this whole off-Broadway show. It’s about 90 minutes or so, and it explores the Hufflepuff House during the time that Harry was at Hogwarts. And it’s really comical; if you go, you’re definitely going to laugh. There’s a lot of inside jokes for those of us who have read the books and seen the films.

Andrew: Micah loved it.

Micah: Yeah, I went in, I didn’t know what to expect, and I really enjoyed it. I definitely recommend anybody who’s in the New York City area to go and see it. It’s a lot of fun.

Andrew: Still playing.

Eric: It’s called Puffs, the play?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: It’s named after Evanna’s cat. [laughs]

Evanna: It’s named after what? My cat? [laughs]

Eric: Your cat.

Evanna: Who, by the way, would definitely be a Hufflepuff.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: But so the whole reason that this play can exist is because Hufflepuffs were not in the books. The ones that were were kind of jerks.

Evanna: Cedric wasn’t a jerk. Tonks wasn’t.

Eric: No, not – well, did you read Cursed Child?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: He turns bad. It’s pretty bad.

Evanna: Cedric?

Eric: But Cedric is the exception. Cedric is, of course… the very fact that he was picked by the arbitrary supernatural Goblet of Fire to be the champion of Hogwarts does say something, and I like that. But for too long, as a conflicted Pottermore Hufflepuff before it really came out, I just think that’s very thin over time, when you keep telling yourself that, “Oh, I feel good about being a Hufflepuff because Cedric Diggory was a Hufflepuff.” But he dies pretty soon too. He just gets bested by Wormtail. And you’re like, “Well, so how far can you go to cling to him as…?” Not because he fails, but just because there’s not a living Hufflepuff who you can really look up to currently, and that’s what Newt is for me.

Evanna: Well, what about Tonks? Okay, wait; Tonks has died, obviously. But don’t you think she’s more of a redeemer for Hufflepuff?

Eric: I wonder… I think that what it is, is that very, very generally, the qualities of Hufflepuff House are not necessarily highlighted in the Harry Potter stories so much. Maybe that’s controversial. Maybe I just forget who’s a Hufflepuff, or… the idea that you would have, though – getting to Newt – a leading man who is a Hufflepuff, for me, is a profound resurgence. Or for the very first time, it feels like the qualities that makes one a Hufflepuff are being brought main stage in a way that they haven’t before.

Evanna: Well, I think it’s because Hufflepuffs are disinclined to play the hero.

Eric: Yes.

Evanna: They don’t seem to seek glory the way Gryffindors and Slytherins do, and they just have a lot less ego than the rest of the Houses for themselves, and that’s why I think Newt is such an unusual hero, because… well, I mean, his cause is so much for the animals and for justice for them. It’s so not about him. And you get the sense that he doesn’t feel comfortable in the spotlight, except when he’s…

[Meow in background]

Evanna: Sorry, that’s my cat chiming in with her support for this point.

[Andrew and Eric laughs]

Evanna: I think he doesn’t feel like… unless he’s actually talking about this cause, which he feels so much for. He doesn’t want to just stand there just to be the center of attention. He’s not like Harry, where he has a “saving people thing” as Hermione called it. And I think that’s why Hufflepuffs are often in the background. They’re the kind of people who support, and they can be… I know for me, personally, a lot of my friends who are Hufflepuffs, and my mum, those people are my rock. And those people, they have this strength that I don’t have, but it’s not necessarily the thing that will put them in the spotlight.

Eric: So I think I should clarify the difference of wanting the spotlight and just wanting to see my fellow Hufflepuffs being represented. That’s the joy of watching Fantastic Beasts for me, is seeing… I mean, Hufflepuff House, I think… when Cedric was chosen as the Hogwarts champion, they felt a sense of pride. And it might not be their defining characteristic, but they were very proud for him. And of course, they used the opportunity to treat Harry like dirt as well, because they’re very loyal to Cedric, but I do feel that that pride for seeing Newt Scamander, a Hufflepuff, in the lead role, but you’re also right; that he’s got the spotlight and he doesn’t want it and he doesn’t seek it, I think, makes him a more compelling character. And I feel so thrilled that J.K. Rowling has chosen to make this person, this character, the hero, the main character of her new story.

Evanna: Me too.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, and speaking of that, so another point I wanted to bring up was just his contributions to the wizarding world. They appear to be teaching the wizarding world about animals, because I think it’s notable that we haven’t heard of any other people who are studying animals to the degree that he is, other than a Care of Magical Creatures teacher at Hogwarts. Is he simply the guy…? And I guess this plays into the fact that Newt doesn’t really want the spotlight. He’s just an author off doing his own thing, and that shines through in his personality. He is introverted, and he does seem a little weird, but that’s just Newt. When you see him take on – was it the Erumpent, in the movie? He’s making all these weird noises, and he doesn’t care.

Evanna: That’s my favorite scene in the movie.

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: He wouldn’t be that outward in front of people unless he has to, when he’s dealing with animals. But then also, Eric, to your point, he could be the reluctant hero later in the series if he’s going to be helping take down Grindelwald, and maybe we’ll see him struggling with that.

Eric: Yeah, that is the thing that ties into Hufflepuffs as a House. And this is from the Pottermore welcome letter; I wrote it down. It says, “Welcome to Hufflepuff House. Our emblem is the badger, an animal that is often underestimated because it lives quietly until attacked, but which, when provoked, can fight off animals much larger than itself, including wolves.” Here’s the whole thing about Hufflepuff House: They’re not a “bunch o’ duffers,” as Hagrid called them. They are, in fact, very talented. And this is where it comes in with Newt, like you’re saying, Andrew; when attacked, or when he needs to fight in the film, he is an exceptional wizard. Also, it helps he’s the first adult that we’ve ever seen in this capacity, performing magic and dueling. So we get to watch him the entire film, Apparating very quickly, and holding his own against a myriad of obstacles. And he even uses the beasts themselves to succeed in fighting and combat and these things. And so he’s very, very, very talented. He’s very accomplished. And I think that that just goes back to the trait of the badger, though, of being detrimentally underestimated, which is great.

Evanna: Do you relate to Newt a lot as a Hufflepuff, Eric?

Eric: I’m not sure, because a lot of what spoke to me in the welcome letter about Hufflepuffs was… it was just the way that they relate to each other and are, I don’t know, interested in their community and very… I think I relate to interactions between Hufflepuffs very much more, in how I keep friendships and what I value in friendships. And it’s not the loyalty aspect so much as just being grounded in things, so I relate to that. And I think Newt, I really respect as a person who is following his own path, because that very much represents my view of my own life trajectory where, I mean, being a part of a Harry Potter website and a Harry Potter podcast was not anyone’s in my family’s idea of success or life trajectory. And when I followed that, pulled that thread, and started traveling due to the opportunities presented to me, everyone was a little blown away in my family. And so standing out but ultimately, being true to myself, being my own person, has been a factor in making every decision I’ve ever made in my life, and it’s gotten me to a happy place where I am now. So I really just believe in being unique and following your own path, which it seems that Hufflepuff House is known to do. And so for that reason, I do see an example figure in Newt, and I feel most at home with the House when I think of Hufflepuffs in that light.

Evanna: That’s interesting. And also, I mean, something I noticed just about you as a Hufflepuff and about Newt is there’s this, as you say, quiet work ethic, where it’s like, yeah, not glory seeking, but that’s what comes first. And the fact that he doesn’t let his personal life, his emotions interfere with what’s going on, the way you don’t even know anything, you don’t even know until Queenie… is it Queenie? She points it out? What does she say about people, “You can read people most when they’re hurting.” That just isn’t addressed in the film until she has this quiet heart-to-heart with him. And I think that’s just so admirable about Hufflepuff, whereas Gryffindors would be like, [dramatically] “My heart is broken, I want the world to know about it, and I’m going to fight for love.”

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: He so much puts that aside, in favor of what he believes is what needs to be done, what is important.

Eric: Yeah, he sacrifices his own… well, I mean, not happiness or well-being in any dramatic way, but I think that’s the other side of Newt as a character in this film, that he is vulnerable, or he’s a character who’s allowed to be vulnerable. I mean, he has this hole; it’s described in the Blu-ray special features. Eddie, during a segment called “The Magizoologist,” talks about how it’s revealed through the course of the film that there’s sort of this void, this little hole in Newt as a character, which gets slowly filled when he begins to find his friends here in this film. And the fact that… you’re right, Evy; Queenie points out that he’s had this relationship in the past, which hasn’t gone well, and that he carries this photo of this girl, but it almost reminds him of something painful, that he is a wholly rounded character. I mean, he doesn’t speak up about it and it’s not really an issue until she points it out, but yeah, he’s very much on a journey. And I think that’s also what makes him a good character, is he has some room to grow as a person, and Newt being a person who hasn’t really felt at home with humans – he tracks with animals more – getting to have him be thrust through circumstances of the film into this situation where he needs to interact with these other people is good for him. But it also… yeah.

Andrew: Let’s talk more about the animals. I know, Evanna, you wanted to talk about this in particular, his connection.

Evanna: Yes, definitely.

Micah: Well, I just wanted to throw… and this might lead into it, because you mentioned vulnerability. And I think that these creatures provide an extra level of vulnerability to Newt, especially moving forward in these films. I mean, I think there were moments where we saw that in the first movie, but I wonder, looking at characters like Grindelwald, assuming that he’s going to play a major role moving forward, could they be used not only against him, but to try and manipulate him in some way?

Eric: What scene is coming to mind is when they take his suitcase in the big committee scene and he becomes almost immediately unhinged, saying, “Do not hurt the beasts; there’s nothing in there that want to hurt you. Don’t touch my creatures.” He is very, very disassembled in that moment.

Andrew: Yeah, they could use the creatures against him. That’d be so hard to watch, though, if they’re keeping the creatures locked up or potentially torturing them or something.

Evanna: Oh God, I don’t want to think about that.

Eric: Yeah, I don’t want to think about… something happy, something happy, real quick.

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Micah: Sorry, sorry.

Evanna: That’s probably going to happen, though, isn’t it? Now that you’ve mentioned it, how he becomes unhinged.

[Andrew groans]

Evanna: Yeah, like that, if you take away his…

Eric: We know J.K. Rowling listens to the podcast, so she’s going to…

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: So Evanna, what do you see in Newt’s connection to his creatures?

Evanna: Okay, yeah, I’m excited to talk about this. Were you finished with your point, Micah?

Micah: Yeah, no, I thought it might tie into what you were going to say, or part, anyway.

Evanna: Okay. Well, I mean, speaking as someone who loves animals, and someone who understands Luna’s connection with animals, I often think it’s like, a lot of people who connect with animals and who want to help them, it’s because they feel misunderstood by society; it’s because they feel like they’re an outsider. And animals, they just have this beautiful quality of letting you be whoever you are. Dogs don’t ever prejudice against anyone based on the normal things that humans prejudice against, like skin color, sexuality, things like that. They just are so accepting. And it’s not that I don’t… I don’t think Luna or Newt prefer animal company; I think it’s just a very different kind of relationship. And animals are just… I mean, animals are creatures that are so, so exploited, and so prejudiced against, just because they’re so different. I really believe – again, this is me speaking as a vegan – but I don’t believe that we are better than animals. I don’t believe that we were born with any more rights than they should have. But because we’re stronger, and in many ways, we have this feeling, humans have this urge where they have to dominate, crush, own, possess anything that’s way too different to them. And we do it with people in our own community who are just a little bit too weird, like with Luna, and I imagine with Newt maybe, where Luna was bullied just because she… we feel threatened by things that are too different to us and are too weird, but are also comfortable in that. And I see that happen to animals; because they are so different from us, we feel like it’s our right and gives us some weird, twisted sense of power. And I think Newt probably relates to the innocence of animals and to the oddness of them, and he feels, as someone who’s probably been bullied himself in school, and thinking about his family and how they were – what is it, Ministry types? And just that he grew up different to them. And he took a different route, as you say, Eric; he took the path less traveled, and he had to be strong in that. And I think he feels this fierce sense of protection for them, because he didn’t get that protection when he was younger, and when he was the odd one out, he didn’t have anyone standing up for him. And I think that’s why he wants to be a voice for animals. That’s my thoughts on it.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Eric: When you were talking about that, I was thinking specifically about just how strange and exotic… I mean, I think in general, animals… what you said is really beautiful about how animals are so different to us, and we somehow feel threatened as a result. Thinking about the beasts in the case in the movie, those crazy creatures, the ones that… there’s that mammal that had… it’s like a big lion, but has like, a puffer fish mane, where it puffs out. I’m just like, “How did this creature…?” There’s creatures in this case in the scene in the movie, where you’re just like, “How did these evolve?” Or the ones that tickled Jacob, or the one with the tendrils coming out of the face, and it’s just gooey and slimy. And you’re just like, “How is this even a creature that evolves?” But it’s so different. It’s the complete exaggeration of the strangeness of beasts, and yet they’re treated so compassionately by Newt. And I think the movie does a really good job of evoking this sense, which is Newt’s shared sense of wanting to protect and educate because that is what they’re there for, and he’s giving these beasts a home. And it’s even said in the movie where they are often being hunted and eradicated. And in fact, I think it’s the tendril beasts things that are the only breeding pair in existence, and so we’re shown that these crazy-looking creatures are… when you hear that they are the only ones left, it tugs at your heart, I think, as just a human. You don’t even have to be an animal lover to realize, “Oh my God, Newt is actually doing something that not only he views as really important, but we should too.”

Andrew: Evanna, we’ve talked about this a bunch of times on the show: Do you think he’s going to use his beasts to take down Grindelwald kind of Pokémon style where he’s choosing these…? [laughs]

Evanna: Damn. Gosh, that’s a big one. I just don’t think Newt believes in using animals, making them…

Andrew: Oh, to fight, yeah.

Evanna: Yeah, making them do… I always had a big problem with – well, not always, because I was a big Pokémon fan as a kid.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Evanna: But as soon as the app came out last year, I was like, “OMG, is Pokémon vegan? I don’t think it is!”

[Eric and Evanna laugh]

Evanna: The ideology that just because they’re there in the world that we get to just own them… I had a really big problem with it; it was a real conflict for me.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Where did that net out?

Evanna: I think I was like, “Oh, this is a game. Get over yourself.”

Eric: Oh, okay.

Evanna: But I felt like it was reinforcing the idea that we get to own and use animals as we see fit, and I just don’t think Newt would be one to train animals. And a lot of those animals, say cats, for example, and dogs, are easier to train, but with things like elephants and lions, you have to use really cruel practices to literally break their spirits to make them cooperate with you, and I don’t think he would. I think he would be strongly against that. I still am quite conflicted about where he sits on the animal rights scale, what his ethics are in relation to animals, because I think you see him in the film cutting up meat and serving it and he doesn’t seem to have any problem with that. I think he more believes in the circle of life and that there’s an order of things.

Eric: A hierarchy?

Evanna: A hierarchy, yeah.

Micah: It was actually tofu.

[Eric and Evanna laugh]

Evanna: Never seen tofu looking like that.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Evanna: It could be the Impossible Meat. There’s apparently this new vegan burger called the Impossible Burger that bleeds like meat.

Andrew: Oh.

Evanna: Yeah. Try it; it’s meant to be great.

Eric: Okay, that creeps me out. I wouldn’t eat a bloody burger any more than I would eat that burger.

Evanna: Well, I don’t think it has blood when it’s cooked. But it’s not actual blood.

Eric: Oh, yeah, okay. I will say, though, I mean, there is precedent in the film for Newt using beasts. The Swooping Evil is Newt’s… if that is in fact the bird that he sets on those Aurors when they’re escaping from the Ministry.

Evanna: That’s true.

Eric: It’s even a moment of comedic nature where he’s like, “Don’t go for the brains, not the brains…”

[Evanna laughs]

Eric: … because the bird immediately collides with this guy’s face, and it’s very much like Alien for a couple seconds there. We see him just roll out, he yo-yos out that bird to save Tina and to attack these Ministry officials, so I do think that he is somewhere on that scale, like you’re saying, Evanna…

Evanna: Right.

Eric: … of he’s okay to a certain extent using beasts, but what you said about having to break an animal’s spirit, I definitely agree he wouldn’t really… he’s not training an army.

Evanna: Yeah, I don’t think he would use cruelty in any situation.

Eric: But if and where the qualities of these beasts can assist him, particularly in getting out of a scuffle? I think that that is acceptable to him.

Andrew: Yeah, like maybe going to fetch a key or stuff…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … not animal to animal or animal to human combat. Just send them on tasks.

Micah: That said, he was willing to trade away Pickett.

Evanna: But not really.

Eric: He told Pickett that he never would have gone through with that.

Andrew: Yeah, he was hesitant, wasn’t he?

Evanna: Oh, that was a tough moment.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: Well, I was wondering, what do you guys think would be his opinion on SPEW and on house-elves?

Eric: I wonder.

Andrew: Well, we know… I was reading his bio; he worked in something house-elf-related in the Ministry, right?

Evanna: Did he?

Andrew: I’m looking it up real quick. Yeah, hold on.

Eric: I think because there’s also…

Andrew: I think he would be a member of SPEW.

Eric and Evanna: Yeah.

Eric: They’re classified as something different than beasts, right?

Evanna: Of course.

Eric: Yeah, so I mean, there’s multiple levels of… I think that he would view them as people first and foremost, so I think that’s true. And I think that knowing Newt’s propensity to just disagree with the standard government’s position on stuff, I think he would absolutely 100% join SPEW and be part of groups that want to affect change. It would be sort of hypocritical if he wasn’t, because he himself is trying to change a very large established public mindset as it pertains to creatures, and so I think that it would be right up his alley to do an overhaul on what people have traditionally taken beasts, these other creatures, these other intelligent, sentient species with cultures and histories. I think that he would want to change all of it.

Andrew: He worked in the Office for House-Elf Relocation at the Ministry for two years before joining the Beast Division.

Evanna: Oh, wow.

Andrew: So presumably, he wanted to look out for the house-elves.

Evanna: But relocating them with new owners? New households?

Andrew: Yeah, I guess so.

Eric: Probably, yeah.

Andrew: But at least he…

Evanna: Does it say when he worked there?

Andrew: Well, it was before joining the Beast Division, so it was the early 1900s.

Evanna: Maybe that’s where he formed his beliefs. That might be where he saw… maybe he quit because he didn’t like what he saw what was happening, and that people weren’t making the kind of changes he wanted.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: I like that idea.

Micah: That’s a good point.

Evanna: I don’t know how soon before he started collecting and saving creatures that was.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s a good question. He just seems like the type of person who grew up fascinated by beasts in general.

Evanna: Definitely.

Andrew: From the first time he read about them or saw one, he was just always hooked on it, and this is definitely his lifelong passion. And the reason I had asked you, Evanna, if he could get his beasts involved in the fight, is because I feel like, like I’ve said, this wizarding world, this movie series is clearly going towards that big war. And Newt has got to be involved somehow, right? Because he’s still going to be the lead character.

Evanna: Sure.

Andrew: So that’s why I’m wondering if he’s going to use his beasts somehow, but I guess we’ll see. What were you going to say, Micah?

Micah: One question that I did have – and I know we have discussed this on the podcast, so more for Evy – about just speaking of beasts and Newt, what are the chances, I guess… do you think that either Fawkes came from Newt to Dumbledore, or Aragog came from Newt to Hagrid?

Evanna: Oh, wow. I think I’ve read that before. I think it might have been something one of you guys tweeted about. That’s definitely… that’s got to be a thing, isn’t it?

[Eric and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: Because there’s that one line in the book about… what was it?

Eric: “I came to Hagrid in a pocket from a traveler.”

Evanna: Oh! Oh, really?

Eric: Yeah, Aragog says that to Harry.

Evanna: I didn’t really think of… I was more talking about Fawkes the phoenix.

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Evanna: I feel like that’s definitely… yeah, I feel like Newt definitely passed him on to Dumbledore.

Andrew: Yeah. And of course, those two were very close. We don’t know why yet, but…

Evanna: Do we know when Dumbledore got Fawkes?

Eric: No. But we know that he cherishes Fawkes; there’s a special connection and relation. Dumbledore’s everything is a phoenix, like his Patronus… I think he even… he’s not an Animagus, but if he was, I think it would be a phoenix as well. I don’t know. It’s an interesting…

Evanna: Oh, it’s going to be something heart-wrenching, like Newt is on his deathbed and gives him a phoenix egg or something, isn’t it?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Evanna: Totally is.

Eric: Wait, are there phoenix eggs? Is that a thing? [laughs] Or are they just ashes from the phoenix it was previously?

Evanna: I don’t know.

Andrew: I don’t know either.

Eric: It’s a chicken and egg joke that I tried to make there. But yeah, I definitely think… well, again, in those special features on the Blu-ray, J.K. Rowling says that Newt was “probably,” which of course, you mean yes, this absolutely happened…

[Evanna laughs]

Eric: … the man who introduced the subject of Care of Magical Creatures to Hogwarts. So because of his views on beasts, and I think that whatever his friendship with Dumbledore turns out to be or turns out to have been, I would hope… and I feel pretty confident we will get that entire backstory of how they became friends, what specifically their relationship is, because that ties into what’s coming with Grindelwald and Dumbledore’s own thing; I get it. But because of Dumbledore’s close friendship with Newt, I think Dumbledore would have seen it as a very good cause. And also, being the school for wizards, that it would be irresponsible not to train young wizards how to how to deal with beasts, how to take care of them. And I think that it’s also just a good practice to forward Newt’s cause by teaching this class, by having this class, so I think that Dumbledore would have very much been okay once Newt suggests that they have a Hogwarts class on this, and they have a textbook to work off of because he’s just written one. I think that that’s based on their friendship. I think that maybe Newt gives Dumbledore a phoenix and Dumbledore gives Newt the class that he has always wanted to be taught at Hogwarts. [laughs]

Micah: And…

Evanna: And do you think…? Big question. Oh, sorry, Micah, I interrupted you.

Micah: No, no, go ahead. You go.

Evanna: Well, do you think Newt…? Obviously, his vision is for animals to be respected and for them to live in their natural habitats, but do you think Newt achieves…? The world that Harry lives in, is it close to what Newt wanted? Has he achieved it? Or I’m wondering, because obviously his… is Rolf his grandson or great-grandson? I should know this.

Eric: I actually don’t know.

Andrew: Great.

Eric: Is a great? I thought it was great.

Evanna: I think it’s great-grandson.

Andrew: I’ll look it up.

Evanna: He becomes a naturalist. I wonder, is it just his family is continuing the work and it’s not… he hasn’t achieved his vision yet for the kind of quality or respect for animals that he’s working towards?

Eric: I think that it’s an ongoing thing. I’d like to believe that Newt, when he eventually dies, or did die, was happy with where he’d gotten to. Because I think that certainly, starting off where he did when there was not even that class at Hogwarts, and ending in a place where his direct contributions to the wizarding world were the foundation of that change… whether or not it’s as far as he wanted it to get, who’s to say? I think probably you’re right in suspecting that maybe not because I do think…

Evanna: I think not, because at the same time, we see so much examples of animal exploitation and abuse, like the way the dragons are kept, and if for wands, dragon heartstrings are used and unicorn hair. It is a very un-vegan world that they’re living in.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Yeah, actually, it’s a really… I wasn’t even thinking about dragon heartstrings as being… I mean, that’s one-third of Ollivander’s entire profession.

Micah: And I would even say with Hagrid, too; while he’s trying to teach Care of Magical Creatures, so much happens with him. And you would think that it’s still not a widely accepted subject. I don’t want to… I mean, he’s treated in a totally inappropriate way many times throughout the series just because of who he is. But just in terms of the subject that he’s trying to teach, he has, I think, similar feelings towards creatures as Newt does. So I was interested to see what you guys thought about that; he talks about how they’re always misunderstood, and he seems to have that same kind of affinity.

Eric: Yeah, but when we’re talking about this, I’m thinking you’re right, but there’s also no real good curriculum set around it. And this might have to do with a couple of things; it might deal with Hagrid’s abilities as a teacher, which are limited. We know he’s Harry’s friend. He’s our friend; that’s why we like him. But in the books, Care of Magical Creatures class is almost used as a punchline to add some humor into an otherwise very scary time of year at Hogwarts. The blast-ended skrewts are the butt of many jokes. I mean, what is their purpose? They’re so weird and odd. The fact that Care of Magical Creatures class is being taught is something, but it’s being taught by Hagrid, who I guess, even though we know he has a passion for beasts, is he really instilling it in the students? And so few students are taking him seriously. I think there’s a line in – is it Book 5 or Book 6? – where Harry comes to terms with one of the beasts and he’s just like, “Okay, I can kind of see how they’re kind of cool. I can see what Hagrid likes in them.” But then most of the class… Ron is complaining about how weird or odd the beasts are, and I just think that… so beasts and how they’re viewed… wasn’t the previous beasts teacher – was that Kettleburn who retired because he lost most of his limbs?

Evanna: Injuries, yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I mean, and that’s terrifying to think that maybe beasts have bitten off this guy’s limbs. [laughs] I think that the real history of Kettleburn is explained on Pottermore, and I don’t think it’s beast-related. But the idea that this goofball was this previous teacher, who was odd and… I just don’t think it actually is actively furthering the cause in the way that an informative TED talk on beasts these days would do. I think that that would go much farther into accomplishing the task than… so you can’t rely on Care of Magical Creatures at Hogwarts alone to change what Newt is trying to change.

Andrew: I think on that note, we should probably start wrapping up here, the character discussion. I think we hit on all the points for the most part.

Eric: A lot of, except…

Evanna: Do you want to talk more about his relationships?

Eric: Yeah, to the other characters?

Evanna: Well, and also, too, what do you think his relationship with Leta Lestrange was, and what it’ll be?

Andrew: Oh, yeah. Yeah, so it looks like… so those teenage casting roles make it sound like we’re going to learn in this next movie what exactly went on between Newt and Leta. We do know they had some sort of falling out. We do know, thanks to a couple Fantastic Beasts spinoff book type things, that Newt took the fall for something that Leta did, and presumably, we’re going to see that scene in the next movie if we’re going back to the teenage years. And also, we’re probably going to be going back to Hogwarts. Isn’t that cool, Evanna?

Evanna: That’s awesome, yeah.

[Eric and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: Yeah. What do you think there? What do you think is going on between Newt and Leta?

Evanna: Oh, I genuinely have no idea.

[Eric and Evanna laugh]

Andrew: Nobody does; that’s okay. [laughs]

Eric: It’s possible that she’s not a Slytherin. I think that’s a possibility.

Andrew: Why do you say that?

Eric: Well, we hear the name Lestrange and we think Slytherins.

Andrew: Oh, right.

Eric: But she could be an outsider, much like Newt is an outsider, and maybe Hufflepuff is the de facto House for outsiders. I mean, maybe that’s… they met as students; either she was a Slytherin who was still a Slytherin but just didn’t fit in with the other Slytherins, and that’s how they met, or she was in his House.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Eric: I think there’s two possibilities there.

Evanna: What do we actually know about her?

Eric: Nothing.

Evanna: Nothing, gosh.

Eric: She’s played by Zoë Kravitz. That’s what we know.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Yeah, and I guess she’s going to have to come into modern day Fantastic Beasts at some point, maybe with the next movie because if Newt is heading back over to Europe for this next one and beyond, presumably we’re going to see her. I know Zoë Kravitz said she’s going to have more of a presence in future movies, so yeah, we’ll see.

Evanna: Does it say…? Has she been confirmed for the next one? Because often that gives it away on IMDb, doesn’t it? Where you know who’s… is it not? I don’t know if it does.

[Eric laughs]

Eric: I think she is, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, I think she is.

Eric: I think Zoë might have given an interview where she said Movie 2 was where you’re really going to find out a lot of stuff.

Andrew: Yeah. And I think the teenage role kind of gives that away. Micah, did you have anything to add here?

Micah: No, I mean, I know we’ve discussed it on other episodes; I’m interested to see what happens in the next film and what exactly he took the fall for. I think they mentioned a beast, right, at some point played a role. I don’t know if that’s been confirmed, though. Has it? Was that part of one of those spinoffs that you mentioned? It was a Jarvey?

Andrew: Vaguely rings the bell that a beast is involved.

Eric: Yeah, it was a Jarvey.

Micah: So it sounds similar to a situation that happened with Hagrid, right, where he got expelled, so definitely some parallels there. And I guess the only other thing that I was looking to talk about with Newt was the bond between him and Dumbledore. And Graves/Grindelwald has that line about, “What makes Albus Dumbledore so fond of you?” Does it have anything to do with Ariana and the theory that she was an Obscurial? And he obviously has worked with them. And so there could be a lot of theorizing done there in terms of, is he on somewhat of a quest? And he was in Africa trying to save this young girl, and is that a cover story for something else? Did he try…? I don’t know. I mean, I think it’s also somewhat coincidental that he finds himself in New York around the same time that there’s one running rampant.

Evanna: So you think it might be that Dumbledore comes to Newt, thinking that he’s the only one who will sympathize with his sister’s case?

Micah: Yeah, I think so. I think that there may be something that he entrusts Newt with, and maybe it’s somewhat of regret that he was unable to save his sister, that he’s sending Newt out to try and save some of these others that are out there. I wonder… I mean, I don’t know for sure, but I feel like it’s just too coincidental that this is all tied together in some way.

Eric: Yeah, it’s certainly fortuitous. But maybe it was Dumbledore that turned Newt on to Obscurials to begin with.

Andrew: Probably.

Eric: I mean, having… I think Dumbledore would make it his mission after the experience of what happened to his sister to try and investigate and find out more and prevent future children from being killed in this way.


Make the Connection


Andrew: Okay, well, to wrap up this discussion, I think we’re going to do some Make the Connection, Eric?

Eric: Yeah, well, it doesn’t have anything to do with the discussion necessarily…

Andrew: Oh, right.

Eric: … but we’re going to test Evanna’s skills of – what is it? – making connections! [laughs]

Evanna: Oh no.

Andrew: Do you remember this from the old MuggleCast days?

Evanna: No, I don’t! What is this?

Andrew: Okay.

Evanna: [laughs] I’m really scared.

Eric: Oh, God! This is a British classic, Evanna. This was Jamie’s pioneer segment.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: And it’s so quirky and random and absolutely insane, but we had a lot of fun asking our patrons to come up with Make the Connections for us to do, so we’re all going to play. And I’m actually in the middle of putting a list into our document right now…

Andrew: How it works, Evanna, is somebody gives us a really weird topic and we have to connect it to Harry Potter in some way.

Evanna: But it’s completely remote? It doesn’t have anything to do with Harry Potter?

Andrew: Basically, yeah.

Evanna: Wow.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, we connect it to Harry Potter. And we can say anything. I mean, it’s completely our own. We’re our own judges on this.

Evanna: Okay.

Andrew: We’ve done a music version of this as well, where we play a new song and then we try to connect it to Harry Potter with the lyrics or something like that. But in this case, we’re going to do these examples from some listeners.

Evanna: Okay.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And people have wild imaginations. So here’s the first one; this is from Jennifer. Make the connection between Harry Potter and “traveling to a planet inhabited only by purple flowers in a Converse shoe-shaped sailboat through the stars.” [laughs]

Evanna: Converse?

Eric: Converse shoes.

Andrew: Oh, Converse shoes. I got it. Okay. [laughs]

Eric: So the connection between Harry Potter and traveling to a planet inhabited only by purple flowers in a Converse shoe-shaped sailboat through the stars. I will take this one.

Evanna: What are your listeners on? This is mad.

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Eric: You’ve got to ask them. These are our patrons; these are our most hardcore listeners, too.

Evanna: Wow, okay. This is all you, MuggleCasters; I don’t know what to say to this one.

Eric: Thank you.

Andrew: [laughs] Same.

Eric: I got this. I got this. Okay, first of all, many things… if we’ve learned nothing from Harry Potter, or if we’ve learned one thing from Harry Potter, it should be that things are not always what they seem. And a Converse shoe… there’s examples in Harry Potter of shoes being Portkeys, for instance. And even Newt’s own case…

[Evanna gasps]

Eric: [laughs] I just blew Evanna’s mind right now. I’m having a moment. The Newtcase, for instance, the suitcase appears to be this mangy, dirty, old suitcase, and it’s actually in and of itself a portal to another world. And Newt’s case in particular – let’s get a closer dive – there’s certain environments inside his case, which very much resemble crazy odd environments, like a planet with only purple flowers. So if there were a beast that Newt knew of that survived on this planet with just purple flowers, he would recreate it for being inside his case. And as far as sailing through the stars, that’s fun to do, and you could do it inside the case.

Evanna: Amazing.

Andrew: I was going to say, yeah, that was very good, Eric. Eric has been thinking about this for the past day, I’m sure.

Micah: I have no idea what you just said, but that was spot on.

[Everyone laughs]

Evanna: Gosh.

Andrew: This is from Lourdes: “Make the connection between Fantastic Beasts and overdue library book fines.” How about this? We waited, let’s say five years for a new Harry Potter wizarding world movie. It was way overdue.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: All right.

Andrew: I felt like I was being penalized every day we didn’t have a new Harry Potter movie to look forward to. [laughs]

Eric: I like it. I like it. Micah, here’s one for you: “Make the connection between Harry Potter and jumping on a trampoline in a tutu.” This is from Savannah.

Micah: [laughs] Well…

Andrew: Dumbledore…

Micah: Yeah, go on.

Eric: You’re helping him? Andrew with the assist.

Andrew: … in his spare time in the back of the office puts on his tutu, because we know he’s gay.

[Evanna laughs]

Andrew: And when he wants to let some steam off, he just hops on the trampoline and “Woohoo!”

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Eric: Okay, okay.

Evanna: Wait, isn’t there a more obvious one? Isn’t there a picture of trolls in tutus?

Eric: Trolls in tutus? Yeah.

Andrew: Oh, there you go, yeah.

Evanna: I don’t know what to do with the trampoline, though.

Andrew: That was referenced? That was in a book or something?

Evanna: Yeah, there’s a picture of them.

Andrew: Oh, wow, in tutus. I didn’t know that.

Evanna: The trolls learning to ballet dance.

Andrew: Huh, okay.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, you’re right. That’s totally a thing. Okay, Micah, here’s another one for you then. Shawn McKee: “Make the connection between Harry Potter/Fantastic Beasts and razor burn.”

Micah: All right. The Murtlap bite from Fantastic Beasts.

Eric: Ooh, that’s so good

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: It looked like some razor burn, after she got done with Jacob.

Eric: Here’s one for all of us from Stephen Hauser: “Make the connection between Harry Potter/Fantastic Beasts and Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson.”

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Micah: Who would he play?

Eric: Oh, man.

Andrew: Who would he play? Hagrid.

Eric: He would play the very coolest wizard in 1920s attire you’ve ever seen.

[Evanna laughs]

Andrew: No, he’d play cool Hagrid. “All right, kids, come over here for a lesson.” He’d be super friendly about it, and he’d be able to tame the beasts better than Hagrid ever could. [laughs]

Eric: Amanda Reinking says, “Make the connection between Fantastic Beasts and Pinterest Do It Yourself fails.”

Evanna: Aww. Seamus Finnigan.

Eric: Oh, yeah. There we go.

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Evanna: No, there has to be a better one.

Eric: No, that’s pretty good.

Andrew: Yeah, Pinterest Do It Yourself fails… I mean, yeah, well, I’m just thinking of a failed class assignment. Something that just went wrong during a lesson.

Eric: A lot does. Sophia Gibson: “Make the connection between Harry Potter and deciding where to eat with your friends.”

Andrew: Where to go to Hogsmeade? That’s not a fun answer, though.

Eric: Oh, yeah. Yeah, there we go.

Andrew: [laughs] Okay.

Eric: No, some of these will go quicker. I’ve got a bunch more. [laughs] Hayley Brown: “Make the connection between Fantastic Beasts and Michael Phelps swimming against a great white shark.”

Andrew: Goblet of Fire, the merpeople. [laughs]

Eric: There you go. Boom. JB Verch – oh, okay, Evanna, this one is specifically for you.

Evanna: I’m terrible at this game. It’s fascinating to listen to, but… go for it.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: You’re going to be great. We have a backup one in case this doesn’t work, because he gave two. JB Verch says, “Make the connection between Luna Lovegood and a biker gang.”

Evanna: What? Oh, God. [laughs]

Andrew: Is Luna ever tough? Tough-tough?

Evanna: Luna, tough? No, she’s way too laid back to be tough, isn’t she? I don’t know; someone take this one. I can’t.

Micah: What about when in the movies you get everybody on the Thestrals and head out to the Ministry, right?

Evanna: Oh, that’s perfect!

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, that’s good.

Micah: That’s like getting your biker gang together.

Evanna: Yes. That is, actually.

Andrew: The Thestral gang. Rev ’em up, boys.

Evanna: There’s not enough beers and tattoos, though, is there?

Eric: Oh, well, you have a tattoo, don’t you?

Evanna: I do. I have a Luna tattoo.

Andrew: Really?

Eric: Yeah, there you go. And biker gangs have tattoos.

Andrew: What do you mean? What is it, a quote?

Evanna: No, it’s a hare jumping across a moon.

Andrew: Oh, that’s so cool.

Eric: And hare is her…

Evanna: Patronus.

Eric: Patronus, there you go. Okay, a couple… two more. Brittany Smith: “Make the connection between Harry Potter and a dog with a colored Mohawk.”

Andrew: Oh, something to do with unicorns.

Eric: I was thinking of Tonks.

Micah: Yeah, I was too. I didn’t want to say that, though.

Eric: Probably a Metamorphmagus. There you go. The colored Mohawk. And did we say this one? Alicia: “Make the connection between Fantastic Beasts and going to an obligatory baby shower.”

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Slughorn’s Slug Club meetings. At least with the trio; they didn’t want to be there.

Evanna: But that’s not Fantastic Beasts.

Andrew: Oh, no. Darn it. An obligatory baby shower… showing up for a meeting at MACUSA? I’m trying to think of… the MACUSA president having to deal with Tina. “What do you want, Tina?” I don’t know. [laughs] Having to deal with an obligatory disgruntled employee.

Eric: Yeah, Seraphina Picquery probably does a lot of things out of duty that she would rather not do, but trying times, and she’s a good person so she’ll go and handle it.

Andrew: No, interesting.

Eric: We definitely want to thank all of our patrons for supplying the Make the Connections that we played. That was a lot of fun. Good to get to that fun segment.

Evanna: I’m sorry I’m not on your level. I didn’t understand that game.

Micah: Look, I wanted to get to the purple beaver flying a cheese helicopter, but we’ll save that one for next time.

Eric: Well, do you have an answer for that?

Micah: No, not at all. But maybe…

Andrew: Micah needs a week to think on it.

Micah: Yeah, no, expect to see that in the next Fantastic Beasts film. Plays a major role.

[Evanna laughs]

Eric: Especially if the beasts are on the front lines. The cheese helicopters, definitely the first line of defense.

Andrew: We do want to let everybody know that Micah, Eric, and I will be at MuggleNet Live 2017: 19 Years Later. Believe it or not, Evanna, September 1, 2017 is in canon 19 years later, just like the epilogue.

Evanna: Is it? Oh, that’s awesome. And that’s when you’re having a convention?

Andrew: Yeah, so MuggleNet Live.

Eric: It’s a one-night event inside the Wizarding World of Harry Potter Orlando, including King’s Cross Station, where we can catch the train off Platform 9 and 3/4 and sip down some unlimited butterbeer. And also, we have some film members in attendance. Details are all on the top post in the MuggleCast website, including discounted hotel rates and a special promotional code for listeners of our show. So go check it out. That’s, again, MuggleNet Live, and you can find out more information at MuggleCast.com.

Andrew: Evanna, thanks so much for coming on the show today. We really appreciate it.

Evanna: Thank you for having me. It’s been really fun.

Andrew: Yeah, it was fun.

Evanna: I can’t believe this has been my first official…

Andrew: I know.

Evanna: I know I’ve been on as an interview, but this was a fun one to just… I don’t know, be a geek. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, no, it’s been great. And we’ll let everybody know about your podcast that you’re launching once it gets up and running.

Eric: Have you chosen a name?

Evanna: Thank you. Yeah, it’s called The Chickpeeps podcast.

Eric: Chickpeeps? I love it.

Evanna: Yeah, as in chick people. And also, I really like chickpeas.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: The Chickpeeps podcast.

Andrew: You should eat chickpeas while podcasting every episode.

Evanna: I probably will.

[Andrew and Evanna laugh]

Eric: Are they noisy food when you eat them? Do they crunch? Do they crackle?

Evanna: Have you never had a chickpea?

Eric: No, I’ve never had a chickpea.

Evanna: Oh my gosh, Eric. Wow.

Eric: Okay, I’m going to remedy this today.

Andrew: You need to become a vegan.

Evanna: They’re like beans. They’re these little bean things, but they can be made into chips and all sorts.

Eric: But do they crackle when you eat them?

Evanna: No, sorry.

Eric: All right. Well, I was really hoping that was the case. But okay.

Micah: Well, you’ve had hummus, right?

Eric: Yes.

Evanna: Yeah, that’s made of chickpeas.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Evanna: Yeah, just ground up.

Andrew: And Evanna, I was stalking your Instagram while we were recording, and I saw you went to Veggie Grill? You would eat at Veggie Grill in LA? I love Veggie Grill.

Evanna: Do you? Isn’t it the best? It’s so good.

Andrew: Yes. It is the best. I would be a full-time vegan if I could eat there breakfast, lunch, and dinner every day.

Evanna: Really? Okay, that’s good.

Andrew: It’s so good, yeah.

Evanna: Well, that’s encouraging.

Andrew: Yeah, well, I mean, it’s just because… I think some people think, “Oh, vegan food won’t taste good,” or stuff like that. But you eat there, and I assume other vegan places, and it tastes great.

Evanna: Exactly. I know. People need… that’s what I want to do with my podcast, just make people aware that it’s not a lifestyle of deprivation or restriction. It’s just a very different way, and there’s a very joyful way of doing it. Yeah, I tend to always take my omnivorous friends there because it’s not too expensive. There’s some of them that are just way too expensive. And people make the mistake of thinking vegan is healthy; it absolutely does not have to be.

Andrew: Yeah, and in the case of Veggie Grill, they have burgers. And so when I take somebody there for the first time, I’m like, “Get what you would eat at a place where you would eat meat. So you like burgers? Have a Veggie Grill burger, and I promise you’ll like it.” Awesome. Well, again, thank you for coming on. We really appreciate it.

Evanna: Sure, thank you. It was fun.

Andrew: You are a true fan. We loved having you on.

Evanna: I loved being on! And thank you guys for putting up that casting announcement all them years ago. [laughs] I guess I should thank you for that here.

Andrew: Tell J.K. Rowling we said hi. And by the way, ask her about Scorbus next time you see her. Let us know what she says.

[Eric laughs]

Evanna: Scorbus. [laughs] I can’t believe nobody has asked her about this.

Andrew: [laughs] I know.

Eric: Oh, but also try and get to the bottom of the Lavender Brown thing. Are you aware of this, Evy, that Lavender Brown’s life or death has been in question for years now?

Evanna: Oh, wait. Does she die?

Andrew: We don’t know. On Pottermore, it’s not been clear.

Evanna: She dies in the movie.

Eric: Well, does she? She’s certainly attacked by Greyback, but his MO is attacking children and leaving them alive.

Evanna: Are you serious? Oh, wow.

Eric: Well, he has enough restraint to stop eating somebody so that they will be… because he wants to make as many werewolf abominations as he can, right? So on Pottermore, this whole story in a nutshell is her bio was changed. And it initially had said, what, that she survived?

Andrew: Presumed dead, and then they just got rid of it, so we don’t know.

Evanna: Ooh, controversial.

Andrew: I know, right?

Eric: So since you have the open line to Jo, we could really use that answer.

Evanna: Okay. [laughs]

Micah: And also, ask her to come on the podcast.

Eric: Oh, yeah, definitely. Tell her how much fun that you had, how nice we all are, and we promise to be nice, too.

Micah: It’s been 12 years.

Evanna: Haven’t you interviewed her?

Eric: No, just Emerson.

Evanna: Oh, just Emerson, yeah. That’s a long time ago. Okay, I’ll let her know.

Eric: Well, anyway, you’re always welcome back, by the way.

Evanna: Oh, thank you. Okay. Well, let me know if there’s any episodes that relate to things I’d be interested in. Are you doing any Lovegood episodes?

Eric: Oh, yeah. We’ll see. We’ll do maybe a dive back into Xenophilius and Luna. Well, thank you so much.

Evanna: Thanks.

Andrew: And one quick note, we will actually be off next week for the Fourth of July holiday, so we will see you after that. We have a Fantastic Beasts commentary episode coming up very soon, and we are also going to do a mailbag episode in the coming weeks, catch up on your feedback. Thanks, everybody, for listening. I’m Andrew.

Eric: I’m Eric.

Micah: I’m Micah.

Evanna: I’m Evy.

Andrew: Perfect.

Evanna: [laughs] Did you want me to say that or no?

Eric: Absolutely, 100%.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. Thanks, Evy. We’ll see everybody next time. Goodbye.

Evanna: Thanks, guys. Bye.

Transcript #322

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #322, “Graves”


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, the Harry Potter podcast discussing everything about J.K. Rowling’s wizarding world. Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 322. I’m Andrew.

Eric Scull: I’m Eric.

Micah Tannenbaum: I’m Micah.

Andrew: Hey, that rhymes. “322, I’m Andrew.”

Micah: Good thing you went first.

Andrew: We are joined by one of our Slug Club members from Patreon this week. Welcome, Clara!

Clara: Thank you. I’m happy to be here.

Andrew: Yeah, it’s great to have you here. You are coming to us from Paris today. That is so cool.

Clara: Yes, I studied abroad here five years ago and I haven’t been back since, so just a little vacation.

Andrew: Vacation, she got the email, “Hey, come on MuggleCast.” You were like, “I’m on vacation in Paris, sure!”

[Andrew and Clara laugh]

Andrew: But we appreciate you coming on while you’re on your vacation. What have you been up to over there for fun?

Clara: Well, we got here about ten days ago, and I actually flew into Berlin. Yeah, my uncle lives in Berlin. And we drove from Berlin to Paris, and we did a Belgian brewery tour on the way, and then came here, and mostly have just been walking around. I think yesterday we walked 25,000 steps, so it’s a lot of walking.

Andrew: Nice, so you can eat all the bread.

Clara: Exactly, been eating a lot of bread. And one weird thing I had right before I came on the trip, I had a incident with a bat in my room and I had to get a rabies vaccination…

Andrew: Oh, geez.

Clara: … so I have been having to get the vaccination here, which has been kind of complicated.

[Andrew and Clara laugh]

Andrew: Oh, that’s too bad.

Clara: But that’s okay.

Eric: I’ve heard about vampires in Paris.

Clara: [laughs] But anyway, it’s almost over, and then I leave tomorrow to go home.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Micah: Well, we appreciate the fact that while on vacation, you were willing to come on and record this episode with us.

Clara: Well, no problem. It feels like a nice treat for a vacation. I was excited to be on it, so I did not mind. [laughs]

Micah: I think we should be honest with the people that are listening, though: The real reason that Clara is joining us is because she’s actually scouting Fantastic Beasts 2 from Paris.

[Andrew and Clara laugh]

Eric: It’s true.

Clara: Exactly. That’s a good point.

Andrew: Yeah, good point. She works for Warner Bros.; she’s hanging out with J.K. Rowling a little later today. Good for you.

Clara: That’s my plan tonight.

Andrew: Ask her to come on the show for once.

Clara: [laughs] That would be amazing.

Eric: Ask her to reply to our tweets.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Don’t ask her to do anything. I’m done trying.

[Clara laughs]

Andrew: So let’s get your fandom ID; let’s hear about your interest in Harry Potter. So what’s your favorite book?

Clara: I have two: My favorite for the longest time was Goblet of Fire, and I think just because of the Triwizard Tournament, it felt like something was new, or something new was brought to the table. And then I love Half-Blood Prince as well.

Eric: Good.

Clara: So I love all of them, but yeah, if I had to choose.

Andrew: Favorite movie?

Clara: That one was hard. I really like the second Deathly Hallows, Part 2. I think… I saw it when they did the IMAX release in the fall, I watched it again, and I cried three times during that movie, and they were just… and they were little moments, things that I never thought would make me cry, but I really like that one.

Andrew: Favorite…? Or not favorite; what’s your Hogwarts House?

Clara: Ravenclaw.

Eric: Nice.

Clara: Yes.

Andrew: Ilvermorny House?

Clara: Pukwudgie, which I just found out yesterday. I had never taken that.

Eric: Oh!

Clara: I know. Brown hare, which I think is Luna’s Patronus too.

Andrew: Brown hare. The rabbit? It’s a rabbit, right? What’s your favorite Harry Potter ship, whether it’s real or it’s your dream ship?

Clara: [laughs] This was hard to answer. I don’t know if this would be my ultimate favorite, but I couldn’t think of which one it would be. So I do remember when reading through the sixth book for the first time, I thought it was so exciting when Harry and Ginny finally started developing a relationship, so I would probably choose that right now, just because I was a teenage girl and thought, “This is so cool that they’re finally getting together.”

Andrew: Yeah. The book version of that ship, not the movie version, which in my opinion is bad.

Clara: Oh, for sure. Not very good. Terrible. It’s terrible. [laughs]

Andrew: And then finally, since we are at the 20th anniversary here, how did you get started with Harry Potter?

Clara: Yeah, well, I was in first grade when the first book came out in the US, and I went to the Scholastic Book Fair at school, and they had this whole stand of the first book. And I’d never heard of it, of course, but I thought, “Well, this is the first thing I’ve seen. I’ll just pick it up.” And so I bought it and took it home, and I remember reading the first page and reading about Petunia and Vernon Dursley, and they live on Number Four Privet Drive, and I just thought, “This is so boring.” And I gave it to…

[Andrew laughs]

Clara: I just didn’t make it past the first page. And I set it aside, and my mom picked it up and read it and told me that I had to read it, and I finally did, and I loved it. But I didn’t really… I don’t remember feeling super excited about the books until the fourth book came out, and I remember seeing that in all of the stores and bookstores and stuff. But yeah, that was how I started.

Andrew: Cool. Yeah, that’s a funny story. “Privet Drive, who cares about this?”

Clara: Yeah, boring people

Andrew: “Sell this book, Mom.”

Eric: I couldn’t for the life of me figure out if it was supposed to read “Private,” and that was how British people said the word “private.”

[Clara laughs]

Andrew: Well, thank you for joining us, and nice Scholastic Book Fair shout-out as well. I miss those things.

Clara: Oh yeah, I loved those.


News


Andrew: So let’s talk a little bit of news, and then we’re going to get into a discussion about Graves. And also, we have a bit of an announcement to make. Woop, woop, woop. First of all, actually, all the news this week – just two items – are Cursed Child-related. So on the last episode, we mentioned that the original cast was wrapping up their run in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. It’s already been a year, and now they’re finished. So we wondered if anything special would be happening for that final performance.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Nothing really special, except Rose planted a little kiss on Scorpius’s cheek at the very end of the play. So for shippers of Scorbus, it was bad news. [laughs] For shippers of Scorose, it was great news! And I spoke to somebody, Christina, who’s evidently a Cursed Child super fan; she has been to a bunch of performances. And she was explaining to me that the actress who plays Rose, Cherrelle Skeete, was kind of playing it up over the past couple months. They had her and the actor who plays Scorpius – Anthony Boyle, I believe his name is – they were kind of getting a little more playful in Act 4, Scene 14, where they have a moment together. So it felt like it was leading to something, and they were kind of teasing each other, and they were teasing audiences with the way they were interacting. Anyway, Cherrelle had kind of teased fans, like, “Will they or won’t they? Will they or won’t they kiss? I don’t know.” So she saved it for the final performance. She gave Scorpius a little kiss on the cheek.

Eric: Aww.

Andrew: So yeah, I thought that… I personally don’t ship Scorose, but I think it was a nice little farewell.

Eric: [laughs] You’re being really diplomatic. What happened is I saw this tweet when it came in from Hypable linking to this post, and then I clicked on it and saw that you wrote it, and I literally buckled up, and I was like, “Oh my God.”

Andrew: Buckle up, get ready for Andrew…

Eric: Here’s where Andrew gets… and you crossed off Albus’s name.

Andrew: So yeah, so that happened. And we have a new Cursed Child cast now.

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: The production released portraits like the ones from the original cast members, where they’re all in costume. They look good, but it was just jarring seeing different people playing these roles after getting so used to the original cast. [laughs] It’d be like if halfway through the Harry Potter movies, they recasted everybody. You just get so used to the looks of each of the characters, after we had already adjusted following the movies; now we have to adjust again.

Eric: Well, only if we’re seeing the play.

Andrew: Yeah, or looking at these pictures.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Andrew: I don’t like Harry. I don’t like Ginny.

Eric: Okay, that’s offensive.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: What do you have to go on, man? Have you seen their acting chops?

Andrew: Ron’s gotten a little pudgier. I do like Lucius – or no, no, Draco. [laughs] I do like Draco. Yeah, that’s my thoughts.

Eric: Okay. That was really shallow. I’m sure all of these actors are very, very, very good.

Andrew: I’m sure they’re fine; it’s just taking me a little getting used to, but I need to stop looking at the pictures.

Eric: There is a video; I will click on the video later for the character shoot. I just think it’s probably really exciting as an actor to be able to work with a property that’s as famous and award-winning as Harry Potter.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, it’s the opportunity of a lifetime. You’re set for life.

Eric: So I would definitely like to congratulate the new cast, and once again, thanks to the old cast of Cursed Child for putting on so many performances, and being so beloved.

Andrew: Yep. Clara, did you read Cursed Child? Or see it?

Clara: I bought it a couple days after it came out, and I couldn’t finish it.

Andrew: Oh, wow.

Eric: Good for you.

Clara: I just wasn’t a fan. [laughs] Yeah, I was very excited about it, but no, I think I made it to… how many…? Are there just two parts to that? I didn’t make it very far, whatever. I think I got to the train moment, or when they got Sorted into their Houses.

Andrew: You stopped there? Was it the trolley lady? You couldn’t stand the trolley lady?

Clara: Yeah, she was just weird. No, I thought that was pretty cool. But yeah, I mean, it might have been the format too. It was just so different reading it that way as more of a script, but I didn’t love it.

Andrew: So did you read spoilers? Do you know what happens after that?

Clara: Yes. I could not resist that. [laughs]

Andrew: Okay. All right, well, Eric, we have some news to share, don’t we?

Eric: We do, Andrew.

Andrew: Should I…?

Micah: Go ahead, Andrew, because clearly, you put this in the document, so you should go ahead and read it.

Andrew: [laughs] I did.

Eric: Oh, you beat me to it.

Andrew: Well, Eric knows the details better than I do, so that’s why I threw it to him.

Eric: Well, let’s all say it.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: All at once.

Andrew: We’re going to be at MuggleNet Live!

Eric: … Net Live! September 1, 2017, MuggleCast will be attending MuggleNet Live 2017: 19 Years Later! Yay.

Andrew: And what does that mean? Because my parents were like, “You’ve been doing the podcast for 19 years?” I was like, “No, Mom.”

[Eric and Clara laugh]

Eric: No, Mom. So this is the date, this year, September 1, is the date in the Deathly Hallows epilogue where Harry and Ginny and Ron and Hermione take all their kids off to school, also known as the beginning of Cursed Child.

Micah: Yeah, but we’re not celebrating that.

Eric: But it’s the actual… we’re not celebrating that.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: This is the actual date, and so what it is is it’s an exclusive one night only party inside the Wizarding World of Harry Potter Diagon Alley theme park. And you’ll actually be able to ride the Hogwarts Express as well as Gringotts, and there’s all sorts of lovely food options, unlimited butterbeer, all sorts of stuff. And certain actors from the films will be there; currently announced, Luke Youngblood, who plays Lee Jordan; and Christian Coulson was just announced, who plays… he was the first Tom Riddle, as well as Chris Rankin, Ellie Darcey-Alden, some of the more people you’re familiar with, all the kids from the epilogue – or a lot of them – will all be there wandering about, and there’s no extra charge for photos and autographs and all that stuff. So MuggleNet’s got a really cool sort of evening going on. You can find out all of the details on the website, but actually, go to our website, where there’s a post that I wrote which gives some of the details and our offer code as well.

Andrew: Yes, we are saving people a little money, so make sure you use that offer code. And we’re going to be doing a live podcast, too, right?

Eric: Yeah, yeah. We’re going to figure out either a podcast, a meetup, maybe an exclusive dinner hour in the Leaky Cauldron…

Andrew: Exclusive dinner hour!

Eric: Yeah, all included in ticket prices. We’re still going to work out what we’re doing there, but we will be there, and it’ll be a lot of fun.

Andrew: I’m going to bring a couple Blue Apron boxes. I’m going to cook in the Leaky Cauldron. [laughs]

Eric: Good, I’ll bring your green apron. That will be when… I’ll bring your green apron that…

Micah: And I’ll bring the fire extinguisher.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Hey, I’m a good cook sometimes.

Eric: Yeah. So again, that’s this September, and it’s MuggleNet Live, and MuggleCast will be there. So go check that out on MuggleCast.com at the very top; the first post that you’ll see will be the post with our offer code and all sorts of good stuff.

Andrew: Yeah, excited to do that. It’s going to be a fun time.

Eric: Yeah, it’s always good to see you guys.

Andrew: Yeah… you too.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Kidding.

Micah: Great. Really sold that, Andrew.

Andrew: I haven’t seen Micah in a while. I mean, the last time we were in… Eric and I were in Orlando for GeekyCon, for the Cursed Child release last summer.

Eric: Yeah, and Micah was not.

Andrew: We missed you, Micah.

Micah: Yeah, when was the last time…?

Eric: The three of us were together?

Andrew: Well, that was… we were in New York together.

Eric: Fantastic Beasts, Carnegie Hall.

Andrew: Yeah. Harry Potter always just brings us together. [fake cries] It’s so beautiful. We’re going to start talking about Graves in just a moment, but first, we want to remind you that today’s sponsor is Blue Apron.

[Ad break]


Main Discussion: Percival Graves


Andrew: All right, let’s move on to our character discussion today. we are going to talk about Percival Graves! One of the cooler characters, in my opinion, in this movie.

Eric: He’s great. He’s great, and I think Colin Farrell does an excellent job just being a really cool, mysterious type character. Percival Graves, of course, head of the Auror Department for MACUSA in 1926. Through the course of the film, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, it is revealed that he is, in fact, Grindelwald, Gellert Grindelwald in disguise. Uh-oh. And we’re going to begin our discussion with some name origins, actually, from Katie, who has continued to send us really interesting information. I don’t know where she finds this, but it’s all extremely…

Micah: Google?

[Andrew and Clara laugh]

Eric: Probably.

Micah: No, no, I’m sorry. Let’s keep it a mystery. I don’t want to give anything away.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, yeah. But these were great; she helped us out with our Tina episode, and then continued to submit as we discussed Seraphina last week, and this week Graves. So thanks to Katie in advance for this. But the name Percival, which we know J.K. Rowling does not choose lightly, and in fact, in the case of Percival, reuses it quite often. Percival means one who pierces the valley; hard steel. The most innocent of all the Knights of the Round Table, and the one who found the Holy Grail.

Andrew: Well, he is piercing and tough. So this once again reminds me, wow, these name origins really are brought to the characters in the movies.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, definitely. And it looks like the character of Percival Graves himself, according to Pottermore, is a descendant of one of the first dozen volunteers to train as Aurors for MACUSA; his ancestor was Gondulphus Graves. So the question some people have, I guess, going into the film is: Was Graves a person before Grindelwald was masquerading as him? Or was this a character, sort of like an alias that Grindelwald developed to raise high in the ranks at MACUSA? But it seems like Graves indeed was a person before, and Grindelwald must have captured or killed him and then assumed his role because he was so high up in MACUSA, and simply through disguising himself as him, Grindelwald immediately had access to the top levels of governments in America.

Micah: That’s very interesting. I didn’t think about it that way, in that Graves could be somebody that was never truly a person that existed, that it was somebody that Grindelwald created in order to infiltrate MACUSA and could have been acting as him from very early days. But that seems like a lot of work, and I don’t think that Grindelwald had that much time on his hands.

Eric: Oh, yeah. Can you imagine Grindelwald climbing the ladder in America? Yeah, but no, Graves was actually… so Graves is a very renowned… comes from a good family, a family of Aurors, or long line of severe badasses. The interesting thing… I mentioned that Percival is a name that is used time and again by J.K. Rowling. The other characters, just as a refresher here, who share the name Percival include Dumbledore’s own father, so that’s Albus Dumbledore’s father is Percival Dumbledore. It is one of Albus Dumbledore’s middle names; his name is Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore. Percy Weasley, it turns out its full name is Percival. And there’s a character called Percival Pratt, who was a wizard poet; he has his portrait hung in Hogwarts castle’s grand staircase.

Andrew: Now, how did you find that? Don’t tell me you know every wizard hanging in Hogwarts’s grand staircase.

Micah: Katie found out.

Eric: You’ve got to ask Katie. She did that.

Andrew: Oh, oh. Okay.

Eric: She just worked her magic.

[Clara laughs]

Micah: She possibly knows every portrait hanging.

Eric: She possibly knows every… she’s also a Ravenclaw, just like Clara. So Clara, do you know all the portraits that are hanging in the…?

Clara: [laughs] No, but I was listening to prepare for today, and since I’ve been gone for a while, I haven’t listened to a couple of the last episodes, but I listened to Katie’s today and was intimidated by her knowledge.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, I think we’re all intimidated by her knowledge. We have to keep bringing her stuff on because it’s really good, but we’re all a little scared of her.

[Clara laughs]

Eric: But actually, you know what? While we’re showcasing some patrons, there was a comment from Irvin as we were preparing this document, and I have to share it because he’s found a link through all of these characters named Percival. He’s found something that they have in common, which I really like and have to share here. So Irvin says,

“Regarding ‘Percival,’ I find that the thread of innocence being corrupted runs through all of J.K. Rowling’s Percivals, where they were good people who were influenced by something bad. Percival Graves was taken over by Grindelwald. Albus Dumbledore was seduced by Grindelwald into dabbling with Dark magic. Percival Dumbledore was corrupted by hatred and a thirst for vengeance against Muggle boys. Percy Weasley was corrupted by the Ministry and his own ambition. Further diving into this, the two that are actually called Percival never bounce back from their corruption. Graves is presumed dead, and Percival Dumbledore rots in Azkaban. However, the two characters with a more tenuous connection to the name, Percy Weasley and Albus Percival Dumbledore, eventually see the error of their ways and manage to bounce back.”

Micah: And what about Percival Pratt?

Eric: And Percival Pratt is writing poems somewhere off in the sidelines.

Micah: Hey, we need to talk about all of them.

Andrew: Well, you could argue that Graves still might “bounce back.”

Eric: I certainly hope he does.

Andrew: I don’t presume he’s dead, necessarily. And of course, this is a good opportunity at some point in the next few films to bring him back in, although if he met Newt it’d be like meeting him for the first time, I suppose, because Newt never really met him and vice versa, so that could be interesting.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, this is the interesting thing about Graves, is we’re doing a character discussion on him based on the events of Fantastic Beasts, but ultimately, it’s more of a Grindelwald character discussion because Grindelwald is only posing as Graves. However, to be undercover successfully, especially when you’re working every day with President Picquery and all of Graves’s closest known associates, you have to assume that the Graves that we see in the film is pretty close to the actual Graves, at least how he would have behaved and acted and the things he would have said and done up until the point where he sentences Tina and Newt to death, right? So it’s a convincing disguise for Grindelwald to pull this off, and I think it indicates that Grindelwald became familiar with Graves, and perhaps tortured this information out of him, but really got a sense of who he was in order to successfully pose as him in the Ministry. So I think it’s just worth noting that we’ll talk about Graves, and we’re really talking about Grindelwald, but still we can get a sense of who Graves is because Grindelwald had to successfully pose as him. So just a little disclaimer.

Micah: Yeah, and I made the note that we get the unique perspective of watching a character, really, for an entire film who is not who he appears to be, but we also have very little context for who he should be.

Eric: Right.

Micah: And that is interesting to me, that Grindelwald was able to play up being Graves to such a point where nobody questioned it, and he is at the highest level of government, he is interfacing on a daily basis with the president of MACUSA, he’s sitting in the meeting of the International Confederation amongst all of these leaders that are looking for him, and he is just able to pull it off without raising any suspicion, up until there’s that scene with him and Newt and Tina and the Obscurus. And I think that’s really when Newt starts to suspect that something’s off here, but just a masterful job, and it points to the type of character that we can expect to see from Grindelwald moving forward. I know David Heyman refers to him as being a rock star, as being this seductive individual, and so he’s very clearly able to make connections with people. And I think we get the first real example of that when he interacts with Credence and just the way he’s able to manipulate him, it’s to me a bit of foreshadowing, perhaps? Maybe that’s not the right word, because I was going to say with respect to Dumbledore, and I think that has already taken place, so I think it’s more of a insight into one of his major personality traits, and that’s his ability to use his charm to manipulate people.

Eric: And he does the legwork, too. You get the sense, because this situation is familiar to the Mad-Eye Moody situation with Barty Crouch, Jr. able to overcome Mad-Eye Moody and pose as him. I mean, same in Harry’s fourth year; you get these lessons for an entire year that are not from Mad-Eye Moody at all, and that still remains, given light of the later books, to be the most screen time that you have of that character of Mad-Eye Moody, except it wasn’t him at all. So it’s kind of like that, except I prefer to think of what Grindelwald is doing as stronger and more work, more legwork. Barty Crouch, Jr. got lucky in comparison. Grindelwald is, as a terrifying villain, able to use, as Micah was saying, his charm, able to use his skill, and I think that ultimately it was more legwork, and Grindelwald will do that legwork to overcome obstacles. He’s not going to shy away from hard work. He’s trying to infiltrate the top levels of the Ministry to stay one step ahead of their efforts to find him, and that’s what he’s able to do successfully, until at the very end, as you mentioned, with his obsession with this Obscurus and his quest for greatness. His quest for power blinds his ability to do that.

Micah: Absolutely. And speaking of Goblet of Fire, we put out a question, a poll, actually, on Twitter yesterday. There’s still nine hours left to vote…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: … so I’m sure we’ll get some more here before the day is through, but 127 people shared their opinion. We asked, “What did you think of the Grindelwald/Graves storyline in Fantastic Beasts?”, to which 54% replied, “Goblet of Fire Part 2.” 46% said, “It was epic.” So almost 50/50 in terms of how people felt about that storyline, but…

Eric: Were those the only two options?

Micah: Those were the only two options, yeah. I wanted to keep it…

Eric: Oh, okay, you’re making people decide whether they loved it or…

Andrew: I just voted “It was epic,” because just from a surprise standpoint, it was genuinely surprising, and so I don’t really compare it to Goblet of Fire because of that reason. And not to mention, just the fact that it was Johnny Depp who was playing him. Now, of course, that surprise was ruined going into the movie…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: But yeah, no, I thought it was good.

Micah: Epic?

Andrew: Let’s just hope she doesn’t do this again.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: What did you think, Clara?

Clara: I’m going to go with “It was epic,” just because I hadn’t really thought until I read through these show notes about the similarities between those two. And I like that they are similar, but while watching it, I thought, “This is pretty awesome.” Yeah, so I was surprised and didn’t feel like it was too redundant, so I would go “It was epic.” I would go with that, yeah.

Andrew: I just voted “It was epic” too, so we’re about to swing the poll results.

Micah: Uh-oh.

[Clara and Eric laugh]

Clara: I’m going to vote now too.

Micah: Well, just because you win the popular vote doesn’t mean you… [laughs]

Eric: Okay, anyway! So the character of Graves… and actually, I forget where we found this out. It must have been on Pottermore, right? Where it’s mentioned that he was overseas for a time?

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: Ah, yeah. So we have throughout Potter a long history of characters like Quirrell, for instance, going off to, I think it was, in fact, Albania, that very same forest in Albania where Bertha Jorkins goes missing and Peter Pettigrew finds Voldemort and Quirrell gets possessed by Voldemort. It’s all that number one travel destination for unfortunate souls. But we find out that Graves was overseas, and this is presumably where Grindelwald was able to capture and/or defeat him, and begin posing as him. So we have this situation where Grindelwald then comes back and is posing as him. Now, unclear again what became of Graves after that, whether Graves is still with him, whether Graves is imprisoned somewhere, we do not know.

Micah: I think it’s actually mentioned by Graves when they’re in the room with the International Confederation that he was overseas. I think.

Eric: Oh, there you go.

Micah: Maybe I’m wrong; somebody can check me on that, but I’m almost certain that Graves mentions it during the film that he was overseas, or somebody mentions the fact in MACUSA that Graves was traveling. And this raises questions about his interactions with Newt’s brother, because we know that Colin Farrell let it slip in an interview that the two of them were at least corresponding, so yeah, sort of a international pact between MACUSA and the Ministry to try and bring down Grindelwald. So it definitely leads to a lot more questions about what kind of interactions these two had with each other, and then what happened that allowed Graves to be overtaken by Grindelwald?

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Eric: It’s not a situation where it gets overshadowed in this film, which I love, but the threat of Grindelwald and what Grindelwald means to world peace and his reign of terror… there’s a few lines in here; Newt, I think, calls out, “For the greater good,” and there’s his rhetoric and his intentions are well known in the world at this point, and they’re only going to get bigger and grander and worse. I mean, but there are essentially dozens of agencies, I assume, and wizards after Grindelwald, but in the film, it’s relegated to… I mean, it’s given proper weight, but fortunately, this film isn’t all about Grindelwald; it has so many other things going on. And of course, it’s just the reveal at the end that he’s been Grindelwald, but I think future films will certainly focus on how many people are tracking him, because he’ll probably escape again.

Andrew: Yeah, and I mean, the first movie shows that he’s already a big threat. At the very beginning, we see that he’s a major issue for the wizarding world.

Eric: The newspaper.

Andrew: So I guess they could amp that up, and we could, like you’re saying, actually see people hunting him. But then again, in the next movie he could be in jail the whole time. We really have no clue what is happening.

Eric: It would be really interesting to see some sort of different conflict that has nothing to do with Grindelwald for part two.

Andrew: Right. Because on the other hand, it’s like, breaking out so soon? Eh.

Eric: Yeah, and then he’s on the run for another 19… because the series has to span another 19 years until 1945.

Andrew: Maybe he’ll break out at the end of the next movie. That’ll be the cliffhanger, like, “Ooh, how’s Jacob going to bake some bread to lure him?”

[Clara and Eric laugh]

Eric: Maybe Newt will find a diary that was Grindelwald’s young school diary. I think that could be a plot point in the second Fantastic Beasts.

Clara: I’m just interested to see… I know obviously this first movie we only hear of Dumbledore, but in the next films, I’m interested to see what he’s been doing this whole time, if we get to see some of that… with Voldemort he’s doing all of this research on his own, and so the whole Ministry is still – once they acknowledge that he’s alive – they’re searching for him, and Dumbledore, this whole time, has had his own side project of trying to find out about his past and figure out how to defeat him. So I don’t know; I think it’d be interesting to see what Dumbledore has been doing since Grindelwald left the funeral and they broke off that friendship.

Eric: So while we talked about the difference between Graves and Grindelwald, it’s important to note that anytime Graves does magic in Fantastic Beasts, it’s actually Grindelwald doing the magic. So Graves is able to heal Credence’s wounds on his hand from when his mother, I guess, lashed him with the belt, or was essentially abusing him, beating him; Graves is able to heal those wounds just by waving his hand over the wound. It’s a pretty cool scene in Fantastic Beasts, but it indicates skill level that Grindelwald is far above what we have seen before in terms of magical skill, which I think also works to be intimidating a little bit. And I think he even summons Newt’s case before Newt can even react protectively, summons his case and gets it, and he’s just overall very quick to act, very quick, very competent at magic.

Andrew: But wouldn’t you also assume that Grindelwald somehow studied Graves’s moves? Because wouldn’t it have been a tell if suddenly Graves was acting differently in terms of how he was handling his spell work?

Eric: Yes. Yeah, actually, that’s a good point. But when he’s with Credence, Credence doesn’t know who Graves is supposed to be normally, so he’s allowed to be himself, right?

Andrew: No, that’s true. I just mean towards the end of the movie, for example.

Micah: You definitely see a more darker side of the character when he’s interacting with Credence. The thing of the alley scenes, that’s when he talks a little bit more about this quest for power. We see the symbol of the Deathly Hallows to use as a signal to alert him to when Credence is able to find the Obscurus. So just going back for a sec, though, to talk about how Grindelwald is able to act as Graves, I don’t want to in any way try and diminish Graves and his ability, because we really don’t know much about him, but to assume that he wouldn’t be able to do many of the things that Grindelwald is doing, the pieces that you mentioned, Eric, I think takes a little bit away from the fact that Graves is an Auror at the end of the day, and a well accomplished one at that, and is a descendant of a long line of Aurors, so clearly he’s very, very well accomplished.

Eric: I think my point was just that since we’re dealing with adults here, it’s an unwritten book as to what types of magic we’ll see. But it is Grindelwald who’s able to do these things, so just keeping in mind that none of this goes away now that we have Grindelwald, now that we might no longer have Graves in the films. These are… Grindelwald, again, at the end of the film, is able to fend off hundreds of spells coming his way from all of the Aurors. Literally all of the Aurors are simultaneously fighting him, and he’s able to repel every spell until Newt is able to give his Swooping Evil a shot to save the day, and that’s pretty impressive.

Micah: That raises the question to me, though, what exactly is this transformation that took place? Because if you think back to Goblet of Fire, Barty Crouch, Jr./Mad-Eye Moody is not very much different, if at all, from the Mad-Eye Moody that we see in later films. We don’t really know how different Percival Graves is from Graves/Grindelwald. And I understand that with Polyjuice, you take on the features and the actions of the person that you’re portraying, but I don’t know. To me, it’s a bit confusing. Was that really Graves, or was it Grindelwald as Graves?

Eric: It was Grindelwald as Graves, but I think that it was probably very close to Graves. Graves is just very charismatic. He’s very competent. He strikes me as being interested in the people that he’s working for. There’s a scene, actually… I don’t know; it’s sort of easy to miss, but when he comes down to Tina’s office when she’s working in the wand permit office, and Graves says, “I’ll be down shortly,” and then he comes down, there’s that guy who was grilling Tina a moment ago, Abernathy, and when he says, “Good afternoon, Mr. Graves,” there’s a brief moment where Grindelwald as Graves says, “Afternoon,” pauses as if to recall the guy’s name, and then he says, “Abernathy.” There’s a brief moment where he’s like, “Uh… Abernathy.” And I think…

Andrew: “Hey, you. What’s up, you?”

Eric: “Hey, you.” Yeah, but that should give the indicator that Graves is somebody who knows the people that work under him; he takes the time to know their names. So I think that might be a tell as well as to who Graves is as a person, sort of more generous, more caring than you’d normally have to be if you were a person of that profound skill.

Andrew: But I still think Grindelwald studied him a lot to get him down so there wouldn’t be any tells, because yes, we saw him on screen, maybe, but just think of the times off screen where he was interacting with Seraphina Picquery and these other people of MACUSA. He has to be exactly like Graves to prevent them from questioning, “What’s up with Graves?”

Eric: There’s also this feeling that Grindelwald is somehow telepathic, or at least he has some sort of gift for prophecy? I mean, essentially, what Grindelwald is doing in New York has to do with this vision that he had about an Obscurus. He tells this in the scenes with Credence here, about his vision that has led him here, how he sees the creature and he sees this guy Credence. The whole reason he found Credence to begin with is because apparently, he had this vision where Credence and his mother were circling around, or were related to the source of insane, complex power. Grindelwald never really deduces until it’s too late that Credence is the Obscurial, because Credence is an exceptional case and should have died already for his age, but Grindelwald was moved and brought on by this prophecy or this gift for the sight that he himself has, and that’s something that’s very, very terrifying, the idea that this evil villain can also see the future.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s true. He knows what’s coming. It’ll be him against Queenie.

[Clara and Eric laugh]

Eric: I mean, that’d be kind of interesting. I would watch that.

Andrew: So one thing we wanted to ask was can we expect to see him in future films? And what we asked on Twitter was, “Where is Graves?” And we asked people to submit voicemails. We got one. Let’s listen to this one.

[Voicemail plays]

“Hey MuggleCast, it’s The Lady Ash. As far as your question for this week as where Graves is, I think he is somewhere in Europe. I believe in the beginning of the movie there were newspaper articles talking about how Graves had been over there, and I think that we’re supposed to be led to believe that that’s where he ran into Grindelwald, and that’s where Grindelwald either killed him and took over his identity, or hopefully just left him over there. That’s what I think, anyway. I think Graves is in Europe, and that when we go over there to Paris, that somehow Newt and the gang are just going to run into him randomly, and maybe he’ll have no idea on what was going on in America, or maybe his memory was erased and they have to unlock it, I don’t know, but I definitely think he’s alive, and I think we’re going to see him probably in the next movie. Anywho, excited to hear your thoughts. Have a great day, guys, and thanks for doing what you do. Bye.”

Andrew: All right. Thank you, Lady Ash. Well, she seems pretty confident, although I feel like we heard that Colin Farrell is not returning for Fantastic Beasts? That could, of course, change, and let’s hope it does, but I think there was a comment about that at one point from one of the crew members, or maybe Colin Farrell himself. But still, that makes sense to me, and that would be a good way to work him in. We’ve been wondering how these American characters are going to appear in Europe, because we keep hearing about how Fantastic Beasts will be set in Europe.

Eric: Yeah, having Graves just sort of wander the streets, even under a Memory Charm, seems like not tying up of a loose end. I think Grindelwald very clearly… I think the two options have to be Graves is dead, or Graves is imprisoned. Now, that doesn’t rule out Newt, Tina, Queenie being able to find Graves imprisoned somehow, somewhere. Maybe a charm that’s keeping him wears off and Graves wanders out. Maybe even has amnesia, that could work. But I think that Grindelwald ultimately is too terrifying and formidable to just leave a loose end like Graves wandering around.

Micah: That makes sense. And it’s also possible… we know that Grindelwald has built up, or at least… am I making this up? Nurmengard? I mean, I know that’s where he’s inevitably imprisoned, but I also believe that that’s his stronghold.

Andrew: It is.

Micah: So who knows? Maybe he starts collecting people in that prison and Graves is the first, or he may not be the first. Who knows?

Eric: Oh, I don’t remember that. Didn’t he turn Durmstrang into sort of his own place for a while there? Because in Goblet of Fire

Micah: He went to Durmstrang.

Eric: Well, he went to Durmstrang, but there’s also people would graffiti the Deathly Hallows all over that place when he was taking over. I’m trying to determine if this is from Book 7 or Book 4, but yeah, how Durmstrang gets its reputation for being a school of darker magic, I think, comes from the influence that Grindelwald had over that place in the teens and ’20s and growing up, going into the war. At least, that’s the impression that I got.

Andrew: He was put in Nurmengard, though, and it was his own prison.

Eric: He was, and it’s interesting that he stays there, I mean, for 50 odd years until Voldemort comes and kills him. I’m wondering if it really is a prison he couldn’t have broken out of.

Andrew: You would think he knew the weak points of his own prison. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, if he really has that… yeah, if he has that influence over…

Andrew: He made a spell to get out of his own prison, in case they ever threw him into his own prison.

Micah: But we don’t know what the defeat entailed. It could have been something that maybe removed all of his magical ability.

Eric: Oh, God… and he gave it to Jacob.

[Clara laughs]

Eric: Jacob is going to have all of Grindelwald’s talent. But yeah, so here’s some quotes about Grindelwald, as well as what Grindelwald is trying to accomplish in the wizarding world. Because I keep mentioning this, but J.K. Rowling, David Yates, and David Heyman cracked this story and pretty much all the stories prior to filming for this movie, so they know what’s going on. So this is from David Heyman. He says,

“What Grindelwald wants to do is expose the magical world, and in so doing, create a war with the non-wizarding world. And there is a fear that a fascist, someone who is as intolerant as Grindelwald is, will cause nothing but pain.”

And here’s a quote from Yates.

“He’s a bit of a rock star in the wizarding world. He’s very seductive. He has a brilliant mind. He wants to win people’s hearts and minds. He wants them to feel comfortable with the policies that he’s advocating. He was very close with Dumbledore. The two of them had a very important relationship. And we just touch – in the first movie – on the relationship very slightly and there is much more to come in the following movies.”

And then here’s a final quote from Heyman; this is about Grindelwald’s role in the future films. He says,

“The connective tissue to the Potter universe gets stronger and stronger. What I am enjoying is seeing how as we move forward, I can see the Potter world moving back and seeing how all those lines meet.”

Heyman. So he’s speaking to whatever ends up happening with Grindelwald will sort of form the basis for where the wizarding world is at when Harry Potter picks up. I think that also might secretly foreshadow Voldemort’s involvement, because Voldemort, of course, is going to be alive during this time period. He’s alive, he’s born seven days after Fantastic Beasts 1 ends, and then he’s obviously the main villain in Harry Potter. So I’d like to believe that Voldemort will also be in these movies, but Grindelwald definitely… his rise for power, yeah.

Andrew: Oh, boy. Eh, I don’t want to see Voldemort in these. I think that’s too much.

Eric: Really?

Andrew: We had Voldemort. That’s it; we don’t need it. Grindelwald is our Voldemort in this series.

Eric: Yes, but I mean, if the final Fantastic Beasts film ends in 1945 with Dumbledore’s defeat of Grindelwald, Voldemort wasn’t only alive, he’s also already opened the Chamber of Secrets and he’s already made a Horcrux. I think it was from his father’s murder.

Andrew: All right, so maybe a little easter egg, like a post-credit scene or something; that would be cool.

[Clara and Eric laugh]

Andrew: But in terms of him having a major role, I don’t think there should be two major villains.

Micah: Well, he’s not a villain yet. I mean, it’s the rise of a villain, right?

Andrew: Yeah, I just feel like it’s distracting to have these two major antagonists teasing us. Just focus on the one.

Micah: Yeah, but wouldn’t that also be…? Don’t you think that would help influence a bit the future events, if Grindelwald and Voldemort actually had some sort of connection?

Eric: I think the important part is that Voldemort grows up in a world where people are fearing Grindelwald. The first 12 or 15 years of Voldemort’s young life, there’s this threat, there’s this very real threat of Grindelwald taking over the world, and I have to think that that leaves some kind of influence on Voldemort, who also craves power. But I have a quote here, and this is from Graves himself, because this gives the most insight. This is the thesis statement that Grindelwald is working with. It’s important to note that Grindelwald thinks that Credence is dead, but we know that he is probably not, so there’s a little bit of hope there that Grindelwald won’t go straight to Credence once he gets out. But when he thinks that all of the Aurors have killed Credence, he shouts, “You fools! Do you realize what you’ve done?” President Picquery says, “The Obscurial was killed on my orders, Mr. Graves.” He replies, “Yes, and history will surely note that, Madam President. What was done here tonight was not right.” And Picquery says, “He’s broken one of our most sacred laws.” He says, “A law that has us scuttling like rats in the gutter, a law that demands we conceal our true nature, a law that directs those who are superior to cower in fear lest we risk discovery. Let me ask you, Madam President, and I ask all of you: Who does this law protect? Us or them?” So that’s Grindelwald’s whole theory in a nutshell, I think. He believes wizards are superior, and he would like to see wizards free to practice their magic, free to live life, not hiding.

Andrew: I think Eric just wanted to do a little acting on the show.

[Clara laughs]

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: What do you think?

Eric: No, I mean, it’s an important quote, right?

Andrew: It’s a good point. Can we play this clip from the movie now? That little easter egg we’ve been talking about for a while?

Eric: Which?

Andrew: Hearing Johnny Depp, his voice.

Eric: Oh, do you want to do it on the show and not on bonus MuggleCast?

Andrew: Oh, that’s right. Sorry, sorry, sorry. Never mind. Ignore me.

[Clara and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Coming up on bonus MuggleCast…

Eric: Well, we may have mentioned it before, but Jeanna, who brought this up, who found this, was I think entirely right. [laughs] There’s a scene early on in the film, at 33 minutes, where we may get some Johnny Depp voice in the shadows.

Andrew: We’ll listen and judge. So anyway, anything else we wanted to touch on before wrapping this up?

Eric: Anything else on Graves?

Andrew: Yeah, I hope to see him in future movies, but I’m not confident we will, and it’s too bad because I really love the character. I’ve said this previously; I think Colin Farrell has put on some of the coolest wand work we’ve seen in any Harry Potter/Wizarding World movie.

Eric: He’s kind of suave with the wand.

Andrew: He’s very suave.

Eric: I think it’s, too…

Andrew: And I hope that’s the Graves part of the character, not the Grindelwald part.

Eric: I agree, I agree. We can’t have another suave Johnny Depp character. It just doesn’t work.

Andrew: And only if Johnny Depp was Graves and Colin Farrell was Grindelwald. That would have been better, in my opinion. I don’t want to see Jack Sparrow as Grindelwald.

Eric: Yeah, maybe they’ll recast him.

Andrew: [laughs] I don’t think that’s going to happen.

Eric: But, oh, Graves has cool sleeves. I guess that also helps showing him showcase magic, right? The sleeves of his robes are kind of open at the end, and very cool to watch.

Andrew: Sure. Any other final thoughts on Graves, then?

Clara: I have a question about Grindelwald, that Micah, when you mentioned the prison that he created, this just brought this thought to mind. Do you think that Voldemort considered him to be a threat? Considered Grindelwald to be a threat? Or would you think he would have considered him to be like an ally, someone who had that same vision in mind?

Eric: I’d like to believe, since Voldemort leaves Grindelwald alive that whole time… the only time he goes to find Grindelwald, or actively, I think, seeks him out, is when he’s on the quest for the Deathly Hallows, when he’s on the quest for the Elder Wand and circumstances bring Voldemort on the trail of Grindelwald. Whatever passes between them, or however Voldemort felt about Grindelwald, he was essentially hands off. It was a live-and-let-live sort of situation where Grindelwald is languishing in prison; he’s not an active threat to Voldemort. I think Voldemort actively was just content to let Grindelwald live in prison until such time as he needed information from Grindelwald, where he goes, he gets the information, and then kills him. I think that before then, Voldemort was perfectly content to let him live, and I think that that may indicate that to Voldemort, Grindelwald was either an ally or an idol.

Andrew: Definitely an idol.

Clara: And maybe he was stripped of his power if, I don’t know, Voldemort wouldn’t have any reason to use him.

Eric: That’s really interesting.

Clara: So I don’t know. I just thought about that.

Eric: I like that theory. I love that theory that he’s stripped of his power, that he just does not have any way of getting out because he doesn’t have magic anymore. That would be crazy.

Micah: Yeah, it would make sense, because for what other purpose…? You would think that he would have the ability to escape otherwise, unless… it becomes ironic that he’s imprisoned in his own prison, and that somebody said before, wouldn’t he know the intricacies to be able to escape? Unless it’s so overly powerful that he can’t overcome his own magic. But I like the idea of the fact that he has been stripped, in some capacity, of his magical ability and can no longer fight his way out the way that he would under normal circumstances. But to answer your question, though, too, if he was a priority for Voldemort, why not go after him during his first rise to power? He only comes into play, as was mentioned, as Voldemort is in search of the Elder Wand. But I also think that Voldemort focuses very much on himself and and doesn’t really have a need for Grindelwald. I don’t know if it’s opportunistic, but he’s situational, right? If he needs Grindelwald for something, he’s going to go to Grindelwald and he’s going to get what he needs, and he’s going to move on. I don’t think he’s looking to make friends, but it’s very possible that he learned from his mistakes. He saw a very failed attempt at rising to power and put in place other practices in order to protect himself as he himself rose to power.

Clara and Eric: Yeah.

Eric: And you’re exactly… I’m looking this up for a history lesson, but Nurmengard was, in fact, constructed under the orders of Grindelwald. So you’re absolutely right; Grindelwald originally built the prison. This is according to the Harry Potter Wikia, which is not a reliable source. I just have to keep saying that.

Andrew: [laughs] You say that every time! They source stuff. Leave them alone.

Eric: I can read this entire paragraph and there’s not one annotation, so I don’t know where it came from. But according to this, the prison was built on the orders of Dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald at the height of his power in order to hold Grindelwald’s opponents, and his slogan “For the greater good” is carved over the prison’s entrance. So Nurmengard is totally Grindelwald’s prison. Sort of ironic that he ends up there and can’t get out.

Micah: And Graves could be there.

Andrew: Yeah. I feel like there’s a movie like this, where… for the past few minutes I’ve been trying to think of the comparison. There’s a movie or a book or something where somebody… oh, it was in Rogue One.

Eric: What?

Andrew: They purposely built the Death Star to have a flaw, right?

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s Grindelwald. He probably built it… there’s a flaw somewhere that he could take advantage of to get out of it.

Eric: [laughs] Oh, exactly. And not only that, but there’s so many instances in real history of people building castles or houses that have secret passageways and all sorts of means of getting around, and only the people who are actually physically building the house and the person who’s orchestrating the building actually know how many passageways there are in and out. And if Grindelwald was involved in overseeing the construction of this prison, he absolutely would know all of the ways in which you would escape from said prison, so the fact that he doesn’t either speaks to his not having magic anymore, or him being maybe a reformed character who regrets his actions and he just decides to languish there for 50 odd more years.

Clara: Maybe he’s like Voldemort, very full of himself, and doesn’t think that he needs a way out because never assumes that he will make it into that space himself.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: The flaw in the plan.

[Clara and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Well, that wraps up our discussion on Graves this week. Hooray. I still need a Graves Funko. I’ve been wanting to buy a Graves Funko.

Eric: Oooh.

Andrew: That’s the last one that I want as a tribute to Colin Farrell and that great character, who we might not be seeing again. I don’t know why I just mentioned that. But if you have any feedback about today’s discussion, feel free to email it to MuggleCast@gmail.com. We also have a voicemail line where you can send in your feedback. The number is 1…

Eric: 930…

Andrew: [laughs] I’m pulling it up on the website. 920…

Eric: 1-920-3-MUGGLE.

Andrew: That’s right. Thank you in advance for submitting your feedback. And I think that does it for this week’s episode of MuggleCast; we are going to be recording a couple of bonus MuggleCast installments that will be available exclusively on Patreon, Patreon.com/MuggleCast. You can get those if you pledge $5 or more per month. We’re going to be listening to that clip and analyzing it closely: Is that Johnny Depp in that one scene where Graves is talking? Between Graves and Credence. And also, we’re going to do Make the Music Connection, summer hits edition. This is Memorial Day weekend we’re recording on, and we’ll kick off summer by playing some summer hits, some recent summer hits, and comparing them to the Harry Potter books. We need to do Harry Potter specifically.

Eric: I rely on Make the Music Connections that you do, Andrew, to get me current on music because I don’t know any music. [laughs]

Andrew: Well, I have some bad news, because the four songs I selected, three are from last summer.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: Because we don’t have our song of the summer yet; the summer’s just getting started.

Eric: That’s true, that’s true.

Andrew: I have three from last summer and then one from the summer before that, Demi Lovato’s “Cool for the Summer,” which is still my favorite summer song ever.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Clara, thank you for joining us.

Clara: Thanks for having me.

Andrew: What are you up to in Paris the rest of the day after this?

Clara: Well, I’m trying to decide if I should go to Disneyland Paris.

Andrew: Ah!

Clara: [laughs] I’d only be there for a couple of hours, but it might be worth it.

Andrew: Oh, crap.

Eric: Have you seen Musée d’Orsay?

Clara: I haven’t, but that’s one… I would love to go there too, so kind of in between…

Eric: You have to go to Musée d’Orsay.

Clara: I know. I love impressionist art, so I probably should do that. It’s closer; it’s easier to get to.

Eric: [whispers] Do it.

Andrew: Probably cheaper as well.

Clara: Probably a lot cheaper. [laughs] That’s a good idea.

Andrew: Thank you, everybody, for listening; we will be back next week. What character are we talking about next week? Do we know already?

Eric: We have a few options.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Eric: We’ll figure it out.

Andrew: We’ll figure it out while we’re barbecuing this weekend.

Micah: Let’s do a Twitter poll where the popular vote doesn’t win. We pick the other two options.

Andrew: Thanks, everybody, for listening. I’m Andrew.

Eric: I’m Eric.

Micah: I’m Micah.

Clara: And I’m Clara.

Andrew: Thanks, everybody. We’ll see you next time. Goodbye!

Micah: Bye.

Eric: Au revoir!

Transcript #306

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #306, Ariana the Obscurus?


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, your Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts podcast, covering everything about J.K. Rowling’s Wizarding World. Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 306. Happy December, everybody. Micah, Eric, and I are here this week to talk Fantastic Beasts and J.K. Rowling’s Wizarding World with you. How are you guys?

Eric Scull: Good. It’s always like coming home, taking off our jacket, and cuddling up into bed when we record.

Andrew: That’s what we did when we recorded in person in November last month.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: That’s true. I do miss you guys. Now that we’ve done that, I don’t think we can ever truly comfortably go back to separate sides of the continent type recording.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Let’s only do MuggleCast when we’re together now. [laughs]

Andrew: Recording those in person was a lot of fun; it’s too bad we can’t do that all the time. I was wired on coffee. We were just…

Micah: There was a lot of coffee.

Eric: I just kept giving you coffee. That was all it was.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: I was very tired from the night before. Today, we’re going to have a main discussion. Do you guys remember those? Main discussions?

Eric: Whoa, takes me back.

Andrew: Where we focus on a particular subject, because we have so much to talk about regarding Fantastic Beasts, and I think that’s what we’ll be doing in the weeks ahead. We’re going to be talking about the Obscurus.

Eric: Oooh.

Andrew: Arguably the biggest thing introduced to us by J.K. Rowling, the Obscurus. Very interestingly, J.K. Rowling has had that word around for a while, and we’re going to talk about that. This was sneaky like that.

Micah: Isn’t that part of…? What’s great about this, though, is the fact that we do have the opportunity now to look back on probably close to, what, 20 years of content and other things that are out there that we probably just glazed over. But it’s clear that J.K. Rowling had ideas that we clearly didn’t know about, but the clues are there.

Eric: Oh, yeah, she snuck ’em in. Yeah, right under our noses the whole time, which is true J.K. Rowling fashion.

Micah: I was just going to say, one of the other good things about being able to record this way is that our patrons are able to listen to us live. They’ve missed us. I’ve seen actual comments that say that they’re happy that we are now back doing it this way, as much fun as it was to record in person.

Andrew: Yeah. I also want to say thank you to everybody who listened to our last episode; that was our spoiler-filled episode, number 305. That was our biggest episode in years.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: I hadn’t even thought about… it was very surprising, but in a good way. I think a lot of people may have been searching iTunes, for example, to find some Harry Potter podcasts to listen to after seeing the movie, because there was so much to talk about. So thank you to everybody who listens, and welcome to any new listeners; I’m sure we have a few people who are going to start listening regularly now after maybe discovering us through our November episode, so it’s really great to be here with everybody going through… [laughs] we’re going to be going through a lot in the months and years ahead.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So before we do that, though, just a little announcement for our patrons; these are people who support us at Patreon.com/MuggleCast with either $2 pledges or $5 pledges. We will be hosting a holiday party later this month; we’re going to be doing something live on Google Hangouts, I believe, or YouTube or something, so stay tuned to that. We want to hang out with everybody online, and we’ll get everybody involved in a chat of some sort. Maybe a video chat. We’ll see. But we just want to thank all of our supporters, because after all, it is thanks to those people on Patreon that we’re doing two episodes a month.

Eric: Yeah, and this was the year that we launched our Patreon, so… I mean, our podcast has been around since 2005, but this was the year that we finally said, “Well, let’s give this a try,” and it’s been hugely successful. We’ve met a lot of really cool people who are proud to support us, and we’re proud to have them, and it’s just our way of saying thanks for a great year.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

Micah: Absolutely. And Andrew, you mentioned all the potential new listeners that are finding out about MuggleCast, and I know a lot of them like to go back and listen to older episodes, and I thought it was just important to briefly mention that there’s a little snafu with some of our older episodes, for people who are looking to go back and enjoy the very early days of the show, and we’re working to resolve it as quickly as possible. I know I saw a couple of people tweeting about that, so just hold tight, and we’ll let people know as soon as it’s resolved.

Eric: Yeah, if you’re on the MuggleCast website trying to click players on the first half of our episodes, they’re down; but we’re fixing them.

Andrew: Yeah. By the way, thanks to India for pointing out that iTunes currently right now on their podcast homepage, in their podcast store, they have a “For Harry Potter fans” section, and we’re one of the shows featured in there.

Eric: Ooh! Well, we’d better be. We’re Steve Jobs-approved. [laughs]

Andrew: I’m not sure why we’re last in the list, but…

Eric: I think chronology, because we were the first, right? It’s chronological. It’s got to be.

Andrew: Yeah, maybe. There you go.

Eric: [laughs] We’re Steve Jobs-approved, after all.

Andrew: Right, right.


News


Andrew: Anyway, so let’s talk a little news. We’re going to spread out some of the recent news over this episode and the next episode. Plus, there was some other news that we spoke about after Fantastic Beasts came out, and we recorded some bonus stuff on Patreon, so if you want to hear our thoughts on things like the confirmation of how Graves – or sorry, how Grindelwald – transformed into Graves for so long, we spoke about that. The producer revealed how that happened, so we spoke about that on Patreon. But this was really cute; are you guys Hamilton fans?

Eric: I very much respect Lin-Manuel Miranda and his great talent. The show itself is cool, but I just could never get tickets, so I haven’t seen it yet. But yes, I like Hamilton quite a lot.

Andrew: He’s fantastic on Twitter. He’s just very inspirational; I love following him. I’m not a Hamilton fan yet, but he’s great. He’s just very in touch with his followers and pop culture. So he was doing a list earlier this week, the “POP CULTURE EVENTS FROM WHICH I HAVE STILL NOT RECOVERED, MANY YEARS LATER.”

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: And one of them was this moment, this line from Half-Blood Prince: “‘I am not worried, Harry,’ said Dumbledore, his voice a little stronger despite the freezing water. ‘I am with you.'” And J.K. Rowling took notice of this – I think they follow each other on Twitter – and J.K. Rowling replied, “Cannot tell you what this means (from you), because this moment is one of my very favorites. Always feel Half-Blood Prince gets overshadowed by Deathly Hallows.” And then Lin-Manuel replied, Half-Blood Prince is my favorite precisely because of this reprise of Dumbledore’s ‘You are with me’ at the beginning. You’re deadly with a reprise, Maestro.”

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Yeah, this back and forth is really genius, like everything Lin does. Like you were saying, Andrew, very inspirational, very good feeling, very intelligent… and he’s a Harry Potter fan, which is great.

Andrew: Right. And the reason I wanted to talk about it was I thought it was interesting to hear J.K. Rowling say that she thinks Half-Blood Prince gets overshadowed by Deathly Hallows. Do we agree with her?

[Eric splutters]

Micah: Eric is guilty of that because he doesn’t like Deathly Hallows. [laughs]

Eric: No. No, I don’t. But yeah, what do you guys think? Are you guys guilty of overshadowing Half-Blood Prince by raving about Deathly Hallows? I don’t think so.

Micah: No, I don’t think so, either. Maybe she just means in the sense that it’s the final book, but I do think that so much can be taken out of Half-Blood Prince. And actually, one of my favorite characters is really introduced in that book, and that’s Horace Slughorn, who I have a feeling may make an appearance in one of – if not more than one of – the Fantastic Beasts films…

Eric: Oh, I hope so.

Micah: … particularly because of his tie to Tom Riddle, so I don’t feel that way. I actually really like Half-Blood Prince, I would say more so than Deathly Hallows.

Andrew: Yeah. I do think it has gotten overshadowed because of Deathly Hallows being the final one, but as I wrote in the article on Hypable, Half-Blood Prince is very important because so much happens that… this moment that they spoke about on Twitter, I mean, that was Dumbledore passing the torch to Harry.

Eric: Oh, yeah. You have the very important death of a mentor as the book concludes, but you also have not only the setup with the Horcruxes, we find out what’s going on for the first time, the amazing memory sequences… it’s also the last book that has a chance to be fun and happy before they go camping, before they’re really, really up against it, up against the world alone. So yeah, Half-Blood Prince… I guess I can guess what J.K. Rowling was saying, but I think critically, a lot of people would probably enjoy or say that they enjoy reading Half-Blood more.

Andrew: Yeah. India, who’s listening live via Patreon right now, she points out Jo has also said before that she considers Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows to be two halves of the same book. I do remember J.K. Rowling saying that.

Micah: Interesting.

Eric: That’s even weirder when you factor in that they split the last book into two films. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. I love the Half-Blood Prince movie, too. I need to reread that one, that book. It’s been a while.

Eric: It’s a good one.

Andrew: Anyway, so that was cool. Always love hearing J.K. Rowling reflect on her own books, the Harry Potter ones especially.

Eric: Yeah, I agree too. That was a good tweet.

Andrew: Here’s some exciting news for those of us in the United States: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is officially coming to Broadway in spring 2018.

Eric: Ooh!

Andrew: The producers are working with the Lyric Theatre, which is currently home to Cirque… Cirque Du… Cirque… Cirque Du Soleil.

Micah: Cirque Du Soleil.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: You got there eventually.

Andrew: Cirque Du Soleil Paramour show, not to be confused with Paramore the band.

Eric: Oh, it’s not like, a Cirque du Soleil and Paramore together combined…? Okay.

Andrew: No. That would be cool. I would probably go see that.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, so we don’t know when tickets are going to go on sale. I would assume if it’s spring 2018, then by the end of next year they’ll probably be on sale. Because the UK tickets, that show opened in June for previews, and tickets went on sale in October or November the previous year, so hopefully we’ll get that. Hopefully tickets will be on sale by this time next year. I know a lot of people will be anxious to make sure they get tickets, because it’s going to be hard.

Eric: The interesting thing about this story for me is that they’re actually renovating the theater that it’s going to be in, completely… what’s the word? I’m reading and quoting Hypable. The theater owner “plans a multi-million dollar renovation to completely transform, remodel, and reconfigure the 1,900 seat theater and turn it into a scaled down, more intimate playhouse, with approximately 1,500 seats.” They’re basically building the theater, renovating… multi-millions of dollars are going into this to customize it to the specifications of the director and the producer of the Cursed Child, which is crazy if you think about it.

Micah: That’s smart. Well, it may just not have the ability to contain magic, so it needs to be upgraded.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Well, at first I thought… well, yeah, that’s exactly it. And I’m sure this thing happens more often in New York than is publicized; you just gut theaters, add more seats… or actually, in this case, taking away seats, though. They’re taking it from 1,900 down to 1,500. And at first I was like, “Oh, great, so even fewer Americans can see this play.” But then I looked up the current theater, which is the Palace Theatre in London, and that only seats 1,400. So even after the renovations at this theater in New York, the American theater, which holds 1,500 people, will be bigger than the one in London, so at least then it’s okay. But yeah, just all of these renovations they’re planning to make it a specifically, a particularly good home for the play will be exciting. And I wonder if they won’t in fact add new elements to the play. Maybe they’ll try and get the owl back, Andrew, or something…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: They’d better.

Eric: … to try and make the play, I don’t know, a little different or special. It just seems like they’re really in the whole customization route with this play.

Andrew: Well, I mean, this theater, I’m sure, is willing to do anything to get the Cursed Child, because once you get the Cursed Child, you’re set for like, a decade at least.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Well, that was going to be one thing that I said, though, is that I’m sure whatever money that they’re putting into the renovations they will easily make back by hosting the Cursed Child, and I think, Andrew, that’s what you were alluding to there. But one other question that popped into my mind in seeing this story is does that mean that the Cursed Child will stop its performances over in the UK as of this time? And how does that work from a casting standpoint? Because are they planning to completely recast it here in the US?

Andrew: Yeah, I’ve seen people ask this a lot. First of all, I don’t think the UK cast is going to be coming over here, because by spring 2018, they’re going to be… they could be gone from the play. I mean, actors normally don’t last too long on plays, because they’re doing it night after night, and it’s just mentally… I mean, I’m not a theater expert, but I know it’s a lot of work to do this night after night. Plus, the Cursed Child is not leaving the Palace Theatre on London’s West End anytime soon; it’s staying there. So these two shows, I think, are going to be running simultaneously. I think it will be an all-new cast; that seems pretty… unless one of these actors really wants to move to New York [laughs] and is up for doing a bunch more shows.

Eric: Well, right, like Richard Griffiths and Dan Radcliffe did for Equus.

Andrew: Right, but a limited time thing. In the case of the Cursed Child, the plans are for it to obviously be there for a very long time. So I kind of hate to bring this up, but are they going to make Hermione white again? [laughs] And is that going to be a whole big thing?

Eric: Oh, God. I don’t know.

Andrew: And is Harry going to become Black? [laughs] It’ll be a big deal whoever they cast. I mean, I guess presumably, they’re going to use British actors.

Eric: I would hope so. Well, there are enough British actors working in New York and LA, though, these days.

Andrew: Maybe Dan Radcliffe will do it.

Eric: I hope so.

Andrew: [laughs] Can you imagine?

Eric: By 2018 he’ll be what, 31? 32-ish?

Andrew: I don’t know how old he is. I think he’s a little younger than me. He might be 27.

Eric: Maybe playing 36, though. Yeah, he could do it.

Andrew: Anyway, it’s great news because people here in the US really want to see it, but getting over to the UK is obviously a little difficult. And as we’ve spoken about before, as a script, the show just doesn’t come off that great, but it really is great to see. Eric and Micah, I’m surprised you two haven’t tried to go and see it.

Micah: In London?

Eric: Flights. Just going to blame flights. My broomstick broke.

Andrew: Flights are actually pretty cheap right now, thanks to Brexit.

Eric: [laughs] Well, I will say this, I will make effort to see it when it’s in New York. It’s a lot easier for me to get to New York from here.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: And I have, multiple times. I saw DanRad in How to Succeed, I saw it again when Darren Criss did it, and I saw Rupert Grint in a play with Matthew Broderick. So yeah, I mean, New York is definitely a lot easier to get to for me. And Micah, I can’t imagine you would say differently.

Micah: Yeah, it’s a challenge for me to get to New York, so I don’t know if I’ll be able to see it.

Eric: [laughs] From Long Island?

Micah: Yeah, exactly.

Andrew: I’ll definitely see it once it… I mean, I’ll try to get tickets just like… we’ll all try to get tickets. We’ll go together. We’ll record in person again.

Micah: We’ll get tickets. I’m not worried about it.

Eric: Are we going to be Wormtaily? Are we going to release spoilers the night before?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Wormtaily is back for revenge.

Eric: “Keep the secrets again.”

Andrew: [laughs] Spoiling it two years later. So we’ll keep everybody posted on that. I just wanted to also note – this is a minor thing – for those of you in the Los Angeles area, Wizarding World of Harry Potter; they’re now serving hot butterbeer. This is something I’ve been…

Eric: Did you get some?

Andrew: No, because parking is still $18, and I still don’t love it. [laughs]

Eric: Oh my God, Andrew, how long have we been talking to you about this? Hot butterbeer, it’s the best butterbeer there is. You still don’t have it?

Andrew: Practically smell it from my rooftop.

Micah: Maybe it’s just a little too warm still out in LA, right?

Eric: [laughs] That’s what it is.

Andrew: No, it’s been cooler. But yeah, so they added it recently. I am excited to try it. They also, about a week ago, got rid of the 3-D in Harry Potter and the Forbidden Journey.

Eric: Wait, what?

Micah: How does that work? Isn’t that part of the ride?

Andrew: How does that work? Well…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So here’s what happened: So Harry Potter and the Forbidden Journey in Orlando was not 3-D.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: But for whatever reason for the Hollywood park, they decided to make that one 3-D. I guess they just thought it’d be cooler or something. Well, a lot of people, myself included, do not like it in 3-D. I find the ride nauseating without the 3-D in Orlando. So you try it here in Hollywood, and you have to wear these glasses which darken the images that you’re supposed to be looking at, so the videos look like crap. The 3-D is not good. You’re being thrown all around while you’re in these 3-D environments, and that’s nauseating. The past couple of times I’ve been on it, I just go through it with my eyes closed. It’s not fun. So I think they got a lot of feedback about it, and yeah, they got rid of the 3-D, which is weird. And I guess they’re kind of transitioning it right now trying to make it look better in 2-D.

Eric: That is very interesting. I mean, because the Forbidden Journey… I thought they made it in 3-D in California, because it was sort of a compromise because they didn’t have Escape from Gringotts, which is 3-D in Florida. But I mean, the other thing about Forbidden Journey is there’s real life 3-D things, right? A Dementor, a spider that actually come out at you, right? Do they still have that in California?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, all that’s there, the physical stuff.

Eric: So it’s weird to have both digital 3-D and real 3-D elements that are coming out at you. It would have been kind of weird to see it under your glasses, like you’re saying.

Micah: And doesn’t the…? Is it the Dementor or the spider that spit water on you?

Eric: The spiders, right?

Andrew: Is it still there? Yeah, I think so. I don’t go on it. I don’t like the ride. [laughs]

Eric: Well, yeah, it’s just a shame because that is the only… is that the only ride? Or do they have the hippogriff as well in California?

Andrew: They have the hippogriff ride, but that one is like, 20 seconds long.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: This is why I don’t go!

Micah: See, I don’t like that ride. That ride makes me nauseous.

Andrew: Oh, really?

Eric: Are you sure you don’t mean Dueling Dragons? Because that one…

Micah: No, no, I’ve never gone on the Dueling Dragons.

Eric: Well, that’s even worse.

Andrew: Anne – and I should explain this – Anne is saying in the livestream, “Andrew’s logic: ‘Go on a ride that makes me sick just to close my eyes during the whole ride.'”

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Here’s the thing: I’m peer pressured into going onto it. I have no choice. I’m there with people, so I’ve got to go on it. But there have been a couple of times where I just say, “I’ll sit this one out. You guys have fun.” [laughs]

Eric: “I’ll go through this single rider line.” Yeah, that’s the whole thing. The line experience, it’s still a good environment, right? When you go and get butterbeer – which Andrew doesn’t because of parking – it’s a great social thing.

Andrew: Yeah. Oh, it’s cool to hang out there. I’m going to try to go before I leave.

Eric: You’ve got to do it before they sell out. They’re going to sell out of hot butterbeer because it’s going to be the hit, because it’s so good.

Andrew: No, no.

Micah: Well, because you just mentioned it on the show. That’s clearly…

Andrew: Maybe I’ll go today.

Eric: You’ve got to race our listeners. [laughs]

Andrew: The other problem is the park closes at like, 6:00 p.m. most nights. They don’t even keep it open late, so it’s hard to get over there. Ugh. Anyway, let’s move on.

Micah: Look, you’ve got to make some changes over there, Andrew; they’re clearly not running a tight ship.

Andrew: They’re really not. [laughs]

Micah: They’re failing the wizarding world. But maybe this is something we can discuss at a later time on another episode, but just the general talk about the theme parks: I’m wondering when we can anticipate some sort of announcement about changes coming in. And I assume that they would be related to Orlando, not to LA, but I feel like it’s been a while since we’ve gotten really any news related to the theme park, and we know how big of a cash cow it is for Universal. I can’t imagine that they’re not going to look to continue to enhance, expand, and do some things that would continue to make people want to come down there and hold conventions there and do all sorts of things, so I’m anticipating a 2017 announcement of some kind.

Andrew: Okay, yeah. Well, we can talk about that on our next episode, because we are going to talk about what’s ahead for Harry Potter fans in 2017 in Episode 307, appropriately.

Eric: Our year in review.

Andrew: Yeah. Anyway, Eric, you have a story.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: You insisted we talk about this. Micah and I said no. But Eric wants to, so we’re going to make fun of him for it when he talks about it. Go ahead.

Eric: There is a… so if you follow J.K. Rowling on Twitter, which everybody but Micah used to do… and now Micah does, too, right? You follow her, right, Micah? Now?

Micah: I do, yeah.

Andrew: Finally.

Eric: It was a big thing. Okay. There was this tweet she replied to; basically, there’s this new species of spider which was discovered, and people who discovered it realized that it looks a lot like the Sorting Hat in Harry Potter. So the people who discovered it also have the… I mean, this is how it works in science and biology. You discover a new species, you get to name it. And my Latin nomenclature is a little rusty, so forgive me if I pronounce this wrong, but the new species of spider is called Eriovixia Gryffindori, Gryffindori being, of course, the nod to Harry Potter, because it was Godric Gryffindor’s Sorting Hat that this spider looks like in this photo. And so J.K. Rowling tweeted back to Curio Critters, @curiocritters on Twitter, saying that she was truly honored, and she congratulated them on discovering what she called “another fantastic beast.” And in emojis she pointed to a spider and did little magic stars next to it, and so she has decided that this spider, which is a real world thing, Eriovixia Gryffindori, is a fantastic beast.

Andrew: Okay, well, A., that’s not canon.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I don’t care if she says it on Twitter. That doesn’t make it canon.

Eric: Of course it does!

Andrew: No, no. She was joking. And B., yeah, I guess the thing looks like a Sorting Hat, but if… I mean, good. They discovered a new creature. That’s great.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Eric, we’re not desperate for Harry Potter stories anymore. We’ve got Fantastic Beasts to talk about; we don’t need to talk about spiders that look like hats.

Eric: But you admit it looks like a hat. It looks like the Sorting Hat.

Andrew: From this angle, yes, it looks like a hat. From any other angle, it probably doesn’t.

Eric: I think they got a very good picture of it. And actually, so here’s a little bit of detail on the spider. This isn’t just an empty, filling time on the podcast news story, I swear it, okay? It says the reason this spider takes the shape of a magical hat is to camouflage itself to resemble a dried leaf during the daytime to protect itself from predators. So again, it’s more of this survival aspect thing, but it’s totally real, and the person who named it was a very fond Harry Potter fan growing up and said that he was very affected.

Andrew: [laughs] All right, well, and he caught the attention of J.K. Rowling, so that’s good.

Eric: Yeah, his name is Javed Ahmed, so good going, guy.

Micah: So if you want to see this spider in person, you can travel to India, and…

Eric: Yeah, Mumbai. It said somewhere in that area.

Micah: The Kans forest of Karnataka.

Eric: There you go.

Micah: That’s my only contribution to that story.

Andrew: Let’s move on.

Eric: Thank you, guys. I’m so… thank you for indulging me.

Andrew: Before recording, Micah was like, “I refuse to talk about this.”

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: And I held out for pretty much all but five seconds of that conversation.

Eric: You did great. Thank you so much.

Andrew: Give us something you want to talk about, Micah.


Main Discussion: Post-Fantastic Beasts theorizing


Micah: All right, well, speaking of Fantastic Beasts, we framed this week’s discussion similar to how we really used to theorize about different things. It really does kind of, as Eric said earlier, take us back to when we were talking about Half-Blood Prince, right? And that’s when the show really started, was following the release, I should say, of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince.

Eric: Yeah, the first 100 episodes.

Micah: And a lot of discussion and theorizing went on as to the events that took place in that book, and then of course, what we could all expect in Deathly Hallows. So we know that this has been a big discussion point; we’ve seen a lot of articles and tweets and posts and all sorts of things come through about Ariana Dumbledore and whether or not she is an Obscurus, which was introduced to us in the first Fantastic Beasts film. And the quote was – I believe it’s from Newt – “an Obscurus creates an unstable, uncontrollable, dark force inside the child. Like a parasite, it would drain the child’s power, and ultimately, their life force.” And I think a lot of people naturally went to the conclusion upon hearing this, and upon learning about Credence in this film, that Ariana was in fact an Obscurus. And her story, at least what we know about it from Aberforth and from what we have in terms of passages from Deathly Hallows, seems to align. But we’ll jump into that, I’m sure, as well as what it means for the future – or technically, the past – in terms of the relationship between Dumbledore and Grindelwald and what Ariana being an Obscurus could have meant to the falling out between the two of them, and ultimately, her death. So any initial thoughts there?

Andrew: Well, I do love that this is one of the elements that J.K. Rowling is sliding in slowly. I think that everybody is right; it just all lines up too perfectly. This could play into future Fantastic Beasts movies. We can… first of all, I think the phrase “Fantastic Beast” could very well relate to the Obscurus. An Obscurus is, in a way, a fantastic beast, so for people wondering, “Well, how could they keep calling it Fantastic Beasts?” That’s one way they could get away with it. But yeah, I think everybody’s right here, and I loved… one of my favorite elements of the movie was J.K. Rowling introducing this new form of magic that we in many ways have not heard about before, but we have; it’s just we didn’t know what the name of it was.

Micah: Right. And I like what you’re saying there in terms of the Obscurus being the fantastic beast, and really the first movie was about where to find it, and I wonder if that’s going to be the common thread that we see throughout the next several movies, if in fact the title holds true.

Eric: Yeah, I mean, there are multiple shades of… I mean, the title is not going to be just about one beast. But I like that the film – and I believe we said this when we were contemplating this for a little bit, when we were all together – was the film is about the beast within us. And in the Obscurus, you have this beast that grows and feeds like a parasite, and the fact that, or the possibility that, we already knew what the symptoms were in Ariana, without knowing the cause – now the cause has been revealed – is very exciting, and I think it will take the forefront. I think it’s very clear because of Grindelwald’s appearance in this film, and how big it was and how important it was that he was terrorizing Europe, as well as what the producers and directors have all said in interviews, that Dumbledore will become a major player. And it seems like it was always meant to happen this way, where Dumbledore has some personal stakes, and I think it’s very clear that J.K. Rowling is intending it to be Ariana.

Micah: Right. And so I think that if you look towards the quotes from Aberforth that we mentioned earlier, it gives a little bit of history in terms of what initially happened to Ariana, and then we can go from there.

Eric: Sure.

Micah: So the quote is, “When my sister was six years old, she was attacked by three Muggle boys. They’d seen her doing magic, spying through the back garden hedge. She was a kid, she couldn’t control it, no witch or wizard can at that age. What they saw scared them, I expect. They forced their way through the hedge, and when she couldn’t show them the trick, they got a bit carried away trying to stop the little freak doing it… It destroyed her, what they did: She was never right again. She wouldn’t use magic, but she couldn’t get rid of it; it turned inward and drove her mad, it exploded out of her when she couldn’t control it, and at times she was strange and dangerous. But mostly she was sweet and scared and harmless.”

Eric: Yeah, that’s very clear. [laughs] “Exploded out of her,” it “turned inward,” “she couldn’t use it, couldn’t get rid of it.” This sounds exactly like an Obscurus.

Andrew: It’s pretty close. It’s not right on the nose.

Micah: And we see in Credence there’s a real hesitancy on his part to use magic just given who his adoptive family is and what their feelings are towards the wizarding community, whereas with Ariana, I feel like she probably would have grown up to be a perfectly capable and able witch had this situation not occurred, and her interaction with these three Muggles just completely caused something to happen to her that she decided that she can no longer use magic. And I feel like this would be something very disturbing to see on screen if we actually go back and in time to see what was in fact done to her, because I know we’ve had conversations in prior episodes even about this particular situation and what we could compare it to in “the real world.” It has elements of rape; I think we’ve discussed that. And what’s happened to her is she’s internalizing everything that’s going on to the point where she can’t control her reactions to different things, and we know that one of these outbursts seemingly resulted in the death of her mother.

Eric: Yeah, and her father went crazy and basically attacked these Muggle boys. Mr. Dumbledore, Albus’s father, Albus and Aberforth and Ariana’s father, was put into Azkaban for basically revenge attacking these young boys for what they did to his daughter, and it’s very intense. I mean, this one incident that not only permanently disfigures Ariana and later causes her death, but leads to a firm dismembering of the Dumbledore family… it’s a huge event, and it seems to my mind now completely absurd that J.K. Rowling wouldn’t go into greater detail. The way that it’s presented in Book 7 is it’s a subplot, right? That Harry may not be able to trust Dumbledore, so this whole Dumbledore backstory is all about how Dumbledore was flawed and only human after all, and it’s color but there’s so much else in there you don’t get a lot of time to focus on it. With the Fantastic Beasts coming out, and it’s going to be about Grindelwald and Dumbledore and whatever Newt’s relationship is to the two of them, you have a lot of opportunity now to explore this story in greater detail, so I just think it’s really quite brilliant that she’s given us something that is very clearly… without directly stating, it is very clearly relating to those events, and it’s an absolute in for her to explain this and explore what happened between Dumbledore, Grindelwald, Ariana, the boys, their dad, everything, all in the course of the next couple films.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: When I… this line from Aberforth is interesting: “It destroyed her, what they did: She was never right again.” How can we put this in the context of Credence? Is this when…? At what point would this be in Credence’s timeline?

Micah: I think it’s his entire upbringing for him.

Eric: Yeah, the reason it’s not a specific moment in the film is because Credence is an exception in the film. His whole role is he’s an Obscurus, right? But he’s also an adult, and there are no adult Obscurials. There just aren’t. Newt says the other one that he met in Sudan was 10, and it was killing her. And it did kill her when he removed it, but she was dying. There are no children that survive this. And so it would have been Credence when he was much younger, whatever his… however soon or quickly he was able to be adopted into this non-wizard family, but I think it’s because of whatever happened to his mom, right? The lady – I’m forgetting her name – the crazy lady in Fantastic Beasts who was his adoptive mother talked about how his mother was a witch.

Andrew: Mary Lou.

Eric: Yeah, Mary Lou, thank you. And I think that it was a traumatic childhood event that caused him to basically deny who he was, but he somehow… just like Queenie is a superb Legilimens, Credence was so superb that this Obscurus didn’t kill him, and he was able to gain control over, which is something that no other Obscurus had ever done before. So I think it was young – to answer your question – a young Credence would have been very much the way Ariana was, having outbursts that can’t be contained.

Micah: I think it also depends, too, at what point – and they may say this in the movie and I’m just not remembering – that Credence was adopted, because to me what…

Andrew: Adopted by… well, Mary Lou, yeah, that’s not her actual son.

Micah: Right, that’s what I’m saying; when Mary Lou adopted Credence, and then Credence had to fall in line with the belief system, so that is when he really began to internalize a lot of what he was feeling and what he knew to be true about himself. I feel like in Ariana’s case, she was so young that it’s almost like it was forced upon her to internalize, and maybe it’s the memories she has of what took place at the hands of these three Muggle boys that keeps her magic in check, or maybe her magic was never even allowed to evolve properly the way it’s supposed to because of what was done to her. I think there’s probably varying degrees of Obscurials in terms of how they manifest themselves. I would think it depended upon the situations that they’re in, and I think that… and suppression of magic, I mean, I think there’s definite parallels to our world, let’s say, in terms of suppression of different things. So the fact that she sort of…

Eric: Especially during… going into World War II, right?

Micah: Absolutely.

Eric: I mean, especially suppression of Jewish, of homosexual, of all of that stuff that goes into the World War II Nazi regime. It’s a complete and utter parallel, I think, very intentional and timely in the way… even though it is the darker part of the movie, it’s extremely relevant and important and very interesting that Jo has found a way to make something completely her own, or that is a parallel that exists so firmly in the wizarding world that goes on along. And the interesting thing with me, though, or for me, is the Obscurial or Obscurus, as soon as Newt says it, right? He’s like, “I recognize the marks; it’s totally an Obscurus.” Everybody in that room, the entire International Confederation of Wizards that’s there, including Seraphina Picquery, is like, “That’s impossible. There hasn’t been an Obscurus in centuries.” And Newt does his job and says, “Oh, I saw one last week” or whatever, but they’re so shocked and surprised and in denial that… because we know that America in the 1920s is such a horrible place for wizards; they deny who they are, they hide in secret… I’m actually surprised Obscuruses aren’t more common. I think that that’s the question I would ask J.K. Rowling right now, is why aren’t they just completely more common? If you’re living in this horrible place that makes you deny who you are, why doesn’t it happen more often? That’s kind of my whole thing, but they…

Micah: I don’t think there’s a mass denial, though, of the wizarding community believing in who they are. I think that there are examples of situations in the case of Credence, where you have a young man who has been adopted by a woman who is crazier than a shithouse rat, to borrow a term from you, Eric, that you’ve used many times…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: … and so he’s forced into this situation where he has to truly hide who he is, and we know the result and how it plays itself out. And to tie it back to Ariana’s situation, I don’t think that we’re going to find that the relationship to Grindelwald for both Credence and Ariana are all that different. Who knows if the friendship that developed between Dumbledore and Grindelwald was ever really based in any sort of true friendship? Maybe it was just his desire for power and seeing what an Obscurus could do for him, or multiple Obscurials could do for him, in his quest for power. He found that in Ariana; now, how he comes to know about her existence, maybe it’s just by chance. Maybe it’s more than that. Maybe there’s other people out there who know about Ariana and her situation, but I tend to think that there’s definitely underlying motives here for Grindelwald, and it’s certainly a precursor, I believe, to why he goes in search of Credence in America.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Michael, who’s listening live via Patreon right now, he agrees with you guys. He says, “It’s the biggest thing that doesn’t make sense, in my opinion,” regarding why aren’t there more Obscurials? “Why don’t we know about more of them? What about Muggle-borns who just are never found by the magical community? Wouldn’t they become Obscurials?” That’s a good point too.

Eric: Maybe.

Andrew: I mean, to play devil’s advocate, maybe J.K. Rowling [laughs] does have all this in mind, and she is going to tell us about the Obscurial community, I guess you could say. And maybe they got it more in control in the decades that followed the events of Fantastic Beasts.

Eric: Sure, especially after people die. The other thing is that J.K. Rowling has taken care to make sure that in the case of those Muggle-borns, right, it was proposed that maybe there’s just a bunch of Muggle-borns who were never found, but we know from Harry’s own experience getting his Hogwarts letter, the Hogwarts letter finds you. The wizarding world take great care to make sure that you are informed about who you are. Now, back in the ’40s, we know that Dumbledore has to go to Tom Riddle himself. Maybe it used to not be so easy with the owl post to go and inform wizards that they were wizards, but you still get the sense that they’re specifically trying to prevent a Muggle-born or somebody who’s not expected to have magic or who has no parents to tell them who and what they are. You kind of have to, otherwise something like this develops. So maybe that’s why you have the Hogwarts letter happening on your 11th birthday, because by then, surely you would have noticed some things were off. But it’s right when you’re ready to be taken in and then shown the way, so I don’t know. I don’t know if the timeline works out because if Obscuruses usually kill their hosts before age 10, then it’s usually a much bigger issue and the Hogwarts letter wouldn’t prevent that, so the math didn’t work out for me just then.

Andrew: Let’s read some feedback here from people. This is from… we asked people on Patreon. This was a question for patrons to contribute to this week’s episode. We said, “How could Ariana’s death/Dumbledore play into future Fantastic Beasts films as it pertains to Grindelwald?” Cody said, “For sure. With everything we know about Obscuruses now, plus the Grindelwald connection, I think it’s a very safe bet. Also, the reaction the International Confederation had when Newt told them that what killed Shaw was an Obscurus and how MACUSA handled Credence at the end of the movie shows why the Dumbledores would have wanted to keep Ariana’s condition a secret.”

Eric: That’s a good point, Cody. They reacted in fear and tried to kill it.

Andrew: So do we think in future Fantastic Beasts movies we’re going to jump back in time?

Eric: That’s the question, isn’t it? Because the question is whether or not Graves first learned about Obscuruses because of Ariana and maybe through his correspondence with Dumbledore, or whether that’s yet to happen. It’s so unclear to me what age Dumbledore was, what age Grindelwald was, when the events with Ariana occurred, or at least the initial inciting event. And then years later, of course, is a big confrontation where there’s… is it a duel? Dumbledore’s nose gets broken and Ariana dies? Or one of those happens at a funeral. Maybe at her funeral Dumbledore’s nose gets broken. I get the events all confused; I need to reread Deathly Hallows again. But it’s unclear to me whether or not J.K. Rowling is intending to still show maybe even the initial attack on Ariana, or whether… because I like to assume they were all children at the time, that it was an event in the past. But it’s sort of muddy what the timeline is, whether or not that’s what drove Graves to America, or whether it was something else. But I like to believe that it was Dumbledore…

Micah: Well, not Graves. Grindelwald.

Eric: Yeah, Grindelwald, sorry. Same thing. So Grindelwald discovered Ariana; obviously, she was too weak to be utilized, so he goes in search of another example and is like, “Oh, America is a really terrible place; I’m sure I’ll find somebody suppressing magic there because it’s so horrible.”

Micah: I don’t know if it’s a situation where she was too weak. I think that he tried to utilize her and that’s what resulted in the duel between Dumbledore and Grindelwald and Aberforth, and then there was that spell that hit her and killed her. I think that that’s where the falling out between these two ultimately begins. And so I think there is a chance that you go back in time and we get this moment shown to us; I don’t think you get the same effect in terms of a conversation that’s being had, let’s say between Dumbledore and Newt, where Newt learns about what’s happened to Dumbledore sister. Or perhaps Newt is already aware of this. I think another question to ask is how does Newt factor into this whole storyline? Because he clearly knows about Obscurials and what they are, and maybe Ariana is the first time that he really learns about what this “fantastic beast” really is. I mean, I wouldn’t classify… she’s a person, not a beast, so I think that’s a little weird to refer to her that way, but…

Andrew: Well, we’re going to talk about this in bonus MuggleCast today, actually, for patrons, because we found out this week that Newt’s brother was searching for Grindelwald, so that could explain how Newt is going to have a further role in this series.

Eric: But also, the beasts… you’re right, though, Micah, too, that there’s this inherent knowledge… Newt, it was recently said somewhere else, he’s the foremost authority on everything beasts; he’s the only one who cares enough about these beasts to be the first person… it’s even shown in this movie when Tina is like, “Oh, you’re writing a book? Is it to exterminate them? To kill them?” And he’s like, “No, it’s to protect them.” Newt is the first one who cares, so I think it’s his own passion that really ingratiates Dumbledore to him, or the other way around. Dumbledore, who knows a lot about being very unique and the unique aspects of the wizarding world – he’s discovered dragon’s blood, all this other stuff – is taken to Newt, and I think he includes Newt in some of his research. Much like he does Harry with the Horcruxes, I think he does Newt with either the situation with his sister or something like that. I think it’d be very interesting.

Micah: That’s a fair point. I think from a timing standpoint, though, we’re clearly past these events already having taken place, right?

Eric: It’s true.

Micah: Dumbledore is already working at Hogwarts. Grindelwald is already on the run as a major… I don’t know, convict.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: But also, to your point, maybe you’re right, though; maybe Dumbledore is the one who sends Newt to Africa to find this Obscurus. Maybe he’s developed sort of this passion to protect those that are like his sister was.

Eric: Maybe that’s why Newt gets kicked out of Hogwarts, is because he has to go on a secret mission to stop Grindelwald, and it’s just a convenient way to get him out of the public’s eye.

Micah: Maybe. It’s still clear that there was a creature involved and somebody died, right?

Eric: I bet it was Aragog. [laughs] Oh, wait, that hasn’t happened yet.

Micah: Aragog’s great-great-great-great-great grandfather.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Well, no, it’s only like, 12 years difference, because 1940… wait, no. Wait, the events of the Chamber of Secrets will happen during the timespan of these Fantastic Beasts films. From what J.K. Rowling said, it will end with the confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald in 1945, and the Chamber of Secrets was opened in 1942, so you’ll have Tom Riddle, young, blaming Hagrid for the opening of the Chamber of Secrets, and Aragog. And Aragog, by the way, came to Hagrid in the pocket of a traveler, which is totally going to be Newt, based on the quote from Chamber of Secrets. It’s totally going to be Newt, by the way.

Andrew: Yeah, I guess that adds up.

Eric: But yeah, it’s just so weird how tied in to the central…

Micah: A “traveler,” though; I mean, that’s a very generic way to, I guess, try and get away with it later on.

Andrew: It is.

Eric: Well, Newt is a traveler; he goes to safaris and he’s across the world. If Newt is anything, it’s a traveler.

Micah: I guess you’re right, then. I guess it’s not Aragog’s great-great-great-great-great… it could be his father, for all we know. I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, totally. So I think that the Newt/Dumbledore stuff is… it’s going to be clear to us at all, I think, as a guess because of this Obscurus thing, the way that she really main-staged this thing which I believe very firmly is going on with Dumbledore’s sister. It’ll become clear that Newt was really centerstage the entire Harry Potter story; he had his hands in pies. He was the guy who gave Hagrid Aragog, he was the guy who helped Dumbledore with his sister and help defeat Grindelwald… Newt is sort of the hidden gem of the Harry Potter series, it’s going to turn out to be. [laughs]

Micah: Right. Well, and especially because… and I apologize, because I can’t remember who I saw tweet this, and I think it’s a really great thought and probably other people have come up with it as well, but that Fawkes could have been given to Dumbledore by Newt as well.

Eric: And we know Dumbledore has a very special connection with Fawkes. It’s almost telepathic.

Andrew: That would be very cool. That would be very cool if Newt gave him Fawkes. So we have some other feedback here, but I feel like we’ve said most of what people wanted to say, right? Was there anything in here in particular, Micah, that we should mention? Amber, Katy, Sophia, Lindsay, and Cullen all submitted some stuff…

Micah: Along with a bunch of other people.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, of course, but these were the people we were going to read. But I think everybody seems to be in agreement here that she is probably an Obscurus, and I see this playing into future Fantastic Beasts movies explaining why Dumbledore wants to fight Grindelwald. And then Newt will tie in there somehow as well in a way that is still to be seen.

Micah: Right.

Andrew: He could be, like, the ultimate controller of the Obscurus.

Eric: [laughs] The Obscurus whisperer.

Andrew: Yeah, or just being able to help contain them. I mean, we know he can contain one in a case.

Micah: And what did…? Somebody I saw J.K. Rowling respond to that an Obscurus is like a baby Dementor?

Eric: Oh, she loved that theory. It was crazy. Somebody just tweeted at her and was like, “Hey, friend of mine is thinking that a baby Dementor is an Obscurus,” and she was like, “I love this idea. Winky winky.”

Micah: [laughs] Winky winky?

Eric: I don’t think it was ever… yeah, she did two little winky face emojis.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Eric: I think. I’m looking for the tweet right now, but I can’t find it. But it was totally just like that.

Andrew: I would also like to see a flashback to the night of Ariana’s death because I think that’d be a great treat for Harry Potter fans.

Eric: Me too, but they’d have to get Jamie Campbell Bower to play young Grindelwald. You can’t have Johnny Depp play young Grindelwald. You’ve got to have Jamie.

Andrew: No, that’s true. Well, maybe they don’t get Jamie, but yes, I see your point. Maybe we shouldn’t have Johnny Depp do it. Two other interesting things worth talking about: So the original Fantastic Beasts book, it is “published,” quote unquote, it’s fictionally published by a book company publisher called Obscurus Books.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So this “Obscurus” term has actually been around right in front of us since 2001, when J.K. Rowling originally published Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them and Quidditch Through the Ages.

Eric: I mean, boom, right? This is the epic boom of J.K. Rowling hiding something in plain sight, her brilliance at foreshadowing, at casting a fishing line so far into the past, and hooking us without knowing. It’s unbelievable.

Andrew: So you could be a Negative Nancy and be like, “Oh, she just… okay, she didn’t have the concept for an Obscurial/Obscurus set a decade ago, but she did come up with this word a decade ago, and she just found it and was like, ‘Oh, let me call it Obscurus.'” [laughs]

Eric: No, there’s very much a reason why Newt chooses that to be the name of his publishing company.

Andrew: Is it Newt’s publishing company? So that’s another question.

Eric: It’s got to be. Well, because otherwise… the thing is, it is kind of a dark name, right? It’s like naming your publishing company Horcrux Books. So when Hermione says, “Accio Horcrux books,” the publishing company gets ripped from its foundation in Diagon Alley, flies through Hermione’s dorm room, and into her magical purse. But yeah, it’s a dark word. It’s a dark term.

Micah: No, see, I would argue the opposite. I would say it would be a nod to Ariana, to Credence, to others that he’s come across, because these are kids. These are not kids with evil intent. I would almost see it as a way of honoring them.

Andrew: Yeah. That’s a great idea.

Eric: I like that a lot. But it is a dark creature, isn’t it? I mean, there’s a bad connotation.

Micah: Yeah, absolutely, but I’m trying to keep it positive.

Eric: Yeah. No, I absolutely love your idea.

Andrew: So and this Obscurus Books term/Obscurus has appeared in other areas as well. Friend of the show/always have to mention him, apparently, Cullen said that Obscurus Books is actually in Diagon Alley the theme park, too.

Eric: What?

Andrew: Yeah, there’s a sign that says it. I don’t have a picture, but he says it’s there. And from googling… I’m pretty sure it’s in one of those PlayStation games, like Book of Spells or something as well, so it’s a well known… and by the way, Obscurus Books is in Diagon Alley. It’s a shop in Diagon Alley, both the theme park and in canon. Obviously, if it’s in the theme park. But so if you google image search “Obscurus Books,” you’ll see shots of Diagon Alley from the PlayStation game. And yeah, the cover of Fantastic Beasts, the original cover where it says “Obscurus Books.” And by the way, the Obscurus Books logo – not that this may mean anything – but the “O” is replaced by a moon.

Eric: A half-moon.

Andrew: A half-moon. What does it mean?

Eric: Half-moon spectacles. It’s Dumbledore again.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: Maybe this is what Leta Lestrange does after Hogwarts. She sells Newt’s books. She’s the main proprietor.

Micah: I think that this is… we’re going to have a lot of these types of discussions, I feel like, in the coming months, years even, as we learn more about this story, because I feel like a lot of this stuff is going to be tied back in that… and both of you touched on this earlier; it’s all been there underneath our nose, so to speak, for years, for decades. And J.K. Rowling has always been masterful at weaving it all together in a way that we’re still shocked, we’re still stunned, and that’s what makes us all so much fun, I think, too.

Andrew: Yeah, I mean, there’s so many elements like this – Obscurus, Leta, Grindelwald – so many things open-ended that she introduced in this movie, and yet it didn’t feel like it was just a setup movie. It felt very complete, I thought.

Eric: And nobody was asking about, “Oh, Obscurus Books, Newt’s publishing company.” Nobody was asking about that when… like, “That’s the one question I most want answered out of Harry Potter‘s seven books: What was Obscurus?” Nobody knew this. It was hidden in plain sight. We didn’t understand that these were the questions to ask. It’s crazy.

Andrew: Yeah. And then this is kind of unofficial confirmation about Ariana and the Obscurus…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … on December 1, Pottermore wrote a new piece about Ariana Dumbledore. Basically, it’s a recap of her history. It’s called “The Mysterious Life and Death of Ariana Dumbledore.” So this was published like, two weeks after Fantastic Beasts came out. It just… the timing to release this right after Fantastic Beasts comes out, after all the speculation online about Ariana being an Obscurus, it just seems to be Pottermore’s little wink at the community. They don’t mention an Obscurus in here, but they quote Aberforth, the quotes we read from Aberforth earlier in this episode. Yeah, it’s just basically a recap of Ariana, so that’s basically…

Micah: Unofficial confirmation.

Andrew: They’re watching. Yeah, they know what’s going on. [laughs]

Micah: And what’s really interesting is that throughout all the different comments that people have left, and tweets, I haven’t seen one person say the opposite or that they they don’t believe that this is true, or it’s just a red herring or anything like that. I’m sure there’s probably some people out there that think that way, but I’ve never seen such a strong consensus amongst Potter fans that this is definitely what we’re going to get, or what we’re going to learn, if not in the next film, definitely in future films.

Andrew: It matches up, and as of right now, there’s no reason not to think this is the case.

Eric: It’s just so funny because of the hints that were dropped. It’s finally reached a tipping point on this particular mystery. What other mysteries lay completely hidden in plain sight in Harry Potter, right, that she’s just going to pull…? She’s going to drop the shoe and we’re going to see, “Oh my God,” pull the curtain back and we’ll see. Just like my theory on Aragog and all this other stuff, I think that it’s in the text, it’s hidden. And just to get into conspiracy theory territory, we’re talking about Obscurus Books having a physical storefront or a sign pointing to it in the theme park, that J.K. Rowling… we know that she convinced Heyman and Yates to put Ariana Dumbledore and Aberforth even in Deathly Hallows – Part 2, that they could have easily been cut, because frankly, there’s a lot of stuff that gets cut when you adapt those books. But that they were still important enough to show… and I kind of feel like Ariana, who’s only in Deathly Hallows – Part 2 as a portrait for like, five seconds, is in that movie because that’s a story that was going to eventually get told one day, and that it mattered enough to be in that film so that it could be in future films. And J.K. Rowling has got to send notes to Stuart Craig and is like, “This is what you have to put in Diagon Alley, because it’s relevant to the greater wizarding world, these stories; not the stories we have told, but the stories that will be told,” that it’s all prepped for some massive future Harry Potter huge story that’s coming our way.

Andrew: [emotionally] It’s all so beautiful. Let’s start looking through Quidditch Through the Ages now. Figure out what we’re missing there.

Eric: [laughs] That’s the one where it’s just like, “Oh, what’s going to be relevant?”

Andrew: Katy says, “The only reason for me not to think it is that it would contradict Grindelwald’s belief that all Obscurials are 10 or younger,” in terms of Ariana being an Obscurial.

Eric: Well, she was that age.

Micah: Yeah, there was one person who made the comment, I think, that Ariana was slightly older. I think she was 14 when she died, if the math was correct.

Eric: She is a Dumbledore, though.

Micah: She is a Dumbledore. And we also know that Credence was above the age of 10 as well, and it’s possible. Let’s remember that in the case of somebody like Newt, he may not want to talk about Ariana. Maybe it’s information that he has, and he’s not going to say, “Oh, I knew another Obscurus that was older than she should have been.”

Eric: That’s true too.

Micah: But yeah, I mean, I think there’s probably some more to look into from a detail standpoint in terms of how old she would have been, but I think the other evidence is just so overwhelming that it’s possible that she was another exception to that rule of not really living past the age of 10.

Eric: I think it’s just like you’re saying, Micah, exactly what you’re saying about how, if it was told to Newt in confidence, and Newt would be the kind of person – because he’s a Hufflepuff and Hufflepuffs are loyal – to respect Dumbledore’s confidence and privacy even when talking about Obscurials because it’s relevant to what’s threatening all of America and the wizarding world. He still would protect that secrecy and not openly talk about that 14-year-old girl he just met.

Micah: Right, and I’m not entirely sure what her age was when she was killed. But I will say, to the point that… did you say it was Katy who made it? Yeah, the reaction by Graves/Grindelwald when he finds out that it’s Credence I think is one of complete shock. So that would go against the entire argument of him having experienced Ariana as an Obscurus at an older age, because if he’s in awe of seeing somebody like Credence, given how old he is, it’s almost like it’s something that he’s never seen before. So I don’t know if that completely undermines the entire discussion we just had for the last 30 or 40 minutes, but… [laughs]

Andrew: No, no.

Eric: Well, no, but I’ll also add, too, that it makes me think a lot of Aberforth too, because Aberforth really watched over Ariana a lot more than Albus ever did. And if her condition was as an Obscurial, Aberforth would also have crucial information regarding what that looks like, what that is like, how do you protect someone who is that way. Aberforth would have reason to like Newt as well and rely on Newt for information. So maybe there’s a bit of misdirection here on the part of Jo; maybe Aberforth has more of a role to play in the Newt Scamander storyline than Albus.

Andrew: Yeah. All right, well, let’s wrap it up here. I think we went very in-depth there. If anybody has any feedback to add, please email MuggleCast@gmail.com, or you can hit us up on Twitter with some thoughts. Twitter.com/MuggleCast. We’re always checking, we’re always participating in conversations with people on Twitter. It’s a lot of fun.

Eric: This was just like old times, guys. This was just like old times.

Andrew: Just like old times. Little fun thing here before we start to wrap up the show: We did a quiz on Hypable, “Which Fantastic Beasts creature are you?” It’s a fun quiz. We wanted to all take it for this week’s episode. It’ll ask you a couple serious questions, but it also asks you a couple of fun questions, like what is your ideal date?

Eric: And what’s the best wizarding school? [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, are you an extrovert or an introvert? All to try to figure out what Fantastic Beasts creature are you. Obviously, there are a lot of great ones in the movie, so we thought it’d be fun to identify with one. I got Swooping Evil.

Eric: Really?

Micah: Wow.

Eric: Is that rigged? Did you just want the coolest beast?

Andrew: [laughs] The description says, “You have quite a formidable reputation, but your beak is worse than your bite most of the time. You enjoy picking people’s brains, and though you have a poisonous side, you can also be quite soothing, and you can always be trusted in sticky situations.” I think that’s pretty accurate of me. I’m poisonous.

Eric: I like the way that’s written, actually, because it sees both sides of the beast. It’s really cool in that way.

Andrew: Yeah, Michal is a great writer. What did you guys get?

Eric: Micah?

Micah: Clearly, Eric wants to do some sort of big reveal here for himself.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: Well, yeah, it is a big reveal. It’s a monumental gargantuan reveal.

Micah: I got the Demiguise, and what’s interesting is because I actually thought of that beast before I even took the quiz.

Andrew: Oh, that’s funny.

Micah: And it said, “You’re sensitive and empathetic, and you always trust your feelings, though you prefer not to be the center of attention. Some might even say you’re invisible. You’re sweet, thoughtful, and caring, and occasionally mischievous.”

Eric: That’s you to a tee, Micah. I don’t know if you feel that, but I feel that.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Thanks.

Eric: I think that’s great.

Andrew: And Eric, what is yours? Do we need a drumroll? I don’t have one.

Eric: No, we don’t need a drumroll. How about trumpeting? How about horns, large horns? Because I got the Erumpent.

Andrew: Aww.

Eric: I took it twice, so I know it’s not rigged. And here’s the description, though; this made me feel great. First of all, the Erumpent is wonderful; it’s a wonderful beast to get. The description, though, made me feel even better: “Passionate and friendly, you are a lover at heart. You are always seeking to make connections, though your eagerness to bond can sometimes push others away.” I’m thinking of Jacob running away with the helmet on. “But your big personality can be intimidating. Your generosity and inner glow means that you’re never lonely for very long.”

Andrew: Aw, that’s beautiful.

Eric: Right? Big personality. “Love me; I love you.” So I identify with the Erumpent.

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: Nice.

Eric: Which is impressive.

Andrew: So we’ll have a link in the show notes if anybody wants to take that quiz. It’s fun because we’re going to probably be seeing more of these beasts in the future movies, and maybe you need to figure out which one you should buy for yourself merchandise-wise.

Eric: Ooh, I’m going to get the Erumpent Funko.

Andrew: [laughs] They still only have the Niffler for now. I’m really surprised. I think we spoke about this; like, if this was Disney, they’d have a stuffed animal for every single creature already.

Eric: [laughs] Pastries as well at the Wizarding World.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: You need a Kowalski bakery.

Micah: That would sell big time.

Andrew: Oh yeah, I’d buy one of those, one of Jacob’s items. Loaves of bread in the form of a creature.

Eric: Delectable delights. Pastries, yeah.

Andrew: Okay, so one more thing here. We got an email; this is from Allie. She said she was so excited for the show and it did not disappoint. “I wanted to write in with my thoughts about Fantastic Beasts. I really wasn’t looking forward to it – the story seemed so unnecessary and the casting of Johnny Depp really irked me. However, I thought the movie was pretty adorable, for the most part. The cast in particular really sold it for me. I did have a major issue and that was the death of Credence. I was really stunned that this victim of abuse (who asks for help and never actually gets any) was murdered by the government. It was really horrifying, but I think the main problem was the lack of reaction. No one seems to feel bad about it, and Credence’s senseless death is never brought up after the fact. (I have read that he may have lived as shown by the bit of ash floating away, but still.) J.K. Rowling tells stories about abuse with a lot of sensitivity and thoughtfulness and I was really surprised by this one note element. This really took me out of the movie, and I wish more would have been made of Credence being killed.” What do you guys make of that?

Micah: It’s hard to say without knowing what the story is for the future. I think that all the points that Allie raised are definitely valid, especially the part that you have somebody who has been such a strong victim of abuse throughout the course of the movie, and even the story that probably precedes this, just given his upbringing and the fact that he has a mother who is completely anti-everything that defines him. I don’t really have an answer. I mean, I feel like that’s more a question that J.K. Rowling would have to answer. But I know we’ve talked about on prior episodes that sometimes things, they don’t work out the way that you’re anticipating that they should. I mean, I think that despite the film having this happy ending for Newt and Jacob and some of the others, it didn’t for Credence, and I think that it’s just a hard lesson for all of us to… not necessarily to learn, but this is also the midst of a wizarding war, and there are casualties, regardless of… or I should say, this is the precursor to a wizarding war, and there are going to be casualties. And it’s just unfortunate that everything that this person went through, he couldn’t necessarily get the help that he so needed before everything played itself out.

Eric: Yeah, and I think this ties in really well to J.K. Rowling’s philanthropic efforts with the charity Lumos as well.

Andrew: Absolutely.

Eric: There are children out there that need help, and so I think that’s actually why it is so dark and so devastating, is because it’s meant for us to reflect on, “Well, yeah, that Credence guy had a really tough break.” And they kill him, the government; no less than the government itself kills this kid and prevents him from breathing, because he was sick. He essentially had an illness that maybe could have been cured. There was hope for it from Newt. But on the bright side, I will stress that it is… can I say…? It is confirmed that Credence lived. There’s a deleted scene where he gets on a boat with Newt.

Andrew: We spoke about this on bonus MuggleCast. Right, they did shoot a scene of him going on a boat. I think one reason that they didn’t deal with it more is because he is going to be involved in the future. Now, yeah, you could argue that maybe J.K. Rowling should have given us more, because we’re supposed to believe that he was dead. But I guess on the other hand, maybe they just figured, “Well, let’s not focus too much on his death, because he really isn’t dead,” so they don’t want to do a fake-out. But I still see your point, Allie, that it was very sad, and there wasn’t… they just stepped away from it.

Eric: In the course of the film, the character is never memorialized at the end of it. They could have done a scene with Tina and Newt standing in front of the destroyed church with a little plaque, or a commemoration like “This was the scene where so-and-so lost their lives,” and “Credence, farewell, always in our hearts,” that kind of thing. But Ezra Miller is confirmed for the sequel, which should settle any and all disputes that the character comes back.

Micah: Yeah, but I think the point that Allie is trying to make runs a lot deeper than just whether or not the character is going to be the next film.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: But he wasn’t memorialized.

Micah: Right, and I think a lot of that, just from a film standpoint, has to deal with the fact that you get a massive reveal of Graves being Grindelwald literally seconds after Credence is killed. And I actually felt like, with respect to the movie, I didn’t know when it was going to end. There kept being these moments that just continued and continued and continued, and if I were to criticize the movie at all, that would be the one thing that I would say. I felt like it didn’t do a good job tying up the loose ends, and I think that this is definitely one of them. But Eric, to go back to your point earlier, I think when you were talking about the government, particularly as it relates to World War II and Nazi Germany, the fact that it did kill people, very much along the lines of what we see happen to Credence… and I think that there’s definite parallels here, and I think that you have a situation where somebody is the unfortunate victim of being stereotyped and it results in their death in this case. And that’s very much a major theme that runs through the history of the Second World War, and that’s the timeline that we’re going to be approaching, and I think this is the groundwork for that. So those are just… I mean, those are my thoughts, but I think Allie raises a lot of really good points.

Andrew: But what about the next movie, Micah?

Micah: What about it?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Speaking of the direct sequel to this movie, the second film… again, going over on J.K. Rowling’s Twitter, somebody begged her… it was the end of November; somebody was like, “I can’t go on without knowing more about Leta Lestrange.” She quoted the tweet and said, “Next film, I promise.”

Andrew: And we should maybe do a main discussion speculating about what’s going to be up with her, because that’s probably one of the things I’m most interested in, what’s going to happen with her.

Eric: Yeah, that’s a good idea.

Andrew: Did Newt love her? Give me more!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Thank you, everybody, for listening. We are going to be doing a bonus MuggleCast right after we record this. We’re going to be talking about Newt’s brother; he might have a role in future Fantastic Beasts movies, because a new prop letter was discovered at a Fantastic Beasts exhibit, and there’s a letter from Theesus. T-H-E-S-E-U-S.

Eric: Theseus?

Andrew: To Newt, which reveals that he was searching for Grindelwald, and still might be, so we’re going to talk about the implications, what that means for… and why this letter exists in the first place. J.K. Rowling must have written it for the movie, so why does this exist? Was it going to be in the movie? We’re going to talk about it. It’s going to be super interesting, because I mean, this is… just when you thought you were done, you thought you speculated about everything, here’s something else.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: It’s just like old times!

Andrew: Yeah. So people who pledge $5 a month on Patreon will have access to that. By the way, our next goal will have us doing weekly episodes of MuggleCast – four episodes a month – so we would love your support to get us there. You will also receive signed album art for pledging, and other benefits, like access to the show notes, you’ll be able to stream the recordings as we’re live recording them… thank you to the patrons who tuned in today.

Eric: And chapter readings.

Andrew: And participating in discussion topics and listening to our book readings. We do a lot on Patreon.com/MuggleCast. And thank you; welcome again to new listeners. We really appreciate you tuning in, no matter how long you’ve been listening, and we’ll see everybody next time for Episode 307, in which we will recap the year and look at what’s ahead in 2017.

Eric: So much.

Andrew: I’m Andrew.

Eric: I’m Eric.

Micah: And I’m Micah.

Andrew: Bye, everyone.

Micah: Bye.

Eric: So long.

Transcript #305

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #305, Fantastic Beasts Movie Review (SPOILERS!)


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, your Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts podcast covering everything about J.K. Rowling’s Wizarding World. Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 305, our Fantastic Beasts spoiler episode, now featuring better audio. [laughs]

Eric Scull: Isn’t that always the case? We learn from our past mistakes.

Andrew: Yeah, the spoiler-free episode, I sounded a little distant. Then Eric told us how this mic works. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, it has no problem picking up every tiny bug in all corners of the room, but as far as closeness, people, if we’re sitting around the table, the left side is optimal.

Andrew: Anyway, we’re more balanced now, and we’re here to talk about Fantastic Beasts, everything about it. We’re going to go into the details, so stop listening now.

Micah Tannenbaum: Yes.

Eric: All the gritty details.

Micah: Spoiler alert! Spoiler alert!

Andrew: [makes buzzing alarm sound] You should do… remember in the early MuggleCast days, the intro was like, “If you haven’t read Half-Blood Prince…”

Eric: [laughs] “Stop listening.”

Andrew: “… stop listening now.” I think I did that too.

Micah: You did it at the beginning; it was a Half-Blood Prince warning. So if you haven’t seen Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, please stop listening now.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: How was that?

Andrew: Yeah, that’s great. But please support us on Patreon. Okay, bye.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Micah: But we are in the same room. I think that’s important to say for those people who may not have listened to the previous episode…

Andrew: Yes.

Micah: … which was spoiler-free. We are not holding hands, much like we did during the last episode.

Eric: That actually happened.

Micah: That actually did happen for a brief moment. And yeah, we’re all here in New York.

Andrew: Yeah, and maybe for new listeners who are listening for the first time, I’m Andrew.

Micah: I’m Micah.

Eric: And I’m Eric.

Andrew: And we’ve been doing this for 11 years. [laughs] And we talk about… what’s it called? Harry Potter, and now, Fantastic Beasts.

Eric: Which we saw last night at a event held at Carnegie Hall in New York City, where J.K. Rowling and lead star Eddie Redmayne – actually, all of the main principal cast were there – for where they did a pre-screening, so we saw it a couple days before it comes out nationwide, for charity.

Andrew: Yes. And in between the two episodes, Eric just ran out and got us more caffeine, so we’re ready.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So what are we starting with? [laughs]

Eric: How about the time when Dumbledore killed all those children?

Micah: Oh, wow.

Andrew: Excuse me?

[Micah laughs]

Eric: In the opening scenes.

Andrew: That’s not the movie I saw.

Eric: Sorry, that was a test for any of you still listening who haven’t… who don’t want to be spoiled.

Micah: That did really happen.

Andrew: Should we just talk about the Grindelwald twist first?

Eric: Yeah, let’s lead…

Micah: Well, yeah, let’s start there, because there were moments in the movie where I wanted to turn to you and say, “Is Graves Grindelwald?” And I think that there were a lot of clues, and they started literally right off the bat because the movie opens with Grindelwald, you see the back of his head, and then there’s a very similar shot – Eric, you and I talked about this, I think – literally within minutes later on the back of Graves’s head, and they look very much the same.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: And the opening montage – which I’ll have to go back and watch many times because there’s a lot of great stuff in there – is literally a number of headlines that say, “Where’s Grindelwald?”

Eric: Yeah, “Grindelwald terrorizes Europe.” “Where is Grindelwald?” “Grindelwald disappeared.” And it sets up the mystery, which is the main mystery of this movie, which is “Where is Grindelwald?” Which you don’t know, and it’s kind of shooting at the end, like, “Oh, there was Grindelwald.”

Andrew: Right. And when we found out that Johnny Depp was in it and we saw that shot in the trailer, we were all like, “Is that Johnny Depp? But that also looks like the back of Graves’s head. What’s going on?” So now it kind of all makes sense. What struck me about it, in one way, was first of all, I did not feel comfortable with Johnny Depp as Grindelwald. That scene at the end where you see him, he was doing an Eastern European accent. He just didn’t look good; he was all blonde, right? His eyebrows were blonde, I think, and any facial hair was blonde, and of course, his hair was blonde. I don’t know. It was just so weird to me to see Johnny Depp. Somebody said it almost didn’t look like Johnny Depp; did you hear that?

Eric: Face-wise, yeah, I could tell it was Johnny Depp. What I’m glad about is that they didn’t make it worse; like, they could have taken out his pupils, right? Or done something very weird, the way that Voldemort doesn’t have a nose. The fact that this was just a blonde-haired, blue-eyed, Aryan race blonde dude was actually comforting.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, and so one of the parallels that I found interesting was that Johnny, that he was hiding in Graves’s body somehow that whole time…

Eric: Somehow.

Andrew: … and it reminds you of Movie 1 and Book 1 with Voldemort hiding within Quirrell in a way.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: Right? I mean…

Eric: Yeah, because it’s not clear exactly how that’s taking place. It doesn’t appear to be Polyjuice Potion.

Micah: No.

Andrew: Yeah, so J.K. Rowling will have to explain this.

Micah: Brendan Gleeson wasn’t slugging back…

Eric: You mean Colin Farrell?

Micah: Yeah, Colin Farrell, sorry.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Well, I was alluding to Moody, but…

Eric: Yeah, which actually works because they were in the same movie together, In Bruges.

Micah: They were, yeah.

Andrew: Oh, right, of course. So yeah, that’s another parallel. I mean, it was just interesting because we always spoke about parallels in the Harry Potter books…

Eric: That’s a really cool… yeah.

Andrew: … how 1 relates to 7, 2 to 6, 3 to 5; so it’s interesting how you’re seeing that same surprising element play out.

Eric: I like that a lot.

Micah: Well, I think in Goblet of Fire, it was way overdone. It was way overdone. There was something about it that just made me pick up on it, and I think other people did, but for most people, I think it’s going to be subtle. I don’t think it’s going to be like you’ll figure it out immediately.

Eric: Even that Graves is bad, right? Because at first he starts as this government guy who’s just trying to do his job kind of thing. He’s investigating this big beast attack…

Micah: But he did spend time in Europe; that was also mentioned in the movie.

Eric: Oh, I missed that. Yeah, the hints are all there. For me, it comes out when Newt realizes it, really, when he has that line about “a useless Obscurus”; like, “It’s kept up, it’s so useless.” He’s like, “What would you use it for?”

Andrew: [laughs] Right.

Eric: And Graves is just… so his inner evil is revealed slowly throughout the film.

Andrew: Yeah, one reason I was so surprised by the Depp twist at the end – this was the big one that people kept hinting at – was that in Jeanna’s test screening, Johnny Depp does not appear at the end there.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Colin Farrell says those lines that Johnny Depp says, and it makes sense because maybe they hadn’t shot Depp yet, or they wanted to keep it a secret from the…

Eric: From even the test screenings, because that’s huge news. That’s absolutely…

Micah: That would’ve leaked.

Eric: We speculated about why they would have done it, cast him to begin with, on our last episode, but I can see that they’d want to make it….

Andrew: But you know what frustrates me? Why couldn’t they have held this secret in for another two more weeks?

Eric: Yeah, absolutely, 100%.

Andrew: It would have been a shocker.

Eric: “Is that Johnny Depp?! What?!”

Andrew: Right, right, to see him. Now, there’s a couple things here maybe. Maybe they wanted to boost box office early to…

Eric: Get people to come out and see it, because it’s controversial.

Andrew: Right, well, yeah, and they wanted to get that Johnny Depp draw early to boost box office, because we’ve seen the projections. They’re at like, $75 million, and that would be at the low end of the Harry Potter movies.

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: Remember on Episode 303, I was saying projections are going to come out soon? They came out a day or two after we released the episode. [laughs]

Eric: And they were poor?

Andrew: Well, they were saying $75 million, and that’s how two of the “worst” performing Harry Potter movies were, so not that great. I’m sure they were expecting bigger. But we’ll see; maybe the box office will do really well. So my guess is maybe they released that; they leaked it so… but on the other hand, I would have loved to have had that surprise. But on the other hand, maybe they thought if you saw Johnny Depp, you would have been so shocked that it almost took you out of the movie.

Micah: At the beginning.

Andrew: No, at the end.

Micah: No, no, but you’re saying if you saw it at the beginning, it would have just… at the end…

Andrew: No, no, I mean if you didn’t know Johnny Depp was going to be in this movie at all or was even cast. That’s what I mean.

Micah: See, I didn’t go in knowing that he was going to be in this movie; I just knew that he was cast as Grindelwald, so I didn’t think he was going to appear until the second movie.

Eric: And it’s still shocking what way Grindelwald shows up, which… what is it, Deadline? Where it’s like, “Look for him in a small turn,” because he turns into Johnny Depp.

Andrew: Right, right. Well, when they wrote that, I thought they were only referring to that shot at the very beginning, because what somebody had told me who was involved in the production was that that was the only shot he was in at the very beginning.

Eric: So back to the movie. So Newt casts Revelio, which is what causes Graves to change, which is interesting because we’ve never seen… they didn’t try that on Moody; Moody’s Polyjuice just ran out to become Barty Crouch. It’s specifically… in fact, I think we’ve seen that spell before, but it never really does anything. Snape tries it on the Marauder’s Map but it doesn’t work on the Marauder’s Map. “Revelio. Give me your secrets.” And it somehow works on Grindelwald, which seems like an oversight on Grindelwald’s part. But Newt, as it turns out, is a very accomplished wizard, and I want to talk about Newt’s prowess with you guys here because early in the film, it’s established – again, through a Dumbledore shout-out – that Dumbledore thinks very fond of Newt. And his competence in his knowledge of the beasts, sure, we have already guessed that; he’s able to catch them, he’s able to woo them. But we mentioned all the Apparating and just his street smart kind of way of being in battle. It just seems like he’s really quite agile. And now that we know that these films are going to be about Grindelwald, it just seems like Newt will actually become some kind of agent for Dumbledore against Grindelwald, and maybe more in the middle of this battle than we thought at first.

Micah: Well, clearly he started off on the wrong foot with Grindelwald.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: I mean, he just arrested him at the end of the movie.

Eric: He peed in his cereal! [laughs]

Andrew: “I would have gotten away with it if it wasn’t for you meddling kids!”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Somebody said that last night at dinner.

Micah: Oh, really?

Eric: Oh my God, that’s amazing.

Micah: Going back, though, to your point, the mention of Dumbledore – and we talked a little bit about this at the bar or the restaurant afterwards – was that that’s Grindelwald talking about Dumbledore. So there’s an extra level of the conversation that’s taking place here when he’s mentioning, and could really have influenced why Graves made the decision to try and kill both Tina and Newt in that moment…

Eric: Oh!

Micah: … knowing the closeness that Newt shares with Dumbledore. And I think there’s probably more moments like that in the movie that if you go back and pay attention to what Graves is saying in the lines that he has…

Andrew: There’s a double meaning.

Micah: Double meaning, yeah. And what really sold it for me was when he gives Credence the pendant of the Deathly Hallows, and I forget exactly where that happens in the movie, but it’s one of the back alley scenes where he’s comforting, and you see it.

Eric: And later on, he says, “Touch this and I’ll know.” It’s such a Dark Mark type…

Micah: Such a Voldemort type of…

Eric: … Lord Voldemort type magic.

Micah: Because yeah, I think that there was a lot of talk of, “Oh, we just thought that he was somebody working on behalf of Grindelwald; he was one of his followers,” but you had to have had that kind of reveal at the end. It just couldn’t be that he was just one of the followers; that wouldn’t be a big enough…

Eric: “For Grindelwald and valor!”

Andrew: Well, I was kind of expecting… at first, I thought the big twist was going to be Newt is the bad guy.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: Because there’s a scene, remember… I’m trying to remember what exactly happens, but he’s set up to be like, “You’re the enemy here.” Do you know what I’m talking about? I’m forgetting.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: But actually, so getting back to Newt’s involvement in future films and his character, he is a Nervous Nellie, but he is very skilled. And he’s particularly skilled working with the beasts, so in fighting Grindelwald in future movies, he could be using his beasts to his advantage, to their advantage.

Eric: That raises certain concerns too. I liked when you mentioned this in the previous episode, because you were talking about how Newt uses the Swooping Evil, which is like the world’s coolest yo-yo.

Andrew: Yes, a yo-yo, that’s what I thought of as well.

Eric: It’s the world’s coolest yo-yo. But is it right to use these creatures who could be harmed?

Andrew: Right, that’s a good point.

Eric: And I think that’ll be a… that’s something I wondered about during this movie, but I’m sure in future movies you’ll wonder about it more.

Andrew: Right. Maybe Newt has a medical ward in his case where he takes care of these…

Eric: [laughs] A little…

Micah: Well, he kind of does. I mean, he nursed… was it Frank? The Thunderbird.

Eric: Oh, the Thunderbird.

Andrew: Was his name Frank?

Eric and Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: I missed that. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, it’s Frank.

Micah: … back to health. He was going to set him free.

Andrew: In Arizona! Okay, so Thunderbird, a name of one of the Ilvermorny houses, and weren’t we talking about how the Ilvermorny houses may each represent a quadrant of the US? Is Thunderbird southwest?

Eric: Oh, I don’t know.

Andrew: Anyway, as somebody who loves the desert, I was super into the fact that J.K. Rowling chose Arizona as the place where the Thunderbird goes.

Eric: I love Arizona too.

Micah: But I see that, to your point, it’s almost a conflict of interest, because he is trying to nurse and care for all of these creatures. So to put them in harm’s way and to get them involved in a war, try and use them against Grindelwald and his followers, would be challenging for him.

Eric: I mean, you have the Erumpent, which is… I don’t want to say indestructible, but it would take a lot to hurt it. And we actually got to see it burrow its tusk into the tree and cause the tree to melt and blow up, which was pretty cool, so you get the idea…

Micah: And try and hump Jacob too.

Eric: And try and hump Jacob.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: There were so many… it was very horny, what can you say?

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Micah: Improv.

Eric: Is it still going? I was checking because the cable… yeah, so there were more beasts than I was expecting, and I love that about this. And there were different beasts; we weren’t just… I mean, there were ones we had heard of and some that we hadn’t, and I think that that trend should continue. But yeah, I worry about the role that the beasts will play because I still want this to be about Newt and his beasts. I love the screen time that Newt got just doing weird ass shit, nurturing them and talking with them and relating to them. I love that part of this movie. I think it was… I wanted to say it was the movie’s heart, but Jacob was really the movie’s heart. But Newt as a character, I really enjoy, and just seeing him very deftly maneuver all of these spells that are shot at him. It doesn’t make much sense because we don’t have that backstory of Newt, how he got to be just so good. And he was expelled from Hogwarts; he’s a dropout. He’s a school dropout, and yet, these world leaders know him. He’s able to save all these beasts from around the world, but why? I wanted more.

Andrew: Getting back to Graves for a second, was it ever established how long he had been working with MACUSA?

Eric: No, but Pottermore wrote about the… he’s descended from one of the original 12 wizards that started the…

Micah: Aurors.

Eric: Yeah, one of the original 12 Aurors, thank you. So Graves is just some bureaucrat, whatever, Auror guy. I don’t think it’s established how long he works there.

Micah: Who clearly went on business to Europe…

Eric: Yeah, that’s exactly…

Micah: … and was killed by Grindelwald or something else happened. I don’t know.

Eric: Oh, because you said they mentioned he went to Europe.

Micah: They do, yeah.

Eric: Oh, then it’s clearly… that’s the Albania trick that Jo pulled with Quirrell. Goes to Albania, comes back with the turban, and is all stuttery.

Andrew: Right, right. Aw, poor Graves. I mean, or is Graves’s spirit somewhere? Or soul?

Eric: Yeah. Well, it depends, right? I want to believe that Colin Farrell will be in this movie, because I like Colin Farrell a lot. If he’s just in this first movie, “Oh, he did an amazing job,” and then I was like, “Oh, it’s sad I won’t see him anymore.” But I think it’s likely that Grindelwald killed Graves. No loose ends. If he didn’t need him to still be alive for Polyjuice reasons or for anything like that, it makes sense that he would just dispatch his enemies.

Andrew: Right. Speaking of deaths, the Second Salemers. So Credence was the adopted son of Mary Lou, who’s leading this Second Salemer movement. They both die in this movie.

Eric: Presumably.

Andrew: Presumably. Some people aren’t so convinced that Credence is dead.

Eric: The only reason I say that is because Yates has said in one of the press interviews this week that Credence is in the sequel. It’s weird the way he talks about Credence’s plot; he says… who was the girl? Modesty?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But he talks about Credence’s future and he’s vague about it, but it’s weird. So the only indicator in the film that I saw is there’s that little sliver of black smoke that Newt notices, which indicates that maybe the Obscurus wasn’t completely destroyed.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, I did like his character; I think there’s a lot more there to dive into. And we need to get into this Obscurus stuff, because this is a very interesting new element that J.K. Rowling introduced. I like that they took risks by killing big characters – Credence, Mary Lou, Graves – because there’s a lot more you could dive into with these characters in future movies, but the fact that J.K. Rowling got rid of them now – let’s just say they are dead for now – I think that is a risk that pays off, because then there’s stakes. I was talking about this in the spoiler-free episode: Marvel doesn’t kill off their heroes, and it’s like, where are the stakes if these guys aren’t dying?

Eric: Can’t die, yeah.

Andrew: If they’re killing people… I mean, maybe in these next five films, one of the four are going to… Queenie, Tina could…

Eric: It’s realistic, yeah,

Andrew: Actually, I guess Tina won’t, because Newt eventually ends up marrying her.

Eric: Well, you mentioned stakes; witches are literally being burned at the stake. [laughs]

Andrew: Oh, and the guy who was running for president, Shaw. He dies in this. Very sudden, very… [snaps fingers]

Eric: Yeah, his soul is… do you remember that? They were looking up at him, just sort of… when they’re at MACUSA after he’s murdered?

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Eric: They have like, a body version of him.

Andrew: Oh yeah, it was kind of like a camera.

Eric: Yeah, that was weird.

Andrew: It was weird.

Eric: Unexplained. Add that to the list of questions for Jo.

Andrew: But so this Obscurus… and it took a lot of us time to finally remember this name; I only remember because I have it written down here. An Obscurial. So this is the new element that J.K. Rowling introduces. This Obscurus develops if you’re trying to suppress your magic like Credence was, and it creates this thing that’s you, I guess, that you transform into, and you can cause terror. You can kill people.

Eric: Yeah, it’s like the innate magic that’s in any wizard, if not allowed to flourish or not nurtured, turns against the host, almost, and becomes this. Well, what I love about it, it becomes this beast, essentially. This is the beast within us. This is the beast that… and Newt has to contend with it. It becomes such a beast that Newt is the only one who has, but was able to separate it from its host without killing the host, but that’s never been done before, according to the film. And so I like that the film Fantastic Beasts, you get all these other animals, these creatures that are running around, and then you have the animal within us to contend with as the main villain. So I like that. But yeah, the question was whether or not Newt could save, I guess at the end, Credence from his own demise. But the whole time, Graves is trying to use him.

Andrew: Right, and Graves thought he was a Squib, but he wasn’t.

Micah: The exact opposite.

Eric: Graves saw a vision of a child… they’re talking about this in the alleyway. Grindelwald is already more powerful than Voldemort; I mentioned this a little bit before, but you see Graves doing a lot of wandless magic.

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: He heals Credence’s wounds with just a wave of his hand.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s very good.

Eric: And Graves keeps going on and on and on about this vision that he had of a child who will save us all, right? Which means will wipe out the entire… will serve our means. And there was some sort of divination or prophecy – but not divination or prophecy – that Graves is acting on; that’s why he’s in America, apparently, is because he’s had this vision of what ends up being this Obscurus.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: But it was just that Credence hid it well, and that Modesty chick was just young and creepy, because children are scary in horror films; children are just creepy. They behave weird. So everybody thought it was Modesty, but it was a nice reveal that it’s actually Credence. But he’s older than any other… the tension between this creature and its host kills the host by age 10, usually, I think, or usually by age 8, but Newt said the one that he got was a 10-year-old. But that sets it up for Credence to… Credence is much older; he’s in his 20s.

Andrew: This is all still a little confusing to me; I need to see it again. [laughs]

Micah: I mean, I have two questions about… or the Obscurus plays into my mind in two different areas. One, when we learn about Lestrange…

Eric: Another bomb drop.

Micah: And I’m forgetting about her first name.

Andrew and Eric: Leta.

Micah: Leta Lestrange. Seems to me that she was an Obscurus as well, right? Or am I making that up?

Eric: She was just a girl at school, but I think there was some kind of… it was a star-crossed lovers sort of thing, because I got the feeling she was just into Dark stuff that he didn’t…

Andrew: Well, because either Tina or Queenie says at one point, “Lestrange? That’s a…” and then she trails off.

Eric: “Aren’t they usually…?”

Micah: It was Queenie. It was the conversation that Newt and Queenie had where he said, “Don’t read my mind.”

Andrew: Yeah. An interesting little fact about Legilimens introduced there…

[noise in background]

Andrew: What just fell?

Eric: Your coat.

Andrew: Oh, jacket, okay. I thought an Obscurus just came in.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Andrew: … that when you’re feeling down or something like that, she said you can read minds easier, because she said she has a hard time reading Brits.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: That was just such a funny… “I have a hard time reading your kind,” and we don’t know if she means wizards, and then she says, “Brits.”

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: Super funny.

Andrew: I was just picturing J.K. Rowling writing that, and it was amusing.

Micah: So maybe not Lestrange because she obviously… if they’re at Hogwarts together, then she would be older than what you were saying as it relates to an Obscurus.

Eric: Yeah, but something definitely happened with Newt and her.

Andrew: They were dating, right?

Eric: I think she said that.

Micah: It sounded like there was a romantic interest there, for sure. The second thing that came to mind… and I forget; somebody else brought this up last night and I want to give them credit, so if they’re listening to the show, definitely write in. Ariana.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Micah: There’s a very good chance this may be where Grindelwald learned about Obscurus and their value and what they could potentially do, and so that’s why I want to learn more about Dumbledore and his backstory. We know that his sister was abused on some level.

Eric: There was a traumatic incident which suppressed her…

Micah: Right, so I’m wondering, yeah, was her magic suppressed to the point where she was one of these… is it Obscuri? Is that the plural of it?

Eric: I don’t know. Let’s ask J.K. Rowling. [laughs]

Micah: But I’m wondering, once this movie is officially released, if somebody is going to reach out to J.K. Rowling and ask her that question, because I think that it’s a legitimate question to ask, knowing what we know about the Dumbledore history.

Eric: I think we’re meant to ask… that’s one of the probably main questions we’re supposed to ask coming out of this, because we never really would have thought it… it’s an added element that fits into canon, fits into the existing…

Micah: And given everything that we learn from Aberforth about that basically she was sacrificed on Albus’s way to becoming who he became, at least with respect to the relationship with Grindelwald. So I wouldn’t be surprised if Grindelwald was sort of testing her and seeing what she could possibly mean for the future; that’s why he comes to America when he learns about there being a very powerful Obscurus.

Eric: I want Colin Farrell in the sequels.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, he was really good.

Eric: He was so good.

Andrew: Leta, by the way, she is played by Zoë Kravitz. We did hear that Zoë Kravitz was going to… she was cast kind of late, I believe, and they said…

Eric: That’s right; I remember the casting announcement was way late.

Andrew: Yeah, it came out after, but it makes sense now because she’s just appearing in a photo, something they could easily have added in later. But I think the Lestrange… something very interesting is going to be happening.

Eric: That name just bothers me, man.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. Well, and Newt is clearly bothered by it too.

Micah: But do you think she’s still alive? Or you think she’s dead?

Eric: I think she’s still alive.

Andrew: I think so.

Eric: But I think it’s clear to me, the ending train scene where Queenie and Newt… or is it Tina?

Micah: Tina.

Eric: Tina and Newt.

Micah: The boat, not the train. [laughs]

Andrew: But it may as well be. That was another parallel.

Eric: Did I say the…? It’s not Hogwarts, going home… the scene between them, where she mentions Leta and she’s like, “Oh, do you have somebody to get back to?” sort of thing, it sparked in me an idea that maybe Newt, who’s traveled the world recently – doing the things with beasts, writing his book – might be running from his problems, essentially.

Andrew: Yeah, he’s clearly not… in my opinion, I don’t think he’s over her if he still has a picture of her in his office.

Eric: I mean, his office is huge.

Andrew: Right, but no other pictures except for her. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, she’s the only one.

Micah: I mean, it’s very possible she’s a supporter of Grindelwald.

Eric: Oh, yeah. So Newt has a personal stake in the whole Grindelwald thing.

Andrew: Yeah. Would he know that yet, though? Supporter of Grindelwald?

Eric: It’s just so weird because Grindelwald has been running rampant over the past couple years, and it’s still 19 years from now until his defeat, so that’s a lot of terror.

Micah: I do think, though, that – and it may have been mentioned – I do think she’s tied to his expulsion at Hogwarts. Like, maybe he covered for her.

Eric: Oh God, because somebody got hurt in a beast breakout or something. They mentioned it in the movie. Something to do with a beast.

Andrew: Oh, yeah. Well, shit. What was I just going to say? I just had a cool idea about… oh, what if Newt didn’t kiss Tina at the end because he still has feelings for Leta? Maybe that’s one reason he didn’t kiss. When I was first watching it, it’s just because he was nervous, I thought, and didn’t want to, although I was expecting him to run out of the boat and just give her a quick peck or something.

Eric: Yeah. He does run back, but they still don’t kiss.

Andrew: Right, well, he stops for a second, and then he says, “Can I deliver the book to you…?”

Eric: “In person.” It’s kind of kindergarten-y.

Andrew: Yeah, but then I thought once he went in, he would actually run back out. And she does a little skip, a little hop at the end, which was really cute.

Eric: Jacob gets a kiss, but Newt does not.

Andrew: Right. So it could just be to keep fans waiting, which now everybody’s excited to see that in the sequel.

Eric: I don’t care as much about Tina, but we can get into that later.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. I definitely liked Queenie more. Tina was a little flat.

Eric: It’s just weird how she’s following him around at the beginning, and just kind of has a quirky… she goes places where she’s not supposed to, which is fine…

Andrew: But because she’s… she was an Auror.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, so she just doesn’t take… she just, yeah, sees the value.

Andrew: I thought she was going to stand up for herself when she was standing in front of the President, Madam President, when they were like, “He’s been here for 24 hours, and you didn’t say anything?” She did say something, to Graves.

Micah: Right. And I think there’s history there, too; did you get that same feeling between her and Graves?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. And by the way, in front of Madam President, when they were in that big meeting room with all those people, there was a lot of diversity in that room, including a Native American, so I’m very interested to… I thought that was good. I’ll be interested to see who these people are; who are they representing?

Eric: Yeah. Well, and what I love about that scene is a couple of them noticed or recognized Newt, and were just, “Oh, you saved our country from this beast; how’s it going?” And he’s like, “Hey!” Really helps his credibility in that moment, because he’s the guy who just is being blamed for causing havoc in New York.

Micah: And was it the Minister for Magic that was there as well? Who was the Brit that was there?

Eric: Oh, I don’t remember.

Micah: That spoke to him.

Eric: Oh, yeah, and he says back, “… something, Minister.” It was nice that a couple people called him out. But yet, the world leaders that are in America were never really… there was no second scene with them reacting to America or any kind of…

Micah: Yeah, well, and I said this at the end of our previous episode: I think New York is done, but that doesn’t mean the president of MACUSA is not going to factor into future movies. I definitely see them, not just her, but other characters that were prominent in this movie being in future movies.

Eric: It’s been revealed by David Yates that the second film will return to the UK, probably show a lot of Hogwarts…

Andrew: Paris.

Eric: And Paris.

Andrew: It’s primarily set there.

Eric: And he said the UK too.

Andrew: Oh, right. Parts of it, yeah.

Eric: So that bothers me because it seems like for the immediate future, we’re done with America, and America in this film was pictured in a very morbid, dark, dreary way.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: The Second Salemers, the fear on the streets… it’s very much not the happiest portrait of a country that we’re all from.

Andrew: And we seem to be done with that whole battle about bringing wizards out from hiding, in America, at least, because they Obliviated all the people who found out, so it’s like none of it ever happened.

Eric: And they’re going to remain in secret, which eventually breaks, I guess.

Andrew: Well, that said, Grindelwald does want to bring everybody out of the shadows, but still, I thought that was going to be a major part going forward in America, but that doesn’t seem to…

Eric: And Ilvermorny. There’s that one line about “Which is a better school?” And Queenie, is it? Who’s really loyal to Ilvermorny. But other than that, it would really stink if in the next four films, we don’t physically see Ilvermorny.

Micah: Yeah, well, but keep in mind, Grindelwald is here.

Eric: What? Oh, yeah, is imprisoned, right?

Micah: Right, unless they’re going to extradite him to Azkaban or something like that. Or where is he in the…? Nurmengard?

Eric: Nurmengard.

Andrew: Which he created himself. But that’s at the end; that’s 19 years later from Fantastic Beasts.

Eric: And another 40, yeah.

Micah: So yeah. I mean, maybe Movie 2 opens with him breaking out of whatever the equivalent of Azkaban is here in America.

Andrew: I hope not, though. I don’t want to see him easily breaking out at the very beginning or something like that.

Eric: Hopefully years have passed, right?

Andrew: Yeah. Although, we spoke about this after Cursed Child; wow, it seems so easy to break out of Azkaban. [laughs] The Lestranges did.

Eric: Well, it’s just that so many people do it.

Andrew: Right, right.

Eric: Yeah. It’s weird because the films are in a really precarious position, because anything Grindelwald does, he would have already done, so you almost can’t introduce magic that would allow any of the characters in Harry’s world to have done something easier. He can’t have this super easy breakout spell or something that’s unpredictable that Hogwarts isn’t later proofed for, you know what I’m saying? Because of causality. So it’s weird, but they still manage to introduce totally new stuff. Let’s talk about Queenie if we can. They call her a Legilimens, which is not the same as casting the spell Legilimens, or is it? Or she can do it without spells; she can just read whatever they’re thinking.

Micah: Yeah, it seems like she’s a much more accomplished Legilimens in the sense… or maybe it’s more of a natural thing that she was born with, right? It’s not like Snape just, “I’m going to go into your mind and pull out your thoughts.” She’s a mind reader, which to me, it maybe doesn’t equate the same as a Legilimens. It’s not a forceful penetration of somebody’s mind.

Eric: And you’re not reliving physical.. he could feel her in his head, but with Occlumency and Harry is trying to protect his mind, he’s forced to relive everything Snape is seeing.

Micah: Well, he can feel it, but it’s interesting that Jacob can’t, because he’s a No-Maj.

Eric: Yeah. Definitely more answers needed there, but it’s a different element. And at first, I was just like, “This doesn’t really fit in Harry’s world,” because the way that we know mind reading to… because in the first Harry Potter book, Harry gets the feeling that Dumbledore can read his mind, but it’s not the same as seeing what’s being read pulled out.

Micah: I think there’s more to learn there, also, particularly because of her connection to her sister, which we saw when she was in the bowels of MACUSA and she knew something was wrong and she immediately acted on it.

Eric: Oh, yeah, that was cool.

Micah: So to me, this is something that’s a slightly different type of Legilimency.

Andrew: Yeah. And it could play into helping defeat Grindelwald, if she can read minds.

Eric: If they’re telepathically…

Andrew: Even though the Brits are…

Eric: Brits are much harder, yeah, yeah.

Andrew: But if they’re feeling sad, apparently it’s easier.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Well, speaking of MACUSA… so Newt and Tina are both sentenced to death.

Eric: Which, again, morbid America! They have the death penalty. What was that…?

Micah: It’s Grindelwald, though. [laughs]

Eric: Well, yeah, but I don’t think Graves…

Andrew: But the president approved of it.

Eric: Yeah, I don’t think Graves would have been the sole advocate of that way of killing people. I think the whole government had that method of disposing of their enemies.

Andrew: Right, and remember, there was a Graves before Grindelwald took over the body or whatever the hell happened there.

Eric: So I loved… the repeat effect that they used established that it’s some sort of Pensieve, right? The woman takes her memory out, throws it in the…

Andrew: Yeah. I mean, it essentially looked just like how Dumbledore did it.

Eric: But eventually, when she’s sort of trying to leave, what Newt calls a “death potion” – I think at one point I heard him say that when he’s talking about it – begins to fold up around her and tries to kill her. So is that sort of a way of making an execution more humane? To play out her life’s best moments, like her love for her sister, her mother saying, “Come here, it’s okay, come to bed”?

Andrew: Right, drawing you into the afterlife?

Eric: Did they damage her mentally? She never got that memory back, necessarily, from the pit.

Andrew: Oh, good question.

Eric: So was it a way of making an inhumane, torturous thing more humane?

Micah: It’s almost like assisted suicide.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Well, it could also be… like, what are those moments? What’s the common thread amongst those moments? Happiest moments?

Eric: But there were also the plot moments, like the Creedence stuff that she saw in there, which had no bearing on… I wouldn’t want to see that the last moment before I died. Maybe it’s a way of showing her that she’s a good person? All your life’s greatest hits; maybe that’s what it’s all about?

Andrew: Yeah. Well, and I had a hard time hearing at some point, between the accents, and it wasn’t the best sound system in Carnegie Hall.

Eric: It’s true.

Andrew: It’s not fitted for a movie. So I had first thought that… I almost turned to you to ask what the hell was going on, because I thought maybe they were just stripping them of the magic of being a witch or wizard and just converting them to Muggle or something like that. But yeah, dying is very dramatic. That whole scene reminded me of something out of Divergent by Veronica Roth, just how it looked.

Eric: Very sterile.

Andrew: Yeah, right. Exactly. But I did like it. Again, I like these new areas of magic that we haven’t seen before; it feels refreshing to have J.K. Rowling introduce us to these various new elements, so I did like it overall. And then, of course, Newt helps her get out thanks to that beast as well, hopping on the beast to get over. “I’ll catch you.”

Eric: Was that the Swooping Evil? That was, wasn’t it?

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: It made a noise when you stepped on it. Oh!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: By the way, the Gigglewater in the speakeasy? That’s another classic J.K. Rowling thing that I just love. So you take the shot and then you… [giggles]

Eric: And it might have just been because he was a Muggle and tried it, right?

Micah: Well, Jacob had a couple of those moments.

Eric: Jacob, far and large, one of the lighter areas of the film.

Andrew: He’s the comic relief.

Eric: And also the Niffler.

Andrew: Yeah, everybody was very tickled by the Niffler.

Eric: Just unabashedly… it’s a great opening scene at the bank, right? They’re accomplishing…

Andrew: It was a lot, that whole scene. It was very long, and… I don’t know. I wasn’t as tickled by the Niffler as everybody else.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Like, yeah, it’s cute. It steals things.

Eric: Well, it has an endless pouch in its body for everything it…

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. It’s cute.

Eric: It just unabashedly robs people.

Micah: The Wizarding World will sell a lot of them. [laughs]

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: Yeah, and four to me. [laughs]

Micah: And the Demiguise, because I thought the Demiguise was actually pretty cool.

Andrew: That was pretty funny, yeah.

Eric: So the beasts present an opportunity. They weren’t all comic relief, though. Some were terrifying, right?

Andrew: So inside Newt’s case, there’s these… so you see his workshop once you first step down into it, and then you go through, I guess it was a door or something, and you see he has what are kind of like stages to hold each beast, and there’s curtains with the backdrop.

Eric: That bothered me so much; the curtains have just standard iron or metal rings on them like you’re printing them out at a local Kinko’s to hold them up at a convention.

Andrew: Right, so I’m trying to think what’s up with that.

Eric: Grommets.

Andrew: Is it for the creatures to feel where they are? Because the area… it seems like there’s real trees there, but the backdrops, are they for the beasts or are they for Newt to feel like they’re in these scenes?

Eric: I think it’s just for the beasts.

Andrew: But they would know that’s not real.

Eric: Well, yeah, but you go to a zoo, right? A tiger house or whatever, and they have this sad cat that’s in a pen, but the walls, at least the ones at Lincoln Park in Chicago, are painted to look like the Savannah.

Andrew: Yeah, but the cat isn’t like, “Oh, I’m in the Savannah.” [laughs]

Eric: No, you’re right, but with magic you can have wind, you can have sounds, you can have…

Andrew: True.

Eric: Even while you’re indoors. So that’s what it did for me, because wasn’t it raining the first time he sees the eagle too? Like, actually raining on them, and Newt had to cast his little umbrella spell to not get rained on? So if you can have climate, it goes an extra level to making the beasts feel, I think, a little bit closer like it’s home.

Micah: Yeah, I agree. I mean, I think it’s for the beasts.

Andrew: And then, so the other question is: Is he trying to release all these beasts back into their natural habitats?

Eric: I don’t think all of them.

Andrew: Okay. Obviously the Thunderbird, he was.

Eric: Well, because that’s what brought him to America, right? He said it was something else, but it was that. But I think in general, he’s just caring for these. I don’t know about to what end; maybe he does want to go and release them, but…

Andrew: Maybe after spending a certain amount of time studying them?

Eric: Yeah, breeding them or studying them, because he picked them up from all over the world, so it’s like, he would have to go back to every single one of those individual countries to put them back.

Andrew: But doesn’t that make sense, if the five movies we’re going to see different…?

Eric: “Now I have to put the twig creatures back.”

Andrew: [laughs] Because it seems like somebody who cares about these creatures so much wouldn’t want to hold them in captivity all their life.

Eric: That’s true, unless you could give them a comparable living situation.

Andrew: Yeah, but those stages aren’t comparable. [laughs] In my opinion.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. Well, I like that there were limits to that stage. There was that entire hillside of sheep, though, the sheep creatures that Jacob feeds.

Andrew: Oh, yeah. That was one of the more detailed sets, so to speak.

Eric: I guess there are more places that we haven’t gone inside the case.

Micah: Well, and after that, he goes into the area with an Obscurus, right?

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: Yeah, that was very…

Micah: So does Newt have one in his case that’s still there?

Andrew: Ooh.

Eric: Well, Graves took it out, but it was… well, the Obscurus was contained in a bubble, and that bubble rendered it, Graves called it useless because it was in the protective bubble.

Micah: And that was the girl that he was talking about from Sudan?

Eric: The girl that he was talking about he tried to save, yeah. So Newt is the only person alive who’s ever separated an Obscurus from its host. The host lived, and Newt was carrying it around. I don’t think Newt… this is the thing about Newt, and he is very quirky and stuff, but he doesn’t always have an end game in mind. And I think he was just keeping it in there for safety, for the world’s safety, because it’s terrifying. So I think that was more of a… that was a quarantine situation where he was using it… I don’t think he really had a plan of where it was going.

Micah: Well, one other thing I think will sell well at the Wizarding World is the Bowtruckle.

Andrew: Yeah, that was really cute.

Eric: Adorable.

Andrew: Yeah, and that Bowtruckle who was attached to Newt, and it was really sad when Newt gave him away to the…

Eric: Ron Perlman character.

Andrew: Yeah, exactly, in the speakeasy. Yeah, I would have one of those. Those are cute. Put it in your pocket like Eddie Redmayne did at the premiere.

Eric: A little… maybe made of pipe cleaners, like little… a fully posable little twig creature, right?

Andrew: Right. We’ll see if those show up at the Wizarding World, or even online. Definitely online, I would think.

Eric: Gigglewater’s probably already at the park.

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Well, I don’t think so. Based on… I was hearing some things last night from a couple people.

Eric: Oh, that’s interesting.

Andrew: But apparently they don’t want to do that crossover at the parks there, because that’s Harry Potter’s world, you know what I mean?

Eric: Well, it’s the Wizarding World of Harry Potter. Yeah, okay, I get that.

Andrew: Right. That’s what they’re saying.

Eric: Well, Gigglewater was outlawed in 1957. We don’t know why.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: There was an incident. Suffice to say, no one was hurt afterwards.

Andrew: Yeah, but this is a nice element. Now that we’re following adult wizards, we see stuff like this, like these drinks, the Gigglewater. I mean, imagine what else J.K. Rowling could come up with at bars. How about Obliviate at the end? So Newt does release the Thunderbird to Obliviate all the No-Majes.

Eric: Because it spreads this vial of venom? Or it’s the venom of a Swooping Evil, I think he said?

Andrew: I think that’s right. Yeah, because earlier, he says, “I’ve been working on this, and I think it’ll be really helpful.”

Eric: Yeah, and it takes all the bad memories away.

Andrew: And the Thunderbird, I guess, makes it rain. Making it rain! Making it rain Obliviate! That’d be a good shirt: “Makin’ it rain… Obliviate.” So I talked to one of the Hypable writers who saw it as well, and she said she liked the movie, but she thought this part was a little too convenient. And I thought it was a beautiful scene, but I do agree in that how are all these minds being Obliviated when there are people indoors? Okay, it rains on the people…

Eric: Okay, to be fair, there are people indoors, yeah.

Andrew: Right, and they cut to one of them indoors, in the kitchen.

Eric: In the shower, right?

Andrew: Oh, yeah, in the shower too. So are you telling me this went through the water pipes and…?

Eric: Eh, New York in the 1920s had very questionable plumbing. [laughs]

Andrew: Right, but okay, so Jacob, apparently, doesn’t get rained on and is not Obliviated until he steps outside, so how is it that he avoided the Obliviation?

Eric: That’s a plot hole.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. [laughs] I demand answers, J.K.!

Eric: There is the case to be made that it aerated, right? Like that it’s an airborne… from when it hit the street, it just kind of made a vapor.

Andrew: And I agree with that.

Eric: But then Jacob should have been just as…

Andrew: Exactly, because when it rains, you can smell the rain.

Eric: Oh, yeah, exactly. But then there’s also what Queenie did to Jacob, or didn’t do to Jacob. She let him step out in the rain for a couple seconds, then went out and used her umbrella over him, and then kissed him, and then walked away, and then he still got rained on again. So it’s like, later when he remembers, or when she shows up and he remembers, did she give him some of his memories back? How does that work?

Andrew: He obviously remembers some things deep in his mind, because the bakery items he made looking like the beasts… which was so adorable.

Eric: Those were adorable. I want those.

Andrew: How does that work? Yeah, maybe his mind wasn’t completely Obliviated. I know someone at dinner last night was saying maybe because he saw so much, it would have taken more effort or more rain to Obliviate him.

Eric: True, that’s a little vial spread across an entire city of people.

Andrew: Right, so he would have needed it the most. But maybe when you’re Obliviated, you still do remember… in the back of your head you recognize it, but you don’t know what. This happens to all humans.

Eric: Well, we should also differentiate between… so it wasn’t actually Obliviate. It wasn’t casting the spell Obliviate. It was the venom of the Swooping Evil or whatever, which Newt said only erases bad memories. Bad memories.

Andrew: Oh. Well, then maybe this is less of a plot hole.

Eric: So to the Muggles, it’s a bad memory; a terrifying creature is destroying their city that they live in, and they’re frightened for their lives.

Andrew: Ohh.

Eric: But for Jacob, his happy memories of finding love might have not all been erased because they were on a happier spectrum? It’s specifically bad memories, I think Newt says, while they’re in the case.

Micah: Right. No, that’s a great point.

Andrew: That could explain it.

Eric: I don’t think it 100% covers everything, because Queenie still… the way she looked at him did something.

Micah: Well, he also goes to touch his neck where he got bitten…

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Micah: … so I wonder is it almost like a counterbalance to when he got bitten? Because he doesn’t get sick, right? I mean, he’s a little loopy…

Eric: A little groggy.

Micah: … but he’s not… I wonder if whatever happened to him from getting bitten by… what was the creature that did that?

Eric: Murtlap? The spiky pig, but with soft spikes?

Andrew: Yeah, right.

Eric: The creature that I’m so glad we never saw later in the movie.

Micah: Or was he just touching it because he started to remember as soon as he saw her?

Andrew: I think so. There’s some connection there.

Eric: Something clicked, yeah. I mean, something obviously clicked because his bakery items are beasts, so he didn’t completely forget.

Andrew: So it’ll be interesting to see how these people play into future films, because this does seem to be the new trio, if you will. The core four.

Eric: Quartet.

Andrew: Yeah. Like, how are they going to get over to Paris? Or I was speculating last night, is there going to be this sidebar plotline happening with Jacob and Queenie and I guess Tina stateside while Newt is back overseas?

Eric: That would be cool. That would really be cool.

Andrew: Either way, it seems like they have to unite again. But then, how does Jacob play into fighting Grindelwald?

Eric: Yeah, because Jacob… well, that was such a bold choice that this movie made to have one of the main characters be a Muggle. I’m not going to say No-Maj.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Because if we’re going away from America after this film…

Micah: Well, David Yates messed it up, too, last night.

Andrew: Oh, he did? [laughs]

Eric: On purpose. If we’re not going back to America after this in any big way, I don’t need to learn that term, so I’m just going to say Muggle. Having a Muggle main character, and that’s a big deal, trying to get a loan at a bank for a bakery… real world stuff! But because he’s the heart, the emotional weight of this film, it was a really nice counterbalance to everything that was going on with every magical person. And it was so bold, but I love it. But you’re right, the closer they get to Grindelwald, he’s an easy target because he’s a Muggle. It would be like… I mean, he can’t even see half the stuff, presumably, that they’re going to be… he couldn’t see Hogwarts if they take him to Hogwarts, probably couldn’t see Ilvermorny if they take him to Ilvermorny, so what are they going to do with Jacob?

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t know.

Eric: I think he’s going to franchise out, though…

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: … and he’s going to have a Paris bakery.

Andrew: Yeah, there you go.

Eric: He’s going to have a bakery in Paris when they go to him.

Andrew: Yeah. I think we hit all my points.

Eric: I’m trying to think… yeah, do you have anything, Micah?

Andrew: Obscurus, death room… Newt, I think, will be using those beasts to fight a lot in future movies; that seems to definitely be his thing. Grindelwald twist, still not over it.

Eric: Yeah, I wanted to mention we were leaving the center last night, the Carnegie Hall, and some girl was talking to her two girlfriends… and so essentially, when Johnny Depp was revealed, you could hear the intake of breath, and you could tell on the note that it was a positive, like, [gasps] “Oooh” kind of thing.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Well, people clapped.

Eric: And some people clapped, yeah. And it’s just funny, because we knew it was a controversial topic; we knew it was going to be controversial going in. But so this girl was saying to her friends, like, “Okay, correct me if I’m wrong, but aren’t we against this casting? Didn’t we not like him?”

Andrew: Right.

Eric: It was so funny to hear because I was thinking the same thing. Even I ooh’d and ahhh’d because it’s a cool reveal and it’s sort of unexpected, and he looks so different and acts so different than the character we just saw there a moment ago. But I mean, it’s ultimately about art, which is… I don’t agree with…

Andrew: Okay, David Yates. [laughs]

Eric: I don’t agree with Yates! I don’t agree with Heyman! I think it’s a terrible way to approach because it’s not sensitive to any of the concerns. And it’s like, “Oh, he has talent,” but in the movie it works, where it’s just… it is a reveal. It serves as a… it’s a perfectly serviceable reveal of what’s been going on in the plot. So I don’t know.

Andrew: I was not outwardly… I was shocked, but I was not one of those people clapping, because I am annoyed that he was cast, and I do feel like that wasn’t the best choice for several reasons.

Eric: I think he’s too high profile.

Andrew: Too high profile. It seems like a money grab move. I didn’t like how he looked as Grindelwald.

Eric: I was okay with the looks, but then again, Johnny Depp always plays these way over the top characters that you just can’t love or like. Not that you want to love Grindelwald, but I worry that… so I felt this performance was a little more muted. I mean, partly because he’s in cuffs…

Andrew: And it was very quick. [laughs]

Eric: And it was too quick. So I like that about it, because I was expecting, again, no pupils, weird scars on his face, something more terrible or terrifying, and you got just some guy. Johnny Depp playing just some guy. So I like that for that, because it’s not over the top yet, but I still don’t like the cast. I think they should have gone… this film… it’s almost like kneecapping all of the lead actors if you cast Johnny Depp, because he immediately upstages everyone else except Eddie, who’s now an Oscar winner.

Andrew: Well, so the question is, how big of a role will he have in the sequel and going forward? I mean, is he just going to keep showing up at the beginning and end again, sort of like Voldemort?

Eric: I hope.

Micah: Until you get to the point where he actually has to be stopped.

Andrew: Yeah. It’s going to be hard to top Graves’s wandwork, though. Is Johnny Depp going to be able to do it as good as Graves was? By the way, I did like that we got to see one wizard duel between Tina and Graves. When I saw that, I was like, “Oh, yeah, we should be seeing more of this.”

Eric: They even did the… not Priori Incantatem, but the two streams facing each other.

Andrew: Right. I liked that a lot.

Eric: It’s cool that they’re both Aurors, so they have… and that’s where I specifically thought of, “Oh, they should be careful about doing that kind of stuff,” because if you go back to the Dumbledore/Voldemort battle in the Ministry where they do that, and that’s the first time you see the two strings of magic connect, that’s supposed to be really badass, but if just these two American Aurors are doing that, it maybe has a potential to undercut what Voldemort and Dumbledore were doing. And to top it, Graves, who was secretly Grindelwald, could have thrown elemental magic at her, like fire and all that stuff that [breathes loudly] Voldemort does – I just did the mouth thing – to throw flames. Graves probably could have done all that and more.

Andrew: Yeah. I have a question: In the train scene, or on the rail tracks, subway tracks, why was Graves hitting – was it Newt? – so hard? Spell after spell after spell after spell. What was up with that? And what was the spell supposed to do?

Eric: Make him uncomfortable. The thing is, he was throwing lightning. It was very Emperor Palpatine; it was very Return of the Jedi. He was throwing lightning. And you know you’re not supposed to step on the railway tracks when the car is going by because you’ll get electrocuted? It’s just like that. I was just like, “He’s making Newt really uncomfortable.” Might’ve just been torture, right? Just pain inflicted.

Andrew: Yeah, because I was wondering why it was nonstop, but it didn’t seem to be doing anything to Newt, really, and doing it repeatedly wasn’t getting anywhere.

Eric: Yeah, it’s kind of like Crucio, but a different way of doing…

Andrew: Right, and why not just Crucio?

Eric: Well, yeah.

Andrew: Why not just kill him?

Micah: Yeah. Well, that’s what I wanted to know with both Tina and Newt. I mean, unless you… he was trying to achieve a different end here, and I feel like maybe if things played out a little bit differently and he had killed both of those people… I mean, they’re supposed to be dead anyway, because… by order of the president.

Eric: That’s a good point.

Micah: I just wonder if he was able to achieve what he’s trying to achieve, and then he still has these other people who he had killed in his wake, how would that reflect on somebody like Graves?

Eric: I think that’s what it is. I think that’s why he didn’t kill Newt in that scene where he’s against the tracks, because he hadn’t yet decided to reveal himself, or he hadn’t yet decided to go on the offensive against the Ministry. When he is up in the front of the camera… remember he sighs and then turns around and starts killing the MACUSA people? That’s when I think he made the decision to give up his alias. But before that, he was trying to work within the system and protect, so he wouldn’t kill Newt, because it would look bad if Graves killed Newt, even though, as you point out, they were sentenced to death.

Andrew: I think we should wrap it up here.

Eric: Yeah, for sure. I mean, definitely more to talk about.

Andrew: Yeah, and I need to leave this hotel room. It’s way past checkout time.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: This episode sponsored by the Kitano New York.

Eric: Yes, visit the Kitano for all of your Hotel in Manhattan needs.

Andrew: Yeah, I asked for a late checkout, and now we’re six minutes past that late checkout and I still need to shower. So yeah, thank you, everybody, for listening. We obviously have a lot more to discuss. Please send in your feedback.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: We want to know what you think of the Lestranges, the Obscurus, Graves, Johnny Depp, the Obliviate thing that wasn’t actually Obliviate[laughs]

Eric: Yeah, he said it’s like Obliviate in the movie.

Andrew: Oh, did he? Okay.

Eric: Yeah, the comparison is drawn for sure.

Andrew: Okay, good. Yeah, send us your thoughts on everything. How do you think it compares to the Harry Potter movies? Are you excited to see more of these movies? Do you think they’re going to cast the goat in future movies?

[Micah laughs]

Eric: I think they’re definitely going to cast the goat.

Andrew: What do you think of Jacob? Queenie? Yeah, all that. We have so much more to talk about, and we’re going to in the weeks and months ahead. And we should do a quick plug for our Patreon. Your support does help us do this show; it helped us gather here in New York.

Eric: Fund this trip. Yeah, we wouldn’t have been all together. We’re actually in the same room together for the first time in five years.

Andrew: Yeah, probably. And who knows the last time we all recorded together? I mean, maybe a live podcast, but in this environment, I’m not sure we’ve even…

Micah: I don’t think we’ve ever done it.

Andrew: No. Well, maybe Book 7 release. Eric was there; Micah wasn’t. In London.

Eric: Oh, in the hotel with Laura and Kevin.

Micah: So nine years ago.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: That’s what I’m saying! This is how rare this is, and thanks to our patrons on Patreon, they made this possible.

Andrew: Yes, so thank you.

Eric: Visit Patreon.com/MuggleCast to find out more about that.

Andrew: You’ll receive signed album art. You’ll receive bonus MuggleCast installments.

Eric: While supplies last on the album art. I think with the last couple months, we’re down to fewer than 100.

Andrew: Okay. And we will be actually releasing this spoiler-filled episode early on Patreon, so we give people benefits like that. And again, we really appreciate your support; it’s making the show possible. And yeah, so we’ll be back… this is our second episode of November, so I guess we’ll be back early December, unless we can’t wait, or unless y’all get us to our next Patreon fundraiser goal, which is going to make the show weekly.

Eric: Ooh, there’s that.

Andrew: I wish it was weekly right now because I have so much to say about it.

Eric: Weekly right now, can you imagine? We could really do scene by scene.

Andrew: We could do a whole episode on Obscurus and Graves and all this stuff, what Leta Lestrange is up to…

Eric: Bowtruckles.

Andrew: [laughs] “And now a whole episode on Bowtruckles.”

Eric: Bowtruckles! Thanks, patrons.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: But seriously, thank you. Oh, and you can email us. We don’t always plug our email, MuggleCast@gmail.com.

Andrew: Yeah, if you want to send in your feedback that way. Or on Twitter, twitter.com/MuggleCast. Facebook.com/MuggleCast. We’ll look at feedback all these ways. Okay?

Micah: All right.

Andrew: Till next time. Goodbye.

Eric and Micah: Bye.

Transcript #296

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #296, Gaunty


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, your Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts podcast covering everything about J.K. Rowling’s Wizarding World. Welcome to MuggleCast, Episode 296. Happy Fourth of July weekend to all of our American listeners, and I guess the people over in the UK can celebrate Independence Day with us, too, right?

Selina Wilken: [laughs] Too soon. Nope.

Eric Scull: Ooh.

Andrew: Hashtag Brexit. You know, I tweeted J.K. Rowling asking her if Brexit was going to affect the value of the Galleon, and she hasn’t replied yet.

Eric: Oh, interesting.

Selina: That’s so weird. It’s like she’s snubbing you now. How strange.

Andrew: Well, I want to know. I want to know if I should go buy Galleons or if I should hold off. Maybe now’s a good time to visit Hogwarts; it’s probably cheap. Or Hogsmeade. [laughs]

Eric: I don’t know about that.

Selina: Well, the wizarding world has been independent for years, so I think they’re okay.

Andrew: Yes. Yes, this is true.

Selina: Do you think the wizarding world is in the EU? That’s a whole other discussion.

Andrew: Tweet J.K. Rowling. Let’s get to the bottom of this.

Selina: [laughs] I will. She loves me.

Micah Tannenbaum: One question you should ask is if the Wizarding World in both Orlando and Los Angeles will now become cheaper for us to attend.

Andrew: This is a good point, yes. The answer is probably no. Universal plans to raise ticket prices every year.

Eric: And not lower them.

Andrew: Right, yeah. But actually, legitimately it’s a bad time for people over there in the UK to come visit now because of the value of the pound.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: Anyway, Selina, Micah, Eric, and I are here this week. We’re going to be talking about…

Selina: [laughs] Talking about Brexit.

Eric: Hey, everybody.

Selina: Welcome to BrexitCast.

Andrew: Yeah. We’re going to be talking about Ilvermorny. So J.K. Rowling finally revealed a ton of details about the American wizarding school on Pottermore, and the Houses and the Sorting test, so that’s all coming up on today’s show. But first of all, I just want to offer a quick plug for our Patreon because we just announced a new milestone and we’re close to reaching it. We’re not too many patrons away from hitting it; it’s the Mega MuggleCast Milestone goal, and what this is… we’re planning… if we hit this goal, we will bring back every single MuggleCast host – well, most; a very large majority of MuggleCast hosts – for a super duper mega episode in early September, and we’re just going to get the whole band back together to celebrate a new term at Hogwarts. And of course, we’re approaching a big MuggleCast anniversary, so all that is what we’re working toward as a milestone on Patreon. And just one other quick thing: This is the final month to sign up if you want to receive a T-shirt, so you have to sign up by July 31 to receive a T-shirt through Patreon. Full details are on Patreon.com/MuggleCast. And of course, you get lots of other benefits, too, when you pledge, and thank you to everybody who’s supporting us and who will be supporting us. So that’s that.


Main Discussion: Ilvermorny Houses


Andrew: Let’s get into Ilvermorny.

Eric: Yes.

Selina: Yay!

Andrew: What Houses are we all in? I am Pukwudgie.

Selina: So am I.

Eric: Ah, and I’m Thunderbird.

Micah: And so am I.

Andrew: Okay, I like this split. This is a good little split.

Selina: Me too.

Eric: [laughs] 50/50. Thunderbirds forever!

Andrew: So it was interesting. Basically what happened was they announced Ilvermorny and all the details and the Sorting test at the same time, and I kind of… my only critique about all of this is that it felt weird to me because when we took the Sorting Hat test, the Hogwarts Sorting Hat test on Pottermore all those years ago, we all knew the Hogwarts Houses very well at that point, whereas this, we were just suddenly thrusted into it, like, “Hey guys, here’s the school, here’s the Houses, now get Sorted.” We had no time to decide which one we wanted ourselves, which one we identified with.

Eric: Right, and when we got an answer…

Selina: Well, do you think that kind of…? Oh, go on.

Eric: It was like, “What did we just get?” So that was all.

Selina: Well, do you think it reflects how you’re Sorted at the different schools? Because I’ve been thinking a lot about this and how in Hogwarts it is kind of how you think of yourself, and in Ilvermorny, it kind of is the House chooses you, so you have a lot less autonomy. So actually, maybe it works out that we’re just thrust into a House. But I will say, though, I did have one criticism. I don’t know about you guys; my test was really short. It was less than ten questions, and I sort of felt like, “Is that it?” Like, do I really trust the answer based on that little? And some of the questions were super weirdly phrased and stuff.

Andrew: Well… hmm. I mean, it took me a while to take it because they were asking some deep questions in this test.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: There was that one, it was like, “Okay, ideal scenario: What answer would you want to hear to the question about the beginning of the universe?”

Selina: I know; I was like, “It depends on the question!” [laughs]

Eric: It was like, “Uh… what??”

Selina: Some of my answers definitely were a little bit, “Well, it could be any one of these five, so I’m just going to go with this one,” which felt a little… I mean, it just feels like… it’s so weird to see people be like, “Oh, I guess I’m a blah-blah-blah now,” when it’s like, “Well, are you really, though? How much do we trust it?”

Eric: Maybe it’s meant to be jarring. I don’t know. Maybe it’s… because in all this hubbub that’s happened in the week after, I’m just thinking maybe that was the point. Maybe Jo is just like, “They’re not the same. You shouldn’t think they’re the same.” And so Ilvermorny can get away with giving only seven questions to assess your entire… because ultimately, it’s less about personality, which…

Selina: It just makes me feel less connected to it. Because I’m like, “Yeah, I’m a Pukwudgie, but if I answered three questions differently, maybe I would’ve been something else.”

Eric: That’s true. Exactly, that absolutely makes a lot of sense, even to me. And I want to draw comparisons, and we all want to draw comparisons between Houses in any way. But it’s like, well, because this is so short of a quiz, and because it’s just thrown in there with the most basic traits associated with Houses – unlike the Harry Potter series, where there are seven books – it does feel like it’s intentionally trying to push us away from the mold that we’re so familiar with.

Selina: Right, and maybe that is true. But I will just say I’ve taken the quiz three times; the first time I got Pukwudgie, so that’s what I’m going with. The second time I got Wampus, and the third time I got Thunderbird, and I’m like, “Mmm.” [laughs]

Andrew: And that’s a whole other debate.

Micah: Do it a fourth time, Selina, and then you could be one of those people that only once a decade gets Sorted into all four.

Eric: Yes, you’re the Seraphina Picquery of 2016.

Selina: Yes. [laughs] I just feel like it’s unreliable.

Andrew: Right, and I don’t want to get into that side of the debate because that actually really annoys me, and I’m just out of Harry Potter complaining juice for this month. I tried to start writing an article about it, but I was like, “I can’t do this. I’m done. I’ve said enough this month.”

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Micah: But I think you raise a good point, though, because there’s no way that you can possibly be connected to these Houses in such a short period of time. I mean, think about all the years that you had to connect with Hogwarts and its four Houses, and I feel like these points have all been raised already. But the fact of the matter is J.K. Rowling wanted to be able to provide a Sorting process for this new school, given its connection to the new movie that’s going to be released later on this year, and I just don’t see that there’s any way that we could all say with definitive purpose that we are this House or that House. It’s like a quiz on… unfortunately, I hate to compare it to a Buzzfeed quiz, but that’s kind of what it is.

Andrew and Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: It is, yeah. It’s a personality quiz.

Selina: And that’s kind of my whole reasoning, because I know me and Eric sort of disagree very publicly on this…

Eric: Oh no!

Selina: … but that’s one of my reasons why I’m so quick to – I’m bringing it up, oh my God – no, that I’m so quick to say, “Well, how do we compare these to Hogwarts?” Because I still feel like the Hogwarts House is the ultimate, and I always… I found myself Sorting the Ilvermorny Houses into Hogwarts Houses when I was doing that comparison, because I was like, “I may as well.” [laughs] And I do think… I mean, we can talk about that, but I do think there is…

Micah: But that’s fair, though, because that’s your basis for comparison, though.

Eric: That’s the entire basis.

Selina: Exactly, exactly.

Eric: And Selina and I do not disagree that there’s a correlation between the Houses…

Selina: Okay.

Eric: … but it’s always a question about how do they fit, and what does it all mean?

Selina: Right.

Eric: If you get Thunderbird, and they’re said to be adventurers, well, is that Gryffindor? Because Gryffindor are adventurers. Well, you also have Slytherins who are bull-headed. All the Ilvermorny traits, do they line up? And where do they line up? Is sort of I think where everyone who’s taken this test’s head is at, because frankly, the writing does not… and I did enjoy the story. It’s lengthy, but it did not answer to our satisfaction the same kind of… it didn’t fill the void or provide a sense of belonging so much as just gave you a quiz result that you’re supposed to now… I mean, it now decorates your homepage.

Andrew: It’s just…

Selina: Well, I do want to say one thing, and then you can speak, sorry. I just want to say Ariana from Hypable actually had what I think is the best explanation for how they are different; she said Hogwarts versus Ilvermorny Houses is like your sun versus moon astrology sign. Hogwarts is what you project out and Ilvermorny is what’s going on inside of you, and I was like, “Ah, that makes sense. I like that.”

Andrew: The other thing – and this kind of hit me last night – it’s just for fun. It’s just… people are excited about this new Ilvermorny American wizarding school. It’s cool for us Harry Potter fans to know that J.K. Rowling has this school in her head here in the United States, and it’s just for fun, and this hit me last night when I was at a party with a group of people who are Harry Potter friends, and we were all just being… it was fun to hear what Houses each of us got Sorted into. It was just fun to go around the circle and say it, even though we couldn’t really elaborate on it because we don’t know much about these Houses, but still, it’s just fun. [laughs] That’s all I could say.

Eric: I would… yeah. Are you going to move on?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Okay. We’ll go back to Houses later.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, for sure. Well, so this next part, did we talk about this just now? I guess we kind of did, right? Yeah. But one thing I found interesting was the way that people were actually ending up being Sorted. It looks like – and this panel is a reflection of it – that most people were Sorted into Pukwudgie and Thunderbird.

Eric: This was interesting. This was very, very interesting.

Andrew: Yeah, unlike Pottermore’s Hogwarts test, which was evenly putting people in all the Houses – my theory was for House points reasons – everyone is… so according to the latest version of the poll, which we were running on Hypable, 38% are in Thunderbird. That’s the biggest. Second largest is Pukwudgie with 28%; 22% were in Horned Serpent; and then Wampus has had the smallest number this whole time with 12%.

Eric: And the question is just does this quiz measure different aspects of your person? Why is it that the majority of Harry Potter fans, regardless of what Hogwarts House they’re in, why are the majority of them in Thunderbird and Pukwudgie? How does that…?

Selina: Well, it might have something to do with the questions. I was thinking some of the answers just don’t make sense to me, and I’m thinking maybe other people have the same… they look for… maybe there are just some answers to these questions that are more common than others.

Eric: That’s interesting.

Andrew: Yeah, I agree with that, because… yes. And then there’s been breakdowns of where each Hogwarts House is ending up at Ilvermorny. [laughs] See, all this data has been fun to look through.

Selina: So cool. I like that.

Eric: Yeah, this is… you shared the poll on Hypable; there were the statistics from the Hogwarts… was it Running Club?

Andrew: Yeah, so they conducted their own survey and they gave us the data. So by the way, there is a running club for Harry Potter fans. It’s on Facebook. Like Eric said, Hogwarts Running Club, which is pretty cool.

Eric: Go check it out.

Andrew: Yeah. So the most interesting thing I found was that Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, and Ravenclaw…

Selina: Everyone’s in Thunderbird.

[Micah and Selina laugh]

Andrew: Right, well, besides that, Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, and Ravenclaw all had kind of equal splits in terms of where their students were going at Ilvermorny, but Slytherin had the most equal distribution across all four Ilvermorny schools. And we have pie charts up on Hypable, if you want to check them out.

Micah: This is a real statistical breakdown.

Andrew: Yeah, right? Yeah, thanks to a survey that the Running Club people did. Even BuzzFeed picked this up.

Selina: And all that tells me is that no one is getting into Wampus. [laughs]

Eric: Which is like, why? I don’t know; that would seem to be a more common House, I think.

Selina: I know.

Andrew: I was hoping that J.K. Rowling would take to Twitter to answer some questions about these Houses, because…

Eric: I think she still might, honestly. I mean, I was running infographics all week; I was taking… I have a poll as well with 1,100 people.

Micah: But she was doing nothing.

Eric: She was doing nothing!

Micah: I mean, Eric, you’re working so hard, and she’s not doing a damn thing.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: She’s too busy with Brexit.

Eric: I didn’t say that, nor did I even think it, but I do think that it’s very…

Micah: You implied it.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: No, the few people… well, I don’t have to say few people; the dozens of people – complete opposite – dozens of people I’ve engaged with over the last week about this House thing, this House crisis…

Andrew: [laughs] “Crisis.”

Eric: … this House puzzle, this mystery, because you’re talking about us potentially identifying with a new House that we know nothing about, so there’s that. That’s just what we said before. But the dozens of people I’ve interacted with over the last week, and the 1,100 people who have taken my poll, the 1,100 people who took Hogwarts Running Club’s poll, we all are interested in getting to the bottom of this, and this is something that J.K. Rowling addressed in one tweet; she said that the Houses were not equivalent. What she didn’t say is that they they don’t correlate or have anything to do with one another, so that’s very suspect. She could have elaborated further; she didn’t, so far as I’m aware completely yet. But it’s something that she can always elaborate on in the future; she can do another story on the Houses. It would seem to be time, considering we all took the test now; it’s like, “Well, okay, but what does it mean?” We still want to know, and are we going to realistically have to wait four months till November to maybe get a throwaway line about a certain House in Ilvermorny because we’re going to be interacting with wizards who went there for the first time on screen? Or is there going to be more writing? Or is there going to be more tweets, once she sees 2,000-word essays on Hypable from Selina…

Selina: [laughs] Going to read those now.

Eric: … and all these polls and infographics on tumblr and everything else all around that people are doing, trying to get to the bottom of this. I think a 140-character tweet is not enough to sate our desires and our curiosity.

Selina: And where is that Patronus quiz? Is it ever coming? I don’t think so.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Let’s just jump on Jo.

Micah: You will be Sorted, Selina, into the African School of Witchcraft and Wizardry before you get a Patronus quiz.

[Andrew laughs]

Selina: I’m sure that’s true.

Micah: But actually, that got me thinking, what you just said, knowing that Isolt… is that how you say her name?

Selina: Yeah, Isolt.

Micah: Isolt, that she never attended Hogwarts, so you could argue the fact that there really is no correlation between the two.

Selina: But the one thing that I made out in my article is that Isolt grew up with stories of Hogwarts, and actually, when she decided to build the school, her sons told her that they wanted Houses just like Hogwarts had Houses, and she always dreamed of being in Ravenclaw, and she made Horned Serpent, too, which supports that correlation. So I feel like what the Houses of Ilvermorny do reflect is her idea of what the Hogwarts Houses could be.

Micah: That’s fair.

Selina: Which actually, I really like that idea. I think that goes deeply into the text in a way that feels very J.K. Rowling to me.

Micah: Yeah, I will say that I know we spent a lot of time talking about the backstory that J.K. Rowling provided for the wizarding world here in America, but this particular piece that she released felt much more J.K. Rowling-like.

Andrew: Yes.

Selina: Yeah, so good.

Micah: I don’t know about if it was the same for the rest of you.

Selina: I really enjoyed it. I thought it was so… I’m still thinking like, “Oh, why is this not a…? Why does this have to be a summary?” It could so easily be a full story.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Selina: But the story itself, everything she said, I was like, “This feels very magical to me.”

Andrew: Yeah. By the way, did you guys agree with your initial House selections, reading the description? For example, Pukwudgie, mine, it says, “Named by James Steward, after the fiercely independent magical creature the Pukwudgie; Pukwudgie House is sometimes considered to represent the heart of a witch or wizard. It is also said that Pukwudgie favors healers.” I agree with the fiercely independent part. I mean, I at least feel independent. I enjoy being independent. I don’t know if I’m fiercely independent, but… [laughs]

Selina: You are if you want to be.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, I suppose so.

Eric: For me, I thought it was cool being Sorted into Thunderbird for adventurers, because I had been feeling… I don’t want to say kept in a box with Hufflepuff Sorting on Pottermore, which after reading the Hogwarts letter I actually fully completely agreed with, but I had been dressing as a Gryffindor all those years, as you all know, and I felt kind of cut off from the Gryffindor aspect, which to me is the bold, the brash, the adventurous, the brave. So getting Sorted into Thunderbird was like, hey, this is cool, because now I can feel like I’m still… it speaks to my interest in having adventures and travel and all that kind of stuff that’s part of me, but I had forgotten or not associated with a Hogwarts house. I could then sort of put into in the Ilvermorny Sorting.

Selina: It allows you to find a new side of yourself, I guess. I mean, Thunderbird is the coolest house; can we just all agree on that? [laughs]

Andrew: I think so, yeah. Is that the new Gryffindor?

Selina: I think so. It’s the best. That’s why I like equating it to Slytherin, actually, like I said in the article, too. I really like the idea that this explores… this might be what Slytherin could have been if not for all the negative associations and stereotypes of Hogwarts, because it is for those who internalize… it’s like smart Gryffindor; I say this having identified as a Gryffindor, so please don’t be mad at me. But that think things through more and that are very ambitious and very set out to do things for themselves, for the cause they believe in, and I like the idea that that could be the new cool House.

Eric: There’s also Wampus, though. There’s also the warriors. There’s also the body.

Selina: Yeah, that is the Gryffindor. [laughs]

Eric: So I don’t know. I don’t know. But what about Micah? What did you think, Micah? Thunderbird for you?

Micah: Yeah, I mean, I would not connect as much with the adventurous side of it, but how it broke down the representation of the witch or the wizard. The fact that it’s the soul of that individual, I thought was a really cool connection to make, and so that part of it I like. I mean, going back to Hogwarts, I was Sorted into Ravenclaw and I always thought that that’s where I fit. So it’s interesting to me that if we’re comparing Thunderbird to be more from a popularity standpoint Gryffindor, but I’ve also seen it compared to Slytherin, so it’s interesting to me that this is where I would end up. Although, I did get – when I went through and did the Sorting on Pottermore the first time – a Hatstall between Ravenclaw and Slytherin, so maybe this is starting to show my true colors.

Eric: Micah, you’re good for the soul.

[Micah and Selina laugh]


Main Discussion: The founding of Ilvermorny


Andrew: Let’s get into the Ilvermorny story. This was the… it was very exciting to get Sorted, but of course, there was this giant story here. First of all, just a basic: Ilvermorny is in the United States. It’s atop Mount Greylock in Massachusetts. There was some debate when they first revealed this map because it looked like it was sitting on the Canadian border, so people were wondering if it really wasn’t in America.

Eric: [laughs] I forgot about that.

Andrew: Yeah, I got into a Twitter war with somebody over that, so I was very excited to hear that I was right. [laughs] Anyway, Eric or Micah, do you want to lead us through this discussion?

Eric: Yeah, I will, no problem. Ilvermorny is situated, as it turns out, on the top of Mount Greylock, which is in part of present-day Adams, Massachusetts. Actually, the story is only slightly misleading here. It’s actually a three and a half-hour drive, hundreds of miles from where Plymouth is. In the story, Isolt Sayre – who we’ll get into in just a moment, who ends up founding Ilvermorny – sort of wanders from Plymouth settlement into… it just says into the woods, but she’s actually traveling across the entire state to Mount Greylock, which becomes the settlement for Ilvermorny, which is shrouded in mist and it’s a perfect location for a school that has to still be kept away from prying No-Maj eyes. God, did I just use that word? [laughs] It’s interesting, because this whole story, just as an overview when you’re going through it, there are I think deliberate connections to Hogwarts, both in that Isolt always wanted to go to Hogwarts and so did the kids that we learn about later in the story, but also that there’s some history that really ties in Isolt’s history. Isolt’s personal history ties into Hogwarts in a huge way. So getting into that, Isolt is a direct descendant of Salazar Slytherin, and I mean, surprise, surprise. Who clicked on “Magic in North America Part 5” and expected Salazar Slytherin to pop up?

Andrew: Yeah, definitely not…

Selina: I love that.

Andrew: Yeah, since the information we had heard about the school so far didn’t really connect to the Harry Potter characters we knew, so yeah, that was…

Selina: She’s really not letting the Gaunt family go, is she?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: No, they are deeply intertwined in the whole wizarding world, it seems.

[Selina laughs]

Eric: Yeah, so she’s a direct descendant of Salazar Slytherin, also a famous witch called Morgan, who they’re both described as being pure-blood families. And Gaunt, which you mentioned; Isolt has an Aunt Gaunt. Gormlaith, [pronounces it “Gorm-lathe”] would you say? How would you say this?

Selina: Gormlaith? [pronounces it “Gorm-lith”]

Eric: Gormlaith? Let’s all just agree for the purposes of this episode to say Gormlaith. [pronounces it “Gorm-lith”]

Selina: Okay.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Eric: Gormlaith is like the Aunt Petunia of the story. Well, in a way. But she’s also…

Micah: She’s far worse.

Eric: Far worse, yeah. The evil stepmother, let’s say, who essentially…

Selina: Yeah, this is basically Cinderella of the magical world.

Eric: Or is it Rapunzel?

Selina: I don’t know. Good question. [laughs]

Micah: We can get to that later. I know one of our listeners wrote in.

Eric: We got an email about… we got a message about… yeah, we’ll read that later, and it’s brilliant. But essentially Gormlaith Gaunt, pure-blood fanatic – surprise, surprise – doesn’t like the way that Isolt’s parents are interacting with their local No-Maj neighbors, healing them, offering potions, protecting them and their livestock, and decides to essentially kill them and kidnap Isolt and raise her as her own. So Isolt from the age of 5 is raised by Gormlaith and actually not allowed to attend Hogwarts, which is interesting. Gormlaith early on – this is 1605 or 1610 – has such scorn for what Hogwarts has become and that it did not become the school just for pure-bloods that Salazar Slytherin had wanted it to be, so that’s actually really cool.

Micah: So this is basically Harry Potter if Harry had decided to go off to another part of the world and start a wizarding school.

Eric: Maybe.

Selina: It’s really good, though. I like how closely it resembles, yet it’s totally different.

Eric: And so it’s not until Isolt is about 20, where she… it’s said that Gormlaith keeps her… she grew up in a area, actually a cottage, called Ilvermorny in County Kerry, Ireland. And Gormlaith moved her after her parents’ death to a local place – I think it’s called Hag’s Glen, is its colloquial name – but shrouded in Dark magic, and essentially Isolt is isolated from her local No-Maj neighbors. And it’s kind of sad, actually, in terms of… I actually would compare it to Harry, feeling alone and sort of orphaned from it all. She is sort of, in a way, Isolt is an orphan.

Andrew: Yeah. And just reading the story and learning about her, you just want a full story about her, because she seems like such a remarkable person. Such a badass, where she comes from.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah, and she’s a badass; she steals Gormlaith’s wand and escapes finally at the age of about 20 to America. She cuts her hair, she disguises herself as a man, and gets on the Mayflower, which travels to America. And she didn’t destroy her aunt; she just escaped, and so Isolt from this day forward lives in this fear from her aunt of retribution and that her aunt will find her. So first she moves to England, and then she moves to America.

Andrew: And then… enter the Pukwudgie.

Selina: Yay!

Eric: Enter the Pukwudgie. Oh, yeah. She wanders into the woods, 1,000 miles away.

Andrew: Sounds safe.

Eric: It’s several hundred miles; I’m actually typing it in right now, but I’ll keep talking. She wanders into the woods and encounters not one but two magical creatures that she did not know anything about. One is a Hidebehind, and the other is a, of course, Pukwudgie.

Andrew: Saying that out loud is… [laughs]

Eric: What, Hidebehind?

Andrew: Hidebehind, yeah.

Eric: Well, what does it do? What is its primary…?

Andrew: What does it do? It’s just… no, just it’s again something that… I mean, it is from American folklore; I did Google it. But it’s just something that when I first read it, I was like, “Is this another one of J.K. Rowling’s weird words that she’s inventing or…?” But yeah, no, I thought that was kind of entertaining.

Micah: Like Lethifold?

Andrew: Yeah, right. [laughs]

Eric: I like Lethifold; that’s one of my favorite beasts in the Fantastic Beasts. But yeah, she stumbles into the forest – which I looked, it’s 160 miles away from Plymouth – and actually winds up witnessing a Pukwudgie nearly destroyed, nearly eviscerated by this Hidebehind, and is able to somehow save the Pukwudgie. So this was cool; this is sort of an early indicator that Isolt has a lot of adaptive skill in the story. It comes into play, I guess, throughout the entire story, just that she has a kind nature. She wants to help and is actually quite capable despite her sheltered upbringing of… I guess doing what is what actually ends up working, of being successful at magic.

Andrew: As a Pukwudgie myself, I’m disappointed in William…

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Andrew: … that he needed help in fending off this Hidebehind, but all right, all right.

Eric: I think the point with that is these characters, these creatures are supposed to be that much more terrifying, right? So it’s just that it’s all fresh and new. Even the Pukwudgie, which the story says are very dangerous creatures, and normally you wouldn’t even want to approach a Pukwudgie…

Andrew: Damn right, don’t approach me.

Eric: [laughs] He’s fiercely loyal.

Andrew: Don’t approach Andrew the Pukwudgie.

Micah: Got your bow and arrow ready?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Normally you wouldn’t even want to approach a Pukwudgie, but she does to save it from a Hidebehind, which is a particularly nasty Hidebehind, even more terrifying, and was going to kill the Pukwudgie. So you get this new world aspect of it’s scary, it’s dangerous, it’s uncharted to Europeans, and they just don’t know what to expect. And so I guess this creates a blood debt for the Pukwudgie, who eventually is named William after Isolt’s father, because he will not tell her his individual name. And she nurses him back to health, and in turn, he introduces her to the local wildlife in terms of magic, and they begin sort of a… I guess he’s described as a curmudgeon; they have sort of a curmudgeonly friendship that naturally over the course of time evolves.

Micah: He reminds me of Kreacher.

Eric and Selina: Yeah.

Selina: That’s a good point.

Andrew: Yeah, even if you look at the Pukwudgie art on Pottermore, you get that. Is that what you mean? Or just based on his description?

Micah: Well, just from his behavior too.

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: I mean, just the idea of Pukwudgies – at least in terms of how they at the end of the story seem to serve Ilvermorny – remind me overall of house-elves. But William in particular, I was going to compare him to Dobby, but I think Dobby’s personality is a little too different. Kreacher falls in line with William, especially how he comes around at the end.

Eric: Yeah, I agree. And the story does say that Pukwudgies are distantly related to goblins, but I also see… I mean, for the purposes of the story, it seems that they’re closer to house-elves as well.

Andrew: So then how do we meet the next two?

Eric: So there’s some children in need, and actually sort of echoing the story of William and the Hidebehind, Isolt and William encounter… they hear a scream, I guess; they hear the sound of a mother and father being killed viciously, and these two boys, Webster and Chadwick Boot, are left alive after, unfortunately, their parents have died. And the very same Hidebehind that was going to kill William is finally destroyed. I guess it had escaped wounded; maybe they recognized it from a scar, but they knew it was the same one, and they finally killed it. But this actually becomes – and it’s very interesting – an issue of contention between Isolt and William, because William typically… and Isolt is an exception, but Pukwudgies don’t usually associate with humans; they don’t waste any of their effort or any of their time helping humans. This reminds me of a goblin connection. But it’s because of the blood debt that Isolt eventually grudges William into helping her carry the boys; all she wants is for him to carry the boys back to their sort of stone flap of a shelter, and he grudgingly agrees and then she dismisses him because they argued.

Selina: Yeah, it’s very sad.

Micah: So was the debt paid, though? Do you really feel like…? I mean, we know how the story ends, but…

Eric: Right, right.

Micah: Clearly, he was waiting for her. We can talk more about this later, but he was waiting for her to have that moment of need. And of course, he shows up, but it’s made to make you think that by him willingly carrying one of the boys back, that he is repaying his debt, which of course, we know. I guess my question is, did he know in that moment that he wasn’t repaying the debt and that it was still a possibility that he could be called on later to help her?

Selina: See, this is where we need more story, because this is where the emotion would come into it. We would love to see that scene play out between them.

Eric: Well, maybe we’re meant to form our own opinion on it. Do you think, Selina, that…?

Selina: But there isn’t enough for me to form my own opinion on it. That’s what I mean.

Eric: Oh, darn. Well, it’s going to be one or the other, though, right? Because in the story she specifically calls out and says, “As repayment of the debt that you owe me, help me take one of these children back,” and he’s like, “Ugh,” and he grudgingly agrees.

Selina: But he clearly… as we see from the story later, he still continued to keep… he still wanted to help her and he still wanted to stick around.

Eric: So is that his personal choice? Or is it that the blood debt was not…? I mean, I think we’re meant to – and it should be fairly easy – to just decide which is which.

Selina: Well, okay, as a Pukwudgie myself… [laughs]

Eric: Okay.

Selina: Maybe it’s just the heart thing; we’re going to take that literally and say that he actually does lead with his heart, right? And I would say that explains it.

Eric: Yeah, I would actually tend to agree, because I think it has a sort of beauty either way, but we’ll get to that, I guess, in a moment. So Webster and Chadwick Boot, surprise, surprise, turned out to be magical. Isn’t this beautiful? Isolt has stumbled upon these children, which she raises essentially as her own. But actually, at first, she needs to go back and bury their parents. She never got a chance to; things were so rushed, the children were injured. And she actually stumbles upon, returning to the site of the attack, this Muggle, this No-Maj dude. His name is James, and he’s just chillin’.

Andrew: Who’s the No-Maj in Fantastic Beasts? I’m trying to remember.

Eric: It’s not Jacob, is it?

Selina: Jacob.

Andrew: Jacob, that’s right.

Eric: Oh, it is Jacob.

Andrew: He’s the Jacob of this story.

Micah: Well, and it’s also coincident that his name is James, and there’s a moment later on in the story where he’s basically trying to die in protection of his children. And I just thought, “Really, Jo? You couldn’t come up with another name for a father who would die for love and protection of their child?”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Whoa! Okay, I take offense to that. My middle name is James. I love the name James.

Andrew: My middle name is James, too.

Eric: Your middle name is James, Emerson’s middle name is James… everybody cool has the middle name James.

Andrew: Micah, you’re just jealous.

Selina: Hey, I don’t! [laughs]

Eric: Oh, okay, well, Selina, what’s your middle name?

Selina: Isabella.

Eric: Isabella? I predict there’ll be a cool Harry Potter character named Isabella soon.

Selina: Well, not now.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Eric: How ’bout right now, Jo? But yeah, that is interesting, you’re right, Micah, and the parallels just keep coming. But essentially, they start a family, and this is how this works. It’s a bit Princess Bride-esque as you’re reading it, because Isolt initially fully intends to wipe James’s memory. What ends up happening is she goes to bury the body, she meets him, and he had befriended the boys, actually, on his ship over, and just happened to go in search of the family when they disappeared. And she fully intends to Obliviate him because she’s unable… she’s magically remedying these children in front of him and he’s not supposed to be able to see that kind of stuff. But eventually, they just fall in love despite all odds.

Selina: I know. It’s so nice.

Eric: She never Obliviates him. This is what I want in the story.

Selina: Okay, can I ask…? Because this is actually something… I know we’re trying to move on; it’s like breaking down an entire Harry Potter book in one episode.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I know; it feels like that.

Selina: So I have this thing – and I’m sure that Jo has a plan for it and it’s all fine – but I’m just wondering. You know in the American wizarding world at the time of Fantastic Beasts, there’s so much rules; we know that witches and wizards can’t marry No-Majes because of all the tensions, but I’m just thinking if you literally have the founders of Ilvermorny be a No-Maj and a witch, doesn’t that seem a little bit strange to you guys?

Eric: Yeah, it does.

Selina: I know there’s been a lot of tension since then, but it just seems like if literally the American magical community was founded by the union of a No-Maj and a witch… [laughs]

Eric: Yeah. No, it’s true, and I think somewhere in the story it says that Ilvermorny is one of the least elitist schools because it was founded… but then you look at what Jo has previously written on magic in North America and you find a world in which No-Maj and wizards are even further separated and have been persecuted and there’s been a lot of bloodshed between the two, much more so than in Europe, and you’re just like, “What?” So I think there is some…

Selina: Well, it’s all just a little hypocritical when they have a No-Maj to basically thank for everything that’s happened in the wizarding world.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, it is after all James who first develops the schematics for a cottage, even.

Selina: Exactly, yeah.

Eric: It’s not even… it’s not a castle at that point.

Selina: And his statue is in the castle, still, so we know that they are aware of him still.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Eric: But this family is very happy. They begin to have… well, they have two daughters, so actually James and Isolt… well, they fall in love, they marry, and they have two twin sisters. Two twin daughters, I should say. And it’s about this time where everybody’s favorite aunt – Aunt Sad Face, Aunt Frowny Face – Aunt Gormlaith, do we call her? Hears that there has begun a school across the pond and it’s called Ilvermorny.

Andrew: Aunt Gant, [pronounces both words like “ant”] is I think the word you’re looking for.

Eric: Aunt Gant? Thank you.

Andrew: Sounds better than Aunt Gaunt. [pronounces both words like “ont”]

[Selina laughs]

Eric: Aunt Gant, who in the years since her defeat apparently has not repurchased a wand to replace her missing one, gets a wand from Ollivander’s, also disguises herself as a man, travels under the name of Isolt’s father, William Sayre, comes across on a ship, and on one fateful evening confronts… or actually appears in the woods outside of Ilvermorny. And this is where the story just explodes in my mind; this is just where all the coolest stuff that you could think about happens in terms of its correspondent to the Harry Potter universe.

Andrew: Because of the power of love! As you note here.

Eric: Because of… the power of love is huge. Also, we learn that Slytherin’s wand, which Isolt has, which was Gormlaith’s wand previously, can be disabled.

Andrew: Oh, man. I need a flowchart for all this. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, this is great, right? The wand can be put to sleep. So Slytherin’s wand, which, by the way, has a core of Basilisk horn, which I mean, that just throws Chamber of Secrets right into relevance for me. Slytherin’s monster is a Basilisk; hell, it could be the same one. Maybe he told the Basilisk to sleep, and it was the same Basilisk that Harry encountered thousands of years later, or a thousand years later that was the one that…

Selina: It lost its horn since then, but okay.

Eric: [laughs] I think it had little spiky horn things, right?

Selina: Ah, maybe. Maybe it did.

Eric: Maybe. I don’t know. Let’s consult the prop department.

Selina: Its horn was… anyway.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah. But so Slytherin’s wand is made of Basilisk. He taught the wand to sleep, so there’s some word, and Jo is very clever to not say what it is, but it’s in Parseltongue, and she utters it, and it disables the wand.

Andrew: Why do you say she’s very clever to not say what it is?

Eric: Well, it’s just like Horcruxes, right? You’re not supposed to know what the process is.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Eric: I just think… there’s a scene in Narnia, in The Magician’s Nephew, where the White Witch freezes her entire planet and race in time and space, essentially killing them – it all but kills them – by uttering a single, what’s called “the deplorable word.” It’s the idea that a word has power. And similarly, this magic, Gormlaith says a curse that has their names in it, Isolt and James’s names, and it puts them into an enchanted sleep, like Sleeping Beauty? This is interesting new magic here.

Micah: But at the same time, what she doesn’t realize she’s doing is she’s enhancing the power of the wand cores for both Chadwick and Webster, which is made from the Horned Serpent.

Eric: And this was a part of the story we skipped over by accident, but Isolt can understand Parseltongue and has befriended a river Horned Serpent.

Selina: I think it says she can’t, but we’d have to check that. I just don’t want people to think…

Eric: Yeah, it says she can’t speak it, but she understands… she befriends it and is able to understand or comprehend what it’s saying to her.

Selina: Right.

Eric: So that’s weird. But anyway, her children’s wands are made from the horn of the Horned Serpent, and this Parseltongue that Gormlaith utters, which disables Isolt’s wands, actually notifies Chadwick and Webster. They get a little text message on their wand…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: … that says, “Hey, get up because it’s time to fight.”

Andrew: That’s pretty cool.

Eric: Yeah, it’s pretty, pretty cool.

Micah: And the whole backstory connection – we talked about Slytherin – but the fact that this dream that Isolt had, where the Horned Serpent told her, “Until I’m part of your family, your family is doomed,” of course, the way that this serpent becomes part of the family is by giving his horn and becoming part of Chadwick and Webster’s wand. And of course, if that didn’t happen, I guess we’re meant to believe that Ilvermorny would have been destroyed, so a bit of a prophecy included that comes true. I thought it was a cool little piece that got included there.

Eric: Absolutely.

Selina: I do think it’s sort of a recurring theme. I can’t decide if I like the symmetry or if I think it’s too heavy-handed, that the Gaunts are just continually confused by love. They just do not understand. [laughs] Gormlaith is… she has the same fall as Voldemort because she ultimately doesn’t… she underestimates the power of love, right?

Andrew: Yeah. I like that element of how they can’t…

Micah: Well, actually, she underestimates it first. Voldemort should have not made the same mistake as her.

Eric: Well, she didn’t… oh, yeah. I mean, I don’t know how much…

Micah: If he knew history. Clearly he did not study in Binns’s class.

[Andrew laughs]

Selina: No, he did not pay attention.

Eric: He clearly did not, yeah. I also will say that she didn’t hear anything that… the girls were infants. It’s the scream of the infants that wakes the mother and father, the terrified scream due to the destruction that’s at that point… it was in the yard; now it’s in the castle. But she had never heard the story of the young… nobody tells tales about the daughters yet because they’re just infants, so Gormlaith didn’t actually know that there was anyone else in the castle at the time, so there is that. I’m not trying to give her credit.

Micah: Well, she knew the daughters were there. She didn’t know that Chadwick and Webster were there.

Eric: No, she heard about Chadwick and Webster. I thought it was the children she didn’t know about, or else she would have put them to sleep.

Micah and Selina: No.

Micah: It’s the reverse.

Eric: Okay. All right. Well, I’ll go with you.

Micah: That’s why she was surprised when they came outside.

Eric: Right, and she is trying to discern who their parents were, or…

Micah: Yeah, because her whole purpose is to kidnap her nieces.

Eric: You’re right. You’re right.

Micah: Well, I guess… her grandnieces? Is that what they would be?

Eric: Yeah, she wants to start over with the two girls. You’re right; I was completely off. It’s essentially the story… history’s going to repeat itself. She wants to take the girls back to Hag’s Glen and raise them in her own image, the same way she did Isolt. So that’s actually kind of cool, but terrifying and sad if she were to have been successful.

Selina: All right, so what happens next?

Eric: Well, Chadwick and Webster give her a run for her money, but her Dark magic ends up pretty closely matching them, a little bit more. But there’s a moment where she’s about to kill James in what I imagine to be the bedroom, and Isolt, just not really knowing what she’s saying, shouts out, “William!” and William the Pukwudgie… Andrew and Selina on the windowsill appear and shoot arrows, or one arrow…

Selina: Yes, we do!

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: … one arrow into Gormlaith’s cold, dead heart.

Andrew: He has Katniss helping us too.

Selina: Of course. We’ve all been practicing.

Eric: [laughs] Katniss is in Pukwudgie. And Gormlaith dies.

Andrew: Peace out.

Selina: Yay! The witch is dead.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: She died much like Bellatrix. I don’t know if you caught that.

Eric: She did in the movie.

Selina: Yeah, she exploded into smoke.

Andrew: [laughs] Now that’s finally justified.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Andrew: Oh, that is canon. Okay.

Eric: Well, that’s what makes it interesting because what is… the story goes into an unusual sense of detail here by saying that the venom in William’s arrow reacts negatively with curses, particular curses that were used to prolong Gormlaith’s invulnerability or her life. Essentially, Gormlaith was a precursor to Voldemort in many ways, who had used Dark magic to extend her life or protect herself from death, and she just… nobody suspected or prepared for the foreign venom of the Pukwudgie arrow.

Selina: America!

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: [toughly] ‘Merica!

Andrew: [sings] America, F yeah!

[Selina laughs]

Eric: Yeah, so Gormlaith dies. Her Ollivander store-bought wand just bursts open and the day is saved. And it actually, I think, brings about an interesting change in the family. From that moment on, the girls who grow up… talking about the girls for a moment, Martha and… what would we say, Rionach? [pronounces the “ch” like “sh”]

Selina: Rionach, I think? [doesn’t pronounce the “ch” at all]

Andrew: Rionach. [pronounces the “ch” like “ck”]

Eric: Let’s say Rionach. [doesn’t pronounce the “ch” at all] Martha and Rionach. The story of Gormlaith Gaunt ends up just impacting everyone, I think, and they grow up kind of in fear of repeating that kind of malice. Martha, who it turns out is a Squib, marries a friend of hers from the Pocumtuc tribe, and Rionach, who teaches Defense Against the Dark Arts eventually at Ilvermorny, decides to never marry; presumably it’s a conscious decision to not further the line.

Selina: Yeah, and see, I was expecting a totally different reason she didn’t marry, and I was like, “Really, Jo?” [laughs]

[Andrew sighs]

Eric: Which were you expecting?

Selina: Well, I thought she was going to be a lesbian or something, and I was like, “Aw, that’s so cool.” And then it turned out she just literally didn’t want to marry.

Andrew: [laughs] She didn’t marry because she was a lesbian.

Eric: So the rumor is she could speak Parseltongue, and I guess given all the drama that had happened in her family, she saw it essentially as bad blood and decided not to marry or further the line. And actually, I think the story implies they would have or could have snubbed out the Gaunt line, had there not been more back in England. They would have essentially stopped Slytherin’s lineage from existing in the world entirely. And in fact, along those lines, Slytherin’s wand has a resting place, which absolutely 100% must come into play at some point in a story that she writes…

Selina: I hope not.

Eric: … within the next three or four hundred years of wizarding history. Slytherin’s wand is buried on the grounds of Ilvermorny, turns into a snakewood bush of indescribable species, whatever, comes up from the ground, grows, eventually produces, I guess, leaves with magical healing properties. But Slytherin’s wand remains inactive and is buried underneath this tree, or becomes this tree of sorts.

Selina: Oh, well, there you go, guys. This is how it all ties together because the next Harry Potter play is all about the characters going to America to find Slytherin’s wand.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Wow.

Eric: Is it Harry Potter and the Cursed Bush?

[Everyone laughs]

Selina: Exactly that title.

Andrew: I do think that’s really cool, though, how this wand is essentially a seed for a tree.

Selina: It’s like the Merlin story, isn’t it?

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t know much about that, but I trust you do.

Selina: Okay.

Andrew: [laughs] It kind of just shows you how the wand is very much a part of the earth. It’s based on what it’s made from. We always hear the ingredients that are in a wand, so yeah, I don’t know. I think it’s beautiful that it’s like a seed.

Micah: And I like how she said the best part of Slytherin seemed to have migrated to America, given the fact that, as Eric mentioned, this tree seems to have certain medicinal properties and be able to heal.

Eric: It’s also in its docile state that it does this, which is very interesting. So you have a wand that I would typically equate to an Elder Wand, right? It’s this badass wand; you can teach it to sleep so that your enemies can’t get a hold of it, all this cool stuff. But it ends up being rendered sort of moot in a really cool way. It still has the magic, the good benefits, as you said, but it’s not being sought after. I think it’s probably a well-kept secret what is at the heart of, the root of, that bush.

Andrew: Yeah. So let’s talk about the kiddies then, the children, what they went on to be.

Eric: Yeah, so as we mentioned, Martha was a Squib, which that’s actually really sad for me. I was thinking oh man, because Isolt is the product of two pure-blood families, James being a Muggle, they have two daughters to their own of their blood, and one of them is a Squib. And really, the saddest part is not that she can’t do magic, but that she’s raised in a wizarding school.

Selina: I know. That would suck.

Eric: It’s the Argus Filch. I feel bad for Filch while reading about Martha. There’s just this disconnect; she doesn’t feel like she’s fully part of the wizarding world, despite all her family. And she marries a No-Maj, and doesn’t necessarily move away the way Webster does, but is just forever one step away, at arm’s length, I guess. And that’s just sad when you hear about growing up in Ilvermorny not being able to learn magic.

Andrew: Yeah, that would totally suck. It’s like being at the party and just being the person who’s left out of all the fun.

Eric: Yeah. I mean, but then again, Rionach doesn’t have a happy life, either, necessarily. I mean, well, actually, let’s not equate whether a person’s life was happier or not based on whether they married. I guess that’s flawed.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: But she does have that determination to not further the line, which is no small thing. So she decides to die alone, I guess. Maybe we’ll find out more later. Webster, riffing off of his success at defeating or helping to defeat Gaunty – can we call her? – becomes an Auror for hire, and he actually returns to London and has a happy, prosperous life and family. He’s actually said to be repatriating a particularly Dark wizard of unknown name back to London and meets his wife and marries and eventually has children who have children who have children who have children who, 20 generations later, have Terry Boot, presumably.

Andrew: Okay. Little connection there. Good.

Selina: Yay, a tie-in.

Eric: A little connection. And Chadwick, then, the other child, is the author of Chadwick’s Charms, Volumes 1-7, which are standard texts at Ilvermorny. He marries a Mexican healer, Josefina Calderon, and the Calderon-Boot family remains one of wizarding America’s most prominent today.


Main Discussion: Ilvermorny today


Andrew: All right, so now we get to Ilvermorny today. This was the final section in Pottermore’s and J.K. Rowling’s big breakdown of it. The Sorting process… so there’s no Sorting Hat like there is at Hogwarts. To quote J.K. Rowling’s writing here, here’s how it happens at Ilvermorny: “While the rest of the school watches from the circular balcony overhead, new students file into the round entrance hall. They stand around the walls and, one by one, are called to stand on the symbol of the Gordian Knot set into the middle of the stone floor. In silence the school then waits for the enchanted carvings to react. If the Horned Serpent wants the student, the crystal set into its forehead will light up. If the Wampus wants the student, it roars. The Thunderbird signifies its approval by beating its wings, and the Pukwudgie will raise its arrow into the air.” Selina and I both experienced that; it was very exciting.

Selina: We did.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I like this Sorting a lot. I think it has a very epic feel to it.

Micah: It’s a lot cooler.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Selina: It’s better than having a voice in your head trying to argue with you about where you should go.

Eric: [laughs] I argue with myself all the time, yeah. I don’t need a hat I’m wearing to argue back.

Micah: I mean, there’s something that will always be unique about Hogwarts…

Andrew: Of course.

Micah: … but I just think that this process, at least to me, seems a lot cooler than having a dusty old hat put on your head.

Andrew and Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: And I could really visualize this in my head when I was reading this part of it. It just seems like something that, who knows, could maybe show up in Fantastic Beasts at some point, the movies.

Eric: Oh, yeah, that would be definitely interesting. The other thing that seems to happen, and maybe this is just Jo covering her bases because she introduced outside of the books the idea of Hatstalls; Pottermore exclusively talked about Hatstalls first, and then she went back and said, “McGonagall was a Hatstall,” and, “Hermione was almost a Hatstall,” and all this other stuff. Hatstalls! But so in this backstory, she actually talks about more than one House claiming a student, or we’re saying that… it might be covering your bases, or it might be that this just happens more often at Ilvermorny. I think the text’s a little ambiguous there.

Andrew: Well, based on the fact that people are taking this quiz – like Selina – and getting different Houses each time. [laughs] Maybe that all adds up now.

[Selina laughs]

Eric: Yeah, so it’s possible that it’s more common for people to be picked for more than one House. It’s their choice if that happens.

Selina: I just think it’s a bad quiz. I’m sorry. I’m sorry, Jo. Please forgive us. [laughs]

Andrew: Well, I will give you that you should get the same answer every time you take it, every time you personally take it.

Selina: Yeah, and I mean, but you’re never going to get that with an online quiz. And I think that’s why something like Hogwarts feels so more real to us, because we literally have online quizzes, we have every single character in Hogwarts making up the canvas of what that House stands for – well, not really so much for Hufflepuff and Slytherin; we’re really stereotyped. But for Gryffindor and Ravenclaw both, you have like, oh my God, this huge selection of people that tell you, “Okay, it’s about something deeper inside of you.” Here it’s literally just like, “Oh, what House are you going to be today?” If I answer “I am the strongest when I’m awake,” I get this House. [laughs] I don’t know. Yeah, I need a book. I need a book. That’s my answer.

Eric: I wonder if… and the only way this is going to probably really work is once the Fantastic Beasts movies come out, plural, and we start meeting American wizards and maybe in passing finding out what Houses we are in, they will begin to embody our understanding of each of those Houses.

Selina: Yeah, yeah, I think so.

Eric: I mean, to a certain extent, the story does attempt to say that the Houses take on the qualities of their founders; Webster, Chadwick, James, and Isolt. Each have their own House and their personalities leak into them. But I think the story is too short to really be able to gain much out of it in terms of what that means.

Andrew: So as we mentioned earlier, once a decade a student is placed in all four Houses, and here comes a Fantastic Beasts movie connection…

[Selina gasps]

Andrew: Seraphina Picquery, president of MACUSA from 1920 to 1928; she is one of those people who was Sorted into all four Houses. Now she, as I just said, is the President of MACUSA during the movie, and we’ve seen her in the trailer already, so that’ll be interesting. I guess she’s a very unique type of person if she’s Sorted into all four Houses. [laughs] Is she like a Hermione? She’s just very skilled? Can do anything?

Micah: Could be.

Eric: I have a feeling that we will be getting a lot of story on Seraphina, if not in the films, then a backstory on Pottermore.

Selina: Well, that’s actually interesting, because she’s the Minister – or the President, the President of Magic – until 1928, and the first Fantastic Beasts movie takes place in 1926, so something happens.

Andrew: Is it 1926? Or is it a couple of years earlier? I thought it was…

Selina: I just read it to be 1926, but I just went to Wikipedia.

Eric: You know what, though? That’s eight years. Maybe they have four-year terms, like in the US.

Selina: Maybe, yeah, but then maybe we’ll see a new Minister or President of Magic.

Eric: I wonder.

Andrew: Yeah, well, based on what’s happening in Fantastic Beasts, she is going to be getting involved because of this leak because of Muggles finding out about magic, so she could potentially step down on her own or she could get thrown out.

Eric: Be deposed, or yeah, thrown out. I think this is the second or third time that Pottermore has mentioned Seraphina, though; she was mentioned in the last piece on magic in North America, in terms of… I think it’s Magic in 1920s North America is the segment, but her origin is explained a little bit. She’s from Savannah; I assume that’s Savannah, Georgia. She becomes president, and we’ve seen her in all the trailers and stuff. So I think she has a big role to play, because she’s popping up in all these different areas. I mean, she just sort of gets called out in this story, which is not about anybody that’s not the founder of Ilvermorny as being one of four Houses.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. And then couple other facts here about Ilvermorny: The students don’t receive the wands until after they are Sorted, which is interesting. That differs from Hogwarts. The robes are blue and cranberry. Now, someone reminded me when I was at CinemaCon a couple months ago, they showed this Fantastic Beasts preview, and there’s this very quick glimpse of a group of what looked, to me, students, and they were wearing red. Now, I didn’t see any blue, so I’m still not sure if those were Ilvermorny students in that shot. But you know what? Come to think of it, now I’m thinking about it, I feel like they did have an emblem that looks like that Ilvermorny one that they released on Pottermore. Hmm. I think we’re going to see a group of Ilvermorny students.

Micah: Time for some more detective work.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: We’ve got to go look at this, yeah. Bye, everybody.

Andrew: I think we’re going to see a group of Ilvermorny students in the film. I will make that prediction now. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, man.

Andrew: So my guess is if those were, the robes are cranberry and then underneath they’re blue, because they were wearing…

Eric: A blue inseam?

Micah: Because James likes cranberries or something like that, right?

Eric: Cranberry pie.

Selina: Yeah, pie.

Andrew: That’s so funny. That is so funny.

Micah: Yeah, you don’t need a better reason sometimes. It’s just… that’s enough.

Andrew: [laughs] That’s enough. “What should we color our robes? Well, I just had some cranberry hot pie; it tasted pretty good. Let’s do red.”

[Selina laughs]

Eric: “You’ve got cranberry pie on your nose; did you know? Just there.”

Selina: Or they made them blue and then he spilled cranberry pie all over himself, and they were like, “Oh, that looks nice.”

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: “That goes well together, yeah.” Not having had a formal art education among the four of them, they just thought it looked nice.

Andrew: That makes sense, sure. Why not? And then finally, Eric…

Eric: Yes, history time again. Pukwudgies continue to work at the school…

Andrew: We do.

Eric: … including one particular very old Pukwudgie, whose name is William.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: Oh, and Andrew, I guess.

Andrew: Ignore me. I’m just being goofy; ignore me.

Eric: [laughs] There’s a Pukwudgie who on the anniversary of Isolt’s death polishes her statue and lays mayflowers at the bottom of it. I teared up while reading it the second time on Pottermore. And he laughs off the idea that he’s the original William, but is oddly defensive all things considered of Isolt’s statue. And to tie into the beauty that Jo can sometimes evoke in her writing, to me bookending the story with death – the death of Isolt’s parents and eventually the death of Isolt and James – William, who has been blessed with presumably an unnaturally long life, has witnessed his loved ones passing. Isolt and James, these amazing people, lived and died, right? Their school lives on, their majesty and accomplishments live on, but ultimately, William is shown grieving or paying tribute to the fallen. And so for all the Gormlaith Gaunts, for all the Gaunties out there who want to live forever, these great witches and wizards whose story we got did end up dying, and they’re gone now, and all we have is a statute to them. So I thought it was particularly evocative of Jo’s general message as in Harry Potter.

Micah: Well, and also bookending it with two Williams, right? So you had, as you mentioned, the death of William at the beginning, but also knowing that there’s still a William on the grounds of Ilvermorny in a way protecting his daughter, and I think that that was very well done. And who knows, I mean, it could be a descendant of a descendent of a descendant of William, and as time passes, it’s passed on from one to the other that they need to be protective and respectful of Isolt. But I like the idea that it is the original; it’s stated that we don’t know how long Pukwudgies live, so he could live hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years. But yeah, that’s what the writing of J.K. Rowling… when I was talking about earlier how this felt very much like one of her stories, it’s things like that that she’s able to weave in there that just harken back to when she was writing the Potter series.

Andrew: Yeah. And that is Ilvermorny, ladies and gentlemen.

Selina: Yay.

Andrew: Eric, thank you for leading us through storytime.

Eric: Oh, yeah. You’re welcome. Please return the pillows to the back of the class before walking out the door.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: No, I peed myself. I peed on the pillow during the scarier moments. Sorry.

Eric: Oh, damn, Andrew. Not again.

Micah: Convenient.


Listener feedback


Andrew: [laughs] Convenient. So on Patreon we asked our supporters a question, getting back to the Houses and the Sorting. I wanted to know in what ways people’s Ilvermorny Houses and Hogwarts Houses collectively reflect them, and do you see why J.K. Rowling assigned you these two Houses in particular?

Eric: That’s a good question.

Andrew: Because a lot of people… the biggest question, as Eric hinted at earlier, is that a lot of people were desperately looking for the Hogwarts/Ilvermorny connections, so I’m just going to read… we got a ton of responses, and thank you to everybody who submitted; it was fun to read all these. And patrons can continue to read all them, but I’m just going to read the first few here. Helen said, “I’m a Ravenclaw, and I’ve always been quite geeky and bookish, but I am also a pharmacist, so the healer side of Pukwudgie fits too.” I think that’s beautiful. I mean, that is a great connection for you. [laughs]

Eric: Pretty good.

Andrew: I’m certainly not a healer in any way, so I’m confused by my Pukwudgie-ness.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Jennifer says,

“I am Slytherin and Thunderbird. I know I am ambitious and can be manipulative and slow to trust, so I identify with Slytherin a lot. I didn’t think of myself as adventurous, but someone online said Thunderbirds make decisions based on experience and that makes sense. I’m a physicist, and if I need to go on an adventure to get the data I need to make an informed decision, then that is what I will do. I’m mostly waiting until the movie comes out to see what new info on the Houses we will have by then.”

Elizabeth says,

“I am a Hufflepuff and Thunderbird. I can see why I am Hufflepuff; I am laid-back, a hard worker, and loyal. However, I’m still a bit confused about Thunderbird. I never really considered myself to be adventurous. Maybe just in my daydreams, haha.”

Selina: That’s cute.

Andrew: Yeah. And one more here, or two more. This is from Chase: “I landed Gryffindor on my Hogwarts Sorting and Pukwudgie on my Ilvermorny. Initially, I was a little upset. Let’s be honest; Wampus just sounded so cool.” Okay, Chase.

Eric: [laughs] It’s described as being an unkillable beast; it’s pretty cool.

Andrew: [laughs] Oh, well, that is cool, yeah.

“But after reading all the available lore Jo has provided thus far, I’m more in love with my Ilvermorny Sorting than my original Hogwarts. Everyone knows the story of Gryffindor by now, so I’ll spare the details and characters’ traits, but I see a lot of the same characteristics in Pukwudgie: courageous, caring, kind, to name a few. But the hidden ‘Don’t mess with us’ traits Pukwudgies carry is what really sold me on the House. I’ve always felt I was a little too cold-blooded, so to speak, to be a true Gryffindor, but with Pukwudgie and my apparent school-legal poisonous darts, it totally fits.”

Andrew: [laughs] “School-legal.”

Selina: And that’s where I feel like the connection between the stuff you show and your inner life, like why you act the way you do, sort of comes in and makes the two schools’ Sortings go so well together, is because what you… say you’re a Gryffindor, right? Hermione is a Gryffindor, Harry is a Gryffindor, Neville is a Gryffindor; these are all people, if we were fantasy Sorting them, we would probably Sort them into Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff and maybe Slytherin for Harry. But because they were all Sorted into Gryffindor, they come to be defined by their bravery, and this is like, “But why are you brave?”

Eric: Right.

Selina: Are you brave for your…? Are you the person who is guided by your body, or are you guided by your soul or your need for intellect or your kindness? And you can still be a Gryffindor.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. Well, you have those anomalies, too, like Peter Pettigrew, who’s Gryffindor, and it’s like, “Well, how does that work? Is there more to it?” So there’s a post on Tumblr I want to read here real quick by TheConsultingDramaQueen. This was being shared around on Tumblr a lot, and I happened to come across it, even though I’m rarely on Tumblr. But it says – this is also just sort of a theory – but it’s,

“Hogwarts Houses are chosen based on traits you consider important and value beyond yourself (so Hermione thinks bravery is more important than ‘books and cleverness.’) That’s because the founders wanted to see those values in others. On the other hand, the characters of the Ilvermorny founders ‘leaked into the Houses,’ so it seems to divide along the lines of how you define yourself and what tools you prefer to use in your own approach to life.”

So under that theory, Horned Serpent means “I am defined by what I think,” which is scholars and mind; Wampus is “I’m defined by what I do,” warriors and body; Thunderbird, “I’m defined by my experiences,” adventurer, soul; and Pukwudgie, “I’m defined by what I feel (or maybe love),” healers, heart. I thought that was very interesting.

Selina: That works very well, yeah. That works for me.

Micah: Well…

Selina: I do want to shout-out, though… oh, go on.

Micah: Well, I mean, I just don’t want to crap all over people’s thoughts and theories…

Andrew: But here I go.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: But here I go. No, and I mean it in a good way. But if we just look at it from a story standpoint, if you go back to Hogwarts, it seems like it was founded by four of the most intelligent and powerful witches and wizards of their day, right? There’s almost an elitist touch to it. Versus going to Ilvermorny, you have somebody who’s of pure blood in Isolt, but then you have a No-Maj in James, and then you have two kids in Webster and Chadwick.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: So how they come about the Houses – Chadwick goes with Thunderbird, Webster with Wampus, Isolt with the Horned Serpent, and James with the Pukwudgie – I’m not sure there’s as much in-depth thought that’s been provided to these Houses than, say, back at Hogwarts with the four that were created by the founders.

Eric: I think that’s fair. I mean, Chadwick just thinks that the Wampus is cool, right? So there’s that.

Selina: But that’s why I think they… I mean, when she says, “It is said that they correlate,” it’s not like that is actual fact that they are the body and the mind and the soul, etc. But I do like that thing that Eric just read out; I feel like that’s what we all want to believe, and it kind of goes along with we all kind of also, I think, assign more importance to Hogwarts Sorting than we know there really is, because again, you mentioned Pettigrew, and we know that some people are literally able to choose their own House. And we know that people change when they get older, and they might… was it Dumbledore who said he might have been Sorted differently? So I feel like… I mean, we all sort of say, “I am a Gryffindor!” but really, it’s maybe because we wish we were a Gryffindor. And I think that speaks a lot to Sorting in general; it’s more like what you feel like you are as opposed to what you actually are. But what I was going to say earlier is just that I feel like I should shout out… we have on Hypable – it comes up every once in a while, but maybe we can link it in this – I think it was Katie, did a quiz called “Your hybrid Hogwarts House,” which I always loved because it’s like, rather than saying, “I have to fit myself into this very square little box,” you go, “Well, what is my…?” You always overlap. You always say, “Well, I’m a Gryffindor, but I also see myself being in Hufflepuff or Slytherin or Ravenclaw,” etc. And it’s a very good quiz, a very detailed quiz, and you find the two Houses that reflect you and I think that’s a lot more balanced. And it kind of reminds me of what’s going on here, when you have a Hogwarts House and an Ilvermorny House, and together they define what you are.

Andrew: Yeah, absolutely. Now we have to create a quiz that combines hybrid Hogwarts and hybrid Ilvermorny.

Selina: [laughs] I’m a Thunderpuff.

Eric: Well, you know what? I will shout-out my infographic, then, because I thought that the Hogwarts Houses and Ilvermorny Houses might overlap if they were turned at a 45 degree… turned sideways a little bit, so if an Ilvermorny House could equal two Hogwarts Houses. And this was just a theory, so I sketched something down real quick, wrote it on paper, and it turns out a longtime friend of the show, Jen Levine – who we’ve known for a decade now – actually made an infographic in PowerPoint, which I really like and shared over on MuggleCast, so check that out. It’s not official. Actually, it’s quite flawed based on everybody getting Thunderbird or Pukwudgie.

[Selina laughs]

Eric: But it was a lot of fun to think about, and that was really just looking back over the last weeks; between this story airing and us recording the MuggleCast about it, what I will remember most fondly is just how excited everyone was, and how this sparked great discussion and had a lot of fun things. I’m still collecting data on my poll; maybe I’ll share that on Google. It’s a Google form. It asks what House do you most identify with at Hogwarts, what House do you second most identify with in Hogwarts, and what House were you Sorted into in Ilvermorny?

Selina: Oh, nice.

Eric: And it’s just, again, it’s guessing if there’s… what traits are matching up? And that’s so… we’re just trying to… I have an MIT graduate doing the data crunching, the number crunching…

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: … so results to be concluded, let’s just say that. But I’ll link it in the show notes. But let’s just… it’s this cool idea that somehow affects how we define what we are, think about defining what we are, based on this not complete information on this fictional wizard school, but it’s sort of what we do.

Selina: Yeah. I just wish there was a better quiz. With everyone doing all this work instead of being like, “I am a Thunderbird, therefore…” and I’m like, “Yeah, but are you really?”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: No, yeah, I don’t know.

Andrew: Remember, it’s just for fun. This is just fun…

Selina: What? No! What, are you kidding me? [laughs]

Andrew: … and I think we shouldn’t take it too seriously.

Selina: 296 episodes in and you say we shouldn’t take this too seriously?

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: Remember “No theory is safe”? [laughs]

Andrew: Well, and to get back to Selina’s point earlier, I think, Selina, you said that no quiz could get this right, no matter who did it. I think you could create a quiz that actually got this right every time you took it; same answer.

Selina: I agree, I agree. I just wanted a longer more in-depth quiz, basically. I would probably trust it more than seven questions.

Micah: The only way to get it right is to go to Ilvermorny and get Sorted.

Andrew: Let’s find it. I’m sure Massachusetts’s tourism board is already figuring out how to make some money off of this. Couple of comments from patrons who are listening live: Ryan says he loved your infographic, Eric; he thought it was the best comparison between the two schools he’s seen so far, so there you go.

Eric: Thanks, dude.

Andrew: And Nicole points out – [laughs] getting back to the annoying part of this quiz – she says, “I’ve been watching YouTube videos of people taking the Sorting quiz, and it seems that there are different versions of the quiz. Some of them had questions I didn’t have when taking it.”

Selina: There was actually… I think it’s… I don’t know where it is, but you can Google it. There is a quiz somewhere that has all the questions, and I don’t know how they determine the answers, but I guess they cracked the code or whatever. So you can actually take the complete quiz, which maybe gives you a more accurate result. I got Wampus on that one.

Andrew: Oh.

Eric: Yeah, HP Wikia has all the questions published – I know that much – and screenshot images of the questions. Also, somebody was claiming that they got the same questions, answered the same way, and got different Houses, and that just destroys all of my hope.

Selina: Ohh.

Eric: That destroys everything that I ever think was sacred about Pottermore.

Selina: Right.

Eric: It was always a question, right, Andrew, when you pointed out that it could be a conspiracy that everyone was getting even amounts on Pottermore with the first Hogwarts Sorting quiz.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: I began… I think that it would be very scandalous if this Ilvermorny thing we’re doing… not the same thing, but again, what does it all mean if they’re not applicable? Why would you introduce the Sorting quiz with the story, giving all the traits, and if they are applicable, then why aren’t we getting more even quantities or…? It’s just very confusing. We live in a time of confusion.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Selina: So uncertain!

Andrew: We have an email here before we wrap up the show. This is from Meron; she says,

“I’ve been a long time listener to MuggleCast! You all are absolutely amazing, and listening to your podcast almost seems as if I’m listening to three or more of my closest friends talking about the topic I love the most! I just wanted to share a few thoughts I had while reading Jo’s new story on Pottermore about the history of Ilvermorny. First of all, sorry for being the one who relates everything to the Disney universe, but I was definitely feeling some serious Rapunzel vibes throughout Isolt’s story. The two stories obviously don’t match up completely, but Isolt was kidnapped and raised by her terrifying aunt who valued her only for her pure-blood ancestry, just as Rapunzel was kidnapped by a woman who valued her only because of her beautiful hair. Also, a way for Isolt to distance herself from her aunt was to cut off her hair, which gives a portrayal of how Rapunzel and her kidnapper’s connection would have been broken. I also admire the fact that Isolt’s story is the quintessential story of reaching the American Dream. Isolt starts off as a poor, young child who constantly lives in the shadow of her traumatic past and is chained to a woman that uses and manipulates her; however, it is her own hunger for freedom that pushes her to take the risk of immigrating to a country that she has no clue about at such a young age in search of a better life and to bravely fight through a large number of obstacles to achieve her own sense of comfort and belonging and success. Isolt’s story is a story which many Americans have shared and will continue to share for many years to come.”

Andrew: [laughs] She includes the hashtag here “#Don’tVoteForTrump.”

“It’s great to see that Jo was able to include that sense of the American Dream into her story of Ilvermorny School.”

This is a beautiful email. So on point. I hadn’t thought of this angle before reading this, so thank you, Meron. And do you guys see the Rapunzel part better now? Because weren’t we talking about that earlier? Somebody said Rapunzel.

Eric: Yeah, I’ve got to look at the… yeah, it’s her aunt who kidnaps her and takes her way to exclusion. I’ve got to read the original. I know exactly who I’m going to ask about this as soon as we get off the call about the original fairy tale and how it may or may not have been distilled into Disney’s Tangled. [laughs] Or was it DreamWorks’s Tangled?

Andrew: No, it was Disney.

Eric: Because that I’ve seen more recently, but that aunt in that movie is how I sort of picture Gormlaith.

Andrew: Isolt wanted to #MakeHerLifeGreatAgain, by going to America.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: God. No, definitely. I think it’s a good email, and want to thank Meron, and all our listeners for continually being…

Andrew: Smart.

Eric: … and on Patreon, too, continually being… yeah, finding connections and posting about them and sharing them with each other.

Andrew: Yeah. So that’s what we got for today’s episode, a whole Ilvermorny episode. We will be back later this month to talk about some other news that’s been going on, and I’m sure we will have more to say about Ilvermorny. And our plan right now is early August we’ll probably do Cursed Child. Obviously, there’s going to be a lot to talk about with the Cursed Child once everybody gets their hands on it; it comes out later this month.

Selina: Eh, I’m done talking about it.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: We’ve been talking about it a lot, haven’t we? No, there’s going to be so much more to talk about. Eric and I, by the way, will be at GeekyCon in Orlando for their Cursed Child midnight release party, and we’ll be doing probably a couple panels there as well. You can go to GeekyCon.com for more details. It’s July 29-31.

Eric: Oh, next week I will be at Leviosa; it’s a Harry Potter con. It’s actually this week, now that it’s Sunday. The end of this week; I think it’s Thursday through Sunday. Leviosa.org. Check that out if you’re in the Las Vegas area, or it’s just a three hour drive from Los Angeles. Andrew, come to Leviosa.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: It’s a Harry Potter con, and for me it’s personal because it’s the 10th anniversary of Lumos, which was I guess MuggleCast’s first live podcast at a con.

Micah: Yeah, I was going to say, we did one before that.

Eric: We did one before, yeah, it’s fairly notable; you may have remembered that. But no, the first convention that MuggleCast went to, and the first convention I went to. So it’s 10 years and it’s in Vegas, so that’s pretty cool.

Andrew: Yeah, same for me. That was my first time flying. And in honor of the 10th anniversary, I’ll admit this for the first time: first time having a drink of alcohol.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Very exciting.

Micah: You can say that now, Andrew,

Andrew: [laughs] I’m comfortable coming out with that.

Eric: I think MuggleCast had its own resident bartender, if I’m remembering correctly.

Andrew: Maybe, maybe.

Eric: Yeah, but it was a good time, though. It was really wonderful, and excited to be back in Vegas this week, so come to Leviosa, and if not, come to GeekyCon.

Andrew: Right. Very excited for everybody to read Cursed Child, by the way. I can’t wait to get everybody’s thoughts. We’ve been getting some feedback from people who are seeing the play; some people did agree with us, so there was that. And we will… one thing we got on the last episode; people were saying, “Well, why didn’t you have more people who actually saw the play on the last episode?”

Selina: Yeah, Andrew. [laughs]

Andrew: Well, it was a recording… it was a scheduling issue. We wanted to get it out as soon as possible. Maybe we should have waited.

Selina: Yeah, yeah…

Eric: But check the Hype episode, right?

Selina: Thanks, Eric. I was just going to say, actually, I was thinking about it… I was like, “Well, why didn’t you have us on?” but then I was listening to your episode and actually I really enjoyed hearing Eric and Micah react to the story because I think that’s how a lot of people will get to experience it. I know that it’s hard to judge the story in isolation, but unfortunately, that is how the majority of the Harry Potter fandom will judge the story, so I thought it was fair. And also, that way, you’re the MuggleCast spoiler episode, and Hype’s spoiler episode sort of stand apart because Hype, the Hypable.com’s podcast Hype, had only people who had seen the play on it. Myself, Donya, what’s her face… what’s her name…

Andrew: [laughs] What’s her face.

Selina: Katie! [laughs] Katie and Kyle were all on it…

Andrew: And all saw it.

Selina: … and had a discussion that complemented… we all saw it, yeah, so that sort of complemented yours, and they sort of…

Eric: Selina, did I tell you that Donya brought me a button? She brought me a “Keep the Secrets” button?

Selina: Did she?

Andrew: Aww.

Selina: Well, too late for that. [laughs]

Eric: I know, I know. But she probably…

Selina: You feel unworthy of the button?

Eric: Kind of. I saw her at IndyPop the weekend after, and she got me the button and I wanted to cry, and then I was like, “I don’t deserve this.” And I just kept going back to Andrew’s tweet, which was amazing, where he said the button blew up in his face because of the curse or the magic.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Selina: I have like, three in my drawer, and I’m ashamed when I look at them.

Eric: I know, I know. But it’s… [laughs]

Andrew: We want to… what was I going to say? Oh, a few of us, including Eric and I think Selina, too – and Maroma; she wrote a piece on Hypable this past week about it – it’s becoming more and more apparent, in several of our opinions, that “Keep the Secrets,” that campaign is more about not letting the spoilers get out because it will turn people off from the story. It’s not so much like, “Oh, the fans need to… they can’t hear what’s going to happen.” They don’t want people to know what’s going to happen because it’ll probably… it could affect book sales.

Selina: Well, they need enough people to see the play live so that when the story comes out, if people don’t like it, enough people can say, “No, no, but the play is amazing.”

Andrew: Right.

Selina: Because it literally is amazing, so they’ll have that army of people ready to support the production, and that’s why this play is in preview for seven weeks. I mean, that’s a long time.

Eric: And this is – I’m starting to countdown now from time of recording – four weeks exactly until the book comes out.

Selina: Dun-dun-dun.

Andrew: I’m excited.

Selina: Me too.

Eric: I do want to read it, yeah.

Andrew: No spoilers, but I started working on something for Hypable that I’ve never done before. It’s something that I’ve never written before.

Selina: Uh-oh, I’m excited.

Andrew: Oh, I’ll just say it: I’m writing a fanfiction. [laughs]

Selina: Oh, yeah! [laughs] This is so cool.

Eric: This is going to be like Andrew’s wizard rock single. Can you debut it on MuggleCast?

Andrew: Yeah, maybe I’ll do a live reading here on…

Selina: You should do a live reading.

Micah: I thought you were going to say you’re writing an article.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: No, no, I’m writing a work of fanfiction. I don’t know how it’s… it’s going to be really bad; I just know that from the start.

Selina: It’s going to be so good, you guys.

Andrew: It’s going to be a little sexy.

Micah: Well, if it’s bad, that definitely means it’ll be good, because that’s generally how that stuff works.

Andrew: [laughs] Micah, you just insulted the whole fanfiction community.

Eric: Yeah, let’s quit while we’re ahead on this, guys.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: But the reason I’m writing it is because something doesn’t happen in the play that I wish did, so I’m making that happen now.

Eric: Oh, you may or may not have mentioned that on our spoiler episode, so there’s that.

Andrew: Yes, you probably know what I’m talking about if you listened to our spoiler episode.

Eric: I support it. I think that’s good. I think that’ll be great.

Andrew: Okay. [laughs] So it’s going to be an interesting time on the Internet once this book comes out, I think that’s for sure.

Eric: It’s an interesting time on the Internet now. It’s such an interesting time to be a Harry Potter fan….

Andrew: It is interesting.

Eric: … and to start seeing content like this coming out, and other Sorting quizzes. No Patronus quizzes, but another Sorting quiz. Some answers about what North America has been doing in the wizarding world. And this is something that… it’s an avalanche leading into November.

Andrew: Exactly. That puts a nice bow on it. Before we wrap up, just want to do another quick plug for our Patreon; like I said, this is the final month to sign up before we close off… the opportunity is going to close at the end of this month, so pledge within the next few weeks if you would like to receive a brand new MuggleCast shirt. We released the designs a few weeks ago, and we’re really proud of them and we can’t wait to wear them ourselves. And you’ll also get lots of other benefits, including vlogs and bonus material and access to show notes, and you can listen live like several people are doing this morning to our recording, and a whole lot more, including chapter readings and whatnot. So thanks, everybody, for their support there. Selina, thanks for coming on. Really appreciate it. We love you. You know that.

Selina: Thanks for having me. Aw, I love you guys too.

Andrew: And don’t forget, Selina is over… she does Hype Podcast, and you can listen to all their Cursed Child thoughts if you want to do that.

Selina: Yes, we have a spoiler one and the spoiler-free one, just like MuggleCast.

Andrew: Perfect, perfect. And I think that’s it, so thank you, everybody, for listening, and we’ll see you next time. Bye!

Eric, Micah, and Selina: Bye.

Transcript #290

Transcript for MuggleCast Episode #290, Expelled


Show Intro


[Show music plays]

Andrew Sims: This is MuggleCast, your Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts podcast covering everything about J.K. Rowling’s Wizarding World. Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 290. Micah, Eric, and I are all here this week as usual, and I am pleased to report that Jeanna is back this week. Hey, Jeanna.

Jeanna: Hello again.

Andrew: I’m glad we didn’t scare you away.

Jeanna: I’m glad I didn’t screw up so bad that… [laughs]

Andrew: No, you’re awesome. And we told Micah that he has to be on this episode with you.

Micah Tannenbaum: I was going to say, a fine replacement.

Andrew: [laughs] Actually, better than you, Micah, to be honest, so you’d better watch yourself. Don’t screw up or you’re out.

Jeanna: I’m slowly moving my stuff into the MuggleCast newsroom.

Andrew: [laughs] Okay, well, enough banter about kicking Micah out; he probably believes it’s true.

Eric Scull: It’s okay, Micah, you can stay.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I was already packing up.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: I bet you’re one of those guys that has just a knapsack, right? Everything is just…


Main discussion: Fantastic Beasts trailer


Andrew: [laughs] Big news week: The new Fantastic Beasts trailer came out a couple of days ago, and it is so good. So good. And we’re going to break it down, but first, why don’t we just start with some overall impressions of it because… I’ll start off and just say that I didn’t think there was much magic in the first trailer for Fantastic Beasts, and I didn’t realize that until I watched this one because this one just has the spells, it’s got the references to Harry Potter, which we will definitely be getting into, and… I don’t know; it just felt like a Harry Potter movie and it got me so excited. Did you guys get the same feeling?

Jeanna and Micah: Yes.

Eric: Yeah, I would agree with that 100%. Having more of the magic, having it look like the magic in Harry Potter, that was the big thing for me. Apparition is a big part, or Apparation, whatever you would call it. The art of Apparating.

Andrew: Yeah, even the WB logo Apparates.

Eric: The logo Apparates!

Jeanna: I was going to say that; I thought it was very interesting that it Apparated onto the screen.

Eric: That, I think, is going to be probably the most prominent – it is in the trailer, anyway – in terms of spells used, and I wonder why that is. But ultimately, if you’re adult and you can do it, why not do it?

Micah: I would just say I thought that Eddie Red-mane-ie did a great job…

Andrew: “Red-mane-ie”?

Micah: … introducing J.K. Rowling. [pronounces “Row” like “ow”]

Jeanna: Oh!

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Jeanna: I’m glad someone said that.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. So at the MTV Movie Awards, where he announced… where he played the trailer, as Micah said, he pronounced her name wrong. But I’m actually at CinemaCon this week – it’s where all the movie studios are sharing their upcoming slates with movie exhibitors – and Eddie Redmayne was here yesterday and he said J.K. Rowling’s name correctly, so I think somebody pulled him aside after the MTV Movie awards…

[Eric and Jeanna laugh]

Andrew: … and said, “Hey, you’re going to be kicked out of this fandom really quick unless you straighten out how you pronounce Rowling.” [laughs] “So get it right.”

Eric: Yeah, news next Monday would have been, “Eddie Redmayne removed as lead actor.”

Andrew: [laughs] “Barred from the Harry Potter fandom.”

Micah: I would assume, though, that if more people were watching the MTV Movie Awards that they would have called the… I didn’t actually see a huge response on social media; I was actually expecting a lot more people to call attention to that. But I will say, the entrance was pretty cool that he made; he came up through the suitcase, and of course, at the end of the trailer, we see him going into the suitcase, so a little tip of a cap there.

Andrew: Yeah. So I guess, why don’t we just start out with the thing that I think most people found most intriguing about this Fantastic Beasts trailer?

Micah: The Niffler?

Andrew: [laughs] The Niffler, yeah.

Eric: Definitely the Niffler.

Andrew: No, a couple of… I don’t know, about 30 seconds into the trailer we hear who I think is Graves, played by Colin Farrell…

Eric: I think that’s right.

Andrew: … say to Newt, “There’s much more to you than meets the eye. Kicked out of Hogwarts for endangering a human life with a beast, yet one of your teachers argued against your expulsion. I wonder what makes Dumbledore so fond of you, Mr. Scamander.”

Eric: Albus Dumbledore.

Andrew: So the shocking thing here was that… what shocked me at first was that we’re already hearing references that we understand from the Harry Potter books: Dumbledore, Hogwarts… and that Newt was kicked out of Hogwarts. And what’s particularly interesting about this – and something I’ve been raising a fuss about – is that in the Fantastic Beasts book that J.K. Rowling published in 2001, in Newt’s bio in the back, it said he graduated from Hogwarts, so what gives?

Micah: Maybe he came back.

Andrew: [scoffs] Don’t give me that.

Jeanna: Maybe this is his redemption story.

Andrew: I completely agree with you, 100%.

Jeanna: That was my first thought, is that this is his story all about how his life got flipped, turned upside down, and he got kicked out of Hogwarts. But now he has to do all this stuff – “has to” is a loose term – and he gets reinstated and is allowed to finish his degree.

Eric: But he’s also the reason that all the beasts get let loose in the first place, so…

Andrew: He kind of digs a deeper hole, doesn’t he?

Eric: Yeah, I don’t like the idea that he’s incompetent or not able to be… I want him to be just the smartest, most competent Hufflepuff there is. So I get a little worried that he got kicked out, but if it was for a beast, then you can assume that it was something that he either quickly got under control or resolved, or that this is essentially – as Jeanna said – his sort of coming to peace with himself. This could be room for character growth on that front.

Micah: Could be. I just find it interesting that he has much of the same storyline as Hagrid does, and I know a number of listeners pointed this out, at least from the relationship with Dumbledore, getting expelled, having an affinity for creatures that are potentially dangerous…

Eric: That’s interesting.

Micah: Yeah, it’s very, very similar to Hagrid’s storyline, and so come on, J.K. Rowling. Come up with some new material.

Andrew: Oh, stop it.

[Everyone laughs]

Jeanna: Wow.

Micah: I’m just kidding.

Andrew: Well, we also know that Dumbledore has a great interest in Newt, as Graves says, and J.K. Rowling followed up on that on Twitter. She wouldn’t elaborate further, but I found that interesting as well because Dumbledore is very interested in both Hagrid and Newt.

Eric: This was definitely the most surprising bit, was the name drop of Dumbledore, and then J.K. Rowling on Twitter afterwards going ways to explain it. That was just… I was shocked. And there were a lot of cool things in the trailer, but I wasn’t expecting the Dumbledore name drop.

Andrew: Yeah, I would have expected an offhand reference to Hogwarts, like, “Oh, yeah, I went to Hogwarts, back over in England,” but I didn’t expect it to potentially be a pivotal part of the story.

Eric: Enough to make it in the trailer, too. Like, “kicked out of Hogwarts,” well, that could be just WB’s way of showing that they’re in the same universe for this trailer, but then they have the Dumbledore reference too, so it’s like, which one is excessive, versus which one is actually a plot point? Like if Newt having been kicked out of Hogwarts is part of the greater story of the movie or not.

Andrew: I think that’s… I really hope it is, because I hope this is a redemption story and that Newt will be returning to Hogwarts to complete his degree because I think that would be a great arc over three movies. We’ve seen over the past couple of years… I’m thinking about when J.K. Rowling tweeted, “You all went to Hogwarts. We were all there together.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: People are still deeply connected to Hogwarts, so if they could watch this arc in which Newt feels so bad, presumably, about getting kicked out of Hogwarts, and he wants to go back so bad, we could all relate to that.

Eric: Well, do we see him in Hogwarts in this trailer when he’s squeezing the…? It looks like a giant raisin or something. Did you guys take that to be the greenhouse at Hogwarts?

Jeanna: I did not.

Andrew: No, that’s wishful thinking. [laughs]

Eric: Oh, I totally thought that was, because it’s… and it happens when they’re still talking about Hogwarts. Newt is looking up at the… I kind of want to say the camera.

Micah: Did we watch the same trailer?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah! I can give you a timestamp if you want.

Micah: Yeah, give me a timestamp on this.

Andrew: Eric went through it frame by frame.

Eric: I really thought this was…

Micah: You raised a good point, though, Eric, you did. And I think, going back to the earlier discussion about why Warner Bros. did this, I think it’s just the ability to captivate the audience that may not be as close to the news about Fantastic Beasts, putting out Hogwarts, putting out Dumbledore. Immediately you’re back into that world, and that’s within the first few seconds of this trailer, right?

Eric: I mean, what’s interesting… and we talked about them including the magical things. The other thing was the plates, obviously, right? The plates and/or napkins flying across… is it Jacob, is the Muggle?

Andrew: Yeah, and he was into it.

Eric: And he’s sort of in awe. Oh, yeah, I’d be into it too. So that struck me, but it also could be that this trailer is really meant to sell that they’re the same universe, almost on a deep level, where they’re showing basically the same effects because between Apparition and then what the napkins were doing, that’s exactly straight out of Deathly Hallows, I think. And so with that and Dumbledore and Hogwarts being mentioned, it’s really beating you over the head. Although this trailer feels completely fresh, and I don’t think any of it was reused or repurposed or annoyingly overused, but I have to say maybe that’s the whole point to this, is to showcase the magical aspects of the world that are the same from what we’re used to.

Andrew: And it gets casual fans interested, as I think you were alluding to. When I consider a casual Harry Potter fan, I think of my sister or my brother. If they hear “Hogwarts” and “Dumbledore” specifically, or see Newt’s Hufflepuff scarf… which also, by the way, may be an indicator that Newt really wants to go back to Hogwarts.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Because he brought it with him and he’s like, “Oh, man, I miss my Hufflepuff days. I’m bringing my Hufflepuff pride with me to the US. I want to go back so bad. Oh my God.”

Eric: I know we know this is an issue for many reasons, him being expelled; that would cause a lot of weird plot issues. But how old do we think Newt is supposed to be? Eddie Redmayne is six years older than me; he’s like, 33. So is he really…? Can we really realistically expect that he’s playing a 17-year-old Newt Scamander, an 18-year-old Newt Scamander, or somebody who’s not too old to go back to Hogwarts? Is there an age limit at Hogwarts?

Andrew: No, I don’t think so.

Micah: He looks like he’s 12.

Jeanna: Well, I would say he looks like he’s fresh out of Hogwarts age.

Eric: I would say freshly 20/21. By the way, Micah, the scene which I thought was the greenhouse – it’s like, 19-20 seconds – it turns out on the overhead shot, Jacob is sitting in a chair watching him brew the thing, so it’s not Hogwarts greenhouses.

Jeanna: I have a theory on where that is; I think that’s in his suitcase.

Eric: Ohh.

Jeanna: Because at the end of the trailer, he ushers him down.

Eric: Come on!

Andrew: Yeah, good observation. See, this is why you’re replacing Micah; Micah would never come up with something like that.

Micah: That’s debatable.

[Everyone laughs]

Jeanna: My other thought about them name-dropping Hogwarts so quickly in this trailer, and our association with this film, is we know we know Hogwarts. We know everyone, whether you’re casual or not, knows Hogwarts. Is that because we’re going to meet all the other schools as well, and he’s going to get somewhat of an education from all those schools?

Eric: That’s interesting. Could he continue his education potentially somewhere else? And you know what, Andrew, I was reading a couple of your posts, and you did cite the listener… one of the users sent in the quote from Fantastic Beasts the book, which said that he graduated Hogwarts, then went to the Ministry for two years, then worked in this department, then this department, then this department. And I was thinking, sure, that could probably at this point, since it was written in 2001, it could probably be changed. It could probably be retconned, or just ignored completely, to my understanding. But then I also like the idea that he could continue his education somewhere else.

Andrew: Yeah, I hope he goes back to… well, I mean, I think it seems pretty certain that he’ll go back to Hogwarts, but yeah, maybe along his way he could be going to these other schools.

Eric: Gosh.

Andrew: I think one idea that we kicked around before is that in sequels to Fantastic Beasts, he will be going… it won’t be set in the United States. It’ll be set elsewhere, potentially where one of those other schools could be.

Jeanna: That’s what I’m thinking.

Eric: Right, and maybe even if he pops in at Hogwarts for a couple minutes. Gosh, it’d be weird if they had to close the Studio Tour for a day or two because they had to use some of the sets again.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: Like, “Sorry, we’re filming on these sets again.” [laughs] “Newt is in Diagon Alley right now.”

Andrew: That’d be pretty crazy. But the age question is interesting. I think we’re going to have to set aside the fact that Eddie Redmayne doesn’t look like he should be going to Hogwarts right now because I think, Jeanna, you may have said it: At best, he looks like he’s graduating. He’s in his graduation year.

Eric: He definitely looks young.

Jeanna: Yeah, he’s believable, 17/18. More 18. But if they said 21, and if they said his actual age, which is 35, I’d go anywhere in that range.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, because I’m thinking Prisoner of Azkaban Harry, comparing that to third year Newt. I just could not see that at all, if, say, this movie was set in Newt’s third year at Hogwarts. It just doesn’t…

Eric: Right.

Micah: Yeah, you don’t know what year he was expelled.

Andrew: Right.

Jeanna: Yet.

Andrew: And it’s also important to remember that Dumbledore was a teacher at Hogwarts during this time.

Eric: Well, and that’s the coolest thing, is J.K. Rowling back in 1998 – or it was very early on in the Harry Potter series – was asked how old is Dumbledore? And she said 150. So it’s perfectly logical that she could wrap Dumbledore into this world. That said, how exciting is it that Albus Dumbledore is part of this film’s world? Even if it never amounts to anything more in this film than a name drop, I think it’s pretty darn special to think that while Newt and his friends are solving this problem, somewhere in the world Albus Dumbledore is off discovering the 12 uses of dragon’s blood or something. It’s a really cool idea that just makes me giddy for a whole different reason, on a whole different level.

Andrew: Now, you guys are convincing me that potentially he could be returning to Hogwarts. But alternate theory, and this is the one I set out with initially, and I still stand by it: I wouldn’t be surprised if J.K. Rowling actually changes canon. Because like we referenced a couple minutes ago, in the Fantastic Beasts book at the very back there’s a bio for Newt, and it says “upon graduation from Hogwarts.” What if he doesn’t return to Hogwarts? Or I don’t know, maybe he returns in some capacity and doesn’t graduate? I think that… see, there’s some interesting evidence to support this theory. A new Hogwarts classics boxset is coming out this June, and it only has Beedle the Bard and Quidditch Through the Ages. It doesn’t include Fantastic Beasts, whereas this boxset used to, which is really strange. And we also know – and we talked about this on the last episode – that they are republishing Fantastic Beasts next year, I think in February or March, so if they’re revising Fantastic Beasts, I think that’s going to be a chance for them… assuming it’s going to be the same book but expanded, I think this bio is going to go deeper and either explain further how he left Hogwarts and then eventually came back, or they’re just going to take out “upon graduation from Hogwarts,” because it just seems strange. I have to think J.K. Rowling came up with this expulsion thing more recently than when she wrote this book in 2001, because isn’t that something important you would include in the bio?

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah. No, I don’t think there’s a question about that. And I agree with you; all your sleuthing has turned up some really compelling ideas. But my question then is why is he an expelled student? Why is that relevant to the story of this? Why is it such a plot point? What does that mean for Newt if he has been expelled? Is that just one reason for Colin Farrell’s character to try and discredit him? What exactly…? What gives, that he’s expelled? Does it make him more of a bad boy? Is he more endearing to audiences because he was expelled? A lot of questions.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Micah: Tweet at J.K. Rowling.

Jeanna: I don’t think they’re really going for the bad boy with him. I think it’s more the bumbling “Oops, this happened” type character. But I’m wondering, Andrew, if…

Micah: Sounds like Hagrid.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: Newt is Hagrid’s great-great-grandfather.

Jeanna: [laughs] That would be interesting. I’m wondering if it’s a culmination of our theories, Andrew, where they change it from “He graduated” to “He has an honorary degree because he went to all the different schools and he learned and all that from all of them.”

Eric: Honorary degree, I like that.

Jeanna: Well, now it seems far-fetched that he wouldn’t have graduated from Hogwarts but yet he’s Order of Merlin… I don’t know what class. But he has all these other accolades but yet was kicked out of Hogwarts? That doesn’t add up.

Andrew: Right, especially because you just look at this bio and he had a busy career after Hogwarts, so it’s like… is there going to be a three-year period, if there’s three movies, where he was out of Hogwarts or longer, and then he started this whole career? And by the way, I just want to say that I think it’s fine that she’s changing this canon, because she wrote this back in 2001. It does not relate to the Harry Potter books at all; it plays virtually no role, so it’s okay for her to adjust this in order to make a better story. And yet, the more I think about this redemption thing, that he will be going to Hogwarts – so that’s how J.K. Rowling can explain this bio, he will be going back to Hogwarts – I just love that idea so much and I really hope it’s true.

Eric: That’d be cool.

Micah: You’re assuming that she’s not going to find a way to just weave this all together.

Andrew: Well, the redemption would weave it together.

Micah: Yeah, well, just the fact that you mentioned before that you’re okay with the fact that she is changing the canon, but there’s nothing to state that she will do that. I mean, there’s very good chance, given how good she is at telling a story, that there’s nothing wrong with what she wrote back in 2001…

Eric: And he will be going back?

Micah: … and she just very craftily is able to figure this out.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I don’t know.

Andrew: Well, I think we can… it’s safe to assume, I think, that when she wrote this back in 2000 or 2001, she was not thinking that there would be a film trilogy 15 years down the road. Right?

Eric: In 2001 there was barely a film of Harry Potter at all.

Andrew: Right, exactly. And that’s why I think it’s okay to change this.

Eric: Yeah, I don’t know.

Andrew: Anyway, how about another question? This has been bugging fans a lot. Why wasn’t his wand snapped?

Eric: I was thinking about this a lot because obviously it was in the doc for a couple days now, and I think I have an answer. So we know that Hagrid, when he got expelled, his wand was snapped, but my theory is Hagrid was underage. We know he was in his… was it his third year or fifth year when that happened? I’m forgetting, but he was underage at the time. My theory is Newt is of age, if he was expelled from Hogwarts when he was 17. One of the reasons of them snapping your wand is because you’re an untrained wizard and you can’t possibly be trusted out in the outer world, but if he’s of age, then he’s an adult wizard and should be afforded all the rights of being an adult wizard, including the right to carry a wand, but he won’t have graduated from Hogwarts because Hogwarts can’t have him there.

Andrew: Okay.

Jeanna: That’s the only good theory I’ve ever heard.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: Because I sat here and got angry at the fact that Hagrid had his wand broken, and this guy gets to run around with his wand.

Eric: Well, with Hagrid… I think, too, with the whole Hagrid thing is it happens in Chamber of Secrets. Harry is 12, and you have to… for dramatic weight, JKR has something in there about his wand getting snapped. It’s like, “Oh, they snapped my wand, Harry,” and Harry fears and has nightmares about his own wand being reduced to shreds, and you’re just like, “Oh, this is clearly a child’s nightmare.” Sure, they snap your wand, but I’m saying more along… I can see that being retconned; maybe that never happens. Hagrid we know keeps his wand anyway, or in some form has it in the way of the umbrella. But that’s something that’s interesting to me, the whole snapping of the wand. It’s also possible that his wand was snapped, and the thing is that the wand that we’ve seen him have in promos and in the movie could be another wand, either one that he got from somewhere else where they didn’t have to check to see if he was allowed to carry one, or one from… maybe the woods. I’m trying to think… isn’t there…? There was something about his wand being all natural; did you guys remember this? Or am I making this up? Because it could be that I’m making this up.

Andrew: Newt’s wand?

Eric: Yeah, somebody called it a vegan wand.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: What?

Eric: I believe this might just be…

Micah: Is this in the trailer also?

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: This might be the other podcast I do, Alohomora. A fan theory. But I don’t think it is, but the idea was that he had a vegan wand, meaning that it doesn’t contain animal parts, to symbolize essentially his connection with the magical world. I kind of like that idea. But it has no place in this discussion, because you know what, I think it probably was a fan theory.

Andrew: Well, the other…

Micah: It’s also possible, though – and I don’t know, Andrew, if this was where you were going – but maybe the law/rule wasn’t in place at the time that your wand got snapped if you were expelled.

Andrew: Maybe. I was looking it up a little bit and I didn’t see a starting point. But yeah, that could be possible. I mean, it could have been a Dumbledore era thing or something like that. But I was going to say, he could have just stolen the wand, but then there’s the question of how well would it work?

Eric: Right.

Micah: And we don’t know what he got expelled for either. I mean, what Hagrid got expelled for ultimately resulted in somebody’s death. We don’t know if it’s equivalent.

Eric: Well, it’s essentially the same… oh, yeah, it might not be the same thing. I was going to say it’s similar, though. It’s very similar because of the large beast, right? Wasn’t Aragog rumored to be…? Tom Riddle made it out to be that Aragog was Slytherin’s monster?

Andrew: Yeah. See, but to be expelled from Hogwarts, you have to have done something pretty bad, because there’s other punishment at Hogwarts, like a suspension or…

Micah: You supposedly have to do something really bad. Again, comparing it to Hagrid’s situation, he didn’t do anything, yet he was expelled. Could this be another one of those situations where Newt got set up?

Eric: The other thing is… I mean, I believe Newt is totally guilty of whatever they say he did with the beast, [laughs] just knowing that he ignores or sort of is ignorant of the repercussions of his suitcase. Again, going back to this trailer – which we haven’t really talked a lot about – the clasp, it pops open automatically on its own, or the Niffler somehow causes it to pop open. But he’s consciously aware of this when he’s going through customs in the trailer, and is like, “Oh, got to get that fixed,” but he doesn’t seem to take a whole lot of stock in the dangers of having a flawed briefcase, essentially. A more careful person would get that fixed the next minute.

Andrew: So one other thing – getting back to this Dumbledore line in the trailer – to me, I think this confirms that Dumbledore will be making an appearance at some point. Because J.K. Rowling saying that Dumbledore was very fond of Newt, with the fact that thankfully, thank the Lord, Michael Gambon is still alive and well… we know Dumbledore is a very old character, he’s a beloved character, he’s J.K. Rowling’s favorite character, or top two. I think that there’s a lot of evidence here suggesting that we will see Dumbledore either… perhaps Newt will save the day at the end of the first Fantastic Beasts movie, and maybe not in this movie, but maybe by the next movie or the third movie, Dumbledore is going to want to say something to him. “Hey, Newt, thanks for saving the day over there in the US. Why don’t you come back to Hogwarts? I’m the Headmaster now. I can do that. I can let you back in.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Do you guys think we’re going to be seeing him at some point?

Micah: Yeah.

Jeanna: Definitely.

Andrew: I’m so excited.

Eric: I would love for that to be a thing.

Micah: Why mention the name otherwise? I mean, other than to draw in the fans.

Eric: Right.

Micah: But I think… we haven’t gotten a full casting list for this movie yet, right? So there’s a chance.

Andrew: No, but I think they would make it a surprise. I don’t think they would want anyone to know until you saw it.

Micah: Yeah, I think there’s a good chance. I really, really do. And I think that it kind of plays into the next question that you ask about him being expelled being the catalyst for him going overseas. And then what you just mentioned, if he’s able to save the day, or does he talk with Dumbledore? Does he look to him for advice, knowing that he’s clearly fond of young Newt? So who knows? I mean, there’s a ton of possibilities.

Jeanna: Perhaps Dumbledore was the one who sent him to America.

Eric: “Explore the new world.”

Andrew: To do what? Study the beasts?

Jeanna: Study the beasts, study the small uprising that’s happening.

Eric: I guess it is a way of pursuing his interests without the… what’s the word? Stigma of having been an expelled student.

Jeanna: And I looked it up and I don’t know if we know when in time the next movies are starting, but Dumbledore becomes Headmaster in 1955.

Eric: What’s interesting is – and based on what J.K. Rowling said on Twitter about Dumbledore just being a young teacher at the time and not having as much sway as he obviously does when he’s a headmaster – certain mathematics suggest that Dumbledore would be about 40 in the ’20s. What I would love – and this is my fan wish and hope and dream – is that if there is a younger Dumbledore in the Fantastic Beasts trilogy, that he’s played by Jared Harris, the son of Richard Harris.

Jeanna: Ohh, I would love that.

Andrew: That’s cool. Is he an actor?

Jeanna: Yes, he is.

Andrew: Oh, wow.

Jeanna: He always plays a bad guy. He really does.

Eric: [laughs] Was he Moriarty in the new Sherlock…? The second Sherlock Holmes with Robert Downey, Jr.? I think he was.

Jeanna: I think so, yes. He is in it; I can’t remember if he’s Moriarty or not, but he is in it.

Eric: He’s the bad guy.

Andrew: Interesting. What’s his first name again? I want to look at a picture of him.

Eric: Jared Harris. He actually… so many people say he looks just like Richard Harris did.

Jeanna: He looks like young Richard Harris, and if you close your eyes and listen to him, he has the same cadence as Richard. It’s bizarre.

Eric: So I don’t want to say, “Oh, Michael Gambon shouldn’t be Dumbledore,” but if you’re looking for a 40- or 50-year-old Dumbledore, a much younger… I don’t know. I would like to get to be able to see a more early era Richard Harris.

Andrew: Younger, yeah.

Jeanna: I would like a younger.

Andrew: I see that point, but honestly, I think they would ask Michael Gambon first. Me personally, I’d prefer to see Michael Gambon, and they could put the right amount of makeup on him and do some CGI to make him look younger.

Eric: Well, look at the Tom Riddle orphanage scenes in, what is it, Half-Blood? Do you feel that he looks young there?

Andrew: Oh, right. Yeah. The shorter hair.

Eric: But that’s still… well, that’s the 1930s, isn’t it? It’s supposed to be… or early ’40s.

Jeanna: I didn’t think he looked young enough there, but now you’re saying that’s only ten years difference, they might use him.

Eric: I didn’t think that makeup was very good. But yeah, it was late ’30s, right? Because if ’42 was the Chamber of Secrets, and Riddle was fifth or sixth year, then it was 1938 or ’37 when Dumbledore came calling, so that was their version of 1937 Dumbledore. Not to get too hung up on one point. But I still am just going forward with my fan wish; I would love it to be Jared Harris, who is currently 55.

Micah: The short answer to the question is yes, we all anticipate that he’ll show up at some point, right?

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Jeanna also mentioned that it was in the 1950s that he was promoted to Headmaster, so maybe Dumbledore could help… I’m sure Dumbledore will help him get back into Hogwarts in some way. Maybe there will be a shift in power at Hogwarts during the years that Newt is trying to redeem himself, and then by the end of it, Dumbledore is like, “Oh, I’ve got the hookups with so-and-so, and he or she said they can get you back, so you’re good.”

Eric: [laughs] That was the one thing about this trailer, is even if Dumbledore isn’t a headmaster, his name has some gravitas to whoever’s speaking. Whoever is speaking is interested in why Albus Dumbledore likes Newt.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s a good point. I mean, why would Graves, an Auror, know of Dumbledore, a teacher at Hogwarts overseas?

Eric: And care what he thinks? I mean, even in Deathly Hallows, it is stated that Dumbledore was making worldly connections when he was very young, still at school, actually, still in Hogwarts, so Dumbledore could have been 15 and 16 and be writing state senators or the equivalent just about magical things.

Andrew: True.

Eric: But that’s the cool thing about Dumbledore, is he’s such a worldwide persona at an early age back then that you can use him in this way. It’s really brilliant of Jo to have done this.

Micah: That’s what makes me think that Newt’s mission is not all entirely related to these fantastic beasts. There’s potential for some sort of political motivation, maybe a little bit of spying on the part of Newt. Maybe it’s pushing it a little bit too far, but I feel like clearly he’s going to be involved with the government here in New York, and there’s more to it than just these beasts.

Andrew: Oh, yeah. Yeah, until this trailer, I thought the biggest aspect was actually going to be equality for wizards and witches, and that still seems like it’s going to be a big part of Fantastic Beasts because when these beasts get out of Newt’s suitcase, the Muggles are going to be noticing. And it looks like, actually – getting back to the trailer – there’s a shot of somebody named Shaw at what looks like some sort of political fundraiser, potentially, and American flags are in the background and there’s a big sign of Shaw and it says, “Shaw: America’s future…”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … suggesting he’s running for elected office. My guess is he’s a Muggle and he probably does not like that the beasts have escaped, and that he now knows that wizards and witches are amongst them. So yeah, I think that’s…

Micah: If you look really closely at the bottom, it says, “Make America Great Again.”

Andrew: [laughs] “Make America wizard-free again.”

Eric: So here’s an idea. I just love the idea that the beasts won’t be… no, actually, I don’t like the idea, but I like the possibility that there could be a lot of government motivations behind the plot of this film, because we know he interacts with these high-ranking officials and we know that there are these political activists, right, that we’ve seen in other trailers. It’s just never been stated overtly that there’s something to do with the government, but what if, like what you’re saying, Micah, what if it is? What if the beasts aren’t the biggest part of this film? What if he just… the beasts happen, but it’s really about something else?

Micah: Or the beasts are a means to an end.

Jeanna: That’s what I’m thinking, that they’re the means to the end.

Andrew: There’s a shot of a newspaper being read and there was an interesting little headline; the big headline on the front page was, “Magical disturbances something risk wizarding exposure.”

Eric: What’s the name of the paper? Can you see that?

Andrew: You know what, I tried to make it out, but…

Eric: It’s “The New York” something with a G…

Jeanna: I think it’s “The New York Gazette.”

Andrew: Oh. I thought it was something weird, like “Gilly” or something.

Jeanna: Do you have a timestamp of when it is?

Micah: I thought it said “Ghost.”

Eric: “Ghost”?

Andrew: I don’t have the trailer open; I’m just looking at the…

Micah: You know, like “The New York Post.” “New York Ghost.”

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Because if you look above where it says “International wizard hunt intensifies,” I think the name of the paper is up there too.

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Micah: And it looks like it’s a really short word.

Andrew: “Glean”? “Galleon”?

Jeanna: Oh, you’re right.

Eric: “Quest” something?

Andrew: Okay, we’ve got to figure that out. That’s going to bug me.

[Jeanna laughs]

Micah: Who is Alberto Macellarius?

Jeanna: I don’t know, but I’m wondering if he’ll come into play.

Andrew: [in a nerdy voice] Maybe in the sequel. [back to normal voice] But anyway, there’s a sub-headline that says, “President Seraphina Picquery to address fearful American wizarding community,” and that, to me, suggests that the entire wizarding body across the United States is deeply concerned about what’s going on in New York. So there’s deep ramifications for Newt and his mistake, so if he is trying to get back to Hogwarts as well, he’s definitely seriously endangered his chances. [laughs] How about that suitcase?

Eric: How about that suitcase? [laughs]

Andrew: So towards the beginning of the trailer, we get a little glimpse of some clever magic; I assume this was a J.K. Rowling idea. So we’ve spoken a lot about the suitcase and all of his beasts are hiding in there, and in the trailer at the beginning, one is trying to get out. And when he puts the suitcase in front of US customs – because he just took a ship over from England – he secretly flips a little switch where the keyhole is, and when he flips it, a little tab pops up that says “Muggle-worthy.” In other words, Muggles can see the inside of the suitcase, and it’ll be… there won’t be a world of beasts.

Eric: On the up-and-up. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah. And then of course, his Hufflepuff scarf was in there, his New York City map was in there, a clock, binoculars, some other clothes…

Eric: A magnifying glass.

Jeanna: So were they really in there? Or is that just what he wants customs to see?

Andrew: I think they’re what’s really in there because of the Hufflepuff scarf, right?

Eric: Right. He left his Hufflepuff scarf at home. [laughs] It’s just an illusion.

Andrew: Isn’t there a promotional image of him wearing that scarf?

Eric: I think there is.

Jeanna: There might be.

Micah: Yeah, we’ve definitely discussed that scarf before. But going back to Jeanna’s point from earlier in the episode, though, I mean, this is very reminiscent of the fact that we’ve seen this type of magic before. If in fact that one scene that we talked about is from them being in the trunk, it reminded me of Mad-Eye Moody, it reminded me of the camp tent from the Quidditch World Cup, how you just go inside… and of course, the tent that’s used throughout Deathly Hallows. That these small confined spaces can actually be used for any number of purposes and it would make sense that you can disguise to Muggles the fact that there’s more than meets the eye.

Eric: And just like the Room of Requirement can be any room you need it to be, the suitcase has any number of settings where it is something different. You flip a switch; it’s Muggle-friendly, “Oh, it is just a regular-looking briefcase with regular stuff in it.” I feel like it’s both; I feel like those things in it are real.

Andrew: Oh, yeah, I agree. So one more thing to talk about here – we also got some listener feedback – is “Hedwig’s Theme.” It’s back again. We saw it in the teaser trailer; we discussed it. It appeared again in the second trailer, a different version of it, I guess, similar to the teaser trailer one but also a little newer. A lot of people have been asking me what I thought. I like it. At this point I’m just kind of like, “Okay, cool.” I don’t know if it gets me excited, because I prefer the original version. I don’t necessarily love this regenerated version of “Hedwig’s Theme.”

Jeanna: I had a very adverse reaction when it was used in the first trailer, so…

Andrew: Oh, yeah? And you still don’t like it?

Jeanna: No, you had that reaction.

Andrew: Oh.

Jeanna: I remember you did not care for it. But I am so excited whenever it’s used, and that theme really gets me pulled back in. I know the use of Dumbledore and Hogwarts and the magic flying around, that helps, but especially that theme really pulls me in, and I think this is a very big indicator that they will continue with that theme throughout this series.

Eric: They’ll just stop calling it “Hedwig’s Theme”; it’ll become “Newt’s Niffler’s Theme.”

Andrew: They better not.

[Eric laughs]

Jeanna: Maybe they’ll just call it the magic theme or something.

Eric: The Fantastic Beasts Overture. Yeah, Magic Overture.

Jeanna: “I Love Magic” or…

Eric: Well, and I didn’t like it at all. I didn’t think it had a place in… I mean, I love it, but I didn’t like it in this movie associated with this trilogy. I was like, “Can’t they get something new?” But ultimately…

Micah: Something Newt?

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: A, they probably won’t. And B, actually, the use of it in this trailer finally turned my mind around. I love it in this trailer; I think it is exciting. It’s obviously in a different key and with more, I don’t know, mechanical sounds to it. I don’t know. Whatever they did to it where it’s different, I think it perfectly accentuates this trailer. The fact that it’s familiar is probably just another one of the selling points.

Micah: Of course. I think it would be a miss on the part of Warner Bros. to not use it, because it pulls you in. Similar to, as Jeanna mentioned, Hogwarts and Dumbledore. Right when you hear that music for most people, whether you’re the casual fan or you’re the avid fan, you know what you’re about to see, or you know the world that you’re about to be immersed in.

Eric: What else just got me crazy as I was reviewing it just now, and at 1:08 there’s a brick wall that turns into something else. It’s a speakeasy or something like an old… it reminds me of getting into Diagon Alley through the brick wall.

Jeanna: Oh yeah, I liked that too.

Eric: Come on.

Andrew: Yep, that was another moment where I was like, “The magic is back!”

Eric: Yeah, the magic is back! That is just the coolest.

Andrew: But on the point of iconic themes, I would like to hope – and we learned this the other day – James Newton Howard will be scoring the first Fantastic Beasts movie.

Eric: What has he done?

Andrew: He did only the entire Hunger Games series.

Eric: Oh, man!

Jeanna: Which I don’t remember any of the music from.

Andrew: I know, me neither.

[Everyone laughs]

Jeanna: That’s why when people said that, I was like, “Oh, okay. Yay?”

Andrew: Good, I think?

Eric: [whistles Mockingjay call from The Hunger Games] That’s what I remember from the Hunger Games soundtrack.

Jeanna: What I’m wondering is… I was going to ask, did he compose this trailer?

Andrew: I don’t know.

Jeanna: Because the music in this trailer did get me excited. And his name just thrown out there didn’t really excite me, but I think we learned he was composing one day and then the next day the trailer came out, and I thought, “Oh, all right, I’ll go with this.”

Andrew: Usually, trailers have their own music. There’s some of what you’ll see in the movie, but it’ll sometimes be generic trailer music.

Eric: Yeah, it can be music from other things. You could see a new action movie with Pirates of the Caribbean riffs in the trailer.

Andrew: [sings Pirates of the Caribbean theme] James Newton Howard has also scored The Bourne Legacy, Snow White and the Huntsman, The Huntsman: Winter’s War – which comes out in a couple of weeks – Maleficent, the very bad The Last Airbender, and 2003’s Peter Pan. So he’s got a good track record. It’ll be interesting to see if he sticks around for all of them or… was anybody…? I was feeling a little disappointed; I was kind of holding out for John Williams to come back, since he came back for Star Wars.

Jeanna: He’s too busy making the Star Wars money, man.

Andrew: Yeah, I guess so. I guess so.

Micah: If they had gone to Chris Columbus, then yes, John Williams would have come back, but since it’s David Yates…

Eric: Yeah, Chris has some sway.

Andrew: Well, George Lucas didn’t come back to Star Wars and John Williams still did.

Jeanna: Yeah, George Lucas is… he’s mentally…

Andrew: No one wanted George Lucas to come back.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Andrew: John Williams is still immersed in Harry Potter, though; we’ll talk about that in a little bit.

Eric: I want to see Chris Columbus direct one of these movies, because he always said, “Oh, man, what if I had done one more? What would that have been like?” He was like, “I have to support my decision to go and be with my family, but darn, what would’ve happened? How would it’ve been different?”

Andrew: That would be kind of cool for one Harry Potter director to direct each of the Fantastic Beasts movies. So you got David Yates for this one, you get Chris Columbus for another, and… not Mike Newell; let’s get Alfonso Cuarón back for the finale. Fantastic Beasts 3, set in Australia.

Jeanna: No, let’s not do that.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: I’m ambivalent. It could go right.

Andrew: You don’t want to see Newt go back to Hogwarts and not wear his cloak?

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Jeanna: Yeah, exactly. None of the kids are in uniform.

Eric: We need to Guillermo del Toro Fantastic Beasts, okay? That’s what we need. All the fantastic beasts have 18 eyes and sharper claws.

Andrew: So in bonus MuggleCast today on Patreon we’ll be talking about the beasts in the trailer because we haven’t even talked about those guys yet, why Hogwarts snaps the wands of the students; we’ll be talking about that a little bit more, and what kinds of things the wizarding world parks could do to celebrate the Cursed Child and Fantastic Beasts. Somebody asked us this question and I’ve been thinking about it; I think there’s a lot of potential there. And you know what else I was thinking about while we were just discussing this? If Fantastic Beasts does have a Hogwarts presence, so to speak, Universal will be so happy [laughs] that the Hogwarts castles that they’ve built around the world are now relevant again in a new film series. I think that would just excite them to no end.

Eric: Also, doesn’t Universal Studios Florida also have a New York section built in already?

Andrew: No?

Jeanna: They do. Oh, they do.

Andrew: Wait, the outside? What are you talking about?

Eric: They have the… it’s a small corner. I think it’s where Terminator ride is.

Jeanna: It’s kind of… oh, it is where Terminator is.

Andrew: No, isn’t that the waterfront?

Jeanna: They also have the Marvel section, but they have…

Andrew: Oh, you’re saying New York in other areas of the park.

Eric: Yeah. You know how there’s London in Florida? There’s a London section. I guess that was…

Jeanna: It’s across the way from there. I was just there in October.

Eric: Yeah, it’s New York. They have little… it’s some scaffolding, but the buildings are meant to look like New York City.

Andrew: Oh, I see.

Jeanna: It’s like The Daily Bugle, but it’s just a…

Eric: I think we’re thinking of two different areas.

Jeanna: No, no, no.

Eric: Regardless, there’s a New York; it’s a corner of the park and it’s just a couple of sets that are supposed to look like New York City, and it’s from way back when New York City was more prominent in movies.

Jeanna: It’s where Jaws used to be.

Eric: Yeah, it would be really fun for them to utilize that section as Fantastic Beasts. [laughs] Maybe just to have a merch store or something in Universal, because it’s built in. It’s like, it’s already there; why not?

Andrew: Well, I remember when they announced Diagon Alley that there was also a report that they had plans to do something for Fantastic Beasts. Or no, when they announced Fantastic Beasts, they announced that some elements of Fantastic Beasts would be coming to the theme park, I believe.

Eric: Interesting, interesting.

Andrew: So I guess we’ll see what’s going to happen. I don’t think anything’s going to happen soon, but maybe they’ll add a little daytime show, like the ones that they already have.

Eric: That’d be cool. More on that on Patreon!

Jeanna: I’m assuming Universal put in its contract somehow that any offshoots and new movies will be able to be incorporated into their parks.

Andrew: [laughs] “You must include Hogwarts or Diagon Alley in every single Wizarding World movie to come.” But they could also do expansions; definitely in Orlando, they’ve got the room for that. So let’s move on to some listener feedback. Micah, do you want to read a couple of these?

Micah: Yeah, sure. So we put out the question on Twitter about what excited people the most about the new trailer, and we got some good responses, the first from @QueenAimeedala, who says, “Newt reminds me of Hagrid. Expelled, Dumbledore’s friendship, love of beasts.”

[Eric laughs]

Micah: Yeah, we got that response quite a bit, so a lot of people drawing that comparison. Jemima Skelley said, “Seeing a Niffler!”

Eric: Aww.

Micah: And Kiran agreed, “Everything, but specifically the adorable Niffler and the music. I had goosebumps while watching it.”

Andrew: You’ll see those on shelves in the Wizarding World theme park.

Eric: What, goosebumps?

Andrew: No, Nifflers!

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Next to the Pygmy Puffs.

Micah: Yeah, there’re going to be stuffed Nifflers that you can take them home and…

Andrew: I didn’t think they were that cute. [laughs]

Jeanna: They weren’t what I expected.

Eric: Doesn’t it look like a platypus to anybody else?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah, definitely. I’m waiting for a disgustingly cute beast.

Micah: I thought maybe it was a badger at first because he’s a Hufflepuff.

Eric: Let’s be honest, guys; the Fantastic Beasts series really needs a BB-8 equivalent to compete with Star Wars.

Andrew: Exactly!

Jeanna: Aww.

Eric: [laughs] It’s gong to be the Niffler; I’m predicting it right now. That Niffler will start beep-boop-beeping, and all of a sudden…

Micah: It better survive all three films.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, Newt should totally have a beast sidekick.

Jeanna: I think it is the Niffler. I think the Niffler is his pet.

Eric: I’m sorry, but come Fantastic Beasts 3 the final battle, we’re not going to… the Niffler is going to get it. The Niffler is going to snuff it.

Jeanna: [gasps] Eric!

Andrew: [laughs] Just like Hedwig died?

Eric: In like, Act One.

Micah: Well, as you can see, it was clearly stealing somebody’s wallet there.

Eric: Huh. Street rat.

Jeanna: He’s a mischievous little fella.

Micah: Steal at your own risk. @AnnaBanana1309 said, “Albus Dumbledore…”

Andrew: That’s me. I’m Anna Banana.

[Jeanna laughs]

Micah: “… the magical, epic music, and the way it just feels like the wizarding world.”

Eric: Agreed.

Micah: @BisexualGinny says…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: “The set and costume design. With Harry Potter, we never got to see the fashion decor of the era it was set in,” meaning the ’90s.

Eric: And not much to see there.

Micah: Justin Victoria: “The ethereal Harry Potter charm is back! Grandiose cinematography, beautiful costume design (fedora-wearing Aurors), and badass Farrell.”

[Eric laughs]

Jeanna: American Farrell, which I think is interesting.

Eric: I’m glad for that. He played an American in Phone Booth, but nobody saw that movie.

Andrew: [laughs] This is his chance.

Micah: Chris Davis said, “The Apparition effects. It looks just as cool as it did in Deathly Hallows – Part 1.”

Eric: Agreed.

Micah: I can’t tell if that’s sarcasm or not.

[Jeanna laughs]

Andrew: I think it looked fine in Part 1.

Eric: The Apparition effect perfectly encapsulates what the books say Apparition is like.

Micah: Erika says, “When Newt flipped the switch to ‘Muggle-worthy’ in the trailer. Honestly, my favorite part.”

Eric: That was cute.

Andrew: I wonder if they could somehow make a toy version of that, but not toy, life-size.

Jeanna: I want it for reasons.

Eric: You should sell Newt’s briefcase. The boxset of the DVD/Blu-ray combo should come in a Newtcase.

Andrew: Oh, totally. You know they’re already thinking of that.

Micah: A Newtcase?

Eric: Yeah, that’s what we called it on a former episode of MuggleCast. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, I think that was an episode title once.

Micah: You should do marketing for them. But yeah, there you go; the Wizarding World is going to start selling those. Newtcases.

Eric: Newtcases, get your Newtcases! Well, and then the suitcase is going to be its own character, much like Hogwarts is its own character. The suitcase is going to maybe… I don’t know.

Jeanna: It’s a traveling Hogwarts.

Eric: Refuse to open or something like that. Yeah, you never know. A lot of potential there.

Micah: And Navya makes an interesting point, saying, “Security check when he apparently arrives from a ship. Interesting he doesn’t seem to arrive via magical means.”

Eric: I’m wondering if that wasn’t already addressed by Jo on Pottermore very recently, or just in general. For longer travel, isn’t it harder to use…? A broomstick runs… I don’t want to say runs out, because it doesn’t run on anything. But you wouldn’t take a broomstick over an ocean, because it’s cold, right? I wonder if he just had to because of the distance, is all I’m thinking.

Jeanna: Harry took it over that body of water in Movie 5.

Eric: Yeah, well, that was a movie.

Jeanna: Well…

Andrew: So is this. [laughs]

Eric: And also a river, not the Atlantic Ocean. Nothing Harry traveled was the length of the Atlantic… or they got a dragon to go over the body of water in Book 7.

Andrew: I can’t see the movie diving into the details like this, but maybe one reason could be paperwork-wise. If he was going through customs and whatnot and he’s going to be visiting the United States, he needs to have all that paperwork in order, and part of that would require having a story of how you got over here. “Yeah, I came off the boat that was right there. I’m not a wizard.”

Eric: That’s true.

Micah: Yeah, that’s a good point, especially given all of the issues that seem to be taking place in America right now.

Andrew: Right, they have to be super cautious to not…

Jeanna: And maybe their other channels were cut off because of the things that are happening.

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Micah: It’s a good point. All right, two more tweets here, one from T-Zach, who says, “The familiar name drops, the theme, the characters, the Magical Congress, the newspaper, the beasts, everything.”

Andrew: Actually, I just had another thought: Maybe it’s against the law to Apparate across borders.

Eric: Yeah, maybe. I mean, I just imagine the adverse effects of transporting yourself across the globe could be disastrous. It must be safer, must be safer…

Micah: And he also got expelled; let’s not forget that, so he may not be wanting to use magic right away.

Eric: Oh, right, because they can track it.

Micah: And Matty J.: “The trailer music with Colin’s voice overdub gave me chills. Also, they made Jacob seem good and Colin bad, in a way.” Do you guys agree with that?

Eric: That’s an interesting point. Yeah, Jacob seems like not annoying comic relief, but just kind of the everyman. It seems like he’s our catalyst; he’s our in to the magical world, is this Muggle, and not Newt.

Jeanna: He’s kind of us.

Andrew and Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I’m not totally sure yet of what purpose he serves in the movie, so hopefully it’ll be something good.

Eric: Right, he seems to be an observer.

Andrew: Yeah. Like, if Newt is going to have a sidekick, I want it to be a Pygmy Puff or a cute little sea otter.

Eric: No, Jacob is cute.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: Jacob is cute. I did make this note as I was watching the trailer; one of my notes was, “Why is Jacob allowed to see all this if he’s a No-Maj?”

Eric: Yeah, what makes Newt want to crawl into a suitcase in front of him and go, “Here, come on” with his hand?

Jeanna: What makes him so special that he gets to go to these underground wizard speakeasies and live with Newt and go into his suitcase with him?

Andrew: Maybe they’re in love.

Eric: They’re friends from the first day on the boat to New York.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: I think Jacob is American.

Jeanna: I think he is too. I think he knows the girls.

Andrew: Maybe… hmm. Okay. Well, if that’s the case, then this cancels out my idea. Maybe he sees one of Newt’s beasts poke its head out or escape, and Dan… [laughs] not Dan Fogler. Jacob is the only one who saw it, so Newt is like, “Oh, oh, crap. Here, come with me. I gotta tell you about something.”

Eric: “We’ll wipe your memory later.”

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: “Let me tell you all about… Obliviate.”

Andrew: But we do know he has a big role in the movie; he’s one of the four leads.

Eric: Wasn’t he announced to be a baker in Entertainment Weekly‘s whole thing?

Andrew: Yes. Yeah, he’s the Peeta.

[Eric and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: Something about his shop. I wonder if there will be a love triangle between Newt, Tina, and Jacob.

Andrew: Oh, wow. My heart couldn’t take that.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So that’s all we have for right now about the Fantastic Beasts trailer, one hour later. We’re going to discuss it more in bonus MuggleCast on Patreon, and I’m sure we will discuss it more on future episodes to come. But for now, wow. I am pumped.

Eric: For sure.

Andrew: Hmm?

Eric: I said for sure.

Andrew: Oh, for sure, yes. For sure, to your for sure.


Fun segment: Top Ten


Andrew: So Eric, you’re bringing back the Top Ten list today.

Eric: Yes, yes. People, listeners everywhere – MuggleCast veteran listeners – may remember we had a fun segment. We’re trying to do more of these on MuggleCast since MuggleCast is back and we’re going to be more regular soon and all that other stuff. We’re bringing back old fun segments, and the one we’re going to do this week – and I think this one’s a keeper based on our initial results – is Top Ten! But I guess we already just said that.

Andrew: Da-da-da-da-da!

Eric: [laughs] We need a theme song or something. We had “M-m-m-m-make the music connection.” We need some fun way of intro-ing it.

Andrew: T-t-t-t-ten list!

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: T-t-t-t-top ten!

Eric: Hey, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Andrew: Just use that same thing for every segment. N-n-n-n-news!

Eric: [laughs] So what we did for the Top Ten is we prompted our patrons over on Patreon to give us their answers for what they think in response to the prompt, and then what we did is we picked our favorites and ordered them into a Top Ten list just like we used to do, and also akin of late night television programs where they would also do this. So we’re going to take turns reading it, guys; it’s in the Skype document. But today’s Top Ten prompt was – and this is relevant to the season that it just became recently – “Spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because…” and here’s our Top Ten for that. So number ten: Spring Cleaning is so much easier for wizards because no winter wardrobes to pack away; cloaks are a year-round thing. That was sent in by Shannon Brown.

Andrew: [laughs] Those poor people sweating. Eric knows what that’s like.

Eric: Oh, yeah. [laughs] I just wore it the other day.

Andrew: Oh my gosh, to what? Where did you wear your Hogwarts cloak to?

Eric: It was the Loyola University readathon to support the HP Alliance’s Accio Books Campaign.

Andrew: Oh, cool. Were you sweating in it? Was it a hot day?

Eric: Yes. Yeah, it was.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: No, it was not. It has not been over 50 degrees here.

Eric: I sweated in the car…

Andrew: Yeah, but that cloak keeps the heat in.

Eric: But anyway.

Micah: Did you drive in them?

Eric: I did, yeah.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: He’s driven in them many a time.

Andrew: Have you filled up your gas tank with your cloak on? [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, I actually went to a 7-11 to visit the ATM and I had to walk pretty much across campus to get there.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: It was a lot of fun. Also, you know what? The stares have gone down, and I think that is attributable to the greater presence of nerd culture in the world today, because I remember doing it in 2005 in November in New York to the Disney Store, and the looks I got then to the looks I got on Loyola campus Chicago in 2016, night and day, let me tell you.

Andrew: I want to do a Top Ten list where we count down the weirdest places Eric has worn his cloak.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Jeanna: I will start working on that.

Eric: For the next time. But so spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because… somebody give us number nine.

Andrew: Number nine, from Sarah: because they have Gilderoy Lockhart’s Guide to Household Pests.

Eric: [laughs] I like that one a lot. So Gilderoy Lockhart’s books available in the wizarding world make spring cleaning easier. I buy it.

Andrew: I would buy that.

Micah: And that was from Sarah Pieper. Number eight: A Summoning Spell helps identify where your stuff is so that you can put it where it belongs.

Eric:Accio locket!”

Micah: Stuff.

Andrew: I seriously all the time say “Accio” in my head when I’m on the couch and I’m just like, “Augh.”

Micah: You want the remote?

Eric: Nerd.

Andrew: Yeah. Why can’t my phone just fly to me right now?

Jeanna: It’s usually when I’ve lost something and I’m scrambling to find it at 5 a.m.

Andrew: That’s the one spell I would legit love to have in the real world.

Micah: So thanks to Brandy for that one.

Eric: Jeanna, you should read number seven.

Jeanna: Spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because all your junk can be shoved into a trunk with an Undetectable Extension Charm, and you never have to look at it again! Great for packrats, from Shannon Spicer. Shannon, I totally agree.

Andrew: That’s a good one, but that’s dangerous. Do you really want to save all that stuff and have a way to do it?

Jeanna: I just need an Extension Charm on my closet, so that would help.

Eric: You wouldn’t need to pay so much for an apartment with extra storage with a lot of this stuff. Yeah, agreed. Okay, so down to number six, and this is: Spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because levitating heavy furniture beats asking for help or tiring yourself out. That’s from Shannon Kay. I agree. Actually, if I needed to get stuff that was under the couch and not need to lift the couch manually, that would save me some time.

Andrew: Number four…

Eric: Five.

Andrew: Number five: Spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because they can use a Time-Turner to never let spring start. That’s from Gigi Droesch.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: That’s a good one.

Eric: That was really sinister. I guess it’s just for them so that they can always avoid spring. It’s the ultimate procrastination.

Andrew: I would just stay in summer all the time, I think.

Eric: Good point. Except by the end of it, there’ll be like 15 of you enjoying the sun.

Micah: Number four: Cups of your favorite accompanying refreshment never empty.

Andrew: Ooh.

Jeanna: Never-ending butterbeer.

Micah: So what are you saying, Maureen?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: That people like to drink while they spring clean.

[Jeanna and Micah laugh]

Eric: I like the idea of refilling cups of water for a hard day’s work, or lemonade.

Andrew: No, of beer.

Eric: Yeah, of beer. Let’s be honest.

[Andrew laughs]

Jeanna: All right, number three: Because Scourgify. Done.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Jeanna: That is from Irvin.

Andrew: Yeah, that would be great.

Eric: Yeah, there’s a spell for that. Okay, now we’re getting down to the top two of Top Ten: Spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards because one word: Fiendfyre. [laughs]

Jeanna: That sounds so dangerous.

Eric: By definition, it’s uncontrollable fire. You’re just going to set your shh aflame to get rid of it.

Andrew: Sometimes you’ve got to do that, especially these packrats who are trying to put it all in one giant suitcase.

Eric: I’ve often felt like it would be easier to clean if all of the stuff I owned was just taken from me in a blaze.

Jeanna: Oh my gosh, don’t say that!

Eric: [laughs] Knocking on all of the wood right now.

Micah: To the person who lives with you.

Jeanna: I have stuff here too!

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: That comes from Katy. Also, I would never start Fiendfyre in any place.

Micah: Katy and Irvin are two opposite ends of the spectrum with how they would go about it.

Andrew: And then number one, the number one reason spring cleaning is so much easier for wizards is because Voldemort’s already hidden your antique junk and turned it into Horcruxes. Hey-o!

Eric: Hey-o!

Andrew: That’s from Laura Jamieson. Thank you, Laura. Thank you, everybody who sent those in. Got about 20, right?

Eric: Yeah, a couple notes… well, my shortlist was 20; we actually got 35, I think, submissions total, and some of them were duplicates, so I picked one from each person and then narrowed from there. But we even got an entry from 6-year-old, whose mom is a patron.

Andrew: Aww, that’s cute.

Micah: I was going to say, we have a 6-year-old patron?

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: They have a credit card?

Eric: Yeah, his credit card keeps getting approved, and I really should just…

Micah: Let’s get him a Niffler.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Eric: The 6-year-old whose name I did not write down, his entry was “The stuff cleans itself,” which is true.


News


Andrew: All right, so a couple of news stories here: First of all, the Wizarding World Hollywood finally opened up.

Eric: Yesss.

Andrew: It’s been under construction for years. I was lucky enough to attend the grand opening; it was really awesome. John Williams was there, as I alluded to earlier.

Jeanna: [gasps] So jealous.

Andrew: Yeah, he performed several of his scores from the Harry Potter movies. And they did something really cool this time for this one; they had a firework and projection show all around Hogwarts Castle. I took video of it; you can actually see it on the Hypable Facebook page. Just really amazing. And it was so good that my first thought after it was, “Why aren’t they doing this every night?” Not, of course, with John Williams; he can’t be there every night.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: But do the fireworks. Do the light show. The light show, it was only about… I don’t know, five-ish minutes? But it goes through each of the Hogwarts Houses and then it combines them all into one. It was just so cool. And actually, they had a press day the day after the grand opening. I wasn’t there, but a Universal fan site or something asked one of the creative directors of the park if they have any plans to do a nighttime show, and they said, “Maybe.” So maybe down the road, they will start doing it. I think at night that’d be a great way to get people to come out. I would see that more than once, because it was really awesome, and that’s something that they should do to compete with Disney.

Eric: If they projected against the castle, you might be able to see it from your apartment.

Andrew: I know. Well, I still gotta cut that tree down, but after that.

[Eric laughs]

Jeanna: Cut it down, man.

Micah: Replant, Andrew. Replant that tree.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Yes, you’re right. I’m sorry. And then one other news story today: We’ve raved about the Sorcerer’s Stone Illustrated Edition; it came out late last year. We all have it at this point, right?

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Don’t you dare say no or you’re banned from the show.

Eric: We definitely have it.

Jeanna: I got it for Christmas, so…

Andrew: Aww. Well, open your pocketbooks up again because they have announced the Chamber of Secrets Illustrated Edition.

Eric: [laughs] What kind of an endorsement is that?

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: A truthful one.

Andrew: It’s coming out later this year, again illustrated by Jim Kay. It looks beautiful. It’s got Harry, Ron, and the Weasley twins in the Ford Anglia approaching the Burrow on its cover. They released a couple of pages from inside of it, a great portrait of Hagrid, a new portrait of Hogwarts, a look at the mandrakes, a look at phoenixes. So we all love the first one, obviously; I think it’s safe to say that this one and the rest of them are going to be just as good because these illustrations are just beautiful. And yeah, that’ll come out later this year.

Eric: I can’t wait.

Micah: I think October 4, right, is the date Amazon lists?

Andrew: Oh, okay. 115 illustrations. Yo.

Eric: Is that more than the previous book?

Andrew: That’s more. They said around 100 for the first one. I think there’s just going to be more and more as the books get longer.

Eric: I finally got a chance to read several chapters from it at the readathon. We were just reading along using the illustrated edition, and it just really sucks you in, so it’s really cool. You know a curiosity from this cover, though, of the Chamber of Secrets: The Ford Anglia has a license plate, and it’s letters and numbers.

Jeanna: It does in the movie.

Eric: Oh, I wonder if it’s a movie-ism. I wonder if it’s the same as the one in the movie. Now I’m going to look that up later.

Andrew: [laughs] Eric always points out the finer things.

Eric: It’s just weird; it’s weird that it has a license plate. It’s just… that’s weird.

Jeanna: It’s a refurbished car. It was a functioning car at one point.

Eric: I get it, but what’s the significance of HDW782D? What is that?

Andrew: [laughs] There’s no significance.

Jeanna: Yeah, there’s no significance.

Micah: Or is there?

Eric: No, I’m looking up…

Micah: Eric, it’s the key to the first Fantastic Beasts movie.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Eric: This is JKR’s door all over again, Micah. I’m telling you guys.

Andrew: [laughs] Type that code in.

Eric: I’m going to reserve HDW782D.com right now.

Andrew: Oh my God. Get out of here. Go to FantasticBeastsMovie.com, punch those numbers into the keyboard, see if anything happens. [laughs]

Eric: I’m telling you guys. It’s special.


Listener feedback


Andrew: Okay, so time for a little feedback now. Micah, do you want to read this first one?

Micah: Sure. The first listener feedback comes from Johanne in Norway, who’s been listening for about four or five months now, really enjoys the show, and is halfway through listening to all of our episodes. Thank you, first of all, for… I mean, that’s pretty impressive, right?

Eric: That’s amazing.

Micah: Yeah, I was going to say.

“I find it very interesting to hear all you guys have to say about the series and you have given me completely new perspectives on different aspects of the story. Thank you.”

So Johanne goes on to say basically he’s in a little bit of a pickle, right? That’s what I’m taking away from this.

Andrew: Pickle Pack.

Eric: Pickle Pack?

[Jeanna laughs]

Andrew: So his…

Micah: Go ahead.

Andrew: So he is going to see the Harry Potter play in London in the Easter holiday next year in 2017, but they already bought the book version of the play, and as everyone else, will receive it this summer. So he or she is concerned about…

Micah: I think it’s a she, by the way.

Andrew: Okay. So she is concerned about should she still go see the play next year? And by the way, [laughs] I kind of hope we turn into this support podcast, this advice podcast, where everybody sends their unique situations about the Cursed Child.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: And we decide if they should go see it or not after all. [laughs]

Eric: Here’s my thought on this. And they say, “On one hand, I really want to read it, but it might feel like it might ruin the experience when I see the play.” My whole thing is… here’s my opinion, Johanne, if this helps, is that nothing will ever match seeing the official play with the official cast on the official stage in an official production. Nothing.

Andrew: Agree.

Eric: Not reading the book, not acting out the play with your friends after reading the book, which you can totally do, and I’m starting a podcast where that gets done. But I think that there will be something totally unique for all people who are able to catch the live performance, and so I would argue that you probably can, and it will be safe to read the play for curiosity’s sake. I know I would hate myself having to hold out seven months or eight months to not read a book that I owned and had pre-ordered, too, so I would say go for it.

Andrew: I agree.

Micah: I do too. And I feel like we even raised this question before it was raised here, right? On a previous episode.

Andrew: Yeah, we did.

Micah: Because we knew that something like this was going to happen. I agree with everything that’s been said; I think that going and seeing this play is going to be a unique experience, something that you’re going to enjoy doing. The book comes out – and it will – before you go and see it, then it’s really your decision, right? I just think that better you read it and not just get randomly spoiled, because I think it’s going to be near impossible for you to not encounter some sort of spoiler, whether it’s on television or on the Internet or social media. I would just say do whatever feels right for you, because I just think it’s going to be impossible to go almost an entire year without somehow finding out what happens in the story.

Andrew: Yeah. And I think you can always change your mind later if you read it. You can think about it for a month and be like, “Eh, do I really want to see it?” And then based on how you like the story, you can decide from there too.

Eric: If you hate the story, you can always sell your ticket. [laughs]

Andrew: Exactly.

Micah: Yeah, there you go.

Eric: For a million dollars.

Andrew: Yeah. They might be able to go for a good amount of money, actually.

Micah: So thanks, Johanne.

Andrew: Yeah, and good luck with that.

Micah: Sorry I called you if Johan or something like that.

Andrew: Yeah, you did. I thought that was weird. I was going to ask, but I thought maybe you knew something I didn’t.

Micah: Yeah, no.

Andrew: And if anybody else is in similar pickles, feel free to email us. If there’s any other unique situations, we can certainly try to help you. But make sure it’s a unique situation; we don’t want to read the same stories over again. [laughs]

Eric: This is Chicken Soup for the Cursed Child attendees.

Jeanna: And make sure it’s related back to Potter.

Andrew: Right. So on last month’s episode, we spoke about J.K. Rowling’s “Native Americans in the Wizarding World” piece on Pottermore, and to be honest, we didn’t do the best job that we could have speaking about it. We could have prepared for it more, I think; we could have better represented the views of the Native American community, and we didn’t do that, so for that, we apologize. We did get some feedback; some people are unhappy. Like I said, for example, Tara said, “‘It’s just fiction’ is same as ‘just a mascot.’ It propagates an outdated and distorted view of who we are as Natives.” And then Laura said, “I love you, but listening to three white guys try to talk about why Indigenous people are upset with JKR was just cringeworthy. Indigenous people have been writing about this online since J.K. Rowling first revealed there would be a North American magic school. There is no reason you couldn’t have gotten informed about the conversation before gracing us with your clueless opinions.” And listen, I am completely aware of those three white guys talking about the Native American community, so like I said, we’re sorry about that.

Micah: I think the key is not the fact that three white guys can’t have an intelligent conversation; I think we’ve proven our ability to do that hundreds of times over the course of the life of this podcast.

Eric: Thank you.

Micah: But to your point earlier, I think we could have been informed a little bit more, done a little bit more research, based on what Laura said. I also don’t think that approaching the argument from their standpoint the way that they did, labeling us specifically the way that they did, is any way furthers their argument; if anything, in my mind, it lessens it. So I agree with what you said, Andrew. I think we could have approached it better. We could have been more informed.

Andrew: I think their point is, though, that we could have a different voice on the show, say a Native American voice on the show. I think that’s where Laura was going with that.

Micah: Definitely a possibility. And certainly, it’s not our place to tell anybody how they should feel about a specific issue, especially if it’s coming from their perspective, and it’s them that’s being specifically referenced. So 100% on that point, I agree with what Laura is saying. I agree with what Tara is saying and what others wrote in saying, so…

Andrew: Sorry, I want to wrap up with one more email. This is from Simón; I thought he put it very well. He said,

“Long-time listener, first time emailer. The last episode’s discussion of North American magic touched on a number of complex or sticky aspects of American history. I wanted to comment on some of these as a person of color, focusing on the narrative around the Rappaport law. ‘Segregation’ between magical and non-magical folks could go very wrong very quickly. I’m imagining these films will involve ‘desegregation’ and a more open life for wizards. Given the very specific American history of segregation in the 20th century, and J.K. Rowling’s very British self, I worry that this plot line will play out without any acknowledgement of the black American experience. Making matters worse is the very white cast of Fantastic Beasts. If you watch old black and white films, you’ll notice that you either never see black people or see them as laborers, servants, or entertainers. I worry that this film will do the same or exclude them entirely, while depicting a triumphant desegregation where everyone can come together in understanding and unity, while the Jim Crow South exists a few hundred miles away from the action. One of you mentioned excitement over the New Orleans wandmaker and it got me thinking that New Orleans’ rich history of racial and cultural diversity could allow for some interesting people of color to add to the story and world. Who knows, maybe we’ll meet a freedman or woman in the North. But as much as I love Jo and her writing, she is coming from the perspective of a white British woman, and that means she can very easily pass over these points or handle them poorly. I hope she is doing her due diligence, or has people on her team who are. I am not Native American, but I certainly saw a real lack of consideration or understanding in her use of their history and culture. I worry the same may happen for other marginalized groups, especially since none of them are represented in the cast that we have seen so far.”

So I agree with what Simón said. I will add, though, that the President of MACUSA is a person of color.

Eric: You said it right. Have you been working on that for a month?

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: I’ve been thinking about it since our last episode. I keep thinking about Koozie. So thanks for all that feedback, and if this topic comes up again, because of Fantastic Beasts or for whatever reason, we will do better research and try to have a more accurate discussion.

Eric: This was a great email. It’s a very valid concern. I think it’s worth furthering the issue here, because it’s something that we’d like to see Jo change, essentially.

Micah: I think, though, that what surprises me in a lot of these responses, though, is knowing J.K. Rowling and the way that she has written past series, she’s somebody who doesn’t lack for research and doesn’t lack for knowledge. So again, like in this email, specifically labeling her as being a British white female…

Eric: It doesn’t do credit to previous instances in the past where she has shown her ability to research. That said, the recent blunder, I would call it, with the Native American culture being adapted poorly into the wizarding world shows that there are blind spots, and I think people are just being very apprehensive about what that could mean for the future. And I think J.K. Rowling, being the intelligent woman she is, should be working immediately to correct so that there’s not, for instance, a bad habit forming here.

Andrew: Yeah, and we’ll see. We’ll see. I mean, they are somewhat aware of the issue; when they first posted that Native American article on Pottermore it depicted that Native American – or Native Americans – and that image has since been removed, so they are aware of the backlash. We’ll see what happens from here, though, because everybody’s right; they have to tread carefully here. One last thing here on the show today: This is from Emily, who recently made a very generous donation to our Patreon. She sent in this email after doing so, and I thought to thank her, we should read it. It’s kind of like a little game. She says,

“I’m a licensed nurse and a great fan of the books since forever. Not so much the movies. But I cried tears of joy when I walked into Hogsmeade in Florida on my 30th birthday. I’ve always identified as a Gryffindor. I was Sorted as such on the original Pottermore. Here’s my very brief story: I’m now 33. My man friend is 64. He’s a professional musician. We’ve been together 10 years. As the British say, ‘Mind the Gap.’ Clearly, I haven’t! I figured, well, we’re sharing a home, we have been for quite a while now. My house is his, right? So what would happen if my long term ‘manfriend,’ my partner in love and life – who, I should point out, has no knowledge of the Harry Potter books or movies and absolutely no interest in any of it – what if he took the quiz in my stead? What if HE took the new Sorting Hat quiz on Pottermore, representing me and my ‘House’? Because our homes ARE the same, right? I figured, this is my House. I’ve been with him for ten years. Let’s see what House I’ve been living in!”

So she also did this because she also has only one email address and she couldn’t retake take the quiz. [laughs] So she wants us to guess which House her 64-year-old man friend got. Do you think he got Gryffindor as well, representing her?

Jeanna: I don’t know. I feel like I need more information on him.

Andrew: Being together ten years, if he’s taking the quiz as her so he’s putting in answers that he thinks she would put in, I would think that he would also get Gryffindor. But then again, it’s kind of a new quiz.

Micah: It’s a Hatstall.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Hatstall. Does that happen on the new Pottermore, since the website is all jank now?

Andrew: I don’t know.

Jeanna: I don’t think it does.

Andrew: Who wants a Hatstall, really?

Eric: [sings] “The magic’s gone…”

Micah: Can we just say that after reviewing this very carefully, after going through all the details, that we have a big announcement to make: You’re actually both being sent to Ilvermorny, right?

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: So forget about Hogwarts. It’s irrelevant now. It’s not even the focus of the next movie.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Well, it did appear in the trailer.

Jeanna: You don’t know that, Micah.

Andrew: So why don’t you guys take a guess? Well, Micah guessed they’re going to Ilvermorny. How about Eric and Jeanna?

Eric: I’m going to say I think her man’s a Hufflepuff. I don’t know why. Something about his loyal…

Jeanna: Stop trying to put everyone in your House.

Andrew: Yeah, but remember, he’s playing as her.

Eric: I know.

Andrew: Okay.

Eric: But you know why he’s playing as her? Because he’s loyal, right? Right?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: And loyalty… ultimately, I think Pottermore/J.K. Rowling can always tell; she’s like Santa. That loyalty is going to stick out in any attempted quiz, so I’m going to guess Hufflepuff.

Andrew: She’s like Santa.

Eric: And yeah, I can put people in my House. I don’t care.

Jeanna: [laughs] I will say that he is a Gryffindor because you are where you want to be. I told all of my friends before they took the test, what you are before the test is where you’re supposed to be. So I think he is a Gryffindor.

Andrew: Okay. Well, Emily, please let us know. She didn’t even give me the answer! I’ve been on pins and needles.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So email me again and let me know which House you were Sorted on Pottermore by your man friend, and we’ll reveal it next episode.

Eric: We’re dying to know, Emily.

Andrew: Yeah. Before we wrap up the show, just a quick update about our Patreon: We’re getting really close to starting to do two episodes a month again.

Eric: So close.

Andrew: It is so beautiful. It is so beautiful. We would love your support. Now’s a great time to sign up; our first round of signed album arts are about to go out soon. Erica… Eric. [laughs] Erica Sculla. No, Eric has been very carefully plotting out the first round of signed album art cards; they’ll be going out soon, right, Eric?

Eric: I am holding in my hand 400 stamps.

Andrew: Oh, I thought you were going to hold all 400 cards; that’d be a lot to hold in one hand.

Eric: [laughs] Yes, tomorrow the first round of album art is being shipped; I’m so thrilled. That is happening to our eligible patrons, so close to 300 pieces of art are going out, and people will start to see them in their mailboxes by who knows? As early as the beginning of next week.

Andrew: Yeah, probably. And we’d love to see some pictures of those hanging up; maybe you’ll hang them up on the fridge or something.

Eric: Yeah, tweet at us. Showcase it. We’ll retweet anything that we see. And Andrew, you were saying about how close we are to hitting our first milestone, and we have over 400 patrons and that happened. And keep in mind that the tiers that we have set up for album art and T-shirt is included in that same tier; it’s capped, it’s limited at 687 signups, so we have a little over 200 to go before you won’t be able to get album art or a T-shirt.

Andrew: Right. And when you do sign up on Patreon, if you’re impatient and don’t want to wait for the card or the T-shirt, good news, there’s lots of extra bonus material on the MuggleCast Patreon right now, including bonus MuggleCast segments, chapter readings, and a whole lot more.

Eric: Definitely.

Andrew: And we are about to record two more bonus MuggleCast segments. So we’d appreciate your support; it’s helping the show grow. We have a busy year, busy years ahead, and we need your support to keep this show ticking. And like I said, we’re getting close to two episodes a month again, which we haven’t done in years.

Eric: Right, and that’ll be for everybody, which is great.

Andrew: Exactly.

Eric: That’ll come out on the MuggleCast podcast feed just as this episode did, to celebrate our success and your patronage.

Andrew: Yeah. And I mean, obviously there’s so much to talk about; we’re at 90 minutes right now with this episode.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: So when we’re doing two episodes a month, that will be be around an hour each, probably more in some cases. So thank you, everybody who’s signed up so far, thank you to future supporters, and thank you to everybody for listening. I’m Andrew.

Eric: I’m Eric.

Micah: I’m Micah.

Jeanna: And I’m Jeanna.

Andrew: Thanks again, Jeanna, for coming on, and for dealing with all the Patreon stuff around your apartment.

[Andrew and Jeanna laugh]

Andrew: We’ll see everybody next time for Episode 291. Goodbye!

Eric and Micah: Bye.

Transcript #275

MuggleCast 275 Transcript


Show Intro


[Show music begins]

Andrew: The final episode of MuggleCast for 2014 is brought to you by Audible.com. Audible is the leading provider of audiobooks with more than 150,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 275. A nice… not exactly round number, but it falls on one of those quarter sections, you know what I’m saying?

Eric: It’s a Quarter Quell.

Andrew: [laughs] It’s a Quarter Quell, right.

Selina: Oh.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Good, we’ve already got the show title. The episode is finished.

[Selina laughs]

Eric: Oh, great.

Andrew: That’s the only reason we ever record it for so long. We were always just looking for a show title.

Eric: Goodbye, everybody.

Micah: And Eric, for the first time ever, got in the first, what, ten seconds of recording?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Something like that.

Andrew: Pretty good record. So we’re here for a nice little holiday episode, I guess you could say, even though Christmas and Hanukkah and most of the holidays have passed through December. We’ve reached another end of the year, and we’re going to do a lot of things today. We’re going to look back at the biggest Harry Potter stories of the year, we’re going to complain about… I mean…

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: … we’re going to talk about the new Pottermore material, we’ve got some Fantastic Beasts news to talk about, I have a big question for Micah, we’re going to predict 2015, and then we have a big, big announcement. Maybe not that big, but big. I always hate raising people’s expectations because they will think we’re about to announce something like J.K. Rowling is coming on the podcast or something like this. I’m actually glad that J.K. Rowling has never been on the podcast. Do you know why?

Selina: Oh, yeah? Why? [laughs]

Eric: Because how would we ever top it?

Micah: Well, I think it’s because you can just keep talking about the fact that she’s never been on the podcast.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Yes. That’s fun to do.

Eric: Well, it’s more air time.

Andrew: But I like trolling her on Twitter.

Selina: Uh-huh.

Andrew: I like keeping myself distant from her so I can troll her on Twitter. Like recently, I @-replied her. All I said was, “Please come to Brazil.”

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: It got like a hundred favorites. I was shocked.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Selina: It’s hilarious.

Andrew: [laughs] I was like, “What? People really liked that tweet!”

Micah: You should just keep doing that each week, pick a different country and see how it does.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Selina: But Brazil is like the one that people always ask celebrities to go to, [laughs] so that’s why…

Andrew: Yeah. I sent her a tweet that says, “Congrats on 400 tweets.” That got nineteen favorites. People… there’s a demand for this, I think. So people like…

Eric: I think they expect you to follow in Micah’s shoes, too, with trolling her the way that he does…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … on Twitter all the time.

Andrew: I mean, Micah trolls her by just protesting her.

Eric: Yeah, yeah. It’s really negative. It’s really… yeah, not positive.

Micah: It’s not negative!

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Well, I think J.K. Rowling said something on Twitter a couple of weeks ago that should seal the deal for Micah…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … following her on Twitter. You don’t follow her yet, right?

Micah: I do not.

Andrew: Okay. If this tweet doesn’t do it, I don’t know what will. But we’ll talk about that in a little bit.

Eric: Yeah.


Recap: Wizarding World of Harry Potter Theme Parks


Andrew: First, let’s talk about the biggest stories of the year. We’re just going to jump around. I just wanted to kind of recap 2014 for Harry Potter fans. First of all, Diagon Alley opened.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I know Micah, Eric, and I have all been there at this point. Really wonderful, right? They did such a great job.

Selina: I’m sure it’s just amazing…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Selina: … and the best thing ever, [laughs] and if you can’t go, then your life is over.

Andrew: Yeah. I’m sorry you haven’t been.

Selina: Whatever. I don’t want Butterbeer anyway.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh!

Andrew: Well, you can go to the Studio Tour for that! You got Butterbeer there, didn’t you?

Selina: That’s true. Yeah, I did.

Andrew: It’s not the same, though.

Selina: No.

Andrew: It’s just not the same.

Eric: No. But Diagon Alley is really impressive detail-wise. It’s more detailed. There’s more to see…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … than in the Hogsmeade part of the park, and that is what makes it cool. And…

Selina: Can you go into the shops?

Eric: You can! Yeah, in fact…

Selina: Wow!

Eric: … most of them. More of them… because Hogsmeade had it where there was a couple of shops, but then most of them were storefronts, which were cool. I think Diagon Alley, they strived to actually make more shops so that you can enter them. Like real shops.

Selina: Can you buy stuff?

Eric: Uh-huh! That’s pretty much all you can do.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Or you can wait four hours in line to go on Gringotts.

Eric: Or you can wait four hours for Gringotts. But Gringotts was pretty cool.

Andrew: Here’s kind of a good year-in-review statement about Diagon Alley. People were… there [were] concerns about how busy it would be there after the park opened, and now I think the lines are actually really manageable.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: I haven’t seen any complaints about long lines, even for the Hogwarts Express. That thing, I remember going through it for the first time and seeing the queue. The line… it wasn’t full when I walked through it, but they had built so much queue…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … in anticipation, and it just doesn’t fill up, and I don’t think… I don’t say that in a bad way that they’re not getting as many people that they wanted. I just think that the trains – there’s two of them – run really efficiently. So I think they did a great job, and I’m glad to see that the lines aren’t as crazy. So if you are thinking of going, I’d say go whenever. Maybe not summer, but go whenever. There’s not a huge rush right now.

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: Well, this time of year I’d think would be pretty busy down there, with everybody on vacation from school…

Andrew: Probably, yeah.

Eric: It’s actually…

Micah: People take off work.

Eric: The month of November I heard was when the locals go because it’s just quieting down. It’s like a dull period where the rest of the nation is cold, but nobody has quite hit vacation yet.

Andrew: And it’s right after Universal’s Halloween stuff and right before Christmas.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that’s really when I think the locals go. But yeah, you could go down there now and find probably some not very long wait times.

Micah: Maybe.

Andrew: In other Wizarding World news, the Wizarding World Japan opened up over the summer. Very similar to Hogsmeade. There’s no Diagon Alley. But they have the Black Lake there, kind of sitting near Hogwarts, which I think people really liked. And apparently the Hollywood one is going to have some special features like this as well, that are unique to the Hollywood land, so…

Micah: They should, though.

Selina: Mhm. Yeah.

Micah: I think that provides interest from people to go to those parks, because let’s say you’re on the East Coast of the US and you’ve been to Orlando and you know what that’s all about. I would think if you’re a fan and maybe you’re taking a trip out to California, you’d want to explore. And not to say that Potter fans wouldn’t go anyway, but to have that added interest and know that there’s something different about the park. Because if they’re all the same, what makes them unique?

Selina: Yeah, exactly. It’s not an IKEA.

Andrew: Right.

[Micah laughs]

Selina: Or a Walmart, to speak in your terms. [laughs] You’re supposed to go for a unique experience.

Andrew: Well, what makes it unique to me, as somebody who lives in the LA area, is that I can actually drive there…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … get drunk in the Hog’s Head…

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: … then take a taxi home.

Selina: Mhm.

Andrew: I can’t say that anywhere else.


Recap: David Legeno Passes Away at 50


Andrew: Some sadder news happened this year. David Legeno, who played Fenrir Greyback, he died while hiking in Death Valley over the summer. That was a really sad story.

Eric: Yeah.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: But the rest of the year was lighter news. Well, except for the Ron and Hermione drama.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Oh, did that make this year in review?

Selina: Which I was personally very affected by.

[Andrew laughs]


Recap: J.K. Rowling Writes About Quidditch World Cup on Pottermore


Andrew: J.K. Rowling wrote a story about the trio at the World Cup. That was one of the bigger things on Pottermore this year, I think.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: That legitimately lived up to the excitement because we got some tidbits about where they all are now, so that was really cool.

Micah: It was another one of those new stories, right? That J.K. Rowling wrote this year.

Andrew: Right. A new story. And that could kind of pass as a “new story,” but this Twelve Days of Christmas thing that they did earlier this month, where a lot of media outlets were saying, “J.K. Rowling to write twelve new Harry Potter stories, oh my God!” It was just… it was ridiculous.

Micah: It was funny. I forget… somebody asked me about that. I think it might have been at work. It just came up about how apparently she was writing all these new stories that were going to be released, and I actually had to explain to the person that they weren’t new.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Well, sorry, they are new. But they’re not…

Andrew: They’re not stories.

Micah: They’re supplemental content.

Andrew: Well, right. But some of them were just potions. They weren’t even… it wasn’t even new J.K. Rowling writing.

Eric: Were they this time?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Because I saw a lot of stories now this time…

Andrew: They were, but not all of them.

Eric: I was thinking too, there’s going to be, like, potions. One day you’re just going to get to do an extra potion on Pottermore.

Andrew: Yeah. It was a mess. Even the Pottermore Insider blog released a post saying, “Yeah, no, remember it’s not new J.K. Rowling Harry Potter stories.”ù

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: [laughs] I was like…

Eric: Yeah, the media… it’s funny because how many years are we in now? If you count from ’97, we’re seventeen years into the Harry Potter books being a thing. And the news still can’t…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … handle itself. Or they don’t know exactly how to not blow this out of proportion.

Selina: It’s gotten worse, hasn’t it?

Andrew: It’s gotten worse.

Selina: Because it’s all clickbait now.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: This year, it really got bad. But I’m hoping that people kind of… now they’re understanding that they’re being played, so they’ll stop clicking on them and then people will stop writing that nonsense.

Selina: Yeah.

Eric: Mhm.


Recap: Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them Movie Series


Andrew: Anyway, Fantastic Beasts. It was a big year for Fantastic Beasts. We found out that it will be a trilogy.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: That was a big deal. And then later in the year, we found out the release dates: November 2016, November 2018, and November 2020.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: So…

Micah: Until the last one is split into two.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: Due to content.

Andrew: Well, yeah, remember they said it will be at least a trilogy.

Selina: Mhm.

Andrew: So maybe you’re right, Micah. Maybe it’s not that J.K. Rowling may write five movies or six movies, but they’re just leaving the possibility open to split that last one.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Because that’s kind of what they’re doing with the Avengers. Marvel announced that Avengers: Infinity War is going to be Avengers – Part 1… sorry, Avengers: Infinity War – Part 1.

Selina: Which is just bizarre, isn’t it?

Andrew: It is.

Selina: Because it’s not like it’s…

Andrew: It’s not a book.

Selina: … an adaptation.

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: Yeah. It’s a unique story.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, that’s why I thought the Avengers were going to be… the Avengers as we know them are going to end at Infinity War, but at least one person told me, “I don’t think so.” Who knows?

Eric: I think they’re probably just trying to be like comic books, too, which always are about serialization and continuations and stuff.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: So it’s like they’re making movies – these huge, huge budget movies – like comic books, where you have to get the second issue to read the full story.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: What’s somewhat ironic about that, though, is that it’s really Harry Potter that started this trend of splitting the final…

[Everyone laughs]

Selina: Yes.

Eric: Well, Harry Potter, to the studios, proved that it could be done, I think, right? And there may have been one or two films before it. There were films certainly that…

Micah: Well, I think in terms of major book-to-film adaptations that were significant…

Selina: Mhm.

Micah: … in length beyond just a couple of films…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: … like Potter, we’ve seen it now really with everything, from Hunger Games… I’m sure there [are] plenty of others I’m missing here, but The Hobbit, right?

Selina: The Hobbit.

Andrew: Twilight

Eric: Twilight.

Micah: The Hobbit turned into three. Twilight.

Selina: Twilight.

Andrew: Now, also, Divergent coming up.

Selina: [laughs] Oh, yeah.

Micah: Mhm, exactly. So it’s…

Andrew: That’s the thing to do.

Micah: It’s the cool thing to do. Make more money. Rake in those dollars.

Andrew: [laughs] But we, as fans, can’t really complain, as much as I…

Micah: No, of course not.

Andrew: As much as I despise it, just like anyone else. Obviously, for websites it’s a good thing. For the fans it’s a good thing. For the most part.

Eric: At least with Fantastic Beasts, we know that it’s not being adapted. JKR is writing the screenplay for each film, so it won’t be like they’re stretching any kind of content. These films are being written for the screen. It’ll be really exciting to see how her voice directly translates to the movie.

Selina: Yeah.

Micah: Yeah.

Selina: I’m really excited.

Andrew: It makes me wonder if this whole book-splitting trend was a thing ten years prior, maybe thanks to another film, would Goblet of Fire have been split into two, definitely? Would Order of the Phoenix?

Eric: Yeah, I wonder.

Andrew: Or is it just… are studios…

Micah: It’s just the finales.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: That’s the thing. But when is that trend going to break? It seems inevitable.

Micah: It should have, though. It should have broken way before because I think that you could have justified other books in the Potter series, in particular, being broken into two movies. I know we’ve discussed this…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: … on prior shows, but as early as Goblet of Fire, definitely if not then, then Order of the Phoenix, for sure.

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: Mhm.

Andrew: I mean, Order of the Phoenix… yeah. Well, we don’t need to get into that.

Micah: So much was left out of there.

Andrew: I know.

Eric: I still love that film, though. It’s weird.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: It’s my least favorite.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Because it was my favorite book.

Selina: Yeah, me too.

Andrew: Okay, we’re going to continue with today’s show in just a moment, but first, it’s time to remind everybody that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks, and that is no joke. They have more than 150,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including audio versions of many New York Times Best Sellers. And for listeners of MuggleCast, Audible is offering you a free book to give you a chance to try out their great service. Today, I am going to recommend a book-to-film adaptation. I’m sure you’ve heard of it. It is easily one of the best movies of the year. It is Gone Girl. Now, this is a book by Gillian Flynn. It is a fantastic book and a great movie. In the case of Gone Girl, it’s hard to say whether the book or the film was better; both are so beloved. I highly recommend reading and watching the story, because it really is just one of the best movies of the year. You can grab this one for absolutely free by visiting AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. If that’s not the type of book for you, maybe try The Fault in Our Stars, the book by John Green. Grab The Casual Vacancy by J.K. Rowling. Grab The Cuckoo’s Calling or The Silkworm, also by J.K. Rowling/Robert Galbraith. You can get any of these books for free: AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Try listening to a book instead of reading it. You’re really going to enjoy it, I think. You’ll listen to it just like you do this podcast. AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast to get an audiobook for absolutely free, and we thank Audible for their support of the show.

Micah: Just going back to Fantastic Beasts for a second, talking about a big year for that, how about – and don’t get shocked here that I’m bringing this up – J.K. Rowling’s tweet, the anagram that…

Andrew: Oh, right.

Micah: … basically set off the Twitter world…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: … trying to figure that thing out.

Selina: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah. That was such a big deal because I think… that arguably is one of the most exciting things that happened on Twitter – or not on Twitter; in the Harry Potter fandom – this year because everybody kind of knew it wasn’t going to be some gigantic reveal, and yet it was so exciting because we all remember the riddles on J.K. Rowling’s old website.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: So having her give us a new riddle was just huge. And it was just so simple for her to do, and it seemed to come up spontaneously, when somebody asked her to do a riddle and then the next morning she did it. It was really cool.

Selina: It was very in the spirit of her, wasn’t it?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, and you could tell she was having a blast doing it.

Selina: Mmm.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. This was… I think 2014 will go down as the year that J.K. Rowling…

Selina: Embraced Twitter?

Andrew: Yes, yes.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Absolutely, that is probably one of the most exciting things this year.


Recap: J.K. Rowling on Twitter


Andrew: And yeah, speaking of that, I think one of the things that kicked off this whole Twitter extravaganza for J.K. Rowling was when she spoke about the sixteenth anniversary of the Battle of Hogwarts back in May. This is one of her first tweets, and it was… first tweets that wasn’t like, “Pen and paper are my priority at the moment.”

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: Then after that, she started answering a couple of other questions. But you had to go and look at her tweets. They weren’t showing up in your feed because she was directly replying to people. But then she learned that trick where you put a period in front of the usernames.

Selina: [laughs] She’s been doing that a lot.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Micah: Her assistant told her, yeah.

Selina: So funny.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: So yeah, I think in May was when that really all started, and now it’s a whole big thing.

Selina: It’s very refreshing, too, to see the way she’s interacting with people.

Andrew: It is.

Selina: Because she slams people down, and she’s really personal, both in good and bad. When people try to make a complaint to her, she slams them right back. It’s really cool.

Andrew: She slams them down, but she’s really classy about it.

Selina: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: She’s never mean about it or anything. It doesn’t even come off mean-spirited.

Selina: She always has the upper hand.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.


Recap: J.K. Rowling’s Wonderland Interview


Andrew: Of course, there was that whole big J.K. Rowling’s comments about Ron and Hermione that got twisted by the Sunday Times. I can’t remember what their headline was, but it started a whole brouhaha. That was, I would say, the low point [laughs] of 2014 in terms of Harry Potter fans.

Selina: Mmm.

Andrew: Because everybody was so shocked by that.

Selina: Well, everyone was so upset because even the people that wanted Harry and Hermione to get together at the time… I mean, we’ve all moved on. We’ve all grown up to some extent. We’ve all sort of made our peace with it. And suddenly, it appeared that everything we thought we knew was wrong, and it was like, “Ahh!” [laughs]

Andrew: Right.

Selina: And I probably made it a bigger deal out of it than I should have.

[Andrew laughs]

Selina: [clears throat] But [laughs] it was funny.

Andrew: Yeah, eventually we learned that her comments were misconstrued.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: But she was still reconsidering Ron and Hermione. That’s the best way to put it.

Eric: Yeah. Well, they released… what was it? Wonderland released a promo before releasing the actual article, and it was going to be a month or something ridiculous before the actual words came out.

Andrew: That’s the thing. Wonderland was kind of blame, too, because they released this interview in advance to the Sunday Times. And then the Sunday Times

Eric: Yeah, the Sunday Times did their preview or whatever…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … and they had misconstrued the… like shoddy journalism, and then it was a long time before we could realize that JKR didn’t exactly say exactly…

Andrew: Funnily enough, it was only six days. I was just looking at this.

Eric: Oh. Well, it felt like thirty days. [laughs]

Andrew: But it truly felt like thirty days. [laughs] Truly. That’s why I say…

Selina: But you know what’s funny about it is… we don’t need to spend a lot of time on it, but what’s funny… seeing her actual comments that she was reconsidering Ron and Hermione, I think you can really tell that from the final couple of books because Harry and Hermione were so close friends. And as she said herself, just after the seventh book came out, there were a few moments when it could have gone the other way.

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: And I like it because it’s realistic. It’s not like she made this choice, Ron and Hermione, and she was going to [makes sound like forcing two things together] them together.

Eric: Try to fit a square peg through a round hole.

Selina: Yeah, exactly.

Eric: Yeah.

Selina: She let the characters go where the characters wanted to go.

Andrew: Mhm.

Selina: And I like that.

Eric: And it was a step up back from… or a step forward, because the only comment that I can recall her previously talking about that pairing was the “delusional.”

Selina: Oh, yeah.

Eric: The infamous “delusional” in the Melissa Anelli/Emerson Spartz interview back when I guess Book 6 came out.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: So that was a big blow to Ron and… or Harry and Hermione…

Selina: Harry and Hermione. Yeah, that’s right.

Eric: … shippers everywhere. But this kind of reopened a lot of those same feelings and, I think, took it into a more mature realm.

Selina: Mhm.

Micah: So she retracted the “delusional” comment, because she can’t really…

Selina: She didn’t.

Micah: No, I know she didn’t. But she can’t really call those people delusional if, in her own mind, this was a possibility.

Eric: Right.

Selina: She is delusional

Micah: Yes. And now she’s never coming on the show.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: But shoddy journalism seems to be a running trend though, at least as it relates to the series…

Eric: That’s true.

Micah: … so many years later.

Selina: Yeah.

Micah: No matter what it is, whether it’s about Pottermore, which I know we’ll talk about very shortly here, or even with something along these lines. It’s great that even however many years we are after the fact – what, over seven years after Deathly Hallows was released – that the series is still relevant, the author is still relevant, the characters are still relevant enough that these news outlets – and I say that somewhat liberally, referring to them as news outlets…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: … because most them aren’t, even though… actually, I will say I saw quite a few run with the “Twelve New Stories by J.K. Rowling.”

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Everybody.

Micah: Just that they’re interested and that they’re willing to still write about it all these years later.

Andrew: Well… and I just can’t believe that people fall for this every time. I mean, this has happened so many times this year. If you want to summarize 2014 in the Harry Potter fandom, it was misleading headlines about things that J.K. Rowling is doing or saying and this Fantastic Beasts news. Plus… maybe part of the reason J.K. Rowling has been on Twitter more is so she can have a direct line of communication with the fans…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … instead of having the media reconstruct her words into things that just aren’t true or entirely accurate.

Eric: Or wait six or seven days to release them. [laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Right.

MuggleCast 275 Transcript (continued)


Recap: Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them Movie Series (Continued)


Andrew: So there was one other big story and that relates to Fantastic Beasts. Let’s do that first, since we’re talking about big stories. Warner Bros. announced in October – about a week after we had recorded our last episode, naturally – that David Yates is going to direct Fantastic Beasts. This is when we also found out that the series is going to be at least a trilogy. So this is the first time we’re talking about these two things here on MuggleCast. The “at least a trilogy” comments… we had known that David Yates was rumored to direct Fantastic Beasts. There was a report that had come out a month or two prior, and apparently that had been in the works for months. So now one question that still lingers is, will David Yates be returning for all three movies? And if you read the Warner Bros. statement, it doesn’t sound like it. However, if you went on J.K. Rowling’s page when she shared the announcement, the wording of it very strongly sounded like he is going to direct all three. And I actually tried to get some clarification from Warner Bros. about this, and they were not [laughs] willing to give me any information.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: Yeah. They left it open-ended, let’s say. But here’s what J.K. Rowling said on Facebook, and this statement is loosely like what was released in the press release but there is a key difference. I’m going to take one line from it.

“The studio…”

This is from J.K. Rowling.

“The studio has also confirmed that the films…”

[emphasises the word] Films.

“… set in the wizarding world but predating Harry Potter himself, will be directed by David Yates and will reunite the filmmaking team of David Heyman, J.K. Rowling, Steve Kloves and Lionel Wigram.”

Selina: Right.

Eric: There you go.

Andrew: So… but this is not what it says in the other release, so that’s why I think he is back for all three. Or he’s maybe not officially, but that’s the plan right now unless he’s like [laughs] sick of it.

Eric: “I hate this so much.”

Andrew: [laughs] Right.

Eric: “Get me out of here!” [laughs]

Selina: You know what I’m thinking about this is that… because we’ve all got our own opinions on David Yates and stuff, but [laughs] remember The Hobbit, like you haven’t just seen it.

Micah: Yeah.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I was going to say the same thing.

Selina: Yeah, that was meant to be directed by Guillermo del Toro, who incidentally was also meant to direct Harry Potter at one point or in rumors or something. And when that was first released, I remember lots of people were like, “No, no, get Peter Jackson back. Let’s get the original feel of the Lord of the Rings.” And then now we’ve seen the movies…

[Andrew laughs]

Selina: … and I’m thinking that a lot of people are probably wishing that del Toro would have stepped in and shaken up the universe a bit because treading water can only get you so far, and that’s what I’m worried about with this. It’s not that I don’t like David Yates’s directing style. It’s that I don’t… I mean, Fantastic Beasts is never going to be Harry Potter and trying to make it seem like the same I think you lose a lot of potential. I’m not… I mean, he might do a fantastic job…

[Everyone laughs]

Selina: No pun intended. But… wow, so many headlines. Anyway, I don’t know. I was hoping for someone different.

Andrew: I don’t… I get why he should return for the first movie because they want to carry that feel. David Yates is obviously very connected with the group already, with the producer David Heyman. Obviously, they all worked on Leavesden Studios where they’re going to be working again for Fantastic Beasts. But I don’t understand the reason to bring him back for all three.

Micah: Well…

Andrew: Why do you need that?

Micah: I actually… when Selina brought up The Hobbit, what I thought she was going to say is what happens if this is all shot at the same time?

Selina: [laughs] Oh.

Andrew: Hmm.

Micah: And so it… he really only has to be there for the filming of what would be one movie, even though they’re shooting it all at one time. But…

Andrew: I don’t think that’s going to happen for this.

Micah: Okay.

Andrew: Because it’s three…

Micah: Anyway…

Andrew: No…

Eric: These should be three separate stories set years apart?

Andrew: … I just mean the difference with The Hobbit was that it was originally two, and then when they announced a third they went back and filmed more.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Andrew: So, yeah.

Micah: Well, I think all the points you raised are valid and they’re reasons why they would bring David Yates back. The familiarity that he has with the series; even though it isn’t Potter, it’s still within that same world. He is familiar with J.K. Rowling, Steve Kloves, the list goes on.

Eric: Works well on the team.

Micah: Yeah. And at some point, I would assume… there are going to be brand new characters, but we would potentially see characters that we know, that could make these cameo appearances as we get later on into Newt’s story. But I kind of… I don’t know. It’s almost like, let’s see how he does with this first film.

Selina: Yeah.

Micah: And then make the judgment if it was right or wrong to bring him back.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah, for sure.

Micah: I think he’s worked, what, since Order of the Phoenix?

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: Yeah.

Micah: On the series. And I think it’s about that… and you don’t know. Maybe part of J.K. Rowling’s agreement in doing this was that certain people come back that she’s entrusted with her work, like Heyman and Kloves and now David Yates, because clearly she’s built these long-lasting relationships. She entrusted Heyman very early on with the series, and he’s been there the whole time, and so you never know kind of what goes on behind the scenes. She ultimately has to feel comfortable with the person responsible for directing this, and Yates has been there pretty much since…

Eric: Day one?

Micah: Yeah… minus four films, yes. But…

Eric: Yeah, they optioned the film really early on in the book process.

Micah: Well, when was Order of the Phoenix released? ’05?

Andrew: ’07.

Selina: Seven, yeah. Since the final book.

Andrew: Wait, the book or movie?

Micah: The movie. The movie, sorry.

Eric: 07/12/07?

Micah: So he’s been there seven… or he was there, what, four or five years? So I mean…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: … he’s got a good sense for what this is all about. So we’ll see.

Eric: Yeah, I still stand with… I agree with what Selina said, too. You kind of want it to be completely different.

Selina: Yeah. You want a change, I guess. But you’re absolutely right as well, Micah. I think that we can… I mean, this is a different story and he’s… David Yates, I’m sure, is capable of breathing new life into it. I think I’m just…

Eric: Well, I’m going to see his take on Tarzan first to kind of…

[Micah and Selina laugh]

Selina: Yeah, okay.

Eric: Well, that’s another story. It’s like, well, you want to see him do something different to prove that he can do something different.

Micah: I agree with Selina too, though. I like the point that she made, and I think that having somebody new would be great because one of the problems that a lot of people had with the Potter films was that there wasn’t that continuity, right?

Eric: What?

Micah: It broke so many times. Well, no. I mean yes, there were people who liked the fact that there were different directors along the way, but going through four different directors in an eight-film span, a lot of people didn’t like that because there wasn’t a level of consistency throughout all the films. Whereas here, why bring in somebody who has worked on those films? Why not give somebody else a chance? I think there is a lot of validity to that as well.

Andrew: And just from a visual sense, there could be a great opportunity here to really shake this series up in a visual way, and with David Yates, I don’t think that’s going to happen because I think a lot of what we found in the Harry Potter films will be carrying over, what we saw in the Harry Potter films. Who knows? Still excited for it, of course.

Eric: Yeah, definitely.

Selina: Of course.

Andrew: [in a sarcastic tone] I guess.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Micah: We’re going to see it no matter who directs it anyway, so…

Andrew: Oh, yeah. It doesn’t matter.

Micah: It’s just topic of conversation.

Andrew: But Micah will not follow David Yates on Twitter. I know that much.

[Selina laughs]

Micah: If David Yates was on Twitter, I’d follow him.

Andrew: Really?

Eric: Why?

Andrew: Yeah, I don’t get that.

Micah: Why not?

Eric: He gets a free pass, and J.K. Rowling doesn’t?

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Well, it depends if he actually used his Twitter account.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: But J.K. Rowling uses her Twitter account.

Micah: Yeah, after the fact.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: After you unfollowed her for not using her Twitter account?

Micah: Yup.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: Well, there’s… I think we’ll have Micah convinced in a little bit.


Recap: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince on Pottermore


Andrew: So let’s talk about Pottermore now. They released Half-Blood Prince. It’s out.

Eric: Yay.

Andrew: [laughs] Hooray.

Eric: All of it?

Andrew: So this… all of it. This was the twelve days thing. They released… really, over the twelve days they released the best of Half-Blood Prince, and then a couple of days ago, they released the remainder. And I looked through it; there wasn’t really anything else other than what we received during these twelve days things that was interesting. Not… there wasn’t any other additional tidbits penned by J.K. Rowling herself, but we learned a few things. These were actually pretty interesting, I thought. Snape… she addressed the whole “Is Snape a vampire?” thing. She said no, but…

Selina: What?

Andrew: … at one point in her very, very early notes, she had a vampire wizard named Trocar – T-R-O-C-A-R – who was going to be a professor at Hogwarts, but she doesn’t know how. It was just a very early draft.

Selina: Isn’t it amazing how drafts change?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Selina: It’s… wow. [laughs]

Eric: And it’s a perfect name. It’s right up there with Remus Lupin. She describes in the doc. She describes:

“A Trocar is [a] sharply pointed shaft inserted into arteries or cavities to extract bodily fluids.”

So it’s totally a perfect name for a vampire character.

Selina: Wow. Little on the nose.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We also found out why… J.K. Rowling explained why Snape was the Hogwarts Potions professor. Some people said this wasn’t new, but on Pottermore it was new writing from J.K. Rowling. She said:

“Chemistry was my least favorite subject at school, and I gave it up as soon as I could. Naturally, when I was trying to decide which subject Harry’s arch enemy, Severus Snape, should teach, it had to be the wizarding equivalent.”

So that wasn’t, I guess, big news, but I don’t know.

Eric: That’s funny. That made me laugh. I’m happy to know that.

Andrew: Yeah. I think the biggest thing is she revealed a ghost plot in Half-Blood Prince, meaning kind of…

Selina: Yes.

Andrew: … something she had planned and then changed her mind on. She said that Florean Fortescue – whose ice cream you can purchase in the Wizarding World Diagon Alley…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … was almost a major player.

Micah: Get the Butterbeer.

Andrew: Yeah, the Butterbeer ice cream. That’s a good one.

Eric: [in a high-pitched voice] Get the Butterbeer.

Andrew: He was almost a major player in Deathly Hallows and…

Selina: I knew it!

Andrew: Did you really?

Selina: When I read this…

Andrew: Really?

Selina: Yes! Because… well, I didn’t know that, but [laughs] it was one of those things that I remember people talking about after the seventh book came out. I’m like, “Ah, there were all these clues to Florean Fortescue and it never came to anything.”

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: So it was cool to hear that she thought about it.

Andrew: Oh, that’s interesting. Well… so yeah, she was going to have Florean present Harry some information about the Hallows in Deathly Hallows.

Selina: [laughs] Some Hallows.

Andrew: Yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: “Here they are!”

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Crime solved.

Eric: Ollivander is such an important role in that book, and then his next-door neighbor Florean would have also been this huge important guy.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: So I understand if that was any… had anything to do with why she didn’t do it because she’d already done it, or chosen to do it, with Ollivander.

Micah: Well…

Andrew: And so this Deathly Hallows information was why Harry met Florean in Prisoner of Azkaban, but then she changed her mind when… because “Phineas Black was a much more satisfactory means of conveying clues,” she said.

Eric: Right.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: Micah?

Eric: Well…

Selina: And there’s only so many people you can have walk in and give you information and then leave.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Right, right.

Eric: It’s like, “Oh, hey, you helped me with my homework in year three that week I spent in Diagon Alley. What can you bring to the table now?”

[Selina laughs]

Eric: He’s still going to be, though, this really nice guy who helped Harry with his homework. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: And gave him free ice cream. He’s probably still one of my favorite characters, even though he never played that big a role.

Selina: Wow. How much do you hate the other characters? [laughs]

Eric: Well, there is Eric, the security wizard. I also like him a lot.

Selina: That’s true.

Andrew: And the icing on the cake with this was that she said she feels guilty about killing him because she never used the knowledge she gave him to benefit Harry. So it was interesting what character does she feel guilty…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … or regrets… even that word is taboo now in the fandom.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Regrets killing. It seems like this is the one. The only one.

Micah: I think that… what did I tweet you a picture of? Snorlax? When…

Andrew: Oh, you thought this was boring?

Micah: No, I…

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: That’s what I read it as.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Well, I don’t think it’s all boring. I just… I don’t think that it blows you away.

Selina: No.

Micah: I don’t think that there’s any information that got released in these twelve days leading up to Christmas that was that shocking, and I understand…

Selina: Yeah, no one was gay or anything.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: They didn’t… I don’t know. There was a part that talked about cauldrons and their purpose. Really? Does anybody honestly want to read that?

Eric: I do.

Micah: Well, you do, of course.

Andrew: You know what that’s from…

Eric: What does that mean, of course? What does that mean?

Micah: It just means that you’d want to read it.

Andrew: You consume everything Harry Potter.

Micah: Yes, exactly.

Andrew: If…

Micah: Even though you don’t go to Pottermore.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Well, I did go to Pottermore, actually. I remembered my password, which had been kicking me out, and then I got in.

Micah: You could reset it, you know.

Andrew: Eric, would you read a section on the toilet paper that is used at Hogwarts?

Eric: Probably because any article that talks about toilet paper is going to talk about the bathroom problem of Harry Potter, which is that none of the characters go to the bathroom unless there’s an action scene in there.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: So yeah, I’m a little interested, honestly, in where the Hogwarts students do their business. But…

Andrew: “One of the most common complaints I received in the Harry Potter novels is that they don’t go to the bathroom too much.”

Eric: [laughs] It’s a standard in story writing.

Micah: You should tweet her, actually. I’m sure she would answer that question.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Nobody wants to read about the Hogwarts students going to the bathroom.

Micah: Eric, please, right now, tweet her. Do Hogwarts students use the bathroom?

Selina: Hermione did go to the bathroom at some point in one of the early novels. I distinctly remember…

Eric: No, she said it’s difficult to go to the bathroom. She said it’s difficult with Moaning Myrtle there in the bathroom.

Selina: Oh.

Micah: Eric, please tweet her that.

Andrew: So they only go to the bathroom…

Eric: I’m not going to tweet her that.

Andrew: You’re not going to tweet her that?

Micah: I think it would be a great question.

Eric: I won’t tweet her that for Micah’s enjoyment if he doesn’t follow her on Twitter.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Eric: I’m not going to do it. He won’t see her response unless I retweet it, and I’m not going to do that.

Micah: I’ll see it. I retweeted her, what, last week?

Eric: Yeah, the Anthony Goldstein tweet.

Selina: Wow. [laughs] She was so excited.

Eric: Somehow you still saw that even though you don’t follow her.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Somehow, some way. But one thing I did think was actually interesting was she talked about the Inferi as well. She gave a little bit of background on them in that chapter on Pottermore. But I don’t know, I think at this point I’m just over Pottermore. I think it’s a great resource for people who are still looking for information on the series, who want to go through it again, for people maybe who haven’t read it before, and this kind of provides them a companion. But these bits of information, they just… they don’t hit home. I think we’re looking for some really big news about characters or additional plot lines that just… they’re not there.

Eric: I disagree. I think that… I mean, clearly anything major enough made it into the books. But I’m interested in these ghost plots that are coming to light, and I’m interested in knowing that…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Specifically where that Railview inn was that they stayed in in the first book happened to be in Lily’s hometown. Lily and Petunia’s hometown of Cokeworth. Whatever, just random stuff. And as Deathly Hallows comes around, we’re going to find a lot of what I’m looking for, which is what could have been, or a lot of what didn’t make it, because I don’t even… I don’t love… it’s no secret. I don’t love the seventh Harry Potter book, so I really want to know… this is the opportune time to get any kind of what could have been, what should have been, what almost was type stuff into the mix. So I’m actually more excited for…

Micah: Well, it’s also the last chance, really, for that, right?

Eric: Yeah, for anything in general.

Micah: Because you’d think that she’s put the most important bits into the books that have already been released on Pottermore. At least you’d hope that that’s what she’s done, even though we know that she has a ton of information stored away in boxes and in her mind somewhere [that] she can release at any point. But…

Selina: [clears throat] Encyclopedia.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: Yeah, exactly. So…

Andrew: So…

Micah: Go ahead.

Selina: See, that’s what I want. I don’t want… oh, sorry. I don’t want Pottermore info. I want encyclopedia info! I’m like, “Urgh!”

Andrew: Okay, so Micah mentioned, why is there cauldron stuff? And this goes… kind of relates… I think that this is probably a sample from the encyclopedia. Here is my theory. Everybody listen because it’s now…

Eric: Andrew’s grand theory…

Selina: Okay.

Andrew: Grand theory…

Eric: … of the J.K. Rowling encyclopedia.

Andrew: This is now or never. This is it.

Selina: Okay.

Andrew: So Half-Blood Prince, just published here at the end of the year on Pottermore, okay? That leaves an entire year wide open for them to finish up Pottermore in 2015. They’re going to publish Deathly Hallows, obviously. Maybe they’ll, I don’t know, go back and release some other things J.K. Rowling promised at one point on Twitter a month ago, that there’s going to be a Patronus quiz. So stuff like that. Maybe they’re going to get that out of the way. And then, now that Pottermore has finished – I’ve been saying this for years – they’re going to open up… that is when we’re going to get the encyclopedia. Once Pottermore has finished releasing all seven Harry Potter books. Now, if they finish Pottermore in 2015, that means the encyclopedia can come out in 2016. What else is in 2016? First Fantastic Beasts movie. They release the encyclopedia around the summertime, summer 2016. All the Harry Potter fans lose themselves in excitement.

Eric: Lose all bowel control.

Andrew: Micah refollows J.K. Rowling on Twitter.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Eric gets to learn about Hogwarts toilet paper.

Eric: Yes.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: The fans are lining up at midnight again. And then everybody is reinvigorated, and they’re excited for Fantastic Beasts a couple of months later. So I think the encyclopedia is coming out in 2016; Pottermore will be finished. We remember, going back years ago, when J.K. Rowling said on her Q&A, Micah found, I think – I don’t know who found it – that little…

Micah: I think it was me.

Andrew: It was you. Micah is a sleuth!

Micah: I’ll take credit. [laughs]

Andrew: He may not follow her on Twitter, but he does go through her website.

Micah: Yeah, there was something on her website. Yeah.

Andrew: That said she is working on the encyclopedia, and then…

Selina: Right.

Andrew: … people noticed. And we started writing about it, and then that got deleted.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: And then that same area said, “I am…”

Eric: “Thrilled to be part of Pottermore.”

Andrew: Right. “I am thrilled to be part of Pottermore. I have no plans for the encyclopedia.” [laughs]

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Right after she said, “I am at work on this now.” I think Pottermore got pissed because…

Eric: It’s part of their…

Andrew: … they need the attention.

Selina: Yeah, who’s going to want to read that?

Andrew: Right.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So… right, and that’s the thing. Nobody is going to give two flying pieces of you know what about Pottermore once the encyclopedia is out.

Selina: No.

Andrew: No one is going to care.

Selina: Exactly.

Andrew: So I think 2016…

Eric: Well, they have an opportunity as a new… as new media, multimodal presentation that is Pottermore to give us…

Selina: Right.

Eric: … this information now over the next couple of years. I think you’re right, though, Andrew. I think the encyclopedia was just delayed. They ventured into this agreement so that they can present this information in this really cool, unique way, but…

Selina: Unless they’re just going to release Pottermore: The Book.

[Eric laughs]

Selina: In which case… [laughs]

Andrew: Right. Well, I’m working on Hypable, an article, “10 Headlines We’re Dreading Reading in 2015,”…

Selina: [laughs] Yeah.

Andrew: … and one of them is “J.K. Rowling announces Harry Potter, the Encyclopedia… but it’s only on Pottermore.”

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: That’s what I’m afraid of.

Selina: Yes.

Andrew: It’s going to be some digital only release. But I don’t think they actually will do that.

Selina: No.

Andrew: So there we go. That’s… we’ll talk more about 2015 in a moment, but finally… we’ve talked about J.K. Rowling on Twitter a lot today, so maybe we don’t want to get into this more, but she…

Micah: I actually found the quote… sorry, I was looking it up. But…

Andrew: Go ahead.

Micah: Let’s see here. It started off… well, somebody, I guess, asked her, “Will there ever be a printed encyclopedia?” And this is what she said in June of – hold on – I’m assuming it was last year, or it could have even been 2013.

Andrew: Was this on Twitter? What do you…

Eric: Last year was 2013.

Micah: That’s a good point.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Micah: Almost. Almost! [laughs]

“Will there ever be a book? I don’t know at the moment. The world has kind of outstripped me in the sense that back in 1998 I generated a lot more material than would ever be put in the books. It was simply ridiculous that anyone – to me at the time, I thought, ‘Who would ever want to know the significance of these types of wand woods?'”

“Will there ever be an encyclopedia?”

And she said:

“Possibly.”

And now we flash forward, and this was what I think was on her website when it relaunched:

“For a long time I have been promising an encyclopedia of Harry’s world, and I have started work on this – some of it forms the new content on Pottermore. It is likely to be a time-consuming job…”

Eric: See, there it is. That “some of this will become Pottermore,” meaning some of it won’t be.

Micah: [continues]

“… but when finished I shall donate all royalties to charity.”

So… and then, of course, that changed. So the difference… I’m just reading one of our transcripts. This was Episode 252. So the difference between June and this past week is that she went from “possibly there’s going to be an encyclopedia” to “I am working on this now,” and then, of course, as Andrew mentioned, that disappeared from the website. [laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Well… and that was back in 2012, I believe, that that happened, right?

Eric: Must have been.

Andrew: So she said it’s going to be a time-consuming project. If that were to come out in 2016, that’s four years.

Micah: It was April 23, 2012.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: That’s my birthday.

Andrew: I remember I was in Disney World and I pulled out my laptop. I was like, “Micah, how the heck?”

Micah: It was just… we found it and it was probably something that, as you said, Pottermore just didn’t want out there. J.K. Rowling felt comfortable enough to publish it on her site, and then I think because, in essence, it takes away from Pottermore.

Andrew: It absolutely does.

Micah: If you know… to your point, Andrew, let’s say we know Deathly Hallows will be released next year, and Pottermore will wrap up. We don’t know what purpose it’s going to serve beyond all the books being released.

Andrew: Right.

Micah: And so, if she has said publicly that she’s working on an encyclopedia in addition to Pottermore, and that some of the content that she’s working on does, in fact… part of the content is going into Pottermore, but she still has more that she’s using for this encyclopedia, then we should anticipate that one is actually going to be released at some point in the future.

MuggleCast 275 Transcript (continued)


Recap: J.K. Rowling on Twitter (Continued)


Andrew: Now, turning to J.K. Rowling on Twitter one more time today. We talk about it a lot, but that’s where all the excitement is with J.K. Rowling these days. It’s pretty cool. I teased earlier that there was a tweet that if this doesn’t make Micah refollow J.K. Rowling, I don’t know what will. So somebody tweeted her:

“My wife said there are no Jews at Hogwarts.”

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: [continues]

“I’m a Jew, so I assume she said it to be the only magical one in the family. Thoughts?”

She replied:

“Anthony Goldstein, Ravenclaw, Jewish wizard.”

That’s it. Now, this, it turns out, was one of the original forty Harry Potter characters that she came up with in Harry’s class. [laughs] Some people were like, “Oh, of course she picks Goldstein for the one Jewish person at Hogwarts.”

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: But remember, this was back in the ’90s when it wasn’t some huge thing. And she said that was… I think she said that was one of the names of her friends, right? When she was slamming somebody on Twitter?

Selina: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

[Micah laughs]

Selina: Yes. [laughs]

Micah: Jo slamming…

Selina: One of her slams.

Andrew: [laughs] And then she said:

“OK, let me clarify that!”

The next day because, of course, people were like, “Oh my God, there’s just one Jewish person?”

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: This must make her want to leave Twitter when she has to…

Selina: I know. People are so dumb.

Micah: One special Jewish boy that goes to Hogwarts.

Andrew: Yeah. She said:

“OK, let me clarify that! Anthony isn’t the first Jewish student, nor is he the only one. I just have reasons for knowing most about him!”

That’s because he was one of the originals.

Micah: That makes sense.

Selina: He was one of the OGs.

Andrew: So Micah, does this not make you want to refollow her?

Micah: I think she’s really been active. That’s clear over the last couple of months on Twitter, and I think that as she continues to be more active and do more things… I mentioned the anagram earlier, and certainly once I heard about that I went to check it out. But I think at some point, I’ll follow her again.

Andrew: Okay.

Selina: Oh.

Micah: I think it’s possible.

Andrew: I have another proposal.

Micah: 2015 is a new year.

Andrew: Okay. Yeah, I have another proposal we’ll get to with our big announcement.

Micah: Okay.

Andrew: [laughs] That’s our big announcement: Micah is following J.K. Rowling.

[Everyone laughs]

Selina: Yes.

Micah: Well, I’ve got to get her to reply. I think between the four of us here, we can come up with some questions that we can get her to reply to.

Andrew: Yeah, come to Brazil.

Eric: That’s it. You want special service. You want exactly for her to answer your question the way she’s answering all these other people’s questions like Ingrid Fonseca, who said:

“If you have a Horcrux, what [would it] be? #brazil.”

There’s Brazil again, by the way.

Andrew: [laughs] Right.

Micah: Brazil is its own trend, it seems like.

Eric: J.K. Rowling said:

“I would never have a Horcrux! They are evil objects created by murder!”

She’s answering fans’ questions, which…

Micah: That’s a cop out. Total cop out.

Eric: No, it’s not. It’s not. That’s why we never… she told us early on we’d never learn the process that was involved, because somebody is stupid enough in the world to go out and do it and be like, “Hey, I have a Horcrux now.”

Selina: “I killed this person. What now?”

Eric: Yeah, exactly. JKR…

Micah: Well, hold on a second. I don’t think they need to learn the process in order to, unfortunately, do something like that and claim an item they’re holding in their hand is a Horcrux. I think there are people out there that are stupid enough to do that anyway.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Unfortunately.

Eric: Yeah. But no, she was asked also… she’s just answering fan questions, which is beautiful.

Micah: I think it’s great. And look, when she first came on Twitter, it seemed as if it was done purely for publicity and to just be on Twitter.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Because everybody else was on Twitter. People were impersonating her, I’m sure.

Eric: Well, that’s what it is, yeah. She needed to create one just so that other people didn’t.

Micah: Well, I think it’s fair to say though that if you’re going to be on Twitter, you should embrace it; you should be active with it. That’s the whole point of it, and that’s why people follow you. They don’t follow you so your account sits idle for a couple of months, or you only tweet sparingly and you tweet the same thing over and over again.

Eric: So the entire foundation of why you left, why you stopped following her, is gone now.

Micah: It is…

Eric: Because she’s so active.

Micah: She finally listened to me.

[Micah and Selina laugh]

Micah: And she became more active.

Eric: So now you want to stretch it further. Until she answers one of your specific questions, you won’t follow her back?

Micah: Of course.

Andrew: I think Eric has grown like actually angry that Micah doesn’t follow her.

Selina: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, I find it to be pretty funny. She tweeted – this is eleven days ago:

“Seven minutes to midnight… time for bed.”

This is after this whole question and answer session. She [was] asked about what her favorite quote is and all this other stuff. She says:

“… time for bed. You people never run out of great questions. Sleep well/have a great day!”

And this is J.K. Rowling, the author of these books, who has got so many projects up in the air. She’s taken the time to answer these really cool questions for fans!

Andrew: Yeah. Well, you know what I think it is? I think at some point earlier this year, she realized how easy it is to use. It may not have been her at the very beginning. And then at some point, she downloaded the app on her phone…

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: … and then she can sit there… Eric just referenced that “time for bed” tweet.

Selina: She was playing Candy Crush and she was like, “What am I going to do?”

Andrew: Right, yeah. So she’s in bed, her luxurious California king bed, and she’s got a nice glass of wine next to her table, and she’s like, “Let me see what’s doing on Twitter.” And it’s just so easy, and obviously it’s a lot of fun for her as well to interact with the fans. Like Pottermore… Potter more should be embracing this and have a “Tweets by J.K. Rowling” section and…

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Anyway, so…

Micah: No, you’re right. I’m not disagreeing with you. I think it’s great. I think it’s awesome that she’s actively tweeting and she’s responding to fans. Clearly, people are interested still in all these different things, and the fact that she’s willing and able to reply is awesome.


Looking Ahead to 2015


Andrew: So let’s move on now to what 2015 has in store for Harry Potter fans. I just shared my encyclopedia theory.

Micah: J.K. Rowling on Snapchat.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: That’s the next thing.

Selina: Sending random Snaps to fans. [laughs]

Andrew: “Here’s the pen I’m using to write right now.”

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: I don’t think there’s any doubt, if there’s one thing we know… there’s two things… or maybe three. There’s three things we know for sure. Potter more is going to be completed in 2015 – certainly through Deathly Hallows; that’s definite. Fantastic Beasts casting news – they are going to start filming Fantastic Beasts in 2015, which is crazy to think that this is actually happening in 2015. That means we’re going to learn who’s playing Newt. And the more exciting part – in my opinion, I think – is we’re finally going to learn more about the story because we’re going to hear about these people getting cast and it’s going to be our introduction into Fantastic Beasts. We have no clue what other characters are appearing at this point, and a lot of them are probably going to be new – best friend of Newt, the bird that sits on his shoulder…

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: The little dragon that sits on his shoulder. We’re going to be learning a lot about Fantastic Beasts in 2015. And that’s cool, right?

Eric: Yeah.

Selina: It is. It really is.

Eric: That’s very cool.

Andrew: But who knows how much Warner Bros. is going to release. I mean, the casting stuff may be our best bet at learning more in 2015 because remember, it’s November 2016…

Selina: Yeah, character names and… it’s going to be like Star Wars.

Andrew: Right.

Selina: We’re going to learn character names and character costume designs and stuff.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And then will come the fan posters with using the actors’ likeness and stuff.

Andrew: Yes.

Selina: Yeah. And the teaser trailer with a Nimbus flying across the screen.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Selina: Newt in the desert. It’s going to be great.

Andrew: The teaser trailer should just be that riddle that J.K. Rowling posted on Twitter.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Just that line.

Eric: “Newt Scamander only meant to stay in New York for a couple of hours,” something like that?

Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: We will probably find out more about – well, this isn’t so certain – something about the Wizarding World theme parks. I mean, Japan opened this year.

Eric: Mhm.

Andrew: Hollywood is opening in 2016.

Eric: 2016, okay.

Selina: England, please?

Andrew: England…

Eric: [imitating Selina] England!

[Selina laughs]

Eric: You have the Studio Tour! Come on.

Selina: Oh yeah, and that’s just as good.

Eric: Is it not?

Andrew: I was thinking more we would find out something about a third expansion to the Wizarding World in Orlando because that one is obviously the bread and butter.

Selina: Oh, you have enough.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: What would be next though, if you’re talking expansion to the Wizarding World? I’m sure you’ve written an article on this, Andrew, but what would be next?

Selina: How about a bigger Hogwarts?

Eric: Yeah. One you can stay in.

Andrew: How about a Great Hall to eat in? Oh, I know. People want a Hogwarts hotel. Hotel Hogwarts.

Micah: [laughs] Somebody mentioned the Ministry, right?

Andrew: Oh yeah, that would be a big one.

Eric: Yeah, but I’d go for Hotel Hogwarts.

Selina: Yeah, Hogwarts for sure. Could you imagine?

Micah: Yeah.

Selina: And you could choose to… there would be wings for Hufflepuff and Gryffindor and stuff.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And different classes you could attend that you could sit in on.

Selina: Yeah.

Eric: I think that’s what we all wanted all along.

Selina: Yeah! It’s just one big Hogwarts where we can go…

Eric: Roller coasters are fine.

Micah: They should do it in England, though. Right, Selina?

Eric: Scotland.

Selina: For sure. Scotland, yeah. That would be okay.

Andrew: And each wing would be a different Hogwarts house.

Selina: Yeah.

Eric: And Dumbledore’s office would be the secret J.K. Rowling suite, like the penthouse. [laughs]

Selina: [laughs] Oh, yeah.

Eric: When JKR comes, she gets to stay in Dumbledore’s office.

Selina: And the Chamber of Secrets is like a giant swimming pool or something.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh, cool! Yeah, that’s cool.

Selina: We should design it.

Andrew: This isn’t strictly Harry Potter related, but it is J.K. Rowling related. The Casual Vacancy television series will be premiering on the BBC in early 2015.

Selina: Oh, yeah!

Andrew: And I’ll finally know what happens in that story now.

Eric: [laughs] Yeah, me too.

Andrew: It’s very exciting.

Selina: Not that exciting.

Eric: Presuming they don’t change the ending for TV.

Andrew: Right, right.

Micah: That was a tough book to get through.

Selina: Yeah, it was.

Andrew: Yeah, I didn’t finish.

Eric: Me neither.

Andrew: Eric and I did not finish. And we’ll also be hearing more about the Cormoran Strike television series; this is something we haven’t touched on yet. The BBC and J.K. Rowling announced that they are turning the Cormoran Strike novels – so that’s The Cuckoo’s Calling and The Silkworm – into a drama for BBC One, which I think is really cool. There were talks… there were rumors when The Cuckoo’s Calling first was unveiled as being J.K. Rowling’s that there were studios trying to get it – movie studios. But I think it’s better as a television series because now we know… J.K. Rowling said this year there’s going to be six or seven more of these Cormoran Strike books.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So this could be a long-running series on BBC One…

Micah: Wow.

Andrew: … and I’m really excited about that because I love these books.

Micah: Do we get that in the US?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: BBC One? No… well, we get BBC America.

Eric: Oh, right.

Andrew: The Casual Vacancy is going to be on HBO – we don’t know when, but it’s going to be – so hopefully Cormoran Strike is going to maybe be on HBO as well.

Micah: That would be cool.

Selina: Mhm.

Andrew: It’s the Internet. We’ll have ways of watching it.

[Micah and Selina laugh]

Micah: And then book-wise though, did she say she’s starting to write the fourth one? I thought I read that somewhere.

Andrew: Third.

Micah: I thought the third was already almost finished.

Andrew: Right. She said [that] she was halfway through writing the third one. But yeah, presumably she’ll be writing the fourth one in 2015, I guess. Yeah.

Micah: So we can expect probably a release for 2015 for the third book?

Andrew: Yeah, I’m hoping so.

Selina: Oh Jesus Christ, I’m only like three chapters into the first one.

Andrew: Get reading!

Selina: I know! There’s so much and she writes all this stuff and I’m having trouble just reading it. [sighs] I’m a bad fan.


Announcement: MuggleCast Returns to Monthly Episodes


Andrew: And this gets into our announcement for 2015. We’ve done a few episodes… of course, MuggleCast was always a weekly show when we started in 2005. And then after the final movie came out, we pulled it back to monthly. And then we stopped doing regular episodes because it was just time. There was no spinoff series. J.K. Rowling was barely on Twitter. Micah was barely on Twitter at that time.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: It was a different time.

Eric: That’s why we really ended it.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Because Micah had no interest in Twitter.

Micah: That’s right.

Andrew: And after doing it for so long, MuggleCast had run its course for what we… it served its purpose. And now that… [laughs] believe it or not, this was a factor, in my opinion. Now that J.K. Rowling is on Twitter more…

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: … now that Fantastic Beasts is under two years away, we have decided ≠ drumroll, please…

[Eric makes a drumroll sound]

Andrew: … that we are going to…

Selina: To end it.

Andrew: We are going to end it entirely. No.

[Andrew and Selina laugh]

Andrew: That we are going to do monthly episodes…

Eric: Bing!

Andrew: … beginning again in March.

Eric: Bang! Boom!

Andrew: Bing, bang!

Selina: Happy New Year!

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: Selina, I’m not even sure we told you this yet, did I? So surprise!

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: So Harry Potter is still beloved by everybody. Everybody still loves Harry Potter. Everybody I meet where I live now, Harry Potter comes up at some point. And I’m like, “Did you know MuggleNet?” And they always say yes. And everybody is still obsessed with what J.K. Rowling says on Twitter. These are normal people, not even the people who listen to MuggleCast, not even those crazies. Everybody is just so excited about Fantastic Beasts, about what J.K. Rowling is saying on Twitter, this new Pottermore stuff ≠ believe it or not, Micah…

Micah: What? Whoa, whoa, whoa.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: We just feel like it’s time. So beginning in March, we will resume monthly episodes. That’s a new episode of MuggleCast every month.

Eric: For a nominal fee.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: For $3.99 a month. No, it’s going to be free. And we’re all really excited, I think, to start it back up again.

Eric: Totally.

Micah: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I know we’ve been dropping clues… speaking of Twitter, we’ve dropped a few. I tried out my Photoshop skills [laughs] on the most recent one.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, they caused people to unfollow us on Twitter. They were that bad.

Micah: Oh, did it? Okay.

Andrew: Yeah.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I’m kidding.

Micah: You have, what, a ridiculous following on that account now, so a few here or there don’t hurt at the end.

Andrew: I’m just kidding, I’m just kidding. Yeah, I mean, it’s interesting actually. When we ended monthly episodes of MuggleCast, the Facebook page had 35,000 likes. Now we’re up to 77,000 likes, [laughs] which is just crazy.

Eric: We’ve upped our value [laughs] by doing less.

Micah: More than doubled it.

Andrew: Yeah, and part of the reason… well, a large part of the reason is that I post Harry Potter stories from Hypable on there. And I think people see this page and they’re like, “Oh wow, there’s still Harry Potter news. Cool, I’ll ‘like’ it.” So it’s grown that way. But it just also shows you that there’s still a demand for Harry Potter content.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: People are still as passionate as ever about it.

Selina: That’s so exciting.

Eric: And we would not have anyone else do a Harry Potter podcast. Why not just have it be us?

Andrew: Right, right. I hate to brag about this, but we were the first Harry Potter podcast, so…

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: We were!

Micah: We were. No, definitely we were.

Andrew: So it feels right that we’re going to…

Micah: Come back?

Andrew: … lead the charge on a resurgence here. Maybe in the fandom, we’ll see. We’re going to be all about it.

Micah: We get to celebrate ten years.

Eric: Next August.

Selina: Oh, you guys. That’s awesome.

Andrew: Yes. That’s appropriate. That’s very appropriate. Now, the reason we’re waiting until March is because Micah and I are actually going to be part of a new podcast. If you guys were into…

Micah: Yeah, Andrew, why don’t you tell them the name?

Andrew: Well, we don’t have a name yet. [laughs] But if you’re into Smart Mouths, you’re going to like this new podcast because that will be starting up in January, so… we’ll mention that on future episodes of MuggleCast here. But…

Selina: That’s so exciting!

Andrew: Yes.

Selina: It’s so great! And podcasts as well, they hit a bit of a lull after the initial sort of excitement, but I’m so glad you guys keep doing it and more new podcasts.

Andrew: Thank you, Selina.

Selina: Oh, I love it.

Andrew: Yeah. Well…

Selina: I’m super surprised because I had no idea. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, I’m so sorry I didn’t tell you. [laughs] It didn’t even dawn on me. Sorry about that.

[Selina laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, so… and we’ll have Selina coming on, I’m sure. And I think one of the goals will be to have a fourth… it’ll be Eric, Micah, and I, and then we’ll have a fourth person on at least every episode. I think that’s going to be a goal. We’ll try to freshen things up in ways like that.

Micah: Yeah. And I’m looking forward to continuing to talk about Pottermore and Twitter.

Selina: [laughs] Twitter.

Eric: All of the things you…

Selina: All of the Harry Potter stuff. [laughs]

Micah: No, look, I think it’s always good to play devil’s advocate because there are people out there, I’m sure, who feel similarly about Pottermore – maybe not as much about Twitter at least now, but Pottermore in particular, I think, just… it is what it is. We’ve discussed this so many times on this show, and I think for different people it serves different purposes. But the fact that we just have it is a great thing because it provides us new information and it will continue to into the new year.

Andrew: Well… and the reason that we want to start up monthly episodes again is that Fantastic Beasts, like we mentioned, is going to really get rocking and rolling this year.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And there’s going to be a lot to talk about with that, and there’s going to be other stuff in the Harry Potter fandom to talk about as well.

Micah: So if you had to take a guess now… looking ahead into 2015, we’ll get a lot of casting news – you mentioned that – who is going to play the role of Newt Scamander, if you had to put it on paper right now?

Andrew: Benedict Cumberbatch, obviously.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: Smaug?

Selina: Yeah, Smaug.

Andrew: No, I don’t think it’s going to be a big person. The safe predictions are Matt Smith…

Selina: We don’t even know how old he is, though. It could be literally anyone.

Andrew: Yeah.

Selina: It could be a woman. [laughs]

Andrew: I think he’s in his twenties. Don’t we know that?

Selina: Do we?

Eric: Early twenties, based on when he left… based on the old biography, which could be changed a little bit.

Andrew: Right. There’s going to inevitably be some adjustments. But we know the story is set in the 1920s…

Eric: Yes.

Andrew: … and according to the Harry Potter Wiki he was born in 1897, so that would put him around his twenties. So…

Eric: Yeah, he basically… he leaves Hogwarts and becomes… he trains with the Ministry for a couple of years, I think, and then leaves on a big safari or quest or whatever, based on the older information.

Micah: So mid to late twenties.

Eric: Yeah, mid-twenties. Kind of our age, which is really cool because Harry Potter was our age, growing up.

Selina: And we know that it’s the beginning of his career?

Andrew: We don’t really know that either.

Eric: Not specifically. Yeah, no, not specifically.

Selina: Okay.

Eric: I mean, I think… he’ll probably be pretty esteemed… this is what I’m gathering from the plot so far, is people will know him and he’s going to New York, but then this huge crisis happens, which we do know, and then he’ll be called upon to fix it. So there will be… I think he’ll have a little degree of fame, kind of like an Indiana Jones kind of guy.

Selina: Right, right, right.

Andrew: And I want to touch on something that Selina mentioned. There really is a resurgence with podcasts happening right now.

Eric: Yeah.

Selina: Yeah.

Andrew: Led largely by Serial.

Eric: Serial.

Andrew: That mystery podcast. I still haven’t listened to it, but I want to; everybody is obsessed with it. But I think people are starting to… that helped people realize how convenient podcasts are. Apple now puts the Podcasts app on your phone; I think that’s very helpful to podcasters. So yeah, I just think that there really is a resurgence happening and…

Eric: Also, Welcome to Night Vale is also…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … a really cool, just really well done concept show.

Andrew: Yeah, and everybody has got their phones… one of the reasons I’ve never really believed in YouTube is because it’s not as portable as something like podcasts are. You can really take a podcast anywhere with you. No matter where you are, you can easily listen to it. Whereas YouTube, you can’t watch it anywhere… or everywhere.

Selina: Mhm.

Andrew: I mean, obviously YouTube is very, very, very popular, but we’re podcasters here.

[Eric and Selina laugh]

Andrew: So yeah, that’s our big announcement. Again, it’ll start up again in March.

Selina: Yay!

Andrew: And hopefully the casting announcements will start after that.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: But who knows?


Micah Refollows J.K. Rowling on Twitter


Andrew: And yeah, that’s all we’ve got for today’s episode of MuggleCast. By the way… so Micah, I know… we keep bringing this up, but to kick off our resurgence, I believe in March you should refollow J.K. Rowling.

Micah: I don’t know.

[Eric laughs]

Micah: You know what? Okay, look…

Selina: Hey, at this point, it’s going to have to take something really big. [laughs]

Micah: Hold on. You know what? It’s the end of the year, right? We’re heading into a brand new year. You make resolutions, right?

Eric: Okay. Where are you going with this?

Micah: Well, I’m shifting away from my microphone here for a second so that I can type on the keyboard.

Andrew: Oh my God, I’m so excited.

Selina: Uh-oh.

Andrew: I need to get into the MuggleCast Twitter right now to report the breaking news after it’s done.

Micah: All right, so I’m just making sure. This is her handle, right? @jk_rowling.

Andrew: Right. That’s right. Do it, do it.

Micah: I want to know what follower I’m going to become. She’s got 3,965,281, so I’ll become the 3,965,282nd follower.

Selina: Oh, this is so exciting. You’re so special.

Eric: Don’t pull our leg here. You’re going to do this.

Micah: It’s done! It’s done!

Eric: It’s done!

Andrew: Wow!

Eric: Yay!

Andrew: All that. I can’t believe it. Well, this has truly been a…

Micah: She followed back!

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: She’s been waiting for that, Micah.

Selina: Yeah. [laughs] I was thinking poised.

Micah: She was. I knew it.

Andrew: This has truly been a remarkable landmark episode of MuggleCast. I’m glad you didn’t wait until March, Micah.

Eric: This is going up on the Hall of Fame on the MuggleCast site [laughs] just because Micah followed her.

Andrew: [laughs] Well, what a way to cap off the year.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: I’m adding that to our year in review.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: The biggest Potter stories of the year: Micah follows J.K. Rowling again.

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: I don’t think you’ll regret that decision, Micah.

Eric: No. Take a screenshot.

Micah: It’s not like I don’t take a look at her feed…

Andrew: Right. Well, now you’ll be forced to.

Micah: … of what’s going on. I will, yeah. I have no choice unless I hit “Unfollow” again for some reason.

Andrew: You better not!

Eric: Is that a threat?

Selina: Watch yourself, Jo.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: No.


Show Close


Andrew: Thank you, everybody, for listening. As always, you can visit the MuggleCast website to download all the episodes. Maybe you want to relisten to a few in preparation for the new era. We’ve got every single episode of MuggleCast right there on the website.

Eric: Yup.

Andrew: You can also follow us on social media. If you don’t, now is definitely the time to do it: Twitter.com/MuggleCast, Facebook.com/MuggleCast. We’ve also got the MuggleCast Tumblr: MuggleCast.Tumblr.com.

Micah: Is Kevin making sure we’re getting all our traffic there?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Yes, Kevin Steck, a Tumblr employee. Still looks like… well, it looks like the Tumblr needs some… needs to be updated. I don’t think it’s being maintained anymore.

Eric: We have to wake up those girls.

Andrew: Yeah, yeah. We’ll reach out to them.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: They can… yeah. All right. And I think that’s it. I’m Andrew Sims.

Micah: That’s it.

Eric: I’m Eric Scull.

Micah: I’m Micah Tannenbaum.

Selina: And I’m Selina Wilken.

Andrew: Selina, thank you for joining us.

Micah: Yeah.

Selina: Thank you for having me.

Andrew: No problem. And we’ll see everybody next time for Episode 276. Goodbye!

Eric: Goodbye, 2014!

Selina: Goodbye!

Micah: Bye! See you in ’15!

Selina: Happy New Year!

Transcript #274

MuggleCast 274 Transcript


Show Intro


[Show music begins]

Andrew: Because we always return for the big news, this is MuggleCast Episode [274] for [October 8], 2014.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: This week’s episode of MuggleCast is brought to you by Audible.com. Audible is the leading provider of audiobooks with more than 150,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including fiction, non-fiction, and periodicals. For a free audiobook of your choice, go to AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.

[Show music continues]

Andrew: Welcome to MuggleCast Episode 274. Eric, Micah, and I are all here. Welcome back, guys.

Micah: Hey.

Eric: It’s great to be back.

Andrew: Well, as…

Eric: Or shall I say it’s fantastic to be back.

Andrew: Ah, ah.

Micah: Well, actually, Andrew…

Andrew: [laughs] Yes?

Micah: It is great to be here with both you and Eric, and actually I wanted to apologize because I know we were supposed to be doing this earlier this evening, but I only… you know I work in New York City and I only had planned on spending a few hours there.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: But…

Andrew: I get it!

Eric: Oh!

Andrew: I get it!

Eric: That was smooth-ish.

Andrew: That was smooth.

Eric: Ish. Judges?

Andrew: Bit long of a setup, but I got it.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: So…

Eric: You only meant to be there, at work…

Micah: Yes, I was only meant to be there for a few hours.

Eric: … for a few hours?

Micah: But…

Eric: Like nine to five, specifically?

Micah: Mhm. Something like that.


News: J.K. Rowling Tweets Anagram


Andrew: So, that’s one reason that we are here today. The past couple of days have been a whirlwind for Harry Potter fans because J.K. Rowling decided a couple of days ago, “Well, I’ll throw a little riddle out there about Fantastic Beasts and see if the fans can figure it out.” It all kind of started when J.K. Rowling tweeted a little update saying that… no, not that “pen and paper are her priority,” though they were.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: That she’s tweaking a screenplay which kind of suggested, by the way, that, to me, it read like she’s finishing it up…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … if she’s just “tweaking it.”

Eric: I would agree with that.

Andrew: And she also said she’s finishing up a novel. Now, that could be a whole other discussion.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: But…

Eric: That’s true. Working on a novel.

Andrew: … for now we’ll put that aside. And so then one of her followers said, “Oh, you should tweet a little…” or no, she… the follower said, “Whenever J.K. Rowling tweets, I need to take some time out of my day to dissect it and try to figure out if there’s any hidden clues in it.” [laughs]

Eric: Yeah. Yeah, it was… actually, I have it right here. It was Regan, @peruseproject on Twitter, said:

“Every time J.K. Rowling tweets I stop whatever I’m doing and analyze it for an hour.”

Andrew: And then that triggered J.K. Rowling to say what?

Eric: “See, now I’m tempted to…” so she @ replied her, but she put a period. Look at how tech savvy J.K. Rowling has gotten now, by the way.

Andrew: She’s getting with it, but she still doesn’t know emojis, so…

Eric: Oh, yeah. Well, emojis are another beast all together and not as fantastic. But J.K. Rowling said… okay, so:

“.@peruseproject See, now I’m tempted to post a riddle or an anagram. Must resist temptation… must work…”

Andrew: And then the next morning she released it. [laughs] Do you have it right there with you?

Eric: I do. Okay, here we go. And I’m not paraphrasing. This is word for word. Okay, J.K. Rowling’s tweet:

“Cry, foe! Run amok! Fa awry! My wand won’t tolerate this nonsense.”

Andrew: [laughs] So, at first she didn’t say that it was an anagram.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: There was a debate over whether or not this was some sort of quote from the movie or what, but we assumed that it could be an anagram because she… because of that person who tweeted at her the night before. Now, I don’t know if I had some sort of… I’m sort of connected on a deep level with J.K. Rowling because that night I had happened to wake up at seriously 3:30 a.m. It was really weird for me.

Eric: Whoa.

Andrew: Yeah, and I see this tweet because I checked my phone real quick to make sure nobody has died or anything, and I see this text. So, I…

Eric: Do you often just wake up at odd hours of the night and be like…

Andrew: Well, it doesn’t happen…

Eric: … “Has anybody died?”

Andrew: Well, I figure, “Oh, phone is right there. I may as well check.” [laughs]

Eric: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, that’s true.

Andrew: So, I have text notifications on. I can always see when J.K. Rowling sends a tweet. So, I see this…

Eric: It’s a useful feature, Micah.

Andrew: Yeah, Micah, you could use this. And then… so then…

Micah: Well, I think his point is I don’t follow her.

Eric: You should.

Andrew: But then I’m laying in bed for the next 45 minutes trying to figure out what this means, and I seriously… I lost like an hour of sleep that night because not only did I wake up randomly… anyway, this is besides the point.

Eric: Yeah, yeah.

Andrew: So, J.K. Rowling starts dropping these clues and whatnot, and before you know it, we finally get to the answer. This ended up being a whole big thing. J.K. Rowling, in… according to her, only intended this to hold fans over while she was finishing her screenplay and finishing this book. But then, I guess it… you know, it started making headlines all around the Internet, and I guess she maybe just got wrapped up in the excitement too because… especially today, Tuesday, she was tweeting non-stop.

Eric: Oh, yeah. She was tweeting… she went so far as to tweet fans’ wrong answers and even make fun of really clever, really hilariously some of the responses that people were guessing to her.

Andrew: Mhm. It was pretty entertaining.

Eric: It was extremely entertaining. You were right to call it a whirlwind. It really was a whirlwind that, as you said, even she got caught up in it. It was… it’s just… it was a fun… today especially, the day that we’re recording this, Tuesday the 7th, was just a fun, really, really, really, really fun day to be on Twitter, to be alive…

Andrew: [laughs] To be alive.

Micah: All right.

Eric: … to be following J.K. Rowling.

Micah: Well…

Andrew: So, the answer ended up being:

“Newt Scamander only meant to stay in New York for a few hours.”

Period. That’s it. Now, in another tweet, J.K. Rowling said that this was the first line of a synopsis. Not the script, just a general overview of the story.

Eric: Not the script, it’s a synopsis, so…

Micah: It’s a great… it’s very much in the style of J.K. Rowling. Just, “He only meant to spend…”

Andrew: Right.

Micah: “… but a few hours there.”

Eric: And then this happened.

Micah: And then… right, exactly. So, we know it’s going to lead into a very interesting story for Newt Scamander, and it’s clear that he’s going to be in New York well past when he intended to and it’ll be interesting to see, is that going to be the entire first movie? Will he be only here in the States and in New York, or will he go elsewhere? But I do agree with… and I know I mocked you a little bit, Eric, but it’s always interesting to me how she can really just captivate. Not just the fan community, but so many different people. How they just lock in…

Eric: Mhm.

Micah: … whenever she says anything.

Eric: It’s like a switch.

Micah: It doesn’t matter what she does.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: She tweets, she puts something out there in the public, and people just immediately latch onto it and…

Eric: Having read…

Micah: A whole discussion.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: It was like having her website back from years ago…

Eric: Yeah, that’s true.

Micah: … when she would release clues…

Eric: I did want to say…

Micah: … about book titles and release dates.

Eric: Yeah, I did want to say that this felt a lot like those old days…

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: … with the door, which is why I was like… I was actually really hesitant to try and solve the anagram. In fact, I didn’t. I just enjoyed reading the wrong answers and then…

Andrew: [laughs] Right.

Eric: Because I would always be…

Micah: I tried.

Eric: I was always the last person in through the door when the “Do Not Disturb” sign was down. I could never figure out what to do. I always waited for the self-help guide.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah.

Eric: I just couldn’t do it, so… but still, I was still excited that it was there. And Twitter is the new old J.K. Rowling’s website, by the way, because that thing…

Andrew: Well, because she made it that way today.

Eric: Have you guys tried doing web… what’s the old site? Wayback Machine or something?

Andrew: Yeah. I don’t think it will work because…

Eric: Have you tried going on JKR’s old website through there?

Andrew: I don’t think it would work because it’s Flash, I assume.

Eric: No? Am I the only one who – well, anyway – thought of it?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: But anyway, the old website where she used to have all these really awesome clues and games and fun with the fans… it was a long time coming until today when it just feels like for the first time she really, really just had a blast on social media.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: And you hope it was her and not her assistant, but I think it was genuinely her.

Andrew: I think it was genuinely her, too.

Micah: I will say this though, I look forward to her doing those types of things in the future. I think she’s sort of realized the ability that she has to connect directly with fans where it’s not so intense. It’s really easy. She can pick and choose when she wants to respond. She can do things like this and just completely… Newt Scamander was trending…

Eric: Oh, man.

Micah: … in the United States. Probably internationally. At least I saw that at one point. Yeah, I was at work today and I was trying to solve this damned thing. And she kept giving more clues, and then you knew the more she gave away of it, eventually somebody was going to solve it.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: But I think everybody was pretty much set on the fact that Newt Scamander was part of it and then New York was part of it. What you did with the rest of the letters was pretty much up to you. But I give all the credit in the world to that girl who solved it, and I’m glad that people finally started retweeting her and favoriting her instead of just J.K. Rowling’s response to her because I think that she deserves the notoriety for it.

Andrew: Yeah. With that said, I think a bunch of people figured it out at the same time, but it doesn’t really matter. Because I know MuggleNet tweeted it about the same time as did somebody following me, and then I did a search on Twitter for the exact phrase and they all sort of showed up at 1:47, so… whatever.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: But going back to the point about…

Micah: Then forget everything I just said.

Andrew: No, no, it’s still a good point.

Eric: Yeah, MuggleCast tweeted… from MuggleCast, that Georgia…

Andrew: Yeah, that was me.

Eric: Georgina Eleanor.

Andrew: I looked up who showed up first in the list, but who cares. It doesn’t matter. What…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: Well, actually what’s interesting – I’ll just say this really quickly – is that… sort of the benefit of that is that J.K. Rowling is now following that person.

Andrew: Is she?

Micah: I think so.

Andrew: Oh yeah, I do see that. See… well, okay, I’m happy for that girl, Emily, but…

Micah: [laughs] Now you’re pissed.

Andrew: No, I’m not pissed.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I think that’s fine. Good for her.

Micah: You’re going to curse her out when we’re done with the show.

Andrew: [laughs] No.

Eric: How many people did J.K… I’m going to look this up. How many people does she follow?

Andrew: She follows 49 people.

Eric: Oh my God, that would be awesome! I would be all over her feed all the time.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: That would be awesome.

Andrew: So, I think that this did teach J.K. Rowling something, that it is very easy to get fans excited through Twitter. But it’s also a blessing and a curse. I mean, some media outlets were way off their rockers today calling it, “Oh, it’s going to be a new Harry Potter book that she’s announcing,” because you could sculpt the anagram and get, “New Harry coming,” or something. I can’t remember what it was, but it was embarrassing. Entertainment Weekly and a couple of other sites really screwed that up, I thought.

Eric: Well…

Andrew: But this was… I have to say, I know we like to hate on Pottermore a little bit, but I seriously feel like in the three years that Pottermore has been around, there has never been this level of excitement on that site. What J.K. Rowling did in two days on Twitter…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … Potter more has not been able to accomplish in three years, and I think there is this disconnect between what J.K. Rowling… what people love about J.K. Rowling – the mystery, the excitement, and her former website – and Pottermore, it’s just the excitement is not there on Pottermore. And she could have released this through Pottermore, but I think she loves Twitter now. She gets it. She sits there in her rocking chair on her balcony…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: … sipping some tea, petting the dog, and she just loads up her phone and starts playing with the fans, and it’s fun because you can actually comment on Twitter and you can see real names.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: With Pottermore, it’s just… the community is not there.

Eric: Well, I did want to say she is a… I knew we all knew this, but she’s a master of the 140 characters. Each one of these tweets, it feels like she’s not even trying or has to worry about what she says. Every one of these tweets is perfect.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And it fits in the given space.

Micah: Well, I think…

Eric: She manages to have such a… what I want to say is she manages to have such an overt hilarious great sense of humor even though Twitter is limiting.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: I’m betting the person who taught her Twitter told her that she has to put in 140 characters in order for the tweet to actually go through.

Andrew: That would be mean. That sounds like something you would tell her.

[Everyone laughs]

Andrew: We’re going to continue talking about J.K. Rowling’s anagram in just a moment, but first it’s time to remind you that today’s episode is brought to you by Audible.com, the Internet’s leading provider of audiobooks with more than 150,000 downloadable titles across all types of literature, including audio versions of many New York Times Bestsellers. Now for listeners of MuggleCast, Audible is offering you a free audiobook to try out their great service just in time for fall when instead of holding a book you’re going to want to keep your hands inside your pockets to stay warm. It’s cold everywhere, and I have three awesome recommendations for everybody this week. This is the benefit of doing a podcast every couple of months because all these great books come out while we’re away. First of all, Gone Girl, now in theaters starring Ben Affleck. This is the number one bestseller on Audible.com. A fantastic movie. Whether or not you’re seeing the movie, you should definitely read the book. That is what I hear from everybody. Second, a book that was just published. This is going to be huge with our audience, I think. The Blood of Olympus: The Heroes of Olympus, Book 5. It’s the fifth and final book by Rick Riordan in the Percy Jackson series. You definitely want to check this one out. I know a lot of readers on Hypable were very sad earlier this week because it’s the last one of the series. And finally, another recommendation: The Maze Runner. Of course, this was just in theaters recently. It still is in theaters. Getting great reviews. Readers of the book are very happy with it, actually. There were some changes, but everybody was generally very happy with it. So, those three recommendations. There’s three excellent choices right there for you. You can get any one of these for free by signing up at AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast. Again, Gone Girl, The Heroes of Olympus, Book 5, and The Maze Runner. Get any one of them for free. AudiblePodcast.com/MuggleCast.


Breaking Down the Anagram


Andrew: As for this anagram…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … what… any ideas? The problem is we don’t know much about Newt, but this is certainly an interesting question. Why did he come to New York? So, he was only planning to visit for a few hours, but why did he… J.K. Rowling says:

“Circumstances ensured that he remained… for the length of a movie, anyway.”

Micah: So, he will be here…

Eric: I had a guess…

Micah: … for the whole first movie.

Eric: I kind of had an idea, but then it kind of got foiled, is I was thinking, “Oh, so if he only meant to be in New York for a couple of hours…” I’m thinking very Muggle minded like, “Oh, it’s a layover.” Right?

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: He must be heading to LA or something because he is coming from London. But then that was actually destroyed by the fact that it’s the wizarding world, right? You can probably just take… I mean, I assume an extended Floo Network would take you anywhere in the world. So New York wouldn’t necessarily be a layover [laughs] kind of place. In the same distance or the same amount of time, you could get to New York. You could also get to Georgia and Los Angeles and anywhere else you want to be, I assume. So maybe not that, but maybe…

Andrew: I think it’s more on the path of he went… my gut theory is he went there…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … to go research some beasts, so when the movie opens up we’re going to see him arriving in town, and he’s there to investigate some beasts – who knows which they are ñ and then, obviously, that’s where it starts getting more foggy. So, what are the circumstances? Did he start to realize that a bunch of beasts were there? Did he meet a new character? I don’t think it could be a love interest, even though I wrote that in my Hypable article.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: I mean…

Eric: What’s that? You made something up for the Hypable article?

Andrew: It just seems a little too predictable for J.K. Rowling. [laughs]

Eric: Yeah. No, I agree.

Micah: Yeah, I think you’re going to have some sort of fantastic beast incident…

Eric: Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

Micah: … in New York City that’s going to require his attention. It’s…

Andrew: Mmm.

Eric: Like King Kong level.

Andrew: So… oh.

Micah: Yeah, like King Kong or Godzilla. We’re being a little bit…

Eric: [laughs] Comical.

Micah: … out there.

Andrew: So it’s going to be some sort of incident toward the beginning of the movie to start things off with a bang, and it requires him to hang around longer because he maybe has to get a hold on this beast.

Micah: Yeah, he’s knowledgeable, clearly, about…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: … many of these beasts, and I think that maybe he’s Ace Ventura. [laughs]

Eric: Now that you… wow, wow. But now that you say Godzilla, I’m just thinking that this unknown magical creature just is found lurking in the sewers of New York and begins to threaten the whole city. [laughs] I’m just thinking along those lines.

Andrew: It’s going to be interesting to see the balance between the magical world of New York… we still don’t really know if it’s New York City, but presumably it is.

Micah: I would think.

Andrew: So, the balance of the magical world in New York and then the Muggle world. How often are we going to see the magic around New York?

Eric: Versus him in a hidden… yeah.

Andrew: Right. Like in a Ministry of Magic type place.

Eric: Versus a public place that we would recognize.

Andrew: Right. Right.

Eric: I imagine… if they don’t have… I’m going to put this out here; I’m going to put the cards on the table. If they don’t have a monster ravaging through Times Square scene, I’m going to boycott the movie.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: Well, remember Times Square was not the same back then as it is today.

Eric: Well, that’s… the twenties, thirties… yeah, okay, I get it. But I do want to say that New York works on many levels because New York is a cultural hub. Even back then New York was a huge cultural hub and it’s where everybody landed who immigrated from anywhere across the Atlantic as well, and so it makes sense that there would be a wizarding presence there, no matter what. That’s why it works. That’s why also, I assume, it’s the city that she’s talking about.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: The other thing that kind of came to mind from a historical standpoint. You obviously have… we know that it takes place in the 1920s. Is that what we’re…

Andrew: Yup. Yup.

Micah: … told? And the first World War comes to an end not too long before that, so… I think around 1918. And then toward the end of the ’20s, of course, you have the Great Depression, so I wonder does that at all play into why he has to stay in New York. Does something happen that’s tied…

Eric: Like the stock market crash is really just a giant dinosaur-like creature crashing into the Wall Street building?

Micah: [laughs] Yeah, a giant dragon just…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: It’s Gringotts however many years earlier.

Eric: It’s fun. It’s fun to speculate.

Micah: But I think you could have the tie-in of real life events that are going on, because certainly there were parallels that we drew with Voldemort and his rise to power.

Eric: Well, J.K. Rowling likes to do that. She likes to have this hidden magical world and then show how, when things get out of hand, it manifests itself… it shows up… even Muggles who don’t usually notice nothing, do they, are seeing this stuff happening. So I think there will definitely be, I want to say, a profound stock market crashing type reaction that was secretly caused by magical means that we’re going to learn. Because that’s just J.K. Rowling. That’s what she does, I like to think.

Andrew: So then, I mean, this other tweet that I read, “Circumstances ensured that he remained… for the length of a movie, anyway,” the reason I want to bring that up is because J.K. Rowling, of course, is… well, Warner Bros. is hoping to make a trilogy out of this. So for the length of a movie, she says, does that mean he’s going to be going elsewhere by the end of the movie? Is he going to be heading out of New York? And then I started thinking, well, could he be in a different area with all three films? So this one is in New York, one of them is in England, and then a third one somewhere else. Because didn’t we know about Newt that he travels the world to learn about creatures?

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So…

Eric: Yeah. I mean the new bio is still, like anything she writes in the film… I feel like she doesn’t have a lot that she needs to worry about conflicting because there isn’t all that much about Newt. Well, what there is about Newt we did already read on a former MuggleCast.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But I think that whatever… I mean, it really works out because wherever he was headed at the beginning of the film, where he got delayed, he can just head there – wherever that is – at the end of the film.

Andrew: Right. So I’m looking at the Harry Potter wikia again and it says… so he got the opportunity to write this book, “he jumped at the chance for extra money and the opportunity to spend his summers travelling the world.” So he apparently was doing this every summer, going travelling the world. So maybe that will work in somehow.

Eric: Oh, yeah. And I think it’s likely that the two following films will be set… they’re obviously… I think they’ll center around him, I think that’s safe to say.

Andrew: Oh, yeah.

Eric: And they may be in a different time; they may be five or ten years later maybe. But at that point.. because she just gets to explore; because it has to be during his lifespan, during his ordinary lifespan. But she could do the ’60s in Britain – which is very like Austin Powers-y kind of thing – later.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: At some point, if she wanted to, with a future film.

Micah: Right. At which point you could start pulling in characters that we know.

Eric: Right.

Micah: And have got to know in the Potter series. At least the older ones.

Eric: For how unfamiliar with the character we are, of Newt, and the characters that will obviously be supporting Newt on his journey, I’m just so excited by this premise, right? Wizard in 1920s New York. Wizard beast hunter…

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: … in New York, in the ’20s. It just sounds ridiculously awesome. And now, Andrew, one of the notes that you had here was that it’s been… has it been a year since we found out about Fantastic Beasts?

Andrew: Yes, it’s been a year. September 2013 is when we first found out about this news.

Eric: So, it’s kind of like… I feel like we still don’t know a whole lot about it. I feel like this is the biggest thing that we’ve had since the initial announcement.

Andrew: Well, yeah, I guess official information. Yeah.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: Because, I mean, we’re going to get to the David Yates story in a moment.

Eric: Oh, right!

Andrew: And the release date. But yeah, this is certainly… I was kind of hoping that once people solved this riddle then Warner Bros. or J.K. Rowling would have published the entire synopsis that she’s referring to. That would have been cool. Maybe they’ll do that once they confirm David Yates or something like that.

Eric: And especially if she’s tweaking the script. It’s in pretty good standing.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’s in a pretty good place.

Andrew: Yeah. So hopefully within the next month or two… see, all these tweets were also funny to me because it’s like she did this to tide fans over while she was finishing the script.

Eric: But then immediately got to talking… [laughs]

Andrew: Right. But now she got tied up with this riddle. [laughs] I mean, again, Twitter doesn’t take too much time and hopefully she spent a lot of the day working on it anyway. But it was just pretty funny to me that [laughs] I think the plan was for her to be away for a while.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: And then it blew up the Internet.

Eric: Well, she calls anagrams her spiritual home. She hash tagged.

“Thank you, thank you, for being the kind of people who get excited about an anagram #myspiritualhome”

So, I think she left that conversation in very high spirits regarding Twitter and the people that she interacted with during this whole thing. So yeah, she just kind of had this moment where she was overcome with her old self.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Like her old toy with the fans, see what kind of a rise she could get. I’m sure she isn’t even… I don’t want to say I’m sure, but I figure she wouldn’t even need to read the E! Online magazine recap on what happened. But I think that she enjoys interacting with fans.

Micah: I’m glad you brought that up though, for a second. And I know Andrew talked about it a little bit before, but it’s just such bad reporting on the part of these supposed reputable news outlets.

Andrew: So bad.

Eric: Like to go back and see just how wrong… how not even…

Micah: No, no, no, just the headlines that they’ve had in the last 24 hours. Because they sold it as a new Harry Potter book – a lot of them did. And they really should know at this point that she is not and has stated many times [she] has no plans to write another Harry Potter book. I mean, this… and she even stated as much that this was about the movie.

Andrew: Yeah. They do it for clicks unfortunately, and it’s kind of sick.

Micah: Oh, yeah. Absolutely.

Andrew: Like once or twice I can see, okay, but they did this earlier this year with that new short story in the voice of Rita Skeeter.

Micah: From Pottermore.

Andrew: Right. Everybody was like, “More Harry Potter! Oh my gosh, it’s a new Harry Potter story!” And then they…

Micah: And it wasn’t.

Andrew: Right. And then they did it again…

Micah: Or it kind of was.

Andrew: … with that Celestia War… that singer in the wizarding world.

Micah: Celestina Warbeck?

Andrew: Yes, thank you. Thank you.

Eric: Well…

Andrew: It was on the tip of my tongue.

Eric: Here’s a tweet from JKR:

“An example of something it doesn’t say…”

She’s talking about the anagram.

“… I brung bick Harry. U gladd. Me go wurcke now. No speak.”

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, it’s pretty funny. That was kind of a snipe.

Eric: I feel like that’s kind of saying it’s not about Harry. But she did also give the hints. Like she led…

Andrew: Well, that came after all the media headlines came out and I thought she was sniping at all those…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … who were… because that did get everywhere.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So, anything else to say about this before we move on to some other stories?

Eric: Just that I’m excited. I can’t wait for every announcement.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But really, this was a moment, guys, and if you don’t have Twitter… if you don’t follow J.K. Rowling on Twitter…

Andrew: Now is the time, Micah. He’s talking to you.

Eric: Now is the time. This was a moment…

Micah: I was still able to take part in the fun.

Eric: You should… yeah, right.

Micah: I was!

Eric: And you [should] just realize that this happened today – the last two days, last three days – and it was amazing. I feel like she’s back, baby.

Andrew: She’s back, baby.

Micah: I made a deal with her, though. I would follow her if she answered my question and she still hasn’t answered my question.

Andrew: What’s your question?

Micah: I wanted to know…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: … if there was ever a student that transferred houses.

Andrew: Oh. Well, you’ve got to do it again. She has to… you’ve got to start sending her like every other day.

Micah: I’ve asked twice.

Eric: He did ask twice.

Andrew: Yeah, but you’ve got to just keep firing it off.

Micah: Now since she’s so adamant about it. And she even did mention – and I’m sure it was probably thrown out there prior, but I had no idea – that Newt Scamander was a Hufflepuff, and she included that in one of her tweets today when talking about if he would run from something. She said something to the effect… I’m paraphrasing, but, “No, he’s a Hufflepuff with a lot of courage.”

Andrew: Yeah. “A lot of guts,” I think she said.

Micah: Guts, yeah.

Eric: I did know he was a Hufflepuff, but bless her for saying something nice about Hufflepuffs. I’m going to add that to the book.

Micah: I think she did a great job. Even from the tweet that you just read, Eric, when she was sort of making light of the answers that some people were coming up with…

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: … she was throwing out some factoids. She was really having fun with it and I think that that’s great. It’s great to see that… you said that’s she’s back and maybe she is.

Andrew: [whispers] She’s back! [laughs]

Micah: Maybe this is… [laughs] yeah.

Eric: [laughs] She’s back!

Micah: Maybe this is the start of her being a little bit more…

Eric: Let’s not greet it with fear.

Micah: … interactive with the community. She’s been replying to people more the last few weeks, maybe couple of months. And now today, the last two days, she’s really been interacting with people, and hopefully we get more of those moments moving forward.

Andrew: Yeah. Or it scared her away and we’re never hearing from her again.

Eric: Right.

Micah: No, I don’t think she scares easily.

Andrew: No, I don’t think so either. I think you’re right.

MuggleCast 274 Transcript (continued)


Listener Comments


Andrew: So, on the MuggleCast Facebook I just posted a status a little bit ago saying, “Why do you think Newt Scamander only meant to stay in New York for a few hours?” What does it mean? What’s the second part of that sentence? Why does he have to stay in New York longer? Megan said:

“He starts telling his kids the story of how he met their mother. It takes him longer than expected.”

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: That I believe is a reference to the CBS comedy.

Eric: [laughs] “It takes him longer than expected.”

Andrew: Anne said:

“A Hippogriff ate his plane ticket home.”

That could be feasible. It’s the 1920s. It’s probably easy to lose your ticket.

Eric: [quoting Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade] “No ticket.”

Andrew: It’s not on your phone anymore. Kerry says:

“He discovers the labyrinth of underground tunnels (sewer system) and the creatures making it their home.”

See, I’ve seen this a couple of times. I think it’s too close to the Basilisk thing in Chamber of Secrets.

Eric: Ooh, maybe. But the cool thing, Andrew – and I’m sure Micah can back this up – there are unused stations from the early…

Andrew: Mmm.

Eric: When they were building the subways. There are entire subway stations that… well, it’s much like the London Tube as well. There are entire stations that were built for… and abandoned and never… or decommissioned… certain railway lines just below your normal everyday New York City. There are stations that you can’t even get down into unless you’re walking the tracks. And I love the idea that it could be a lair for a creature.

Micah: Yeah.

Eric: But I see exactly what you mean about it being kind of too Basilisk-y, but I’ll say we have to see. I like the idea of them using the underground thing because that’s a thing.

Andrew: Yeah. Well, it’d be a great way to hide from Muggles, too.

Eric: Right. Oh, yeah.

Andrew: Like if there’s so many of them.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Here’s a couple of good ones. Ben says:

“I think it is likely he unearths some plot involving the oppression of magical creatures or magical creatures being used to further the interests of some evildoer. Knowing J.K. Rowling though, it is probably something much more complicated and clever than either of those.”

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: Yeah, that’s good, right?

Eric: Yeah. I want to say that I want her to stay away from a main bad guy in these.

Andrew: I do, too.

Eric: I want this trilogy to be more free and more light-hearted only in the sense that there’s not an overarching bad guy. I want it to be more like…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Adventure films can have villains, right? But I’d much prefer that the villain was a CGI dragon than… although, that happened with Smaug, right?

Andrew: Yeah. Wouldn’t we also have heard about this villain already in the Harry Potter books, too?

Eric: Yeah, maybe. But also, the books are very closely set in Britain.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: True.

Eric: It’s very almost claustrophobically Britain.

Micah: And if this is an American villain, maybe we never heard about him. Or her.

Andrew: Right. But if he’s only in New York for a year…

Micah: Yeah. I really like the point that was brought up by – sorry, I’m just – Kerry with the underground systems.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Because the whole subway system was started in the early 1900s and by about this time it should be pretty well-developed. And as Eric pointed out, there are areas that never really were used or were abandoned, so that could make for some really cool settings, sort of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle-esque in a way, I guess.

Eric: Well, also I think the latest Spider-Man movie had something to do with an old abandoned New York City subway station…

Micah: Yeah. The first one.

Eric: … with Teddy Roosevelt’s station or his train. But the other thing I wanted to say is that this is… 1920s New York is post Industrial Revolution but it’s closer to the time period… like Hogwarts, you get to Hogwarts by a steam train and steam powered locomotives – steam power came about mid to late 19th century – or the 1800s – and I feel like the whole wizarding world is kind of arrested at that point where there were… the steam train is the most advanced technological thing that you’ll find in the wizarding world. And I want to find out why or I want to find out… because I guess in the 1920s, it would still feel new. Whereas in the 2000s when Harry Potter is set, it’s old. You know what I’m saying?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Did something happen? Maybe not a cataclysmic event or anything, but the Industrial Revolution affected both the wizarding and Muggle world and the wizards adopted what the Muggles did. But being set in the ’20s, this new film will have been closer to when that actually happened, and maybe we’ll just learn some really interesting stuff about how the two sides interacted in regards to technology.

Andrew: Hmm. One more Facebook comment here. Ashia said:

“He was sent on assignment for the Ministry but ended up staying because of the unconventional way magical creatures were being treated in the American magic world.”

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: I like that idea too, because…

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: … kind of like a SPEW situation.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Maybe. I don’t know.

Eric: Yeah, I like that. I like that, too. We have really good ideas.

Andrew: Look guys, we’re speculating again about future J.K. Rowling plots!

Eric: Oh, geez.

Andrew: Who thought that would have ever happened?

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: So, okay…

Micah: Well, at least there’s a chance that the Antipodean Opaleye can make it into one of these three movies.

Eric: Oh, please Jo.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Please put the Antipodean Opaleye for us. Please put that in one of your novels. Or one of your movies.


News: David Yates Rumored To Direct Fantastic Beasts


Andrew: So, a little other Fantastic Beasts news now. It’s been reported by Variety that David Yates is actually going to be the one directing Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. He of course directed Order of the Phoenix through Deathly Hallows – Part 2. So, he handled half of the eight Harry Potter movies. This hasn’t been made official yet, but it was reported on August 21 and apparently they’ve been in talks with him since May. That’s what the guy who broke this story said on a podcast that I listened to recently. So, this has [actually been] happening behind the scenes for a while. I don’t know what’s taking so long. Maybe Yates is still figuring out if he has the patience to do this.

Eric: Well, it’s his current film, right? Because you pointed out…

Andrew: Yes.

Eric: … on the last MuggleCast that he’s at Leavesden…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … currently shooting Tarzan.

Andrew: Right. So, he’s at… Leavesden is where they filmed all eight Harry Potter movies. I think I jokingly said maybe Yates will be stopping by the production offices if they’re at Leavesden to consult on some wizarding world things, because I’m sure Stuart Craig is going to be there, the set designer. So, what was you guys’ initial reaction to this? It was very split for multiple reasons. Some people didn’t love any of his movies; some people loved a couple. I personally did not think Order of the Phoenix was a good start for him. I did not like Order of the Phoenix – favorite book, least favorite movie. And I just did not like the direction in that movie. So, what were you guys’ reaction to Yates?

Eric: Micah?

Micah: Well, I can’t remember where I had this discussion before, but having sat down across the table from him and interviewing him for this podcast…

Andrew: [laughs] You have to say nice things.

Micah: I have to have a sense of loyalty to the man, who reminds me of Linus from the Charlie Brown comics.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Oh, that’s… honestly, that’s a hundred percent accurate. He is the most gracious gentle soul.

Micah: And there’s a little bit of similarity just in appearance between the two. But anyway…

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: I compare him to Winnie the Pooh because he’s soft spoken…

[Micah laughs]

Andrew: … and a little pudgy.

Micah: So…

Andrew: [laughs] So, you’re…

Eric: What were you saying, Micah?

Micah: I personally didn’t have any issue with Order of the Phoenix through Deathly Hallows – Part 2, at least from an overall standpoint. Sure, there are plenty of podcasts out there that we’ve done where we’ve talked about the little things here and there, but certainly not on the same level that I disliked Prisoner of Azkaban. We could go on and on about that, but…

Eric: Well, I’m glad you brought that up.

Micah: But…

Eric: Oh sorry, you keep going.

Micah: I will just say, people are going to say that they want this new and fresh feel to everything, and that when you bring in somebody who’s already worked on half of the series it’s hard to really get that new feel. Because as much as you want to keep the magical world and you want to keep that feeling that you get every time that you see Hogwarts show up on the screen, you also are going into a different type of film with a character that we know very little about.

Eric: Right.

Micah: But I will say for as much as people want to jump on bringing back David Yates, David Heyman is being brought back as well and he’s been there for all eight films.

Eric: Right.

Micah: So, it’s really unfair to get on the case of somebody like Yates when really Heyman has had a much larger role…

Andrew: Yeah! Blame him!

[Eric laughs]

Micah: … in the production of all of these films. No, he’s been there from day one.

Eric: Remember we also… no, he’s the shepherd.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: I like to think of David Heyman as the shepherd.

Micah: But you understand what I’m saying? I get it, the director is always going to…

Andrew: Well…

Eric: Certain people would take comfort, Micah, in knowing that David Yates…

Micah: And I’m one of them. I’m one of them.

Eric: … has worked on four of them. And the later four Harry Potter films are some of my favorite Harry Potter films-ish. But I think that what I want to say, and this is not against David Yates because I love the guy and I think he’s very… I love what he did technical-wise. I love some of the… I love the montages – sorry, I just do – in Order of the Phoenix and I love certain camera angles and certain things that he did with the later series. But world builder is not as much a description I would give to him as a director as I would Alfonso Cuaron, and I don’t like Prisoner of Azkaban. Everybody knows that about me as a movie, but Alfonso Cuaron I think would still be my first choice of previous… of former Potter directors to direct Fantastic Beasts the movie because he has that… it just translates really well. He has that capability of really expanding and defining an entire world.

Micah: But if you’re talking world builder, aren’t you talking Chris Columbus? Because…

Andrew: Yeah, exactly. That’s what I was going to say.

Eric: Well, is it Chris Columbus or is it…

Micah: And Stuart Craig.

Eric: … Stuart Craig? Was that Stuart Craig? Was it the art department that had… because I really want to weigh Chris Columbus’s strengths…

Micah: Well, there’s a good chance that a lot of these people are going to be back. When you’re talking about somebody like Stuart Craig and really…

Eric: Oh, why couldn’t they just co-direct?

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: Have Chris Columbus and Alfonso Cuaron… and even Steve Kloves. Bring Steve Kloves back. Oh wait, it’s not set in Britain, so I don’t know about that.

Micah: And bring Mike Newell as well.

Andrew: So Chris Columbus…

Eric: And bring Mike Newell.

Andrew: … will be yelling in the background, “Don’t forget the world building,” every ten minutes? [laughs]

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I just think… because I feel like everybody should be back on this. I feel like there should be cameos…

Andrew: Well, hold on. This isn’t fair. Wait a second.

[Micah laughs]

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: So, this is…

Micah: Andrew is going to step in.

Andrew: I wrote what they call a think piece the day after this David Yates story broke. By adding David Yates, they are now too big to fail because they are bringing everybody back. As many people as you could conceivably imagine coming back for this…

Eric: Maybe in the crew, but not in the cast.

Andrew: Right. Well… but you don’t want the cast. You’ve got Yates, director for…

Eric: No, you don’t want the cast.

Andrew: Oh, right. Okay. So, you’ve got Yates. You have J.K. Rowling writing the screenplay; we always have to keep that in mind. We’ve got Heyman. That’s three huge names and like we keep saying, probably Stuart Craig is going to be involved too, presumably the costume designer… I mean, how many more people do you need?

Eric: Oh, I said Steve Kloves before. I did mean Mike Newell. Steve Kloves adapted…

Andrew: [laughs] So you want all the directors to come back?

Eric: They won’t need…

Micah: Well, J.K. Rowling is basically doing Steve Kloves’s job.

Eric: Yeah, they won’t need Steve Kloves just because there’s not a book to adapt. There’s… she’s writing the screenplay. She’s saving…

Micah: Right.

Eric: She cut out his job. Sorry, Steve, you’re laid off. But…

Micah: Here’s what I’ll say, though. With J.K. Rowling, though, if you’re in her shoes, right? You’re writing something that is about the world that you entrusted to David Heyman, and David Heyman took it and created really this eight-part series and along with Stuart Craig and all the directors. There’s probably something to be said, of course, for that familiarity and knowing that you can give this to those people and that they can make something very, very good with it. And I could also play devil’s advocate and say, “This is going to do well anyway because it’s Potter.”

Eric: Right.

Micah: But there’s something to be said for that group of people because they took her story and on screen made it into the success that it is.

Andrew: Yeah. And another thing to keep in mind is with… since we don’t have a book to base the movie on, you’re not going to be making these book-to-film comparisons.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: So, I think that’s also going to improve everyone’s feelings about this film when they walk out of the theater. If you’re not sitting there being like, “Oh, they didn’t leave in that scene. They forgot this scene…”

Eric: Yeah. And to a certain extent, that’s always without fail that unfortunately…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … it’s just always on our mind with the…

Andrew: With all book-to-film adaptations.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Andrew: Truly.

Eric: But now it’ll be more freeing. And you know what? I’m sure that’ll be a relief for the director whoever ends up directing this, for sure.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: It’ll be even more… because it’s like… there’s no… I wanted to say there used to be three steps, right? It’s like JKR writes the book, somebody adapts it – usually Steve Kloves except that one time – and then somebody else has to direct from the adaptation.

Andrew: Right.

Eric: But now because JKR is writing it… and I’m sure she’s going to give the best direction anyway in the screenplay. I’m sure she’s going to write the screenplay like a book.

Andrew: Yeah. Also makes me wonder, I wonder if she’s going to be on set a lot? Because she wasn’t really on set with the Harry Potter films.

Eric: Well, I think she’ll totally visit, but… because even the writer, their job is done once the script is done.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Producers, you imagine having to be there nearly every day. Directors, absolutely. Cast, absolutely. But the writer, screenwriter, maybe not. But I’d like to think that she is going to be there every day, but…

Andrew: I feel like she will be interested in being there more often since they’ve got to make sure they get this right.

Eric: Right, because I feel like before too, the adaptation, right? It was out of her hands. She had written the books years before the films went into production, and then the films went into production and it’s just like, “Okay, here’s the…” and she approved the screenplay and this, that, the other thing, but there wasn’t enough… there wasn’t more she could do. Now if there’s a question with the script or whatever that comes up during filming, they can just Skype her or call her up.

Andrew: Right, right.

Eric: Something like that.

Andrew: Yeah, I’m sure they’re going to be talking to her a lot. So yeah, as for the fandom, I think I did a poll. I need to find it, but I think more people were interested in David Yates doing it than not. Most people were happy about it. Seemed like…

Eric: I like his movies. I really do. I…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Yeah, because I’m one of the people who doesn’t like Book 5 all that much, but I like Movie 5.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And I like the whole second half of the film series. So…

Andrew: Yeah. Well, and I’m excited for this as well. I don’t think he personally will be responsible for any particularly major problems because we aren’t comparing it to a book. J.K. Rowling is writing the screenplay.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: All these people are coming back. So, I just found the poll. 50 percent said yes, they like that David Yates is directing; 27 percent said no; and 22 percent said undecided. And rightfully so. We don’t know much about this yet, so…

Eric: Oh, yeah. I mean, David Yates strikes me as a director who can take something and run with it, right? He makes it his own. That’s not to say he doesn’t make… because he does make it his own, but it’s enjoyable. It’s very straightforward almost kind of thing. I’m trying to think of if any of his Harry Potter films were particularly contemplative. Everything… that part in part comes from them all being adaptations too, right? And they’re all just like, “One thing has to happen after another,” because they’re covering a whole year of history in a two-hour film. But I don’t know. I feel like in terms of cerebral, I would probably go to… after seeing Gravity, I would just go straight to Cuaron for it.

Andrew: Mhm.

Eric: And I forgive him partially for Prisoner of Azkaban.


News: Rumored Release Dates for Fantastic Beasts


Andrew: So as we alluded to earlier… let’s move on from Yates now. We knew that this was… a New York Times report several months ago said that this was going to be a planned trilogy; that was the first time we heard it was going to be a trilogy. And then on August 6, just a few days after we recorded the most recent MuggleCast, we… Warner Bros. announced a slew of mystery release dates and the majority of them were for – quote, unquote – “untitled DC films,” referring to things like Batman and Wonder Woman, all these types of things. But then on November 16, 2018, and November 20, 2020, [laughs] there were two – quote, unquote – “untitled WB event films.” Now, a couple of people – myself included – immediately jumped to the conclusion that these are Fantastic Beasts 2 and 3 because this is the same day of the year that Fantastic Beasts 1 comes out; that’s November 18, 2016. So, these movies are apparently going to be spaced out two years apart from one another, which is…

Eric: But be on the same weekend?

Andrew: Yeah, same weekend. It’s that pre-Thanksgiving weekend.

Eric: Yeah, it’s the golden spot, so…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … even if a movie is on its way out, it makes it into the new year.

Andrew: Yeah, and this is a big date in cinema. First two Harry Potter were there, I believe another one was there, the Twilight movies were there, Hunger Games are there now… so this is a big day.

Micah: I think Goblet of Fire was there, wasn’t it? That’s when we all got together.

Eric: Yeah, that’s the first live MuggleCast.

Andrew: And then the rest were summer.

Eric: It’s like week 47, is it, of the year? 47 out of 52? That sounds right to me. Yeah, it’s that same weekend for every…

Andrew: It’s kind of interesting to me because we know with The Hobbit right now, Warner Bros. is releasing them every year. For some reason, they want to place these two years apart from one another. I don’t know if there’s anything to be said for that, but…

Micah: I think it depends how they approach it. If they’re going to… The Hobbit, obviously, was all shot at once, right? And then they just…

Andrew: Yeah, except for when they…

Micah: … made it into three movies?

Andrew: Yeah, they had to go back and film a bunch of stuff when they added the third.

Eric: Yeah, the pickups.

Micah: Yeah, I guess that’s expected, but…

Andrew: See, I would think from a production standpoint, they would want to film them all back-to-back. That’s one of the reasons they split Deathly Hallows into two movies because they filmed it all at once.

Eric: But it would kind of be a delay, right? It would get them… because JKR… because this is new stuff. It’s not to say… it’s not an adaptation. We know that.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But because it’s all new stuff, it would delay the front end of the… because JKR, whoever, would have to write the follow-up scripts first.

Andrew: Right. So J.K. Rowling needs more time, which makes sense considering she’s also writing other books.

Eric: Especially if she’s going to write the second and third movie.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: But then also, there’s… I think no matter what, the production is going to… or post-production, right? Yeah, the CGI and everything they have to add in is going to take a long time because I want these films to be…

Andrew: True.

Eric: Oh wait, I was going to say effects heavy but then didn’t they say they were using a lot of animatronics and practical effects during the filming for this?

Andrew: I think you’re confusing that with Star Wars. [laughs]

Eric: Wow. It’s possible.

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: I’m sure you’re right. Wow, I am. Okay. Well, I want the… you know what? Where do you guys stand on that? Let’s ask you that. Do you think that the new Fantastic Beasts should rely on practical effects, which tend to stand the test of time better – think Jurassic Park – or CG effects, which also work when done well?

Andrew: Well, whatever they did with Harry Potter just do that again.

[Andrew and Eric laugh]

Andrew: Because I thought they looked great in Harry Potter – all the Harry Potter movies.

Eric: You know what? That was mostly animatronics, though. Buckbeak…

Andrew: Well, then there you go. Yeah, right, and the Basilisk.

Eric: Everything except Grawp I think… Grawp was CG motion capture and the giants at the end were like CG motion capture.

Micah: The dragon probably was CG.

Eric: No, that’s a real dragon actually.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: Which dragon?

Micah: That’s good. That’s great. They hired him.

Eric: The not-Antipodean.

Micah: Well, you have them in Goblet of Fire.

Andrew: I think it’s a mix.

Micah: And then you had Deathly Hallows – Part 2.

Andrew: Deathly Hallows. Yeah.

Eric: Yeah.

Micah: But…

Andrew: Well, we’ll know that they’re using animatronics if they take the one off the top of the Diagon Alley expansion.

Eric: [laughs] Oh, gosh.

Andrew: It’s like missing for a few months. We’re like, “Where’d it go?” They’re like, “Oh, it’s just away for repairs. Don’t worry about it.”

Micah: It took a trip.

Eric: It escaped!

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: No, they would say something funny, right?

Micah: It’s on vacation in London.

Eric: They would say it’s on union break or something.

Andrew: Yeah. Then when it comes back, its head is moving and it can flap its wings.

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: We’re like, “Oh, wow. Okay, that was a cool break for it.”

Eric: Okay, yeah.

Micah: With two years though, one of the things that came to mind though also is how well the first one does. They could certainly play around with the release date a little bit if that first movie has the success that it anticipates. But if it doesn’t do well, maybe they’re spaced out so that they can cancel them if they need to.

Andrew: True.

Eric: Look, do you think under any… do you think there’s any universe… in the theory of infinite universes, do you think there’s one where Harry Potter – like a Harry Potter follow-up film – doesn’t succeed?

Andrew: No. Well…

Micah: No.

Andrew: … where it is positioned right now, no, because again Yates, Heyman, J.K. Rowling. I think that…

Eric: Oh, and it’s a proven weekend, right?

Andrew: Right.

Eric: It’s when four out of the eight Harry Potter films or five out of the eight, I think.

Andrew: And things like J.K. Rowling’s anagram prove how alive the fandom can still be if she throws some fire on the flames. Throw some… what am I trying to say? Throw some gas on the flames? Something like that.

Eric: Yeah, ignites the spark.

Andrew: Yeah, something like that.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So yeah, I think it’s definitely going to end up being three films. Warner Bros., of course, really wants this to be three movies so they’re going to do everything in their power to make sure it happens. Which is why I still want J.K. Rowling to write a little mini book, free ebook, that introduces us to Newt. Get everybody talking. The media will be like, “Oh my God, new Harry Potter book,” even though it’s not, but that’s okay because people will be talking about it.

Eric: Well, and we were thinking about… we were talking earlier about how it’s been a year and what do we know? What don’t we know? Thinking about what we still don’t know. We don’t know the director, for sure, that’s true, but also any casting announcements. We still have so far to go in terms of Fantastic Beasts, in terms of the first film, even though we like to look ahead at the later films. I want to know who’s going to be playing Newt Scamander. I want to know how that first movie is going to turn out quite a bit.

Andrew: Here are the four things we know for sure. Here are the five things we know for sure. I just realized I misnumbered this.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: David Heyman is returning to produce. David Yates is returning to direct – we’re assuming that’s correct. Number three: it will be released November 18, 2016. Number four: Warner Bros. is planning a trilogy. And then number five, we learned during the initial announcement is that there is a planned theme park attraction of some sort and Warner Bros. is, of course, going to be going all out to create merchandise.

Eric: To realize that, yeah.

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Six is that it will be set in New York.

Andrew: Well, yeah, that too. [laughs] And now seven is her little synopsis thing today.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: So, that’s what we know.

MuggleCast 274 Transcript (continued)


News: J.K. Rowling Reveals Her Patronus


Andrew: A little other story not related to Fantastic Beasts. Again, J.K. Rowling on Twitter. Dropping all the exciting info on Twitter these days. We didn’t know her Patronus, what her Patronus was, which blows my mind. I would have thought we learned about this a while ago.

Eric: Yeah. You know what? It feels like that question could have been out there since Book 3, right?

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: Since ’99 people should have been asking because I feel like people… you’re right, that question should have been answered already.

Andrew: Or maybe Pottermore’s Book 3.

Eric: Yeah. [laughs]

Andrew: Throw it in there somewhere. New from J.K. Rowling…

Eric: Well, there’s…

Andrew: … my Patronus.

Eric: Yeah. You know the Patronus thing though, with Pottermore? And I do want to bring this up, is apparently there will be a test…

Andrew: Yes!

Eric: … about what your Patronus is.

Andrew: And that’s another thing J.K. Rowling revealed.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: So, on Twitter she said… or somebody asked her:

“WHAT IS YOUR PATRONUS?”

Eric: All caps.

Andrew: Now, see this person, Micah, wrote the question in all caps.

Eric: Yeah.

Andrew: Have you done that? Maybe that’s what you’ve got to do to get your question answered.

Micah: She only answers questions with caps. I got it. All right.

Eric: No, it’s if you ask your question in caps, she might…

Andrew: Yeah.

Micah: Oh.

Andrew: The person asked the question…

Eric: It’s proven… it’s tried and tested this one time…

Andrew: Yeah.

Eric: … from @acciowandspells.

Andrew: But then not only that, this person wrote:

“Thank you. You help us everyday. We are Potterheads until the end…”

So, you have to write the question in all caps and then write a really nice message.

Micah: Then kiss her ass.

Andrew: Yeah, kiss her ass. Exactly. [laughs]

Eric: I don’t know because all of that ass kissing… whoa, I can’t believe we just said that about a fellow fan.

[Andrew and Micah laugh]

Eric: All of that additional wittering really only got… she responded… she was kind of short in her response though, right? She said…

Andrew: She’s like she doesn’t really want to answer it.

Eric: She like, “It’s a pine marten.”

Andrew: So, then you have to go and Google this pine marten because you’re like, “What the heck is a pine marten?”

Eric: “I’ve never heard of a pine marten.” Yeah.

Andrew: It’s an adorable little cat looking thing.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: It’s in the same family as minks, otters – which, of course, Hermione’s Patronus – badgers – reference to Hufflepuff – wolverines, and weasels. So…

Eric: Aww. Actually, it’s quite a menace in the UK and Ireland. [laughs]

Andrew: Yeah, that too.

Eric: Oh, wait. No, no, no, it’s not a menace. It’s a savior, right? Because I’m looking at the wordplay they used in this Hypable article, “…the invasive gray squirrel.” So, the gray squirrel was a menace in the UK and Ireland, and the pine marten got rid of the gray squirrel.

Andrew: Mmm.

Eric: Or helped to get rid of. So, it’s actually… it’s like a Robin Hood of like a… or like a gallant knight coming to the rescue of the UK and Ireland.

Micah: Do you think she just said to herself, “Let me come up with the most obscure animal.”

Eric: No. You know what? I think… although that would get people to read, right? Isn’t that J.K. Rowling’s thing?

Micah: Well, I guarantee you…

Eric: Well, pine martens…

Micah: And I think I tweeted this at the time. I guarantee you, with the exception of the people who live in the UK where this animal is popular, nobody had any clue what this thing was.

Eric: Well, that’s what I’m saying. It’s like… but there are regional animals. There just are. We know what dingoes are and kangaroos because they’re fairly world…

Micah: Because we live… [laughs]

Eric: … known. No, but I’m saying… like voles. Have you ever heard of a vole? Because I’ve heard of a vole.

Micah: I’ve heard of it, yeah.

Andrew: Is it [unintelligible]?

Eric: It’s like an underground dwelling creature who lives in burrows. But that’s a strictly… I feel like… we all grew up in the northeast, guys, so I feel like that’s why we know what that is and I feel like it’s a very geographically… anyway, my point is…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: … I feel like from the second that she invented the rules of a Patronus, like in Book… when she was planning for Book 3 or even sooner in the cafe on a napkin, she knew what her own would be. It’s just that for some reason years later, throughout the years, that somehow never came up.

Andrew: Yeah, it is weird. But I like Micah’s question, too. Now I’m thinking about that. It’s kind of… I don’t think you’ve read Divergent, but it kind of reminds me of Divergent when they switch factions.

Eric: Oh, yeah. Well, he’s got a great question. We retweeted from… everybody we know, even MuggleCast, MuggleNet… everybody retweeted his thing and it still didn’t get…

Micah: You want me to do this again tomorrow?

Andrew: Yes, and I’ll do it too.

Eric: All caps this time. All caps.

Andrew: We’re going to go crazy. We’re going to…

Micah: So you’ll retweet me, is that what you’re saying?

Andrew: Yeah, sure. Whatever. Or I’ll write it on the MuggleCast account. That’s what I meant. Write it on the MuggleCast account.

Micah: Oh, okay.

Andrew: Yeah. And every day. [laughs]

Micah: All right, every day.

Andrew: Every day we’ll tweet it.

Micah: There we go.

Eric: Oh God, let’s not anger her, all right? She’s still got a ways to go.

Andrew: With a new nice comment.

Micah: Somebody replied to me saying probably not because it would somehow delegitimize the Sorting Hat, but…

Andrew: Yeah, if you go against the Sorting Hat, you’re kind of a butt.

Micah: I can’t imagine in all the years that the school is around that somebody did not, in fact, change houses.

Eric: Well, Micah, let’s settle this once and for all. I feel like… isn’t the answer already in the books, right? Or on Pottermore? Because you can be a Hatstall. Okay? We know that from Pottermore. There are characters who were Hatstalls, who… but then also, the Sorting Hat takes your choice into consideration, so doesn’t it make sense that maybe they don’t transfer houses but you do absolutely have a say in the house you go into? Isn’t that like the same thing?

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: No because…

Eric: Like if the Sorting Hat came to you…

Micah: As you grow older you could change, certainly.

Eric: So you’re like, “This isn’t working out for me. It’s been two years and I still feel like I’d be better suited…”

Andrew: “I feel like I’m a Hufflepuff.”

Eric: Right.

Micah: Right. Or somebody says…

Andrew: That makes sense. I think it’s an interesting question.

Micah: … “Seamus is really bullying me. I can’t live here anymore. I need to go be in Ravenclaw.”

Eric: You know what, though?

Andrew: Ah. Well, see, that’s a human resources issue.

[Everyone laughs]

Eric: You know also though, guys, I do want to say this. The classes, right? They did have classes with other houses.

Andrew: Yeah, right.

Eric: So, they had Potions with the Sytherins, which was terrible, but they had Herbology with the Hufflepuffs. I feel like in that way, you would have friends in other houses. I don’t know. We see them as divided because Harry tends to stick to his own house until Luna and maybe some others in year five or whatever, but I feel like you do interact with people of other houses. So, there’s no reason to transfer normally kind of in a way. I’m just saying, if she never replies to you, Micah, I want that to be the answer.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: I could keep coming up with questions, though. I could say, “Has anybody ever transferred schools?”

Andrew: Well, here’s what we… start thinking them up.

Micah: Is there a foreign exchange program?

Andrew: Start thinking them up because you know she’s going to be doing interviews like absolutely crazy come Fantastic Beasts movie time.

Micah: She needs to come on our goddamn show already.

Andrew: There are going to be a bazillion interviews.

Eric: Yeah. For MuggleCast 275, we will have J.K. Rowling on our show. [laughs]

Andrew: [laughs] Not… no, I’ve given up with that. She had her chance!

Eric: Oh.

Andrew: I’m just kidding. One other…

Micah: Why don’t you tweet that out? We’ll retweet it.

Andrew: [laughs] I’ll get flamed for that.

Micah: No, no, no. The question if she’ll come on the show.

Andrew: Oh. Start doing that everyday?

Micah: 275, we want you on.

Andrew: Yeah. Yeah, we could.

Micah: Let’s go.


Announcement: Jamie Gets Engaged


Andrew: To wrap up the show today, we actually have a little exciting announcement about a MuggleCast alum, I guess you could call him: Jamie Lawrence. He got engaged. Aww! Happy…

Eric: Congratulations.

Andrew: Congratulations to Jamie.

Micah: It’s great news.

Andrew: He got engaged to Sophie, his girlfriend of… I think about three years? No, no, no, 2008. Oh my God, it’s been…

Eric: Six years.

Andrew: It’s been a long time, yeah. [laughs] So… I met her at the Beedle the Bard event that we did in London in 2008.

Eric: Oh, yeah.

Andrew: Or was that 2007?

Eric: I feel like it was ’08.

Andrew: When did Beedle the Bard… wait, no. Beedle the Bard came out in 2007 because I recently looked this up.

Eric: Really?

Andrew: Yeah, I know. It was published December 2007.

Eric: Oh, at the very extreme end of the year.

Andrew: Yeah, which is so weird that Beedle the Bard came out a few months after Deathly Hallows.

Eric: Yeah, that is weird. That’s really weird.

Andrew: So…

Micah: Well, it had to. I mean it was in the book, right?

Andrew: True. Well, it didn’t have to, but…

[Eric and Micah laugh]

Andrew: Yeah, it did have to come out after Deathly Hallows.

Eric: Because originally it was just for one person that won the auction, right? She had a hand… but then she had to write special permission to get it produced into a book…

Andrew: No. Well, sort of. So, she wrote… she made seven handwritten copies total.

Eric: Oh, right.

Andrew: Gave them to six very important people in her life. The seventh she auctioned off. Amazon was the winning bidder…

Eric: Yes!

Andrew: … and they got permission… they worked with Rowling to publish it.

Eric: And she… but she did get permission from the six other people who had the handwritten copies.

Andrew: Oh, okay.

Eric: Yeah, I think. That’s what I remember anyway. Yeah, so… oh, that’s really weird. Well, congratulations to Jamie anyway.

Andrew: [laughs] Yeah, I forgot what we were talking about.

Eric: Please invite us to your wedding.

Micah: Yeah.

Andrew: Yeah. I want to get…

Micah: And congratulations to your sister as well, Andrew.

Andrew: Yes. [laughs] Thank you, Micah.

Eric: What happened to Becca?

Andrew: She got engaged today.

Eric: What?

Andrew: Yup. Big day in the MuggleCast family. And you guys are all invited! [laughs]

Eric: Cool.

Andrew: No, Micah, you can come if you want.

Micah: All right.

Andrew: I only say that because you’re near.

Eric: Do you know her fiance? Do you know him?

Andrew: Yeah, I’ve met him a couple of times. He’s a big MuggleCast fan.

Eric: What?

Andrew: No, I’m kidding. I’m kidding. [laughs]

Eric: Oh.

Micah: Go hang out with Heidi.

Andrew: [laughs] What?

Micah: At the wedding.

Andrew: You’re going to hang out with Heidi, my mom?

Micah: Yeah. Just say, “Hi. What’s up?”

Andrew: Okay.

Micah: I haven’t seen her in a while.

Andrew: Yeah, sure. Okay.

Eric: [laughs] He’s just going to say, “Hi. What’s up?”

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: It’s okay, Andrew. Micah is just going to say, “Hi. What’s up?”…

Andrew: Well, I don’t have the date yet.

Eric: … to your mom.

Andrew: I think it’s before Fantastic Beasts comes out.

Eric: Oh, okay.

Andrew: Maybe she should do it in the gap… no, Jamie should do it in one of the gap years. November 2017, between two Fantastic Beasts movies.

Eric: Yeah, I feel like it’s not a stretch to plan life events in between two Harry Potter tent pole events.

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: I feel like that’s what [unintelligible] for us.

Andrew: I would. I would.

Eric: Yeah.


Show Close


Andrew: All right, so that’s it for MuggleCast. [laughs] Big episode, an hour long.

Eric: Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

Andrew: Thank you everybody for listening. We’ll continue to do these new episodes as we have some interesting news to discuss. We even got in some theories today. No theory is safe.

Eric: That’s right.

Andrew: And what else is there to say?

Eric: Well…

Andrew: Let’s plug stuff. Micah and Eric, what you got?

Eric: Just earlier before we sat down to record this episode of MuggleCast, we recorded our 242nd episode of Game of Owns, the Game of Thrones podcast, brought to you by WatchersOnTheWall.com. It’s Micah and myself are hosts, or co-hosts, on that podcast, along with Zack Luye, our friend for several years now – big Harry Potter fan – and Kate Welch, who is in the gaming industry in Seattle.

[Car honking noises in the background]

Eric: And somebody outside my window…

[Andrew laughs]

Eric: … is very angry or something.

Andrew: A very big fan of Game of Owns.

Eric: Yeah, yeah, yeah. But that’s our Game of Thrones podcast. We’re actually reading the third Game of Thrones book now in the off season between seasons 4 and 5 of the TV show.

Andrew: Cool.

Eric: So, go check that out. Actually, you know what I want to plug? Sorry to keep hogging up the airspace here, but I recently became a co-producer, co-editor of the Improvised Star Trek Podcast and I want to give these guys just the best… the most credit I possibly can. If you, listener, happen to also enjoy Star Trek, as I do more recently – Next Generation, Voyager era – these guys are the best and they have a podcast. It’s bi-weekly, just like MuggleCast used to be, and every two weeks they put out an episode and they source episode titles from their listeners through Facebook, through Twitter, and you just give them an episode title and they create – they have their own ship’s crew, and they have experiences and events in space in the 24th century just like Star Trek. And it’s in-jokes. It’s a mix of in-jokes and satire and improv. It’s all improvised on the spot and then the editor’s job, the producer’s job, is to go and put in sound effects and music and everything to make it sound and feel like an actual Star Trek episode with all the Star Trek stuff.

Andrew: Cool.

Eric: I do want to say, it’s called the Improvised Star Trek Podcast. Go check it out. It is on iTunes and the website is ImprovisedStarTrek.com.

Andrew: Micah? Game of Owns as well?

Micah: Yeah. Eric pretty much covered it. I would just say we’re at @GameofOwns on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and then, of course, the website, GameOfOwns.com, so plenty of ways for you to connect with the show. And then if you want to follow me and hear my random…

Andrew: Pleas to J.K. Rowling every day.

Eric: Careful. He doesn’t follow J.K. Rowling on Twitter, guys.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: And snarky comments to J.K. Rowling… no, I’m just kidding. I’m at @mjtbaum. So yeah, give me a follow. You never know what you’re going to get.

Eric: You know what’s funny, Micah? I call it @mjtbaum, but I’ve never heard you call it that. [laughs]

Andrew: That’s what I call it, too.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: And I’m over at…

Micah: Glad we’re all in agreement…

[Eric laughs]

Micah: … on my Twitter handle.

Andrew: Yeah, that was bothering me…

Micah: By the way, Andrew was the one who convinced me to get on Twitter way, way back in the day.

Andrew: Darn right!

Micah: And he said, “Look, you just got to do it.”

Andrew: “You just got to do it.”

Micah: I was hesitant about it and he convinced me. And I remember when you first… I don’t know how many years ago it was at this point, but when you first told me to join Twitter and I had a BlackBerry back at that time.

Andrew: Mhm.

Micah: And I just remember I was out for dinner that night or something along… something like that, and my phone just… I guess the setting was automatically turned on to let me know when I got a new follower.

Andrew: Oh.

Micah: And I’m sure you had pushed this out on MuggleCast and MuggleNet and all these other places, and my phone just literally did not stop going off…

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: … for about…

Andrew: Your BlackBerry was…

Micah: … four or five hours.

Andrew: Crazy. Well, and now to this day, you still don’t follow J.K. Rowling. Super weird.

[Eric sighs]

Andrew: You’re going to follow one day.

Eric: He did and then he got… what was it? What was the catalyst, Micah? Why did you stop following her? You did it…

Andrew: She was so boring.

Eric: Oh, right.

Micah: Because she really… honestly, she didn’t tweet.

[Andrew laughs]

Micah: She just put a couple of tweets out there.

Andrew: So, he protested by unfollowing.

Eric: Right.

Andrew: I think it was smart.

Micah: Really quick, my thing is I’m not a proponent of somebody who goes on Twitter just to say they are on Twitter but then not do anything with their Twitter account.

Eric: Right, right.

Micah: But now she has definitely been more active, so we’ll see what happens.

Andrew: Don’t follow her until the next episode. We have to have a big moment.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: All right, and then I’m over at Hypable, Twitter.com/Hypable, Twitter.com/sims. I’m always tweeting about Harry Potter, by the way, because I know that’s what people follow me for, so… and then, of course, I also do Hype After Dark, which is my weekly podcast. You can go to HypePodcast.com for that and that is $4 a month.

Micah: I’ve been on that, too.

Andrew: Yes, you were on it recently, actually.

Eric: Ooh.

Andrew: Yeah, we talked about Kevin and Laura.

[Eric laughs]

Andrew: Laura, by the way, who is now in New York. Crazy.

Eric: Yes. How cool is that, right? Half of the old MuggleCast panel is…

Andrew: I’m happy for her.

Eric: Are you in New Jersey now or are you back in LA?

Andrew: No, I’m in LA.

Eric: Okay.

Andrew: But next time I go back to New Jersey for the holidays…

Eric: I’ll be back…

Andrew: When? When are you back?

Eric: No, I’ll be back in PA and I’m coming up to New York Christmas a week, the 20th to 27th.

Andrew: Oh, I smell a meetup.

Eric: I know, I smell… well, now that Kevin and Laura are there too, right?

Micah: All five in one place?

Eric: Wow.

Andrew: Yeah, and I hear Kevin and Laura are paying, so I’m definitely in.

[Everyone laughs]

Micah: Well, one of that… never mind.

Andrew: One of the two. [laughs]

Eric: I have an article queued up from Hypable that I’m ready to read as soon as we finish this, too: “Fifteen ‘Charmed’ cameos to surprise and delight you.”

Andrew: Oh, yeah. I don’t even watch that show and I was shocked. [laughs]

Eric: [laughs] Well, it was written by Karen Rought and I’m happy to see number two here on the thing is Oded Fehr, who I love from The Mummy and The Mummy Returns.

Andrew: Oh, okay. Cool.

[Show music begins]

Eric: So, I’ll read this article as soon as we’re done.

Andrew: Awesome. Well, thank you everybody for listening. And again, we’ll be back when… I don’t know. Newt Scamander is announced. [laughs] Or J.K. Rowling drops the full synopsis. One of those two things, probably. So, we’ll see everybody next time for Episode 275.

Micah: Five.

Andrew: Yes. [laughs] Goodbye.

Eric: Goodbye.

Micah: Bye.

[Show music continues]