Hypable.com writer Kendra joins the show! Eric recaps a great LeakyCon weekend in Dallas!
We meet a brand-new Fantastic Beast – the chupacabra – and get our first glimpse at baby nifflers
Newt is headed to Paris to “track” Credence, but how does he even know he’s alive?
Chapter-by-Chapter continues with Chapter 3 of Half-Blood Prince
Are the media headlines meant to make readers and the wizarding community feel safe despite Voldemort’s known return to power?
Why has Dumbledore been reinstated as Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot?
Our first (passing) mention of Inferi
Is Harry’s lack of trust in Dumbledore showing up at Privet Drive a result of their relationship from Order of the Phoenix?
Why didn’t Harry tell the Dursleys that Dumbledore would be visiting? How would they have reacted if he did?
We discuss Dumbledore and Petunia’s prior correspondence. Was Dumbledore ready to play that hand if necessary?
Privet Drive Payoff: Dumbledore puts the Dursleys in their rightful place!
Are we seeing a Grindelwald-era Dumbledore based on the way he intimidates the Dursleys or is he just setting affairs in order?
Dumbledore’s hand, mead, Grimmauld Place, Kreacher and more!
We learn that Harry must return to Privet Drive one more time
The hosts give their MVPs of the Week and Rename the Chapter; plus a great Crackpot Theory on Felix Felicis
Quizzitch: Who gave Ambrosius Flume his first job, thanks to Slughorn?
This week’s episode is brought to you by BeachBody On Demand (text MuggleCast to 303030 for a FREE trial!) and
Running time: 1:27:17, 52.4 MB
… Did that work? Is he listening to this episode?
With Micah gone this week, we’re joined by two of our listeners, Alex and Stefanie, who do their best impressions of the NY News Anchor.
Patrons in the U.S. have received their mugs, but
we need to know if they arrived okay! And if yours arrived broken (rare but possible), let us know: Email firstname.lastname@example.org with photos. Eric will be attending
LeakyCon and looks forward to appearing on panels and meeting listeners! This week’s episode is sponsored by Puffs the Play! Receive a
special discount on tickets to see Puffs at New York City’s New World Stages. Chapter by Chapter continues with analysis of Chapter 2 of Half-Blood Prince: Spinner’s End.
The brilliance of this chapter is how Snape is playing Bellatrix and Naricissa simultaneously but in different ways.
How much does Voldemort know about Dumbledore’s injury? He can’t know about the Horcrux… right?
Does one line from Bellatrix help make Delphi’s existence canon?
Why would Bellatrix have such a hard time trusting Snape’s word when Voldemort is content with his reasoning? And what should she do if she had ever learned the truth?
Who is the MVP of the chapter? Those poor elves…
We rename the chapter to reflect what really happens.
Crackpot Theory: Has Bellatrix made an unbreakable vow before?
Have questions or comments about HBP Chapter 3? E-mail
email@example.com, or use the voicemail line or feedback form on our website!
Running time: 1:12:53, 43.7 MB
Happy Birthday Harry & Jo!
Harry Potter’s birthdays from worst to best MuggleCast turns 13 years old on August 7!
We break down the details of two new Crimes of Grindelwald posters
ZouWu? JKR reveals the mysterious beast in the recent Crimes of Grindelwald trailer!
Ezra Miller talks about Credence’s character development
The biggest Harry Potter LEGO set ever hits store shelves August 15
Patrons share their thoughts and questions on the latest trailer
Does Dumbledore see Grindelwald in the Mirror of Erised because he desires him to be captured?
What role exactly will Nicolas Flamel play in The Crimes of Grindelwald?
How will Jacob find himself with Newt?
Will Credence be reunited with his true family? Will he ever get the chance to go to wizarding school?
Was Abernathy working for Grindelwald the whole time? Did he help him capture Graves?
We compare Grindewald’s populist movement and Dumbledore’s timid response to that of the U.S. in the 1930s
Voicemails cover the Deathly Hallows, splitting the films into five parts, Johnny Depp and more
Chicken Soup For The MuggleCast Soul returns
Don’t forget: Cormoran Strike is back in Lethal White on September 18
Quizzitch: What floor is Vernon Dursley’s office on at Grunnings?
This week’s episode is brought to you by Blue Apron! Get you first three meals FREE by visiting
Running time: 1:25:10, 51.1 MB
Andrew and Eric reminisce on their latest trivia night battle, which leaves Andrew and friends with a huge prize.
The new Crimes of Grindelwald trailer is here and we go scene-by-scene!
There is some mixed reaction to Dumbledore’s DADA lesson with Newt
What interests Credence so much about Circus Arcanus?
Who is Grindelwald addressing when he says hiding in the shadows serves us no longer?
A flying black curtain – is this a new obscurial effect or perhaps a Lethifold?
Dumbledore’s deepest desire is not socks – he sees Grindelwald in the Mirror of Erised!
Newt, Tina and Leta team up to escape the French Ministry of Magic!
The Niffler is back! What’s up with those cats? And is Newt trying to rescue the Oni Oni?
Is Leta referring to herself when she tells Newt he never met a monster he couldn’t love?
Could Grindelwald be referring to his own failed relationship with Dumbledore when he asks Newt if Dumbledore will mourn for him? Could it be a reference to Ariana?
Does Abernathy help Grindelwald escape from prison?
What are Newt and Jacob up to in Nicolas Flamel’s home?
The hosts react to Johnny Depp’s in-character appearance at Comic-Con
Patrons weigh in with their thoughts on the new trailer
Quizzitch: On what historic date was the actor who plays Grimmson born?
Running time: 1:13:47, 44.3 MB
Slug Club member Chris joins the show
David Heyman says Grindelwald is scarier than Voldemort!
Why is Dumbledore teaching a young Newt Defense Against the Dark Arts?
“After all this time,” Chapter-by-Chapter returns! And just in time for HBP’s birthday!
We analyze the chapter that had been brewing in JKR’s mind for more than 13 years
Would The Other Minister have worked earlier in the series?
Where’s Harry? Our first Potter book that doesn’t begin with the boy wizard!
Voldemort is on the rise and its clear the tone of the series has shifted
Fireplace entrances, shady portraits, secret staff – do wizards have a superiority complex?
Should the Ministry have considered lifting the International Statute of Secrecy?
Does Fudge ever consider enlisting the help of the Muggle Prime Minister?
Do other heads of state have similar relationships with their Muggle counterparts?
Rufus Scrimgeour: our thoughts on the new Minister and do we have cause to trust him?
Kingsley Shacklebolt “Undercover Secretary”
Whatever came of the Ministry’s inquiry into the death of Sirius Black?
How much control do magical governments have over their Muggle counterparts?
Two new segments debut with Character MVP and Rename The Chapter!
Patrons weigh in with their thoughts on the first chapter of Half-Blood Prince!
Quizzitch: What is the name of the bridge that gets destroyed by Death Eaters?
This week’s episode is sponsored by BeachBody On Demand! Get a FREE trial by texting ‘MuggleCast’ to 303030!
Running time: 1:22:21, 49.4 MB
Cursed Child is coming to two new cities… San Francisco (2019) and Hamburg, Germany (2020). Could a Midwest location be next?
Chamber of Secrets turns 20 years old!
We begin our Half-Blood Prince discussion looking back at some popular fan theories
Patrons share their midnight release party memories!
We discuss how parts of Half-Blood Prince were originally written for Chamber of Secrets and that it was Book 2’s working title
The hosts revisit some of MuggleCast’s theories following the release of the sixth book
Who is the Half-Blood Prince? Harry? Voldemort? Felix Felicis?
We dive deep into The Underground Lake, one of MuggleNet’s notorious series of editorials
What did Dumbledore mean by Remember My Last, Petunia?
Who will take over the DADA vacancy?
Why does Dumbledore trust Snape?
Voicemails cover a Deathly Hallows symbol in Goblet of Fire, deluminators, Cho Chang and more!
Quizzitch: What two Order members does Harry bump into (in order) in the HBP chapter, “Silver and Opals”?
This week’s episode is sponsored by ZipRecruiter! Find the perfect candidates by visiting
Running time: 1:10:40, 42.3 MB
Slug Club member Sarah joins the show!
Warner Brothers cracks down on unofficial fan events
Main Discussion: The Department of Mysteries & The Prophecy
Who are The Unspeakables?
The Brain Room: just what are they studying in there?
What does each of us think is beyond The Veil?
Does the Veil have magical properties to draw one in?
Was the Ministry built around the amphitheater that houses the Veil?
How is security so lax around such a dangerous room?
The Love Room: why is it locked?
The Planet Room: what can you do in here that makes it worthy of the Department of Mysteries?
Are there alien wizards?
The Time Room: do we believe this is where Time Turners were invented?
The Hall of Prophecies: why are they kept locked away?
Should who the Prophecy concerns be able to hold onto the prophecy?
Do we forgive Dumbledore for withholding this information until now?
Patreon Question of the Week: What other rooms could be within the Department of Mysteries?
Quizzitch: What is the spell that Hermione uses to mark the doors in the revolving room?
Coming this July… chapter-by-chapter for Half-Blood Prince!
In this week’s Bonus MuggleCast we discuss how The Department of Mysteries scene in Order of the Phoenix marks the beginning of the end for Lucius Malfoy.
Pledge $5 or more per month to hear this discussion!
This week’s sponsor is Blue Apron. Get your first three meals FREE by visiting
Running time: 1:23:19, 50 MB
Slug Club member Karen joins the show
Listeners share their Order of the Phoenix release party memories
Cursed Child cleans up at the Tony Awards
Universal Orlando adds Harry Potter to their nighttime water show
Main Discussion: Major Events of the Phoenix
Grimmauld Place: Was this truly the safest place for the Order to be headquartered?
Do Sirius and the Order underestimate the threats within the Black Family home?
Ministry Interference at Hogwarts: What are Umbridge’s credentials for becoming DADA professor?
Was it always Fudge’s intention for Umbridge to become Headmistress?
Do the Educational Decrees expose weaknesses in Dumbledore’s leadership?
The Formation of Dumbledore’s Army: we discuss the Hog’s Head, the Room of Requirement and the importance of unifying (almost) all of the Houses
Welcome to St. Mungo’s: why was it cut from the film?
Augusta Longbottom, Neville’s parents, Lockhart and Harry’s connection to Nagini
We reminisce on those gum wrapper theories!
Patrons share their top 5 moments from Order of the Phoenix
Don’t worry, we’ll spend Episode 374 inside the Department of Mysteries and discussing The Prophecy
Quizzitch: Who was the last member of the Dumbledore’s Army to sign up in the Hog’s Head?
Bonus MuggleCast (
available on Patreon) includes memorable lines from the fifth book and Crimes of Grindelwald trailer speculation
Running time: 1:14:54, 44.9 MB
Paris, London, New York: Pottermore offers fans the chance to attend the Fantastic Beasts 2 premieres for charity
Cursed Child is up for 10 Tony Awards
Main Discussion: Fresh Faces of the Phoenix
What would have happened to Harry without the support of Luna and her father?
We discuss Bellatrix exposing Harry’s ignorance and her unwavering loyalty to Voldemort
Does Tonks make the Order of the Phoenix cool?
Dolores Umbridge has one redeeming quality – she’s the reason for Dumbledore’s Army!
Do we overlook the importance of Ms. Figg? Was she best equipped to keep Harry safe?
What’s up with the relationship between Squibs and cats?
Mundungus Fletcher… enough said!
What if these characters were introduced earlier in the series? What if they never were?
This episode’s lone voicemail asks about a Hermione-based movie with Emma Watson
Quizzitch: Who did JKR say would win in a fight: Crookshanks or Mrs. Norris?
Luna Lovegood and Dolores Umbridge character discussions
Running time: 1:29:26, 47.7 MB
Slug Club member Amy joins the show!
The Crimes of Grindelwald screenplay cover is revealed…
And we analyze every beast, symbol and little detail
Did Alan Rickman feel Snape was an underutilized character in the films?
JKR reveals her next project will be a children’s book!
We start June off with our first Order of the Phoenix discussion
What were the biggest theories prior to Order of the Phoenix being released?
Like: What exactly is the Order of the Phoenix? Will Snape ever teach DADA? Is he a spy? Is Lupin really James Potter in disguise? What is the gleam of triumph and what does it mean? What’s up with Ms. Figg? Which character(s) won’t make it through Book 5?
Quizzitch: A witch or wizard who is gifted at reading minds is called a what?
Running time: 1:16:38, 46 MB